Visual evoked potentials to stimuli in apparent motion

Attenuation of visual reafferent signals in the parietal cortex during voluntary movement

It is well established that the cortical processing of somatosensory and auditory signals is attenuated when they result from self-generated actions compared with external events. This phenomenon is thought to result from an efference copy of motor commands used to predict the sensory consequences of an action through a forward model. The present work examined whether attenuation also takes place for visual reafferent signals from the moving limb during voluntary reaching movements. To address this issue, EEG activity was recorded in a condition in which visual feedback of the hand was provided in real time and compared with a condition in which it was presented with a 150-ms delay, thus creating a mismatch between the predicted and actual visual consequences of the movement. Results revealed that the amplitude of the N1 component of the visual event-related potential evoked by hand visual feedback over the parietal cortex was significantly smaller when presented in real time compared with when it was delayed. These data suggest that the cortical processing of visual reafferent signals is attenuated when they are correctly predicted, likely as a result of a forward model.

Temporal and spatial congruence of components of motion-onset evoked responses investigated by whole-head magneto-electroencephalography

Motion-onset related components in averaged whole head co-recorded MEG and EEG responses of 24 adults to a low-contrast checkerboard pattern were studied. The aims were to identify these components, to characterize quantitatively their maps and to localize the underlying sources by equivalent-current-dipole (ECD) analyses with a spherical head model.After a weak P1, a large start-elicited negativity arises, comprising the novel N2a (occipital positive and parieto-central negative, peak-latency 141 ms) and the N2 like N2b (bilateral parieto-temporal, 175 ms) component. It is followed by a large positive stop-related component, P2 (156 ms after motion-offset). The corresponding MEG components N2am and N2bm showed bilateral dipole fields with considerable overlap. P1m has a single dipole field around the midline. N2a(m) and N2b(m) can be modelled with two bilateral ECDs with significant different locations. The study shows that accurate mapping and ECD analyses can distinguish two neighbouring areas of the visual cortex, 21+/-4 (SE) mm separated, which activities are reflected in both spatio-temporally closely related N2(m) components. N2a(m) and N2b(m) originate in the extrastriate cortex, possibly close to or in V3/V3A and MT/V5 respectively. Motion-evoked activity in (near) V3/V3A is novel on the basis of EEG data.

Human V5 demonstrated by magnetoencephalography using random dot kinematograms of different coherence levels

To investigate the cortical mechanisms for motion perception in human V5, we measured visual evoked magnetic fields in response to random dot kinematograms (RDKs) of three different coherence levels (50, 70 and 100%) using a 122-channel whole-head magnetometer. As the coherence level increased, the peak amplitude measured by the root mean square (RMS) of the local response increased significantly (7.4+/-1.0, 9.5+/-1.5 and 15.5+/-3.2 fT/cm on the right, 6.4+/-0.3, 7.8+/-0.7 and 12.5+/-0.9 fT/cm on the left; for the coherence level of 50, 70 and 100%, respectively). There was no significant difference between the hemispheres. As for the peak latency, there was no significant difference in terms of coherence levels or hemispheres. The response was localized posterior to the junction of the ascending limb of the inferior temporal and lateral occipital sulci (human V5). These findings indicate that processing of global motion in terms of the synchronized portion correlates well with the response amplitude but not with its latency. Thus, we could estimate the magnetic responses of human V5 non-invasively by presenting different coherence levels of the visual motion stimuli. Hemispheric laterality was recognized, although the dominant side varied among subjects.

Alternative perceptual states 'apparent motion' and 'perceived simultaneity' lead to differences of induced EEG rhythms

An investigation of the cortical response (EEG) to periodically presented stimuli producing an ambiguity between long-range apparent motion and flicker is reported. ERPs to stimulus onsets differed slightly between the two percepts, in accordance with the results of Manning et al. (1988), Selmes et al. (1997). Induced rhythms exhibited a strong increase in induced beta and gamma powers at electrode positions T7 and T8 during the perception of apparent motion in two out of 10 participants. In addition, a small overall increase in alpha power at 12-13 Hz and a decrease in delta power below 3.5 Hz during perceived motion were found. The results indicate that a variety of different neural rhythms are involved in the perception of long-range apparent motion.

The development of hemispheric asymmetry in human motion VEPs

In six healthy adults we examined the sources underlying P1 and N2 of the motion VEP. For this purpose was acquired, in addition to the VEP, MRI images and patterns of regional cerebral blood flow with SPECT for three of the subjects. With the same motion stimulus we also examined the spatial distribution of N2 in children. In both adults and children left and right half-field responses were compared. It was found that N2 is generated by extrastriate activity and that motion stimuli are not equivalently processed in the two cerebral hemispheres. In adults, N2 dominates in one hemisphere irrespective of the visual half-field used for stimulation whereas children show an ipsilateral maximum for N2 upon half-field presentation.

Human brain potentials observed using the line-motion method: the neurophysiological correlates of visual illusory motion perception

This study shows the temporal dynamics of neurophysiological activities in illusory motion perception. Event-related brain potentials were recorded from 12 healthy subjects while they performed a two-alternative (motion/no motion), forced-choice task using the line motion method. Amplitudes of a late positive component at Fz, Cz, Pz, O1 and O2 increased as cue lead time (CLT) increased. At a CLT of 50 ms, the amplitudes of the late positive component (the peak latency at O1, O2: 310 ms; Fz, Cz, Pz: 360-390 ms) observed during illusory motion perception was larger than that observed during no motion perception, even though the physical stimuli were the same. These results suggest that the perception of illusory motion correlates to a relatively late stage of visual information processing.

Time-till-breakdown and scalp electrical potential maps of long-range apparent motion

A series of psychophysical and electrophysiological experiments is reported using the apparent motion (AM) breakdown effect. Breakdown describes an effect in AM in which, during continuous viewing, the percept of smooth of a single stimulus alternates with the percept of two discrete alternating stimuli. Visual evoked potentials (VEPs) were recorded during periods of motion or breakdown ("nonmotion") in horizontal and vertical displays. VEPs were compared with synthetic VEPs ("composite-flash") produced by adding VEPs to each element of the display recorded in isolation. Subtraction of VEPs was used in an attempt to compare the electrical responses with the processing of information relating to the form of the stimulus, subthreshold motion processing, and suprathreshold motion processing. The results, presented as scalp electrical potential distribution maps, were interpreted as consistent with a central adaptation process underlying the breakdown effect. The results also indicated that the hemispheric asymmetries in AM VEPs described by Manning, Finlay, and Fenelon (1988) were most likely due to the position of the stimuli in the visual field, rather than as a lateralization of motion processes per se. The results also provided evidence that the subthreshold and suprathreshold motion responses to the display were the product of different populations of motion units.

Human cortical area responding to stimuli in apparent motion

Apparent motion is the perception of the realistic smooth motion of an object which flashes first at one place then at another. To investigate human cortical responses to stimuli in apparent motion, we used a multichannel biomagnetometer to record the magnetic fields evoked by these stimuli in four normal subjects. The results showed the presence of a localized cortical area exclusively sensitive to apparent motion stimuli that is identical to that for smooth motion. In three subjects this area corresponded to the human homologue of MT/V5. Moreover, the same region in the extrastriate cortex was involved in the short range (0.1 degree) apparent motion process as well as the long range (1.0 degree) process.

Parvocellular and magnocellular contributions to visual evoked potentials in humans: stimulation with chromatic and achromatic gratings and apparent motion

Psychophysical evidence suggests that two major parallel pathways, the parvocellular (P) and the magnocellular (M) pathways, exist in humans. We herein report that responses specific to the P and M systems can be recorded in human visual evoked potentials (VEPs) by using the appropriate stimuli. The onset of isoluminant chromatic (red-green) and high contrast achromatic sinusoidal gratings were used for stimulating the P-system. A chromatic stimulation evoked a characteristic negative wave (N1) with peak latencies around 120 msec. The amplitude showed an inverse U-shaped function as a function of spatial frequency with a peak at 2 c/deg. In contrast, VEPs to achromatic (black-white) gratings showed different spatial frequency characteristics with a peak at 5.3 c/deg. By varying the luminous intensity ratio between the red and green gratings, N1 was found to reach a maximum during isoluminant stimulation. An apparent motion display was used for stimulating the M-system. The speed of alternation (i.e., the interstimulus interval (ISI)) was varied to record both the transient and steady-state VEPs. Transient VEPs showed triphasic waves with the major positive peak (P1) at around 120 ms. Steady-state VEPs were quasi-sinusoidal waveforms, depending on the ISI, and were quite stable across all subjects. There was a also high correlation between the motion threshold and the VEP amplitude. The above observations indicate that characteristic potentials may distinguish between these two parallel visual systems in humans. Thus, the combined use of isoluminant color and high contrast achromatic gratings and an apparent motion display is considered to be useful for evaluating both systems electrophysiologically.

Isolation and characteristics of a steady-state visually-evoked potential in humans related to the motion of a stimulus

We have examined the visual potential evoked by two motion stimuli. In the first stimulus (termed coherent motion) a random-dot pattern oscillated between phases of coherent and incoherent ("snowstorm") motion, and in the second a random-dot pattern alternated in direction of motion (termed direction change). We found that the response to the coherent motion stimulus is low-pass with respect to speed, has low contrast sensitivity and increases steadily with the contrast of the stimuli. The direction change visually-evoked potential (VEP) is band-pass with respect to speed, has high contrast sensitivity but then saturates and even reduces as the stimulus contrast is raised above 0.1. The behaviour of the direction change VEP is similar in nature to results from psychophysical experiments of motion perception and to the known properties of directionally selective cells of the cortex. On the other hand the behaviour of the coherent motion VEP suggests this may not be mediated by a mechanism specific to motion.

Contrast dependence of motion-onset and pattern-reversal evoked potentials

This study deals with the effect of stimulus contrast, between 1.3% and 96%, on the visual evoked potentials (VEPs) for onset of motion and for pattern reversal of checkerboard stimuli. The VEPs for pattern reversal and for the onset of motion both contain an initial positive peak (P1; peak latency about 120 msec) followed by a later negative peak (N2; peak latency 160-200 msec). However the P1 peak dominates the pattern-reversal VEP when recorded from the midline occipital lead, where it is maximal, while the N2 peak is larger in the motion-onset VEP, especially when recorded from unipolar lateral occipital leads. Whereas the amplitude of the P1 peak in both the pattern-reversal VEP and the motion-onset VEP decreases with decreasing contrast (becoming undetectable at a contrast of about 2% for the motion-onset VEP), the amplitude of the N2 peak in both types of VEP does not vary significantly with contrast, above a contrast of 1.3%. The increase in peak latency with decreasing contrast is also more pronounced for the positive than the negative peaks of both types of VEP. Taking into account the high contrast sensitivity of the magnocellular system (thought to be involved in the processing of motion) compared with the parvocellular system (probably more concerned with the processing of form), our findings suggest that for both motion-onset and pattern-reversal VEPs the negative peak is attributable to the motion-processing magnocellular pathway and the positive peak to the form-processing parvocellular system.

Lateral motion bias associated with reading direction

We found that when Americans view ambiguous lateral long-range apparent motion, they exhibit a robust bias to experience leftward movement. In successive experiments, right-handers and left-handers, and left-side drivers from Japan equally manifested this leftward bias. However, bilingual viewers whose first language reads from right to left exhibited no lateral bias. Furthermore, the bilingual sample produced a significant correlation between exposure to English and extent of leftward motion bias. The findings provide strong evidence that reading habits can influence directionality in motion perception.

Event-related potentials to irrelevant deviant motion of visual shapes

Event-related potentials to visual shapes moving across the visual field were recorded from 10 subjects. The subjects had to respond to the appearance of one of the shapes, while other shapes were irrelevant. On the periphery some of the shapes changed their orientation or their form. Sometimes the direction of movement was different from the standard direction. Subjects did not detect the changes of the pattern on the visual periphery, and the ERPs to these non-detected deviants were identical to the ERPs to the standard stimuli. Six subjects detected the irrelevant direction of movement. In these subjects the deviant direction of motion elicited a fronto-central positive wave (P3s) with 322 ms mean latency. There was no such sharp positive peak in the four subjects who did not detect the deviant direction of movement. Unlike the non-target stimuli, the targets elicited a large positive wave (P3b) with 530 ms mean latency.

Time-till-breakdown and VEP measures of short-range apparent motion

Varying short-range apparent motion (AM) stimulus displacements from 2.7 to 21.6 min it was found that VEP amplitudes varied as a function of the limits for short-range AM described using time-till-breakdown as a behavioural measure of AM strength. This VEP amplitude difference was, however, in the reverse direction to that predicted as the "motion" condition elicited lower VEP amplitude responses than the "non-motion" conditions (which did not significantly differ from each other). This direction of VEP amplitude difference was supported by an intensive study of a single subject. The "breakdown effect" enabled VEPs to be gathered during periods in which the subjective experience was of either coherent lateral motion, or breakdown (incoherent motion) without changing any stimulus parameter. The VEP component identified in expt 2, as predicted, was of lower amplitude during motion with respect to periods of breakdown. The results of these experiments are discussed in terms of describing motion and breakdown in short-range AM displays as "coherent" and "incoherent" motion, rather than as "motion" and "non-motion".

Properties of visual evoked potentials to onset of movement on a television screen

In 80 subjects the dependence of movement-onset visual evoked potentials on some measures of stimulation was examined, and these responses were compared with pattern-reversal visual evoked potentials to verify the effectiveness of pattern movement application for visual evoked potential acquisition. Horizontally moving vertical gratings were generated on a television screen. The typical movement-onset reactions were characterized by one marked negative peak only, with a peak time between 140 and 200 ms. In all subjects the sufficient stimulus duration for acquisition of movement-onset-related visual evoked potentials was 100 ms; in some cases it was only 20 ms. Higher velocity (5.6 degree/s) produced higher amplitudes of movement-onset visual evoked potentials than did the lower velocity (2.8 degrees/s). In 80% of subjects, the more distinct reactions were found in the leads from lateral occipital areas (in 60% from the right hemisphere), with no correlation to handedness of subjects. Unlike pattern-reversal visual evoked potentials, the movement-onset responses tended to be larger to extramacular stimulation (annular target of 5 degrees-9 degrees) than to macular stimulation (circular target of 5 degrees diameter).

Handedness and hemispheric asymmetry of pattern reversal visual-evoked potentials

Pattern reversal visual-evoked potentials (EP) from temporal leads in the two hemispheres of 26 right-handed (14 right-eye-dominant and 12 left-eye-dominant) and 10 left-handed (left-eye-dominant) adults were recorded. Checkerboard patterns (check sizes: 5.7 and 17 min of arc) at 1 and 8 Hz were reversed. Stimuli (a) subtended 6 degrees of visual field, (b) subtended 1 degree of visual field (foveal condition), and (c) were restricted to the annular portion of the visual field around the fovea (peripheral condition). Larger EP amplitudes in right or left hemisphere in relation to handedness, temporal frequency, and visual field condition were recorded. Eye dominance of dextrals appeared to play a role in determining the hemispheric asymmetry. Previous literature data and present results in relation to the hypothesis of different hemispheric specialization for basic visual information are discussed.

Contrast and hemispheric asymmetry: an electrophysiological investigation

Visual evoked potentials by 8 Hz phase-reversed sinusoidal gratings of different spatial frequency were recorded from occipital and temporal leads of left and right hemispheres. Seven adult subjects were investigated. At low contrast, the VEP amplitudes in the two hemispheres were symmetrical. At medium and high contrast, the amplitudes were larger in one hemisphere. On the contrary, the "phase advance" as a function of contrast was comparable in the two hemispheres. The results were discussed according to the literature on different neural population involved in contrast perception.

Motion components of VEPs to the waggon wheel effect

Visual evoked potentials (VEPs) from eight subjects are presented from scalp sites O1, O2, T5, T6, P3 and P4. A spoked wheel was illuminated by a constantly flashing strobe. By adjusting the real angular speed of the wheel the subjective impression was given of; a stationary wheel, a wheel spinning slowly or spinning rapidly clockwise. Two visually identified components, a negativity and a positivity, were found to be of larger amplitude in response to motion. The results were interpreted as consistent with a model of AM proposing motion information to be processed within the visual system.

Left-right visual field asymmetry in bistable motion perception

Twelve observers viewed two alternating frames, each consisting of three rectangular bars which were displaced laterally by one cycle in one frame with respect to the other. At long interframe intervals (IFIs) observers perceived a group of three elements moving as a whole (group movement), whereas with IFIs shorter than 40-60 ms the overlapping elements in each frame appeared stationary while the third element appeared to move from one end of the display to the other (end-to-end movement). The percentage of group movement responses in central viewing was compared to those obtained for stimulus presentation in the left and right visual fields (4 deg eccentricity), for opposite horizontal directions of motion. All ten right-handed subjects showed a left-field advantage in sensitivity to group movement. The two left-handed subjects showed a similar advantage in sensitivity with right-field presentation. The effects of monocular vision, hand used in the task, spatial frequency, and contrast on visual field asymmetry were all investigated in two right-handed subjects. None of these factors affected the left-right asymmetry.

Individual differences in responses of untrained observers to stroboscopic apparent motion

Two large groups of inexperienced subjects (n = 208 and n = 50) and a small group of experienced subjects (n = 5) were tested using time-till-breakdown as a measure of long-range apparent motion across a range of temporal frequencies. One group of inexperienced subjects was retested after one week and demonstrated quite stable patterns of response. Large intersubject variability was observed in terms of the amount of motion seen, with most inexperienced subjects reporting very little apparent motion. A raster display produced a peak frequency 1 Hz higher than a standard tachistoscope display. The role of experience was also examined with a small group of inexperienced subjects (n = 8) tested once daily over five consecutive days. There was high intersubject variability and intrasubject consistency, demonstrating little influence of learning and experience. The results are discussed in terms of current ideas on the breakdown effect.