Recurrent arthritis in Reiter's syndrome: a function of inapparent chlamydial infection of the synovium?

The role of Chlamydia and Chlamydophila infections in reactive arthritis

Chlamydia trachomatis and Chlamydophila pneumoniae are human pathogens; the former being the etiologic agent for trachoma as well as a prevalent sexually transmitted bacterium, while C. pneumoniae is a respiratory pathogen responsible for community-acquired pneumonia. Patients with reactive arthritis show evidence of present or past Chlamydial infection. Chlamydia spp., has been strongly implicated as a triggering factor for reactive arthritis. We describe the simultaneous occurrence of C. pneumoniae and C. trachomatis infections in a subject with reactive arthritis. We suggest treatment for a patient with Chlamydia-associated arthritis to define a means by which persistent organisms can be induced to return to the active developmental cycle, thereby making them more accessible to antibiotic activity.

Reactive arthritis which occurred one year after acute chlamydial urethritis

A 30-year-old Japanese man developed dactylitis with sausage-like fingers in addition to balanitis and stomatitis. One year prior to these symptoms, acute chlamydial urethritis had been successfully treated by levofloxacin. On admission, Chlamydia trachomatis DNA was not detected in the urine sediment by PCR method, however, he was diagnosed to have reactive arthritis based on the clinical findings of asymmetric dactylitis, circinate balanitis, stomatitis and positivity for HLA B27 antigen. He was treated with methotrexate and his arthritis improved. The past chlamydial infection may have been involved in the pathogenesis of reactive arthritis in this patient.

Chlamydial infection preceding the development of rheumatoid arthritis: a brief report

Chlamydia trachomatis-triggered reactive arthritis is a well-documented entity that has been extensively described. We do not have a clear understanding about the inflammatory oligoarthritis associated with the presence of this organism. It is rarely cultured from the synovial fluid, but is usually detectable by molecular biological techniques. Typically, Chlamydia trachomatis causes a sterile but inflammatory oligoarthritis. We report an unusual case of inflammatory monoarthritis in a young woman in whom Chlamydia was isolated from the synovial fluid. This is the first case of documented isolation of Chlamydia from synovial fluid, which subsequently was diagnosed as rheumatoid arthritis.

The occurrence of antibodies against chlamydia species in patients with monoarthritis and chronic closed lock of the temporomandibular joint

PURPOSE

The study goal was to investigate the occurrence of serum antibodies to Chlamydia trachomatis, Chlamydia pneumoniae, and Chlamydia psittaci in patients with temporomandibular joint (TMJ) monoarthritis or chronic closed lock and in control subjects.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

An indirect microimmunofluorescence test for detecting antibodies against C trachomatis was used. Twenty-three patients (12 with monoarthritis and 11 with chronic closed lock) and 42 control subjects were evaluated.

RESULTS

Six patients with monoarthritis, 5 patients with chronic closed lock of the TMJ, and 6 control individuals were considered to have had a past C trachomatis infection based on their immunoglobulin G titers. Corresponding groups for C pneumoniae investigation included 3 patients with monoarthritis, 4 patients with chronic closed lock, and 17 control subjects, and for C psittaci, 1 patient with monoarthritis, 2 patients with chronic closed lock, and 1 control subject. Statistically significant differences between patients and control subjects were found for C trachomatis only; monoarthritis versus control (P =.016), chronic closed lock versus control (P =.038), and all patients versus control (P =.007). Patients with monoarthritis did not differ from patients with chronic closed lock with regard to antibodies against C trachomatis.

CONCLUSION

The occurrence of serum antibodies to C trachomatis was significantly higher in patients than in control subjects, but this occurrence did not correlate with severity of observed tissue changes. Nevertheless, an association may exist between the presence of C trachomatis and TMJ disease.

In situ hybridisation and direct fluorescence antibodies for the detection of Chlamydia trachomatis in synovial tissue from patients with reactive arthritis

BACKGROUND

Chlamydia trachomatis is associated with Reiter's syndrome and reactive arthritis but the form in which the organism survives in synovial cells is unclear.

AIM

To compare in situ hybridisation with direct fluorescence in the detection of inapparent chlamydial infection in synovial tissue.

METHODS

Synovial tissue from four patients with reactive arthritis patients was examined using biotin labelled probes for chlamydial DNA and fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) labelled monoclonal antibodies against the major outer membrane protein.

RESULTS

In two of the four patients, evidence of chlamydial infections was detected by in situ hybridisation in parallel sections but not with FITC labelled monoclonal antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

Detection of chlamydial DNA by in situ DNA hybridisation may be a better way to identify chlamydial infection in synovial tissue than phenotype targeting with FITC conjugated antibodies, which is used as a standard procedure for screening clinical specimens for chlamydia.

The hand and the eye

A variety of systemic diseases may affect both the hand and eye, leading to profound sensory and functional deficits. The aetiology of some of the most common conditions is reviewed, with an explanation of their manifestations in the hand and eye. Recognition of the association between a hand condition and ocular pathology may aid in diagnosis of a systemic disorder or allow early detection and prevention of ocular disease and loss of vision.

Ultrastructural and molecular analyses of the persistence of Chlamydia trachomatis (serovar K) in human monocytes

Previous studies have suggested that monocytes may play a role in the dissemination of Chlamydia trachomatis, and in establishment of persistent infection with this bacterium. Infection of cultured human peripheral blood monocytes with C. trachomatis serovar K produced persistent, nonproductive infection. Transmission electron microscopy of such infected cultures revealed single or multiple Chlamydia in monocyte inclusions over a culture period of 10 days. Those inclusions were aberrant, and normal reticulate bodies within the inclusions were not observed. Immunoelectron microscopy showed the chlamydial major outer membrane protein and lipopolysaccharide to be associated with the bacterial plasma membrane. Lipopolysaccharide was also identified in the monocyte cytoplasm. Molecular analyses of primary chlamydial rRNA transcripts demonstrated that the organism is viable and metabolically active within monocyte inclusions. However, attempts to overcome chlamydial growth arrest by incubation of Chlamydia-infected monocytes with tryptophan, and antibodies against alpha interferon, gamma interferon, or tumor necrosis factor, were all ineffective, suggesting that known mechanisms of growth inhibition do not hold in human monocytes. These observations indicate that infection of human peripheral blood monocytes with C. trachomatis may be involved in the genesis/maintenance of extra-urogenital inflammation, since non-culturable, metabolically active bacteria persist in those cells.

Comparison of synovial tissue and synovial fluid as the source of nucleic acids for detection of Chlamydia trachomatis by polymerase chain reaction

OBJECTIVE

Difficulties in detecting Chlamydia trachomatis in human joints by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) may be related to whether synovial tissue or synovial fluid (SF) is used as the source of DNA in PCR amplification. In this study, a new PCR assay was developed and used to compare chlamydial DNA in paired samples of SF and synovial tissue from patients with arthritis.

METHODS

The PCR assay targeted the ribosomal RNA operons, which are present in 2 copies on the C trachomatis chromosome. DNA from several relevant bacteria and chlamydial serovars was used for testing this screening system. The detection of chlamydial DNA in nucleic acid preparations from matched samples of SF and synovial tissue was compared by PCR assay. Samples were obtained from 55 patients, including patients with reactive arthritis, Reiter's syndrome, and other arthropathies.

RESULTS

Testing of the PCR screening system confirmed it to be highly specific and sensitive. Use of this assay to screen DNA from SF and synovial tissue samples showed that 29 (53%) of 55 synovial tissue preparations were positive for chlamydial DNA, but only 16 (29%) of the matched SF samples from these 29 patients were similarly positive. Five (9%) of 55 SF samples, but not their tissue counterparts, were positive for chlamydial DNA by PCR.

CONCLUSION

Detection of chlamydial DNA in the joints of patients by PCR gives positive results more often when synovial tissue rather than SF is the source of target nucleic acids. Although synovial tissue is the source of choice for the most reliable determination of chlamydia in the joint, both synovial tissue and SF should be assayed if possible.

Case report: in situ hybridization for detection of inapparent infection with Chlamydia trachomatis in synovial tissue of a patient with Reiter's syndrome

The authors have shown that protein antigens, RNA, and DNA from Chlamydia trachomatis are present in synovial tissues of patients with Reiter's syndrome (RS). However, those studies gave no insight into the host cell type involved or the precise tissue location of the bacteria. To address such issues, the authors developed an in situ hybridization system to detect chlamydia, and they used that system to examine synovial biopsies from a patient with RS and a patient without RS. The in situ system uses a previously described digoxigenin-labeled DNA probe that hybridizes with chlamydial 16S rRNA sequences in paraformaldehyde-fixed samples. Control studies with chlamydia-infected and uninfected HeLa cells confirmed that the in situ system is as sensitive as is direct fluorescence cytology for detection of the organism. Morphology of host and chlamydia cells is preserved after hybridization. Studies using synovial tissue from an osteoarthritis patient produced no in situ hybridization signal, but similar hybridization to tissue from a culture-/direct fluorescence cytology- negative RS patient had a strong intracellular signal for chlamydia within a subsynovial cell layer. These in situ hybridization results confirm the extensive presence of chlamydia in synovia and extend the authors' earlier observation that chlamydia RNA is present in the synovia of patients with RS. The data also confirm their electron microscopy studies, indicating that chlamydia are intracellular in synovial tissue, and they further show that infected host cells are located beneath the synovial lining.

Alteration of Chlamydia trachomatis biologic behavior in synovial membranes. Suppression of surface antigen production in reactive arthritis and Reiter's syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the biologic state of Chlamydia and its surface antigen expression in the synovial membranes of patients with Chlamydia-associated reactive arthritis/Reiter's syndrome (ReA/RS).

METHODS

Expression of chlamydial lipopolysaccharide (LPS), major outer membrane protein (MOMP), and elementary body (EB) antigens was studied by gold labeling immunoelectron microscopy on 6 synovial membrane and 2 synovial fluid (SF) pellet samples from 6 patients with Chlamydia-associated arthritis. The study findings were compared with 24-hour cultures of HeLa cells infected with Chlamydia trachomatis EB.

RESULTS

Persistent C trachomatis infection was found in all 6 synovial membrane samples from patients who had either early or chronic arthritis. The infection persisted despite antibiotic treatment, including a 1-month course of doxycycline therapy. Most persistent organisms were atypical reticulate bodies (RBs) found in both fibroblasts and macrophages. Specific, but weak, immunogold staining for all 3 antibodies was found on both intracellular RBs and extracellular EBs. In the SF samples, Chlamydia surface antigens were detected only in phagosomes containing degraded electron-dense materials.

CONCLUSION

The synovial membrane biopsies conducted in this study of Chlamydia-associated ReA/RS revealed atypical RBs with diminished MOMP and LPS expression. Such altered organisms may escape immune surveillance and contribute to disease chronicity; moreover, these organisms may be difficult to detect and treat in some ReA/RS patients.

Reiter's syndrome and reactive arthritis: a current view

This paper reviews advances in the understanding of the pathogenesis of reactive arthritis that have occurred over the last decade. Inflammatory aseptic joint disease has been linked with prior infection initiated by many different species of microorganisms. The presence of intra-articular bacterial antigens has now been firmly established with the demonstration of bacteria, bacterial fragments, DNA, RNA, and bacterial lipopolysaccharide in joints of patients with reactive arthritis. Chlamydia trachomatis, Salmonella enteritidis, and Shigella flexneri have all been detected in the joint by immunological techniques, although there is still some doubt as to the form in which they reach the joint and whether or not they persist. A number of phlogistic bacterial components could be acting as arthritogens. Negative joint culture results from patients with reactive arthritis make it unlikely that bacteria in the joint are viable, although chlamydial DNA has been shown in the joints of patients with sexually acquired reactive arthritis using the polymerase chain reaction. The use of antimicrobial therapy in the treatment of reactive arthritis is under review; data suggests that long-term antibiotic treatment warrants further study. The role of HLA-B27 in disease pathogenesis is discussed as are possible mechanisms of interplay between germ and gene. HLA-B27 might confer disease susceptibility by affecting immune mechanisms other than classical antigen presentation. The immunopathogenesis of joint inflammation in reactive arthritis is explored with reference to studies of humoral and cellular immune responses. Serological evidence to support the concept of molecular mimicry is far from conclusive; the results of relevant studies are summarized. Lymphocyte proliferation experiments suggest that antigen presenting cells play an important role. Finally, our views on reactive arthritis in the 1990s, and areas of new and potentially fruitful future research are presented.

Intracellular location of inapparently infecting Chlamydia in synovial tissue from patients with Reiter's syndrome

Culture of Chlamydia trachomatis from synovial tissues/fluids from Reiter's syndrome (RS) patients frequently yields negative results. However, we have identified chlamydial RNA at that site in such patients, suggesting that viable organisms may be present. Here we define the cellular location of chlamydia within the synovium via in situ hybridization. Using a chlamydial ribosomal RNA-directed probe, we show that synovial tissue from culture-negative RS patients gives strong hybridization which is often localized to a subsynovial cell layer, rather than to the synovial lining; in some cases, hybridizing cells are dispersed through the synovium. All hybridization signal is located within host cells, indicating that infectious extracellular elementary bodies are rare or absent. These data confirm the extensive intracellular presence of inapparent chlamydia in the synovia of RS patients and provide some insight into the usual culture negativity of synovial tissues for the organism.

Are antibiotics of any use in reactive arthritis?

In the pathogenesis of reactive arthritis, infection through the mucosal route and genetic susceptibility (HLA-B27) are the most important contributing factors. With regard to non-specific urethritis, most probably caused by Chlamydia trachomatis infection, the use of early antimicrobial therapy has been shown to be effective in preventing arthritic recurrences. When the arthritis has been initiated, short-term conventional antimicrobial therapy seems unable to modify the course of the ongoing disease. In patients with acute reactive arthritis, a prolonged (3-month) treatment with tetracycline shortens the duration of arthritis when triggered by Chlamydia trachomatis, while such treatment has not proved effective in enteroarthritis. In patients with chronic reactive enteroarthritis, a prolonged course of quinolones, such as ciprofloxacin, might be of benefit. Sulfasalazine, which has an effect in the acute exacerbations of ankylosing spondylitis, is probably also effective in chronic reactive arthritis. An antimicrobial effect can be one of the mechanisms by which sulfasalazine exerts its therapeutic effect. Follow-up studies are necessary to assess the influence of antibiotic therapy on the late prognosis of patients with reactive arthritis.

Inapparent genital infection with Chlamydia trachomatis and its potential role in the genesis of Reiters syndrome

An infectious etiology has been suggested for Reiter's syndrome (RS) because the disease has often been observed to follow episodes of urethritis or dysentery. Despite demonstrations of bacterial antigens in the synovial tissues of RS patients, it is not clear whether viable organisms are present in the synovium in any particular stage of this disease. Furthermore, it is not clear how either viable organisms or their product(s) might reach the joints. Infection with the bacterium Chlamydia trachomatis is the most common sexually transmitted disease in the United States, and as such this organism has emerged as a primary pathogen associated with RS. Previous work from our group has shown that synovial biopsy tissues from a majority of RS patients studied show significant levels of apparently intact chlamydial RNA, even when synovial or urethral cultures from the same patients are unequivocally negative for the organism. We show here that inapparent urethral infection with chlamydia occurs with high prevalence in men, and that inapparent cervical infection with the organism occurs at high prevalence in women. These data provide an important link in the relationship between initial chlamydial infection and possible subsequent genesis of RS, and they may give useful insight into mechanisms by which chlamydial infection can lead to development of this disease. Our data argue further that inapparent infection may be a significant factor in pathogenesis for all chlamydia-related diseases, and they suggest that, contrary to current ideas, C. trachomatis can generate disseminated infection.

Inapparent ocular infection by Chlamydia trachomatis in experimental and human trachoma

There is substantial indirect evidence which suggests that Chlamydia trachomatis can generate inapparent, persistent infections in human. To confirm this directly, we examined ocular chlamydial infection in both the cynomolgus monkey model of trachoma and in patient samples from a trachoma-endemic area. In monkeys, ocular infection was studied over time using direct immunofluorescence cytology (DFA) and a molecular hybridization screening system which targets chlamydial ribosomal RNA. In eleven animals infected once with B serovar, DFA and probe screening of parallel conjunctival swabs gave congruent results through day 42 post-infection. Thereafter, DFA showed clearing of chlamydia and was negative by day 70, as in previous studies. In contrast, hybridization analysis indicated a continuing presence of chlamydial RNA in all samples from all animals through the end of the experiment at day 84 post-infection. Similarly, analysis of swabs from trachoma patients showed that a number of DFA-negative samples gave clear positive signal for chlamydial RNA. Taken together these data indicate that ocular chlamydial infection persists for longer periods than previously thought, judging solely on the basis of DFA, and they support the idea that inapparent ocular chlamydial infection occurs in vivo.