Somatic mutation of immunoglobulin light-chain variable-region genes

Beyond Hot Spots: Biases in Antibody Somatic Hypermutation and Implications for Vaccine Design

The evolution of antibodies in an individual during an immune response by somatic hypermutation (SHM) is essential for the ability of the immune system to recognize and remove the diverse spectrum of antigens that may be encountered. These mutations are not produced at random; nucleotide motifs that result in increased or decreased rates of mutation were first reported in 1992. Newer models that estimate the propensity for mutation for every possible 5- or 7-nucleotide motif have emphasized the complexity of SHM targeting and suggested possible new hot spot motifs. Even with these fine-grained approaches, however, non-local context matters, and the mutations observed at a specific nucleotide motif varies between species and even by locus, gene segment, and position along the gene segment within a single species. An alternative method has been provided to further abstract away the molecular mechanisms underpinning SHM, prompted by evidence that certain stereotypical amino acid substitutions are favored at each position of a particular V gene. These "substitution profiles," whether obtained from a single B cell lineage or an entire repertoire, offer a simplified approach to predict which substitutions will be well-tolerated and which will be disfavored, without the need to consider path-dependent effects from neighboring positions. However, this comes at the cost of merging the effects of two distinct biological processes, the generation of mutations, and the selection acting on those mutations. Since selection is contingent on the particular antigens an individual has been exposed to, this suggests that SHM may have evolved to prefer mutations that are most likely to be useful against pathogens that have co-evolved with us. Alternatively, the ability to select favorable mutations may be strongly limited by the biases of SHM targeting. In either scenario, the sequence space explored by SHM is significantly limited and this consequently has profound implications for the rational design of vaccine strategies.

Reverse Transcriptase Mechanism of Somatic Hypermutation: 60 Years of Clonal Selection Theory

The evidence for the reverse transcriptase mechanism of somatic hypermutation is substantial and multifactorial. In this 60th anniversary year of the publication of Sir MacFarlane Burnet's Clonal Selection Theory, the evidence is briefly reviewed and updated.

Why does somatic hypermutation by AID require transcription of its target genes?

In this review, I discuss the currently available experimental evidence concerning the molecular interactions of the activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) with transcription of its target genes. The basic question that underlies the transcription relationship is how the process of somatic hypermutation of Ig genes can be restricted to their variable (V) regions. This hallmark of SHM assures that high affinity antibodies can be created while the biological functions of their constant (C) region are undisturbed. I present a revised model of AID function in somatic hypermutation (SHM): In a B cell that produces AID protein and undergoes mutation of the V regions of the expressed Ig heavy and light chain genes, only some of the transcription complexes initiating at the active V-region promoters are associated with AID. When AID travels with the elongating RNA polymerase (pol), it attracts proteins that cause the pausing/stalling of pol and termination of transcription, followed by termination of SHM. This differential AID loading model would allow the mutating B cell to continue producing full-length Ig proteins that are required to avoid apoptosis by permitting the cell to assemble functional B cell receptors.

The amino acid residue at position 95 and the third CDR region in the H chain determine the ceiling affinity and the maturation pathway of an anti-(4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl antibody

Two groups of anti-(4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) Abs each possessing a different amino acid, Tyr or Gly, at position 95, appeared respectively at early and late stages of immunization. The early Abs predominantly harbored Tyr95 and were referred to as the Tyr95 type. These had ∼100-fold lower ceiling affinity than the late Abs harboring Gly95, which were referred to as the Gly95 type. We found that in order to raise affinity, the Tyr95 type utilized a mutation at position 33 in V(H), while the Gly95 type used multiple mutations in both V(H) and V(L), and that the effect of the mutations was reciprocal; the former mutation had a positive effect on Tyr95 type Abs but a negative effect on Gly95 type Abs, and vice versa. The reciprocal effect of these mutations on affinity enabled us to assess the type of Abs prepared by introducing 20 different amino acids at position 95. We found that Abs harboring Lys95, Arg95, Pro95, and Tyr95 belonged to the Tyr95 type and those with Ala95 and Gly95, to the Gly95 type. Since this dependency on the amino acid at position 95 was observed in H chains whose third CDR (CDR 3H) consisted of 9 amino acids and not 11, the CDR 3H region was also considered to play an important role in determining the maturation pathway and the magnitude of the ceiling affinity.

A coming-of-age story: activation-induced cytidine deaminase turns 10

The discovery and characterization of activation-induced cytidine deaminase (AID) 10 years ago provided the basis for a mechanistic understanding of secondary antibody diversification and the subsequent generation and maintenance of cellular memory in B lymphocytes, which signified a major advance in the field of B cell immunology. Here we celebrate and review the triumphs in the mission to understand the mechanisms through which AID influences antibody diversification, as well as the implications of AID function on human physiology. We also take time to point out important ongoing controversies and outstanding questions in the field and highlight key experiments and techniques that hold the potential to elucidate the remaining mysteries surrounding this vital protein.

DNA polymerases in adaptive immunity

To cope with an unpredictable variety of potential pathogenic insults, the immune system must generate an enormous diversity of recognition structures, and it does so by making stepwise modifications at key genetic loci in each lymphoid cell. These modifications proceed through the action of lymphoid-specific proteins acting together with the general DNA-repair machinery of the cell. Strikingly, these general mechanisms are usually diverted from their normal functions, being used in rather atypical ways in order to privilege diversity over accuracy. In this Review, we focus on the contribution of a set of DNA polymerases discovered in the past decade to these unique DNA transactions.

Silent development of memory progenitor B cells

T cell-dependent immune responses generate long-lived plasma cells and memory B cells, both of which express hypermutated Ab genes. The relationship between these cell types is not entirely understood. Both appear to emanate from the germinal center reaction, but it is unclear whether memory cells evolve while obligatorily generating plasma cells by siblings under all circumstances. In the experiments we report, plasma cell development was functionally segregated from memory cell development by a series of closely spaced injections of Ag delivered during the period of germinal center development. The injection series elevated serum Ab of low affinity, supporting the idea that a strong Ag signal drives plasma cell development. At the same time, the injection series produced a distinct population of affinity/specificity matured memory B cells that were functionally silent, as manifested by an absence of corresponding serum Ab. These cells could be driven by a final booster injection to develop into Ab-forming cells. This recall response required that a rest period precede the final booster injection, but a pause of only 4 days was sufficient. Our results support a model of memory B cell development in which extensive affinity/specificity maturation can take place within a B cell clone under some circumstances in which a concomitant generation of Ab-forming cells by siblings does not take place.

Somatic hypermutation and junctional diversification at Ig heavy chain loci in the nurse shark

We estimate there are approximately 15 IgM H chain loci in the nurse shark genome and have characterized one locus. It consists of one V, two D, and one J germline gene segments, and the constant (C) region can be distinguished from all of the others by a unique combination of restriction endonuclease sites in Cmu2. On the basis of these Cmu2 markers, 22 cDNA clones were selected from an epigonal organ cDNA library from the same individual; their C region sequences proved to be the same up to the polyadenylation site. With the identification of the corresponding germline gene segments, CDR3 from shark H chain rearrangements could be analyzed precisely, for the first time. Considerable diversity was generated by trimming and N addition at the three junctions and by varied recombination patterns of the two D gene segments. The cDNA sequences originated from independent rearrangements events, and most carried both single and contiguous substitutions. The 53 point mutations occurred with a bias for transition changes (53%), whereas the 78 tandem substitutions, mostly 2-4 bp long, do not (36%). The nature of the substitution patterns is the same as for mutants from six loci of two nurse shark L chain isotypes, showing that somatic hypermutation events are very similar at both H and L chain genes in this early vertebrate. The cis-regulatory elements targeting somatic hypermutation must have already existed in the ancestral Ig gene, before H and L chain divergence.

Hypermutation in shark immunoglobulin light chain genes results in contiguous substitutions

Among 631 substitutions present in 90 nurse shark immunoglobulin light chain somatic mutants, 338 constitute 2-4 bp stretches of adjacent changes. An absence of mutations in perinatal sequences and the bias for one mutating V gene in adults suggest that the diversification is antigen dependent. The substitutions shared no patterns, and the absence of donor sequences, including from family members, supports the idea that most changes arose from nontemplated mutation. The tandem mutations as a group are distinguished by consistently fewer transition changes and an A bias. We suggest this is one of several pathways of hypermutation diversifying shark antigen-receptor genes--point mutations, tandem mutations, and mutations with a G-C preference--that coevolved with or preceded gene rearrangement.

Emerging links between hypermutation of antibody genes and DNA polymerases

Substantial antibody variability is created when nucleotide substitutions are introduced into immunoglobulin variable genes by a controlled process of hypermutation. Evidence points to a mechanism involving DNA repair events at sites of targeted breaks. In vertebrate cells, there are many recently identified DNA polymerases that inaccurately copy templates. Some of these are candidates for enzymes that introduce base changes during hypermutation. Recent research has focused on possible roles for DNA polymerases zeta (POLZ), eta (POLH), iota (POLI), and mu (POLM) in the process.

The 3' Igkappa enhancer contains RNA polymerase II promoters: implications for endogenous and transgenic kappa gene expression

We have created a kappa transgene in which a polymerase (pol) III promoter replaces the pol II promoter. Two independent transgenic lines show somatic hypermutation of the transgene in B cells from hyperimmunized mice. Both lines transcribe transgenes from the pol III promoter in the liver. However, in spleen and spleen B cell-derived hybridomas, they also transcribe mRNA from pol II promoters located within the 3' kappa enhancer of the preceding transgene copy in a tandem transgene array. The findings demonstrate that in an array of multiple transgenes the expression (and somatic hypermutation) of an individual transgene copy must be considered in the context of the other copies. We also show that sequences around the 3' kappa enhancer in endogenous genes are transcribed. The possible role of these promoters in endogenous kappa gene expression is discussed. An unrelated finding in this study was a novel RNA splice in one hybridoma.

Altered spectra of hypermutation in DNA repair-deficient mice

Affinity maturation of the humoral immune response is based on the ability of immunoglobulin variable genes to undergo a process of rapid and extensive somatic mutation followed by antigenic selection for antibodies with higher affinity. While the behaviour of this somatic hypermutation phenomenon has been well characterized over the last 20 years, the molecular mechanism responsible for inserting mutations has remained shrouded. To better understand this mechanism, we studied the interplay between hypermutation and other DNA associated activities such as DNA repair. There was no effect on the frequency and pattern of hypermutation in mice deficient for nucleotide excision repair, base excision repair and ataxia-telangiectasia mutated gene repair of double strand breaks. However, variable genes from mice lacking some components of mismatch repair had an increased frequency of tandem mutations and had more mutations of G and C nucleotides. These results suggest that the DNA polymerase(s) involved in the hypermutation pathway produces a unique spectra of mutations, which is then altered by mismatch repair and antigenic selection. We, also describe the differential pattern of expression of some nuclear DNA polymerases in hypermutating versus non-hypermutating B lymphocytes. The rapidly dividing germinal centre B cells expressed DNA polymerases alpha, beta, delta, epsilon and zeta, whereas the resting non-germinal centre cells did not express polymerases alpha or epsilon at detectable levels, although they did express polymerases beta, delta and zeta. The lack of expression of polymerase epsilon in the non-germinal centre cells suggests that this enzyme has a critical role in chromosomal replication but does not participate in DNA repair in these cells.

Somatic hypermutation and the three R's: repair, replication and recombination

Somatic hypermutation introduces single base changes into the rearranged variable (V) regions of antigen activated B cells at a rate of approximately 1 mutation per kilobase per generation. This is nearly a million-fold higher than the typical mutation rate in a mammalian somatic cell. Rampant mutation at this level could have a devastating effect, but somatic hypermutation is accurately targeted and tightly regulated. Here, we provide an overview of immunoglobulin gene somatic hypermutation; discuss mechanisms of mutation in model organisms that may be relevant to the hypermutation mechanism; and review recent advances toward understanding the possible role(s) of DNA repair, replication, and recombination in this fascinating process.

Cis-acting sequences that affect somatic hypermutation of Ig genes

We review our studies on the mechanism of somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes. Most experiments were carried out using Ig transgenes. We showed in these experiments that all required cis-acting elements are present within the 10-16 kb of a transgene. Only the Ig variable region and its proximate flanks are mutated, not the constant region. Several Ig gene enhancers are permissive for somatic mutation. Association of the enhancer with its natural Ig promoter is not necessary. However, the mutation process seems specific for Ig genes. No mutations were found in housekeeping genes from cells with high levels of somatic hypermutation of their Ig genes. The Ig enhancers may provide the Ig gene specificity. An exception may be the BCL6 gene, which was mutated in human but not in mouse B cells. Transcription of a region is required for its mutability. When the transcriptional promoter located upstream of the variable region is duplicated upstream of the constant region, this region also becomes mutable. This suggests a model in which a mutator factor associates with the RNA polymerase at the promoter, travels with the polymerase during elongation, and causes mutations during polymerase pausing. The DNA repair systems, nucleotide excision repair and DNA mismatch repair, are not required. Our recent data with an artificial substrate of somatic mutation suggest that pausing may be due to secondary structure of the DNA or nascent RNA, and the specific mutations to preferences of the mutator factor.

Does base composition help predispose the complementarity-determining regions of antibodies to hypermutation?

A survey of the base usage in genes coding for human antibodies reveals that more (A+T) and less (C+G) are found in the segments coding for the complementarity-determining regions, while the opposite is true for the segments coding for framework and constant regions. The possibility that this bias in base usage may contribute to hypermutation is explored.

Somatic hypermutagenesis in immunoglobulin genes. III. Somatic mutations in the chicken light chain locus

We report a new approach based on the Monte Carlo method, to analyze gene conversion. With this, we have examined 235 somatic mutations in the chicken Vlambda gene and found that about 75% of somatic mutations significantly correlated with donor sequences in 25 pseudo Vlambda genes (set C) versus about 25% that did not (set N). The RGYW and TAA consensus sequences of mutational hotspots were earlier revealed in mammalian V genes. Analysis for correlation between somatic mutations in the Vlambda gene and the consensus sequences showed that the somatic mutations of set N were correlating with the consensus sequences (P(W < Wrandom) < 0.01) and the somatic mutations of set C were not. Based on further statistical analysis, we suggest that there must be at least two mechanisms responsible for somatic hypermutagenesis in the Vlambda gene: gene conversion and another, which accounts for the elevated frequencies of somatic mutations at the RGYW and TAA consensus sequences.

Tracing the development of single memory-lineage B cells in a highly defined immune response

To study the development of B lymphocyte memory, we identified and isolated splenic B cells expressing a highly defined antibody variable region that constitutes a reproducible and predominant component of the memory antibody response to p-azophenylarsonate (Ars). Isolation was achieved during the primary immune response by surface staining and flow cytometry using a specific anti-idiotypic antibody called E4, which recognizes this canonical V region, encoded by one set of V gene segments. The isolated E4+ cells displayed all of the phenotypic characteristics of germinal center centrocytes, including a low level of surface Ig, a lack of surface IgD, a high level of receptor for peanut agglutinin, and expression of mutated antibody V genes. E4+ B cells were first detected in the spleen 7-8 d after primary immunization, reached peak numbers from days 10-13, and waned by day 16. Surprisingly, at their peak, E4+ cells comprised only 40,000 of all splenocytes, and half of these failed to bind Ars. Using this number, we estimate the total number of Ars-specific memory-lineage cells in the spleen to be no more than 50,000 (0.1%) at any one time, and presumably far fewer that are committed to the memory pool. Chromosomal copies of rearranged V genes from single E4+ cells were amplified by nested PCR, and the amplified products were sequenced directly without cloning, using standardized conditions that disclose virtually no Taq polymerase errors. V gene sequence analyses of E4+ cells isolated from single mice confirmed their canonical nature and revealed that they were derived from few precursors. In the average mouse, the E4+ pool was derived from fewer than five canonical precursors. Somatic mutations were found within the V genes of almost all cell isolates. At day 13, a significant fraction of E4+ cells had mutations known to increase antibody affinity for Ars, suggesting they were products of at least one cycle of post-mutational antigen-driven selection. However, the lack of shared mutations by clonally related cells indicated that the selective expansion of mutant subclones typical of memory responses had not yet taken place. This was supported by the observation that half of the E4+ cells failed to bind Ars. Collectively, our results indicate that the memory compartment is a highly selected entity, even at relatively early stages of the primary immune response when somatic mutation and clonal selection are still in progress. If germinal centers are the source of memory B cells, our data suggest that B cell memory may be derived from only a small fraction of all germinal centers.

Somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes

The relationship between somatic hypermutation and affinity maturation in the mouse is delineated. Recent work on the anatomical and cellular site of this process is surveyed. The molecular characteristics of somatic hypermutation are described in terms of the region mutated and the distinctive patterns of nucleotide changes that are observed. The results of experiments utilizing transgenic mice to find out the minimum cis-acting sequences required to recruit hypermutation are summarized. The hypothesis that V gene sequences have evolved in order to target mutation to certain sites but not others is discussed. The use that different species make of somatic hypermutation to generate either the primary or secondary B cell repertoire is considered. Possible molecular mechanisms for the hypermutation process and future goals of research are outlined.

The molecular basis of somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes

Somatic hypermutation amplifies the variable region repertoire of immunoglobulin genes. Recent experimental evidence has thrown light on various molecular models of somatic hypermutation. A link between somatic hypermutation and transcription coupled DNA repair is shaping up.

An immunoglobulin mutator that targets G.C base pairs

Hypermutation can be defined as an enhancement of the spontaneous mutation rate which the organism uses in certain types of differentiated cells where a high mutation rate is advantageous. At the immunoglobulin loci this process increases the mutation rate > 10(5)-fold over the normal, spontaneous rate. Its proximate cause is called the immunoglobulin mutator system. The most important function of this system is to improve antibody affinity in an ongoing response; it is turned on and off during the differentiation of B lymphocytes. We have established an in vitro system to study hypermutation by transfecting a rearranged mu gene into a cell line in which an immunoglobulin mutator has been demonstrated. A construct containing the mu gene and the 3' kappa enhancer has all the cis-acting elements necessary for hypermutation of the endogenous gene segments encoding the variable region. The activity of the mutator does not seem to depend strongly on the position of the transfected gene in the genome. The mutator is not active in transformed cells of a later differentiation stage. It is also not active on a transfected lacZ gene. These results are consistent with the specificity of the mutator system being maintained and make it possible to delineate cis and trans mutator elements in vitro. Surprisingly, the mutator preferentially targets G-C base pairs. Two hypotheses are discussed: (i) the immunoglobulin mutator system in mammals consists of several mutators, of which the mutator described here is only one; or (ii) the primary specificity of the system is biased toward mutation of G-C base pairs, but this specificity is obscured by antigenic selection.

Somatic hypermutation of immunoglobulin genes is linked to transcription initiation

To identify DNA sequences that target the somatic hypermutation process, the immunoglobulin gene promoter located upstream of the variable (V) region was duplicated upstream of the constant (C) region of a kappa transgene. Normally, kappa genes are somatically mutated only in the VJ region, but not in the C region. In B cell hybridomas from mice with this kappa transgene (P5'C), both the VJ region and the C region, but not the region between them, were mutated at similar frequencies, suggesting that the mutation mechanism is related to transcription. The downstream promoter was not occluded by transcripts from the upstream promoter. In fact, the levels of transcripts originating from the two promoters were similar, supporting a mutation model based on initiation of transcripts. Several "hot-spots" of somatic mutation were noted, further demonstrating that this transgene has the hallmarks of somatic mutation of endogenous immunoglobulin genes. A model linking somatic mutation to transcription-coupled DNA repair is proposed.

Role of conserved amino acid residues in the complementarity determining regions on hapten-antibody interaction of anti-(4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl) acetyl antibodies

Monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) specific to (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) were prepared at various times after immunization and the amino acid sequences of VH and V lambda 1 in these mAbs were deduced from cDNA nucleotide sequences. Replacements due to somatic mutation were not found in day 7 mAbs but were found in those of days 14, 84 and 294. The affinity of day 7 mAbs to NP-glycine(NP-Gly) was in the order of 10(4) M-1 and it increased about 8000-fold with time after immunization. The extrinsic circular dichroism (CD) spectrum of the NP-epsilon-aminocaproic acid (NP-Cap)/Ab complex was unique for each mAb, although the spectra were grouped into two types, which tended to shift from one type to another with time, suggesting a variation in the micro-environments around NP-Cap in the combining sites. All these data indicate that the structure of the combining site was altered by somatic mutation; however, the fine-specificity measured by cross-reactivity with hapten analogues did not change significantly with time. We examined the amino acid residues in CDRs responsible for recognition of NP-haptens by comparing the amino acid sequences of anti-NP mAbs. Analyses revealed the presence of several conserved amino acid residues in CDRs of VH and V lambda 1, such as Tyr-32H, and Tyr-60H, in addition to a core segment involving Arg-50H.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Immunoglobulin light chain class multiplicity and alternative organizational forms in early vertebrate phylogeny

The prototypic chondrichthyan immunoglobulin (Ig) light chain type (type I) isolated from Heterodontus francisci (horned shark) has a clustered organization in which variable (V), joining (J), and constant (C) elements are in relatively close linkage (V-J-C). Using a polymerase chain reaction-based approach on a light chain peptide sequence from the holocephalan, Hydrolagus colliei (spotted ratfish), it was possible to isolate members of a second light chain gene family. A probe to this light chain (type II) detects homologs in two orders of elasmobranchs, Heterodontus, a galeomorph and Raja erinacea (little skate), a batoid, suggesting that this light chain type may be present throughout the cartilaginous fishes. In all cases, V, J, and C regions of the type II gene are arranged in closely linked clusters typical of all known Ig genes in cartilaginous fishes. All representatives of this type II gene family are joined in the germline. A third (kappa-like) light chain type from Heterodontus is described. These findings establish that a degree of light chain class complexity comparable to that of the mammals is present in the most phylogenetically distant extant jawed vertebrates and that the phenomenon of germline-joined (pre-rearranged) genes, described originally in the heavy chain genes of cartilaginous fishes, extends to light chain genes.

Conservation of sequence in recombination signal sequence spacers

The variable domains of immunoglobulins and T cell receptors are assembled through the somatic, site specific recombination of multiple germline segments (V, D, and J segments) or V(D)J rearrangement. The recombination signal sequence (RSS) is necessary and sufficient for cell type specific targeting of the V(D)J rearrangement machinery to these germline segments. Previously, the RSS has been described as possessing both a conserved heptamer and a conserved nonamer motif. The heptamer and nonamer motifs are separated by a 'spacer' that was not thought to possess significant sequence conservation, however the length of the spacer could be either 12 +/- 1 bp or 23 +/- 1 bp long. In this report we have assembled and analyzed an extensive data base of published RSS. We have derived, through extensive consensus comparison, a more detailed description of the RSS than has previously been reported. Our analysis indicates that RSS spacers possess significant conservation of sequence, and that the conserved sequence in 12 bp spacers is similar to the conserved sequence in the first half of 23 bp spacers.

Comparison of somatic mutation frequency among immunoglobulin genes

We analyzed the frequency of somatic mutation in immunoglobulin genes from hybridomas that secrete anti-(4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenyl)acetyl (NP) monoclonal antibodies. A high frequency of mutation (3.3-4.4%) was observed in both the rearranged VH186.2 and V lambda 1 genes, indicating that somatic mutation occurs with similar frequency in these genes in spite of the absence of an intron enhancer in lambda 1 chain genes. In contrast to the high frequency in J-C introns, only two nucleotide substitutions occurred at positions -462 and -555 in the 5' noncoding region in one of the lambda 1-chain genes and in none of the other three so far studied. Since a similar low frequency of somatic mutation was observed in the 5' noncoding region of inactive lambda 2-chain genes rendered inactive because of incorrect rearrangement, this region may not be a target or alternatively, may be protected from the mutator system. We observed a low frequency of nucleotide substitution in unrearranged V lambda 1 genes (approximately 1/15 that of rearranged genes). Together with previous results (Azuma T., N. Motoyama, L. Fields, and D. Loh, 1993. Int. Immunol. 5:121), these findings suggest that the 5' noncoding region, which contains the promoter element, provides a signal for the somatic mutator system and that rearrangement, which brings the promoter into close proximity to the enhancer element, should increase mutation efficiency.

Mapping the upstream boundary of somatic mutations in rearranged immunoglobulin transgenes and endogenous genes

Mammalian B-cell specific somatic hypermutation contributes to affinity maturation of the antibody response. This mutator activity is highly focused on rearranged immunoglobulin variable regions, but the underlying mechanism remains to be elucidated. In an effort to gain insights into the mechanism of somatic hypermutation, the precise distribution and frequency of mutations upstream of murine immunoglobulin genes was determined by examining the same variable gene segments when mutated in different B-cell lines. Immunoglobulin sequences analysed included kappa light chain transgenes bearing mutated V kappa 24 variable regions, and the endogenous V kappa gene isolated from myeloma MOPC167, which also exhibits mutations in the variable region. In addition, mutated endogenous VH1 gene segments of the S107 heavy chain variable gene family were also examined. For both VH1 and V kappa 24, somatic mutations were generally not found upstream of the leader intron, even in genes which exhibited a high mutation frequency in the variable region itself. The 5' somatic mutation boundary identified in immunoglobulin transgenes overlaps the boundary observed in endogenous genes, suggesting that both share cis-elements required for defining the mutable domain. Furthermore, the location of this 5' boundary appears not to change when these immunoglobulin genes are examined in different cell lines. These data may be indicative of a defined start site for immunoglobulin mutator activity.

Affinity maturation of lymphocyte receptors and positive selection of T cells in the thymus

In this review we have re-evaluated the dominant paradigm that TcR V genes do not somatically mutate. We highlight the many structural and functional similarities between Ig and TcR antigen-specific receptors on B and T cells. We have reviewed the factors influencing the somatic and germline evolution of IgV regions in B cells, have evaluated in detail various models which could be invoked to explain the pattern of variation in both transcribed and non-transcribed segments of germline IgV-gene DNA sequences, and applied this perspective to the TcR V beta and V alpha genes. Whilst specific TcRs recognize a complex of a short antigenic peptide bound to MHC Class I or II glycoprotein, and Ig receptors can recognize both oligopeptides and conformational determinants on undegraded polypeptides, they both employ heterodimer variable regions (Fabs) utilizing all three CDRs in epitope binding. We conclude that a plausible case can be made for the possibility that rearranged TcR V genes may undergo some type of somatic hypermutation process during T-cell development in the thymus (concurrent with or after the positive selection phase) thus allowing a repertoire of TvR alpha beta heterodimers to be both positively and negatively selected by the same set of ligands (self MHC + self peptide) in the thymus.

Somatic hypermutation of an immunoglobulin mu heavy chain transgene

We have analyzed somatic hypermutation of an immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy chain transgene. Hybridomas expressing the transgene were produced from immunized transgenic mice and transgene copies were sequenced to assay for mutation. In two IgM-producing hybridomas, as well as in several IgG-producing hybridomas, mutations were found in the VDJ region of the transgene. In the IgM-producing hybridomas, both mutated and unmutated transgene copies were present and expressed as mRNA. Several mutated transgene copies were present in a single cell and these showed different patterns of mutation. Two IgG-producing hybridomas isolated from a single animal also showed a hierarchical pattern of mutation indicating that transgene mutations can accumulate during B cell proliferation, similar to the mutational process for endogenous antibody genes. Among hybridomas that expressed both IgG and IgM molecules derived from the transgene, the isotype-switched gamma transgene copy exhibited a higher level of mutation than the mu transgene copies. Our results indicate that the 15-kb ARSmu transgene contains all the sequence information required to target the Ig-specific hypermutational machinery, and raise the possibility that sequences associated with the endogenous CH locus might enhance somatic mutation.

Characterization of a V kappa family in Mus musculus castaneus: expansion at the subset level

We have examined the same kappa chain variable (V kappa) region family in several mouse species in order to observe short-term, incremental change at immunoglobulin (Ig) multigene loci. In the present study, the Igk-V24 family has been characterized in a Mus m. castaneus colony derived from individuals originating in Thailand and compared to the same family in Mus m. domesticus (BALB/c) and Mus pahari, representing about 1-2 and about 5-9 million years of evolution, respectively. Southern hybridization of genomic DNA with a probe encoding the prototype Igk-V24 coding region reveals restriction fragment patterns indicative of two distinct M. m. castaneus haplotypes. These haplotypes appear to result from an unequal recombination between similar gene arrays, as their restriction patterns are unique but contain many common fragments. The complexity of these patterns indicates a marked expansion in the Igk-V24 family of M. m. castaneus relative to BALB/c and M. pahari. Additional analyses using probes specific for individual subsets demonstrate that the expansion is not general throughout the entire family, but is restricted to particular subsets and therefore to relatively short chromosomal segments. One subset alone accounts for most of the expansion and comprises over 40% of the entire M. m. castaneus family. The wide range of Igk-V24 family complexity seen among M. m. castaneus, M. m. domesticus, and M. pahari, as well as among the different M. m. castaneus family subsets, suggests a model of random evolution in V kappa family copy number rather than one which is selective.

Characterization of a V kappa family in Mus musculus castaneus: sequence analysis

To examine genetic variation at immunoglobulin (Ig) multigene loci over short spans of evolutionary time, we have compared members of an Ig kappa chain variable (V kappa) region family from several mouse species. In this study, seven unique Igk-V24 family members have been isolated from Mus m. castaneus and characterized by nucleotide sequence determination for comparison to their counterparts in Mus m. domesticus (BALB/c), and Mus pahari, representing 1-2 million years of evolution in the former case and 5-8 million years in the latter. Parsimony, together with evolutionary distances calculated for various pairs of Igk-V24 family coding regions, relate all family members to a common progenitor existing roughly 24 million years ago (Mya). A significant portion of the M. m. castaneus family consists of pseudogene segments in various degrees of progressive degeneration. The substitution patterns and divergence rates for all gene segments are characteristic of their respective subsets, especially in the areas flanking the coding regions. Complex and variable patterns of diversity are seen in potentially expressed coding regions, which appear to reflect quite different selective pressures on various subregions within the V kappa protein domain. These results indicate that evolutionary pressures are operating at the level of family subsets, their individual members, and subregions within similar molecules.

Somatic hypermutagenesis in immunoglobulin genes. II. Influence of neighbouring base sequences on mutagenesis

A new approach for the analysis of hotspots of mutations is described. It is based on the classification of hotspot site sequences. Using this approach, the consensuses RGYW and TAA of hotspot sites were revealed in the V gene. Correlation between somatic mutations and these consensuses is investigated by the statistical weight method in 323 somatic substitutions in 14 V genes. Assuming the absence of any correlation, the probability of observing such data in the sample would be very low (0.0003). These results support the idea that emergence of somatic mutation is significantly influenced by neighbouring base sequences. This idea was also supported by the analysis of 296 somatic mutations in flanking sequences of V genes. It is supposed that this influence is an important feature of somatic hypermutagenesis.

Sequencing heavy- and light-chain variable genes of single B-hybridoma cells by total enzymatic amplification

We have devised a protocol to obtain accurate and complete sequences of the immunoglobulin heavy- and light-chain variable-region (VH and VL) genes of single B-hybridoma cells that express defined V genes. The amplification achieved ranges from 2 x 10(13)- to 1 x 10(14)-fold. Only one potential Taq DNA polymerase error was observed in 7590 nucleotides of sequence, thus permitting the identification of naturally occurring somatic mutations. The two-step nature of the amplification protocol provides sufficient DNA for a minimum of 160 sets of sequencing reactions of both the VH and VL genes from one cell without cloning. The amplification of relatively long segments of DNA in the first step of the protocol permits second-step amplification and sequencing of regions that flank VH and VL codons. Fractionating cellular lysates prior to the first step of amplification permits the separate amplification of V genes on opposite sister chromatids and possibly on opposite strands of the same DNA duplex. Accurate sequencing of VH and VL genes of defined germ-line origin that are expressed by single B cells taken directly from the animal is thus made feasible by this approach.

Analysis of a T cell receptor gene as a target of the somatic hypermutation mechanism

In an effort to identify cis-acting elements required for targeting of the somatic hypermutation process in mice, we examined whether a T cell receptor (TCR) transgene under the control of the immunoglobulin (Ig) heavy (H) chain intron enhancer would be mutated in antigen-stimulated B cells. Hybridomas were established from splenic B cells of mice carrying two copies of the TCR transgene after hyperimmunization with phosphorylcholine keyhole limpet hemocyanin. Northern analysis revealed that all of the transgene-containing hybridomas expressed the TCR mRNA. Multiple somatic point mutations were found in seven of eight endogenous Ig VH genes examined. In contrast, 29 of 32 TCR genes examined contained no mutations. One potential mutation was seen in each of the three other TCR genes. Our data indicate that although the TCR transgene is expressed in B cells, it is not efficiently targeted by the mutator mechanism. Furthermore, the presence of an Ig H chain enhancer is itself not sufficient for targeting of the somatic hypermutation mechanism.

Non-random features of the repertoire expressed by the members of one V kappa gene family and of the V-J recombination

The 5' and 3' flanking sequences of 14 members of the V kappa Ox (VK 4/5) gene family of BALB/c mice have been established. The family was unusual in the number of bases between the codon for Pro 95 and the heptamer sequence; most members contained four but there were also examples of none. A conserved leader sequence was used to amplify the genomic DNA of rearranged genes in order to analyze the spleen B cell repertoire of non-immunized animals. The library contained many members with virtually identical sequences to one or other of the already known members of the family. In addition, there were repeats of other sequences, allowing the definition of 12 hitherto undefined members of the family. Only 3 out of 96 could have originated by gene conversion, or as artefacts of the amplification procedure, and only 2 were putative somatic mutants. The frequency of expression of different members of the V kappa Ox gene family was not random, and some germ-line genes were unrepresented in the library. The high frequency of V kappa Ox1-J kappa 5 is in line with the dominance of this combination in the oxazolone response. An analysis of the junctional segment showed that although in most cases the diversity was due to trimming, there were exceptions indicating de novo additions (N or P bases). The average number of bases trimmed from the V kappa and the J kappa segments was not the same. There was no correlation in the number of bases trimmed from V kappa or J kappa in each recombination. The implications of asymmetric trimming in terms of the mechanism of recombination are discussed.

Linkage of two pseudogenes from V kappa 1 and V kappa 9 murine immunoglobulin families

As an initial step towards the molecular analysis of the murine V kappa locus, a cosmid library from BALB/cJ mouse liver DNA was screened with probes representing 10 V kappa families. Of eight cosmids that were isolated from the initial screen, five contained a single restriction fragment that hybridized to the probes. Two cosmids contained two fragments that hybridized to the same probe, V kappa 4, indicating that some V kappa 4 gene segments are linked. One cosmid had two genes that belonged to different families, V kappa 1 and V kappa 9. The two gene segments were located within 12 kb of each other and lay in the same transcriptional orientation. Linkage of gene segments from the V kappa 1 and V kappa 9 families is consistent with a genetic map of the locus, and provides physical evidence for the first time that two genes from different families are closely linked in the murine kappa locus. Sequence analysis revealed that both genes are pseudogenes: the V kappa psi 1.7 gene segment has eight mutations, including termination codons, insertions, and deletions, and the V kappa psi 9B.8 gene segment has two mutations of an insertion and altered RNA splice site. Both genes have the potential to rearrange based on the sequence of their heptamer-nonamer motifs. The identification of pseudogenes raises the question of how many nonfunctional genes are present in the murine germline repertoire.

Characterization of a murine immunoglobulin VH gene segment in subgroup III: a new member of the 7183 gene family

A new gene for the variable region of the immunoglobulin heavy chain (VH gene) has been isolated from BALB/c adult liver DNA using a cDNA plasmid probe containing a mouse VH sequence. The complete nucleotide sequence of this germline gene (VH10-19), shows that it belongs to the 7183 gene family. The VH gene appears to contain an intervening 104-base-long sequence and displays the same recombination signal sequences that those observed in the germline 81X. The presence of an internal heptamer at the 3' end of the VH10-19 coding region let an alternative recombination event that could increase the representation of this gene in the immature repertoire.

Selection of antigen-specific, idiotype-positive B cells in transgenic mice expressing a rearranged M167-mu heavy chain gene

Flow cytometric analysis of antigen-specific, idiotype-positive (id+), B cell development in transgenic mice expressing a rearranged M167-mu gene shows that large numbers of phosphocholine (PC)-specific, M167-id+ B cells develop in the spleen and bone marrow of these mice. Random rearrangement of endogenous V kappa genes, in the absence of a subsequent receptor-driven selection, should give rise to equal numbers of T15- and M167-id+ B cells. The observed 100-500-fold amplification of M167-id+ B cells expressing an endogenous encoded V kappa 24]kappa 5 light chain in association with the M167 VH1-id transgene product appears to be an antigen driven, receptor-mediated process, since no amplification of non-PC-binding M167 VH1/V kappa 22, T15-id+ B cells occurs in these mu-only transgenic mice. The selection and amplification of antigen-specific, M167-id+ B cells requires surface expression of the mu transgene product; thus, no enhancement of M167-id+ B cells occurs in the M167 mu delta mem-transgenic mice, which cannot insert the mu transgene product into the B cell membrane. Surprisingly, no selection of PC-specific B cells occurs in M167-kappa-transgenic mice although large numbers of B cells expressing a crossreactive M167-id are present in the spleen and bone marrow of these mice. The failure to develop detectable numbers of M167-id+, PC-specific B cells in M167-kappa-transgenic mice may be due to a very low frequency of M167-VH-region formation during endogenous rearrangement of VH1 to D-JH segments. The somatic generation of the M167 version of a rearranged VH1 gene may occur in less than one of every 10(5) bone marrow B cells, and a 500-fold amplification of this M167-Id+ B cell would not be detectable by flow cytometry even though the anti-PC antibody produced by these B cells is detectable in the serum of M167-kappa-transgenic mice after immunization with PC.

Diphosphoryl lipid A derived from lipopolysaccharide (LPS) of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides inhibits activation of 70Z/3 cells by LPS

Diphosphoryl lipid A derived from nontoxic lipopolysaccharide (LPS) of Rhodopseudomonas sphaeroides ATCC 17023 did not stimulate the murine pre-B cell line 70Z/3 to synthesize surface immunoglobulin or kappa mRNA. However, it effectively blocked Escherichia coli LPS-induced activation of 70Z/3 cells in a concentration-dependent manner. This inhibition was specific only to cells activated by LPS, since it did not inhibit activation of 70Z/3 cells by gamma interferon. Maximal inhibitory effect occurred when the antagonist was added within 2 h before adding the LPS. These results strongly suggested that R. sphaeroides diphosphoryl lipid A is competing with E. coli LPS for physiological lipid A receptors on the 70Z/3 cells.

Distribution of mutations around rearranged heavy-chain antibody variable-region genes

The mechanism of somatic hypermutation in the variable region of immunoglobulin genes expressed in mammalian B cells is a major unexplained phenomenon in the generation of diversity in the immune system. To evaluate possible mechanisms, the distribution of somatic mutations was examined for a group of five cloned, rearranged, somatically mutated VH genes generated in C57BL/6j mice. These mutated VH genes were sequenced and compared with their germ line counterparts from a point approximately 550 base pairs upstream of the transcription start site to an EcoRI site some 1,200 base pairs downstream of JH-4. The location of the transcription start (cap) sites was also precisely determined. Most (greater than or equal to 94%) of the 118 mutations scored occurred between the transcription start site and the distal end of JH-4. However, seven mutations occurred upstream of the transcribed region, and at least four were found downstream of JH-4. The target region for the mutator mechanism therefore clearly extends into the 3' nontranslated and 5' nontranscribed regions. Thus, models which propose the transcribed region of the DNA as the sole substrate for the mutation process are not ruled out but are inadequate to explain the upstream distribution of somatic mutations.

Distribution of mutations around rearranged heavy-chain antibody variable-region genes

The mechanism of somatic hypermutation in the variable region of immunoglobulin genes expressed in mammalian B cells is a major unexplained phenomenon in the generation of diversity in the immune system. To evaluate possible mechanisms, the distribution of somatic mutations was examined for a group of five cloned, rearranged, somatically mutated VH genes generated in C57BL/6j mice. These mutated VH genes were sequenced and compared with their germ line counterparts from a point approximately 550 base pairs upstream of the transcription start site to an EcoRI site some 1,200 base pairs downstream of JH-4. The location of the transcription start (cap) sites was also precisely determined. Most (greater than or equal to 94%) of the 118 mutations scored occurred between the transcription start site and the distal end of JH-4. However, seven mutations occurred upstream of the transcribed region, and at least four were found downstream of JH-4. The target region for the mutator mechanism therefore clearly extends into the 3' nontranslated and 5' nontranscribed regions. Thus, models which propose the transcribed region of the DNA as the sole substrate for the mutation process are not ruled out but are inadequate to explain the upstream distribution of somatic mutations.

Fine-mapping of DNA damage and repair in specific genomic segments

The susceptibility of various genomic regions to DNA damage and repair is heterogeneous. While this can be related to factors such as primary sequence, physical conformation, and functional status, the exact mechanisms involved remain unclear. To more precisely define the key features of a genomic region targeted for these processes, a useful tool would be a method for fine-mapping gene-specific DNA damage and repair in vivo. Here, a polymerase chain reaction-based assay is described for measuring DNA damage and repair in small (less than 500 bp) genomic segments of three transcriptionally active but functionally distinct loci (rearranged immunoglobulin heavy chain variable region [Ig VDJ], low-density lipoprotein receptor gene, and N-ras proto-oncogene) in human tonsillar B lymphocytes. Analysis of ultraviolet (254 nm)-induced DNA damage revealed single-hit kinetics and a similar level of sensitivity (D50% approximately 6000 joule/m2) in all three regions, indicating that a single photoproduct was sufficient to fully block PCR amplification. A similar time period per unit length was required for repair of this DNA damage (average t1/2 per fragment length = 23.5 seconds per bp). DNA damage and repair was also detectable with the base adducting agent, 4-nitroquinoline-1-oxide. However, in this case IgVDJ differed from segments within the other two loci by its relative inaccessibility to alkylation. This assay thus permits high-resolution mapping of DNA damage and repair activity.

Parallel evolution of antibody variable regions by somatic processes: consecutive shared somatic alterations in VH genes expressed by independently generated hybridomas apparently acquired by point mutation and selection rather than by gene conversion

We identified, in independently generated hybridoma antibodies, blocks of shared somatic alterations comprising four consecutive amino acid replacements in the CDR2s of their heavy chain variable regions. We found that the nucleotide sequences encoding the shared replacements differed slightly. In addition, we performed genomic cloning and sequencing analyses that indicate that no genomic sequence could encode the block of shared replacements in any one of the antibodies and thus directly serve as a donor by a recombinational process. Finally, in a survey of other somatically mutated versions of the same heavy chain variable gene, we found several examples containing one, two, or three of the shared CDR2 mutations in various combinations. We conclude that the shared somatic alterations were acquired by several independent events. This result, and the fact that the antibodies containing the four shared mutations were elicited in response to the same antigen and are encoded by the same VH and VK gene segments, suggests that an intense selection pressure has fixed the shared replacements by favoring the clonal expansion of B cells producing antibodies that contain them. The basis of this selection pressure is addressed elsewhere (Parhami-Seren, B., L. J. Wysocki, M. N. Margolies, and J. Sharon, manuscript submitted for publication).

Analysis of somatic mutations in kappa transgenes

We have examined the nature and localization of somatic mutations in three kappa transgenes cloned from IgG-secreting hybridomas. All of the mutations identified were single base substitutions. Mutations were localized to the variable (V) region and its flanking sequences. In every case, the nuclear matrix association region, kappa enhancer, and C gene were spared. These data indicate that the rearranged kappa gene contains the necessary sequences for targeting of the mutation process, and suggest that the observed localization of mutations to the V region reflects the inherent specificity of this mutation process.

Early rearrangements of genes encoding murine immunoglobulin kappa chains, unlike genes encoding heavy chains, use variable gene segments dispersed throughout the locus

Immunoglobulin heavy-chain variable region (TH) gene segments located closest to the joining (JH) gene segments are preferentially rearranged during ontogeny, indicating that chromosomal position influences the frequency of rearrangement. In addition, certain VH gene segments are repeatedly rearranged, suggesting that the DNA sequence or structure surrounding these segments may increase the probability of rearrangement. To determine whether there is similar based rearrangement of kappa variable (V kappa) gene segments, 25 rearrangements were sequenced from murine fetal and neonatal B-cell hybridomas and from subclones of a pre-B cell line that rearranged V kappa genes during in vitro culture. Four gene segments were isolated twice and one gene segment was isolated three times, suggesting that the process that targets individual variable gene segments for repeated rearrangement operates on both the VH and V kappa loci. Based on a current map of the V kappa locus, the rearranged gene segments belong to nine families that are dispersed throughout the locus. Thus, in these cell types, V kappa rearrangements use germ-line gene segments located across the entire locus, whereas the corresponding VH rearrangements use gene segments proximal to the JH gene segments. Heterogeneity of V kappa rearrangements would add diversity to the biased pool of VH rearrangements, producing a broad repertoire of antibodies early in development.

The role of somatic hypermutation in the generation of antibody diversity

The immune system is capable of establishing an enormous repertoire of antibodies before its first contact with antigen. Most antibodies that express germ-line sequences are of relatively low affinity. Once antigen enters the system, it stimulates a somatic mutational mechanism that generates antibodies of higher affinity and selects for the expression of those antibodies to produce a more effective immune response. The details of the mechanism and regulation of somatic hypermutation remain to be elucidated.