Migration of activated lymphocytes when adoptively transferred into cannulated rat brain

Immunological considerations of modern animal models of malignant primary brain tumors

Recent advances in animal models of glioma have facilitated a better understanding of biological mechanisms underlying gliomagenesis and glioma progression. The limitations of existing therapy, including surgery, chemotherapy, and radiotherapy, have prompted numerous investigators to search for new therapeutic approaches to improve quantity and quality of survival from these aggressive lesions. One of these approaches involves triggering a tumor specific immune response. However, a difficulty in this approach is the the scarcity of animal models of primary CNS neoplasms which faithfully recapitulate these tumors and their interaction with the host's immune system. In this article, we review the existing methods utilized to date for modeling gliomas in rodents, with a focus on the known as well as potential immunological aspects of these models. As this review demonstrates, many of these models have inherent immune system limitations, and the impact of these limitations on studies on the influence of pre-clinical therapeutics testing warrants further attention.

Brain CD8+ and cytotoxic T lymphocytes are associated with, and may be specific for, human immunodeficiency virus type 1 encephalitis in patients with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome

CD8+ T cells infiltrate brains with human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) encephalitis (HIVE) and related animal models; their perineuronal localization suggests cytotoxic T cell (CTL)-mediated neuronal killing. Because CTLs have not been identified in acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) brains, the authors identified their cytotoxic granules in autopsy AIDS brains with HIVE and without HIVE (HIVnE) plus controls (7 to 13 cases/group) and determined gene expression profiles of CTL-associated genes in a separate series of cases. CD3+ and CD8+ T cells were significantly increased (P < .01) in perivascular spaces and inflammatory nodules in HIVE but were rare or absent in brain parenchyma in HIVnE and control brains. Eight HIVE brains contained granzyme B+ T cells and five contained perforin+ T cells. Their T-cell origin was confirmed by colocalization of CD8 and granzyme B in the same cell and the absence of CD56+ natural killer cells. The CTLs directly contacted with neurons, as the authors showed previously for CD3+ and CD8+ T cells. CTLs were rare or absent in HIV nonencephalitis (HIVnE) and controls. Granzyme B and H precursor gene expression was up-regulated and interleukin (IL)-12A precursor, a maturation factor for natural killer cells and CTLs, was down-regulated in HIVE versus HIVnE brain. This study demonstrates, for the first time, CTLs in HIVE and shows that parenchymal T cells and CTLs are sensitive biomarkers for HIVE. Consequently, CD8+ T cells and CTLs could mediate brain injury in HIVE and may represent an important biomarker for productive brain infection by HIV-1.

Microglia phagocytose alloreactive CTL-damaged 9L gliosarcoma cells

Intracranial adoptive transfers of alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (aCTL) for brain tumor treatment were safe and showed promise in preclinical and early clinical trials. To better understand the endogenous immune responses that may ensue following cellular therapy with aCTL, we examined the ability of microglia to phagocytose aCTL-damaged and undamaged rat 9L gliosarcoma cells in vitro and in vivo. In vitro, 5.5+/-0.9% of microglial cells isolated from adult tumor-bearing rat brains phagocytosed aCTL-damaged 9L cells, whereas microglia did not bind to or ingest undamaged 9L cells. Addition of supernates from either 9L cell cultures or from aCTL+9L co-incubate cell cultures to microglia did not significantly alter their ability to bind to or phagocytose damaged glioma cells even though the latter contained T helper 1 and 2 cytokines. At 3 days following intracranial 9L cell infusion, 17.5+/-0.1% of the microglia phagocytosed CFSE-labeled aCTL-damaged 9L tumor cells within the adult rat brain, confirming the in vitro data. The results suggest that microglia within the tumor microenvironment of the adult rat glioma model selectively remove damaged, but not undamaged, glioma cells.

Human alloreactive CTL interactions with gliomas and with those having upregulated HLA expression from exogenous IFN-gamma or IFN-gamma gene modification

By flow cytometry, a panel of 18 primary glioma cell explants exhibited high expression of class I HLA-A, B, C, but class II HLA-DR expression was absent. Freshly isolated normal brain cells displayed little or no HLA antigens. Alloreactive cytotoxic T lymphocytes (aCTL), sensitized to the HLA of the patient, were generated in a one-way mixed lymphocyte response (MLR). The specificity of aCTL was confirmed to be to target cells (patient glioma cells or lymphoblasts) expressing the relevant HLA antigens. However, nontumor patient-specific aCTL did not lyse normal brain cells. Titration of antibodies to HLA class I into cytotoxicity assays blocked lysis of gliomas by aCTL, confirming aCTL T cell receptor (TCR) interactions with the class I antigen on gliomas. Furthermore, aCTL interactions with glioma cells caused their apoptosis. Coincubations of aCTL with gliomas resulted in upregulated cytokine secretion. Importantly, dexamethasone, an immunosuppressive steroid used for brain edema, did not affect aCTL lytic function against tumor, indicating that steroid-dependent patients may benefit from the immunotherapy. We also explored the use of interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) to increase aCTL tumor recognition. Coincubation of gliomas with exogenous IFN-gamma (500 U/ml, 48 h) caused a 3-fold upregulation of HLA class I and a slight induction of class II antigen expression. Gene-modified glioma cells producing IFN-gamma similarly displayed upregulated HLA expression. Glioma cells incubated with exogenous IFN-gamma or IFN-gamma-transduced glioma cells were more susceptible to lysis by aCTL than their parental counterparts, thus supporting the concept of combining IFN-gamma cytokine gene therapy with adoptive aCTL immunotherapy for brain tumor treatment.

Distribution of adoptively transferred, tumor-sensitized lymphocytes in the glioma-bearing rat

For adoptively transferred lymphocytes to exert anti-tumor effects in vivo, they must traffic or initiate the migration of endogenous immune cells to the site of tumor. Using a rat model, we examined the trafficking of tumor-sensitized lymphocytes to an intracerebral glioma. By labeling the cells with 111Indium oxine (111In) prior to intravenous injection, we were able to quantify the relative number of lymphocytes that traveled to the tumor site. There was no difference in lymphocytic influx between the tumor-bearing and non-tumor-bearing cerebral hemispheres in 3-day rat glioma models. However, in 7-day models, significantly greater numbers of 111In-labeled lymphocytes resided in the tumor-bearing hemisphere at 12 h post-administration. This number increased more than two-fold by 24 h post-adoptive transfer. Using fluorescent-labeled lymphocytes and microscopy, we confirmed that the detection of radioactivity within the brain was truly due to tumor infiltrating 111In-labeled lymphocytes. Adoptively transferred cells were found in perivascular and peritumoral locations. These data demonstrate that tumor-sensitized lymphocytes traffic to an intracerebral target site where they can exert an effect, further supporting adoptive immunotherapy as a treatment for glioma.

New tools to trace populations of inflammatory cells in the CNS

Cells of the central nervous system (CNS) and immune system communicate regularly. There is a constant surveillance of the intact, healthy CNS by activated T-cells, and massive infiltration of the CNS by immune cells under pathological conditions such as neurodegeneration or neuroinflammation. Labeling CNS-infiltrating T-cells is an essential tool to identify the signals and mechanisms, which mediate the interaction between immune cells and cells of the CNS. In this article, we will present an overview describing currently used cellular markers and demonstrate how these markers have contributed to our current knowledge of CNS inflammation and immune surveillance.

Glioma immunology and immunotherapy

OBJECTIVE

Despite advances in conventional therapy, the prognosis for most glioma patients remains dismal. This has prompted an intensive search for effective treatment alternatives. Immunotherapy, one such alternative, has long been recognized as a potentially potent cancer treatment but has been limited by an inadequate understanding of the immune system. Now, increased insight into immunology is suggesting more rational approaches to immunotherapy. In this article, we explore key aspects of modern immunology and discuss their implications for glioma therapy.

METHODS

A thorough literature review of glioma immunology and immunotherapy was undertaken to inquire into the basic immunology, central nervous system immunology, glioma immunobiology, standard glioma immunotherapy, and recent immunotherapeutic advances in glioma treatment.

RESULTS

Although gliomas express tumor-associated antigens and appear potentially sensitive to immune responses, many factors work together to inhibit antiglioma immunity. Not surprisingly, most clinical attempts at glioma immunotherapy have met with little success to date. However, novel immunostimulatory strategies, such as immunogene therapy, directed cytokine delivery, and dendritic cell manipulation, have recently yielded dramatic preclinical results in glioma models. This suggests that glioma-derived immunosuppression can be overcome.

CONCLUSION

Modern molecular biology and immunology techniques have yielded a wealth of new data about glioma immunobiology. Armed with this information, many investigators have proposed novel means to stimulate antiglioma immune responses. Although definitive clinical results remain to be seen, the current renaissance in glioma immunology and immunotherapy shows great promise for the future.

Fluorescent dyes for lymphocyte migration and proliferation studies

Fluorescent dyes are increasingly being exploited to track lymphocyte migration and proliferation. The present paper reviews the properties and performance of some 14 different fluorescent dyes that have been used during the last 20 years to monitor lymphocyte migration. Of the 14 dyes discussed, two stand out as being the most versatile in terms of long-term tracking of lymphocytes and their ability to quantify lymphocyte proliferation. They are the intracellular covalent coupling dye carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl ester (CFSE) and the membrane inserting dye PKH26. Both dyes have the advantage that they can be used to track cell division, both in vitro and in vivo, due to the progressive halving of the fluorescence intensity of the dyes in cells after each division. However, CFSE appears to have the edge over PKH26 based on homogeneity of lymphocyte staining and cost. Two other fluorescent dyes, although not suitable for lymphocyte proliferation studies, are valuable tracking dyes for short-term (up to 3 day) lymphocyte migration experiments, namely the DNA-binding dye Hoechst 33342 and the cytoplasmic dye calcein. In the future it is highly likely that additional fluorescent dyes, with different spectral properties to CFSE, will become available, as well as membrane inserting fluorescent dyes that more homogeneously label lymphocytes than PKH26.

Rat brain tumor models in experimental neuro-oncology: the 9L, C6, T9, F98, RG2 (D74), RT-2 and CNS-1 gliomas

Rat brain tumor models have been widely used in experimental neuro-oncology for almost three decades. The present review, which will be selective rather than comprehensive, will focus entirely on seven rat brain tumor models and their utility in evaluating the efficacy of various therapeutic modalities. Although no currently available animal brain tumor model exactly simulates human high grade brain tumors, the rat models that are currently available have provided a wealth of information on in vitro and in vivo biochemical and biological properties of brain tumors and their in vivo responses to various therapeutic modalities. Ideally, valid brain tumor models should be derived from glial cells, grow in vitro and in vivo with predictable and reproducible growth patterns that simulate human gliomas, be weakly or non-immunogenic, and their response to therapy, or lack thereof, should resemble human brain tumors. The following tumors will be discussed. The 9L gliosarcoma, which was chemically induced in an inbred Fischer rat, has been one of the most widely used of all rat brain tumor models and has provided much useful information relating to brain tumor biology and therapy. The T9 glioma, although generally unrecognized, was and probably still is the same as the 9L. Both of these tumors can be immunogenic under the appropriate circumstances, and this must be taken into consideration when using either of them for studies of therapeutic efficacy, especially if survival is used as an endpoint. The C6 glioma, which was chemically induced in an outbred Wistar rat, has been extensively used for a variety of studies, but is not syngeneic to any inbred strain. Its potential to evoke an alloimmune response is a serious limitation, if it is being used in survival studies. The F98 and RG2 (D74) gliomas were both chemically induced tumors that appear to be either weakly or non-immunogenic. These tumors have been refractory to a variety of therapeutic modalities and their invasive pattern of growth and uniform lethality following an innoculum of as few as 10 tumor cells make them particularly attractive models to test new therapeutic modalities. The Avian Sarcoma Virus induced tumors and a continuous cell line derived from one of them, designated RT-2, have been useful for studies in which de novo tumor induction is an important requirement. These tumors, however, are immunogenic and this may limit their usefulness for survival studies. Finally, a new chemically induced tumor recently has been described, the CNS-1, and it appears to have a number of properties that should make it useful in experimental neuro-oncology. It is essential to recognize, however, the limitations of each of the models that have been described, and depending upon the nature of the study to be conducted, it is important that the appropriate model be selected.

The failure of current immunotherapy for malignant glioma. Tumor-derived TGF-beta, T-cell apoptosis, and the immune privilege of the brain

Human malignant gliomas are rather resistant to all current therapeutic approaches including surgery, radiotherapy and chemotherapy as well as antibody-guided or cellular immunotherapy. The immunotherapy of malignant glioma has attracted interest because of the immunosuppressed state of malignant glioma patients which resides mainly in the T-cell compartment. This T-cell suppression has been attributed to the release by the glioma cells of immunosuppressive factors like transforming growth factor-beta (TGF-beta) and prostaglandins. TGF-beta has multiple effects in the immune system, most of which are inhibitory. TGF-beta appears to control downstream elements of various cellular activation cascades and regulates the expression of genes that are essential for cell cycle progression and mitosis. Since TGF-beta-mediated growth arrest of T-cell lines results in their apoptosis in vitro, glioma-derived TGF-beta may prevent immune-mediated glioma cell elimination by inducing apoptosis of tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes in vivo. T-cell apoptosis in the brain may be augmented by the absence of professional antigen-presenting cells and of appropriate costimulating signals. Numerous in vitro studies predict that tumor-derived TGF-beta will incapacitate in vitro-expanded and locally administered lymphokine-activated killer cells (LAK-cells) or tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes. Thus, TGF-beta may be partly responsible for the failure of current adoptive cellular immunotherapy of malignant glioma. Recent experimental in vivo studies on non-glial tumors have corroborated that neutralization of tumor-derived TGF-beta activity may facilitate immune-mediated tumor rejection. Current efforts to improve the efficacy of immunotherapy for malignant glioma include various strategies to enhance the immunogenicity of glioma cells and the cytotoxic activity of immune effector cells, e.g., by cytokine gene transfer. Future strategies of cellular immunotherapy for malignant glioma will have to focus on rendering glioma cell-targeting immune cells resistent to local inactivation and apoptosis which may be induced by TGF-beta and other immunosuppressive molecules at the site of neoplastic growth. Cytotoxic effectors targeting Fas/APO-1, the receptor protein for perforin-independent cytotoxic T-cell killing, might be promising, since Fas/APO-1 is expressed by glioma cells but not by untransformed brain cells, and since Fas/APO-1-mediated killing in vitro is not inhibited by TGF-beta.