The mouse peripheral blood micronucleus test with 2-acetylaminofluorene using the acridine orange supravital staining method

Empirical Comparison of Genotoxic Potency Estimations: The In Vitro DNA-Damage ToxTracker Endpoints versus the In Vivo Micronucleus Assay

Genetic toxicology is an essential component of compound safety assessment. In the face of a barrage of new compounds, higher throughput, less ethically divisive in vitro approaches capable of effective, human-relevant hazard identification and prioritisation are increasingly important. One such approach is the ToxTracker assay, which utilises murine stem cell lines equipped with green fluorescent protein (GFP)-reporter gene constructs that each inform on distinct aspects of cellular perturbation. Encouragingly, ToxTracker has shown improved sensitivity and specificity for the detection of known in vivo genotoxicants when compared to existing ‘standard battery’ in vitro tests. At the current time however, quantitative genotoxic potency correlations between ToxTracker and well-recognised in vivo tests are not yet available. Here we use dose–response data from the three DNA-damage-focused ToxTracker endpoints and from the in vivo micronucleus assay to carry out quantitative, genotoxic potency estimations for a range of aromatic amine and alkylating agents using the benchmark dose (BMD) approach. This strategy, using both the exponential and the Hill BMD model families, was found to produce robust, visually intuitive and similarly ordered genotoxic potency rankings for 17 compounds across the BSCL2-GFP, RTKN-GFP and BTG2-GFP ToxTracker endpoints. Eleven compounds were similarly assessed using data from the in vivo micronucleus assay. Cross-systems genotoxic potency correlations for the eight matched compounds demonstrated in vitro–in vivo correlation, albeit with marked scatter across compounds. No evidence for distinct differences in the sensitivity of the three ToxTracker endpoints was found. The presented analyses show that quantitative potency determinations from in vitro data enable more than just qualitative screening and hazard identification in genetic toxicology.

Correlation of In Vivo Versus In Vitro Benchmark Doses (BMDs) Derived From Micronucleus Test Data: A Proof of Concept Study

In this study, we explored the applicability of using in vitro micronucleus (MN) data from human lymphoblastoid TK6 cells to derive in vivo genotoxicity potency information. Nineteen chemicals covering a broad spectrum of genotoxic modes of action were tested in an in vitro MN test using TK6 cells using the same study protocol. Several of these chemicals were considered to need metabolic activation, and these were administered in the presence of S9. The Benchmark dose (BMD) approach was applied using the dose-response modeling program PROAST to estimate the genotoxic potency from the in vitro data. The resulting in vitro BMDs were compared with previously derived BMDs from in vivo MN and carcinogenicity studies. A proportional correlation was observed between the BMDs from the in vitro MN and the BMDs from the in vivo MN assays. Further, a clear correlation was found between the BMDs from in vitro MN and the associated BMDs for malignant tumors. Although these results are based on only 19 compounds, they show that genotoxicity potencies estimated from in vitro tests may result in useful information regarding in vivo genotoxic potency, as well as expected cancer potency. Extension of the number of compounds and further investigation of metabolic activation (S9) and of other toxicokinetic factors would be needed to validate our initial conclusions. However, this initial work suggests that this approach could be used for in vitro to in vivo extrapolations which would support the reduction of animals used in research (3Rs: replacement, reduction, and refinement).

Estimating the carcinogenic potency of chemicals from the in vivo micronucleus test

In this study, we investigated the applicability of using in vivo mouse micronucleus (MN) data to derive cancer potency information. We also present a new statistical methodology for correlating estimated potencies between in vivo MN tests and cancer studies, which could similarly be used for other systems (e.g. in vitro vs. in vivo genotoxicity tests). The dose-response modelling program PROAST was used to calculate benchmark doses (BMDs) for estimating the genotoxic and carcinogenic potency for 48 compounds in mice; most of the data were retrieved from the National Toxicology Program (NTP) database, while some additional data were retrieved from the Carcinogenic Potency Database and published studies. BMD05s (doses with 5% increase in MN frequency) were derived from MN data, and BMD10s (doses with 10% extra cancer risk) were derived from carcinogenicity data, along with their respective lower (BMDL) and upper (BMDU) confidence bounds. A clear correlation between the in vivo MN BMD05s and the cancer BMD10s was observed when the lowest BMD05 from the in vivo MN was plotted against the lowest BMD10 from the carcinogenicity data for each individual compound. By making a further selection of BMDs related to more or less equally severe cancer lesions, the correlation was considerably improved. Getting a general scientific consensus on how we can quantitatively compare different tumour lesion types and investigating the impact of MN study duration are needed to refine this correlation analysis. Nevertheless, our results suggest that a BMD derived from genotoxicity data might provide a prediction of the tumour potency (BMD10) with an uncertainty range spanning roughly a factor of 100.

In vivo erythrocyte micronucleus assay III. Validation and regulatory acceptance of automated scoring and the use of rat peripheral blood reticulocytes, with discussion of non-hematopoietic target cells and a single dose-level limit test

The in vivo micronucleus assay working group of the International Workshop on Genotoxicity Testing (IWGT) discussed new aspects in the in vivo micronucleus (MN) test, including the regulatory acceptance of data derived from automated scoring, especially with regard to the use of flow cytometry, the suitability of rat peripheral blood reticulocytes to serve as the principal cell population for analysis, the establishment of in vivo MN assays in tissues other than bone marrow and blood (for example liver, skin, colon, germ cells), and the biological relevance of the single-dose-level test. Our group members agreed that flow cytometric systems to detect induction of micronucleated immature erythrocytes have advantages based on the presented data, e.g., they give good reproducibility compared to manual scoring, are rapid, and require only small quantities of peripheral blood. Flow cytometric analysis of peripheral blood reticulocytes has the potential to allow monitoring of chromosome damage in rodents and also other species as part of routine toxicology studies. It appears that it will be applicable to humans as well, although in this case the possible confounding effects of splenic activity will need to be considered closely. Also, the consensus of the group was that any system that meets the validation criteria recommended by the IWGT (2000) should be acceptable. A number of different flow cytometric-based micronucleus assays have been developed, but at the present time the validation data are most extensive for the flow cytometric method using anti-CD71 fluorescent staining especially in terms of inter-laboratory collaborative data. Whichever method is chosen, it is desirable that each laboratory should determine the minimum sample size required to ensure that scoring error is maintained below the level of animal-to-animal variation. In the second IWGT, the potential to use rat peripheral blood reticulocytes as target cells for the micronucleus assay was discussed, but a consensus regarding acceptability for regulatory purposes could not be reached at that time. Subsequent validation efforts, combined with accumulated published data, demonstrate that blood-derived reticulocytes from rats as well as mice are acceptable when young reticulocytes are analyzed under proper assay protocol and sample size. The working group reviewed the results of micronucleus assays using target cells/tissues other than hematopoietic cells. We also discussed the relevance of the liver micronucleus assay using young rats, and the importance of understanding the maturation of enzyme systems involved in the processes of metabolic activation in the liver of young rats. Although the consensus of the group was that the more information with regard to the metabolic capabilities of young rats would be useful, the published literature shows that young rats have sufficient metabolic capacity for the purposes of this assay. The use of young rats as a model for detecting MN induction in the liver offers a good alternative methodology to the use of partial hepatectomy or mitogenic stimulation. Additional data obtained from colon and skin MN models have been integrated into the data bases, enhancing confidence in the utility of these models. A fourth topic discussed by the working group was the regulatory acceptance of the single-dose-level assay. There was no consensus regarding the acceptability of a single dose level protocol when dose-limiting toxicity occurs. The use of a single dose level can lead to problems in data interpretation or to the loss of animals due to unexpected toxicity, making it necessary to repeat the study with additional doses. A limit test at a single dose level is currently accepted when toxicity is not dose-limiting.

An automated new technique for scoring the rodent micronucleus assay: computerized image analysis of acridine orange supravitally stained peripheral blood cells

We developed an automated image analysis system to obtain objective data for the rodent peripheral blood micronucleus assay with acridine orange (AO) supravital staining. The system was able to identify micronucleated reticulocytes (MNRETs) and to evaluate inhibition of bone marrow cell proliferation by measuring the reticular area of reticulocytes (RETs). We also developed automated equipment to produce homogeneous acridine orange-coated glass slides. This study was designed to compare automated scoring with manual scoring using 4 model clastogens and 2 mouse strains. The MNRET incidence induced by each clastogen was similar for automated and manual scoring, and there was good correlation (r=0.92) between the methods. In addition, an index of bone marrow toxicity based on the reticular area of RETs was compared to the conventional index (% of polychromatic erythrocytes (PCE) to total erythrocytes; PCE ratio) and was similar. The results indicated that our technique for computer-assisted image analysis for the micronucleus assay with AO supravitally stained peripheral blood RETs was comparable to conventional microscopic scoring, and it was superior in objectivity and statistical power.

Achievements by CSGMT/JEMS.MMS: the Collaborative Study Group for the Micronucleus Test in the Mammalian Mutagenesis Study Group of the Environmental Mutagen Society of Japan

The Collaborative Study Group for the Micronucleus Test (CSGMT) is one of the task groups in the Mammalian Mutagenesis Study Group (MMS) of the Environmental Mutagen Society of Japan (JEMS). It was established in 1982 and has made efforts to understand what the micronucleus test is, what are the advantages and disadvantages of the test as an in vivo detection system for mutagens/carcinogens, and to establish a standard protocol applicable to numerous chemicals. Members of the CSGMT have published more than 75 papers as part of collaborative studies and have contributed to the understanding of the nature of the micronucleus test and to setting guidelines for testing of medicinal and other chemicals. The CSGMT held some workshops to share up-to-date knowledge and techniques on the micronucleus test. Through workshops and collaborative studies, the CSGMT contributed to the maintaining of a high standard of knowledge and techniques among Japanese researchers of the micronucleus test. This paper reviews achievements made by the CSGMT until now.

Bone marrow micronucleus assay: a review of the mouse stocks used and their published mean spontaneous micronucleus frequencies

We have examined published negative control data from 581 papers on micronucleated bone marrow polychromatic erythrocytes (mnPCE) for differences in mean frequency and the frequency distribution profile among the mouse stocks used with the bone marrow micronucleus assay. For the 55 mouse stocks with published micronucleus assay data, the overall mean frequency is 1.95 mnPCE/1,000 PCE (1.95 mnPCE/1,000); for the 13 stocks most commonly used in the assay, it is 1.88 mnPCE/1,000. During the last 5 years, the mnPCE rate for these 13 major stocks has been 1.74 mnPCE/1,000. This current mean frequency is a substantial decrease from the mean of 3.07 mnPCE/1,000 observed for these 13 stocks for data published prior to 1981. Of the major stocks, the highest mean mnPCE negative control frequencies were observed for MS/Ae > BALB/c > C57Bl/6, and the lowest for CD-1 < Swiss Webster. We note that hybrid mouse stocks appear to have lower and less variable negative control frequencies than either of their parent strains and that the negative control frequency for some progeny stocks have diverged significantly from that of the parent stocks. Overall mean negative control frequencies appear to be correlated with breadth of the frequency distribution profile of published mean negative control values. Furthermore, a possible correlation between negative control frequency in the micronucleus assay and sensitivity to clastogens of different mouse strains may be indicated. The databases generated here allow us to define a range of norms for both the historical mean frequency and individual experimental mean frequencies for most stocks, but in particular, for the more commonly used mouse stocks. Our analysis, for the most part, bears out the recommendation of the first Gene-Tox Report on the micronucleus assay that the historical negative control frequency for a mouse stock should fall between 1 and 3 mnPCE/1,000. Eighty-six percent of the most commonly used mouse stocks have historical mean frequencies within this range. Though individual experimental mean values would not necessarily be expected to fall within the 1-3.00 mnPCE/1,000 range, 65.3% of the 2,327 published negative control values do, and 83.5% are < 3 mnPCE/1,000. The frequency with which an individual experimental mean value lies outside the 1.00 to 3.00 mnPCE/1,000 range differs among stocks and appears related to the mouse mean frequency. We suggest that the recommended range for historical mean frequency be extended slightly, to approximately 3.4 mnPCE/1,000, to accommodate some commonly used strains with overall mean negative control frequencies just above 3.00 mnPCE/1,000.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Micronucleus induction in mouse peripheral blood reticulocytes by 2,7-diaminophenazine and related compounds

The peripheral blood micronucleus test using acridine orange (AO) supravital staining was performed with phenazine (Pz), 1-aminophenazine (1-APz), 2-aminophenazine (2-APz) and 2,7-diaminophenazine (2,7-DAPz). Male ICR mice and BDF1 mice were treated intraperitoneally once or twice 24 h apart with each chemical. Irrespective of the number of administrations, Pz and 1-APz were not clastogenic in either mouse strain. In the single treatment regime, 2-APz slightly increased micronucleated reticulocytes (MNRETs) 48 h after 200 mg/kg dosing in ICR mice and 72 h after 400 mg/kg dosing in BDF1 mice. The MNRET frequencies were not enhanced after double treatment in either mouse strain. The single treatment with 2,7-DAPz strongly and dose-dependently induced MNRETs in BDF1 mice, and the incidences of MNRETs, which peaked 48 or 72 h after treatment, were much higher than those in ICR mice. In both mouse strains, the frequencies of MNRETs observed after double treatment with 2,7-DAPz were higher than those after single treatment. The MNRET incidence induced 72 h after first 200 mg/kg dosing in BDF1 mice was 2.21%.

Micronuclei induced in peripheral blood of E mu-PIM-1 transgenic mice by chronic oral treatment with 2-acetylaminofluorene or benzene but not with diethyl-nitrosamine or 1,2-dichloroethane

Micronucleus induction in peripheral blood was examined during carcinogenicity assays of the genotoxic carcinogens 2-acetylaminofluorene (2-AAF), benzene, diethylnitrosamine (DEN) and 1,2-dichloroethane (1,2-DCE) in lymphoma prone E mu-PIM-1 transgenic mice. In both sexes, micronuclei were increased in polychromatic (PCE) and normochromatic (NCE) erythrocytes after 14 weeks of oral treatment with 75 mg/kg 2-AAF or 50 and 100 mg/kg benzene. The micronucleus frequencies induced by benzene were higher in males than in females. There was no apparent treatment related suppression of erythropoiesis by 2-AAF or by benzene. Blood micronucleus frequencies induced by benzene were similar in transgenic mice and their non-transgenic litter mates. There was no micronucleus induction or PCE suppression detected in the blood of either sex after treatment with 1 and 3 mg/kg DEN or 100 to 300 mg/kg 1,2-DCE. At 40 weeks bone marrow was sampled from mice given 100 mg/kg benzene, and it was confirmed that micronucleated PCE frequencies in blood were an accurate reflection of those induced in bone marrow. However, the spontaneous and induced frequencies of micronucleated cells in blood were slightly higher in PCE than in NCE suggesting that a small degree of selective removal of micronucleated cells occurs in this mouse strain. Control micronucleus frequencies in E mu-PIM-1 mice appeared comparable to those in other, non-transgenic mouse strains. Thus micronuclei are readily detectable in blood during chronic exposure to the bone-marrow clastogens 2-AAF and benzene, but not to DEN and 1,2-DCE, probably because active species do not reach the bone marrow in sufficient concentrations to induce increases in micronuclei.