Does mitochondrial ATP synthesis decline as a function of change in the membrane environment with ageing

Mitochondrial decay in the aging rat heart: evidence for improvement by dietary supplementation with acetyl-L-carnitine and/or lipoic acid

Mitochondrial decay has been postulated to be a significant underlying part of the aging process. Decline in mitochondrial function may lead to cellular energy deficits, especially in times of greater energy demand, and compromise vital ATP-dependent cellular operations, including detoxification, repair systems, DNA replication, and osmotic balance. Mitochondrial decay may also lead to enhanced oxidant production and thus render the cell more prone to oxidative insult. In particular, the heart may be especially susceptible to mitochondrial dysfunction due to myocardial dependency on beta-oxidation of fatty acids for energy and the postmitotic nature of cardiac myocytes, which would allow for greater accumulation of mitochondrial mutations and deletions. Thus, maintenance of mitochondrial function may be important to maintain overall myocardial function. Herein, we review the major age-related changes that occur to mitochondria in the aging heart and the evidence that two such supplements, acetyl-l-carnitine (ALCAR) and (R)-alpha-lipoic acid, may improve myocardial bioenergetics and lower the increased oxidative stress associated with aging. We and others have shown that feeding old rats ALCAR reverses the age-related decline in carnitine levels and improves mitochondrial beta-oxidation in a number of tissues studied. However, ALCAR supplementation does not appear to reverse the age-related decline in cardiac antioxidant status and thus may not substantially alter indices of oxidative stress. Lipoic acid, a potent thiol antioxidant and mitochondrial metabolite, appears to increase low molecular weight antioxidant status and thereby decreases age-associated oxidative insult. Thus, ALCAR along with lipoic acid may be effective supplemental regimens to maintain myocardial function.

Insulin exposure and unifying aging

BACKGROUND

Absence of a widely agreed upon central paradigm for mammalian aging.

OBJECTIVE

Detailed elaboration of a proposed mammalian aging paradigm.

METHODS

Elaboration of a new theoretical model.

RESULTS

Hormonal imbalance-growth factor exposure theory (HI-GFE theory) can account for two major aging phenomena: (1) decline in mammalian 'reserve capacity' and consequent rise of diseases of maintenance, and (2) rise then peaking of most age-associated proliferative diseases. Reserve capacity decline via gradual decline in mitochondrial maximal energy production (state 3) accounts for the gradual redirection of declined maximal energy production toward survival functions like ion pumping to the relative detriment of RNA and protein synthesis as seen in lesser synthetic rates and slower turnover with consequent gradual cellular impairment. Developmental program triggered, and over-ample nutritionally driven, growth factor exposure in youth to middle age encourages promotional events that lead to proliferative diseases that rise coincident to rapidly declining reserve capacity and cumulative increased mutational status of age.

CONCLUSIONS

Declining mitochondrial state 3 aging energy production status is easily and safely reversible with probable consequences of greatly postponing the decline in overall 'reserve capacity' which may also improve insulin: growth hormone balance and result in lower overall growth factor exposure and consequent longer healthy life of a potentially greater magnitude increase in life spans than that seen in calorie-restricted animals.

Carnitine palmitoyl transferase-I activity in the aging mouse heart

We investigated the influence of age on carnitine palmitoyl transferase-I (CPT-I, EC 2.3.1.21) activity in the mouse heart. There was an age-associated decrease in CPT-I activity from 2 to 26 months (P = 0.006). We studied the effect of oxygen-derived radicals on CPT-I activity. Mitochondria from 2-month-old mouse hearts exposed to different concentrations of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) showed a dose-related decrease in CPT-I activity (P < 0.002). To determine the possible reversibility of the age change in CPT-I activity, we studied the effect of oral administration of propionyl-L-carnitine (PLC). Oral pretreatment of middle-aged (18-month-old) mice with PLC resulted in a 37% increase of basal CPT-I activity (P < 0.05) compared to age-matched untreated animals, and restored it to a level similar to that of 2-month-old mice. Pretreatment of senescent (26-month-old) mice with PLC, however, showed no significant change in basal CPT-I activity. It is possible that the age-related decrease in CPT-I activity may result from an in vivo accumulation of oxygen-derived radical damage. It appears that the age change in CPT-I activity in 18- but not in the 26-month-old mice is reversible with PLC.

Human epidermal cells progressively lose their cardiolipins during ageing without change in mitochondrial transmembrane potential

Mitochondria dysfunction is considered to be a major cause of the modifications that occur during cell ageing. For this reason, cardiolipin, a suitable marker of the chondriome, as well as the mitochondrial transmembrane potential were examined in keratinocytes obtained from 9- to 75-year-old women. The study was carried out by flow cytometry using two fluorescent mitochondria probes: nonyl acridine orange, which binds specifically to cardiolipin, and rhodamine 123, which is incorporated mainly in response to transmembrane potential. Cardiolipin levels in cells from elderly donors (75 years old) would be 57% lower (r = 0.540; P = 0.0002) than those in children (9 years old), while the inner transmembrane potential remained unchanged (r = 0.0394; P = 0.8017). The stability of the membrane potential may be explained by either or both of the following hypotheses: (i) the same pool of organelles able to maintain membrane potential is conserved even when cardiolipin levels decrease (ii) mitochondria membrane potential does indeed decrease with age but is compensated by glycolysis energy production. Finally, it may be stated that the fluorescent probes nonyl acridine orange and rhodamine 123 might be of interest in testing the phenotype of senescent cells and would be useful in screening the role of certain specific genes in cell ageing.

Cardiolipins and biomembrane function

Evidence is discussed for roles of cardiolipins in oxidative phosphorylation mechanisms that regulate State 4 respiration by returning ejected protons across and over bacterial and mitochondrial membrane phospholipids, and that regulate State 3 respiration through the relative contributions of proteins that transport protons, electrons and/or metabolites. The barrier properties of phospholipid bilayers support and regulate the slow proton leak that is the basis for State 4 respiration. Proton permeability is in the range 10(-3)-10(-4) cm s-1 in mitochondria and in protein-free membranes formed from extracted mitochondrial phospholipids or from stable synthetic phosphatidylcholines or phosphatidylethanolamines. The roles of cardiolipins in proton conductance in model phospholipid membrane systems need to be assessed in view of new findings by Hübner et al. [313]: saturated cardiolipins form bilayers whilst natural highly unsaturated cardiolipins form nonlamellar phases. Mitochondrial cardiolipins apparently participate in bilayers formed by phosphatidylcholines and phosphatidylethanolamines. It is not yet clear if cardiolipins themselves conduct protons back across the membrane according to their degree of fatty acyl saturation, and/or modulate proton conductance by phosphatidylcholines and phosphatidylethanolamines. Mitochondrial cardiolipins, especially those with high 18:2 acyl contents, strongly bind many carrier and enzyme proteins that are involved in oxidative phosphorylation, some of which contribute to regulation of State 3 respiration. The role of cardiolipins in biomembrane protein function has been examined by measuring retained phospholipids and phospholipid binding in purified proteins, and by reconstituting delipidated proteins. The reconstitution criterion for the significance of cardiolipin-protein interactions has been catalytical activity; proton-pumping and multiprotein interactions have yet to be correlated. Some proteins, e.g., cytochrome c oxidase are catalytically active when dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine replaces retained cardiolipins. Cardiolipin-protein interactions orient membrane proteins, matrix proteins, and on the outerface receptors, enzymes, and some leader peptides for import; activate enzymes or keep them inactive unless the inner membrane is disrupted; and modulate formation of nonbilayer HII-phases. The capacity of the proton-exchanging uncoupling protein to accelerate thermogenic respiration in brown adipose tissue mitochondria of cold-adapted animals is not apparently affected by the increased cardiolipin unsaturation; this protein seems to take over the protonophoric role of cardiolipins in other mitochondria. Many in vivo influences that affect proton leakage and carrier rates selectively alter cardiolipins in amount per mitochondrial phospholipids, in fatty acyl composition and perhaps in sidedness; other mitochondrial membrane phospholipids respond less or not at all.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

A comparative study of succinate-supported respiration and ATP/ADP translocation in liver mitochondria from adult and old rats

This study was undertaken to compare the rates of succinate-supported hepatic mitochondrial respiration between 12 months (adult) and 29 months (old) male Fischer 344 rats. Experiments were also performed to determine the activity of adenine nucleotide translocase and the effect of its inhibition on mitochondrial respiration. Succinate-supported state 3 mitochondrial respiration was found to decline 20% between 12 and 29 months of age in rat liver, along with a similar 25% decrease in the respiratory control ratio with age. Adenine nucleotide translocase activity is shown to decrease 39% from adult to old rat liver mitochondria. This decrease does not, however, account for the decline in state 3 respiration, since translocase activity is approximately 50% greater than state 3 respiration in both adult and old rats. Therefore, adenine nucleotide translocase is not rate-limiting for state 3 mitochondrial respiration. Neither the rate of succinate permeation into the mitochondrial nor the rate of electron transport is rate-limiting for state 3 respiration, indicated by the greatly increased oxygen consumption with addition of the uncoupler carbonyl cyanide m-chlorophenyl hydrazone (m-CCCP). These processes, therefore, are not responsible for the observed decline in state 3 respiration. The implications and possible cause of the age-related decrease in the maximal rate of ATP-synthesis are discussed.

Oxidative phosphorylation in mouse liver mitochondria during weaning

Oxidative energy metabolism in mouse liver mitochondria was examined during weaning using different substrates. During the post-natal development, from suckling to weanling stage, the respiration rates showed a temporary decrease. These altered levels recovered in the adults. Respiration rates with the three substrates studied namely, glutamate, beta-hydroxybutyrate and succinate showed the same pattern. However, the levels of primary dehydrogenase as well as that of basal adenosine triphosphatase were not significantly altered during weaning. The content of cytochromes aa3 and b significantly decreased during this period. The results indicate that cytochrome aa3 may be of primary importance in the restoration of full respiratory function in mitochondria after the weaning period.

Respiratory activity of isolated rat liver mitochondria following in vitro exposure to oxygen species: a threshold study

Respiratory activity of isolated rat liver mitochondria was assayed following in vitro exposure to oxygen radicals. Our results show that mitochondrial respiration is more sensitive to O2.(-) than to H2O2. However, ferrous ions drastically enhance the toxicity of the enzymatic system generating H2O2 because of the production of the hydroxyl radicals. A protection against those oxygen species could be given by SOD in the xanthine/xanthine oxidase system and by catalase with the glucose/glucose oxidase system. The most damaging system was the combination of Fe2+ with H2O2. In this case, OH. is formed in a Fenton-like reaction. The fact that the OH. is the most damaging molecule accounts for the finding that catalase and desferrioxamine were efficient protectors in this system. Threshold levels of O2.(-) and H2O2 able to inhibit the mitochondrial respiration have been estimated. It is concluded that under normal respiration such thresholds are not reached in vivo and that the impairment of the mitochondrial respiratory activity does not seem to originate only from the natural free radical production in those organelles. However, if the production of free radicals is such to exceed the defense capability, like under oxidative stress, then the critical threshold can be surpassed and the respiration impaired leading to irreversible damages.

Age-related changes in respiration coupled to phosphorylation. I. Hepatic mitochondria

Age-related changes affecting mitochondrial adenine nucleotide metabolism may underlie age-related decreases in hepatic metabolic activities. Oxidative activity coupled with phosphorylation, the apparent Km and Vmax of the adenine nucleotide translocase (AdNT), the adenine nucleotide pool size and membrane lipid composition were determined for hepatic mitochondria from young (3 months), mature (12 months) and aged (24 months) Fischer 344 male rats which had been fed NIH-31 diet. The age-related decreases in state 3 respiration supported by NAD-linked substrates were 2-4-fold greater than that of an FAD-linked substrate. The 32% (P less than 0.05) decrease in the AdNT Vmax calculated for the aged rats was accompanied by a 17% decrease in the AdNT Km. The exchangeable pool of adenine nucleotides in mitochondria from aged rats was 72% (P less than 0.05) that in the young rats. While the age-related increase in the cholesterol/phospholipid-Pi ratio and changes in the phospholipid head group pattern were not significant, the overall change in the fatty acid pattern effected a 20% (P less than 0.05) decrease in the n-6/n-3 fatty acid ratio. These data suggest that the reduced Vmax of the AdNT is a consequence of a diminished pool of exchangeable adenine nucleotides. The lower AdNT velocity may reflect the effect of changes in the lipid environment of the membrane in which it is embedded. The major shifts in these parameters occurred during the second year of life.

Lack of age-dependent changes in rat heart mitochondria

The effects of aging on the composition and function of cardiac mitochondria from rats exhibiting significant decreases in synaptic brain mitochondria composition and function have been studied. Cytochrome content and cytochrome absorbance wavelength maxima do not change in heart mitochondria. Respiratory activities, respiratory control ratios, ADP/O ratios, and H+/O ratios do not change with increasing age. Unlike in brain synaptic tissue, energy output of the heart does not decrease with age.

Restriction enzyme analysis of mitochondrial DNA in aging human cells

Human diploid fibroblasts show a limited lifespan in vitro. To investigate the integrity of mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) in aging fibroblasts, whole cell DNA samples from the human cell line IMR-90 have been prepared at 36, 22, and 3 population doublings (PD) from the end of the lifespan (63 PD). These DNA samples were then digested separately with 19 different restriction endonucleases, and the resulting fragments were separated by agarose gel electrophoresis and transferred to nitrocellulose filters. Fragment sizes were revealed by hybridization to 32P-labelled mouse mtDNA and autoradiography, and were compared with computer maps of fragments generated from the known sequence of human mtDNA. These 19 enzymes recognize a total of 297 recognition sites comprising 1315 nucleotide base pairs (bp), approximately 8% of the human mtDNA (16 569 bp). Control experiments reveal that a minor component representing as little as 5% of the total mtDNA can be detected. No changes were seen in the restriction fragment pattern with fibroblast cell age. It is concluded that there are no large deletions, insertions, or rearrangements in human mtDNA, and no single base changes in the detectable regions. This suggests efficient maintenance of mtDNA molecules and/or elimination of damaged mtDNA during fibroblast cell lifespan.