Hypotonic fragility of outer membrane and activation of external pathway of NADH oxidation in rat liver mitochondria are increased with age

Apparent "mild depolarization of the inner mitochondrial membrane" as a result of a possible generation of the outer membrane potential

Recently reported kinase-linked mild depolarization of mitochondria, which prevents the generation of the reactive oxygen species (ROS) and disappears in various organs of the old mice, has been assumed to represent a crucial component of the mitochondrial anti-aging program. To measure mitochondrial inner membrane potential (IMP), the authors used fluorescent probe safranin O⁺. It is widely accepted that the accumulation of such cationic probes in the mitochondrial matrix depends exclusively on IMP, thus completely ignoring the possibility of the outer membrane potential (OMP) generation. However, computational analysis performed in the presented work suggests that the kinase-linked generation of the positive OMP might take place under the described conditions, because the measured potential includes the algebraic sum of both IMP and OMP. Alternatively to the suggested mild depolarization of mitochondria, the reported experimental data might reflect mainly a change of the positive OMP generated by the VDAC-kinase complexes. We also demonstrate that the reported in the literature mitochondrial hyperpolarization induced by erastin (known to prevent VDAC-tubulin interactions) and the depolarization caused by the mitochondrial VDAC knockdowns in the cancer cells might actually represent a decrease or increase, respectively, of the magnitude of the kinase-linked positive OMP. This is consistent with our hypothesis that VDAC voltage gating by the kinase-linked metabolically-dependent OMP plays a very important physiological role in regulating the cell energy metabolism under normal and pathological conditions, in the maintenance of the cell death resistance and even in the genetic aging program.

Redox state-dependent aggregation of mitochondria induced by cytochrome c

Cytochrome c is known to play central role in apoptosis. Here, it is shown that ferricytochrome c, but not ferrocytochrome c is able to directly induce the aggregation of rat liver mitochondria, similar to the effect caused by magnesium ions at high concentrations. The aggregation was revealed by a decrease in light dispersion of mitochondrial suspension and it was confirmed by the optical microscopy. In the medium containing NADH and cytochrome c, mitochondrial aggregation was initiated only after exhaustion of NADH leading to oxidation of cytochrome c. The aggregation induced by 30 μM ferricytochrome c, but not by 5 mM MgCl(2), was completely inhibited by 30-100 μM ferricyanide, thus indicating that ferricyanide-cytochrome c specific interaction prevents mitochondrial aggregation. After completion of the aggregation caused by ferricytochrome c, this effect cannot be readily reversed by subsequent reduction of cytochrome c. The aggregation induced by ferricytochrome c and/or magnesium ions explains masking of the external NADH-oxidase activity of mitochondria in vitro reported in the literature. This new cytochrome c redox state-dependent phenomenon might also be involved in more complex mechanisms controlling aggregation (clustering) of mitochondria in vivo under the influence of pro-apoptotic factors and requires further study.

Dextran causes aggregation of mitochondria and influences their oxidoreductase activities and light scattering

It has been reported that dextrans diminish the intermembrane space of mitochondria, increase the number of contact sites between the inner and the outer mitochondrial membranes, decrease the outer membrane permeability to adenosine 5(')-diphosphate, and change the kinetic properties of mitochondrial kinases. In the present work the influence of dextran M40 (5% w/v) on the oxidoreductase activities of the inner and outer membranes of mitochondria, the interaction of cytochrome c with mitochondrial membranes, and the light scattering by rat liver mitochondria were studied. No influence of dextran on the release of cytochrome c from mitochondria or its interaction with mitochondrial membranes was observed. Decreases in the NADH-oxidase (to 80+/-2% of the control), NADH-cytochrome c reductase (to 26+/-2%), succinate-cytochrome c reductase (to 70+/-5%), and NADH-ferricyanide reductase (to 75+/-3%) activities induced by dextran, which may be due to the mitochondrial aggregation, were observed. The formation of aggregates was registered by light scattering, confirmed by light microscopy, and explained within the framework of the Gouy-Chapman theory of the electrical double layer. The observed mitochondrial aggregation seems to be useful also for understanding the mechanisms of mitochondrial condensation and perinuclear clustering during apoptosis.

Cytochrome c sorption-desorption effects on the external NADH oxidation by mitochondria: experimental and computational study

The rupture of the outer mitochondrial membrane is known to be critical for cell death, but the mechanism, specifically its redox-signaling aspects, still needs to be studied in more detail. In this work, the external NADH oxidation by rat liver mitochondria was studied under the outer membrane rupture induced by the mitochondria hypotonic treatment or the inner membrane permeability transition. The saturation of the oxidation rate was observed as a function of mitochondrial protein concentration. This effect was shown to result from cytochrome c binding to the mitochondrial membranes. At a relatively high concentration of mitochondria, the oxidation rate was strongly activated by 4 mm Mg(2+) due to cytochrome c desorption from the membranes. A minimal kinetic model was developed to explain the main phenomena of the external NADH oxidation modulated by cytochrome c and Mg(2+) in mitochondria with the ruptured outer membrane. The computational behavior of the model closely agreed with the experimental data. We suggest that the redox state of the released cytochrome c, considered by other authors to be important for apoptosis, may strongly depend on its oxidation by the fraction of mitochondria with the ruptured outer membrane and on the cytoplasmic cytochrome c reductase activity.

Failure of exogenous NADH and cytochrome c to support energy-dependent swelling of mitochondria

The possibility of direct oxidation of external NADH in rat liver mitochondria and of the inner membrane potential generation in this process is still not clear. In the present work, the energy-dependent swelling of mitochondria in the medium containing valinomycin and potassium acetate was measured as one of the main criteria of the proton-motive force generation by complex III, complex IV, and both complexes III and IV of the respiratory chain. Mitochondria swelling induced by external NADH oxidation was compared with that induced by succinate or ferrocyanide oxidation, or by electron transport from succinate to ferricyanide. Mitochondria swelling, nearly equal to that promoted by ferrocyanide oxidation, was observed under external NADH oxidation, but only after the outer mitochondrial membrane was ruptured as a result of the swelling-contraction cycle, caused by succinate oxidation and its subsequent inhibition. In this case, significantly accelerated intermembrane electron transport and well-detected inner membrane potential generation, in addition to mitochondria swelling, were also observed. Presented results suggest that exogenous NADH and cytochrome c do not support the inner membrane potential generation in intact rat liver mitochondria, because the external NADH-cytochrome c reductase system, oriented in the outer mitochondrial membrane toward the cytoplasm, is inaccessible for endogenous cytochrome c reduction; as well, the inner membrane cytochrome c oxidase is inaccessible for exogenous cytochrome c oxidation.

Cytochrome c release occurs via Ca2+-dependent and Ca2+-independent mechanisms that are regulated by Bax

Release of cytochrome c from mitochondria is a key initiative step in the apoptotic process, although the mechanisms regulating this event remain elusive. In the present study, using isolated liver mitochondria, we demonstrate that cytochrome c release occurs via distinct mechanisms that are either Ca(2+)-dependent or Ca(2+)-independent. An increase in mitochondrial matrix Ca(2+) promotes the opening of the permeability transition (PT) pore and the release of cytochrome c, an effect that is significantly enhanced when these organelles are incubated in a reaction buffer that is based on a physiologically relevant concentration of K(+) (150 mm KCl) versus a buffer composed of mannitol/sucrose/Hepes. Moreover, low concentrations of Ca(2+) are sufficient to induce mitochondrial cytochrome c release without measurable manifestations of PT, though inhibitors of PT effectively prevent this release, indicating that the critical threshold for PT varies among mitochondria within a single population of these organelles. In contrast, Ca(2+)-independent cytochrome c release is induced by oligomeric Bax protein and occurs without mitochondrial swelling or the release of matrix proteins, although our data also indicate that Bax enhances permeability transition-induced cytochrome c release. Taken together, our results suggest that the intramitochondrial Ca(2+) concentration, as well as the reaction buffer composition, are key factors in determining the mode and amount of cytochrome c release. Finally, oligomeric Bax appears to be capable of stimulating cytochrome c release via both Ca(2+)-dependent and Ca(2+)-independent mechanisms.

Metabolically derived potential on the outer membrane of mitochondria: a computational model

The outer mitochondrial membrane (OMM) is permeable to various small substances because of the presence of a voltage-dependent anion channel (VDAC). The voltage dependence of VDAC's permeability is puzzling, because the existence of membrane potential on the OMM has never been shown. We propose that steady-state metabolically derived potential (MDP) may be generated on the OMM as the result of the difference in its permeability restriction for various charged metabolites. To demonstrate the possibility of MDP generation, two models were considered: a liposomal model and a simplified cell model with a creatine kinase energy channeling system. Quantitative computational analysis of the simplified cell model shows that a MDP of up to -5 mV, in addition to the Donnan potential, may be generated at high workloads, even if the OMM is highly permeable to small inorganic ions, including potassium. Calculations show that MDP and DeltapH, generated on the OMM, depend on the cytoplasmic pH and energy demand rate. Computational modeling suggests that MDP may be important for cell energy metabolism regulation in multiple ways, including VDAC's permeability modulation and the effect of electrodynamic compartmentation. The osmotic pressure difference between the mitochondrial intermembrane space and the cytoplasm, as related to the electrodynamic compartmentation effects, might explain the morphological changes in mitochondria under intense workloads.

Mg(2+) induces intermembrane electron transport by cytochrome c desorption in mitochondria with the ruptured outer membrane

The mechanism of external NADH oxidation in rat liver mitochondria is not clear yet, but it evidently includes the intermembrane electron transport (IMET). We showed that Mg(2+) significantly stimulated IMET insensitive to rotenone-antimycin A-myxothiazol in mitochondria with the hypotonically damaged outer membrane, even in the absence of exogenous cytochrome c. This effect was more specific than simply ionic strength increase. Direct evidence for cytochrome c desorption from mitochondrial membranes under 4 mM Mg(2+) influence was obtained to explain the stimulatory effect of Mg(2+) on external NADH oxidation that was coupled to the inner membrane potential generation. Obtained data suggest that cytochrome b(5) is normally oriented towards the cytosol in the outer membrane, and can be accessible for endogenous cytochrome c reduction only through the outer membrane rupture or permeabilization, to activate external NADH oxidation.

Membrane potential generation coupled to oxidation of external NADH in liver mitochondria

Oxidation of added NADH by rat liver mitochondria has been studied. It is found that exogenous NADH, when oxidized by rat liver mitochondria in sucrose hypotonic medium supplemented with Mg2+ and EGTA, generates a membrane potential (delta psi) even in the absence of added cytochrome c. ADP and phosphate decrease delta psi, the effect being reversed by oligomycin. Rotenone and myxothiazol do not inhibit delta psi generated by oxidation of exogenous NADH. Added cytochrome c increases the rate of the exogenous NADH oxidation and coupled delta psi formation. In sucrose isotonic medium, or in hypotonic medium without Mg2+, exogenous NADH fails to stimulate respiration and to form a membrane potential. In the presence of Mg2+, exogenous NADH appears to be effective in delta psi generation in isotonic sucrose medium if mitochondria were treated with digitonin. In isotonic KCl without Mg2+, oxidation of exogenous NADH is coupled to the delta psi formation and MgCl2 addition before mitochondria prevents this effect. In hypotonic (but not in isotonic) sucrose medium, Mg2+ makes a portion of the cytochrome c pool reducible by exogenous NADH or ascorbate. It is assumed that (i) hypotonic treatment or digitonin causes disruption of the outer mitochondrial membrane, and, as a consequence, desorption of the membrane-bound cytochrome c in a Mg2+-dependent fashion; (ii) incubation in isotonic KCI without Mg2+ results in swelling of mitochondrial matrix, disruption of the outer membrane and cytochrome c desorption whereas Mg2+ lowers the K+ permeability of the inner membrane and, hence, prevents swelling; (iii) desorbed cytochrome c is reduced by added NADH via NADH-cytochrome b5 reductase and cytochrome b5 or by ascorbate and is oxidized by cytochrome oxidase. The role of desorbed cytochrome c in oxidation of superoxide and cytoplasmic NADH as well as possible relations of these events to apoptosis are discussed.