Reversibility of cyclization of the Tetrahymena rRNA intervening sequence: implication for the mechanism of splice site choice

Circular RNAs as Therapeutic Agents and Targets

It has recently been reported that thousands of covalently linked circular RNAs (circRNAs) are expressed from human genomes. circRNAs emerge during RNA splicing. circRNAs are circularized in a reaction termed "backsplicing," whereby the spliceosome fuses a splice donor site in a downstream exon to a splice acceptor site in an upstream exon. Although a young field of research, first studies indicate that backsplicing is not an erroneous reaction of the spliceosome. Instead, circRNAs are produced in cells with high cell-type specificity and can exert biologically meaningful and specific functions. These observations and the finding that circRNAs are stable against exonucleolytic decay are raising the question whether circRNAs may be relevant as therapeutic agents and targets. In this review, we start out with a short introduction into classification, biogenesis and general molecular mechanisms of circRNAs. We then describe reports, where manipulating circRNA abundance has been shown to have therapeutic value in animal disease models in vivo, with a focus on cardiovascular disease (CVD). Starting from existing approaches, we outline particular challenges and opportunities for future circRNA-based therapeutic approaches that exploit stability and molecular effector functions of native circRNAs. We end with considerations which designer functions could be engineered into artificial therapeutic circular RNAs.

Molecular roles and function of circular RNAs in eukaryotic cells

Protein-coding and noncoding genes in eukaryotes are typically expressed as linear messenger RNAs, with exons arranged colinearly to their genomic order. Recent advances in sequencing and in mapping RNA reads to reference genomes have revealed that thousands of genes express also covalently closed circular RNAs. Many of these circRNAs are stable and contain exons, but are not translated into proteins. Here, we review the emerging understanding that both, circRNAs produced by co- and posttranscriptional head-to-tail "backsplicing" of a downstream splice donor to a more upstream splice acceptor, as well as circRNAs generated from intronic lariats during colinear splicing, may exhibit physiologically relevant regulatory functions in eukaryotes. We describe how circRNAs impact gene expression of their host gene locus by affecting transcriptional initiation and elongation or splicing, and how they partake in controlling the function of other molecules, for example by interacting with microRNAs and proteins. We conclude with an outlook how circRNA dysregulation affects disease, and how the stability of circRNAs might be exploited in biomedical applications.

Perturbed folding kinetics of circularly permuted RNAs with altered topology

The folding pathway of the Tetrahymena ribozyme correlates inversely with the sequence distance between native interactions, or contact order. The rapidly folding P4-P6 domain has a low contact order, while the slowly folding P3-P7 region has a high contact order. To examine the role of topology and contact order in RNA folding, we screened for circular permutants of the ribozyme that retain catalytic activity. Permutants beginning in the P4-P6 domain fold 5 to 20 times more slowly than the wild-type ribozyme. By contrast, 50% of a permuted RNA that disjoins a non-native interaction in P3 folds tenfold faster than the wild-type ribozyme. Hence, the probability of rapidly folding to the native state depends on the topology of tertiary domains.

Molecular recognition properties of IGS-mediated reactions catalyzed by a Pneumocystis carinii group I intron

We report the development, analysis and use of a new combinatorial approach to analyze the substrate sequence dependence of the suicide inhibition, cyclization, and reverse cyclization reactions catalyzed by a group I intron from the opportunistic pathogen Pneumocystis carinii. We demonstrate that the sequence specificity of these Internal Guide Sequence (IGS)-mediated reactions is not high. In addition, the sequence specificity of suicide inhibition decreases with increasing MgCl(2) concentration, reverse cyclization is substantially more sequence specific than suicide inhibition, and multiple reverse cyclization products occur, in part due to the formation of multiple cyclization intermediates. Thermodynamic analysis reveals that a base pair at position -4 of the resultant 5' exon-IGS (P1) helix is crucial for tertiary docking of the P1 helix into the catalytic core of the ribozyme in the suicide inhibition reaction. In contrast to results reported with a Tetrahymena ribozyme, altering the sequence of the IGS of the P.carinii ribozyme can result in a marked reduction in tertiary stability of docking the resultant P1 helix into the catalytic core of the ribozyme. Finally, results indicate that RNA targeting strategies which exploit tertiary interactions could have low specificity due to the tolerance of mismatched base pairs.

Tertiary interactions with the internal guide sequence mediate docking of the P1 helix into the catalytic core of the Tetrahymena ribozyme

The L-21 ScaI ribozyme catalyzes sequence-specific cleavage of an oligonucleotide substrate. Cleavage is preceded by base pairing of the substrate to the internal guide sequence (IGS) at the 5' end of the ribozyme to form a short RNA duplex (P1). Tertiary interactions between P1 and the catalytic core dock P1 into the active site of the ribozyme. These include interactions between the catalytic core and 2'-hydroxyls of the substrate at nucleotide positions -3u and perhaps -2c. In this study, 2'-hydroxyls of the IGS strand that contribute to P1 recognition by the ribozyme are identified. IGS 2'-hydroxyls (nucleotide positions 22-27) were individually modified to either 2'-deoxy or 2'-methoxynucleotides within full-length semisynthetic L-21 ScaI ribozymes generated using T4 DNA ligase. Thermodynamic and kinetic characterization of the resulting IGS variant ribozymes justify the following conclusions: (i) 2'-Hydroxyls at nucleotide positions G22 and G25 play a critical energetic role in docking P1 into the catalytic core, contributing 2.6 and 2.1 kcal.mol-1, respectively. (ii) The loss of binding energy is manifest primarily as an increase in the rate of dissociation. Because turnover for the wild-type ribozyme is limited by product dissociation, G22 and G25 deoxy variants display up to a 20-fold increase in the multiple-turnover rate at saturating substrate. (iii) IGS tertiary interactions are energetically coupled with the tertiary interactions made to the substrate, consistent with P1 becoming undocked from its binding site in J8/7 upon substitution of either the G22 or G25 2'-hydroxyl. (iv) The G22 deoxy variant loses energetic coupling between guanosine and substrate binding, suggesting that in this variant the P1 helix is also undocked from its binding site in J4/5, the proposed site of guanosine and substrate interaction. Therefore, in combinations with previous studies four P1 2'-hydroxyls are implicated as important for docking. The contributions of the 2'-hydroxyl tertiary interactions are not equivalent and follow the hierarchical order G22 > G25 >> -3u > -2c. Because the G22 2'-hydroxyl appears to mediate P1 docking into both J8/7 and J4/5, it may serve as the molecular linchpin for the recognition of P1 by the catalytic core.

A circular trans-acting hepatitis delta virus ribozyme

A circular trans-acting ribozyme designed to adopt the motif of the hepatitis delta virus (HDV) trans-acting ribozyme was produced. The circular form was generated in vitro by splicing a modified group I intron precursor RNA in which the relative order of the 5' and 3' splice sites, flanking the single HDV-like ribozyme sequence-containing exon, is reversed. Trans-cleavage activity of the circular HDV-like ribozyme was comparable to linear permutations of HDV ribozymes containing the same core sequence, and was shown not to be due to linear contaminants in the circular ribozyme preparation. In nuclear and cytoplasmic extracts from HeLa cells, the circular ribozyme had enhanced resistance to nuclease degradation relative to a linear form of the ribozyme, suggesting that circularization may be a viable alternative to chemical modification as a means of stabilizing ribozymes against nuclease degradation.

Lead cleavage sites in the core structure of group I intron-RNA

Self-splicing of group I introns requires divalent metal ions to promote catalysis as well as for the correct folding of the RNA. Lead cleavage has been used to probe the intron RNA for divalent metal ion binding sites. In the conserved core of the intron, only two sites of Pb2+ cleavage have been detected, which are located close to the substrate binding sites in the junction J8/7 and at the bulged nucleotide in the P7 stem. Both lead cleavages can be inhibited by high concentrations of Mg2+ and Mn2+ ions, suggesting that they displace Pb2+ ions from the binding sites. The RNA is protected from lead cleavage by 2'-deoxyGTP, a competitive inhibitor of splicing. The two major lead induced cleavages are both located in the conserved core of the intron and at phosphates, which had independently been demonstrated to interact with magnesium ions and to be essential for splicing. Thus, we suggest that the conditions required for lead cleavage occur mainly at those sites, where divalent ions bind that are functionally involved in catalysis. We propose lead cleavage analysis of functional RNA to be a useful tool for mapping functional magnesium ion binding sites.

Dynamics of ribozyme binding of substrate revealed by fluorescence-detected stopped-flow methods

Fluorescence-detected stopped-flow and equilibrium methods have been used to study the mechanism for binding of pyrene (pyr)-labeled RNA oligomer substrates to the ribozyme (catalytic RNA) from Tetrahymena thermophila. The fluorescence of these substrates increases up to 25-fold on binding to the ribozyme. Stopped-flow experiments provide evidence that pyr experiences at least three different microenvironments during the binding process. A minimal mechanism is presented in which substrate initially base pairs to ribozyme and subsequently forms tertiary contacts in an RNA folding step. All four microscopic rate constants are measured for ribozyme binding of pyrCCUCU.

Group I permuted intron-exon (PIE) sequences self-splice to produce circular exons

Circularly permuted group I intron precursor RNAs, containing end-to-end fused exons which interrupt half-intron sequences, were generated and tested for self-splicing activity. An autocatalytic RNA can form when the primary order of essential intron sequence elements, splice sites, and exons are permuted in this manner. Covalent attachment of guanosine to the 5' half-intron product, and accurate exon ligation indicated that the mechanism and specificity of splicing were not altered. However, because the exons were fused and the order of the splice sites reversed, splicing released the fused-exon as a circle. With this arrangement of splice sites, circular exon production was a prediction of the group I splicing mechanism. Circular RNAs have properties that would make them attractive for certain studies of RNA structure and function. Reversal of splice site sequences in a context that allows splicing, such as those generated by circularly permuted group I introns, could be used to generate short defined sequences of circular RNA in vitro and perhaps in vivo.

RNA substrate binding site in the catalytic core of the Tetrahymena ribozyme

In catalysis by group I introns, the helix (P1) containing the RNA cleavage site must be positioned next to the guanosine binding site. We have identified a conserved adenine in the catalytic core that contributes to the stability of this arrangement and propose that it accepts a hydrogen bond from a specific 2'-OH in P1. Such base-backbone tertiary interactions may be generally important to the organization of RNA tertiary structure.

Self-splicing of a mitochondrial group I intron from the cytochrome b gene of the ascomycete Podospora anserina

We have shown that the second intron of the Podospora mitochondrial gene coding for cytochrome b (Cytb 12) splices autocatalytically, using in vitro transcripts generated from the T7 promoter. The reaction takes place at 37 degrees C in the presence of 50 mM TRIS-HCl pH 7.5, 60 mM MgCl2 and 1 mM GTP but shows a low efficiency even at high KCl concentrations of up to 1.2 M. Under these conditions, intron bI2 follows the conventional pathway of group I splicing, and all characteristic products, with regard to both transesterification and hydrolysis, could be identified. Moreover, the intron is capable of undergoing cyclization, thereby releasing the noncoded G and one additional nucleotide (U) from the 5' end. The 5' cleavage site is preceded by the same two nucleotides, indicating a base-pairing at the same site of the internal guide sequence (IGS) for both splicing and cyclization ("one-binding-site model"). In addition, products resulting from site-specific hydrolysis 138 nucleotides downstream of the 5' splice site were detected. Unusually, the shortened intron is also able to form a circular RNA and an alternative sequence that aligns the cyclization site to the catalytic core of the intron must be assumed.

Circle reopening in the Tetrahymena ribozyme resembles site-specific hydrolysis at the 3' splice site

The Tetrahymena intron, after splicing from its flanking exons, can mediate its own circularization. This is followed by site-specific hydrolysis of the phosphodiester bond formed during the circularization reaction. The structural components involved in recognition of this bond for hydrolysis have not been established. We have made base substitutions to the P9.0 pairing and at the 3'-terminal guanosine residue (G414) of the intron to investigate their effects on circle formation and reopening. We have found that disruption of either P9.0 pairing or binding of the terminal nucleotide result in the formation of a large circle, C-413:5E23 from precursor RNA molecules that have undergone hydrolysis at the 3' splice site. This circle is formed at the phosphodiester bond of the 5'-terminal guanosine residue of the upstream exon via nucleophilic attack by the 3'-terminal nucleotide of the intron. The large circle is novel since it can reopen eight bases downstream from the original circularization junction at a site resembling the normal 3' splice site, restoring a guanosine to the 3' terminus and re-establishing P9.0 pairing. The new 3' terminus of the intron is capable of recircularization at any of the three normal wild-type sites. We conclude that both P9.0 and the 3'-terminal guanosine residue are required for the selection of the phosphodiester bond hydrolysed during circle reopening.

Comparison of binding of mixed ribose-deoxyribose analogues of CUCU to a ribozyme and to GGAGAA by equilibrium dialysis: evidence for ribozyme specific interactions with 2' OH groups

Dissociation constants at 15 degrees C were measured by equilibrium dialysis for the binding of rCrUrCrU, dCrUrCrU, rCdUrCrU, rCrUdCrU, and rCrUrCdU to the L-21 ScaI form of the self-splicing group I LSU intron from Tetrahymena thermophila. Substitution of deoxyribose for ribose in each of the middle two positions makes the free energy change for binding 1-2 kcal/mol less favorable, compared to about 0.3 kcal/mol less favorable for each of the terminal positions. Dissociation constants for binding of the same oligomers to rGGAGAA were measured by optical melting methods. Substitution of a single deoxyribose for ribose makes the free energy change for binding less favorable by 0.4-0.9 kcal/mol for this simple duplex formation. Comparison of the effects for binding to ribozyme and to rGGAGAA indicate that ribozyme-specific tertiary interactions dependent on the middle two 2' OH groups of rCrUrCrU add about 2 kcal/mol of favorable free energy for binding to L-21 ScaI. Comparisons are made with results from gel retardation studies [Pyle, A. M., McSwiggen, J. A., & Cech, T. R. (1990) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 87, 8187-8191; Pyle, A. M., & Cech, T. R. (1991) Nature (London) 350, 628-631].

Direct measurement of oligonucleotide substrate binding to wild-type and mutant ribozymes from Tetrahymena

Like protein enzymes, RNA enzymes (ribozymes) provide specific binding sites for their substrates. We now show that equilibrium dissociation constants for complexes between the Tetrahymena ribozyme and its RNA substrates and products can be directly measured by electrophoresis in polyacrylamide gels containing divalent cations. Binding is 10(3)- to 10(4)-fold tighter (4-5 kcal/mol at 42 degrees C) than expected from base-pairing interactions alone, implying that tertiary interactions also contribute to energetic stabilization. Binding decreases with single base changes in the substrate, substitution of deoxyribose sugars, and lower Mg2+ concentration. Ca2+, which enables the ribozyme to fold but is unable to mediate efficient RNA cleavage, promotes weaker substrate binding than Mg2+. This indicates that Mg2+ has special roles in both substrate binding and catalysis. Mutagenesis of a region near the internal guide sequence disrupts substrate binding, whereas binding is not significantly affected by a mutation of the guanosine-binding site. This approach should be generally useful for analysis of ribozyme variants independent of their catalytic activities.

Nobel lecture. Self-splicing and enzymatic activity of an intervening sequence RNA from Tetrahymena

A living cell requires thousands of different chemical reactions to utilize energy, move, grow, respond to external stimuli and reproduce itself. While these reactions take place spontaneously, they rarely proceed at a rate fast enough for life. Enzymes, biological catalysts found in all cells, greatly accelerate the rates of these chemical reactions and impart on them extraordinary specificity. In 1926, James B. Summer crystallized the enzyme urease and found that it was a protein. Skeptics argued that the enzymatic activity might reside in a trace component of the preparation rather than in the protein (Haldane, 1930), and it took another decade for the generality of Summer's finding to be established. As more and more examples of protein enzymes were found, it began to appear that biological catalysis would be exclusively the realm of proteins. In 1981 and 1982, my research group and I found a case in which RNA, a form of genetic material, was able to cleave and rejoin its own nucleotide linkages. This self-splicing RNA provided the first example of a catalytic active site formed of ribonucleic acid. This lecture gives a personal view of the events that led to our realization of RNA self-splicing and the catalytic potential of RNA. It provides yet another illustration of the circuitous path by which scientific inquiry often proceeds. The decision to expand so many words describing the early experiments means that much of our current knowledge about the system will not be mentioned. For a more comprehensive view of the mechanism and structure of the Tetrahymena self-splicing RNA and RNA catalysis in general, the reader is directed to a number of recent reviews (Cech & Bass, 1986: Cech, 1987, 1988a, 1990; Burke, 1988; Altman, 1989). Possible medical and pharmaceutical implications of RNA catalysis have also been described recently (Cech, 1988b).

The conserved U.G pair in the 5' splice site duplex of a group I intron is required in the first but not the second step of self-splicing

Group I self-splicing introns have a 5' splice site duplex (P1) that contains a single conserved base pair (U.G). The U is the last nucleotide of the 5' exon, and the G is part of the internal guide sequence within the intron. Using site-specific mutagenesis and analysis of the rate and accuracy of splicing of the Tetrahymena thermophila group I intron, we found that both the U and the G of the U.G pair are important for the first step of self-splicing (attack of GTP at the 5' splice site). Mutation of the U to a purine activated cryptic 5' splice sites in which a U.G pair was restored; this result emphasizes the preference for a U.G at the splice site. Nevertheless, some splicing persisted at the normal site after introduction of a purine, suggesting that position within the P1 helix is another determinant of 5' splice site choice. When the U was changed to a C, the accuracy of splicing was not affected, but the Km for GTP was increased by a factor of 15 and the catalytic rate constant was decreased by a factor of 7. Substitution of U.A, U.U, G.G, or A.G for the conserved U.G decreased the rate of splicing by an even greater amount. In contrast, mutation of the conserved G enhanced the second step of splicing, as evidenced by a trans-splicing assay. Furthermore, a free 5' exon ending in A or C instead of the conserved U underwent efficient ligation. Thus, unlike the remainder of the P1 helix, which functions in both the first and second steps of self-splicing, the conserved U.G appears to be important only for the first step.

The conserved U.G pair in the 5' splice site duplex of a group I intron is required in the first but not the second step of self-splicing

Group I self-splicing introns have a 5' splice site duplex (P1) that contains a single conserved base pair (U.G). The U is the last nucleotide of the 5' exon, and the G is part of the internal guide sequence within the intron. Using site-specific mutagenesis and analysis of the rate and accuracy of splicing of the Tetrahymena thermophila group I intron, we found that both the U and the G of the U.G pair are important for the first step of self-splicing (attack of GTP at the 5' splice site). Mutation of the U to a purine activated cryptic 5' splice sites in which a U.G pair was restored; this result emphasizes the preference for a U.G at the splice site. Nevertheless, some splicing persisted at the normal site after introduction of a purine, suggesting that position within the P1 helix is another determinant of 5' splice site choice. When the U was changed to a C, the accuracy of splicing was not affected, but the Km for GTP was increased by a factor of 15 and the catalytic rate constant was decreased by a factor of 7. Substitution of U.A, U.U, G.G, or A.G for the conserved U.G decreased the rate of splicing by an even greater amount. In contrast, mutation of the conserved G enhanced the second step of splicing, as evidenced by a trans-splicing assay. Furthermore, a free 5' exon ending in A or C instead of the conserved U underwent efficient ligation. Thus, unlike the remainder of the P1 helix, which functions in both the first and second steps of self-splicing, the conserved U.G appears to be important only for the first step.

Reverse self-splicing of the tetrahymena group I intron: implication for the directionality of splicing and for intron transposition

Using short oligoribonucleotides as ligated exon substrates, we show that splicing of the Tetrahymena rRNA group I intron is fully reversible in vitro. Incubation of ligated exon RNA with linear intron produces a molecule in which the splice site sequences of the precursor are reformed. Reversal of self-splicing is favored by high RNA concentration, high magnesium and temperature, and the absence of guanosine. 5' exon sequences that can pair with the internal guide sequence of the intron are required, whereas 3' exon sequences are not essential. Integration of the intron into ligated exon substrates that have the ability to form stem-loop structures is reduced at least one order of magnitude over short, unstructured substrates. We propose that the formation of these structures helps drive splicing in the forward direction. We also show that the Tetrahymena intron can integrate into a beta-globin transcript. This has implications for transposition of group I introns.

Reversible cleavage and ligation of hepatitis delta virus RNA

A 148-nucleotide subfragment of hepatitis delta virus RNA was shown to undergo cleavage and ligation reversibly. The direction of the reaction is determined by the presence or absence of Mg2+ ions, with the presence of Mg2+ favoring the cleavage reaction. Ligation requires specific conformation of the RNA molecules involved and occurs only between two cleaved RNA fragments that are still held together by hydrogen bonds. The ligation reaction occurs rapidly on removal of Mg2+ by EDTA. This represents a new class of RNA enzymes.

Effects of substrate structure on the kinetics of circle opening reactions of the self-splicing intervening sequence from Tetrahymena thermophila: evidence for substrate and Mg2+ binding interactions

The self-splicing intervening sequence from the precursor rRNA of Tetrahymena thermophila cyclizes to form a covalently closed circle. This circle can be reopened by reaction with oligonucleotides or water. The kinetics of circle opening as a function of substrate and Mg2+ concentrations have been measured for dCrU, rCdU, dCdT, and H2O addition. Comparisons with previous results for rCrU suggest: (1) the 2' OH of the 5' sugar of a dinucleoside phosphate is involved in substrate binding, and (2) the 2' OH of the 3' sugar of a dimer substrate is involved in Mg2+ binding. Evidently, the binding site for a required Mg2+ ion is dependent on both the ribozyme and the dimer substrate. The apparent activation energy and entropy for circle opening by hydrolysis are 31 kcal/mol and 50 eu, respectively. The large, positive activation entropy suggests a partial unfolding of the ribozyme is required for reaction.

Autocatalytic activities of intron 5 of the cob gene of yeast mitochondria

The terminal intron of the mitochondrial cob gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae can undergo autocatalytic splicing in vitro. Efficient splicing of this intron required a high concentration of monovalent ion (1 M). We found that at a high salt concentration this intron was very active and performed many of the reactions described for other group I introns. The rate of the splicing reaction was dependent on the choice of the monovalent ion; the reaction intermediate, the intron-3' exon molecule, accumulated in NH4Cl but not in KCl. In addition, the intron was more reactive in KCl, accumulating in two different circular forms: one cyclized at the 5' intron boundary and the other at 236 nucleotides from the 5' end. These circular forms were able to undergo the opening and recyclization reactions previously described for the Tetrahymena rRNA intron. Cleavage of the 5' exon-intron boundary by the addition of GTP did not require the 3' terminus of the intron and the downstream exon. An anomalous guanosine addition at the 3' exon and at the middle of the intron was also detected. Hence, this intron, which requires a functional protein to splice in vivo, demonstrated a full spectrum of characteristic reactions in the absence of proteins.

Kinetics for reaction of a circularized intervening sequence with CU, UCU, CUCU, and CUCUCU: mechanistic implications from the dependence on temperature and on oligomer and Mg2+ concentrations

The self-splicing intervening sequence from the rRNA precursor in Tetrahymena thermophila produces a covalently closed, circularized form (C IVS). Reaction rates for reverse cyclization (linearization) of C IVS by the covalent addition of the oligoncleotides CU, UCU, CUCU, and CUCUCU have been measured. The dependence of the observed rates on oligomer and Mg2+ concentrations indicates the presence of intermediates that are generated by separate binding steps for both oligomer and Mg2+. Linearization of C IVS by OH- hydrolysis is suppressed in the presence of oligomer, suggesting oligomer binds near the active site. The binding constants derived for CU at 30 degrees C in 1 and 10 mM Mg2+ are 5 X 10(3) and 2.5 X 10(4) M-1, respectively. These are roughly 4 orders of magnitude larger than expected for simple Watson-Crick base pairing. The binding constants derived for UCU, CUCU, and CUCUCU at 30 degrees C in 10 mM Mg2+ are 1.2 X 10(5), 4 X 10(5), and greater than 10(7) M-1, respectively. The free energy increments for binding of UCU and CUCU relative to CU are similar to those expected from a nearest-neighbor model for addition of base pairs. This indicates the factors responsible for the unusually strong binding of CU to C IVS are restricted to two nucleotides.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Autocatalytic activities of intron 5 of the cob gene of yeast mitochondria

The terminal intron of the mitochondrial cob gene of Saccharomyces cerevisiae can undergo autocatalytic splicing in vitro. Efficient splicing of this intron required a high concentration of monovalent ion (1 M). We found that at a high salt concentration this intron was very active and performed many of the reactions described for other group I introns. The rate of the splicing reaction was dependent on the choice of the monovalent ion; the reaction intermediate, the intron-3' exon molecule, accumulated in NH4Cl but not in KCl. In addition, the intron was more reactive in KCl, accumulating in two different circular forms: one cyclized at the 5' intron boundary and the other at 236 nucleotides from the 5' end. These circular forms were able to undergo the opening and recyclization reactions previously described for the Tetrahymena rRNA intron. Cleavage of the 5' exon-intron boundary by the addition of GTP did not require the 3' terminus of the intron and the downstream exon. An anomalous guanosine addition at the 3' exon and at the middle of the intron was also detected. Hence, this intron, which requires a functional protein to splice in vivo, demonstrated a full spectrum of characteristic reactions in the absence of proteins.

Structure of the catalytic core of the Tetrahymena ribozyme as indicated by reactive abbreviated forms of the molecule

The precursor rRNA of Tetrahymena thermophila contains a group I intervening sequence (IVS) that catalyzes its own excision to yield mature rRNA. The excised IVS catalyzes a number of cleavage/ligation reactions that are analogous to the transesterification reactions of splicing. We examined the behavior of a variety of 3'-truncated forms of the IVS and found several abbreviated molecules that retained catalytic activity. The reactivity of these molecules indicates that the site at which cleavage/ligation occurs lies in close proximity to all of the conserved sequence elements within the catalytic core of the IVS.

Selection of circularization sites in a group I IVS RNA requires multiple alignments of an internal template-like sequence

Circularization and reverse circularization of the Tetrahymena thermophila rRNA intervening sequence resemble the first and second steps in splicing, respectively. However, site-specific base substitutions show that different nucleotides are involved in selection of the 5' splice site and the circularization sites. Furthermore, a substitution at the major circularization site that prevents circularization can be suppressed by second substitutions at two different nucleotide positions. A model is proposed in which adjacent and overlapping sequences can function as a binding site, forming a short duplex with the sequence at the circularization site and thus directing circularization and reverse circularization. Because the 5' exon-binding site and three potential circularization binding sites fall within a contiguous eight nucleotide region, this sequence may translocate relative to the catalytic core of the ribozyme in a template-like manner.

5' exon requirement for self-splicing of the Tetrahymena thermophila pre-ribosomal RNA and identification of a cryptic 5' splice site in the 3' exon

The intervening sequence (IVS) of the Tetrahymena thermophila ribosomal RNA precursor undergoes accurate self-splicing in vitro. The work presented here examines the requirement for Tetrahymena rRNA sequences in the 5' exon for the accuracy and efficiency of splicing. Three plasmids were constructed with nine, four and two nucleotides of the natural 5' exon sequence, followed by the IVS and 26 nucleotides of the Tetrahymena 3' exon. RNA was transcribed from these plasmids in vitro and tested for self-splicing activity. The efficiency of splicing, as measured by the production of ligated exons, is reduced as the natural 5' exon sequence is replaced with plasmid sequences. Accurate splicing persists even when only four nucleotides of the natural 5' exon sequence remain. When only two nucleotides of the natural exon remain, no ligated exons are observed. As the efficiency of the normal reaction diminishes, novel RNA species are produced in increasing amounts. The novel RNA species were examined and found to be products of aberrant reactions of the precursor RNA. Two of these aberrant reactions involve auto-addition of GTP to sites six nucleotides and 52 nucleotides downstream from the 3' splice site. The former site occurs just after the sequence GGU, and may indicate the existence of a GGU-binding site within the IVS RNA. The latter site follows the sequence CUCU, which is identical with the four nucleotides preceding the 5' splice site. This observation led to a model where where the CUCU sequence in the 3' exon acts as a cryptic 5' splice site. The model predicted the existence of a circular RNA containing the first 52 nucleotides of the 3' exon. A small circular RNA was isolated and partially sequenced and found to support the model. So, a cryptic 5' splice site can function even if it is located downstream from the 3' splice site. Precursor RNA labeled at its 5' end, presumably by a GTP exchange reaction mediated by the IVS, is also described.

The chemistry of self-splicing RNA and RNA enzymes

Proteins are not the only catalysts of cellular reactions; there is a growing list of RNA molecules that catalyze RNA cleavage and joining reactions. The chemical mechanisms of RNA-catalyzed reactions are discussed with emphasis on the self-splicing ribosomal RNA precursor of Tetrahymena and the enzymatic activities of its intervening sequence RNA. Wherever appropriate, catalysis by RNA is compared to catalysis by protein enzymes.

Reactivity of modified ribose moieties of guanosine: new cleavage reactions mediated by the IVS of Tetrahymena precursor rRNA

An RNA molecule consisting of the 5' exon and intervening sequence (IVS) of Tetrahymena precursor rRNA was oxidized with sodium periodate to convert the ribose moiety of the 3' terminal guanosine into a dialdehyde form. The modified RNA undergoes a specific cleavage reaction at the 5' splice site, but has no apparent cyclization activity. This novel reaction mediated by the IVS RNA is pH dependent over the range 6.5-8.5 and leaves a 5' phosphate and a 3'-OH at the newly created termini. The dialdehyde form of monomer guanosine is also capable of causing a specific cleavage reaction at the 5' splice site although the nucleotide is not covalently attached to the IVS RNA in the final product. These and other findings described in this report suggest that the cis diol of the intact ribose moiety of guanosine is not an absolute requirement for the IVS-mediated reactions.

Two domains for splicing in the intron of the phage T4 thymidylate synthase (td) gene established by nondirected mutagenesis

Of 97 nondirected T4 thymidylate synthase-defective (td) mutations, 27 were mapped to the intron of the split td gene. Clustering of these intron mutations defined two domains that are functional in splicing, each within approximately 220 residues of the respective splice sites. Two selected mutations, tdN57 and tdN47, fell within phylogenetically conserved pairings, with tdN57 disrupting the exon I-internal guide pairing (P1) in the 5' domain and tdN47 destabilizing the P9 helix in the 3' domain. A splicing assay with synthetic oligonucleotides complementary to RNA junction sequences revealed processing defects for T4tdN57 and T4tdN47, both of which are impaired in cleavage at the 5' and 3' splice sites. Thus prokaryotic genetics facilitates association of specific residue changes with their consequences to splicing.

Efficient trans-splicing of a yeast mitochondrial RNA group II intron implicates a strong 5' exon-intron interaction

The reaction mechanism for self-splicing introns requires the existence of a 5' exon binding site on the intron. Experimental evidence is now presented consistent with the existence of such a binding site by demonstrating efficient and accurate trans-self-splicing of a yeast mitochondrial group II intron. Partial and complete trans-splicing reactions take place in the absence of branch formation, part of the usual pathway of nuclear splicing and group II self-splicing. In addition to indicating the existence of a 5' exon binding site on the intron, the results have mechanistic implications for group II self-splicing and perhaps for nuclear splicing as well.

One binding site determines sequence specificity of Tetrahymena pre-rRNA self-splicing, trans-splicing, and RNA enzyme activity

The specificity of reactions catalyzed by the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA intervening sequence (IVS) was studied using site-specific mutagenesis. Two sequences required for 5' splice-site selection during self-splicing were defined. Single-base changes in either a 5' exon sequence or a 5' exon-binding site within the IVS disrupt their ability to pair and result in inefficient or inaccurate splicing. Combinations that restore complementarity suppress the effect of the single-base changes. Sequence alterations in the 5' exon-binding site also change the specificity of two other reactions: intermolecular exon ligation (trans-splicing) and the enzymatic nucleotidyltransferase activity of the IVS RNA. Thus the substrate specificity of an RNA enzyme can be changed in a manner predictable by the rules of Watson-Crick base-pairing.

Processing of phage T4 td-encoded RNA is analogous to the eukaryotic group I splicing pathway

Several features of the split td gene of phage T4 suggest an RNA processing mechanism analogous to that of the self-splicing rRNA of Tetrahymena and other group I eukaryotic introns. Previous work has revealed conserved sequence elements and the ability of td-encoded RNA to self-splice in vitro. We show here that a noncoded guanosine residue is covalently joined to the 5' end of the intron during processing. Further, we demonstrate the existence of linear and circular intron forms in RNA extracted from T4-infected cells and from uninfected Escherichia coli expressing the cloned td gene. Sequence analysis of the intron cyclization junction indicates that the noncoded guanosine and one additional nucleotide are lost from the 5' end of the intron upon cyclization. This analysis places a uridine residue upstream of the cyclization site, in analogy to three other group I cyclization junctions. These striking similarities to the splicing intermediates of eukaryotic group I introns point not only to an analogous processing pathway and conserved features of cyclization site recognition but also to a common ancestry between this prokaryotic intervening sequence and the group I eukaryotic introns.

Mechanism of recognition of the 5' splice site in self-splicing group I introns

Group I introns include many mitochondrial ribosomal RNA and messenger RNA introns and the nuclear rRNA introns of Tetrahymena and Physarum. The splicing of precursor RNAs containing these introns is a two-step reaction. Cleavage at the 5' splice site precedes cleavage at the 3' splice site, the latter cleavage being coupled with exon ligation. Following the first cleavage, the 5' exon must somehow be held in place for ligation. We have now tested the reactivity of two self-splicing group I RNAs, the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA and the intron 1 portion of the Neurospora mitochondrial cytochrome b (cob) pre-mRNA, in the intermolecular exon ligation reaction (splicing in trans) described by Inoue et al. The different sequence specificity of the reactions supports the idea that the nucleotides immediately upstream from the 5' splice site are base-paired to an internal, 5' exon-binding site, in agreement with RNA structure models proposed by Davies and co-workers and others. The internal binding site is proposed to be involved in the formation of a structure that specifies the 5' splice site and, following the first step of splicing, to hold the 5' exon in place for exon ligation.

A model for the RNA-catalyzed replication of RNA

A shortened form of the self-splicing ribosomal RNA intervening sequence of Tetrahymena thermophila has enzymatic activity as a poly(cytidylic acid) polymerase [Zaug, A.J. & Cech, T.R. (1986) Science 231, 470-475]. Based on the known properties of this enzyme, a detailed model is developed for the template-dependent synthesis of RNA by an RNA polymerase itself made of RNA. The monomer units for RNA synthesis are tetra- and pentanucleotides of random base sequence. Polymerization occurs in a 5'-to-3' direction, and elongation rates are expected to approach two residues per minute. If the RNA enzyme could use another copy of itself as a template, RNA self-replication could be achieved. Thus, it seems possible that RNA catalysts might have played a part in prebiotic nucleic acid replication, prior to the availability of useful proteins.

New reactions of the ribosomal RNA precursor of Tetrahymena and the mechanism of self-splicing

The availability of Tetrahymena pre-rRNA of discrete size, produced by transcription of recombinant plasmids with bacteriophage SP6 RNA polymerase, has permitted a more detailed investigation of the self-splicing reaction. The predicted splicing intermediate, the product of cleavage by guanosine at the 5' splice site, was identified. This intermediate was tested in the intermolecular exon ligation reaction and found to be competent to undergo the second step of splicing. These results and others that evaluated the reactivity of the 5' and 3' splice sites independently show that splicing occurs in two separable steps. The 3' splice site was found to be susceptible to site-specific hydrolysis leaving a hydroxyl terminus. This is interpreted as an indication that the 3' splice site is activated for nucleophilic attack in general and for exon ligation in particular. Preliminary evidence for specific hydrolysis at the 5' splice site was also obtained. All of the newly characterized intervening sequence RNA-mediated reactions as well as those found previously are divided into three categories: transesterification by guanosine at sites following two or three pyrimidine nucleotides (and, as a minor reaction, at sites following other guanosine residues); transesterification by oligopyrimidines or by the 5' exon (which terminates with C-U-C-U-C-UOH) at the site following the 3'-terminal guanosine residue of the intervening sequence; and specific hydrolysis at the splice sites. One of the products of the reactions at the 3' splice site is a molecule that contains the 5' exon still attached to the intervening sequence. It has a 3'-terminal GOH and undergoes cyclization both at the normal cyclization site within the intervening sequence and at the 5' splice site. The finding that the splice site can act as a cyclization site, combined with the earlier observation that the normal cyclization site is subject to attack by guanosine mononucleotide, leads us to propose that all these reactions may be occurring in the same active site. Translocation (a conformational change) would then bring different oligopyrimidine sequences into the active site for attack by guanosine. On the basis of the experimental results, a model for the local structure at the active site is described. A key feature of the model is the interaction between the U at the end of the oligopyrimidine sequence, a G residue within the internal guide sequence in the intervening sequence, and another G residue that can be either the attacking group for transesterification or the 3'-terminal G of the intervening sequence.

The intervening sequence RNA of Tetrahymena is an enzyme

A shortened form of the self-splicing ribosomal RNA (rRNA) intervening sequence of Tetrahymena thermophila acts as an enzyme in vitro. The enzyme catalyzes the cleavage and rejoining of oligonucleotide substrates in a sequence-dependent manner with Km = 42 microM and kcat = 2 min-1. The reaction mechanism resembles that of rRNA precursor self-splicing. With pentacytidylic acid as the substrate, successive cleavage and rejoining reactions lead to the synthesis of polycytidylic acid. Thus, the RNA molecule can act as an RNA polymerase, differing from the protein enzyme in that it uses an internal rather than an external template. At pH 9, the same RNA enzyme has activity as a sequence-specific ribonuclease.

Sites of circularization of the Tetrahymena rRNA IVS are determined by sequence and influenced by position and secondary structure

The sequence of the cloned Tetrahymena ribosomal RNA intervening sequence (IVS) was altered at the site to which circularization normally occurs. The alterations caused circularization to shift to other sites, usually a nearby position which followed three pyrimidines. While a tripyrimidine sequence was the major determinant of a circularization site, both location of a sequence and local secondary structure may influence the use of that sequence. For some constructs circularization appeared to occur at the position following the 5' G, the nucleotide added to the IVS during its excision. Portions of the internal guide sequence (IGS), proposed to interact with the 3'exon were deleted without preventing exon ligation. Thus if the IGS-3'exon interaction exists, it is not essential for splicing in vitro.

Intermolecular exon ligation of the rRNA precursor of Tetrahymena: oligonucleotides can function as 5' exons

The dinucleotide CpUOH, when incubated with self-splicing Tetrahymena pre-rRNA in the absence of GTP, functions as a 5' exon. It cleaves the precursor exactly at the 3' splice site and becomes covalently ligated to the 3' exon. Other oligonucleotides with sequences that resemble CUCUCU, the sequence at the 3' end of the 5' exon, can add to the 3' exon in this reaction. Such splicing in trans is most readily explained by a site within the intervening sequence that binds the last few nucleotides of the 5' exon. This binding site functions in splice site recognition and is also part of the active site of the ribozyme. The mechanism by which 5' splice sites are selected in Tetrahymena rRNA and group I mitochondrial RNA splicing is like that used in nuclear mRNA splicing, in that it involves specific pairing of bases adjacent to the splice site with a complementary RNA sequence.

Self-catalyzed cyclization of the intervening sequence RNA of Tetrahymena: inhibition by intercalating dyes

The intervening sequence (IVS) excised from the pre-rRNA of Tetrahymena undergoes a self-catalyzed cleavage-ligation reaction to form a covalently closed circular RNA. This cyclization reaction is kinetically inhibited by ethidium bromide (50% inhibition at 22 +/- 14 microM, greater than 99% inhibition at 53 +/- 16 microM for a 20 minute reaction). The dye does not alter the sites of the cyclization reaction, but it does increase the relative amount of reaction at a minor site 19 nucleotides from the 5' end of the IVS. The reversibility of the inhibition and the relative inhibitory strength of acridine orange, ethidium and proflavine suggest that inhibition is due to intercalation of the dye in functionally important secondary or tertiary structures of the IVS. The concentration of dye required to inhibit cyclization is much higher than expected from the known binding constants of such dyes to tRNA. At high Mg2+ to Na+ ratios, conditions which should stabilize RNA structure, a subpopulation of the IVS RNA molecules is resistant to ethidium inhibition, even at 200 microM ethidium. These data are interpreted as reflecting two conformational isomers of the IVS that differ in their reactivity and in their sensitivity to dye binding.

Reactions of the intervening sequence of the Tetrahymena ribosomal ribonucleic acid precursor: pH dependence of cyclization and site-specific hydrolysis

During self-splicing of the Tetrahymena rRNA precursor, the intervening sequence (IVS) is excised as a unique linear molecule and subsequently cyclized. Cyclization involves formation of a phosphodiester bond between the 3' end and nucleotide 16 of the linear RNA, with release of an oligonucleotide containing the first 15 nucleotides. We find that the rate of cyclization is independent of pH in the range 4.7-9.0. A minor site of cyclization at nucleotide 20 is characterized. Cyclization to this site becomes more prominent at higher pHs, although under all conditions examined it is minor compared to cyclization at nucleotide 16. The circular IVS RNAs are unstable, undergoing hydrolysis at the phosphodiester bond that was formed during cyclization. We find that the rate of site-specific hydrolysis is first order with respect to hydroxide ion concentration, with a rate constant 10(3)-10(4)-fold greater than that of hydrolysis of strained cyclic phosphate esters. On the basis of these results, we propose that circular IVS RNA hydrolysis involves direct attack of OH- on the phosphate at the ligation junction, that particular phosphate being made particularly reactive by the folding of the RNA molecule. Cyclization, on the other hand, appears to occur by direct attack of the 3'-terminal hydroxyl group of the linear IVS RNA without prior deprotonation.

Oligomerization of intervening sequence RNA molecules in the absence of proteins

The intervening sequence RNA excised from the ribosomal RNA precursor of Tetrahymena forms linear and circular oligomers when exposed to a heating-cooling treatment in vitro. The reactions require no protein or external energy source. Oligomerization is different from other self-catalyzed reactions of the intervening sequence RNA in that it involves intermolecular rather than intramolecular recombination, producing RNA molecules that are substantially larger than the original. The observation that RNA molecules can catalyze their own oligomerization has possible implications for the evolution of chromosomes and for the replicative cycle of plant viroids and virus-associated RNA's.

RNA catalysis and the origin of life

Until the discovery of catalytic RNAs, first the self-splicing intron in Tetrahymena and then the bacterial RNAse P, cellular enzymes had always seemed to be protein in nature. The recognition that RNA can catalytically make and break phosphodiester bonds simplifies some of the assumptions required of a rudimentary self-replicating entity. Available information on the chemistry of RNA-catalyzed reactions is reviewed, with particular attention to self-splicing introns and tRNA processing by RNase P. An explicit model for a self-replicating RNA is described. The model postulates a nucleotide binding/polymerization site in the RNA, and takes advantage of intrinsic fluidity in RNA higher order structure to dissociate parent and progeny complementary strands.