Approaches to a three-dimensional model of E. coli ribosome

Transfer RNA docking pair model in the ribosomal pre- and post-translocational states

A consensus has been reached that the conformation of the anticodon-codon interactions of two adjacent tRNA molecules on the ribosome is a Sundaralingam-type (S-type). Even if it is kept to the S-type, there are still various possibilities. Various experimental data have been supporting an idea that the conformation of A-site tRNA is different from that of P-site tRNA. Those data as well as the recent result of Brimacombe and co-workers that U20:1 of lupin tRNAmMetbound to the A-site was cross-linked to a region, 875-905, of 23S rRNA in combination with the other recent findings of Nierhaus and co-workers about the spin-contrast method of neutron diffraction of the ribosome and the better accessible nucleotide patterns of phosphorothioated tRNAs on the ribosome have led to a new tRNA docking pair model, in which the highly conserved G18 and G19 of D-loop in A-site tRNA and C56 and C61 of TpsiC-loop in P-site tRNA base pair along with the conventional base pairs of adjacent codon-anticodon interactions. This A-P tRNA pair model can be translocated to the P-E tRNA pair model without changing the conformation except the ACCA termini, keeping the position of the growing nascent polypeptide chain.

The elongating ribosome: structural and functional aspects

We determined the positions and arrangements of RNA ligands within the ribosome with a new neutron-scattering technique, the proton-spin contrast-variation. Two tRNAs were bound to the ribosome in the pre-translocational and the post-translocational state. The mass centre of gravity of both tRNAs resides at the subunit interface of the body of the 30S subunit. Both tRNAs are separated by an angle of 50-55 degrees, and their mutual arrangement does not change during translocation. The mass centre of gravity moves by 13 +/- 3 A (1A = 0.1 nm) during translocation, corresponding well with the length of one codon. Using an RNase-digestion technique, the length of the mRNA sequence covered by the ribosome was determined to be 39 +/- 3 nucleotides before and after translocation. The ribosome moves like a rigid frame along the mRNA during translocation. In contrast, both tRNAs seem to be located on a movable ribosomal domain, which carries the tRNAs before, during, and after translocation, leaving the microtopography of the tRNAs with the ribosome unaltered. This conclusion was derived from an analysis of the contract patterns of thioated tRNAs on the ribosome. The results have led to a new model of the elongation cycle, which reinterprets the features of the previous "allosteric three-sites model" in a surprisingly simple fashion. Finally, a mutational analysis has identified a single nucleotide of the 23S rRNA essential for the peptidyltransferase activity.

Structures of small subunit ribosomal RNAs in situ from Escherichia coli and Thermomyces lanuginosus

Small ribosomal subunits from the prokaryote Escherichia coli and the eukaryote Thermomyces lanuginosus were imaged electron spectroscopically, and single particle analysis used to yield three-dimensional reconstructions of the net phosphorus distribution representing the nucleic acid (RNA) backbone. This direct approach showed both ribosomal RNAs to have a three domain structure and other characteristic morphological features. The eukaryotic small ribosomal subunit had a prominent bill present in the head domain, while the prokaryotic subunit had a small vestigial bill. Both ribosomal subunits contained a thick 'collar' central domain which correlates to the site of the evolutionarily conserved ribosomal RNA core, and the location of the majority of ribosomal RNA bases that have been implicated in translation. The reconstruction of the prokaryotic subunit had a prominent protrusion extending from the collar, forming a channel approximately 1.5 nm wide and potentially representing a 'bridge' to the large subunit in the intact monosome. The basal domain of the prokaryotic ribosomal subunit was protein free. In this region of the eukaryotic subunit, there were two basal lobes composed of ribosomal RNA, consistent with previous hypotheses that this is a site for the 'non-conserved core' ribosomal RNA.

Phenotypic effects of targeted mutations in the small subunit rRNA gene of Tetrahymena thermophila

Tetrahymena thermophila is an ideal organism with which to study functional aspects of the rRNAs in vivo since the somatic rRNA genes of T. thermophila can be totally replaced by cloned copies introduced via microinjection. In this study, we made small insertions into seven sites within the small subunit rRNA gene and observed their phenotypic effects on transformed cells. Two mutated genes coding for rRNA (rDNAs), both of which bear insertions in highly conserved sequences, failed to transform and are therefore believed to produce nonfunctional rRNAs. Three other altered rDNAs produce functional rRNAs that can substitute for most or all of the cellular rRNA. Two of these bear insertions in highly variable regions, and, surprisingly, the other has an insertion in a region that is well conserved for both sequence and secondary structure among eucaryotes. In addition, two other insertions appear to destabilize rRNAs that contain them. Our findings make predictions concerning the positions of some of these sites within the tertiary structure of the small ribosomal subunit and thus serve as an in vivo test of the existing tertiary structure models for the small subunit rRNA. Our results are in good agreement with expectations based on sequence comparison and in vitro work.

Phenotypic effects of targeted mutations in the small subunit rRNA gene of Tetrahymena thermophila

Tetrahymena thermophila is an ideal organism with which to study functional aspects of the rRNAs in vivo since the somatic rRNA genes of T. thermophila can be totally replaced by cloned copies introduced via microinjection. In this study, we made small insertions into seven sites within the small subunit rRNA gene and observed their phenotypic effects on transformed cells. Two mutated genes coding for rRNA (rDNAs), both of which bear insertions in highly conserved sequences, failed to transform and are therefore believed to produce nonfunctional rRNAs. Three other altered rDNAs produce functional rRNAs that can substitute for most or all of the cellular rRNA. Two of these bear insertions in highly variable regions, and, surprisingly, the other has an insertion in a region that is well conserved for both sequence and secondary structure among eucaryotes. In addition, two other insertions appear to destabilize rRNAs that contain them. Our findings make predictions concerning the positions of some of these sites within the tertiary structure of the small ribosomal subunit and thus serve as an in vivo test of the existing tertiary structure models for the small subunit rRNA. Our results are in good agreement with expectations based on sequence comparison and in vitro work.

Computer modeling 16 S ribosomal RNA

A three-dimensional structure for 16 S RNA has been produced with a computer protocol that is not dependent on human intervention. This protocol improves upon traditional modeling techniques by using distance geometry to fold the molecule in an objective and reproducible fashion. The method is based on the secondary structure of RNA and treats the molecule as a set of double-stranded helices that are linked by flexible single-strands of variable length. Data derived from chemical cross-linking studies of 16 S RNA and tertiary phylogenetic relationships provide the constraints used to fold the molecule into a compact three-dimensional form. Possibly subjective evaluation of the input data are transformed into verifiable quantitative parameters. Relationships based on general locations within the 30 S subunit or on protein-RNA interactions have been specifically excluded. The resolution of the model exceeds that of electron micrographs and approaches that obtained in preliminary X-ray crystal structures. The model size of 245 x 190 x 140 A is compatible with that of the 30 S subunit as determined by electron microscopy. The volume of the model is 1.87 x 10(6) A which is similar to that of the small subunit in a preliminary X-ray crystal structure. The radius of gyration of the model structure of 76 A is intermediate to that seen for partially denatured and fully folded 16 S RNA. Computer graphics are used to display the results in a manner that maximizes the opportunities for human visual interpretation of the models. A format for displaying the structures has been developed that will make it possible for researchers who have not devoted themselves to ribosomal modeling to comprehend and make use of the information that the models embody. On this basis the computer-generated models are compared with models developed by other researchers and with structural data not included in the folding parameter data set.

Prediction of the recognition sites on 16S and 23S rRNAs from E. coli for the formation of 16S-23S rRNA complex

Interactions between RNA molecules have been postulated to play an important role in the assembly of ribosomes. Using the sequence analysis and the search of continuous complementary regions on 16S rRNA and 23S rRNA, the recognition sites involved in the formation of ribosome of E. coli are postulated. The number of postulated sites was narrowed down by taking available experimental data. The suggestive evidence for correct postulation is obtained from sequence comparison studies of 16S and 23S rRNAs from various species. The sites 891-899 and 1195-1203 on 16S rRNA along with the corresponding complementary sites 1904-1912 and 760-768 on 23S rRNA are predicted to be the most probable candidates for the sites of recognition between 16S and 23S rRNAs. The possibility of the involvement of the additional site 630-638 on 16S rRNA with its complementary site 2031-2039 on 23S rRNA cannot be ruled out.

Model for the three-dimensional folding of 16 S ribosomal RNA

We have derived a model for the three-dimensional folding of Escherichia coli 16 S ribosomal RNA, using interactive computer graphic methods. It is based on (1) the secondary structure derived from comparative sequence analysis, (2) the three-dimensional co-ordinates for the centers of mass of the 30 S subunit proteins, and (3) the locations of sites in 16 S rRNA that interact with specific ribosomal proteins, from footprinting and crosslinking studies. We present a detailed description of the derivation of the model. About 75% of the RNA chain is sufficiently constrained to provide a useful model. This contains most of the universally conserved core of the molecule. In all but a few instances, protected and crosslinked sites can be placed within or very close to their cognate proteins, while obeying stereochemical rules. The overall shape of the model and locations of specific regions of the RNA correspond well to data derived from electron micrographs of 30 S subunits, although such data were not used to construct the model. Phylogenetic variations in the structure are readily accommodated; as an example, we have modeled the 950-nucleotide mammalian mitochondrial 12 S rRNA by superimposing it on the E. coli structure. The three major RNA domains, as defined by secondary structure, appear to exist as autonomous structural units in three dimensions, for the most part. There is an extensive interface between the 5' and central domains, whereas the 3' major domain has relatively little apparent contact with the rest of the structure. The 5', central and 3' major domains form structures that resemble the body, platform and head, respectively, seen in electron micrographs of 30 S subunits. We discuss possible roles for the ribosomal proteins in stabilizing specific structural features of the RNA during ribosome assembly. The decoding site, as deduced from footprinting and crosslinking studies involving the tRNA anticodon stem-loop, is well-localized. Bases protected from chemical probing by the anticodon stem-loop line the cleft of the subunit. The conserved loop at position 530, which contains some of the bases protected by A site-bound tRNA, is remote (approx. 80 A) from the decoding site. Protection of these bases by the anticodon stem-loop is thus unlikely to be due to direct contact.

Prediction of three-dimensional structure of Escherichia coli ribosomal RNA

A model for the tertiary structure of 23S, 16S and 5S ribosomal RNA molecules interacting with three tRNA molecules is presented using the secondary structure models common to E. coli, Z. mays chloroplast, and mammalian mitochondria. This ribosomal RNA model is represented by phosphorus atoms which are separated by 5.9 A in the standard A-form double helix conformation. The accumulated proximity data summarized in Table 1 were used to deduce the most reasonable assembly of helices separated from each other by at least 6.2 A. Straight-line approximation for single strands was adopted to describe the maximum allowed distance between helices. The model of a ribosome binding three tRNA molecules by Nierhaus (1984), the stereochemical model of codon-anticodon interaction by Sundaralingam et al. (1975) and the ribosomal transpeptidation model, forming an alpha-helical nascent polypeptide, by Lim & Spirin (1986), were incorporated in this model. The distribution of chemically modified nucleotides, cross-linked sites, invariant and missing regions in mammalian mitochondrial rRNAs are indicated on the model.