Recipient management and embryo transfer

Towards Improving the Outcomes of Assisted Reproductive Technologies of Cattle and Sheep, with Particular Focus on Recipient Management

The Australian agricultural industry contributes AUD 47 billion to the Australian economy, and Australia is the world's largest exporter of sheep meat and the third largest for beef. Within Australia, sheep meat consumption continues to rise, with beef consumption being amongst the highest in the world; therefore, efficient strategies to increase herd/flock size are integral to the success of these industries. Reproductive management is crucial to increasing the efficiency of Australian breeding programs. The use of assisted reproductive technologies (ARTs) has the potential to increase efficiency significantly. The implementation of multiple ovulation and embryo transfer (MOET) and juvenile in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer (JIVET) in combination with genomic selection and natural mating and AI is the most efficient way to increase genetic gain, and thus increase reproductive efficiency within the Australian livestock industries. However, ARTs are costly, and high variation, particularly between embryo transfer recipients in their ability to maintain pregnancy, is a significant constraint to the widespread commercial adoption of ARTs. The use of a phenotypic marker for the selection of recipients, as well as the better management of recipient animals, may be an efficient and cost-effective means to increase the productivity of the Australian livestock industry.

Breeding performance of Indonesian beef cattle as recipients for embryo transfer

The objective of this study was to evaluate the breeding performance of Indonesian beef cattle (Ongole cross) as recipients for embryo transfer using Limousin embryos. As a result, the pregnancy rate was 35% (7 out of 20 cows). There was a significant difference (P<0.01) in the serum progesterone concentration between the nonpregnant and pregnant cows at the time of the embryo transfer (day 7 after the estrus). The pregnancy rate in the Indonesian beef cows was low, which may be due to their insufficient genetic quality and/or low physical conditions caused by the poor management, like a low-nutrition diet. The low progesterone concentration in the nonpregnant cows on day 7 may be associated with the failure of embryo implantation.

Effects of parity and season on pregnancy rates after the transfer of embryos to repeat-breeder Japanese Black beef cattle

Abstract. Repeat-breeder (RB) cows are a major source of economic waste due to their decreased fertility. Embryo transfer (ET) is an alternative tool to improve the fertility of RB cows. The aims of the present study were to evaluate the effects of recipient parity and the season on pregnancy rates following ET in RB Japanese Black beef cattle. Embryos were transferred nonsurgically to recipients, consisting of 155 heifers (< 2 years old) and 172 cows (< 8 years old), which were defined as RB cattle. Of the recipients that were presented for ET, 57 recipients received a fresh embryo and 270 recipients received a frozen embryo. There were no differences in the pregnancy rates between cattle that received fresh embryos or frozen embryos. The rates of recipients with pregnancy, abortion, stillbirth, and normal calving were similar between heifers and cows. In cows, the pregnancy rates were lower (P < 0.05) in summer (June to August) than in spring (March to May) and winter (December to February). In heifers, however, there were no differences in the pregnancy rates among the seasons. Our findings indicate that in RB Japanese Black beef cattle, the parity of the recipients does not have an effect on the pregnancy rates following the transfer of fresh and frozen embryos. However, heat stress may affect reproductive performance in RB Japanese Black cows.

Treatments for the synchronisation of bovine recipients for fixed-time embryo transfer and improvement of pregnancy rates

Although embryo transfer technology has been used commercially in cattle for many years, the inefficiency of oestrus detection, especially in recipients, has limited the widespread application of this technology. The most useful alternative to increase the number of recipients utilised in an embryo transfer program is the use of protocols that allow for embryo transfer without the need for oestrus detection, usually called fixed-time embryo transfer (FTET). Most current FTET protocols are based on progestin-releasing devices combined with oestradiol or GnRH, which control and synchronise follicular wave dynamics and ovulation. Conception rates to a single FTET have been reported to be similar to those after detection of oestrus, but pregnancy rates are higher because these treatments have increased the proportion of recipients that receive an embryo. Recent changes to treatments for FTET, such as the administration of eCG, have resulted in increased pregnancy rates and provide opportunities to make these treatments easier to perform on farm.

Pregnancy rates and metabolic profiles in cattle treated with propylene glycol prior to embryo transfer

The objective of this study was to determine the effect of a sustained propylene glycol administration to recipients of frozen/thawed in vivo derived bovine embryos. Heifers were treated with oral propylene glycol for the last 20 days before embryo transfer (n = 142), and untreated as controls (n = 133). Progesterone, insulin, insulin-like growth factor-I, glucose, urea and triglyceride were analysed in blood on Day 0 and Day 7 of the estrous cycle corresponding to embryo transfer. The heifers were selected as recipients when showing progesterone levels <2.0 ng/ml (Day 0) and >2.5 ng/ml (Day 7), according to corpus luteum quality on Day 7 by technicians unaware of animals treated. Within treated animals, significantly more recipients were selected, and increased progesterone, corpus luteum quality, pregnancy and calving rates were recorded. Day 7 progesterone concentrations were higher in heifers treated and transferred. Propylene glycol increased insulin and insulin-like-growth factor-I, but glucose, urea and triglyceride did not vary. Furthermore, insulin-like-growth factor-I, glucose and triglyceride increased at estrous time, but urea decreased and insulin remained unaltered. Together with the sustained gain in pregnancy rates throughout the experiment (2 years), other evidences suggested that the observed effects did not rely on nutritional deficiency. Thus, propylene glycol improved pregnancy rates after embryo-transfer, and progesterone, insulin and insulin-like-growth factor-I are probably involved in this effect.

Screening of some variables influencing the results of embryo transfer in the ewe. Part II: two-day-old embryos

Each of sixty Rasa aragonesa ewes received two embryos on Days 2-3 of the estrous cycle (Day 0=estrus) from 27 donors of the same breed that were superovulated with pFSH. The influence of several variables on fertility and prolificacy after transfer was studied by discriminant analysis. Our results showed that the main variables contributing to higher fertility were: in the donor-recipient couple, degree of estrus synchrony between them (better if donors were in estrus before recipients); in recipients, interval from FGA withdrawal to estrus onset, prolificacy in the previous lambing, age (all, better if inferior to the mean) and interval from the previous lambing (better if superior to the mean); in donors, ovulation rate (better if lower than the mean); and in embryos, developmental stage (better if superior to the mean). Likewise, the main variables contributing to higher prolificacy were: in donors, body condition score (better if higher than the mean) and weight (better if inferior to the mean); and in recipients, plasma progesterone concentration at transfer (better if inferior to the mean). The percentage of ewes correctly classified as lambing or not was 71.7% (P<0.01), and 72.5% of the ewes were correctly classified as having one or two lambs (P<0.05). Whether the criteria we have found for optimum results after transfer are applicable or not to conditions other than ours will need to be confirmed.

Improvement of pregnancy rate in Japanese Black cows by administration of hCG to recipients of transferred frozen-thawed embryos

Japanese Black primiparous and multiparous beef cows (n = 120) were selected as recipients and randomly divided into three groups (A, B, and C) of 40 recipients each. Group A received an intramuscular (i.m.) treatment of 1500 IU human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) on day 1 (day 0 = onset of estrus), while Group B received an i.m. treatment of hCG on day 6. Group C received an i.m. treatment of 5 ml saline on day 6 as a control. On day 7, frozen-thawed embryo transfer was conducted in all groups, and pregnancy was diagnosed by palpated per rectum 40-50 days after the transfer. Twelve recipients were randomly selected from each group. Plasma progesterone (P) and estradiol-17beta (E2) concentrations were determined in these recipients on days 6, 7 and 14, and at the time of pregnancy diagnosis, and their ovaries were examined for a corpus luteum and follicles by palpated per rectum. The pregnancy rate in Group B was higher (67.5%. P < 0.05) than the rate in Group C (45.0%) and in Group A (42.5%). The plasma P concentration on day 14 tended to be higher although not significantly in Group B than in Groups C and A. At the time of pregnancy diagnosis, the blood P concentration of pregnant recipients in Group B was higher (P < 0.05) than that of those in Groups C and A. The plasma E2 concentrations on days 7 and 14 were lower (P < 0.05) in Group B than in Groups C and A. These results showed that administration of hCG 6 days after estrus improved the pregnancy rate for non-surgical frozen embryo transfer 7 days after estrus by enhancing luteal function and depressing E2 secretion.

Factors affecting frozen and fresh embryo transfer pregnancy rates in cattle

The effects of a large number of factors on the pregnancy rates of fresh and frozen cattle embryos were examined over a period of years at several different locations. For fresh embryos, overall pregnancy rates were 68.3% (n=9023) and 77.1% (n=2650) at different locations and time periods. Frozen-thawed embryo pregnancy rates were 56.1% (n=3616) in The Netherlands and 58.4% (n=5297) and 68.7% (n=774) for two studies in the United States. Pregnancy rates of surgical versus nonsurgical transfers were very similar. There were no differences in the pregnancy rates of beef versus dairy embryos, but the pregnancy rate was higher in dairy and beef heifers and beef cows than in dairy cows. Although on-farm pregnancy rates in California were higher than in the northeast United States, there was no influence of season on pregnancy rate. Estrous asynchrony between plus and minus 24 h did not affect pregnancy rate for frozen-thawed or fresh embryos. Neither breed nor parity of recipients affected the influence of asynchrony on pregnancy rates. Embryo grade was a significant factor in pregnancy rate for both fresh and frozen-thawed embryos, but neither embryo stage nor age was a significant factor. Pregnancy rate was not affected by holding embryos after flushing for up to 3 h prior to freezing.

Developmental competence of juvenile calf oocytes in vitro and in vivo: influence of donor animal variation and repeated gonadotropin stimulation

Juvenile calf oocytes represent an untapped source of germ plasm for reproduction. Reports on the developmental competence of calf oocytes have been controversial. In this research, oocytes were recovered after gonadotropin stimulation from Holstein calves (N = 10) at 2-3 mo of age (2-mo cycle) and again at 4-5 mo of age (4-mo cycle). The in vitro developmental competence was measured, and prestimulation follicle numbers (for 2-mo cycle) and poststimulation follicle numbers (both cycles) were obtained. The number of antral follicles doubled after stimulation (23.4 +/- 6.1 vs. 55.1 +/- 16.1) for the 2-mo cycle and for the 4-mo cycle (47.4 +/- 12.4). The number of follicles observed prior to stimulation in the 2-mo cycle was found to be highly correlated with the poststimulation oocyte recovery for both collection cycles (r = 0.95, 2-mo cycle; r = 0.81, 4-mo cycle). The majority (90-96%) of recovered oocytes were found to be usable for in vitro maturation and fertilization; of these, 41-42% cleaved and 10-11% developed to morulae or blastocysts. Eighty-four in vitro-produced embryos were transferred to synchronized recipients and resulted in 11 pregnancies, leading to 7 live (4 males, 3 females) and 2 dead (one male, one female) calves at full term. No significant differences were observed between the 2-mo and 4-mo collection cycles; however, 73% of the total pregnancies resulted from the 2-mo cycle. All pregnancies resulted from embryos of high-responding donors. The high correlation between the number of follicles prior to stimulation and the poststimulation response suggests the possibility of screening calves prior to stimulation for routine embryo production.

Understanding maternal contributions to fertility in recipient cattle: development of herds with contrasting pregnancy rates

Causes of variation amongst recipients within a herd in their ability to initiate and maintain pregnancy is largely unknown. In order to develop an experimental resource to understand the biology of recipient reproductive performance, each of 155 contemporary yearling heifers received 2 in vitro-produced embryos on 6 separate occasions during a 26-month period. Sixty days after transfer, pregnancy and the number of foetuses were determined ultrasonically and then pregnancies were terminated and the process was repeated. Heifers were ranked on their aggregate pregnancy rate performance, and the highest (High) and lowest (Low) 25 were retained. Mean pregnancy rates of all recipients ranged from 0.20 to 0.67 depending on transfer occasion. The mean +/- s.e. pregnancy rate of the High and Low sub-herds were 0.76+/-0.04 vs. 0.11+/-0.03, respectively (P<0.001), with 55% and 37% of this difference due to differences in Day 25 return to oestrus rates and losses between Day 25 and Day 35, respectively. We suggest that failure in the mechanism involved in maternal recognition of pregnancy was a major cause of the difference between the two sub-herds. These sub-herds are a unique experimental resource for understanding the early pregnancy process in cattle.

Factors affecting pregnancy rate following nonsurgical embryo transfer in buffalo (Bubalus bubalis): a retrospective study

The objectives of this study were to determine the pregnancy rate and factors affecting it following nonsurgical embryo transfer in buffalo. Donor buffalo were superovulated with FSH, and embryos collected nonsurgically were evaluated for stage of development and quality. They were transferred nonsurgically to 91 recipients on Days 5 to 7 of the natural (n = 52) or induced (n = 39) estrus (estrus = Day 0). The overall pregnancy rate of 24/91(26.4%) was higher than in earlier reports for buffalo but was much lower than in cattle. Pregnancy rates were not affected by season (autumn vs winter), side of transfer (right vs left uterine horn), or type of estrus (spontaneous vs induced). The pregnancy rate was high 11/27(40.7%) when donors and recipients were closely synchronized, while it was compromised when recipients were in estrus at +12 h (1/7, 14.3%) and at -12 h (5/27, 18.5%). Asynchrony beyond 12 h on either side resulted into conception failure. The pregnancy rate tended to increase with the increase in CL size of recipients, while stage of embryonic development had no effect. The transfer of an 8-cell embryo with a 16-cell embryo led to the birth of heterosexual twins, indicating that the uterine milieu of Day 5 to 6 recipients may be tolerated by the out-of-phase 8-cell embryo, at least in the presence of a more mature embryo. Embryo quality had the greatest effect on pregnancy rate as it was higher (P < 0.005) after the transfer of Grade I than Grade III embryos (6/10, 60.0% vs 3/36, 13.9%). Assessment of returns to estrus indicated that among nonpregnant recipients, 17/67 (25.4%) embryos never matured sufficiently to prevent luteolysis through maternal recognition of pregnancy (MRP), while 14/67 (20.8%) embryos probably died following MRP. These results indicate that efforts to increase pregnancy rate following embryo transfer in buffalo should include prevention of luteolysis during the first week of transfer and a reduction in the incidence of embryonic mortality.

Direct transfer of bovine embryos frozen-thawed in the presence of propylene glycol or ethylene glycol under on-farm conditions in an integrated embryo transfer program

An integrated bovine embryo transfer program was conducted in collaboration with 11 Japanese prefectural livestock experiment stations. The program was conducted to evaluate the practicability of the direct transfer method for bovine embryos frozen-thawed in the presence of propylene glycol (PG) or ethylene glycol (EG) under on-farm conditions. Embryos at the compacted morula to expanded blastocyst stages were collected from superovulated donors on Day 7 or 8 after estrus and equilibrated in 1.6 M PG or 1.8 M EG in Dulbecco's phosphate-buffered saline (DPBS) supplemented with 20% heat-inactivated calf serum. Embryos were then loaded individually into a 0.25-ml straw and placed directly into a cooling chamber of a programmable freezer precooled to -7 degrees C. After 2 min, the straw was seeded, maintained at -7 degrees C for 8 min more, and then cooled to -30 degrees C either at 0.3 degree C/min or 0.5 degree C/min before being plunged into liquid nitrogen. Embryos at the same stages were also frozen in the presence of 1.4 M glycerol (GLY) by a conventional method, which served as a control. The frozen embryos were thawed by allowing the straws to stand in air for 5 to 10 sec and then immersing them in a 30 degrees C water bath. Embryos frozen-thawed in the presence of PG or EG were nonsurgically transferred into the uterine horn without diluting the cryoprotectant. Embryos frozen-thawed in the presence of GLY were nonsurgically transferred after removing GLY either by the stepwise method (GLY-I) or by in situ dilution with 0.3 M sucrose solution (GLY-II). A total of 1,273 (PG: 400, EG: 418, GLY-I: 177, GLY-II; 278) frozen-thawed embryos was transferred into recipients, yielding 545 pregnancies (overall: 42.8%, PG: 36.0%, EG; 44.7%, GLY-I; 48.6%, GLY-II; 46.0%). The pregnancy rate with PG was significantly lower than that with EG or GLY-II (P < 0.05). The pregnancy rate was affected by the type of cryoprotectant, the region where the embryo transfer program was carried out, the developmental stage of the embryos, the parity of the recipients, and corpus luteum (CL) quality of the recipients. There were no differences in rates of abortion and stillbirth among the 3 cryoprotectants. The present study demonstrates that EG can be effectively used as a cryoprotectant for freezing and direct transfer of bovine embryos, and that the direct transfer method is applicable under on-farm conditions.

Synchronization of estrus in embryo transfer recipients after using a combination of PRID or CIDR-B plus PGF2α

The use of CIDR-B or PRID in combination with prostaglandin F2alpha (PGF2alpha) for synchronizing estrus in embryo transfer recipients was evaluated in 2 experiments. In Experiment 1, virgin heifers (n=263) were synchronized using either a PRID (including estradiol benzoate capsule) or a CIDR-B in a combined program in which devices were inserted on Day 1, an injection of prostaglandin was given on Day 6, and devices were withdrawn on Day 7. The interval from device removal to the onset of estrus was significantly shorter for CIDR-B than for PRID-treated animals (50.44 vs 55.50 hours; P<0.003). The CIDR-B treatment resulted in a similar degree of synchrony to the PRID treatment (74.0 vs 70.4%; P=0.68). InExperiment 2, cows (n=95) and heifers (n=93) were allocated at random to be synchronized using a PRID (excluding estradiol benzoate capsule) plus PGF2alpha or a CIDR-B device plus PGF2alpha. The devices were inserted on Day 1, an injection of prostaglandin was given on Day 10 and the devices were removed on Day 12. Estrus was observed earlier following the CIDR-B treatment (43.50 vs 47.04 hours; P=0.01), but the degree of synchrony was similar (76.2 vs 76.3%; P>0.10) for the CIDR-B and PRID-treated animals. In both experiments, there were no significant differences in the proportions of animals observed in estrus, selected as embryo transfer recipients, or which achieved pregnancy consequent on embryo transfer between those synchronized using CIDR-B or PRID regimens. We conclude that the CIDR-B is a suitable device for synchronizing estrus in embryo transfer recipients.