The structure and origin of giant nuclei in human cancer cells

Polyteny: still a giant player in chromosome research

In this era of high-resolution mapping of chromosome territories, topological interactions, and chromatin states, it is increasingly appreciated that the positioning of chromosomes and their interactions within the nucleus is critical for cellular function. Due to their large size and distinctive structure, polytene chromosomes have contributed a wealth of knowledge regarding chromosome regulation. In this review, we discuss the diversity of polytene chromosomes in nature and in disease, examine the recurring structural features of polytene chromosomes in terms of what they reveal about chromosome biology, and discuss recent advances regarding how polytene chromosomes are assembled and disassembled. After over 130 years of study, these giant chromosomes are still powerful tools to understand chromosome biology.

Distinct responses to reduplicated chromosomes require distinct Mad2 responses

Duplicating chromosomes once each cell cycle produces sister chromatid pairs, which separate accurately at anaphase. In contrast, reduplicating chromosomes without separation frequently produces polytene chromosomes, a barrier to accurate mitosis. Chromosome reduplication occurs in many contexts, including: polytene tissue development, polytene tumors, and following treatment with mitosis-blocking chemotherapeutics. However, mechanisms responding to or resolving polyteny during mitosis are poorly understood. Here, using Drosophila, we uncover two distinct reduplicated chromosome responses. First, when reduplicated polytene chromosomes persist into metaphase, an anaphase delay prevents tissue malformation and apoptosis. Second, reduplicated polytene chromosomes can also separate prior to metaphase through a spindle-independent mechanism termed Separation-Into-Recent-Sisters (SIRS). Both reduplication responses require the spindle assembly checkpoint protein Mad2. While Mad2 delays anaphase separation of metaphase polytene chromosomes, Mad2’s control of overall mitotic timing ensures efficient SIRS. Our results pinpoint mechanisms enabling continued proliferation after genome reduplication, a finding with implications for cancer progression and prevention.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.15204.001

Before a cell divides, it duplicates all its genetic information, which is stored on chromosomes. Then, each chromosome evenly divides into two new cells so that each cell ends up with identical copies of the genetic information. Because the cellular machinery that evenly divides chromosomes is built to recognize chromosomes that were duplicated exactly once, it is important to maintain this pattern of alternating one round of duplication with one round of division. Cells that instead duplicate their chromosomes more than once can make mistakes during division that are associated with diseases such as cancer.

Chromosomes with extra duplications are present in normal tissues such as the placenta of mammals. They can also occur in human diseases and may even result from chemotherapy treatment. However, we know almost nothing about how cells respond to these problematic chromosomes when dividing.

By studying cells from the Drosophila melanogaster species of fruit fly, Stormo and Fox discovered two distinct ways in which cells respond to extra chromosome duplications. One response occurs in cells that were experimentally engineered to undergo an extra chromosome duplication. These cells delay division so that the chromosome separation machinery can somehow adapt to the challenge of separating more than two chromosome copies at once. The second response occurs in cells that naturally undergo extra chromosome duplications before division. In these cells, Stormo and Fox discovered a new type of chromosome separation, whereby the extra chromosome copies move apart from each other before cell division. In doing so the chromosomes can better interact with the chromosome separation machinery during division.

Stormo and Fox also found that a protein named Mad2 is important in both responses, and gives the cell enough time to respond to extra chromosome copies. Without Mad2, the separation of chromosomes with extra duplications is too hasty, and can lead to severe cell division errors and cause organs to form incorrectly.

Having uncovered two new responses that cells use to adapt to extra chromosomes, it will now be important to find other proteins like Mad2 that are important in these events. Understanding these processes and the proteins involved in more detail could help to prevent diseases that are associated with extra chromosomes.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.15204.002

Hypoxia and defective apoptosis drive genomic instability and tumorigenesis

Genomic instability is a hallmark of cancer development and progression, and characterizing the stresses that create and the mechanisms by which cells respond to genomic perturbations is essential. Here we demonstrate that antiapoptotic BCL-2 family proteins promoted tumor formation of transformed baby mouse kidney (BMK) epithelial cells by antagonizing BAX- and BAK-dependent apoptosis. Cell death in vivo correlated with hypoxia and induction of PUMA (p53 up-regulated modulator of apoptosis). Strikingly, carcinomas formed by transformed BMK cells in which apoptosis was blocked by aberrant BCL-2 family protein function displayed prevalent, highly polyploid, tumor giant cells. Examination of the transformed BMK cells in vivo revealed aberrant metaphases and ploidy changes in tumors as early as 9 d after implantation, which progressed in magnitude during the tumorigenic process. An in vitro ischemia system mimicked the tumor microenvironment, and gain of BCL-2 or loss of BAX and BAK was sufficient to confer resistance to apoptosis and to allow for accumulation of polyploid cells in vitro. These data suggest that in vivo, even in cells in which p53 function is compromised, apoptosis is an essential response to hypoxia and ischemia in the tumor microenvironment and that abrogation of this response allows the survival of cells with abnormal genomes and promotes tumorigenesis.

Polyploidization in the trophoblast and uterine glandular epithelium of the endotheliochorial placenta of silver fox (Vulpes fulvus Desm.), as revealed by the DNA content

Dynamics of genome multiplication during establishment of interrelations between trophoblast and glandular epithelium of the endometrium has been studied in the course of formation of placenta in the silver fox. During formation of the placenta, penetration of the trophoblast into the zone of the endometrial glandular epithelium and of endometrial blood vessels into the zone of expanding trophoblast occurs. The trophoblast, which gradually replaces epithelium and a part of the stroma of the endometrium, closely adjoins endometrial vessels but does not disrupt them, thereby the endotheliochorial placenta is formed. Cytophotometric measurements of the DNA content in trophoblast nuclei have shown that most of them are polyploid: predominantly 4-64c, occasionally 128c and 256c. Polyploidy of the trophoblast may be a consequence of various types of polyploidizing mitoses. Cytophotometric measurements of the DNA content in mitotic figures have revealed the presence of mitoses of diploid cells, i.e. with the DNA amount of 4c (2n), and polyploid cells, i.e. 8c (4n), and 16c (8n), therefore trophoblast cells in the silver fox placenta are able to enter mitosis up to the octaploid level. Higher degrees of polyploidy in the trophoblast cells seem to be achieved by endoreduplication. Polyploidization of the uterine glandular epithelial cells during placentation in the silver fox occurs until the level of 8c. Thus, the tissue-specific response of the uterus to the implanting embryo consists of active proliferation and polyploidization of the glandular epithelium, which may compensate formation of prominent population of decidual cells (i.e., connective tissue cells). In the endotheliochorial placenta of the silver fox the regularity is confirmed that cells of both maternal and fetal origin are, as a rule, polyploid in sites of their contact in placenta, which may be of protective significance in the contact of allogenic organisms.

Microphotometrical image analysis of the subtelomeric region of T-banded endoreduplicated chromosomes of Chinese hamster ovary cells

Microphotometrical scanning and computer graphic image analysis were carried out to detect the distribution of chromatin densities in subtelomeric segments of T-banded endoreduplicated chromosomes of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. Chromatin density patterns detected with this method were similar to those previously found in CHO and normal human chromosomes. The highest chromatin densities were considered as marker segments which led to the detection of reciprocal changes of position in endoreduplicated chromosomes during cell spreading on the slide. The problem of the subtelomeric T-banding density patterns found in the endoreduplicated chromosomes and their relation to the structure and molecular composition of this region is briefly discussed.

Naevocyte triggering by recombinant human growth hormone

The influence of growth hormone and insulin-like growth factor I on human melanocytes is being increasingly recognized. Clinical evidence has shown that when recombinant human growth hormone (hGH) is administered to children of short stature, the growth of melanocytic naevi is boosted. This study was conducted on 56 hGH-triggered naevi and nine similar lesions excised before or after hGH therapy for hypopituitarism and Turner's syndrome. A series of 40 naevi excised from age-matched healthy children served as controls. Atypicality of naevocytes was investigated using image analysis, AgNOR counts, immunohistochemistry (HMB-45, NKI-C3, Ki-67, anti-bcl-2-oncoprotein), and DNA flow cytometry. The data associate hGH treatment with anisokaryosis and increased AgNOR and Ki-67 counts in naevocytes. The same cells also show abnormal patterns of HMB-45 immunolabelling. These indications of naevocyte activation were not suggestive of malignant transformation. hGH-triggered melanocytomas should be added to the list of atypical melanocytic naevi. The long-term evolution of these lesions remains unknown and the potential risk of malignant transformation awaits careful evaluation.

Polytene chromosomes in mammalian cells

This article deals with the structural and functional organization of polytene chromosomes in mammals. Based on cytophotometric, autoradiographic, and electron microscopic data, the authors put forward a concept of nonclassic polytene chromosomes, with special reference to polytene chromosomes in the mammalian placenta. In cells with nonclassic polytene chromosomes, two phases of the polytene nucleus cycle are described, such as the endointerphase (S phase) and endoprophase (G phase). The authors generalize that the main feature of nonclassic polytene chromosomes is that forces binding the sister chromatids are much weaker than in the Diptera classic polytene chromosomes. This concept is confirmed by comparative studies of human, mink, and fox polytene chromosomes. The final step of the trophoblast giant cell differentiation is characterized by a transition from polyteny to polyploidy, with subsequent fragmentation of the highly polyploid nucleus into fragments of low ploidy. Similarities and dissimilarities of pathways of formation and rearrangement of nonclassic polytene chromosomes in mammals, insects, plants, and protozoans are compared. The authors discuss the significance of polyteny as one of the intrinsic conditions for performance of the fixed genetic program of trophoblast giant cell development, a program that provides for the possibility of a long coexistence between maternal and fetal allogenic organisms during pregnancy.

Significance of polyploidy in megakaryocytes and other cells in health and tumor disease

Polyploidy--the doubling of chromosome sets of cells caused by a stop of mitosis at different levels of the mitotic cycle--is a phenomenon widely observed in plants, protozoa, metazoa, and animals. In man obligate polyploid tissues are found in liver parenchyma, heart muscle cells, and bone marrow megakaryocytes. Polyploidy occurs mostly in stable and highly differentiated cells and tissues. Besides age, stimulation of proliferation and increased metabolic function lead to polyploidization in these organs. Aneuploidy, however, is exclusively found in tumor cells. Megakaryocyte differentiation and polyploidy are controlled by thrombopoietin-like activities, of which the loci of production are still unknown. Megakaryocytes are unique among polyploid mammal cells. On the precursor level they maintain their proliferative activity independently of the mammal's age. Once having entered the incomplete mitotic cycle they stop cytokinesis and develop into highly polyploid cells. Polyploidization of megakaryocytes is the basic requirement for establishing highly effective hemostasis in mammals, which exhibit blood circulation based on high blood pressures. Every polyploidization results in increased production of membrane materials with which the platelet becomes endowed. By shedding cytoplasmic fragments approximately 3000 platelets are set free from a 32c megakaryocyte, compared with only 16 nucleated thrombocytes by mitotic division. There is further evidence that the heterogeneity of platelets mostly depends on the different polyploidy classes of the megakaryocytes from which they are derived. Changes in the polyploidy pattern of megakaryocytes could therefore have consequences for hemostatic disorders in several human diseases, particularly in malignancy.

The course of endomitosis in human cells

The course of endomitosis in human hydatidiform moles has been analyzed. It differs from the classical description of endomitosis in that endoprophase is completely missing and, very probably, so is a typical interphase. The chromosomes are even less synchronized in their replication and condensation cycle than in normal mitosis. At no point do all chromosomes decondense, but a part remains condensed while others are extended and in the process of synthesizing DNA. Even two paired sister chromosomes may replicate nonsynchronously. The latest replicating chromosome is usually a large darkly staining chromosome, which we tentatively identify as the inactive X. No DNA synthesis takes place during "endometaphase" or "endoanaphase" stages, when the chromosomes are most condensed. Some polyploid "endoanaphases" or "endotelophases" with stretched out chromosomes obviously represent end-stages of the endomitotic pathway, and the nuclei are in the process of reverting into evenly stained nuclei. In some "endometaphases," a near-haploid number of chromosomes can be counted. In others, the endochromosomes seem to be compound structures consisting of several chromosomes that have not separated during the previous endomitoses. This is seen also in normal trophoblast and cervical cancer. In large cancer cells, such bundles can be seen in the process of falling into individual chromosomes.

X chromatin, endomitoses, and mitotic abnormalities in human cervical cancer

The incidence of X chromatin bodies and mitotic modifications and aberrations has been analyzed using Feulgen-squash preparations in 47 cervical cancers from Helsinki and 35 from Madison. Sixteen of the 82 tumors did not display any X chromatin bodies, and some others showed a lower than normal frequency, especially in the large nuclei. Different hypotheses to explain the absence of Barr bodies in female tumors have been reviewed. A new observation is that 44/82 tumors contained endomitoses. The metaphase/prophase ratio (M/P) was higher than 1.5 in all but three cases, reaching values as high as 23.0 (Madison) and 34.2 (Helsinki), and in one exceptional case, 51.8. The different types of cells, mitotic, endomitotic, and those with large to giant nuclei, form their own strands or layers. Cervical cancer is diagnosed earlier in Finland than in Madison due to a Pap mass screening program, and consequently, the survival of the patients after 5 years was 27/47 in Helsinki and 6/35 in Madison. No correlation could be established between the M/P (or other mitotic phenomena) or the stage and grade of the tumor, the age of the patient, or survival time.

Mechanisms of growth in hydatidiform moles

Nuclear morphology and DNA synthesis were analyzed to determine the mechanism through which hydatidiform moles proliferate. Hydatidiform moles are characterized by a great variation in nuclear morphology and size. There are cells with small nuclei of variable size that have chromocenters and Barr bodies which do not undergo DNA synthesis or mitosis, as well as cells in the diploid range that have evenly stained nuclei that display numerous mitoses and a high proportion of interphase nuclei in the process of DNA synthesis. Nuclei in the medium range show classical endomitotic stages. Endomitotic nuclei in endometaphase do not label with tritiated thymidine; endoanaphase nuclei may have one or a few chromosomes labeled, and endotelophase nuclei are heavily labeled. Nuclei that are evenly stained and are in the medium- to giant-size range label differently, depending upon their size. Many of the medium-sized nuclei are labeled, indicating DNA synthesis; the large nuclei are rarely labeled, and the giant nuclei are never labeled. The growth of a hydatidiform mole appears to be the result of normal mitosis and cytokinesis, as well as polyploidization and accompanying cell enlargement achieved through endomitosis and endoreduplication.

Mitotic modifications and aberrations in human cervical cancer

Mitotic modifications and aberrations characteristic of human malignant tumors have been analyzed and illustrated in cervical cancer. Most of them can be explained by assuming that the coordination of the centrosomal and chromosomal mechanisms, typical of normal mitosis, is disturbed. When the spindle mechanism is ahead of the chromosomes, the prophase is relatively shortened. This expresses itself in an increase of the ratio of metaphases to prophases (M/P), which in normal tissues is around 1. With M/P values of 4-6, the first tripolar metaphases are formed, and with higher ratios, divisions having more and more poles appear. The spindle and the chromosomes are out of step in the opposite direction in endocycles, in which the spindle is slowed down or absent. The most common of the endocycles is endoreduplication, followed by endomitosis, which is found in more than half of the cervical cancers. Mitotic abnormalities include lagging chromosomes in metaphase and anaphase and bridges in anaphase, which, when numerous, may lead to restitution. More sporadically occurring are C-mitosis and other abnormalities, including cell and nuclear fusions. There is a wide range of variation in the occurrence and frequency of chromocenters within a tumor, and an even greater variation between tumors. About one-fifth of cervical cancers lack X chromatin bodies. The abnormal chromosome constitutions in cancer are the result of various mitotic modifications and aberrations, as well as chromosome rearrangements. New chromosome combinations are constantly created and selection promotes the fastest dividing ones, which, in turn, become new stem lines of the tumor.

Endomitosis: a reappraisal

The concept and role of endomitosis is reevaluated in the light of observations on three organisms. Endomitosis which morphologically agrees with Geitler's (1939) classical definition is compared in tapetal cells of the liliaceous plant Eremurus, in the septal cells of the testicular follicles of the grasshopper Melanoplus, and in human cells from normal and molar trophoblasts and cervical cancer. These observations, together with those of Kidnadze and Istomina (1980), show that functionally at least two fundamentally different types of endomitosis exist, although morphologically the stages resemble each other in the three organisms. In the first type, exemplified by Eremurus, each endomitosis leads to a chromosome constitution which represents one level higher ploidy, a course that has been assumed to be characteristic of endomitosis in general. The second type, observed in its most characteristic form in the grasshopper, seems to be stationary: no DNA synthesis occurs, but an intensive RNA synthesis takes place. Presumably such cells have reached a final state in their development and are specialized in manufacturing one or more gene products. Endomitosis in normal placenta comes near this type, although DNA synthesis takes place in occasional cells. However, similar endomitotic nuclei in the hydatiform moles are in the process of DNA synthesis. When endomitosis is analyzed in different organisms and tissues, the observation that this process is not one entity should be kept in mind.