Specificity of spontaneous mutation in the lacI gene cloned into bacteriophage M13

Spontaneous mutant frequency and mutation spectrum for gene A of phiX174 grown in E. coli

The use of transgenic targets for measuring mutant frequencies in mammalian tissue requires an estimate of the mutant frequency that results from recovery of the transgene in bacterial recovery systems. In this study, we have determined the spontaneous mutant frequency, estimated the mutation rate, and ascertained the mutation spectrum for gene A of phiX174 grown in E. coli strain CQ2 from 156 small independent cultures. The mutant frequency of 12 of the 156 cultures was 17 +/- 1.0 x 10(-6) and the estimated mutation rate per gene replication was 7.4 +/- 2.3 x 10(-6). The mutant frequency and spectrum from E. coli were not significantly different from that of solvent-treated embryonic mouse cells in culture, 19 +/- 0.5 x 10(-6) (Valentine CR et al. [2002]: Environ Mol Mutagen 39:55-68), indicating that those spontaneous mutants were primarily derived from E. coli. The E. coli spectrum was heavily weighted toward two major target sites (hot spots), 4225A-->G (56%) and 4218G-->A or C (20%). Four new target sites and one new mutational event were recovered by the gene A forward assay. A mutant spectrum from an expanded phage stock was also determined to assess the effects of propagating the virus. This mutant frequency was higher (6 x 10(-4)), contained more double mutants (15% compared to 0.6%), and had a significantly different spectrum from the spectrum for independent cultures (fewer A:T-->G:C and G:C-->C:G changes and more G:C-->A:T; P < 0.002). The E. coli mutation spectrum will be useful for determining the origin of gene A mutation in tissues of phiX174 transgenic mice.

Transcription increases multiple spontaneous point mutations in Salmonella enterica

The spontaneous rate of G.C-->A.T mutations and a hotspot T.A-->G.C transversion are known to increase with the frequency of transcription-increases that have been ascribed primarily to processes that affect only these specific mutations. To investigate how transcription induces other spontaneous point mutations, we tested for its effects in repair-proficient Salmonella enterica using reversion assays of chromosomally inserted alleles. Our results indicate that transcription increases rates of all tested point mutations in the induced gene: induction significantly increased the individual rates of an A.T-->T.A transversion, an A.T-->G.C transition and the pooled rates of the three other point mutations assayed. Although the S.enterica genome is thought to have a mutational bias towards G.C base pairs, transitions creating A.T pairs were approximately 10 times more frequent than the reverse mutation, resulting in an overall mutation pressure to lower G+C contents. Transitions occurred at roughly twice the rate of transversions, similar to results from sequence comparisons; however, several individual transversions are more frequent than the least common transition.

Protection by dietary compounds against mutation in a transgenic rodent

One of the most relevant biomarkers of genotoxicity and, potentially, carcinogenesis is the occurrence of mutations. Data indicate that carcinogens are highly specific with regard to their target tissue in inducing both tumors and mutations. This specificity may reflect the dependence on tissue-specific metabolic activation, the organ-specific environment or both. Ideally, therefore, mutation should be determined in a real animal rather than in a cell culture system. The lacI transgenic rodent model provides such a system. We have used this model to investigate tissue, species and sex specificity of mutation induced by selected dietary carcinogens and to examine how some compounds may alter the induction of mutation. We have studied mutation using several chemicals, including the dietary heterocyclic amine 2-amino-1-methyl-6-phenylimidazo[4,5-b]pyridine (PhIP), the environmentally important aromatic hydrocarbon benzo[a]pyrene and the food contaminant aflatoxin B1. We have shown that the mutagenic potency of these chemicals can be modulated by other dietary compounds, including green tea and conjugated linoleic acid, and the dioxin 2,3,7,8-tetrachlorodibenzo[b,e][1,4]dioxin (TCDD). These results demonstrate that the lacI transgenic rodent is a useful model for the study of chemoprevention in vivo.

The Big Blue(R) transgenic mouse mutation detection assay: the mutation pattern of sectored mutant plaques

There are mutational artifacts in the Big Blue(R) assay and it is important to characterize the source and nature of these mutations. Differences were reported in the mutation patterns of a small sample of 23 sectored and 91 circular mutant plaques derived from skin using the Big Blue(R) transgenic mouse mutation detection system [G. R. Stuart, N.J. Gorelick, J.L. Andrews, J.G. de Boer, B.W. Glickman, The genetic analysis of lacI mutations in sectored plaques from Big Blue transgenic mice, Environ. Mol. Mutagen 28 (1996) 385-392.]. We have extended these observations by analyzing 46 sectored and 224 circular mutant plaques derived from seven tissues. The frequency of sectored mutant plaques is estimated to be 16% with no significant variation with tissue type. However, the patterns of mutation for sectored mutants and mouse-derived mutations differed significantly (p=0.04). Base substitutions in sectored mutant plaques do not show the asymmetries found in circular mutants consistent with integration of a GC rich transgene into the AT rich mammalian genome. Sectored mutants have mutation patterns consistent with a mixture of mouse, in vitro and Escherichia coli-derived mutations. Data on the relative frequencies of different mutant plaque morphologies suggests that overlapped plaques are substantially contaminated by sectored plaques at recommended plating densities.

The lacI gene as a target for mutation in transgenic rodents and Escherichia coli

The lacI gene has been used extensively for the recovery and analysis of mutations in bacteria with various DNA repair backgrounds and after exposure to a wide variety of mutagens. This has resulted in a large database of information on mutational mechanisms and specificity of many mutagens, as well as the effect of DNA repair background on mutagenicity. Most importantly, knowledge about the mutational sensitivity of the lacI gene is now available, yielding information about mutable nucleotides. This popularity and available knowledge resulted in the use of the lacI gene in transgenic rodents for the study of mutagenesis in mammals, where it resides in approximately 40 repeated copies. As the number of sequenced mutations recovered from these animals increases, we are able to analyze the sites at which mutations have been recovered in great detail and to compare the recovered sites between bacteria and transgenic animals. The nucleotides that code for the DNA-binding domain are nearly saturated with base substitutions. Even after determining the sequences of approximately 10,000 mutations recovered from the animals, however, new sites and new changes are still being recovered. In addition, we compare the nature of deletion mutations between bacteria and animals. Based on the nature of deletions in the animals, we conclude that each deletion occurs in a single copy of the gene.

Towards validation of the Big Blue transgenic mouse mutagenesis assay: the mutational spectrum of ex vivo pinpoint mutant plaques

To explore further the origin of spontaneous mutations recovered with the Big Blue transgenic mouse mutagenesis assay, the spectrum of ex vivo mutations from pinpoint mutant plaques was determined and compared with the spectrum of putatively mouse-derived mutations from circular, mutant plaques. The entire lacI gene and lacZ operator region from 62 pinpoint blue plaques was sequenced. The observed mutational spectrum of pinpoint mutants differed significantly from that seen in circular mutants (p < 0.0001). Only four percent of the mutations were transitions at CpG sites whereas this type of mutation was the most common (35%) in circular mutants. Microdeletions/microinsertions were seen more frequently in pinpoint mutants relative to circular mutants. Four base pair deletion/insertion events at the E. coli hotspot tandem repeats were seen in 10 of 62 (16%) pinpoint mutants and minor hotspots of mutation were observed at bp 141 and 1110. The mutational spectrum of pinpoint mutants provides further evidence that most circular mutants originate in mouse.

Database and software for the analysis of mutations at the lacI gene in both transgenic rodents and bacteria

The use of transgenic rodents for the study of genetic toxicology has increased dramatically in the past several years. A great deal of the recent work has employed the lacI locus in transgenic mice. In addition to the transgenic data, a substantial amount of information exists regarding mutation of the lacI gene in bacteria. In an effort to centralize the information regarding mutations in the lacI gene in both rodents and bacteria, we have created a computerized database that contains information about DNA sequence alterations on about 500 mutations in transgenic rodents and 8,000 mutations in bacteria. We have also produced a software package for the analysis of the lacI database. Routines have been developed for the analysis of single base substitutions, including programs to (i) determine if two mutational spectra are different; (ii) determine if mutations show a DNA strand bias; (iii) determine the frequency of transitions and transversions; (iv) display the number and kind of mutations observed at each base in the coding region; (v) perform nearest neighbor analysis; and (vi) display mutable amino acids in the lacI protein. The software runs only on IBM-compatible machines running Microsoft Windows. The software and lacI database are freely available via the internet (http:/(/)sunsite.unc.edu/dnam/mainpage.++ +html).

Spontaneous mutation in Big Blue transgenic mice: analysis of age, gender, and tissue type

A lacI-containing transgenic mouse mutation detection system (Big Blue) was used to determine the frequency and spectrum of spontaneous mutation in two rapidly dividing tissues (male germ cells and thymus) and one slowly dividing tissue (brain) at 3 and 10 months of age. By screening 9.4 million lambda plaques, a total of 343 circular mutant plaques were recovered from the three tissues. The mutation frequencies and spectra were determined by sequencing the lacI gene and associated lacZ operator in all samples and correcting for "jackpot" mutations. The mutation frequencies and spectra were similar in all three tissues and there were no age-dependent or gender-dependent changes. When the mutation spectrum in each tissue was compared by utilizing large numbers of independent mutations (average: 75 per tissue), there was evidence for small tissue-specific differences. The spectrum of "jackpot" mutations, which clearly represents in vivo mouse-derived mutations, was similar to that of nonjackpot mutations, providing additional evidence that observed mutations occur in mouse. In the aggregate, the results suggest that there is: (i) a core mutation frequency and spectrum that is modified weakly by tissue-specific metabolism, and (ii) a steady-state level of spontaneous mutation in adult mice reflecting the balance between the accumulation of new mutations and the elimination of mutated cells by either selection against suboptimal cellular function or apoptosis triggered by accumulated DNA damage.

Mutational spectra in the lacl gene in skin from 7,12-dimethylbenz[a]anthracene-treated and untreated transgenic mice

Transgenic mice carrying the bacterial lacl gene in a lambda shuttle vector were used to isolate and characterize background and 7,12-dimethylbenz[a]anthracene (DMBA)-induced mutations in skin. Adult male mice were treated once topically with either DMBA or acetone or were left untreated. Seven days later, DMBA treatment had significantly increased the mutant frequency in the skin (mean +/- SEM, 36 +/- 3 x 10(-5)) versus in vehicle-treated (6.4 +/- 1.2 x 10(-5)) and untreated mice (7.1 x 1.0 x 10(-5)). At least 10 mutants from each of three DMBA-treated and three untreated mice were selected for DNA sequence analysis. In each case, the entire 1080-bp target gene was sequenced. Base-pair substitutions predominated (86 of 96 mutations), although frameshift and deletion mutations were also detected. Twelve percent of the mutants carried more than one mutation. In controls, the mutations were predominantly GC-->AT transitions (26 of 42), and no AT-->TA transversions were recovered. In contrast, in the DMBA-treated mice, AT-->TA transversions represented 42% of the mutations (23 of 54) and GC-->AT transitions accounted for only 11%. The AT-->TA transversions occurred mostly at 5'-CA sites. This class of mutation has been recovered frequently in ras genes from DMBA-treated mice and probably represents an early event in carcinogenesis (Nelson MA et al., Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 89:6398-6402, 1992). Our present results are consistent with the types of DNA damage induced by DMBA. The observation of different mutant frequencies and spectra in treated and control mice demonstrates the utility of this approach in the study of mutagenesis in vivo.

Development of a lambda-based complementation assay for the preliminary localization of lacI mutants from the Big Blue mouse: implications for a DNA-sequencing strategy

The Big Blue transgenic mouse carrying the E. coli lacI gene as a mutational target in a lambda-based shuttle vector has been receiving increasing attention in genotoxicity testing because it offers the potential of studying mutation in a mammalian system in vivo. The system not only provides information on mutant frequency, but it also offers the potential of providing information about mutational specificity. Such data is not only important for studies of mutational mechanisms; it offers a critical advantage for determining the mutational response at levels where significant increases in mutant frequency have not been discerned. The repeated sequencing of the entire 1080-bp lacI target, however, remains a formidable task. Here we report on the adaptation of the "negative complementation" assay for the lacI-d phenotype to accommodate the lambda lacI recovered from the Big Blue transgenic animal. This assay permits the localization of mutations to an approximately 330-bp region to facilitate the production of mutational specificity data. The assay is based upon lysogenization of the lambda containing the lacI mutation into a lacI+ host. Of 107 sequenced lacI mutants recovered from Big Blue mice, 74 were identified as NC+ (lacI-d) using this assay. Of these 74, 49 occurred in the region 32-208 bp, which has traditionally been viewed as the NC+ domain. 33 of these mutations were previously identified as producing the NC+ phenotype while another 7 occurred at sites where NC+ mutants have been recovered, but involved a new base substitution. 9 mutants involved new sites. An additional 25 mutants located downstream of the presumed NC+ region were also found to be NC+ as determined by their blue colour on X-gal plates. Of these, 18 occurred in the 209-360-bp region. In parallel, 54 lacI mutants carrying unknown mutations were examined. 37 of these produced blue colonies in this assay. The sequencing of these mutants revealed that 20 (54%) of the 37 mutants were located in the 32-208-bp region. This complementation assay can potentially reduce the amount of DNA sequencing necessary to produce a mutational spectrum by optimising the choice of sequencing primers, and thus provide a significant saving of the material and time required. Furthermore, evidence indicates that the restriction of the mutational target to the NC+ region extends these savings without reducing the usefulness of the mutational specificity data.

Transgenic animal models for measuring mutations in vivo

Transgenic animal models for measuring mutations provide a powerful tool for rapidly assessing tissue-specific mutations following in vivo treatment. These models are based on the insertion into the rodent genome of the Escherichia coli lacI (lac repressor) or lacZ (beta-galactosidase) genes that serve as targets for mutations. Following in vivo treatment of animals, genomic DNA is isolated from various tissues and the target gene is packaged into lambda-phage heads; the lambda-phage are used to infect E. coli in order to produce plaques. Mutations in the target gene are then detected using colorimetric or selective procedures. In this review methods are discussed for producing these transgenic models, the target genes used, gene rescue techniques, sequencing of isolated mutants, and parameters that affect dosing regimens and design of studies. We also present a summary of data published to date with these systems and present our conclusions and proposed directions for future research.

Echinomycin, a bis-intercalating agent, induces C-->T mutations via cytosine deamination

Echinomycin, a bis-intercalating, antitumor drug, has been studied for its ability to induce the deamination of cytosine to uracil (C-->U) in double-stranded DNA. We have employed a sensitive lacZ alpha-complementation reversion assay to detect G.C-->A.T mutations at a number of sites in M13mp2 DNA to determine the extent to which distortions of DNA structure induced by echinomycin may affect C-->U rates. When double-stranded M13mp2 DNA with a 12-base target containing a CpG site was incubated at 37 degrees C, the reversion frequency of the echinomycin-treated DNA increased linearly over time, with a rate constant 3-fold greater than DNA incubated without echinomycin. Of the 11 ways that blue pseudo-revertants can occur in the target, 96% of the observed revertants arose from C-->T and tandem CC-->TT transitions, with 78% attributable to single-base C-->T changes at three sites. Transfection into ung+ cells decreased the reversion frequencies by 85% to near background levels, indicating that the increase in C-->T mutations was due to deamination of C to U. The cytosine deamination rate constants for the entire target at pH 6.0 and 37 degrees C were 1.2 x 10(-11) sec-1 for untreated DNA and 3.5 x 10(-11) sec-1 for echinomycin-treated DNA. The increase in C-->T mutation rates occurred at cytosines both proximal and distal to a CpG echinomycin-binding site. We hypothesize that this increase in deamination rate is due to a more open or single-stranded DNA structure caused by the echinomycin: DNA interaction.

The use of selection in recovery of transgenic targets for mutation analysis

Transgenic animal mutagenesis assays using lambda shuttle vectors have recently been described for isolation and characterization of spontaneous and chemical induced DNA mutations. Extensive information on lambda and E. coli genetics provides a wealth of techniques to allow selection of mutant target genes. Here we describe the modification of an E. coli host which permits two methods for the direct selection of mutant genes. These methods reduce the number of plates needed to be screened for a comparable amount of frequency data by 20-100-fold and thus provide a significant savings of the materials and time required for the screening of mutations. In addition, mutants selected by these approaches described here may alter or broaden the spectrum of mutations that are recoverable. Ultimately, a combination of selective and nonselective techniques may prove valuable for the analysis of mutations produced in vivo in transgenic animals.

A comparison of the fidelity of copying 5-methylcytosine and cytosine at a defined DNA template site

5-Methylcytosine has been postulated to be an endogenous mutagen in procaryotes and eucaryotes leading to base substitution hot spots, C-->T transitions, resulting from spontaneous deamination of mC to T. The possibility remains, however, that a second mechanism involving mispairing of mC with A might also contribute to base substitution mutagenesis via G-->A transitions. Stimulation of the G-->A mutational pathway could involve preferential misincorporation of dAMP opposite template mC compared to C. To investigate this possibility, we synthesized a sequence containing mC at a defined template location. We compared the fidelity of copying mC versus C and the efficiency of extending mismatched base pairs at the mC position using three DNA polymerases, AMV reverse transcriptase, Drosophila DNA polymerase alpha, and mutant Escherichia coli Klenow fragment containing no proofreading exonuclease activity. Significant differences in misinsertion and mismatch extension efficiencies were observed only for the case of AMV reverse transcriptase. AMV reverse transcriptase was observed to incorporate dAMP 4 to 5-fold more efficiently opposite mC than C. Favored extension of a 5-MeC.A over C.A mispair was also observed with a difference of about 3-fold. In contrast to AMV reverse transcriptase, Klenow fragment showed no significant difference when copying either mC or C sites or when extending mispairs involving mC and C. Incorporation of dAMP opposite either C or mC was barely detectable using pol alpha, although pol alpha has been observed to form A.C mismatches in other sequences. While we cannot completely exclude the possibility that dAMP might be incorporated opposite mC in preference to C, our results suggest that contributions of the G-->A pathway to mC mutagenic hot spots are likely to be minor, lending additional support to the model invoking deamination of mC.

Specificity of SOS mutagenesis in native M13lacI phage

Base substitutions account for 90% of all forward mutations sequenced in unmodified M13lacI DNA grown in both UV-irradiated and nonirradiated hosts. The principal effect of SOS induction was an increase in the contribution of transversions, in particular A.T----T.A events.

Genetic assay of misincorporation

A system to characterize mutations arising from in vitro nucleotide misincorporation, which avoids the effects of in vivo mismatch repair on recovery of mutants, was constructed and evaluated. The lacI gene of Escherichia coli was inserted into phage M13 and the M13-lacI recombinant was introduced into a strain of E. coli lacking a resident lacI gene. In this system the function of the M13-bearing lacI gene can be detected by plaque color. Mutants in the 5'-region of the lacI gene (encoding operator-binding domain) are seen as blue plaques when the host strain is grown in the presence of chromogenic substrate, X-gal, in the absence of inducer. The use of uracil-containing single stranded DNA from M13-lacI as template for DNA synthesis avoids the contribution of mismatch repair (in transfection recipients) on the recovery of mutants. To demonstrate the usefulness of the M13-lacI system we produced nucleotide misincorporations by in vitro DNA synthesis in the N-terminal region of the lacI template in the presence of only 3 deoxynucleoside triphosphates (dNTPs). Such mutagenic reactions were conducted in the absence of dATP with 4 different primers and in the absence of dGTP with 2 primers. The type of mutants produced by these reactions were identified through sequencing of DNA from progeny phage after screening for i- (blue plaque) phenotype. Mutations recovered in this system consisted of single and multiple base substitutions in the region of the template near the 3'-terminus of the primer. Nearly all of the mutants induced by '-A' conditions were T----C base substitutions, and those induced by '-G' conditions were C----T transitions. In general, the results were consistent with the spectrum of spontaneous mutants produced in strains deficient in mismatch repair, although some differences were noted. Several new base substitutions within the lacI gene (producing i- phenotype and unobserved by others) were isolated by the procedures described in this paper.

Spectra of spontaneous and mutagen-induced mutations in the lacI gene in transgenic mice

Transgenic mice with a lambda shuttle vector containing a lacI target gene were generated for use as a short-term, in vivo mutagenesis assay. The gene is recovered from the treated mice by exposing mouse genomic DNA to in vitro packaging extracts and plating the rescued phage on agar plates containing 5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl beta-D-galactopyranoside (X-Gal). Phage with mutations in the lacI gene form blue plaques, whereas phage with a nonmutated lacI form colorless plaques. Spontaneous background mutant rates using this system range from 0.6 x 10(-5) to 1.7 x 10(-5), depending upon tissue analyzed, with germ cells exhibiting less than one-third the background rate of somatic tissue. Treatment of the mice with N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (EtNU), benzo[a]pyrene (B[a]P), or cyclophosphamide caused an induction of mutations over background. Recovery of the lacI target for sequence analysis was performed by genetic excision of a plasmid from the phage using partial filamentous phage origins. The predominant mutations identified from untreated and treated populations were base substitutions. Although it has been shown by others that 70% of all spontaneous mutations within the lacI gene, when replicated in Escherichia coli, occur at a hot spot located at bases 620-632, only 1 of 21 spontaneous mutations has been identified in this region in the transgenic mouse system. In addition, 5 of 9 spontaneous transitions analyzed occur at CpG dinucleotides, whereas no transition mutations were identified at the prokaryotic deamination hot spots occurring at dcm sites (CCA/TGG) within the lacI gene. For EtNU, approximately equal amounts of transitions and transversions were observed, contrasting with B[a]P-induced mutations, in which only transversions were obtained. In addition, B[a]P mutagenesis showed a predominance of mutations (81%) involving cytosines and/or guanines, consistent with its known mode of action. The discovery of a spontaneous mutation spectrum different from that of bacterial assays, coupled with the concordance of EtNU and B[a]P base mutations with the known mechanisms of activity for these mutagens, suggests that this transgenic system will be useful as a short-term, in vivo system for mutagen assessment and analysis of mechanisms leading to mutations.

Analysis of 2-amino-N6-hydroxyadenine-induced mutagenesis in phage M13mp2

The mechanism of mutagenesis induced by 2-amino-N6-hydroxyadenine (AHA) and its deoxyriboside (AHAdR) was studied by determining the nucleotide sequences of phage M13mp2 mutant DNA samples. Mutations in the lac promoter-lacZ alpha region of the phage were induced by addition of this agent to culture media in which the phage was growing inside the host bacteria. The spectrum of spontaneous mutation was also investigated. The induced sequence changes were mostly base transitions (80% with AHA and 90% with AHAdR). A few single-base deletions and additions were detected, but they were ascribable to spontaneous mutations. These results are consistent with the incorporation type mechanism proposed by Janion (this issue). In the Ames Salmonella assay, both AHA and AHAdR showed strong mutagenicity in strain TA100 but no activity in TA98.