Fetal ECG during labour: a suggested standard

Head orientation and electrode placement potentially influence fetal scalp ECG waveform

BACKGROUND

Fetal monitoring based on electrocardiographic (ECG) morphology is obtained from a single unipolar fetal scalp electrode. Ideally, it should be obtained from multiple leads, as ECG waveform depends on alignment between electrode and electrical heart axis. This alignment is unknown in fetuses. Besides, fetuses are surrounded by conductive media, which may influence ECG waveform. We explored the influence of electrode position and head orientation on ECG waveforms of unipolar and bipolar scalp ECGs recorded in air and in conductive medium.

METHODS

We recorded ECGs in one adult subject at five different scalp positions in five different head orientations both in dry and immersed conditions. The ratio between T-amplitude and QRS-amplitude (T/QRS ratio) of unipolar and bipolar scalp ECGs was determined and compared between all conditions.

RESULTS

In the dry condition, we observed in the unipolar leads little to no difference between different electrode positions (maximal T/QRS difference 0.00-0.01) and minor differences between head orientations (0.02-0.03), whereas bipolar leads showed no recognizable ECG signal at all. During the immersed condition, we found variation in the unipolar leads, both between electrode positions (maximal T/QRS difference 0.02-0.05) and between head orientations (0.03-0.06). Bipolar leads showed different ECG signals in contrasting head orientations.

CONCLUSIONS

Both unipolar and bipolar scalp lead-derived ECG waveforms are influenced by electrode position and head orientation when the subject is submerged in a conductive medium. Fetal monitoring based on single scalp lead ECG waveform might be suboptimal, as it lacks correction for fetal head orientation and electrode position.

ST analysis of the fetal electrocardiogram - Comments on recent experimental data

In their paper, Andriessen at al present a validation of fetal ECG analysis and the clinical STAN device in midgestation fetal lambs exposed to 25 minutes of umbilical cord occlusion. The study presents results that contrast remarkably from previously published experimental data which raises a number of questions and comments.

The most striking finding of Andriessen et al is the recording of an extremely high number of alarms from the STAN equipment during control conditions when no alarms at all are expected. These patterns have never been seen, neither in the clinical situation nor in our own fetal sheep studies. The reason for this becomes apparent when their way of recording the FECG is scrutinized. In their assessment of STAN, Andriessen at al use an assumed negative aVF lead with the assumption that it will reflect the FECG in the same way as the unipolar scalp lead used clinically. The signal used for disqualification of STAN is itself not qualified to properly represent the fetal scalp lead signal that STAN is designed for. To question a proven technology is fully accepted but those attempting would be asked to argue along fully validated data and related analysis including questioning of their own data.

ST analysis of fetal electrocardiography in labor

Since its introduction more than 40 years ago, electronic fetal monitoring has become widely used for intrapartum surveillance to determine fetal wellbeing in labor. Although fetal hypoxia and acidosis are reflected in changes in fetal heart rate, there is no evidence that cardiotocography has been effective in reducing neonatal morbidity related to fetal distress occurring during labor. Indeed the specificity of this tool is poor and in many instances the incorporation of electronic fetal monitoring into intrapartum care has merely led to an increase in medical intervention rather than an improvement in neonatal outcome. Fetal electrocardiography (ECG) analysis provides an additional method for assessing the response of the fetus to hypoxia and in particular to the development of metabolic acidosis. ST changes in the fetal ECG can be quantified with computational analysis, reducing subjective interpretation that has been problematic with traditional electronic fetal monitoring. Formal algorithms indicating appropriate points for intervention in labor have been designed. The fetal ECG has been shown to be a useful adjunct to traditional electronic fetal monitoring in several randomized controlled trials with evidence of reduced rates of neonatal encephalopathy and reduced rates of obstetric intervention.

ST analysis as an adjunct to electronic fetal monitoring: an overview

Conventional electronic fetal monitoring in the United States has value as a screening tool but is extremely limited as a diagnostic tool. ST analysis was developed as an adjunctive technology, able to measure changes in the ST segment of the fetal electrocardiogram during periods of hypoxia, improving the identification of the fetus at risk for metabolic acidemia at birth. Currently used only in a handful of hospitals in the United States, studies abroad have demonstrated that an integrated approach utilizing electronic fetal monitoring, ST analysis, and standardized guidelines in a selected patient population can improve neonatal outcome, decrease acidemia at birth, and decrease obstetric operative delivery. Research is needed to determine whether similar results are possible in the US population.

Fetal ECG waveform analysis

Fetal ECG waveform analysis as an adjunct to electronic fetal monitoring (EFM) has developed over the last 3 decades. From a multitude of potential parameters, ST waveform analysis has been documented to provide the information required to shift EFM from a screening device to a diagnostic tool that meets the standards of evidence-based medicine. This chapter details the experimental and clinical evolution of the STAN methodology for intrapartum fetal surveillance. Observational data formed the basis for cardiotocograph (CTG) and ST waveform analysis clinical guidelines. Data from two large, randomized controlled trials (6826 cases) are summarized together with the first analysis of the recently completed EU project of 7823 term fetuses monitored as part of the study to introduce ST analysis into clinical practice. The reduction in the incidence of newborns with marked neurological symptoms is supported by these findings. The detection of ST changes allowed earlier and more consistent intervention.

Noninvasive antepartum recording of fetal S-T segment with a newly developed 151-channel magnetic sensor system

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to evaluate the efficiency of the detection of the S-T segment in the fetal PQRST complex that is recorded in the antepartum period with the use of a newly developed noninvasive 151-channel magnetic sensor array.

STUDY DESIGN

One hundred two fetal magnetocardiographic recordings were performed on normal fetuses with gestational ages that ranged from 27.5 to 39.5 weeks. After the removal of the interfering maternal heart signals, the fetal heart data were inspected to detect the presence of P, QRS, and T segments.

RESULTS

The QRS complex was detectable in 100%, the P wave was detectable in 95.1%, and the T wave was detectable in 87.3% of the recordings.

CONCLUSION

Fetal magnetocardiography was recorded successfully, the QRS complex was observed in all subjects, and the T detection rate increased, with the gestational age reaching a peak of 97%. Further study of the S-T segment through the antepartum period could lead to advances in the detection of fetal jeopardy before labor.

The fetal electrocardiogram

Advances in microprocessing technology have made fetal ECG analysis a feasible adjunct to fetal surveillance. Time interval and morphology changes of the FECG occur during fetal hypoxia. The use of these changes to detect a fetus at risk of intrapartum asphyxia awaits validation in terms of both future and ongoing clinical trials. Recognition of FECG changes during decelerations may improve the sensitivity of EFM. Antepartum FECG analysis has potential for the detection of a number of pathological fetal conditions, including intrauterine growth retardation, but remains hampered by low signal-to-noise ratios, rendering successful signal acquisition unreliable.

The T/QRS ratio of the electrocardiogram does not reliably reflect well-being in fetal lambs

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to determine the diagnostic power of the T/QRS ratio of the electrocardiogram to predict fetal well-being.

STUDY DESIGN

In 47 fetal lambs (3 to 5 days after surgery, gestational age 123.5 +/- 3.0 days) asphyxia was induced by restriction of uterine perfusion. Fetuses were either pretreated with an adenosine transport inhibitor (n = 16) or a calcium channel blocker (n = 12) or served as controls (n = 19). Arterial oxygen content > or = 1.5 mmol/L or pH > or = 7.15 were chosen as limits for fetal well-being.

RESULTS

Arterial oxygen content was reduced from 3.3 (+/- 1.0) to 1.3 (+/- 0.5) mmol/L, and pH decreased to 7.03 (+/- 0.10). Mortality was 53%. Both drugs did not affect well-being, survival, or the T/QRS ratio. Maximum T/QRS ratios were reached at the peak of asphyxia. Sensitivity and specificity of the T/QRS ratio were 24.0% and 42.6% to predict hypoxemia and 25.1% and 45.3% to predict acidemia. Pearson correlation coefficients for T/QRS ratio versus oxygen content and pH were 0.169 and 0.192, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

(1) In fetal lambs the T/QRS ratio failed to predict hypoxemia or acidemia. (2) Fetal survival was not correlated with the height of the T/QRS ratio during or after asphyxia.

A comparative study of the fetal electrocardiogram recorded by the STAN an Nottingham systems

OBJECTIVE

To compare the T:QRS ratio recorded by the STAN and Nottingham fetal electrocardiogram (FECG) monitors.

DESIGN

Prospective observational study.

SETTING

London teaching hospital delivery suite and research unit.

METHODS AND SUBJECTS

The T:QRS ratios generated by the STAN and Nottingham FECG monitors were simultaneously recorded and compared using signals generated from a computer-produced ECG signal and signals from 11 term fetuses recorded during labour.

RESULTS

There was an acceptable level of agreement between the two systems with the computer-generated signals, but it was not clinically acceptable with the signals from the fetuses recorded during labour. Disagreements in the T:QRS values were probably due to differences in the reference points for the measurement of the S-T segment and T-wave height.

CONCLUSION

The different points of reference for measurement of S-T segment and T-wave height can explain poor agreement between the two methods of FECG waveform analysis. The suggested adopted points of reference are those corresponding to adult electrocardiographic methodology.

Plymouth randomized trial of cardiotocogram only versus ST waveform plus cardiotocogram for intrapartum monitoring in 2400 cases

OBJECTIVE

The physiology of changes in the ST waveform of the fetal electrocardiogram has been elucidated in extensive animal and human observational studies. A combination of heart rate and ST waveform analysis might improve the predictive value of intrapartum monitoring. Our purpose was to compare operative intervention and neonatal outcome in labors monitored by the conventional cardiotocogram with those monitored by ST waveform plus the cardiotocogram.

STUDY DESIGN

A prospective, randomized clinical trial was performed on 2434 high-risk labors in a district general hospital in Plymouth, England. Statistical analysis was performed by Student t test and chi 2 analysis.

RESULTS

There was a 46% reduction (p < 0.001, odds ratio 1.85 [1.35-2.66]) in operative deliveries for "fetal distress" and a trend to less metabolic acidosis (p = 0.09, odds ratio 0.38 [0.13-1.07]) and fewer low 5-minute Apgar scores (p = 0.12, odds ratio 0.62 [0.35-1.08]) in the ST waveform plus cardiotocogram arm.

CONCLUSIONS

ST waveform analysis discriminates cardiotocogram changes in labor, and the protocol for interpretation is safe. Further randomized studies are warranted.

Randomised trial of cardiotocography alone or with ST waveform analysis for intrapartum monitoring

It is possible to record the fetal electrocardiographic waveform (ECG) from the scalp electrode used in labour for detection of fetal heart rate. Animal and observational studies of changes in the ST waveform of the ECG during hypoxia suggest that a combination of heart rate and ST waveform analysis might improve the predictive value of intrapartum monitoring. In a randomised trial, we have studied intervention rates and neonatal outcome for high-risk labours monitored either by conventional cardiotocography (CTG) or by ST waveform analysis plus CTG. 1200 women with pregnancy of at least 34 weeks' gestation were assigned to the groups when the decision to apply a fetal scalp electrode was made. Neonatal outcome was assessed by umbilical-cord blood gas analysis, Apgar scores, resuscitation needed, and postnatal course. All recordings were retrospectively viewed by an observer unaware of clinical details to check adherence to the trial protocol. The addition of ST waveform monitoring to CTG substantially reduced the proportion of deliveries for fetal distress (ST + CTG 27/615 vs CTG 58/606; p less than 0.001). The groups did not differ in rate of operative delivery for other reasons, incidence of asphyxia at birth, or neonatal outcome. Metabolic acidosis and low 5 min Apgar scores were less common in the ST + CTG than the CTG group, but not significantly so. The only case of birth asphyxia in the ST + CTG group was identified by both heart rate and ST changes. The review of recordings showed that the reduction in intervention rate was among cases with CTG patterns classified as normal or intermediate, whereas there was no difference in intervention rates among cases with abnormal recordings. Our findings confirm that ST waveform analysis discriminates CTG changes in labour and that our protocol for interpretation is safe. Further randomised studies are warranted.

Clinical assessment of fetal electrocardiogram monitoring in labour

OBJECTIVE

To assess the potential clinical value of fetal electrocardiographic (ECG) monitoring in labour.

DESIGN

Descriptive study of the use of ECG waveform analysis during labour and its correlation with other indices of fetal and neonatal well-being.

SETTING

Teaching hospital in Oxford.

SUBJECTS

86 high risk pregnancies.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Suitability of ST Segment Analyser (Cinventa, Sweden) for clinical use; relation between the T/QRS ratio during labour (an index of ST segment and T wave elevation) and intrapartum cardiotocography, umbilical artery pH at birth and Apgar scores; T/QRS ratio trends in labour.

RESULTS

The system was robust and user-friendly. No statistically significant relation was found between T/QRS ratios in labour and FHR abnormalities in the cardiotocograph. There was a weak relation between T/QRS ratios and umbilical artery acidosis: at a cervical dilatation of 4 cm, the Spearman rank correlation of the mean T/QRS ratio with umbilical artery actual base deficit was r = -0.31, 0.05 greater than P greater than 0.01. The correlation of T/QRS with the umbilical artery pH was not statistically significant, although a trend was present (Spearman rank: r = -0.26, P greater than 0.05). Correlation of the T/QRS ratio with Apgar scores at 1 and at 5 min was not statistically significant. Only 3 of 16 infants with an Apgar score of less than 7 at 1 min had a mean T/QRS ratio above 0.25 at any time during labour.

CONCLUSION

Further research is necessary before a decision can be made whether this new method of fetal monitoring should be introduced into clinical practice.

Direct antenatal fetal electrocardiographic waveform analysis

OBJECTIVE

To establish a technique for continuous recording of fetal electrocardiograms (ECG) for waveform analysis in the antenatal period.

DESIGN

Prospective descriptive study.

SETTING

Fetal Medicine Unit, Queen Charlotte's and Chelsea Hospital, London, UK.

SUBJECTS

35 women undergoing antenatal fetal blood sampling.

INTERVENTIONS

One end of an insulated Cooner wire was attached to the sampling needle and the other to an automatic ECG-ST waveform analyser.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

ECG signals were obtained with the needle in the fetal abdomen during intrahepatic umbilical vein sampling or aspiration of fetal urine but not when it was in the placental cord insertion.

RESULTS

Continuous recording of the T/QRS ratio was obtained for a total of 166 min (mean 8 min per fetus) from 20 fetuses (16-38 weeks). The T/QRS ratio had no correlation with gestational age and fetal heart rate and was similar to values described in term fetuses in labour.

CONCLUSIONS

The technique described can identify ST waveform changes and may be useful in the investigation of fetal cardiac arrhythmias, intrauterine growth retardation and in monitoring fetal transfusions.

Suitability of fetal scalp electrodes for monitoring the fetal electrocardiogram during labour

As the limitations of heart-rate based intrapartum monitoring have become apparent, there is renewed interest in analysis of the fetal electrocardiographic waveform as obtained from a fetal scalp electrode. A high quality ECG signal is necessary for waveform analysis. This study examined the suitability of five commonly available scalp electrodes for collecting this signal by examining their physical and electrical characteristics, together with a randomised clinical trial in which the ECG trace quality was assessed in 50 patients. The frequency response of Copeland electrodes was such that they attenuate the ECG signal more than the baseline noise. Difficulties were experienced in obtaining optimum attachment and the long, semi-rigid design increased movement artefact resulting in significantly poorer quality ECG signals. Whilst the Hewlett-Packard double spiral electrode had a near ideal frequency response, certain design features made it difficult to apply and remain secure so the clinical signals were of intermediate quality. The Corometrics and Cetro single spirals had the most stable attachment to the scalp and a near ideal frequency response, so produced significantly better signal quality in the clinical trial. Currently, single spiral electrodes are the most suitable for electrocardiographic data collection.

Fetal ECG waveform analysis should improve fetal surveillance in labour

Fetal heart rate (FHR) and fetal electrocardiogram (ECG) recordings were obtained from a scalp electrode with maternal thigh as reference and used for ST waveform analysis in 201 patients in labour. Nearly 45% had suspicious or abnormal FHR traces whilst only 27% had T/QRS ratio greater than 0.25 (mean +/- 2 SD). A normal T/QRS ratio identified 99.3% of fetuses with normal buffering capacity in cord artery blood. Of 13 infants with a cord artery blood pH less than 7.15, standard bicarbonate was less than 15.0 mmol/l in five who had an average T/QRS ratio less than 0.25 throughout labour. Of the eight with respiratory acidosis, five had an increase in T/QRS ratio greater than 0.25 for longer than 20 minutes prior to delivery, in two the ratio increased during the last few minutes and one had no change (pH 7.14). Persistent elevation of T/QRS in the first stage of labour identified those with decrease in buffer capacity in cord arterial blood (sensitivity of 94.1%). Acute hypoxia was recognized by the rapid rise in T/QRS. The specificity of T/QRS to identify fetuses at risk increased by combining the ST waveform analysis with FHR changes.

STAN--the Gothenburg model for fetal surveillance during labour by ST analysis of the fetal electrocardiogram

Waveform analysis of the fetal ECG for fetal surveillance is regaining widespread interest. This paper presents our present knowledge on ST waveform analysis during human labour. A unipolar scalp lead with the maternal thigh as reference makes it possible to identify the T wave and at the same time decrease signal noise. The development of an ECG analyser (STAN) has enabled us to collect 201 ECG recordings during labour on which ST analysis could be undertaken. The data indicate that waveform analysis of the fetal ECG improves fetal surveillance during labour.

Fetal ECG during labour: a presentation of a microprocessor system

Changes in the ST waveform of the fetal ECG have been detected in 47 term deliveries with vertex presentations using a specially developed microprocessor-based system for on-line recording of T wave amplitude. The T wave was quantified by the T/QRS ratio. The recording included one scalp electrode for exploration and a maternal skin electrode as reference. Signal quality allowed optimal ST waveform assessment in 89% of the cases. The degree of perinatal asphyxia was judged from cord artery acid-base status and the neonatal outcome. In completely normal fetuses at term the mean T/QRS ratio was 0.148 with a standard deviation of 0.048. With this basic information we can proceed in the investigation of the T/QRS ratio as a means for fetal surveillance.