Specificity of in vitro reconstitution of bromegrass mosaic virus

The brome mosaic virus 3' untranslated sequence regulates RNA replication, recombination, and virion assembly

The 3' untranslated region in each of the three genomic RNAs of Brome mosaic virus (BMV) is highly homologous and contains a sequence that folds into a tRNA-like structure (TLS). Experiments performed over the past four decades revealed that the BMV 3' TLS regulates many important steps in BMV infection. This review summarizes in vitro and in vivo studies of the roles of the BMV 3' TLS functioning as a minus-strand promoter, in RNA recombination, and to nucleate virion assembly.

Depurination of Brome mosaic virus RNA3 inhibits its packaging into virus particles

Packaging of the segmented RNA genome of Brome mosaic virus (BMV) into discrete particles is an essential step in the virus life cycle; however, questions remain regarding the mechanism of RNA packaging and the degree to which the viral coat protein controls the process. In this study, we used a plant-derived glycosidase, Pokeweed antiviral protein, to remove 14 specific bases from BMV RNA3 to examine the effect of depurination on virus assembly. Depurination of A771 within ORF3 and A1006 in the intergenic region inhibited coat protein binding and prevented RNA3 incorporation into particles. The disruption of interaction was not based on sequence identity, as mutation of these two purines to pyrimidines did not decrease coat protein-binding affinity. Rather, we suggest that base removal results in decreased thermodynamic stability of local RNA structures required for packaging, and that this instability is detected by coat protein. These results describe a new level of discrimination by coat protein, whereby it recognizes damage to specific viral RNA elements in the form of base removal and selects against incorporating the RNA into particles.

Genome packaging by spherical plant RNA viruses

The majority of positive-strand RNA viruses of plants replicate and selectively encapsidate their progeny genomes into stable virions in cytoplasmic compartments of the cell where the opportunity to copackage cellular RNA also exists. Remarkably, highly purified infectious virions contain almost exclusively viral RNA, suggesting that mechanisms exist to regulate preferential packaging of viral genomes. The general principle that governs RNA packaging is an interaction between the structural CP and a specific RNA signal. Mechanisms that enhance selective packaging of viral genomes and formation of infectious virions may involve factors other than CP and nucleic acid sequences. The possible involvement of replicase proteins is an example. Our knowledge concerning genome packaging among spherical plant RNA viruses is still maturing. The main focus of this review is to discuss factors that have limited progress and to evaluate recent technical breakthroughs likely to help unravel the mechanism of RNA packaging among viruses of agronomic importance. A key breakthrough is the development of in vivo systems and comparisons with results obtained in vitro.

Deletion of highly conserved arginine-rich RNA binding motif in cowpea chlorotic mottle virus capsid protein results in virion structural alterations and RNA packaging constraints

The N-proximal region of cowpea chlorotic mottle virus (CCMV) capsid protein (CP) contains an arginine-rich RNA binding motif (ARM) that is also found in the CPs of other members of Bromoviridae and in other RNA binding proteins such as the Tat and Rev proteins of human immunodeficiency virus. To assess the critical role played by this motif during encapsidation, a variant of CCMV RNA3 (C3) precisely lacking the ARM region (C3/Delta919) of its CP gene was constructed. The biology and the competence of the matured CP derived in vivo from C3/Delta919 to assemble and package progeny RNA was examined in whole plants. Image analysis and computer-assisted three-dimensional reconstruction of wild-type and mutant virions revealed that the CP subunits bearing the engineered deletion assembled into polymorphic virions with altered surface topology. Northern blot analysis of virion RNA from mutant progeny demonstrated that the engineered mutation down-regulated packaging of all four viral RNAs; however, the packaging effect was more pronounced on genomic RNA1 and RNA2 than genomic RNA3 and its CP mRNA. In vitro assembly assays with mutant CP subunits and RNA transcripts demonstrated that the mutant CP is inherently not defective in packaging genomic RNA1 (53%) and RNA2 (54%), but their incorporation into virions was competitively inhibited by the presence of other viral RNAs. Northern blot analysis of RNA encapsidation in vivo of two distinct bromovirus RNA3 chimeras, constructed by exchanging CPs having the Delta919 deletion, demonstrated that the role of the conserved N-terminal ARM in recognizing and packaging specific RNA is distinct for each virus.

Dispensability of 3' tRNA-like sequence for packaging cowpea chlorotic mottle virus genomic RNAs

The 3' ends of three genomic RNAs (gRNAs) of cowpea chlorotic mottle virus (CCMV) terminate in a highly conserved tRNA-like structure (3'TLS). To examine the intrinsic role played the 3'TLS in packaging, the competence of each gRNA lacking the 3' TLS (DeltaTLS-gRNA) to interact with dissociated coat protein (CP) subunits and form virions was assayed in vitro. In contrast to the well established requirement for the participation of either viral 3'TLS or host-tRNAs in the assembly of RNA-containing virions in brome mosaic virus (BMV; Choi, Y, G., Dreher, T. W., Rao, A. L. N. 2002. tRNA elements mediate the assembly of an icosahedral RNA virus. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 99, 655-660), CCMV CP does not require the presence of viral TLS in cis or in trans. Similar in vitro assembly assays showed that CCMV CP subunits also packaged BMV RNAs lacking 3' TLS as well as two other non-bromoviral RNAs although with lesser efficiency. To characterize sequences of CCMV RNA3 (C3) required for packaging, a series deletions was engineered into C3 and their effect on virus assembly was examined. It was observed that, unlike BMV RNA3 whose packaging requires a bipartite signal (Choi, Y. G., Rao, A. L. N. 2003. Packaging of brome mosaic virus RNA3 is mediated through a bipartite signal. J. Virol. 77, 9750-9757), packaging of C3 is independent of either movement protein (MP) ORF or CP ORF or 3' non-coding regions. Based on the differential prerequisites identified in this study for the assembly of BMV and CCMV, we hypothesize that the adaptive condition for movement in monocotyledonous host has made packaging a necessary co-requirement for BMV.

Packaging of brome mosaic virus RNA3 is mediated through a bipartite signal

The three genomic and a single subgenomic RNA of brome mosaic virus (BMV), an RNA virus infecting plants, are packaged by a single-coat protein (CP) into three morphologically indistinguishable icosahedral virions with T = 3 quasi-symmetry. Genomic RNAs 1 and 2 are packaged individually into separate particles whereas genomic RNA3 and subgenomic RNA4 (coat protein mRNA) are copackaged into a single particle. We report here that packaging of dicistronic RNA3 requires a bipartite signal. A highly conserved 3' tRNA-like structure postulated to function as a nucleating element (NE) for CP subunits (Y. G. Choi, T. W. Dreher, and A. L. N. Rao, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 99:655-660, 2002) and a cis-acting, position-dependent packaging element (PE) of 187 nt present in the nonstructural movement protein gene are the integral components of the packaging core. Efficient incorporation into BMV virions of nonviral RNA chimeras containing NE and the PE provides confirmatory evidence that these two elements are sufficient to direct packaging. Analysis of virion RNA profiles obtained from barley protoplasts transfected with a RNA3 variant lacking the PE provides the first genetic evidence that de novo synthesized RNA4 is incompetent for autonomous assembly whereas prior packaging of RNA3 is a prerequisite for RNA4 to copackage.

cis-acting elements required for efficient packaging of brome mosaic virus RNA3 in barley protoplasts

Brome mosaic virus (BMV) is a positive-sense RNA plant virus, the tripartite genomic RNAs of which are separately packaged into virions. RNA3 is copackaged with subgenomic RNA4. In barley protoplasts coinoculated with RNA1 and RNA2, an RNA3 mutant with a 69-nucleotide (nt) deletion in the 3'-proximal region of the 3a open reading frame (ORF) was very poorly packaged compared with other RNA3 mutants and wild-type RNA3, despite their comparable accumulation in the absence of coat protein. Computer analysis of RNA secondary structure predicted two stem-loop (SL) structures (i.e., SL-I and SL-II) in the 69-nt region. Disruption of SL-II, but not of SL-I, significantly reduced RNA3 packaging. A chimeric BMV RNA3 (B3Cmp), with the BMV 3a ORF replacing that of cucumber mosaic virus (CMV), was packaged negligibly, whereas RNA4 was packaged efficiently. Replacement of the 3'-proximal region of the CMV 3a ORF in B3Cmp with the 3'-proximal region of the BMV 3a ORF significantly improved packaging efficiency, and the disruption of SL-II in the substituted BMV 3a ORF region greatly reduced packaging efficiency. These results suggest that the 3'-proximal region of the BMV 3a ORF, especially SL-II predicted between nt 904 and 933, plays an important role in the packaging of BMV RNA3 in vivo. Furthermore, the efficient packaging of RNA4 without RNA3 in B3Cmp-infected cells implies the presence of an element in the 3a ORF of BMV RNA3 that regulates the copackaging of RNA3 and RNA4.

Positional effect of deletions on viability, especially on encapsidation, of Brome mosaic virus D-RNA in barley protoplasts

Brome mosaic virus (BMV), a tripartite RNA plant virus, accumulates RNA3-derived defective RNAs (D-RNAs) in which 477-500 nucleotides (nt) are deleted in the central region of the 3a protein open reading frame (ORF), after prolonged infection in barley. In the present study, six artificial D-RNAs (AD-RNAs), having deletions of the same size as the naturally occurring D-RNA but at different positions in the 3a ORF, were constructed and tested for their amplification and encapsidation in barley protoplasts by coinoculation with BMV RNA1 and 2, or RNA1, 2, and 3. Northern blot analysis of RNA accumulation in total and virion fractions showed that deletions of 492 nt in the 3'-proximal and the 5'-proximal regions of the 3a ORF decreased encapsidation efficiency of the AD-RNAs compared with that of RNA3, whereas deletions in the central region enhanced encapsidation efficiency. The present results also show that deletion positions affect competition with RNA3 in the amplification and encapsidation of AD-RNAs.

tRNA elements mediate the assembly of an icosahedral RNA virus

tRNAs, the adapter molecules in protein synthesis, also serve as metabolic cofactors and as primers for viral RNA-directed DNA synthesis. The genomic and subgenomic RNAs of some plant viruses have a 3'-terminal tRNA-like structure (TLS) that can accept a specific amino acid and serve as a site for initiation of replication and as a simple telomere. We report a previously undescribed role for the TLS of brome mosaic virus (BMV), and potentially for cellular tRNA, in mediating the assembly of its icosahedral virions. BMV genomic RNAs and subgenomic RNA lacking the TLS failed to assemble into virions when incubated with purified BMV coat protein. Assembly was restored by addition of a 201-nt RNA containing the BMV TLS. TLSs from two other plant viruses as well as tRNAs from wheat germ and yeast were similarly active in the BMV virion assembly reaction, but ribosomal RNA and polyadenylate did not facilitate assembly. Surprisingly, virions assembled from TLS-less BMV RNA in the presence of tRNAs or TLS-containing short RNA did not incorporate the latter molecules. Consistent with a critical role for the BMV TLS in virion assembly, mutations in the BMV genomic RNAs that were designed to disrupt the folding of the TLS also abolished virion assembly. We discuss the likely roles of the TLS in early stages of virion assembly.

Packaging of tobacco mosaic virus subgenomic RNAs by Brome mosaic virus coat protein exhibits RNA controlled polymorphism

The coat protein (CP) of icosahedral Brome mosaic virus (BMV) was expressed from a genetically engineered rod-shape Tobacco mosaic virus. Molecular characterization of the progeny recovered from symptomatic plants revealed that BMV CP selectively packaged the three subgenomic RNAs of the hybrid virus into two differently sized icosahedral virus-like particles (VLPs). The smaller VLPs packaged only the two smaller subgenomic RNAs. Additional in vitro reassembly assays with BMV CP subunits and transcripts of hybrid subgenomic RNAs further demonstrated that the ability of BMV capsids to display polymorphism is not dependent on the RNA size alone and appears to be controlled by some other feature(s) of the genetically engineered RNA.

Molecular studies on bromovirus capsid protein. VII. Selective packaging on BMV RNA4 by specific N-terminal arginine residuals

An arginine-rich RNA-binding motif (ARM) found at the N-proximal region of Brome mosaic virus (BMV) coat protein (CP) adopts alpha-helical conformation and shares homology with CPs of plant and insect RNA viruses, HIV-Rev and Tat proteins, bacterial antiterminators, and ribosomal splicing factors. The ARM of BMV CP, consisting of amino acids 9 through 21 with six arginine residues, is essential for RNA binding and subsequent packaging. In this study analysis of the alpha-helical contents of wild-type and mutant peptides by circular dichroism spectra identified protein determinants required for such conformation. Electrophoretic mobility-shift assays between viral RNA and BMV CP peptides with either proline or alanine substitutions revealed that the interaction is nonspecific. Expression in vivo of mature full-length BMV CP subunits, having the same substitutions for each arginine within the ARM, derived from biologically active clones was found to be competent to assemble into infectious virions and cause visible symptom phenotypes in whole plants. However, analysis of virion progeny RNA profiles of CP variants and subsequent in vitro reassembly assays between mutant CP and four BMV RNAs unveiled the ability of arginine residues at positions 10, 13, or 14 of the ARM to confer selective packaging of BMV RNA4. Thus, BMV CP contains determinants that specifically interact with RNA4 to ensure selective packaging.

Molecular studies on bromovirus capsid protein

Brome mosaic bromovirus (BMV) and cucumber mosaic cucumovirus (CMV) are structurally and genetically very similar. The specificity of the BMV and CMV coat proteins (CPs) during in vivo encapsidation was studied using two RNA3 chimera in which the respective CP genes were exchanged. The replicative competence of each chimera was analyzed in Nicotiana benthamiana protoplasts, and their ability to cause infections was examined in two common permissive hosts, Chenopodium quinoa and N. benthamiana. Each RNA3 chimera replicated to near wild-type (wt) levels and synthesized CPs of expected parental origin when co-inoculated with their respective genomic wt RNAs 1 and 2. However, inoculum containing each chimera was noninfectious in the common permissive hosts tested. Encapsidation assays in N. benthamiana protoplasts revealed that CMV CP expressed from chimeric BMV RNA3 was capable of packaging heterologous BMV RNA, however, at a lower efficiency than parental BMV CP. By contrast, BMV CP expressed from chimeric CMV RNA3 was unable to package heterologous CMV RNA. These observations demonstrate that BMV CP, but not CMV CP, exhibits a high degree of specificity during in vivo packaging. The reasons for the noninfectious nature of each chimera in the host plants tested and factors likely to affect encapsidation in vivo are discussed.