Strains and mutants of tobacco mosaic virus are both found in virus derived from single-lesion-passaged inoculum

Tobamoviruses as Models for the Study of Virus Evolution

The study of tobacco mosaic virus and other tobamovirus species has greatly contributed to the development of all areas of virology, including virus evolution. Research with tobamoviruses has been pioneer, or particularly significant, in all major areas of research in this field, including: the characterization of the genetic diversity of virus populations, the mechanisms and rates of generation of genetic diversity, the analysis of the genetic structure of virus populations and of the factors that shape it, the adaptation of viruses to hosts and the evolution of host range, and the evolution of virus taxa and of virus-host interactions. Many of these continue to be hot topics in evolutionary biology, or have been identified recently as such, including (i) host-range evolution, (ii) predicting the overcoming of resistance in crops, (iii) trade-offs between virus life-history traits in virus evolution, and (iv) the codivergence of viruses and hosts at different taxonomical and spatial scales. Tobamoviruses may be particularly appropriate to address these topics with plant viruses, as they provide convenient experimental systems, and as the detailed knowledge on their molecular and structural biology allows the analysis of the mechanisms behind evolutionary processes. Also, the extensive information on parameters related to infection dynamics and population structure may facilitate the development of realistic models to predict virus evolution. Certainly, tobamoviruses will continue to be favorite system for the study of virus evolution.

Host effect on the genetic diversification of beet necrotic yellow vein virus single-plant populations

Theoretical models predict that, under restrictive host conditions, virus populations will exhibit greater genetic variability. This virus response has been experimentally demonstrated in a few cases but its relation with a virus's capability to overcome plant resistance is unknown. To explore the genetic host effects on Beet necrotic yellow vein virus (BNYVV) populations that might be related to resistance durability, a wild-type virus isolate was vector inoculated into partially resistant Rz1, Rz2, and susceptible sugar beet cultivars during a serial planting experiment. Cloning and sequencing a region of the viral RNA-3, involving the pathogenic determinant p25, revealed that virus diversity significantly increased in direct proportion to the strength of host resistance. Thus, whereas virus titers were highest, intermediate, and lowest in susceptible, Rz1, and Rz2 plants, respectively; the average number of nucleotide differences among single-plant populations was 0.8 (±0.1) in susceptible, 1.4 (±0.1) in Rz1, and 2.4 (±0.2) in Rz2 genotypes. A similar relationship between host restriction to BNYVV root accumulation and virus genetic variability was detected in fields of sugar beet where these specific Rz1- and Rz2-mediated resistances have been defeated.

Identification and molecular characterization of two naturally occurring Soybean mosaic virus isolates that are closely related but differ in their ability to overcome Rsv4 resistance

A naturally occurring Rsv4 resistance-breaking isolate (L-RB) and a closely related non-resistance-breaking isolate (L) of Soybean mosaic virus (SMV) were identified in soybean fields in London, Ontario, Canada. The viral genomes of L and L-RB were completely sequenced. Each isolate has a 9585-nucleotide genome with a single open reading frame encoding a polyprotein of approximately 350 kDa. L-RB and L have a very high sequence similarity (99.6%) at both the nucleotide and amino acid levels. Phylogenetic analysis showed that the two isolates belong to the G2 pathotype. Pathogenicity predictions of all virus/soybean combinations, based on the phylogenetic profile, were confirmed by pathogenicity tests using L and L-RB isolates and soybeans carrying different resistance genes, with an exception that L-RB infected a soybean cultivar carrying Rsv4 resistance. The temporal and spatial proximity of L and L-RB and their high sequence similarity suggest L-RB was likely derived from the SMV-L quasispecies. Recombination analysis did not reveal the evidence of genetic recombination for the emergence of L-RB. Mutations introduced by virus-encoded RNA-dependent RNA polymerase during viral genome replication and selection pressure probably contributed to the occurrence of L-RB.

Molecular analysis of quasispecies of Kyuri green mottle mosaic virus

The population diversity of progeny viruses of Kyuri green mottle mosaic virus (KGMMV) in consecutive serial passages in two systemic hosts, zucchini squash and cucumber plants, established from genetically identical viral RNA, was examined in this study. An initial plant was inoculated with in vitro transcripts from a full-length cDNA clone of KGMMV. The initial viral population (passage 0) was transferred five times in parallel populations in the same hosts species for analysis of progenies of KGMMV. The percentage of mutations of progeny viruses fluctuated slightly, as expected, during the serial passage, and these results did not correlated with the mutation frequency calculated as the total number of mutation observed in all the clones sequenced for a given viral population were divided by the total number of bases sequenced for the population. The mutation frequencies represented similar distributions over the course of serial passages in the two systemic host plants. Seventeen unique mutations were detected from a total of 40 clones (19,120 bases) sequenced, indicating a relatively small overall mutation rate of 17 nucleotide substitutions. The majority of observed mutations in the viral populations consisted of substitutions: 61.60 and 64.08% of the mutations in cucumber and zucchini populations, respectively. The types of transitions and silent mutations indicated that progenies of KGMMV reached stabilized selection during the host passages and maintained viral quasispecies in systemic hosts.

Evolution of Soybean mosaic virus-G7 molecularly cloned genome in Rsv1-genotype soybean results in emergence of a mutant capable of evading Rsv1-mediated recognition

Plant resistance (R) genes direct recognition of pathogens harboring matching avirluent signals leading to activation of defense responses. It has long been hypothesized that under selection pressure the infidelity of RNA virus replication together with large population size and short generation times results in emergence of mutants capable of evading R-mediated recognition. In this study, the Rsv1/Soybean mosaic virus (SMV) pathosystem was used to investigate this hypothesis. In soybean line PI 96983 (Rsv1), the progeny of molecularly cloned SMV strain G7 (pSMV-G7) provokes a lethal systemic hypersensitive response (LSHR) with up regulation of a defense-associated gene transcript (PR-1). Serial passages of a large population of the progeny in PI 96983 resulted in emergence of a mutant population (vSMV-G7d), incapable of provoking either Rsv1-mediated LSHR or PR-1 protein gene transcript up regulation. An infectious clone of the mutant (pSMV-G7d) was synthesized whose sequences were very similar but not identical to the vSMV-G7d population; however, it displayed a similar phenotype. The genome of pSMV-G7d differs from parental pSMV-G7 by 17 substitutions, of which 10 are translationally silent. The seven amino acid substitutions in deduced sequences of pSMV-G7d differ from that of pSMV-G7 by one each in P1 proteinase, helper component-proteinase, and coat protein, respectively, and by four in P3. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first demonstration in which experimental evolution of a molecularly cloned plant RNA virus resulted in emergence of a mutant capable of evading an R-mediated recognition.

Variability and genetic structure of plant virus populations

Populations of plant viruses, like all other living beings, are genetically heterogeneous, a property long recognized in plant virology. Only recently have the processes resulting in genetic variation and diversity in virus populations and genetic structure been analyzed quantitatively. The subject of this review is the analysis of genetic variation, its quantification in plant virus populations, and what factors and processes determine the genetic structure of these populations and its temporal change. The high potential for genetic variation in plant viruses, through either mutation or genetic exchange by recombination or reassortment of genomic segments, need not necessarily result in high diversity of virus populations. Selection by factors such as the interaction of the virus with host plants and vectors and random genetic drift may in fact reduce genetic diversity in populations. There is evidence that negative selection results in virus-encoded proteins being not more variable than those of their hosts and vectors. Evidence suggests that small population diversity, and genetic stability, is the rule. Populations of plant viruses often consist of a few genetic variants and many infrequent variants. Their distribution may provide evidence of a population that is undifferentiated, differentiated by factors such as location, host plant, or time, or that fluctuates randomly in composition, depending on the virus.

Susceptibility to recombination rearrangements of a chimeric plum pox potyvirus genome after insertion of a foreign gene

Infectious RNA transcripts were generated from a chimeric cDNA clone of the plum pox potyvirus (PPV) genome containing the bacterial beta-glucuronidase (GUS) gene inserted between the sequences coding for the P1 and HC proteins. An artificial cleavage site specific for the NIa viral proteinase was engineered between the GUS and HC sequences to produce free GUS and HC proteins. The resulting virus PPVGus/ was stably maintained during the first round of infection, although plants remained symptomless and virus accumulation was delayed with respect to wild-type infection. PPVGus/ deleted variants, missing between 645 and 1779 nt, were detected in a subsequent plant passage. PPVGus/ deletions were confined inside the GUS gene, never affecting the P1 and HC coding regions, in contrast with previous reports of deletions in other potyvirus-based vector, in which deletions frequently reached the HC gene. These results suggest that the N-terminus of the PPV HC protein may be essential for virus viability. Analysis of the deletion endpoints showed short stretches of similarity in donor and acceptor RNAs, as well as oligo A tracts conserved in most junction sites, suggesting that deletions in PPVGus/ might take place by similarity-assisted recombination events.

Recombination and polymerase error facilitate restoration of infectivity in brome mosaic virus

The tRNA-like structure present in the 3' noncoding region of each of the four virion RNAs of brome mosaic virus possesses a conserved A-67-U-A-65 (67AUA65) sequence. Four mutations in this region (67UAA65, 67GAA65, and 67CAA65, each with a double base change, and 67GUA65, containing a single point mutation), previously shown in vitro to be defective in minus-strand promoter function, were introduced into full-length genomic RNAs 2 and 3, and their replicative competence was analyzed in barley protoplasts. All four RNA 3 mutants were capable of replication, although progeny plus-sense RNA 3 accumulation was only 12 to 42% of that of the wild type. Replication of RNA 2 transcripts bearing these mutations was even more severely debilitated; the accumulation of each mutant progeny plus-strand RNA 2 was < 10% of that of the wild type. Analysis of mutant RNA 3 progeny recovered from local lesions induced in Chenopodium hybridum and systemic infections in barley (Hordeum vulgare) plants revealed that the mutant base at position 67 from the 3' end had in each case been modified to an A. These changes generated RNAs with functional pseudorevertant (67AAA65 for mutants 67UAA65, 67GAA65, and 67CAA65) or revertant (67GUA65-->67AUA65) sequences. In most instances, the presence of internal markers permitted discrimination between polymerase error and RNA recombination as the process by which sequence restoration occurred. The pseudorevertant sequence was found to be capable of persistence during subsequent propagation in plants when present on RNA 3 but not when present on RNA 2. These data document the fluidity of the RNA genome and reveal situations in which polymerase error or recombination can function preferentially to restore an optimal sequence. They also support the concept that RNA viruses frequently exist as quasispecies and have implications concerning evolutionary strategies for positive-strand RNA viruses.

Alfalfa mosaic virus temperature-sensitive mutants. V. The nucleotide sequence of TBTS 7 RNA 3 shows limited nucleotide changes and evidence for heterologous recombination

Nucleotide sequence determination of the coat protein cistron of the alfalfa mosaic virus (AIMV) temperature-sensitive mutant, Tbts 7 (uv) revealed a small number of point mutations of which only one results in the replacement of an amino acid: the asparagine residue at position 126 is replaced by an aspartate residue. RNA transcribed in vitro from a Tbts 7 cDNA 4 clone directed the production in vitro of a polypeptide which shows the same altered electrophoretic mobility in SDS-polyacrylamide gels as the Tbts 7 coat protein. Nucleotide sequence analysis of the 32-kDa open reading frame revealed some base changes, but none of these lead to changes in the primary structure of the protein. The 5'-terminal sequence of Tbts 7 RNA 3 was analyzed by cDNA cloning. At least three different types of nontranslated leader sequences were found, indicating considerable heterogeneity at the 5' end of the mutant RNA 3. The results indicated that the low abundance of RNA 3-containing particles in Tbts 7 virus preparations might be due to malfunctioning of the 5' terminus of Tbts 7 RNA 3 during replication.

Genetic heterogeneity of the RNA genome population of the plant virus U5-TMV

The genetic heterogeneity in a population of the U5 strain of tobacco mosaic virus (U5-TMV) was studied. The T1 fingerprint characterizing a cloned population did not vary after a new cloning step in the local lesion host Nicotiana tabacum Xanthi-nc, nor during four series of 20 passages in the systemic host N. tabacum Samsum. No heterogeneity was observed among 10 clones derived from the cloned populations, while 1 of 18 clones derived from a 20-fold passaged population differed from the rest in 1 of 55 oligonucleotides. A higher heterogeneity was found in an uncloned field isolate in which 2 of 10 clones differed in type in 1 and 2 oligonucleotides, respectively. These data agree with those reported for bacterial and animal RNA viruses and are compatible with the quasi-species model for RNA populations. On the other hand, the intrapopulational heterogeneities found for U5-TMV are considerably smaller than those reported for other RNA viruses, our data showing a high genetic stability for U5-TMV.

Variability and evolution of the plant RNA virus pepper mild mottle virus

The RNA genomes of 26 isolates of pepper mild mottle virus were compared by their RNase T1 fingerprints. Twenty-three isolates came from epidemic outbreaks in greenhouse-grown peppers in Almería (southeastern Spain) from 1983 to 1987; three other isolates, from 1980, came from Sicily (Italy) and Zaragoza (central Spain). The 26 fingerprints can be classified into 10 different types; nucleotide substitution rates show them to be very similar. Cluster and cladistic analyses group types corresponding to the Almería isolates separate from those of 1980. Intraannual and interannual nucleotide differences were estimated. An evolutionary model for pepper mild mottle virus built on these data indicates a highly stable population, maintaining its diversity through time, with a main prevailing haplotype from which closely related variants arise that do not replace it. This high stability could be due to strong functional constraints on variation, as suggested by the high proportion of invariant versus polymorphic sites in fingerprints.

RNA virus evolution and the control of viral disease

RNA viruses and other RNA genetic elements must be viewed as organized distributions of sequences termed quasi-species. This means that the viral genome is statistically defined but individually indeterminate. Stable distributions may be maintained for extremely long time periods under conditions of population equilibrium. Perturbation of equilibrium results in rapid distribution shifts. This genomic organization has many implications for viral pathogenesis and disease control. This review has emphasized the problem of selection of viral mutants resistant to antiviral drugs and the current difficulties encountered in the design of novel synthetic vaccines. Possible strategies for antiviral therapy and vaccine development have been discussed.

Plant-virus-based vectors for gene transfer will be of limited use because of the high error frequency during viral RNA synthesis

The error frequency during the RNA replication of alfalfa mosaic virus (AMV) was calculated to be significantly higher than 10(-5). It may be expected that RNA synthesis in general will have low fidelity compared to DNA synthesis. The low fidelity of RNA replication will severely restrict the usefulness of vectors for genetic engineering which are based on RNA viruses, viroids or DNA viruses which are replicated via an RNA intermediate (e.g. caulimoviruses). Spontaneous mutants selected by host shift were found to be much less stable than UV-induced mutants. This difference points to variations in fidelity during RNA synthesis, probably due to the local sequence of the template.

The quasispecies (extremely heterogeneous) nature of viral RNA genome populations: biological relevance--a review

We review evidence that cloned (or uncloned) populations of most RNA viruses do not consist of a single genome species of defined sequence, but rather of heterogeneous mixtures of related genomes (quasispecies). Due to very high mutation rates, genomes of a quasispecies virus population share a consensus sequence but differ from each other and from the consensus sequence by one, several, or many mutations. Viral genome analyses by sequencing, fingerprinting, cDNA cloning etc. indicate that most viral RNA populations (quasispecies) contain all possible single and double genomic site mutations and varying proportions of triple, quadruple, etc. site mutations. This quasispecies structure of RNA virus populations has many important theoretical and practical implications because mutations at only one or a few sites may alter the phenotype of an RNA virus.