Spinal cord compression in neuroblastoma

Treatment and outcome of neuroblastoma with intraspinal extension: A systematic review

We performed a systematic review to define the long-term health problems and optimal treatment strategy for patients with neuroblastoma with intraspinal extension. Of 685 identified studies, 28 were included in this review. The burden of long-term health problems is high; a median of 50% of patients suffered from neurological motor deficit, 34% from sphincter dysfunction, and 30% from spinal deformity. The currently available literature remains suboptimal as a guide for treatment of NBL with intraspinal extension. More well-designed, prospective studies are needed to determine the optimal treatment strategy.

Epidural compression in neuroblastoma: Diagnostic and therapeutic aspects

The involvement by tumour of intervertebral foramina and the consequent invasion of the spinal space, accompanied or not by neurological symptoms, represent a well-recognised pattern of presentation of neuroblastoma. The main peculiarity of this condition stands in the fact that, in case of its late detection or inadequate treatment, severe, permanent neurological compromise may ensue. Surprisingly enough, remarkable disagreements still exist regarding its optimal treatment and the related literature provide contrasting indications at this respect. The neurosurgical and the chemotherapeutic approaches have equally convinced supporters, while the use of radiation therapy is uncommon, possibly without good reasons. This mini-review intends to report the clinical experiences of the major Paediatric Oncology Groups with the aim to collect as many data as possible in the perspective of establishing common guidelines for proper diagnosing and treatment of this important complication.

Treatment of spinal involvement in neuroblastoma patients

INTRODUCTION

Considerable controversy exists regarding the appropriate management of spinal involvement in neuroblastoma (NB) patients. We review a large group of such patients and offer treatment recommendations.

METHODS

Forty-six patients with epidural and/or neural foraminal involvement treated between 1987 and 1998 were staged according to the International NB Staging System (INSS) and classified as high-risk (INSS stage 4; n = 31) or low-risk (INSS stage <4; n = 15). Of 13 high- risk patients with normal neurologic examinations and no radiographic high-grade spinal cord compression (HGSCC), 12 were treated initially with chemotherapy, and only 1 demonstrated neurologic deterioration. HGSCC was present in 18 patients with high-risk NB; 7 of 10 (70%) treated initially with chemotherapy and 6 of 6 (100%) managed initially with operation improved or remained stable. All 9 low-risk patients with normal neurologic examinations and no HGSCC remained neurologically intact following operations (n = 7) or chemotherapy (n = 2). All 4 low-risk patients with HGSCC treated with operations improved or remained stable, and 0 of 2 (0%) low-risk patients treated initially with chemotherapy remained stable. Spinal deformities occurred in 2 of 16 patients (12.5%) treated nonoperatively and in 9 of 30 (30.0%) who underwent operations.

CONCLUSIONS

High-risk NB patients with spinal involvement but normal neurologic examinations should be offered chemotherapy. High-risk patients with HGSCC may respond to chemotherapy, but a small percentage will require operations for progressive neurologic deficits. Chemotherapy may be avoided in low-risk patients who are offered potentially curative operations. Patients treated with operations for epidural disease are at high risk of subsequently developing spinal deformity.

Treatment of neuroblastoma with intraspinal extensions

Neuroblastoma is the most common malignant cause of spinal compression in the paediatric population. Chemotherapy is commonly considered as the first-line treatment for these patients. The role of neurosurgical decompression and radiotherapy are still controversial. Thirteen children diagnosed as having neuroblastoma with intraspinal extension were included in this report. All patients presented with neurological deficits and were treated with chemotherapy initially, after which 3 patients recovered, 4 improved and 6 were aggravated into paraplegia. Two of the 6 aggravated patients received emergent laminectomy with removal of intraspinal tumour and recovered satisfactorily. Although spread of tumour into the spinal canal indicates an advanced disease, aggressive treatments such as chemotherapy and surgical resection can often improve neurological symptoms and life quality. Neurological decompression is recommended for patients with intraspinal neuroblastoma and rapid neurological deterioration during chemotherapy.

Biologic variables in the outcome of stages I and II neuroblastoma treated with surgery as primary therapy: a children's cancer group study

PURPOSE

To determine prospectively whether surgery alone is sufficient therapy for Evans stages I and II neuroblastoma and to define biologic and clinical features having prognostic potential for this group.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between June 1989 and August 1995, 374 eligible children (age range, 0 to 18 years) with newly diagnosed stage I (n = 141) and stage II (n = 233) neuroblastoma were registered onto Children's Cancer Group trial 3881. Surgical resection was the only primary therapy except in cases with spinal cord compression, where radiation therapy was allowed. Event-free survival (EFS) and overall survival (OS) were analyzed by life-table methods according to clinical and biologic features.

RESULTS

EFS and OS (mean +/- SE) for all stage I patients were 93% +/- 3.0% and 99% +/- 1.0%, respectively, compared with 81% +/- 4.0% and 98% +/- 2. 0%, respectively, for stage II patients. The significantly higher recurrence rate among stage II patients was managed successfully in 38 of 43 children with either surgery or multimodality treatment. There was one death among stage I patients and six among stage II. For stage II patients tumor MYCN gene amplication, unfavorable histopathology, an age greater than 2 years, and positive lymph nodes predicted a lower OS (P <.05).

CONCLUSION

Children with stages I and II neuroblastoma have 98% survival with surgery alone as primary therapy. Supplemental treatment was necessary in only 10% of stage I patients and 20% of stage II patients. In children with localized neuroblastoma, a subset of patients that are at higher risk for death can be defined as those with stage II disease who have tumor MYCN amplification or who are >/= 2 years of age with either unfavorable histopathology or positive lymph nodes.

The treatment of neuroblastoma with intraspinal extension with chemotherapy followed by surgical removal of residual disease. A prospective study of 42 patients--results of the NBL 90 Study of the French Society of Pediatric Oncology

BACKGROUND

Neuroblastoma is the most common malignant cause of spinal compression in the pediatric population. More than 30% of patients who are impaired prior to treatment remain impaired after the completion of therapy. Those who do not improve after decompressive laminectomy may go on to develop severe delayed spinal deformities.

METHODS

To decrease the long term sequelae of routine neurosurgical intervention for all intraspinal extensions of neuroblastoma, the French NBL 90 Study was formulated to use chemotherapy as a first-line treatment for all nonmetastatic neuroblastomas with intraspinal extension. Neurosurgical decompression and excision was recommended only for patients demonstrating rapid neurologic deterioration.

RESULTS

The overall survival of the 42 patients registered was 97%. Initial neurologic impairment was present in 27 patients (64%), including 11 with paraplegia. Thirty-two patients received chemotherapy as first-line treatment. Complete regression of the intraspinal component was observed in 13 patients and partial regression of greater than 50% of the initial volume in 5 patients. Of 19 evaluable patients presenting with a neurologic deficit and treated with primary chemotherapy, recovery was completed in 11 and partial in 3. Four patients failed to recover from long-standing pretreatment paraplegia. Only one patient worsened during therapy, and recovered completely after emergent neurosurgical intervention. Seven patients underwent initial neurosurgical procedures; six had a neurologic deficit and five recovered completely, including all three who presented with acute onset of paraplegia. Three patients had extraspinal surgery as exclusive treatment. Six patients (15%) suffered severe neurologic sequelae. Only one of the patients who underwent surgery required spinal stabilization for progressive deformity, but follow-up is limited.

CONCLUSIONS

By treating patients with dumbbell neuroblastoma initially with chemotherapy, the authors were able to reduce the size of the intraspinal mass in 58% of patients, improve partial neurologic deficits in 92%, and avoid neurosurgical decompression in 60%. Neurologic deficits also improved in 83% of patients requiring emergent neurosurgical intervention.

Localized dumbbell neuroblastoma: a study of 25 cases treated between 1982 and 1987 using the same protocol

Among the 108 non-metastatic neuroblastomas treated at the Institut Gustave Roussy between 1982 and 1987, 25 dumbbell neuroblastomas were observed. Therapeutics included: 1) an initial laminectomy in forms with neurological deficit; 2) surgical excision of the primary tumor; 3) preoperative chemotherapy in children in which the primary tumor was considered as unresectable at diagnosis and postoperative chemotherapy in cases of incomplete resection; and 4) radiation therapy on macroscopic residual disease. Fifteen out of 25 (60%) presented a neurological deficit. A laminectomy was performed in 14 cases. Neurological recovery was good in 4 cases, partial in 4 cases, and absent in 4 cases. Two patients were worse after the procedure. The event-free survival was 88%. This high survival rate is linked: 1) to the non-metastatic stage; 2) to a high proportion of children under 1 year of age (18/25) (median age = 7 months); and 3) to a high proportion of thoracic location (12/25). The high incidence of macroscopically incomplete excision (13/25) did not jeopardize the prognosis. Out of the 22 survivors, there were 8 cases of major neurological sequellae (36%) and 5 cases of major orthopedic ones (26%). The coexistence of a serious functional prognosis and an excellent vital prognosis for these patients has led us to analyse the therapeutic modalities, to reevaluate the necessity of routine initial neurosurgical removal by laminectomy and to discuss the use of first line chemotherapy.

Neuroblastoma in an adult causing spinal cord compression: report of a case and review of the literature

Adult neuroblastoma (ANB) is an uncommon malignancy, there being only 42 reported cases in the world literature. The purpose of this report is to present a case of ANB with spinal cord compression by an intraspinal component, and review methods of diagnosis and treatment. NB is one of the most frequent childhood malignancies (90% of the patients are less than 10 years old) and both pathologists and clinicians tend to exclude it from differential diagnosis when the patient is an adult. When the tumour is located in the paraspinal region, local extension through the intervertebral foramen into the spinal canal can occur in a dumbbell fashion, a pattern of growth first described by Weber in 1856.