Quality control in the in vitro fertilization laboratory

Forty years of embryo transfer in cattle: a review focusing on the journal Theriogenology, the growth of the industry in North America, and personal reminisces

After the first successful transfer of mammalian embryos in 1890, it was approximately 60 years before significant progress was reported in the basic technology of embryo transfer (ET) in cattle. Starting in the early 1970s, technology had progressed sufficiently to support the founding of commercial ET programs in several countries. Today, well-established and reliable techniques involving superovulation, embryo recovery and transfer, cryopreservation, and IVF are utilized worldwide in hundreds, if not thousands, of commercial businesses located in many countries. The mean number of embryos produced via superovulation has changed little in 40 years, but there have been improvements in synchrony and hormonal protocols. Cryopreservation of in vivo-derived embryos is a reliable procedure, but improvements are needed for biopsied and in vitro-derived embryos. High pregnancy rates are achieved when good quality embryos are transferred into suitable recipients and low pregnancy rates are often owing to problems in recipient management and not technology per se. In the future, unanticipated disease outbreaks and the ever-changing economics of cattle and milk prices will continue to influence the ET industry. The issue of abnormal pregnancies involving in vitro embryos has not been satisfactorily resolved and the involvement of abnormal epigenetics associate with this technology merits continued research. Last, genomic testing of bovine embryos is likely to be available in the foreseeable future. This may markedly decrease the number of embryos that are actually transferred and stimulate the evolution of more sophisticated ET businesses.

Transporte de oócitos bovinos em meio de maturação por diferentes períodos de tempo sem controle da atmosfera gasosa

Avaliou-se a viabilidade do transporte de oócitos em meio quimicamente definido, e analisou-se a necessidade da adição ou não de hormônios neste meio. Os oócitos do grupo-controle (0h) foram maturados por 24h em estufa de CO2, e os dos grupos experimentais foram transportados em incubadora portátil. No experimento I, as taxas de clivagem foram similares (P>0,05) para os grupos 0h (59,7%), 3h (53,5%) e 9h (48,8%), e houve redução nos grupos 6h (46,1%) e 12h (43,8%). Essas taxas foram semelhantes entre os grupos 3h, 6h, 9h e 12h. A produção de blastocistos não foi diferente (P>0,05) para os grupos 0h (38,0%), 3h (32,3%), 6h (27,3%) e 9h (24,8%), e houve redução no grupo 12h (18,9%). Essas taxas foram semelhantes entre os grupos 6h, 9h e 12h. No experimento II, não houve diferença (P>0,05) entre as taxas de clivagem para os grupos 0h (71,4%), 3h (70,3%), 6h (56,0%) com hormônios, e os grupos 3h (64,8%) e 6h (54,1%) sem hormônios. A produção de blastocistos foi similar (P>0,05) para os grupos 0h (46,1%), 3h com hormônios (45,8%) e 3h sem hormônios (41,1%), porém houve redução nos grupos 6h com hormônios (35,5%) e 6h sem hormônios (33,5%). Essas taxas foram semelhantes entre os grupos 3h sem hormônios e 6h com e sem hormônios. Estes resultados indicam que é possível otransporte de oócitos bovinos por um período de até nove horas, e que a adição de hormônios neste meio não influencia os índices de clivagem e de blastocistos

Quality Management Issues in the Assisted Reproduction Laboratory

In the United States, the Clinical Laboratory Improvement Act (CLIA) of 1988 describes requirements and guidelines for implementing a quality control/quality assurance (QC/QA) program for moderate and high complexity laboratories. These requirements and guidelines apply to Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) laboratories as well. The general topic of QC and QA as it pertains to in vitro fertilization (IVF) and embryo transfer (ET) is extensively reviewed. This review summarizes many of the QC and QA events that contribute to the advancement of knowledge in this biotechnological field. These events include control of the culture environment inside and outside of the incubator, as well as factors that affect culture media. This review also discusses, in considerable detail, the QC and the QA that pertain to equipment used within the laboratory and how to control for potential contaminants, which reside within the laboratory. This review provides evidence to indicate the need for laboratory personnel to monitor quality improvement issues on a continuous basis. Personnel must be willing to change as improvements in technology occur in order to meet the ever-evolving demands of a more difficult patient population. Suggestions for meeting these demands are offered.

Transvaginal ovum pick-up (OPU) in the cow: a new disposable needle guidance system

A study was conducted to modify the routinely used ovum pick up (OPU) devices to permit use of disposable needles and to simplify the technique and to make it more economical and practical to use. Long nondisposable needles are commonly used in transvaginal OPU despite several disadvantages. A new OPU device was developed using 19-g disposable needles to eliminate these disadvantages and to make the technique more successful. The disposable needle was connected to silicone tubing by means of a stainless steel connector. The system was inserted into a stainless steel tube, creating a rigid structure within which to move the needle back and forth. A blunt needle can be changed simply by replacing it with a new one, even while the device is in the vagina of a cow. The needle guidance system is incorporated into a new OPU device together with the transducer of an ultrasonographic scanner with an unilateral orientated scanning field, making it possible to utilize the needle length to its maximum. This combination permits easy manipulation of the ovaries, easy positioning of follicles on the puncture line, and enables the use of shorter needles which directly enter the scanned area without loss of useful needle length. As a preliminary result we obtained an overall oocyte recovery rate of 42%. Although this is promising, additional puncture sessions are needed to establish more consistent recovery rates. When OPU is used routinely, application of short disposable needles is more practical and economical.

Effects of volume, culture media and type of culture dish on in vitro development of hamster 1-cell embryos

We examined effects of medium volume and two different culture media (HECM-3 and HECM-4) on in vitro development of hamster embryos. Groups of 5 to 8 1-cell embryos were cultured for 72 h in either < or =100 or > or =100 microl volumes. In the first experiment, embryos were cultured in Petri dishes with 2, 5, 20, 50 or 100 microl of medium using the two media (2 x 5 factorial experiment). Optimal volumes for morula and blastocyst development were 100 microl of HECM-3 and > or =50 microl of HECM-4; in HECM-4, > or =20 microl volumes were suitable whereas in HECM-3 < or = 50 microl volumes were unsuitable. In the second experiment, embryos were cultured in 100, 200, 500 and 1000 microl of HECM-3 and HECM-4 using organ culture dishes. Controls were 100 microl drops in Petri dishes. In organ culture dishes, blastocyst development was < or =6% in HECM-3 and 33-41% in HECM-4, and suitable volumes for development to at least morulae were > or =200 microl of HECM-3, and > or =100 microl of HECM-4. In both experiments development to morula and blastocyst stages with 100 microl volume in Petri dishes was significantly higher with HECM-4 (96 and 85% in Experiment 1 and 2, respectively) than that with HECM-3 (52 and 40% in Experiment 1 and 2, respectively; P < 0.05). These results indicate that attention should be paid to both type and volume of medium and interaction with type of culture dish for optimizing development of embryos in vitro.

Incubator management in an assisted reproductive technology laboratory

OBJECTIVE

To study the effect of incubator management on assisted reproductive technology (ART) outcomes.

DESIGN

Series of retrospective and controlled, randomized studies.

SETTING

Tertiary care infertility practice.

PATIENT(S)

Mammalian gametes/embryos.

INTERVENTION(S)

Evaluation of human and bovine oocytes/embryos cultured in various environmental conditions.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Fertilization and embryo development rate as well as clinical pregnancy rate (PR).

CONCLUSION(S)

Here we review the general topic of incubator management as it pertains to ART. Discussed within the context of this article will be our experiences as they relate to incubator management. Details as they apply to incubator environment also will include gamete/embryo positions within incubator, air quality, and quality control.

In vitro maturation and embryo production in cattle

When immature bovine oocytes are released from their follicles and are cultured in standard maturation medium, they resume the first meiotic division. The alteration of basic maturation conditions can affect oocyte competence significantly, as reflected by the morula and blastocyst yield after in vitro fertilization. The conditions used from the beginning of maturation up to the blastocyst stage have been shown to influence not only the developmental competence but also, potentially, the normal epigenetic make-up of the embryo. The methods described in this chapter outline the different steps of in vitro production of bovine embryos up to the blastocyst stage in semidefined conditions: (1) oocyte maturation, (2) in vitro fertilization, and (3) in vitro development. The first section explains procedures of ovary collection and oocyte aspiration and selection for in vitro maturation. The second section involves methods for the preparation of semen and oocytes for fertilization. The last section explains the best conditions to obtain blastocysts after 8 d of in vitro culture.

Male and female effects on the in vitro production of bovine embryos

A 3-year study was carried out to evaluate male and female effects on the efficiency of an in vitro fertilization (IVF) programme. The semen of different bulls used for artificial insemination was tested for the in vitro production of transferable blastocysts. The fertilization capacity was recorded for each bull. Bovine oocytes were matured in vitro, fertilized with frozen/thawed semen of 63 individual bulls and cultured during 8 days. The semen of one bull was used as control. The percentage of cleavage (36.3-93.4%) and blastocysts on day 7 (6.9-51.2%) varied from bull to bull. Despite high variability, blastocysts were produced with the semen of all bulls in the first trial. Moreover, oocytes fertilized with 85% of tested bulls reached a blastocyst rate not different to the control bull. The correlation coefficients of six bulls showed no significant male effect but an influence of oocytes on the cleavage rate (F-value 0.38, P > 0.05, and 12.4, P < 0.001, respectively). The development to blastocysts on day 7 was significantly influenced by sperms and also oocytes and session (P < 0.01), but no combined interaction was observed between female and male. It is concluded that transferable embryos can be produced in vitro in the first trial with frozen/thawed semen of 63 tested bulls. The results show different capacities of bulls to produce embryos and high male and female effects on the efficiency of an IVF programme.

Computer-assisted sperm motion analysis of bovine sperm treated with insulin-like growth factor I and II: implications as motility regulators and chemokinetic factors

The effects of insulin-like growth factors (IGFs) I and II on motility of bovine sperm were examined using a computer-assisted sperm motion analyzer (CASA). The following kinematic parameters were examined: percentage of rapidly moving cells, straight-line velocity , curvilinear velocity, average path velocity, amplitude of lateral head displacement, and beat cross frequency. Sperm were treated with IGF-I (100 ng/mL) or IGF-II (250 ng/mL) and compared to sperm in modified Tyrodes' medium only (control) at 90, 180, and 360 min using CASA. Insulin-like growth factor I and II increased the percentage of rapidly moving cells, straight-line velocity, curvilinear velocity, average path velocity, amplitude of lateral head displacement, and beat cross frequency compared to the control treatment. These results indicate that IGFs may be involved in initiation and maintenance of bovine sperm motility.

Identification of insulin-like growth factor I in bovine seminal plasma and its receptor on spermatozoa: influence on sperm motility

Insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) has been identified in human seminal plasma. This study was conducted to determine whether IGF-I is present in bovine seminal plasma, whether sperm cells express the IGF-I receptor (IGF-IR), and whether IGF-I affects sperm motility. Semen samples were collected from bulls by electroejaculation and maintained at 37 degrees C, and motility of sperm was assessed. After centrifugation to separate sperm cells from seminal plasma, the seminal plasma was submitted to a validated heterologous RIA for IGF-I. Significant concentrations of IGF-I (116.29 +/- 40.83 ng/ml expressed as mean +/- SD) were measured in bovine seminal plasma. Sperm cells were washed with buffer and subjected to either radioreceptor assay (RRA) or immunocytochemistry (IC). RRA revealed a single high affinity for the IGF-IR with a Kd of 0.83 nM as determined by the computer program LIGAND. IC, using three monoclonal antibodies, localized the IGF-IR to the acrosomal region of the sperm. Computer-assisted sperm-motion analysis was used to determine the effects of IGF-I and IGF-II on bovine sperm motility parameters. Both IGF-I and IGF-II increased sperm motility and straight-line velocity (p < 0.05) relative to the control. The presence of IGF-IR on sperm, the presence of IGF-I in semen, and the ability of IGF-I to stimulate sperm motility provide evidence that the IGF system may be involved in the fertilization process in the bovine species.

Practical measures to improve in vitro blastocyst production in the bovine

Media, chemicals, sera and protocols used for in vitro production of bovine embryos are different from one laboratory to another. This paper describes some of the critical steps required to produce embryos in vitro, suggests quality control measures to lower variations in blastocyst yield and describes different tests which may be used when implementing new procedures in a routine production system.

The effect of the culture vessel and insemination method on the in vitro fertilization and development of human oocytes

Our laboratory has corroborated previously published work demonstrating that tissue culture tubes and microdrops perform equally well for in vitro fertilization and culture of human oocytes and embryos.

Manual versus computer-automated semen analyses. Part III. Comparison of old versus new design MicroCell Chambers

OBJECTIVE

To determine accuracy and precision of old and new design MicroCell counting Chambers analyzed manually and with a computer-automated semen analyzer (CASA; Hamilton-Thorn Research, Beverly, MA).

DESIGN

Prospective study using comparative measurements of the concentration of latex beads with old and new design MicroCell Counting Chambers (Conception Technologies, Inc. La Jolla, CA).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

Beads were counted manually and with CASA to evaluate the accuracy of old and new design 20 MicroCell Chambers.

RESULTS

The old design 20 MicroCell Chamber demonstrated a significant difference in bead concentration beginning at the 9.9 mm CASA stage position compared with stage positions of 0.0 to 9.5 mm. The new design 20 MicroCell Chamber demonstrated the same difference at the 8.0 mm CASA stage position compared with stage positions 0.0 to 7.6 mm. Similar findings were observed when the beads were analyzed manually.

CONCLUSIONS

When analyzed within a specific range of stage positions, the old and new design 20 MicroCell Chambers are accurate and precise whether analyzed manually or with CASA.

Using Fyrite to monitor incubator carbon dioxide levels

PURPOSE

The Fyrite analyzer (Bacharach, Incorporated) was evaluated to ascertain whether it would perform within the range specified by the manufacturer (+/- 0.5%). Fyrite analyzer samples were compared to control samples obtained using an infrared CO2 monitor (Ohmeda, Model Number 5200).

METHODS

Ten Fyrite analyzer measurements from each of three incubators were obtained using two different analyzers by three investigators for a total of 60 measurements per investigator. Twenty control measurements for each of the three incubators were obtained using an infrared monitor calibrated at the 5.0% CO2 level.

RESULTS

Fyrite analyzer values fell outside of an acceptable range (Control mean CO2 +/- 0.5%) for 7 of 60 (11.7%) observations for Incubator 1 and 4 of 60 (6.7%) observations for Incubator 2. (Incubator 3 had no values outside the range.) The Fyrite analyzers were significantly different from each other (P = 0.002). The three investigators (I) differed significantly from the control (I1 and I3, P < 0.001; I2, P = 0.02) as well as from each other (I1 vs I2, P < 0.001; I1 vs I3, P < 0.001; I2 vs I3, P < 0.016).

CONCLUSIONS

Use of an infrared monitor for incubator calibration and monthly CO2 checks in concert with daily use of the Fyrite as a monitoring tool only is the better method.

In vitro development up to hatching of bovine in vitro-matured and fertilized oocytes with or without support from somatic cells

To verify the importance of somatic cells upon in vitro embryo development, in vitro-matured (IVM) and -fertilized (IVF) bovine oocytes were cultured in TCM 199 supplemented with estrous cow serum (10% v/v) and 0.25 mM sodium pyruvate (ECSTCM) under the following treatments: 1) ECSTCM alone; 2) together with bovine oviduct epithelial cells (BOEC); 3) with cumulus cells (CC); 4) in fresh BOEC conditioned ECSTCM; or 5) in frozen-thawed BOEC conditioned ECSTCM. Culturing zygotes encased in cumulus cells significantly reduced the cleavage rate (P<0.05). There was no difference between culture systems in the proportions of embryo development through the 8-cell stage (P=0.42) up to the morula/blastocyst stages (P=0.50) at Day 7 post insemination. However, co-culture with BOEC yielded the highest percentage (21.2% of zygotes; P<0.05) of quality Grade-1 and Grade-2 embryos with the number of blastomeres per embryo (114.4) comparable to that of 7-day-old in vivo-developed embryos of similar grades (102.5), and higher (P<0.05) than those of the other treatments. The ratio of blastocysts to total morulae/blastocysts obtained from frozen-thawed conditioned medium was lower (P<0.05) than that from ECSTCM or after co-culture with BOEC at Day 7 post insemination. On average, 7.5 to 17.5% of the zygotes developed to blastocyst, expanded blastocyst and hatched blastocyst stages by Day 10 post insemination, depending upon the culture system. The difference between treatments, however, was not significant (P=0.68). The results indicate that chronological development up to hatching of bovine IVM-IVF embryos is not favored by somatic cells; however, the presence of viable oviduct epithelial cells in culture significantly improves the quality of 7-day-old embryos.

Impact of incubator type on the yield of in vitro produced bovine blastocysts

Because of suboptimal in vitro production of bovine blastocysts a new incubator model (Mini) was tested against the traditional (Heraeus). The difference between their properties seemed only to be the volume of the incubator space. No difference was noted between the CO2 or the temperature, but the data clearly showed a highly significant increase of the blastocyst rates, 6% versus 51% in the Heraeus and the Mini incubator, respectively, calculated as blastocysts per cleaved embryos. It was concluded that the incubator type or model may be a very important part of the in vitro production of bovine embryos, although we were not able to pin point specific causes for this difference.

In vitro preimplantation mouse embryo development with incubation temperatures of 37 and 39 degrees C

Embryos from two strains of mice were used to assess the effect of incubation temperature on pronuclear and two-cell development to the morula/blastocyst (M/B) stage. Embryos from B6D2F2 and B6SJLF1 strains were cultured in medium M16 at either 37 or 39 degrees C until 120 hr post human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) or 0, 24, or 48 hr at 37 degrees C and the remaining time at 39 degrees C. Overall M/B development for pronuclear embryos was 0.6, 0, 32.3, and 52.4% for 0-96, 24-72, 48-48, and 96-0 hr at 37 and 39 degrees C, respectively. Only 0-96 and 24-72 hr at 37 and 39 degrees C were not different (P greater than 0.10). Overall M/B development for two-cell embryos was 48.1, 78.1, and 98.0% for 0-72, 24-48, and 72-0 hr at 37 and 39 degrees C, respectively. Percentage development at each time was different (P less than .01) for each category. Additionally, the number of nuclei for morulae and blastocysts tended to be higher for embryos initiating culture at the two-cell stage compared to pronuclear embryos. The first cell cycle was most dramatically affected by a 2 degrees C increase in incubator temperature. More advanced embryos can tolerate slight increases in incubator temperature more readily than pronuclear embryos.

An evaluation of hamster, rat, and mouse sperm-cell motility in media formulated with water of different qualities

The in vitro motility of caudal epididymal spermatozoa from four hamsters, four rats, and four mice was compared in modified Tyrode's medium (TLP-PVA) prepared with water of three qualities: (1) Sigma tissue culture water, 18 m omega, high quality (HQ); (2) deionized distilled water, 4.5 m omega prior to distillation, intermediate quality (IQ); and (3) tap water, low quality (LQ). The objective was to evaluate the in vitro bioassay potential of spermatozoa from these species, in terms of relative sensitivities to toxins in different qualities of water. An average sperm motility index (SMI) was calculated per treatment at 2, 4, and 6 hr, where SMI = fpm2 x % motility. Hamster SMI could be used to discriminate between HQ and IQ media at 4 and 6 hr (P less than 0.001), while rat SMI could be used to discriminate between HQ and IQ media at 6 hr (P less than 0.05). Mouse SMI did not differ between HQ and IQ media. The ability to discriminate between extremes in quality. HQ or IQ vs LQ, was equal between species (P less than 0.001). These results suggest that hamster spermatozoa provide the more sensitive in vitro bioassay model, while rat and mouse spermatozoa may be used for assay of extremes in water quality.