Substrate preferences of human placental DNA methyltransferase investigated with synthetic polydeoxynucleotides

Recombinant human DNA (cytosine-5) methyltransferase. I. Expression, purification, and comparison of de novo and maintenance methylation

A method is described to express and purify human DNA (cytosine-5) methyltransferase (human DNMT1) using a protein splicing (intein) fusion partner in a baculovirus expression vector. The system produces approximately 1 mg of intact recombinant enzyme >95% pure per 1.5 x 10(9) insect cells. The protein lacks any affinity tag and is identical to the native enzyme except for the two C-terminal amino acids, proline and glycine, that were substituted for lysine and aspartic acid for optimal cleavage from the intein affinity tag. Human DNMT1 was used for steady-state kinetic analysis with poly(dI-dC).poly(dI-dC) and unmethylated and hemimethylated 36- and 75-mer oligonucleotides. The turnover number (k(cat)) was 131-237 h(-1) on poly(dI-dC).poly(dI-dC), 1.2-2.3 h(-1) on unmethylated DNA, and 8.3-49 h(-1) on hemimethylated DNA. The Michaelis constants for DNA (K(m)(CG)) and S-adenosyl-L-methionine (AdoMet) (K(m)(AdoMet)) ranged from 0.33-1.32 and 2.6-7.2 microM, respectively, whereas the ratio of k(cat)/K(m)(CG) ranged from 3.9 to 44 (237-336 for poly(dI-dC).poly(dI-dC)) x 10(6) M(-1) h(-1). The preference of the enzyme for hemimethylated, over unmethylated, DNA was 7-21-fold. The values of k(cat) on hemimethylated DNAs showed a 2-3-fold difference, depending upon which strand was pre-methylated. Furthermore, human DNMT1 formed covalent complexes with substrates containing 5-fluoro-CNG, indicating that substrate specificity extended beyond the canonical CG dinucleotide. These results show that, in addition to maintenance methylation, human DNMT1 may also carry out de novo and non-CG methyltransferase activities in vivo.

DNA binding discrimination of the murine DNA cytosine-C5 methyltransferase

Mammalian DNA cytosine-C5 methyltransferase modifies the CpG dinucleotide in the context of many different genomic sequences. A rigorous DNA binding assay was developed for the murine enzyme and used to define how sequences flanking the CpG dinucleotide affect the stability of the enzyme:DNA complex. Oligonucleotides containing a single CpG site form reversible 1:1 complexes with the enzyme that are sequence-specific. A guanine/cytosine-rich 30 base-pair sequence, a mimic of the GC-box cis-element, bound threefold more tightly than an adenine/thymine-rich sequence, a mimic of the cyclic AMP responsive element. However, the binding discrimination between hemi- and unmethylated forms of these DNA substrates was small, as we previously observed at the K(m)DNA level (Biochemistry, 35, 7308-7315 (1996)). Single-stranded substrates are bound much more weakly than double-stranded DNA forms. An in vitro screening method was used to select for CpG flanking sequence preferences of the DNA methyltransferase from a large, divergent population of DNA substrates. After five iterative rounds of increasing selective pressure, guanosine/cytosine-rich sequences were abundant and contributed to binding stabilization for at least 12 base-pairs on either side of a central CpG. Our results suggest a read-out of sequence-dependent conformational features, such as helical flexibility, minor groove dimensions and critical phosphate orientation and mobility, rather than interactions with specific bases over the course of two complete helical turns. Thus, both studies reveal a preference for guanosine/cytosine deoxynucleotides flanking the cognate CpG. The enzyme specificity for similar sequences in the genome may contribute to the in vivo functions of this vital enzyme.

Spreading of methylation along DNA

Mouse DNA methyltransferase is able to catalyse the transfer of a methyl group to certain CG-containing single-stranded oligonucleotides. The presence of a methylcytosine is required for efficient transfer. This methylcytosine may or may not be on the same oligonucleotide as that containing the accepting CG dinucleotide. When the accepting CG dinucleotide forms part of an unmethylated CG dinucleotide pair, its accepting activity is dramatically reduced. This provides the potential for methylation to spread along the DNA when it is rendered single-stranded at replication. It could also help to maintain fully methylated CG islands and asymmetrically methylated sites.

Co-operative interactions of oligonucleosomal DNA with the H1e histone variant and its poly(ADP-ribosyl)ated isoform

H1 histone somatic variants from L929 mouse fibroblasts were purified by reverse-phase HPLC. We analysed the ability of each H1 histone variant to allow the H1-H1 interactions that are essential for the formation of the higher levels of chromatin structure, and we investigated the role played by the poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation process. Cross-linking analysis showed that H1e is the only somatic variant which, when bound to DNA, is able to produce H1-H1 polymers; the size of polymers was decreased when H1e was enriched in its poly(ADP-ribosyl)ated isoform. Measurement of the methyl-accepting ability in native nuclei compared with nuclei in which poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation was induced showed that the poly(ADP-ribosyl)ated H1 histone had not been removed from linker regions, in spite of its different interaction with DNA.

Binding of histone H1e-c variants to CpG-rich DNA correlates with the inhibitory effect on enzymic DNA methylation

Within the H1 histone family, only some fractions enriched in the H1e-c variants are effective in causing a marked inhibition, in vitro, of enzymic DNA methylation and, in gel retardation and Southwestern blot experiments, in binding double-stranded (ds) CpG-rich oligonucleotides. Both the 6-CpG ds-oligonucleotide and the DNA purified from chromatin fractions enriched in 'CpG islands' are good competitors for the binding of H1e-c to 6-meCpG ds-oligonucleotide. Because of their ability to bind any DNA sequence and to suppress the enzymic methylation in any sequence containing CpG dinucleotides, these particular H1 variants could play some role in maintaining linker DNA at low methylation levels and even in preserving the unmethylated state of the CpG-rich islands which characterize the promoter regions of housekeeping genes.

Inhibition of CpG methylation in linker DNA by H1 histone

H1 exerts a specific in vitro inhibitory effect on enzymic DNA methylation. The experiments reported in this paper were undertaken in order to assess whether the lower methylation level found in internucleosomal DNA compared to core DNA is the in vivo consequence of the well-known localization of this histone in the linker region, as opposed to a possible deficiency of CpG dinucleotides in linker DNA. The methyl-accepting ability of H1-depleted oligonucleosomes from human placenta and of the corresponding core particles were assayed by addition of purified DNA methyltransferase, using S-adenosylmethionine as the methyl group donor. We have found that approx. 80% of newly-incorporated methyl groups are localized in linker DNA, which is indeed a good potential substrate for enzymic DNA methylation. Addition of quasi-physiological amounts of H1 to H1-depleted oligonucleosomes markedly reduced their methyl-accepting ability, while exerting a re-condensing effect on these particles, as revealed by the distortions of their circular dichroism spectra.

Histones and DNA methylation in mammalian chromatin. II. Presence of non-inhibitory tightly-bound histones

After removal, by high-salt extraction, of the loosely-bound components present in human placenta chromatin, tightly-bound cationic proteins could be solubilized, by acid extraction, from the 'stripped' chromatin, as well as from the 'stripped' loops or from the 'digested matrix'. These acid-soluble tightly-bound proteins are, in terms of apparent molecular mass and immunoreactivity, quite similar to the 'typical', loosely-bound histones, and, similarly to their 'loosely-bound' counterparts, they can be subdivided in distinct H1-, H2A-, H2B-, H3- and H4-like components, the 'digested matrix' being however characterized by the absence of tightly-bound H1. These tightly-bound histones, at variance from the 'typical' ones, readily find a right-handed helical conformation upon renaturation by progressive dialyses. The H1 components strongly differ also in their effects on enzymic DNA methylation: while 'typical' H1 has a strong inhibitory effect, its tightly-bound counterpart exerts a slight but definite stimulation.

Histones and DNA methylation in mammalian chromatin. Differential inhibition by histone H1

Histones (from calf thymus or from human placenta), if renatured in the presence of EDTA, caused a severe inhibition of in vitro methylation of double-stranded DNA (from Micrococcus luteus) by human placenta DNA methyltransferase. The absence of EDTA during the histone renaturation procedure abolished--at least in the 'physiological' range of the histones/DNA ratio--the inhibition. The H1 component was responsible for this inhibition, no effect being exerted by the other histones. H1 preparations were more effective if renatured in the presence of EDTA--90% inhibition being reached at a 0.3:1 (w/w) H1/DNA ratio. It seems likely that the requirement for the presence of EDTA during the renaturation process is correlated to its ability to induce a fairly stable ordered conformation of the histones, although this effect could also be shown with the 'inactive' H2a, H2b and H3 components, and was instead less evident with histone H1. The restriction to histone H1 of the ability to inhibit enzymic DNA methylation may account for the lower methylation levels present in the internucleosomal DNA of mammalian chromatin.

In vitro methylation of CpG-rich islands

CpG islands are distinguishable from the bulk of vertebrate DNA for being unmethylated and CpG-rich. Since CpG doublets are the specific target of eukaryotic DNA methyltransferases, CpG-rich sequences might be expected to be good methyl-accepting substrates in vitro, despite their unmethylated in vivo condition. This was tested using a partially purified DNA-methyltransferase from human placenta and several cloned CpG-rich or CpG-depleted sequences. The efficiency of methylation was found to be proportional to the CpG content for CpG-depleted regions, which are representative of the bulk genome. However, methylation was much less efficient for CpG frequencies higher than 1 in 12 nucleotides, reaching only 60% of the expected level. That suggests that the close CpG spacing typical of CpG-islands somehow inhibits mammalian DNA methyltransferase. The implications of these findings on the in vivo pattern of DNA methylation are discussed.

Mouse DNA methylase. Intracellular location and degradation

DNA methylase extracted with low salt from mouse Krebs II ascites cell nuclei has been degraded stepwise by trypsin treatment. Degradation, accompanied by a limited reduction in size of the native enzyme, leads to the progressive introduction of several nicks so that, eventually, fragments of 14, 18, 24 and 28 kD are released on denaturation. This illustrates the domain structure of the enzyme. In contrast to ascites cell nuclear extracts, preparations from liver nuclei are already nicked and the major from of the enzyme contains a 100 kD fragment though the native molecular weight is unchanged. Newborn mouse liver contains more undegraded enzyme that is mostly firmly-bound within the nucleus. Trypsin treatment increases the de novo activity of the enzyme and prevents its aggregation in the absence of salt, even in the presence of high concentrations of native DNA.

Sea urchin DNA methyltransferases

DNA methyltransferase activities have been partially purified from unfertilized eggs and blastula nuclei of sea urchin embryos. Comparative studies, using different DNAs as substrates, show that the two preparations are most active on hemimethylated and single-strand DNA, but they methylate, though at a lower rate, also on double-strand DNA. The two activities show distinctive efficiencies in methylating plasmid DNAs and marked differences in the rate of methyl transfer to DNAs in different structural states: linear, relaxed, or supercoiled. The ratio of the apparent specific activity of the two preparations depends on the particular DNA used as substrate and its structure. Methylation analysis of the restriction fragments of methylated plasmid DNAs shows a linear correlation between introduced methyl groups and the percent of CpG of each particular fragment, indicating that methylation is substantially random and sequence is less relevant than conformation in determining enzyme efficiency. The data do not permit us to decide if the two activities are different enzymes or the same enzyme with different modulating factors.

Localization, in human placenta, of the tightly bound form of DNA methylase in the higher order of chromatin organization

In human placenta, the DNA of all subfractions of the third level of chromatin organization exhibits similar values of the methylcytosine-to-cytosine ratio. The tightly bound form of DNA methyltransferase is mostly recovered in the 'stripped loop' fraction, although, on the basis of the DNA content, the 'stripped loops' and the 'stripped matrix' appear to possess a similar amount of the enzyme. DNA methyltransferase activity is instead totally absent from the 'digested matrix', i.e., from the fraction remaining after digestion of the 'stripped matrix' with DNAase I. Upon addition of exogenous DNA methyltransferase, however, the DNA of this fraction, which is only 1% (in weight) of the total chromatin DNA and which has a length of approx. 9 kbp, can readily undergo methylation.

Inactivation of de novo DNA methyltransferase activity by high concentrations of double-stranded DNA

The activity of eukaryotic DNA methyltransferase diminishes with time when the enzyme is incubated with high concentrations (200-300 micrograms/ml) of unmethylated double-stranded Micrococcus luteus DNA. Under similar conditions, single-stranded DNA induces only a limited decrease of enzyme activity. The inactivation process is apparently due to a slowly progressive interaction of the enzyme with double-stranded DNA that is independent of the presence of S-adenosyl-L-methionine. The inhibited enzyme cannot be reactivated either by high salt dissociation of the DNA-enzyme complex or by extensive digestion of the DNA. Among synthetic polydeoxyribonucleotides both poly(dG-dC).poly(dG-dC) and poly(dA-dT).poly(dA-dT), but not poly(dI-dC).poly(dI-dC), cause inactivation of DNA methyltransferase. This inactivation process may be of interest in regulating the 'de novo' activity of the enzyme.