Nuclease digestibility of chromatin is affected by nuclei isolation procedures

DNA stainability with base-specific fluorochromes: dependence on the DNA topology in situ

The influence of DNA topology on stainability with the externally binding fluorochromes Hoechst 33258 (HO) and mithramycin (MI) was investigated in HeLa nuclei in comparison with the intercalating dye propidium iodide (PI). Changes in DNA topology were induced with a mild DNAse I treatment. Stainability properties of untreated and nuclease-treated nuclei were compared with those of the supercoiled-circular and the relaxed-linear forms of the plasmid pBR322. DNAse-treated nuclei stained with HO showed a higher fluorescence intensity than control samples, independently of the dye concentration, in contrast with the findings obtained with PI. Similar behaviour was observed with the relaxed-linear form of pBR322, compared with the supercoiled-circular molecule. With MI, the stainability of HeLa nuclei did not depend on the DNA topology, whereas the stainability of the plasmid was similar to that of HO. In order to assess whether this discrepancy depended on differences in the availability of DNAse-sensitive sites to the fluorochromes, fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) studies were performed in nuclei stained with HO+PI, or with HO+MI dye pairs. After DNAse I digestion, the relative FRET efficiency between donor (HO) and acceptor molecules (PI or MI) was reduced significantly only when MI was the acceptor. This result may be due to greater stainability of DNAse-sensitive sites with HO than with MI. These findings indicate that DNA stainability with base-specific fluorochromes may be affected by the topology of chromatin regions.

c-Ha-rasVal 12 oncogene-transformed NIH-3T3 fibroblasts display more decondensed nucleosomal organization than normal fibroblasts

We have compared the nucleosomal organization of c-Ha-rasVal 12 oncogene-transformed NIH-3T3 fibroblasts with that of normal fibroblasts by using micrococcal nuclease (MNase) as a probe for the chromatin structure. The bulk chromatin from asynchronously and exponentially growing ras-transformed cells was much more sensitive to MNase digestion than chromatin from the normal cells. Southern hybridization analyses of the MNase digests with probes specific for the ornithine decarboxylase (odc) and c-myc genes showed that the coding and/or 3' end regions of these growth-inducible genes carry a nucleosomal organization both in ras-transformed and normal cells. Studies with cells synchronized by serum starvation showed that in both cell lines the nucleosomal organization of chromatin is relatively condensed at the quiescent state, becomes highly decondensed during the late G1 phase of the cell cycle, and starts again to condense during the S phase. However, in ras-transformed cells the decondensation state stayed much longer than in normal cells. Moreover, irrespective of the phase of the cell cycle the bulk chromatin as well as that of the odc and c-myc genes was more sensitive to MNase digestion in the ras-transformed cell than in the normal fibroblast. Decondensation of the chromatin was also observed in the normal c-Ha-ras protooncogene-transfected cells, but to a lesser extent than in the mutant ras-transformed cells. Whether the increased degree of chromatin decondensation plays a regulatory role in the increased expression of many growth-related genes in the ras-transformed cells remains an interesting object of further study.

Parameters influencing the flow cytometric analysis of DNA sensitivity to nuclease S1

Some parameters that influence the analysis in situ of DNA sensitivity to digestion with nuclease S1 have been studied in isolated HeLa nuclei with flow cytometry. DNA staining with the intercalating fluorochrome propidium iodide allowed the nucleolytic activity on double-stranded (ds) DNA to be determined by monitoring the relative reduction in nuclear fluorescence intensity. Nuclei isolated in buffer at low ionic strength in order to decondense chromatin fibres, showed a lower fluorescence intensity than nuclei with native chromatin, after digestion with nuclease S1 under identical conditions. Nuclei prepared with dispersed chromatin and digested with increasing amounts of enzyme showed a decrease in fluorescence intensity that reached a limit value at about 50% of the value of undigested control samples. On the other hand, in nuclei with native chromatin, fluorescence intensity decreased only about 18%. The NaCl concentration in the reaction buffer strongly influenced the DNA sensitivity to S1 nuclease. By increasing salt molarity from 5 mM to 200 mM, the digestion of dsDNA was significantly reduced as also shown by the amount of released nucleotides from purified calf thymus DNA. The detection of DNA sensitivity to nuclease S1, as assessed by the cytometric method, was shown to be more sensitive than a biochemical technique involving hydrolysis of purines. These results indicate that both the procedure for nuclei isolation and the digestion conditions have to be carefully controlled when evaluating in situ the presence of S1-sensitive sites.

Flow cytometric evaluation of DNA stainability with propidium iodide after histone H1 extraction

A flow cytometric evaluation of the effect of the histone H1 extraction on DNA stainability with propidium iodide was performed on isolated HeLa nuclei. Selective removal of the lysine-rich protein was attained by using two established techniques involving treatment with 0.7 M NaCl or low pH. DNA stainability was monitored at different dye/DNA-P ratios, varying from low to high saturating concentrations. Depletion of the histone H1from nuclei results in the transition from low to high affinity of a portion of binding sites, as shown by 1) the increase in fluorescence intensity after staining with the dye at low saturating concentrations and 2) the higher value of the fluorescence intensity ratio (FI5/FI50) exhibited by H1-depleted nuclei stained with a low (5 micrograms/ml) vs. a high (50 micrograms/ml) concentration, as compared with control samples.

Selective displacement of nuclear proteins by antitumor drugs having affinity for nucleic acids

The nuclear chromatin binding sites of the antitumor drugs mitoxantrone, ametantrone, doxorubicin, mithramycin, and actinomycin D and the intercalating ligand ethidium were studied by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis of the proteins released from rat liver nuclei in the presence and absence of these drugs in buffer of low ionic strength (10 mM NaCl). At 25-50 microM free ligand concentration, each drug produced a specific and reproducible pattern of extractable proteins of different molecular weight by (i) releasing new proteins, (ii) altering the quantity of particular extracted proteins, and/or (iii) selectively entrapping other proteins in the nuclei. Ethidium, up to 100 microM, did not affect release of proteins from the nuclei. These results indicate that each ligand either has different binding site(s) in chromatin or modulates chromatin structure in a specific way by changing the affinity of different sets of proteins for their respective binding sites, resulting in their selective extraction or entrapment. The lack of effect of ethidium indicates that intercalation of the ligand to DNA, per se, does not alter the release of nuclear proteins. If patterns of nuclear proteins selectively released or retained by antitumor drugs are found to correlate with biological activity, this type of analysis may be helpful in new drug design and screening.

Histone acetylation: a step in gene activation

Cellular ageing appears to consist mainly in a loss of adaptability and a progressive decrease in the capacity of the cell to maintain homeostasis. Such age related phenomenon can be the result of stochastic or of programmed events, and may occur through changes in the base pairs or coding of the DNA, through increasing levels of error in transcription and finally through alterations at the translation step of proteins synthesis. The purpose of this chapter is to present histone acetylation as a key event in the control of chromatin structure and transcription.

Nuclease sensitivity of storage-protein genes in isolated nuclei of pea seeds

The chromatin structure of legumin genes in nuclei isolated from leaves and cytyledons of pea (Pisum sativum L.) was investigated. Digestions with micrococcal nuclease (EC 3.1.31.1.) showed that the nucleosomal repeat length of total chromatin (171±25 base pairs) was similar in nuclei from both tissues. The sensitivity to pancreatic deoxyribonuclease (DNase I; EC 3.1.21.1.) of the legumin genes in cotyledon nuclei was greater than that in leaf nuclei; this increase in sensitivity correlated with transcriptional activity of the genes. No DNase-I-hypersensitive sites were detected in these genes in either tissue.

Modulation of the sensitivity of chromatin to exogenous nucleases: implications for the apparent increased sensitivity of transcriptionally active genes

We have examined the effects of changing the ionic composition of the buffers in which nuclei are isolated on the sensitivity of chromatin to micrococcal nuclease and deoxyribonuclease I. Unless nuclei are isolated in buffers containing physiological levels of monovalent (150 mM KCl) and divalent (2-5 mM MgCl2) cations, there is a substantial loss of higher order structure. The ionic composition of the buffer in which the digestion is carried out also affects the amount of material digested both by modulating higher order structure and by determining the solubility of the released material. Magnesium ion concentrations greater than 2 mM and calcium ions at virtually any concentration precipitate substantial amounts of the released chromatin fragments. These observations can be interpreted in light of the known effects of the ions on 10- and 30-nm fiber structure and used as a basis for improvements in techniques for isolating chromatin and for studying its structure and function using exogenous nuclease probes. The apparent nuclease sensitivity of transcriptionally active chromatin was reexamined and shown to be more likely a reflection of differential solubility rather than an overall increase in nuclease sensitivity.

Single-strand-specific degradation of DNA during isolation of rat liver nuclei

We have investigated structural change in rat liver DNA produced by different isolation procedures and specifically compared the integrity of DNA derived by phenol extraction from isolated and purified nuclei with preparations extracted immediately from a crude liver homogenate containing intact nuclei. As indicated by stepwise elution from benzoylated DEAE-cellulose, most structural change in DNA was evident following nuclei isolation. Damage principally involved generation of single-stranded regions in otherwise double-stranded DNA fragments; totally single-stranded DNA was not detected by hydroxylapatite chromatography. Caffeine gradient elution suggested formation of single-stranded regions extending for up to several kilobases. In neutral sucrose gradients, differences in sedimentation rates of respective DNA samples consequent upon S1 nuclease digestion could be detected after isolation of nuclei, though not in other circumstances. The observed single-strand-specific nuclease digestion of DNA could apparently be reduced if steps were taken to reduce autodigestion during nuclei isolation by reduction of temperature and covalent cation concentration. The results are discussed in terms of the use of exogenous and endogenous nucleases in chromatin fractionation studies involving isolated nuclei and possible artifactual findings that may be generated by single-strand-specific autodigestion.

Cell cycle variations in chromatin structure detected by DNase I

We have recently developed a reproducible method for the use of DNase I as a sensitive probe of chromatin structure (Prentice, D A & Gurley, L R, Biochim biophys acta 740 (1983) 134) [12] and have used this probe to investigate chromatin structure during the interphase of the cell cycle. Chinese hamster cells (line CHO) were synchronized by: (1) mitotic detachment, to obtain M-phase cells; (2) isoleucine deprivation, to obtain G1-phase cells; and (3) sequential use of isoleucine deprivation followed by release into the presence of hydroxyurea, to obtain cells blocked at the start of S phase. The cells were released from the various blocking schemes and nuclei were isolated and digested with DNase I at various times. The digestion kinetics were monitored to detect possible changes in chromatin condensation through the cell cycle. The chromatin was much more accessible to DNase I in G1 phase than in S or G2 phase, with only small variations in structure detected in late G1 and very early S phase. From early S phase up to mitosis, the chromatin became increasingly condensed and inaccessible to DNase I action. These results support the concept of a chromatin condensation cycle during interphase as well as during mitosis.

Transcriptionally active chromatin

Eukaryotic chromatin has a dynamic, complex hierarchical structure. Active gene transcription takes place on only a small proportion of it at a time. While many workers have tried to characterize active chromatin, we are still far from understanding all the biochemical, morphological and compositional features that distinguish it from inactive nuclear material. Active genes are apparently packaged in an altered nucleosome structure and are associated with domains of chromatin that are less condensed or more open than inactive domains. Active genes are more sensitive to nuclease digestions and probably contain specific nonhistone proteins which may establish and/or maintain the active state. Variant or modified histones as well as altered configurations or modifications of the DNA itself may likewise be involved. Practically nothing is known about the mechanisms that control these nuclear characteristics. However, controlled accessibility to regions of chromatin and specific sequences of DNA may be one of the primary regulatory mechanisms by which higher cells establish potentially active chromatin domains. Another control mechanism may be compartmentalization of active chromatin to certain regions within the nucleus, perhaps to the nuclear matrix. Topological constraints and DNA supercoiling may influence the active regions of chromatin and be involved in eukaryotic genomic functions. Further, the chromatin structure of various DNA regulatory sequences, such as promoters, terminators and enhancers, appears to partially regulate transcriptional activity.

Mechanism of enhanced RNA synthesis in acute-phase rat liver and its relationship to chromatin structure

Nuclei isolated from the liver of rats undergoing an acute inflammatory reaction induced by turpentine treatment show increased RNA synthesis. This increase is essentially determined by a faster polyribonucleotide-elongation rate while the number of transcribing polymerase molecules is unchanged. The sensitivity of chromatin to micrococcal-nuclease digestion and the composition of chromosomal proteins are not affected by the acute-phase process. Therefore the increased RNA synthesis by liver nuclei from acutely inflamed rats does not seem to correlate with major changes in chromatin structure.

DNAase I and cellular factors that affect chromatin structure

The use of DNAase I as a probe of chromatin structure is frequently fraught with problems of irreproducibility. We have recently evaluated this procedure, documented the sources of the problems, and standardized the method for reproducible results (Prentice and Gurley (1983) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 740, 134-144). We have now used this probe to detect differences in chromatin structure between cells blocked (1) in G1 phase by isoleucine deprivation, or (2) in early S phase by sequential use of isoleucine deprivation followed by release into the presence of hydroxyurea. The cells blocked in G1 phase have easily-digestible chromatin, while cells blocked in early S phase have chromatin which is much more resistant to DNAase I. These differences were found to be the result of diffusible factors found in the cytoplasm and nuclei of G1- and S-phase cells, respectively. The G1 cells contained a cytoplasmic factor which modulates the chromatin structure of S-phase nuclei to a more easily digestible state, while cells blocked in S phase contain a nuclear factor which modulates the chromatin structure of G1 nuclei to a state more resistant to digestion. DNAase I is much more sensitive to these cell cycle-specific chromatin changes than is micrococcal nuclease. The results indicate that, under controlled conditions, DNAase I should be a valuable probe for detecting chromatin structural changes associated with cell cycle traverse, differentiation, development, hormone action and chemical toxicity.