Full recovery from deafness after removal of a large acoustic neurinoma associated with neurofibromatosis 2: case report

Hearing improvement after vestibular schwannoma surgery in the era of the hearing preservation rule - case report and literature review

OBJECTIVES

Hearing preservation after vestibular schwannoma (VS) surgery remains a surgical challenge. In some patients with preserved inner ear function, hearing improvement is achievable. As it is currently impossible to determine which patients will present this outcome, predictions must rely on previously published reports. Our case report describes a patient who experienced hearing improvement from an unuseful level to a useful one after vestibular schwannoma surgery.

METHODS

Surgery was performed via suboccipital retrosigmoid approach. The patient underwent a basic audiovestibular protocol before and after the surgery - pure tone and speech audiometry, otoacoustic emissions, auditory brainstem responses, electronystagmography - together with a detailed questionnaire study. Usefulness of hearing was evaluated using the AAO-HNS guidelines, supplemented by a frequency of 4 kHz.

RESULTS

Hearing was preserved and even improved from an unuseful level to a useful one. Based on the available literature, the most informative predictive factors for such a result seem to be: sudden sensorineural hearing loss prior to surgery, elicitable otoacoustic emissions and the origin from the superior vestibular nerve.

CONCLUSION

There are a limited number of studies on this topic and it is still impossible to regularly improve hearing in properly selected patients. Furthermore, the importance of postoperative hearing quality compared to other symptoms and complications remains debatable.

Surgical pathology of spinal schwannomas: a light and electron microscopic analysis of tumor capsules

OBJECTIVE

Although spinal schwannomas are often encountered, the pathology of the tumor capsule has not been reported. In this study, we describe the ultrastructural pathology of the tumor capsule of spinal schwannomas.

METHODS

In 18 patients who underwent total removal of spinal schwannomas (C2-conus), the tumor capsule was collected and examined by light and electron microscopy.

RESULTS

The thickness of the tumor capsule ranged from 15 to 800 microm (mostly 30-100 microm) and was composed of three layers from the surface to the center: 1) a thinly stretched nerve tissue layer; 2) a fibrous layer of fibrocytes, abundant collagen fibers, and tumor vessels; and 3) a thin transitional layer intermingled with fibrous components and tumor cells. The thickness of each layer varied in different regions of the surface. There was no clear separation between the tumor capsule and the neoplastic tissue, even on the electron microscopic level. A number of nerve fibers ran through the fibrous layer and beneath the capsule as well as in the nerve tissue layer.

CONCLUSION

Compared with vestibular schwannomas, which have been reported to be covered by an extremely thin layer (3-5 microm) of connective tissue, spinal schwannomas were well encapsulated. The capsule was composed of three distinct components; however, the cleavage between thin capsule and tumor cells was indistinct, and the thickness of the axon-containing capsule varied from site to site. Therefore, resection of the nerve of tumor origin, rather than enucleation, would be justified to avoid tumor recurrence. Surgeons should be aware of this pathology when performing the procedure.

Hearing improvement after middle fossa resection of vestibular schwannoma

OBJECTIVE

The preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative variables of patients experiencing hearing improvement after middle fossa resection of vestibular schwannomas were evaluated as potential prognostic indicators.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective case review with new objective postoperative data collected on patients with documented hearing improvement.

SETTING

California Ear Institute at Stanford and Stanford University Hospital, a tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS

The patient group consisted of 30 consecutive patients undergoing middle fossa approach to vestibular schwannoma between October 24, 1994, and November 11, 1998.

INTERVENTION

Hearing preservation surgery via the middle cranial fossa approach was performed on all patients.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Pure-tone averages (PTAs) and speech discrimination scores (SDS) were used to document hearing preoperatively and postoperatively. Preoperative electrophysiologic studies of auditory brainstem response, electronystagmography, electrical neuronography, transient evoked otoacoustic emissions, and distortion product otoacoustic emissions were evaluated. Intraoperative continuous nerve action potential and auditory brainstem response tracings were reviewed. Postoperative auditory brainstem response and transient evoked otoacoustic emissions were obtained when possible on patients whose hearing improved. Statistical analysis was completed using Student's t test and chi-square test.

RESULTS

Seventeen (57%) of 30 patients with tumors ranging from 2 to 31 mm maintained hearing postoperatively. Among patients with hearing preservation, 7 (41% or 23% of the overall group) exhibited hearing improvement (PTA 2 improved by > or =5 dB and/or SDS improved by > or =12%). Three of these 7 patients moved from nonfunctional (AAOHNS class C/D) to functional (AAOHNS class A/B) categories. All patients who enjoyed postoperative hearing improvement had preoperative absence or abnormality of ABRs. No patient with normal preoperative ABR experienced hearing improvement. Hearing improvement patients also had lower preoperative caloric function on electronystagmography compared with the entire group (p < 0.02) and were more likely to have superior vestibular nerve tumors. No differences were noted for electrical neurography and otoacoustic emissions.

CONCLUSIONS

Middle fossa resection of vestibular schwannoma offers patients the possibility of hearing improvement after treatment. The chance of hearing improvement is significantly higher than with other forms of treatment such as radiation therapy or translabyrinthine surgery. Although preoperative ABR abnormality may be an indicator of poor prognosis for hearing preservation, those patients who enjoy hearing improvement come from the group of patients with abnormal preoperative ABRs. Other factors identified as associated with hearing improvement include poor SDS with more normal PTA 2, and significantly decreased electronystagmographic caloric function (as an indicator of superior vestibular nerve tumors). Hearing improvement to the functional range after surgical resection is possible in some patients previously thought to be poor candidates for hearing preservation attempts. Hearing improvement may continue for many months after surgery.

Different aspects of hearing preservation in surgery of vestibular schwannoma in women and men

Pre-operative and postoperative auditory function was reviewed retrospectively in 98 patients with vestibular schwannomas. According to their hormonal status, women were categorized as "premenopausal" and "postmenopausal". Before surgery, 48% of the women (65% premenopausal) and 16% of the men presented with sudden hearing loss. The degree of auditory function before operation was similar for women and men. Preservation of pre-operative hearing was possible for 41% of the women (21% premenopausal) and 59% of the men. Further details of the surgery and the results of histopathological examination were also compared for women and men. Our results support substantial evidence that hearing preservation after surgery of vestibular schwannoma is easier to accomplish for men than for women. The finding of significantly more sudden hearing loss in premenopausal women may suggest a hormonal influence on tumour growth, which may also be partially responsible for the difference in hearing prognosis between women and men.

Long-term follow-up of the residual intracanalicular tumours after subtotal removal of acoustic neurinomas

We examined growth potential of residual intracanalicular tumours left from subtotal removal of large acoustic neurinomas. Eleven patients were followed-up by magnetic resonance (MR) imaging. The interval between surgery and MR study ranged from 12 to 29 years (median, 16 years). MR images of two patients showed no evidence of tumour remnant, and in six a small tumour was localized in the internal auditory canal. The other three showed an intracanalicular tumour protruding slightly towards the intracranial portion. This result suggests that the intracanalicular residual tumours have less risk of regrowth after subtotal removal of acoustic neurinomas. It is advisable to choose intracapsular, subtotal removal without opening the internal auditory canal in the treatment of acoustic neurinoma, if it is large in size and there is a high risk of nerve injury.