Amide proton exchange as a probe of protein folding pathways

Hydrogen-deuterium exchange in membrane proteins monitored by IR spectroscopy: a new tool to resolve protein structure and dynamics

As more and more high-resolution structures of proteins become available, the new challenge is the understanding of these small conformational changes that are responsible for protein activity. Specialized difference Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) techniques allow the recording of side-chain modifications or minute secondary structure changes. Yet, large domain movements remain usually unnoticed. FTIR spectroscopy provides a unique opportunity to record (1)H/(2)H exchange kinetics at the level of the amide proton. This approach is extremely sensitive to tertiary structure changes and yields quantitative data on domain/domain interactions. An experimental setup designed for attenuated total reflection and a specific approach for the analysis of the results is described. The study of one membrane protein, the gastric H(+),K(+)-ATPase, demonstrates the usefulness of (1)H/(2)H exchange kinetics for the understanding of the molecular movement related to the catalytic activity.

Analysis of 1H/2H exchange kinetics using model infrared spectra

This paper investigates the different approaches that best retrieve band shape parameters and kinetic time constants from series of protein Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectra recorded in the course of 1H/2H exchange. In this first approach, synthetic spectra were used. It is shown that 1H/2H exchange kinetic measurements can help resolve spectral features otherwise hidden because of the overlap of various spectral contributions. We evaluated the efficiency of Fourier self-deconvolution, synchronous/asynchronous correlation, difference spectroscopy, principal component analysis, inverse Laplace transform, and determination of the underlying spectra by global analysis assuming first-order kinetics with either known or unknown time constants. It is demonstrated that some strategies allow the extraction of both the time dependence and the spectral shape of the underlying contributions.

Structural stability of human α-thrombin studied by disulfide reduction and scrambling

Human alpha-thrombin is a very important plasma serine protease, which is involved in physiologically vital processes like hemostasis, thrombosis, and activation of platelets. Knowledge regarding the structural stability of alpha-thrombin is essential for understanding its biological regulation. Here, we investigated the structural and conformational stability of alpha-thrombin using the techniques of disulfide reduction and disulfide scrambling. alpha-Thrombin is composed of a light A-chain (36 residues) and a heavy B-chain (259 residues) linked covalently by an inter-chain disulfide bond (Cys(1)-Cys(122)). The B-chain is stabilized by three intra-chain disulfide bonds (Cys(42)-Cys(58), Cys(168)-Cys(182), and Cys(191)-Cys(220)) (Chymotrypsinogen nomenclature). Upon reduction with dithiothreitol (DTT), alpha-thrombin unfolded in a 'sequential' manner with sequential reduction of Cys(168)-Cys(182) within the B-chain followed by the inter-chain disulfide, generating two distinct partially reduced intermediates, I-1 and I-2, respectively. Conformational stability of alpha-thrombin was investigated by the technique of disulfide scrambling. alpha-Thrombin denatures by scrambling its native disulfide bonds in the presence of denaturant [urea, guanidine hydrochloride (GdmCl) or guanidine thiocyanate (GdmSCN)] and a thiol initiator. During the process, cleavage of the inter-chain disulfide bond and release of the A-chain from B-chain was the foremost event. The three disulfides in the B-chain subsequently scrambled to form three major isomers (designated as X-Ba, X-Bb, and X-Bc). Complete denaturation of alpha-thrombin was observed at low concentrations of denaturants (0.5 M GdmSCN, 1.5 M GdmCl, or 3 M urea) indicating low conformational stability of the protease.

Attenuated total reflection IR spectroscopy as a tool to investigate the orientation and tertiary structure changes in fusion proteins

Membrane fusion proceeds via a merging of two lipid bilayers and a redistribution of aqueous contents and bilayer components. It involves transition states in which the phospholipids are not arranged in bilayers and in which the monolayers are highly curved. Such transition states are energetically unfavourable since biological membranes are submitted to strong repulsive hydration electrostatic and steric barriers. Viral membrane proteins can help to overcome these barriers. Viral proteins involved in membrane fusion are membrane associated and the presence of lipids restricts drastically the potential of methods (RMN, X-ray crystallography) that have been used successfully to determine the tertiary structure of soluble proteins. We describe here how IR spectroscopy allows to solve some of the problems related to the lipid environment. The principles of the method, the experimental setup and the preparation of the samples are briefly described. A few examples illustrate how attenuated total reflection Fourier-transform IR (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy can be used to gain information on the orientation and the accessibility to the water phase of the fusogenic domain of viral proteins. Recent developments suggest that the method could also be used to detect changes located in the membrane domains and to identify intermediate structural states involved in the fusion process.

The folding pathway of alpha-lactalbumin elucidated by the technique of disulfide scrambling. Isolation of on-pathway and off-pathway intermediates

The technique of disulfide scrambling permits reversible conversion of the native and denatured (scrambled) proteins via shuffling and reshuffling of disulfide bonds. Under strong denaturing conditions (e.g. 6 m guanidinium chloride) and in the presence of a thiol initiator, alpha-lactalbumin (alphaLA) denatures by shuffling its four native disulfide bonds and converts to an assembly of 45 species of scrambled isomers. Among them, two predominant isomers, designated as X-alphaLA-a and X-alphaLA-d, account for about 50% of the total denatured structure of alphaLA. X-alphaLA-a and X-alphaLA-d, which adopt the disulfide patterns of (1-2,3-4,5-6,7-8) and (1-2,3-6,4-5,7-8), respectively, represent the most unfolded structures among the 104 possible scrambled isomers (Chang, J.-Y., and Li, L. (2001) J. Biol. Chem. 276, 9705-9712). In this study, X-alphaLA-a and X-alphaLA-d were purified and allowed to refold through disulfide scrambling to form the native alphaLA. Folding intermediates were trapped kinetically by acid quenching and analyzed quantitatively by reversed phase high pressure liquid chromatography. The results revealed two major on-pathway productive intermediates, two major off-pathway kinetic traps, and at least 30 additional minor transient intermediates. Of the two major on-pathway intermediates, one takes on a native-like alpha-helical domain, and the other comprises a structured beta-sheet, calcium binding domain. The two major kinetic traps are apparently stabilized by locally formed non-native-like structures. Overall, the folding mechanism of alphaLA is essentially congruent with the model of "folding funnel" furnished with a rather intricate energy landscape.

Attenuated total reflection IR spectroscopy as a tool to investigate the structure, orientation and tertiary structure changes in peptides and membrane proteins

During the last few years, attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (ATR-FTIR) has become one of the most powerful methods to determine the structure of biological materials and in particular of components of biological membranes, like proteins that cannot be studied by x-ray crystallography and NMR. ATR-FTIR requires a little amount of material (1-100 microg) and spectra are recorded in a matter of minutes. The environment of the molecules can be modulated so that their conformation can be studied as a function of temperature, pressure, pH, as well as in the presence of specific ligands. For instance, replacement of amide hydrogen by deuterium is extremely sensitive to environmental changes and the kinetics of exchange can be used to detect tertiary conformational changes in the protein structure. Moreover, in addition to the conformational parameters that can be deduced from the shape of the infrared spectra, the orientation of various parts of the molecule can be estimated with polarized IR. This allows more precise analysis of the general architecture of the membrane molecules within the biological membranes. The present review focuses on ATR-IR as an experimental approach of special interest for the study of the structure, orientation, and tertiary structure changes in peptides and membrane proteins.

Protein folding intermediates and pathways studied by hydrogen exchange

In order to solve the immensely difficult protein-folding problem, it will be necessary to characterize the barriers that slow folding and the intermediate structures that promote it. Although protein-folding intermediates are not accessible to the usual structural studies, hydrogen exchange (HX) methods have been able to detect and characterize intermediates in both kinetic and equilibrium modes--as transient kinetic folding intermediates on a subsecond time scale, as labile equilibrium molten globule intermediates under destabilizing conditions, and as infinitesimally populated intermediates in the high free-energy folding landscape under native conditions. Available results consistently indicate that protein-folding landscapes are dominated by a small number of discrete, metastable, native-like partially unfolded forms (PUFs). The PUFs appear to be produced, one from another, by the unfolding and refolding of the protein's intrinsically cooperative secondary structural elements, which can spontaneously create stepwise unfolding and refolding pathways. Kinetic experiments identify three kinds of barrier processes: (a) an initial intrinsic search-nucleation-collapse process that prepares the chain for intermediate formation by pinning it into a condensed coarsely native-like topology; (b) smaller search-dependent barriers that put the secondary structural units into place; and (c) optional error-dependent misfold-reorganization barriers that can cause slow folding, intermediate accumulation, and folding heterogeneity. These conclusions provide a coherent explanation for the grossly disparate folding behavior of different globular proteins in terms of distinct folding pathways.

Direct evidence by H/D exchange and ESI-MS for transient unproductive domain interaction in the refolding of an antibody scFv fragment

The refolding kinetics of a single-chain Fv (scFv) fragment, derived from a stabilized mutant of the phosphorylcholine binding antibody McPC603, was investigated by H/D exchange and ESI-MS and compared with the folding kinetics of its constituting domains V(H) and V(L). Both V(H) and V(L) adopt essentially native-like exchange protection within the dead time of the manual-mixing H/D exchange experiment (10 s) and in the case of V(L), which contains two cis-prolines in the native conformation, this fast protection is independent of proline cis/trans isomerization. At the earliest time point resolvable by manual mixing, fewer deuterons are protected in the scFv fragment than in the two isolated domains together, despite the fact that the scFv fragment is significantly more stable than V(L) and V(H). Full H/D exchange protection in the scFv fragment is gained on a time scale of minutes. This means that the domains in the scFv fragment do not refold independently. Rather, they associate prematurely and in nonnative form, a kinetic trap. Unproductive domain association is observed both after equilibrium- and short-term denaturation. For the equilibrium-denatured scFv fragment, whose native structure formation is dependent on a cis conformation of an interface proline in V(L), this cis/trans isomerization reaction proceeds about one order in magnitude more slowly than the escape from the trap to a conformation where full H/D exchange protection is already achieved. We interpret these data in terms of a general kinetic scheme involving intermediates with and without domain association.

Hydrogen/deuterium exchange kinetics of apolipophorin-III in lipid-free and phospholipid-bound states. An analysis by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy

Attenuated total reflection Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy was used to probe the kinetics of hydrogen/deuterium exchange in Manduca sexta apolipophorin-III (apoLp-III). ApoLp-III is an exchangeable apolipoprotein that is made up of five elongated amphipathic alpha-helices in a helical bundle conformation in the monomeric lipid-free form. Upon interaction with phospholipids, it is postulated to undergo a large conformational change whereby the hydrophobic interior is exposed, facilitating binding to the lipid surfaces. We have used the lipid-free and dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine-bound apoLp-III to study the dynamically variable domains in the two forms. Three populations of amide protons varying in their hydrogen/deuterium exchange rates were found to exist: slow, intermediate, and fast exchanging, which could correspond to completely buried, partially buried, and solvent-exposed domains on the protein in both the states. In lipid-free apoLp-III, 36, 12, and 52% of the total residues contributed to the slow, intermediate, and fast exchanging populations, respectively. In the dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine-bound form, the corresponding distribution was 20, 16, and 64%, representing a 12% increase in the number of exposed residues. The results are discussed in terms of increased solvent accessibility due to gross tertiary structural reorganization.

Hydrogen exchange in the carbon monoxide complex of soybean leghemoglobin

Hydrogen/deuterium exchange rates for individual amide protons have been measured for the carbon monoxide complex of soybean leghemoglobin. Fast two-dimensional NOESY experiments were performed, with 5.2-min data-collection time for each spectrum, which made possible the measurement of NOE cross-peaks of relatively rapidly exchanging amide protons at early time points. Exchange rates were measured for 61 backbone amides, the protection factors were calculated to provide information on the packing and local stability of the protein. The data are consistent with the presence of transient cooperative local unfolding of helical segments. The B-, E-, G- and H-helices have extensive regions of slow-, medium- and fast-exchanging amide protons. For each of these helices, there is a progressive decrease in protection on moving from the helix center to the termini. This is consistent with a stable helix center, with dynamic fraying at the ends. Amide exchange from the A-helix and C-helix is rapid except in small local regions. The F-helix, which is located on the proximal side of the heme pocket and is well formed in solution as demonstrated by characteristic medium range NOE connectivities [Morikis, D. Lepre, C.A. & Wright, P.E. (1994) Eur. J. Biochem. 219, 611-626], exhibits fast exchange for all amide protons. The implied flexibility and low stability of the F-helix may be functionally important in facilitating movement of the helix upon ligand binding. Fast exchange has also been observed for all amide protons in the CE-loop and in turns, as expected for flexible or solvent exposed regions. A strong tertiary contact has been established between the A-, G- and H-helices by the presence of a slowly exchanging indole N epsilon H of Trp129.

Evidence for a bound water molecule next to the retinal Schiff base in bacteriorhodopsin and rhodopsin: a resonance Raman study of the Schiff base hydrogen/deuterium exchange

The retinal chromophores of both rhodopsin and bacteriorhodopsin are bound to their apoproteins via a protonated Schiff base. We have employed continuous-flow resonance Raman experiments on both pigments to determine that the exchange of a deuteron on the Schiff base with a proton is very fast, with half-times of 6.9 +/- 0.9 and 1.3 +/- 0.3 ms for rhodopsin and bacteriorhodopsin, respectively. When these results are analyzed using standard hydrogen-deuteron exchange mechanisms, i.e., acid-, base-, or water-catalyzed schemes, it is found that none of these can explain the experimental results. Because the exchange rates are found to be independent of pH, the deuterium-hydrogen exchange can not be hydroxyl (or acid-)-catalyzed. Moreover, the deuterium-hydrogen exchange of the retinal Schiff base cannot be catalyzed by water acting as a base because in that case the estimated exchange rate is predicted to be orders of magnitude slower than that observed. The relatively slow calculated exchange rates are essentially due to the high pKa values of the Schiff base in both rhodopsin (pKa > 17) and bacteriorhodopsin (pKa approximately 13.5). We have also measured the deuterium-hydrogen exchange of a protonated Schiff base model compound in aqueous solution. Its exchange characteristics, in contrast to the Schiff bases of the pigments, is pH-dependent and consistent with the standard base-catalyzed schemes. Remarkably, the water-catalyzed exchange, which has a half-time of 16 +/- 2 ms and which dominates at pH 3.0 and below, is slower than the exchange rate of the Schiff base in rhodopsin and bacteriorhodopsin. Thus, there are two anomalous results, the inconsistency of the observed hydrogen exchange rates of retinal Schiff base in the two pigments with those predicted from the standard exchange schemes and the enhancement of the rate of hydrogen exchange in the two proteins over the model Schiff base in aqueous solution. We suggest that these results are explained by the presence of a structural water molecule (or molecules) at the retinal binding sites of the two pigments, quite close, probably-hydrogen bonded, to the Schiff base proton. In this case, the rate of exchange can be faster than that found for the model compound due to an "effective water concentration" near the Schiff base that is increased from that found in aqueous solution.

Characterization of a folding intermediate of apoplastocyanin trapped by proline isomerization

The unfolding and refolding transitions of French bean apoplastocyanin (apo-Pc), a beta-sandwich protein, have been characterized. The apoprotein is stabilized by sodium sulfate and can be reversibly unfolded by guanidine hydrochloride (GuHCl). However, in contrast to holo-Pc, apo-Pc is unstable at low ionic strength, suggesting that the copper ion stabilizes the holoprotein. The equilibrium unfolding transition monitored by peptide circular dichroism (CD) and tyrosine fluorescence is described by a two-state model. The kinetics of the unfolding transition were monitored using a manual mixing technique and are consistent with a single two-state transition. In contrast, the kinetics of the refolding reaction measured by fluorescence and CD show two transitions with different rates. The relaxation time of the slower phase (800-1000 s) is almost independent of GuHCl concentration. The faster phase was observed only under strongly native conditions, and its relaxation time is GuHCl-dependent. Double-jump experiments and acceleration by cyclophilin demonstrate that both phases involve cis-trans isomerization of proline residues. The changes in fluorescence associated with the two phases are more than 150% of the total change expected from equilibrium experiments, indicating the presence of intermediate(s) with fluorescence greater than the unfolded state. Amide hydrogen-exchange experiments coupled with two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy demonstrate the formation of an intermediate in the very low refolding reaction in which amide protons in the beta-sheets are weakly protected from exchange. No CD evidence for nativelike beta-sheet formation was found for this intermediate. The NMR experiments suggest that the intermediate is compact with flexible beta-sheets and altered packing of the hydrophobic core. It has many of the characteristics of a molten globule. However, the 1H NMR spectrum of the intermediate exhibits a small number of shifted resonances that indicate the presence of specific tertiary interactions in a localized region. A mechanism for refolding of apoplastocyanin is proposed that includes two slow steps corresponding to trans-->cis isomerization of two prolines.

Structural energetics of the molten globule state

Certain partly ordered protein conformations, commonly called "molten globule states," are widely believed to represent protein folding intermediates. Recent structural studies of molten globule states of different proteins have revealed features which appear to be general in scope. The emerging consensus is that these partly ordered forms exhibit a high content of secondary structure, considerable compactness, nonspecific tertiary structure, and significant structural flexibility. These characteristics may be used to define a general state of protein folding called "the molten globule state," which is structurally and thermodynamically distinct from both the native state and the denatured state. Despite extensive knowledge of structural features of a few molten globule states, a cogent thermodynamic argument for their stability has not yet been advanced. The prevailing opinion of the last decade was that there is little or no enthalpy difference or heat capacity difference between the molten globule state and the unfolded state. This view, however, appears to be at variance with the existing database of protein structural energetics and with recent estimates of the energetics of denaturation of alpha-lactalbumin, cytochrome c, apomyoglobin, and T4 lysozyme. We discuss these four proteins at length. The results of structural studies, together with the existing thermodynamic values for fundamental interactions in proteins, provide the foundation for a structural thermodynamic framework which can account for the observed behavior of molten globule states. Within this framework, we analyze the physical basis for both the high stability of several molten globule states and the low probability of other potential folding intermediates. Additionally, we consider, in terms of reduced enthalpy changes and disrupted cooperative interactions, the thermodynamic basis for the apparent absence of a thermally induced, cooperative unfolding transition for some molten globule states.

An infrared study of 2H-bond variation in myoglobin revealed by high pressure

A high-pressure Fourier-transform infrared technique was used to probe the evolution of 2H bonds inside the helical segments of myoglobin in relation to p2H, Tris concentration in the medium and iron-ligand nature. The analysis was focused on changes in the conformation-sensitive amide-I' band, reflecting the peptide C = O group stretching vibrations coupled to the in-plane N-2H bending and C = N stretching modes. From data obtained under high pressure, the strength of 2H bonds, inside the alpha-helical segments of the protein at atmospheric pressure, is not simply a function of p2H and salt concentration. At low Tris concentration (50 mM), the strength of these 2H bonds increases with p2H, whereas for a higher Tris concentration (100 mM) this strength is lower at p2H 7 than at p2H 6.0 or 8.5. It is also observed that the azidometmyoglobin molecule exhibits tighter intrahelical interactions and lower sensitivity to pressure than aquametmyoglobin. Information is also presented regarding interhelical interactions in relation to the solvent.

Demonstration by NMR of folding domains in lysozyme

Although there has been much speculation on the pathways of protein folding, only recently have experimental data on the topic been available. The study of proteins under conditions where species intermediate between the fully folded and unfolded states are stable has provided important information, for example about the disulphide intermediates in BPTI, cis/trans proline isomers of RNase A3 and the molten globule state of alpha-lactalbumin. An alternative approach to investigating folding pathways has involved detection and characterization of transient conformers in refolding studies using stopped-flow methods coupled with NMR measurements of hydrogen exchange. The formation of intermediate structures has been detected in the early stages of folding of cytochrome c, RNaseA and barnase. For alpha-lactalbumin, hydrogen exchange kinetics monitored by NMR proved to be crucial for identifying native-like structural features in the stable molten globule state. An analogous partially folded protein stable under equilibrium conditions has not been observed for the structurally homologous protein hen egg-white lysozyme, although there is evidence that a similar but transient state is formed during refolding. Here we describe NMR experiments based on competition between hydrogen exchange and the refolding process which not only support the existence of such a transient species for lysozyme, but enable its structural characteristics to be defined. The results indicate that the two structural domains of lysozyme are distinct folding domains, in that they differ significantly in the extent to which compact, probably native-like, structure is present in the early stages of folding.

Relationship between protein/solvent proton exchange and progressive conformation and fluctuation changes in hemoglobin

The pH dependence of the tertiary structural changes and the quaternary reorganization of the alpha beta interface of oxyhemoglobin in solution has been previously observed in our laboratory. The present work aims to establish whether or not these progressive structural changes with pH result from proton exchange between the protein and the solvent. We therefore have used infrared spectroscopy, acid/base titration and 1H/2H exchange to assess the effect of external proton concentration on the structural and dynamic properties of the hemoglobin molecule in solution. This study is also performed on the carbonmonoxy form since the affinity of hemoglobin for CO is much higher than for oxygen. The present findings demonstrate that affinity changes are closely related to protein fluctuations, as well as structural modifications. An increased affinity, induced either by ligand replacement or pH variation, is associated with the constrained chains exhibiting a lower degree of fluctuation, together with a looser alpha beta interface association.

Characterization of the critical state in protein folding. Effects of guanidine hydrochloride and specific Ca2+ binding on the folding kinetics of alpha-lactalbumin

The reversible unfolding and refolding kinetics of alpha-lactalbumin induced by concentration jump of guanidine hydrochloride were measured at pH 7.0 and 25 degrees C using tryptophan absorption at 292 nm, with varying concentrations of the denaturant and free Ca2+. The refolding reaction of alpha-lactalbumin from the fully unfolded (D) state occurs through the two stages: (1) instantaneous formation of a compact intermediate (the A state) that has a native-like secondary structure; (2) tight packing of the preformed secondary structure segments to lead finally to the native structure, this stage being the rate-determining step of the reaction and associated with acquisition of the specific structure necessary for strong Ca2+ binding. Under strongly native conditions, the observed kinetics of refolding is also complicated by the presence of a slow-folding species (10%) in the unfolded state. Considering these facts, the microscopic rate constants in folding and unfolding directions have been evaluated from the observed kinetics and from the equilibrium constants of the transitions among the native (N), A and D states. Close linear relationships have been found in the plots of the activation free energies, obtained from the microscopic rate constants, against the denaturant concentration. They are similar to the linear relationship between the free energy of unfolding and the denaturant concentration. It was demonstrated that the slope of the plots should be approximately proportional to a change in accessible surface area of the protein during the respective activation process, and that only a third of the difference in accessible surface area between A and N is buried in the critical activated state of folding. However, the selective effect of Ca2+ binding on the folding rate constant has been observed also, demonstrating that the specific Ca2+-binding substructure in the N state is already organized in the activated state. Thus, only a part of the protein molecule involving the Ca2+-binding region is organized in the activated state, with the other part of the molecule being left less organized, suggesting that the second stage of folding may be a sequential growing process of organized assemblage of the performed secondary structure segments.

Structural characterization of folding intermediates in cytochrome c by H-exchange labelling and proton NMR

To understand the process of protein folding, it will be necessary to obtain detailed structural information on folding intermediates. This difficult problem is being studied by using hydrogen exchange and rapid mixing to label transient structural intermediates, with subsequent analysis of the proton-labelling pattern by two-dimensional nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Results for cytochrome c show that the method provides the spatial and temporal resolution necessary to monitor structure formation at many defined sites along the polypeptide chain on a timescale ranging from milliseconds to minutes.

NMR evidence for an early framework intermediate on the folding pathway of ribonuclease A

The presence of an early intermediate on the folding pathway of ribonuclease A has been demonstrated by a study of the exchange reaction between the backbone amide protons in the folding protein and solvent protons using rapid mixing techniques. A structural analysis of the intermediate by two-dimensional 1H-NMR is consistent with the framework model of protein folding in which stable secondary structure first forms the framework necessary for the subsequent formation of the complete tertiary structure.

Strategy for obtaining non-native protein structures using antibody cross-reactions

Antibodies made to short peptides or to unfolded forms of proteins are often found to cross-react with intact proteins. These cross-reactions can be used to populate non-native protein conformations, possibly including protein folding intermediates, and the structures of the non-native conformations can be characterized using amide proton exchange and two-dimensional NMR.