Effects of myonecrotic snake venom phospholipase A2 toxins on cultured muscle cells

A Cytotoxicity Assay as an Alternative to the Murine Model for the Potency Testing of Bothrops jararaca Venom and Antivenom: An Intralaboratory Pre-validation Study

Antivenom therapy is the only specific treatment for snakebite envenomation, and antivenom potency determination is key in the efficacy assurance quality control process. Nowadays, this process relies on the in vivo murine model - thus, the development of alternative in vitro methods is imperative. In the current study, the principle of the proposed method is the ability of Bothrops venom to induce cytotoxic effects in Vero cells, and the capacity to evaluate the inhibition of this cytotoxicity by the respective antivenom. After exposure to the venom/antivenom, the relative proportions of adherent (viable) cells were evaluated by direct staining with Coomassie Blue. The optical density (OD) of the lysed cell eluate was directly proportional to the number of adherent cells. This cytotoxicity-based alternative method could represent a potential candidate for validation as a replacement for the current in vivo test. The in vitro-determined cytotoxicity of the Brazilian Bothrops reference venom (expressed as the 50% effective concentration; EC50) was 3.61 μg/ml; the in vitro-determined 50% inhibitory concentration (IC50) of the Brazilian Bothrops reference antivenom was 0.133 μl/ml. From these two values, it was possible to calculate the potency of the reference antivenom. The results from the assays exhibited a good linear response, indicating that the method could be a potential candidate replacement method for use in antivenom quality control prior to lot release, subject to further validation.

Proteomics, toxicity and antivenom neutralization of Sri Lankan and Indian Russell's viper (Daboia russelii) venoms

BACKGROUND

The western Russell's viper (Daboia russelii) is widely distributed in South Asia, and geographical venom variation is anticipated among distant populations. Antivenoms used for Russell's viper envenomation are, however, raised typically against snakes from Southern India. The present study investigated and compared the venom proteomes of D. russelii from Sri Lanka (DrSL) and India (DrI), the immunorecognition of Indian VINS Polyvalent Antivenom (VPAV) and its efficacy in neutralizing the venom toxicity.

METHODS

The venoms of DrSL and DrI were decomplexed with C18 high-performance liquid chromatography and SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis under reducing conditions. The proteins fractionated were identified through nano-ESI-liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LCMS/MS). The immunological studies were conducted with enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. The neutralization of the venom procoagulant effect was evaluated in citrated human plasma. The neutralization of the venom lethality was assessed in vivo in mice adopting the WHO protocol.

RESULTS

DrSL and DrI venom proteomes showed comparable major protein families, with phospholipases A2 (PLA2) being the most abundant (> 60% of total venom proteins) and diverse (six protein forms identified). Both venoms were highly procoagulant and lethal (intravenous median lethal dose in mice, LD50 = 0.24 and 0.32 µg/g, for DrSL and DrI, respectively), while lacking hemorrhagic and anticoagulant activities. VPAV was immunoreactive toward DrSL and DrI venoms, indicating conserved protein antigenicity in the venoms. The high molecular weight venom proteins were, however, more effectively immunorecognized than small ones. VPAV was able to neutralize the coagulopathic and lethal effects of the venoms moderately.

CONCLUSION

Considering that a large amount of venom can be injected by Russell's viper during envenomation, the potency of antivenom can be further improved for optimal neutralization and effective treatment. Region-specific venoms and key toxins may be incorporated into the immunization procedure during antivenom production.

Comparative venomics and preclinical efficacy evaluation of a monospecific Hemachatus antivenom towards sub-Saharan Africa cobra venoms

Cobras are the most medically important elapid snakes in Africa. The African genera Naja and Hemachatus include snakes with neurotoxic and cytotoxic venoms, with shared biochemical, toxinological and antigenic characteristics. We have studied the antigenic cross-reactivity of four sub-Saharan Africa cobra venoms against an experimental monospecific Hemachatus haemachatus antivenom through comparative proteomics, preclinical assessment of neutralization, and third generation antivenomics. The venoms of H. haemachatus, N. annulifera, N. mossambica and N. nigricollis share an overall qualitative family toxin composition but depart in their proportions of three-finger toxin (3FTxs) classes, phospholipases A₂ (PLA₂s), snake venom metalloproteinases (SVMPs), and cysteine-rich secretory proteins (CRISPs). A monospecific anti-Hemachatus antivenom produced by Costa Rican Instituto Clodomiro Picado neutralized the lethal activity of the homologous and heterologous neuro/cytotoxic (H. haemachatus) and cyto/cardiotoxic (N. mossambica and N. nigricollis) venoms of the three spitting cobras sampled, while it was ineffective against the lethal and toxic activities of the neurotoxic venom of the non-spitting snouted cobra N. annulifera. The ability of the anti-Hemachatus-ICP antivenom to neutralize toxic (dermonecrotic and anticoagulant) and enzymatic (PLA₂) activities of spitting cobra venoms suggested a closer kinship of H. haemachatus and Naja subgenus Afrocobra spitting cobras than to Naja subgenus Uraeus neurotoxic taxa. These results were confirmed by third generation antivenomics. BIOLOGICAL SIGNIFICANCE: African Naja species represent the most widespread medically important elapid snakes across Africa. To gain deeper insight into the spectrum of medically relevant toxins, we compared the proteome of three spitting cobras (Hemachatus haemachatus, Naja mossambica and N. nigricollis) and one non-spitting cobra (N. annulifera). Three finger toxins and phospholipases A₂ are the two major protein families among the venoms analyzed. The development of antivenoms of broad species coverage is an urgent need in sub-Saharan Africa. An equine antivenom raised against H. haemachatus venom showed cross-reactivity with the venoms of H. haemachatus, N. mossambica and N. nigricollis, while having poor recognition of the venom of N. annulifera. This immunological information provides clues for the design of optimum venom mixtures for the preparation of broad spectrum antivenoms.

Distinctive Distribution of Secretory Phospholipases A₂ in the Venoms of Afro-Asian Cobras (Subgenus: Naja, Afronaja, Boulengerina and Uraeus)

The protein abundances of phospholipases A₂ in cobra venom proteomes appear to vary among cobra species. To determine the unique distribution of snake venom phospholipases A₂ (svPLA₂) in the cobras, the svPLA₂ activities for 15 cobra species were examined with an acidimetric and a colorimetric assay, using egg yolk suspension and 4-nitro-3-octanoyloxy benzoic acid (NOBA) as the substrate. The colorimetric assay showed significant correlation between svPLA₂ enzymatic activities with the svPLA₂ protein abundances in venoms. High svPLA₂ activities were observed in the venoms of Asiatic spitting cobras (Naja sputatrix, Naja sumatrana) and moderate activities in Asiatic non-spitters (Naja naja, Naja atra, Naja kaouthia), African spitters (subgenus Afronaja), and forest cobra (subgenus Boulengerina). African non-spitting cobras of subgenus Uraeus (Naja haje, Naja annulifera, Naja nivea, Naja senegalensis) showed exceptionally low svPLA₂ enzymatic activities. The negligible PLA₂ activity in Uraeus cobra venoms implies that PLA₂ may not be ubiquitous in all snake venoms. The svPLA₂ in cobra envenoming varies depending on the cobra species. This may potentially influence the efficacy of cobra antivenom in specific use for venom neutralization.

First Look at the Venom of Naja ashei

Naja ashei is an African spitting cobra species closely related to N. mossambica and N. nigricollis. It is known that the venom of N. ashei, like that of other African spitting cobras, mainly has cytotoxic effects, however data about its specific protein composition are not yet available. Thus, an attempt was made to determine the venom proteome of N. ashei with the use of 2-D electrophoresis and MALDI ToF/ToF (Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization Time of Flight) mass spectrometry techniques. Our investigation revealed that the main components of analysed venom are 3FTxs (Three-Finger Toxins) and PLA₂s (Phospholipases A₂). Additionally the presence of cysteine-rich venom proteins, 5'-nucleotidase and metalloproteinases has also been confirmed. The most interesting fact derived from this study is that the venom of N. ashei includes proteins not described previously in other African spitting cobras-cobra venom factor and venom nerve growth factor. To our knowledge, there are currently no other reports concerning this venom composition and we believe that our results will significantly increase interest in research of this species.

Cytotoxiciy of Naja nubiae (Serpentes: Elapidae) and Echis ocellatus (Serpentes: Viperidae) Venoms from Sudan

In Sudan, as in many African countries, no local specific antivenom is manufactured resulting in snake bite victims being treated by antivenoms imported from abroad. In the present work we measured the cytotoxic effect of the recently described spitting cobra (Naja nubiae) and the carpet viper (Echis ocellatus) snake venoms using a cell based assay. We also investigated the efficacy of four antivenoms CSL (Australia), SAIMR (South Africa), snake venom antiserum (India), and EchiTAb-Plus-ICP (Cost Rica) to neutralize the cytotoxic effect of the two venoms. The venoms resulted in a remarkable inhibition of cell viability with N. nubiae being more cytotoxic than E. ocellatus. The four antivenoms studied were effective in neutralizing N. nubiae cytotoxicity. However, only partial efficacy in neutralizing the cytotoxic effect of E. ocellatus was achieved using CSL (Australia) and SVA (India) antivenoms. Based on the cross neutralization by the four antivenoms, the Sudanese N. nubiae venom most likely has homologous epitopes with similar snakes from Australia, South Africa, India, and Cost Rica, while E. ocellatus venom from Sudan shares little homology with similar snakes from other countries.

Isolation and characterization of "Reprotoxin", a novel protein complex from Daboia russelii snake venom

In snake venoms, non-covalent protein-protein interaction leads to protein complexes with synergistic and, at times, distinct pharmacological activities. Here we describe a new protein complex containing phospholipaseA(2) (PLA(2)), protease, and a trypsin inhibitor. It is isolated from the venom of Daboia russelii by gel permeation chromatography, on a Sephadex G-75 column. This 44.6 kDa complex exhibits only phospholipase A(2) activity. In the presence of 8M urea it is well resolved into protease (29.1 kDa), PLA(2) (13 kDa), and trypsin inhibitor (6.5 kDa) peaks. The complex showed an LD(50) of 5.06 mg/kg body weight in mice. It inhibited the frequency of spontaneous release of neurotransmitter in hippocampal neurons. It also caused peritoneal bleeding, and edema in the mouse foot pads. Interestingly, the complex caused degeneration of both the germ cells and the mouse Leydig cells of mouse testis. A significant reduction in both the diameter of the seminiferous tubules and height of the seminiferous epithelia were observed following intraperitoneal injection of the sub-lethal dose (3 mg/kg body weight). This effect of the toxin is supported by the increase in the activities of acid and alkaline phosphatases and the nitric oxide content in the testes, and a decrease in the ATPase activity. Because of its potent organ atrophic effects on the reproductive organs, the toxin is named "Reprotoxin". This is the first report demonstrating toxicity to the reproductive system by a toxin isolated from snake venom.

Phospholipase A2 diversity and polymorphism in European viper venoms: Paradoxical molecular evolution in Viperinae

We report the diversity and polymorphism of phospholipase A(2) (PLA(2)) transcripts from snakes belonging to nine European viper subspecies. This diversity results in the expression of a combination of six PLA(2) species--ammodytin I1, ammodytin I2, ammodytin L, ammodytoxin, vaspin A and vaspin B--with 19 known isoforms of the first five of these species. Most of the European viper venoms studied contained either a myotoxin or a neurotoxin, and all contained ammodytin I1 and ammodytin I2. There is no evidence that a given pattern of PLA(2) species constitutes a taxonomic criterion, and isoform analysis would be required for such discrimination. Analysis of the phylogenetic relationships between PLA(2) species from European vipers and those of other members of the Viperinae revealed a strong correlation between the geographical source of the viper and the clustering seen for the different isoforms, for each PLA(2) species. The K(a)/K(s) values calculated for the mature protein-coding region of paralogous genes showed that ratios for pairs including vaspin B or one ammodytoxin isoform were greater than 1.09, whereas those for most of the remaining pairs were less than 1. Different patterns of mutation were observed in comparisons of the different PLA(2) isoforms. The mechanisms directing a mutation toward a precise exon remain unresolved.

Cytotoxicity of Lachesis muta muta snake (bushmaster) venom and its purified basic phospholipase A2 (LmTX-I) in cultured cells

Human envenoming by Lachesis muta muta venom, although infrequent, is rather severe, being characterized by pronounced local tissue damage and systemic dysfunctions. Studies on the pharmacological actions of L. m. muta venom are relatively scant and the direct actions of the crude venom and its purified phospholipase A(2) (PLA(2)) have not been addressed using in vitro models. In this work, we investigated the cytotoxicity of L. m. muta venom and its purified PLA(2) isoform LmTX-I in cultured Madin-Darby canine kidney (MDCK) and in a skeletal muscle (C2C12) cell lines. As revealed by neutral red dye uptake assay, the crude venom (10 or 100 microg/ml) induced a significant decrease in cell viability of MDCK cells. LmTX-I at the concentrations tested (70-270 microg/ml or 5-20 microM) displayed no cytotoxicity in both MDCK and C2C12 cell lines. Morphometric analysis of Feulgen nuclear reaction revealed a significant increase in chromatin condensation (pyknosis), apparent reduction in the number of mitotic nuclei and nuclear fragmentation of some MDCK cells after incubation with L. m. muta venom. Monolayer exposure to crude venom resulted in morphological changes as assessed by scanning electron microscopy. The staining with TRITC-labelled phalloidin showed a marked disarray of the actin stress fiber following L. m. muta venom exposure. In contrast, LmTX-I had no effect on nucleus and cell morphologies as well as on stress fiber organization. These results indicate that L. m. muta venom exerts toxic effects on cultured MDCK cells. The LmTX-I probably does not contribute per se to the direct venom cytotoxicity, these effects are mediated by metalloproteinases/disintegrins and other components of the venom.

Comparative characterisation of Russell's viper (Daboia/Vipera russelli) venoms from different regions of the Indian peninsula

Russell's viper (Daboia/Vipera russelli) venom from different regions of India was subjected to chromatographic, electrophoretic, biochemical and immunological analysis. The elution profiles from ion-exchange chromatography and protein banding pattern from SDS-PAGE showed a significant variation in the constituents of venoms. The acidic proteins are found to be predominant in the venoms of eastern and western regions while basic proteins are the major contributors of the northern and southern regional venoms. The major variation of phospholipases A(2) in the venom samples of India may be described as: southern regional venom is rich in basic, toxic PLA(2) while this activity showed a dramatic decrease as one moves towards west, north and eastern regions of India. In addition, the caseinolytic, TAME-hydrolytic, anticoagulant, oedema-inducing and haemorrhagic activities of the venoms have also varied from one region to another. The muscle specimens of mice injected with venoms of different regions showed variable change in the muscle fibre damage and cell morphology. The eastern regional venom is most lethal among all the venoms. The lethal potencies for four regional venoms vary as: eastern>western>southern>northern. The polyclonal antibodies prepared against the venom of southern region showed cross-reaction with the venoms of other regions, but the extent of cross-reaction and diffusion patterns are different. However, the polyclonal antibodies prepared against southern regional venom showed no protection against lethal toxicity of other regional venoms.

Purification and characterization of three acidic, cytotoxic phospholipases A2 from Indian cobra (Naja naja naja) venom

Three acidic phospholipases A2 (NN-I2c-PLA2, NN-I2d-PLA2 and NN-I2c-PLA2) were purified by successive chromatography of Indian cobra (Naja naja naja) venom on CM-Sephadex C-25, Sephadex G-50 and QAE Sephadex A-25 columns. They have molecular weights of 13,000-14,500 by sodium dodecyl sulphate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. They showed tryptophan specific fluorescence emission spectra (approximately 345 nm). All the three phospholipases A2 were enzymatically highly active with specific activities 9-17 micromol min(-1) mg(-1). They were non-lethal to mice when injected intraperitoneally in doses up to 10 mg kg(-1) body weight. They induced edema in mouse foot pads and were cytotoxic to Ehrlich ascites tumour cells. They did not exhibit direct haemolytic and anticoagulant activities.

The composition of Naja naja venom samples from three districts of West Bengal, India

The variation in the composition of Naja naja venoms from three neighbouring districts of West Bengal, eastern India and the corresponding differences in the severity of pathogenesis due to venom composition variation are reported. These venom samples differ with respect to chromatographic elution profile and enzyme activity associated with each fraction. Presence of higher quantities of basic phospholipase and plasma protein hydrolase in the venom samples of Burdwan and Purulia make them more toxic than Midnapur venom sample. A polyvalent antivenom manufactured in western India was hardly effective in neutralizing the pathobiological manifestation of the venom samples from eastern India.

Two types of Russell's viper revealed by variation in phospholipases A2 from venom of the subspecies

This study compared the phospholipases A2 (PLA2S) present in four commercially available venoms of Russell's viper subspecies by HPLC fractionation and partial sequence analysis. A potent heterodimeric PLA2 neurotoxin (designated a Russtoxin) was found in the venoms of all Russell's vipers except Daboia russelli (Sri Lanka and South India). The venom PLA2S of D. r. russelli (southern India) used in a previous study appear to be the same as those of D. r. pulchella (Sri Lanka), while the venom PLA2S of D. r. russelli (Pakistan) and D. r. siamensis (Burma and Thailand) resemble those of D. r. formosensis (Taiwan). This study provides evidence for the presence of two types of Russell's viper. Daboia russelli formosensis (Taiwan). D. r. siamensis (Thailand and Burma) and D. r. russelli (Pakistan) represent one type whose venom contains PLA2S having an Asn residue at the N-terminus, while D. r. pulchella (South India and Sri Lanka) represents the other type, whose venom contains PLA2S with a N-terminal residue Ser.

A major lethal factor of the venom of Burmese Russell's viper (Daboia russelli siamensis): isolation, N-terminal sequencing and biological activities of daboiatoxin

A major lethal factor, daboiatoxin (DbTx), showing strong PLA2 activity (specific activity 91.7 nmoles/min/mg), was purified to homogeneity from the venom of Burmese Russell's viper (Daboia r. siamensis) by a combination of gel filtration on Sephadex G-75 and ion-exchange chromatography on CM-Sephadex C-25, followed by purification on high-performance gel filtration Shim-pack Diol-150 column. DbTx is a single-chain PLA2 toxin with approximate mol. wt 15,000 as determined by HPLC gel filtration and SDS-PAGE. It constitutes 12% of total venom protein and is the main lethal component of Burmese Russell's viper venom with an LD50 i.p. (0.05 mg/kg) 12-fold greater than that of the whole venom (LD50 i.p. 0.6 mg/kg). DbTx produces neurotoxic symptoms in mice and exhibits potent oedema-inducing activity (minimum oedema dose 0.05 microgram), indirect haemolytic activity and a strong myonecrotic activity, but no haemorrhagic activity. DbTx is cytotoxic to HeLa cells causing cytolysis of the cells 24 hr post-exposure to toxin (50 micrograms/ml). The first 20 N-terminal amino acid sequence (NFFQF AEMIV KMTGK EAVHS) shows a significant resemblance to those of the PLA2s from the venoms of Bulgarian viper (V. a. ammodytes) and Taiwan Russell's viper (V. r. formosensis).

Broad cytolytic specificity of myotoxin II, a lysine-49 phospholipase A2 of Bothrops asper snake venom

The cytotoxic activity of Bothrops asper myotoxin II, a lysine-49 phospholipase A2 isoform, on different cell types in culture, was investigated. Myotoxin II caused a dose-dependent cytolytic effect on all cell types tested, characterized by rapid release of cytoplasmic lactic dehydrogenase and drastic morphological cell alterations. Quantitative differences in the susceptibility to myotoxin II among cell types fell within a relatively narrow range, and in general, the toxin was cytolytic at concentrations of 50-100 micrograms/ml (3-7 microM), when assays were performed using culture medium as a diluent. Toxin activity was markedly enhanced if phosphate-buffered saline was utilized instead of medium. The cytotoxic activity of myotoxin III, an aspartate-49 isoform from the same venom, on both endothelial cells and skeletal muscle myoblasts was higher than that of myotoxin II, suggesting that, although phospholipase A2 activity is clearly not required for the induction of cell damage, it may have an enhancing role. In contrast to B. asper myotoxins, other basic phospholipases A2 with myotoxic activity in vivo (notexin from Notechis scutatus, and two enzymes isolated from Vipera russelli venom) did not affect endothelial cells and myoblasts. Pretreatment of cells with neuraminidase, tunicamycin, or protamine, did not alter their susceptibility to myotoxin II. At low temperatures (2-4 degrees C) myotoxin II was devoid of cytolytic effect. Washing and neutralization experiments using heparin with low affinity for antithrombin or mouse monoclonal antibody MAb-3 suggest that at low temperatures myotoxin II binds very weakly to the cells, and that its normal interaction with the putative target is probably not only based on charge, but that a membrane penetration event may be required.