The three-dimensional structure and function of Escherichia coli ribosomal RNA, as studied by cross-linking techniques

A Path to the Atomic-Resolution Structures of Prokaryotic and Eukaryotic Ribosomes

Resolving first crystal structures of prokaryotic and eukaryotic ribosomes by our group has been based on the knowledge accumulated over the decades of studies, starting with the first electron microscopy images of the ribosome obtained by J. Pallade in 1955. In 1983, A. Spirin, then a Director of the Protein Research Institute of the USSR Academy of Sciences, initiated the first study aimed at solving the structure of ribosomes using X-ray structural analysis. In 1999, our group in collaboration with H. Noller published the first crystal structure of entire bacterial ribosome in a complex with its major functional ligands, such as messenger RNA and three transport RNAs at the A, P, and E sites. In 2011, our laboratory published the first atomic-resolution structure of eukaryotic ribosome solved by the X-ray diffraction analysis that confirmed the conserved nature of the main ribosomal functional components, such as the decoding and peptidyl transferase centers, was confirmed, and eukaryote-specific elements of the ribosome were described. Using X-ray structural analysis, we investigated general principles of protein biosynthesis inhibition in eukaryotic ribosomes, along with the mechanisms of antibiotic resistance. Structural differences between bacterial and eukaryotic ribosomes that determine the differences in their inhibition were established. These and subsequent atomic-resolution structures of the functional ribosome demonstrated for the first time the details of binding of messenger and transport RNAs, which was the first step towards understanding how the ribosome structure ultimately determines its functions.

cDNA, genomic sequence cloning and overexpression of ribosomal protein gene L9 (rpL9) of the giant panda (Ailuropoda melanoleuca)

The ribosomal protein L9 (RPL9), a component of the large subunit of the ribosome, has an unusual structure, comprising two compact globular domains connected by an α-helix; it interacts with 23 S rRNA. To obtain information about rpL9 of Ailuropoda melanoleuca (the giant panda) we designed primers based on the known mammalian nucleotide sequence. RT-PCR and PCR strategies were employed to isolate cDNA and the rpL9 gene from A. melanoleuca; these were sequenced and analyzed. We overexpressed cDNA of the rpL9 gene in Escherichia coli BL21. The cloned cDNA fragment was 627 bp in length, containing an open reading frame of 579 bp. The deduced protein is composed of 192 amino acids, with an estimated molecular mass of 21.86 kDa and an isoelectric point of 10.36. The length of the genomic sequence is 3807 bp, including six exons and five introns. Based on alignment analysis, rpL9 has high similarity among species; we found 85% agreement of DNA and amino acid sequences with the other species that have been analyzed. Based on topology predictions, there are two N-glycosylation sites, five protein kinase C phosphorylation sites, one casein kinase II phosphorylation site, two tyrosine kinase phosphorylation sites, three N-myristoylation sites, one amidation site, and one ribosomal protein L6 signature 2 in the L9 protein of A. melanoleuca. The rpL9 gene can be readily expressed in E. coli; it fuses with the N-terminal GST-tagged protein, giving rise to the accumulation of an expected 26.51-kDa polypeptide, which is in good agreement with the predicted molecular weight. This expression product could be used for purification and further study of its function.

Analysis of the roles of tRNA structure, ribosomal protein L9, and the bacteriophage T4 gene 60 bypassing signals during ribosome slippage on mRNA

A 50-nucleotide coding gap divides bacteriophage T4 gene 60 into two open reading frames. In response to cis-acting stimulatory signals encrypted in the mRNA, the anticodon of the ribosome-bound peptidyl tRNA dissociates from a GGA codon at the end of the first open reading frame and pairs with a GGA codon 47 nucleotides downstream just before the second open reading frame. Mutations affecting ribosomal protein L9 or tRNA(Gly)(2), the tRNA that decodes GGA, alter the efficiency of bypassing. To understand the mechanism of ribosome slippage, this work analyzes the influence of these bypassing signals and mutant translational components on -1 frameshifting at G GGA and hopping over a stop codon immediately flanked by two GGA glycine codons (stop-hopping). Mutant variants of tRNA(Gly)(2) that impair bypassing mediate stop-hopping with unexpected landing specificities, suggesting that these variants are defective in ribosomal P-site codon-anticodon pairing. In a direct competition between -1 frameshifting and stop-hopping, the absence of L9 promotes stop-hopping at the expense of -1 frameshifting without substantially impairing the ability of mutant tRNA(Gly)(2) variants to re-pair with the mRNA by sub-optimal pairing. These observations suggest that L9 defects may stimulate ribosome slippage by enhancing mRNA movement through the ribosome rather than by inducing an extended pause in translation or by destabilizing P-site pairing. Two of the bypassing signals, a cis-acting nascent peptide encoded by the first open reading frame and a stemloop signal located in the 5' portion of the coding gap, stimulate peptidyl-tRNA slippage independently of the rest of the gene 60 context. Evidence is presented suggesting that the nascent peptide signal may stimulate bypassing by destabilizing P-site pairing.

Coupling of open reading frames by translational bypassing

Translational bypassing joins the information found within two disparate open reading frames into a single polypeptide chain. The underlying mechanism centers on the decoding properties of peptidyl-transfer RNA (tRNA) and involves three stages: take-off, scanning, and landing. In take-off, the peptidyl-tRNA/messenger RNA (mRNA) complex in the P site of the ribosome dissociates, and the mRNA begins to move through the ribosome. In scanning, the peptidyl-tRNA probes the mRNA sliding through the decoding center. In landing, the peptidyl-tRNA re-pairs with a codon with which it can form a stable interaction. Although few examples of genes are known that rely on translational bypassing to couple open reading frames, ribosomes appear to have an innate capacity for bypassing. This suggests that the strategy of translational bypassing may be more common than presently appreciated. The best characterized example of this phenomenon is T4 gene 60, in which a complex set of signals stimulates bypassing of 50 nucleotides between the two open reading frames. In this review, we focus on the bypassing mechanism of gene 60 in terms of take-off, scanning, and landing.

One protein from two open reading frames: mechanism of a 50 nt translational bypass

Translating ribosomes bypass a 50 nt coding gap in order to fuse the information found in the two open reading frames (ORFs) of bacteriophage T4 gene 60. This study investigates the underlying mechanism by focusing on the competition between initiation of bypassing and termination at the end of the first ORF. While nearly all ribosomes initiate bypassing, no more than 50% resume translation in the second ORF. Two previously described cis-acting stimulatory signals are critical for favoring initiation of bypassing over termination. Genetic analysis of these signals supports a working model in which the first (a stem-loop structure at the junction between the first ORF and the coding gap) interferes with decoding in the A-site, and the second (a stretch of amino acids in the nascent peptide encoded by the first ORF) destabilizes peptidyl-tRNA-mRNA pairing.

The stability and dynamics of ribosomal protein L9: investigations of a molecular strut by amide proton exchange and circular dichroism

Nuclear magnetic resonance and circular dichroism experiments were used to investigate the stability and dynamic aspects of ribosomal protein L9 from Bacillus stearothermophilus in solution. This unusually shaped protein, with its two widely spaced RNA-binding domains linked by a connecting helix, has been hypothesized to serve as a "molecular strut", most likely playing a role in ribosome assembly and/or maintaining the catalytically active conformation of ribosomal RNA. Protection factors for amide proton exchange were quantitatively measured in an extensive series of NMR experiments, providing probes of the stability and dynamics of localized regions of the protein. Results show that each of the two RNA-binding domains contains a highly stable core. The exposed central helix that connects the two domains is helical in solution, albeit not rigid, a result that is supported by amide proton protection factors, circular dichroism measurements, and carbon-13 and proton chemical shift index values. A conserved glycine and lysine-rich loop in the N-terminal domain is ordered and quite stable, a surprising result, since this loop had been presumed to be disordered in the original crystallographic analysis. Interestingly, the most dynamic parts of the protein are the regions that contain the likely RNA-binding residues in each of the two domains. The present results add further support to the notion that the L9 protein plays an architectural role within the ribosome, with the central helix serving as a molecular strut, or perhaps a spring, linking the two widely spaced RNA-binding domains.

Ribosomal protein L9: a structure determination by the combined use of X-ray crystallography and NMR spectroscopy

The structure of protein L9 from the Bacillus stearothernophilus ribosome has been determined at 2.5 A resolution by refinement against single crystal X-ray diffraction data with additional constraints provided by NMR data. This highly elongated protein consists of two domains separated by a nine-turn connecting helix. Conserved aromatic and positively charged amino acid residues on the surface of each domain are likely to be directly involved in binding 23 S ribosomal RNA. The shape of the protein, with its two widely spaced RNA-binding sites, suggests that it may serve as a "molecular strut", most likely playing a role in ribosome assembly and/or maintaining the catalytically active conformation of the ribosomal RNA. The combined use of X-ray and NMR data in the refinement procedure was essential in defining the N-terminal domain of the protein, which was relatively poorly determined by the X-ray data alone. In addition to resolving the ambiguities in defining the hydrophobic core and side-chain conformations with the N-terminal domain, this combined NMR-X-ray analysis provides the first detailed and accurate view of the N-terminal RNA-binding site. NMR data also showed that the N-terminal domain is stable in solution, indicated by amide protons that are protected from solvent exchange. The lack of definition of the N-terminal domain in the X-ray structure is therefore likely due to packing disorder within the crystal rather than structural instability. This combined NMR-X-ray analysis provides a useful model as to how X-ray and NMR data can be practically and logically combined in the determination of the structure of a single protein molecule.

Modeling the structure of the ribosome

Considering the size and complexity of the ribosome and the growing body of data from a wide range of experiments on ribosomal structure, it is becoming increasingly important to develop tools that facilitate the development of reliable models for the ribosome. We use a combination of manual and computer-based approaches for building and refining models of the ribosome and other RNA-protein complexes. Our methods are aimed at determining the range of models compatible with the data, making quantitative statements about the positional uncertainties (resolution) of different regions, identifying conflicts in the data, establishing which regions of the ribosome need further experimental exploration, and, where possible, predicting the outcome of future experiments. Our previous low-resolution model for the small subunit of the Escherichia coli ribosome is briefly reviewed, along with progress on atomic resolution modeling of the mRNA-tRNA complex and its interaction with the decoding site of the 16S RNA.

Two regions of the Escherichia coli 16S ribosomal RNA are important for decoding stop signals in polypeptide chain termination

Two regions of the 16S rRNA, helix 34, and the aminoacyl site component of the decoding site at the base of helix 44, have been implicated in decoding of translational stop signals during the termination of protein synthesis. Antibiotics specific for these regions have been tested to see how they discriminate the decoding of UAA, UAG, and UGA by the two polypeptide chain release factors (RF-1 and RF-2). Spectinomycin, which interacts with helix 34, stimulated RF-1 dependent binding to the ribosome and termination. It also stimulated UGA dependent RF-2 termination at micromolar concentrations but inhibited UGA dependent RF-2 binding at higher concentrations. Alterations at position C1192 of helix 34, known to confer spectinomycin resistance, reduced the binding of f[3H]Met-tRNA to the peptidyl-tRNA site. They also impaired termination in vitro, with both factors and all three stop codons, although the effect was greater with RF-2 mediated reactions. These alterations had previously been shown to inhibit EF-G mediated translocation. As perturbations in helix 34 effect both termination and elongation reactions, these results indicate that helix 34 is close to the decoding site on the bacterial ribosome. Several antibiotics, hygromycin, neomycin and tetracycline, specific for the aminoacyl site, were shown to inhibit the binding and function of both RFs in termination with all three stop codons in vitro. These studies indicate that decoding of all stop signals is likely to occur at a similar site on the ribosome to the decoding of sense codons, the aminoacyl site, and are consistent with a location for helix 34 near this site.

Characterization and primary structure of proteins L28, L33 and L34 from Bacillus stearothermophilus ribosomes

The complete amino acid sequences of 3 proteins from the 50S subunit of Bacillus stearothermophilus ribosomes were determined by N-terminal sequence analysis and by sequencing of overlapping fragments obtained from enzymatic digestions and chemical cleavages. The proteins BstL28, BstL33 and BstL34, named according to the equivalent proteins in Escherichia coli ribosomes, consist of 60, 49, and 44 amino acid residues and have calculated molecular masses of 6811.0, 5908.6, and 5253.9 Da, respectively. They are highly basic with a content of positively charged residues ranging between 29% for L33 and 45% for L34. The 3 proteins were positioned in the 2-dimensional map of B stearothermophilus 50S ribosomal proteins. The electrophoretic mobilities confirm sizes and net charges deduced from the sequences.

Localization of a series of RNA-protein cross-link sites in the 23S and 5S ribosomal RNA from Escherichia coli, induced by treatment of 50S subunits with three different bifunctional reagents

50S ribosomal subunits were reacted with bis-(2-chloroethyl)methylamine, 2-iminothiolane or methyl p-azidophenyl acetimidate, and RNA-protein cross-link sites on the RNA were localised using our published procedures. The degree of precision with which these sites could be determined was variable, depending on the particular protein or RNA region concerned. The following positions in the 23S RNA were identified as encompassing the individual cross-link sites (numbered from the 5'-end, with asterisks denoting sites previously reported): L1, 1864-67, 1876-78, 2119-33, 2163-72*, L2, 1819-20*; L3, 2832-34; L4, 320-25*; 613-17*; L5, 2307; L6, 2473-81*; L9, 1484-91; L11, 1060-62; L13, 547-50; L14, 1993-2002; L17, 1260-95; L18, 2307-20; L19, 1741-58; L21, 544-48*; 1198-1248; L23, 63-65, 137-41*; L24, 99-107*; L27, 2272-83, 2320-23*; 2332-37*; L28, 195-242, 368-424; L29, 101-02*; L30, 931-38; L32, 2878-90; L33, 2422-24. Cross-links to 5S RNA were observed with L5 (positions 34-41), and L18 (precise site not localised).