Interaction of human and Escherichia coli tRNA(Phe) with human 80S ribosomes in the presence of oligo- and polyuridylate templates

Functional involvement of a conserved motif in the middle region of the human ribosomal protein eL42 in translation

Ribosomal protein eL42 (formerly known as L36A), a small protein of the large (60S) subunit of the eukaryotic ribosome, is a component of its exit (E) site. The residue K53 of this protein resides within the motif QSGYGGQTK mainly conserved in eukaryotes, and it is located in the immediate vicinity of the CCA-terminus of the ribosome-bound tRNA in the hybrid P/E state. To examine the role of this eL42 motif in translation, we obtained HEK293T cells producing the wild-type FLAG-tagged protein or its mutant forms with either single substitutions of conserved amino acid residues in the above motif, or simultaneous replacements in positions 45 and 51 or 45 and 53. Examination of the level of exogenous eL42 in fractions of polysome profiles from the target protein-producing cells by the Western blotting revealed that neither single substitution affects the assembly of 60S ribosomal subunits and 80S ribosomes or critically decreases the level of polysomes, but the latter was observed with the double replacements. Analysis of tRNAs bound to 80S ribosomes containing eL42 with double substitutions and examination their peptidyl transferase activity enabled estimation the stage of the elongation cycle, in which amino acid residues of the conserved eL42 motif are involved. We clearly show that cooperative interactions implicating the eL42 residues Q45, Q51, and K53 play a critical role in the ability of the human ribosome to perform properly elongation cycle at the step of deacylated tRNA dissociation from the E site in the human cell.

Interaction of tRNA with eukaryotic ribosome

This paper is a review of currently available data concerning interactions of tRNAs with the eukaryotic ribosome at various stages of translation. These data include the results obtained by means of cryo-electron microscopy and X-ray crystallography applied to various model ribosomal complexes, site-directed cross-linking with the use of tRNA derivatives bearing chemically or photochemically reactive groups in the CCA-terminal fragment and chemical probing of 28S rRNA in the region of the peptidyl transferase center. Similarities and differences in the interactions of tRNAs with prokaryotic and eukaryotic ribosomes are discussed with concomitant consideration of the extent of resemblance between molecular mechanisms of translation in eukaryotes and bacteria.

Positioning of CCA-arms of the A- and the P-tRNAs towards the 28S rRNA in the human ribosome

Nucleotides of 28S rRNA involved in binding of the human 80S ribosome with acceptor ends of the A site and the P site tRNAs were determined using two complementary approaches, namely, cross-linking with application of tRNA(Asp) analogues substituted with 4-thiouridine in position 75 or 76 and hydroxyl radical footprinting with the use of the full sized tRNA and the tRNA deprived of the 3'-terminal trinucleotide CCA. In general, these 28S rRNA nucleotides are located in ribosomal regions homologous to the A, P and E sites of the prokaryotic 50S subunit. However, none of the approaches used discovered interactions of the apex of the large rRNA helix 80 with the acceptor end of the P site tRNA typical with prokaryotic ribosomes. Application of the results obtained to available atomic models of 50S and 60S subunits led us to a conclusion that the A site tRNA is actually present in both A/A and A/P states and the P site tRNA in the P/P and P/E states. Thus, the present study gives a biochemical confirmation of the data on the structure and dynamics of the mammalian ribosomal pretranslocation complex obtained with application of cryo-electron microscopy and single-molecule FRET [Budkevich et al., 2011]. Moreover, in our study, particular sets of 28S rRNA nucleotides involved in oscillations of tRNAs CCA-termini between their alternative locations in the mammalian 80S ribosome are revealed.

Structural and functional topography of the human ribosome

This review covers data on the structural organization of functional sites in the human ribosome, namely, the messenger RNA binding center, the binding site of the hepatitis C virus RNA internal ribosome entry site, and the peptidyl transferase center. The data summarized here have been obtained primarily by means of a site-directed cross-linking approach with application of the analogs of the respective ribosomal ligands bearing cross-linkers at the designed positions. These data are discussed taking into consideration available structural data on ribosomes from various kingdoms obtained with the use of cryo-electron microscopy, X-ray crystallography, and other approaches.

Sites of 18S rRNA contacting mRNA 3' and 5' of the P site codon in human ribosome: a cross-linking study with mRNAs carrying 4-thiouridines at specific positions

Long synthetic mRNAs were used to study the positioning of the E site codon, the 2nd and 3rd nucleotides of the A site bound codon and a nucleotide 3' of this codon with respect to the 18S rRNA in the human 80S ribosome. The mRNAs contained a GAC triplet coding for Asp and a single 4-thiouridine residue (s(4)U) upstream or downstream of the GAC codon. In the presence of tRNA(Asp), the GAC codon of the mRNAs was targeted to the ribosomal P site thus placing s(4)U in one of the following positions -3, -2, -1, +5, +6 or +7 with respect to the first nucleotide of the P site bound codon. It was found that mRNAs that bore s(4)U in positions +5 to +7 cross-linked to the 18S rRNA nucleotides C1696, C1698 and 1820-1825, the distribution of cross-links among these targets depending on the position of s(4)U. Cross-links of mRNAs containing s(4)U in positions -3 to -1 were found in the region 1699-1704 of the 18S rRNA. In the absence of tRNA, all mRNAs cross-linked only to C1696 and C1698. Absence of the cross-linked nucleotides C1696 and C1698 in the case of mRNAs containing s(4)U in positions -3 to -1 confirmed that tRNA(Asp) actually phased the mRNA on the ribosome.

Arrangement of 3'-terminus of tRNA on the human ribosome as revealed from cross-linking data

This study is directed towards an important problem concerning the organization of the peptidyl transferase center (PTC) on the mammalian ribosome that cannot be studied by X-ray analysis since crystals of 80S ribosomes are still unavailable. Here, we investigated the arrangement of the 3'-end of tRNA in the 80S ribosomal A and P sites using a tRNA(Asp) analogue that bears a 4-thiouridine (s(4)U) attached to the 3'-terminal adenosine. It was shown that an additional nucleotide s(4)U77 on the 3'-end does not impede codon-dependent binding of the tRNA to the A and P sites of 80S ribosome. Mild UV-irradiation of the ribosomal complexes containing a short appropriately designed mRNA and the tRNA analogue resulted in cross-linking of the analogue exclusively to 28S rRNA. The cross-linking site was detected in the 4302-4540 fragment of the 28S rRNA which belongs to the highly conserved domain V that in prokaryotic ribosomes is involved in the formation of the PTC. Nucleotides cross-linked to the tRNA analogue were determined by means of reverse transcription. A comparison of the results obtained with a dynamic model of mutual arrangement of s(4)U77 of the A site tRNA and nucleotides of 23S rRNA built on the basis of an atomic model for the prokaryotic PTC led to the conclusion that environments of the tRNA 3'-terminus in prokaryotic and eukaryotic ribosomes share a significant extent of similarity, although pronounced differences are also detectable.

[The environment of tRNA 3'-terminus in 80S ribosome A and P sites]

The environment of tRNA 3'-terminus in the 80S ribosomal A and P sites was studied with a tRNA(Asp) analogue that bears a 4-thiouridine residue (s4U) attached to the 3'-terminal adenosine. The tRNA(Asp) analogue was obtained by in vitro T7 transcription followed by crosslinking with [32P]ps4Up and removal of the 3'-terminal phosphate. It was shown that the presence of the additional nucleotide at the 3'-end does not to hinder the codon-dependent binding of the tRNA to the A and P sites of 80S ribosome. Mild UV-irradiation of the ribosomal complexes containing a short appropriately designed mRNA and the tRNA analogue resulted in crosslinking of the analogue exclusively to 28S rRNA. The crosslinking was completely dependent on the presence of s4U in the tRNA analogue. Using hydrolysis of the crosslinked 28S rRNA with RNase H in the presence of deoxyoligomers complementary to various rRNA sequences, we determined that the crosslinking occurred in fragment 4302-4540 of the 28S rRNA. This fragment is evolutionarily conservative and belongs to domain V that is involved in the formation of the peptidyl transferase site in prokaryotic ribosomes. The use of reverse transcription allowed the determination of the tRNA analogue crosslinking in the P site to nucleotides U4461 and U4502, and the analogue in the A site, to nucleotides U4469 and C4507. In addition, nucleotide C4462 was crosslinked to both P site and A site-bound tRNA analogue. An analysis of the results demonstrates that environments of the tRNA 3'-termini are closely similar in both prokaryotic and eukaryotic ribosomes.

Stop codons and UGG promote efficient binding of the polypeptide release factor eRF1 to the ribosomal A site

To investigate the codon dependence of human eRF1 binding to the mRNA-ribosome complex, we examined the formation of photocrosslinks between ribosomal components and mRNAs bearing a photoactivable 4-thiouridine probe in the first position of the codon located in the A site. Addition of eRF1 to the phased mRNA-ribosome complexes triggers a codon-dependent quenching of crosslink formation. The concentration of eRF1 triggering half quenching ranges from low for the three stop codons, to intermediate for s4UGG and high for other near-cognate triplets. A theoretical analysis of the photochemical processes occurring in a two-state bimolecular model raises a number of stringent conditions, fulfilled by the system studied here, and shows that in any case sound KD values can be extracted if the ratio mT/KD<<1 (mT is total concentration of mRNA added). Considering the KD values obtained for the stop, s4UGG and sense codons (approximately 0.06 microM, 0.45 microM and 2.3 microM, respectively) and our previous finding that only the stop and s4UGG codons are able to promote formation of an eRF1-mRNA crosslink, implying a role for the NIKS loop at the tip of the N domain, we propose a two-step model for eRF1 binding to the A site: a codon-independent bimolecular step is followed by an isomerisation step observed solely with stop and s4UGG codons. Full recognition of the stop codons by the N domain of eRF1 triggers a rearrangement of bound eRF1 from an open to a closed conformation, allowing the universally conserved GGQ loop at the tip of the M domain to come into close proximity of the peptidyl transferase center of the ribosome. UGG is expected to behave as a cryptic stop codon, which, owing to imperfect eRF1-codon recognition, does not allow full reorientation of the M domain of eRF1. As far as the physical steps of eRF1 binding to the ribosome are considered, they appear to closely mimic the behaviour of the tRNA/EF-Tu/GTP complex, but clearly eRF1 is endowed with a greater conformational flexibility than tRNA.

The invariant uridine of stop codons contacts the conserved NIKSR loop of human eRF1 in the ribosome

To unravel the region of human eukaryotic release factor 1 (eRF1) that is close to stop codons within the ribosome, we used mRNAs containing a single photoactivatable 4-thiouridine (s(4)U) residue in the first position of stop or control sense codons. Accurate phasing of these mRNAs onto the ribosome was achieved by the addition of tRNA(Asp). Under these conditions, eRF1 was shown to crosslink exclusively to mRNAs containing a stop or s(4)UGG codon. A procedure that yielded (32)P-labeled eRF1 deprived of the mRNA chain was developed; analysis of the labeled peptides generated after specific cleavage of both wild-type and mutant eRF1s maps the crosslink in the tripeptide KSR (positions 63-65 of human eRF1) and points to K63 located in the conserved NIKS loop as the main crosslinking site. These data directly show the interaction of the N-terminal (N) domain of eRF1 with stop codons within the 40S ribosomal subunit and provide strong support for the positioning of the eRF1 middle (M) domain on the 60S subunit. Thus, the N and M domains mimic the tRNA anticodon and acceptor arms, respectively.

The polypeptide chain release factor eRF1 specifically contacts the s(4)UGA stop codon located in the A site of eukaryotic ribosomes

It has been shown previously [Brown, C.M. & Tate, W.P. (1994) J. Biol. Chem. 269, 33164-33170.] that the polypeptide chain release factor RF2 involved in translation termination in prokaryotes was able to photocrossreact with mini-messenger RNAs containing stop signals in which U was replaced by 4-thiouridine (s4U). Here, using the same strategy we have monitored photocrosslinking to eukaryotic ribosomal components of 14-mer mRNA in the presence of tRNA(f)(Met), and 42-mer mRNA in the presence of tRNA(Asp) (tRNA(Asp) gene transcript). We show that: (a) both 14-mer and 42-mer mRNAs crossreact with ribosomal RNA and ribosomal proteins. The patterns of the crosslinked ribosomal proteins are similar with both mRNAs and sensitive to ionic conditions; (b) the crosslinking patterns obtained with 42-mer mRNAs show characteristic modification upon addition of tRNA(Asp) providing evidence for appropriate mRNA phasing onto the ribosome. Similar changes are not detected with the 14-mer mRNA.tRNA(f)(Met) pairs; (c) when eukaryotic polypeptide chain release factor 1 (eRF1) is added to the ribosome.tRNA(Asp) complex it crossreacts with the 42-mer mRNA containing the s(4)UGA stop codon located in the A site, but not with the s(4)UCA sense codon; this crosslink involves the N-terminal and middle domains of eRF1 but not the C domain which interacts with eukaryotic polypeptide chain release factor 3 (eRF3); (d) addition of eRF3 has no effect on the yield of eRF1-42-mer mRNA crosslinking and eRF3 does not crossreact with 42-mer mRNA. These experiments delineate the in vitro conditions allowing optimal phasing of mRNA on the eukaryotic ribosome and demonstrate a direct and specific contact of 'core' eRF1 and s(4)UGA stop codon within the ribosomal A site.

Chemical accessibility of 18S rRNA in native ribosomal complexes: interaction sites of mRNA, tRNA and translation factors

During protein synthesis the ribosome interacts with ligands such as mRNA, tRNA and translation factors. We have studied the effect of ribosome-ligand interaction on the accessibility of 18S rRNA for single strand-specific modification in ribosomal complexes that have been assembled in vivo, i. e. native polysomes. A comparison of the modification patterns derived from programmed and non-programmed ribosomes showed that bases in the 630- and 1060-loops (530- and 790-loops in E. coli) together with two nucleotides in helices 33 and 34 were protected from chemical modification. The majority of the protected sites were homologous to sites previously suggested to be involved in mRNA and/or tRNA binding in prokaryotes and eukaryotes, implying that the interaction sites for these ligands are similar, if not identical, in naturally occurring programmed ribosomes and in in vitro assembled ribosomal complexes. Additional differences between programmed and non-programmed ribosomes were found in hairpin 8. The bases in helix 8 showed increased exposure to chemical modification in the programmed ribosomes. In addition, structural differences in helices 36 and 37 were observed between native 80S run-off ribosomes and 80S ribosomes assembled from isolated 40S and 60S subunits.

Protection patterns of tRNAs do not change during ribosomal translocation

The translocation reaction of two tRNAs on the ribosome during elongation of the nascent peptide chain is one of the most puzzling reactions of protein biosynthesis. We show here that the ribosomal contact patterns of the two tRNAs at A and P sites, although strikingly different from each other, hardly change during the translocation reaction to the P and E sites, respectively. The results imply that the ribosomal micro-environment of the tRNAs remains the same before and after translocation and thus suggest that a movable ribosomal domain exists that tightly binds two tRNAs and carries them together with the mRNA during the translocation reaction from the A-P region to the P-E region. These findings lead to a new explanation for the translocation reaction.

Influence of systematic error on the shape of the scatchard plot of tRNAPhe binding to eukaryotic ribosomes

Scatchard plots of tRNAPhe binding to poly(U)-programmed human 80 S ribosomes can be curved, either concave upwards or concave downwards, depending on the experimental conditions. The influence of a systematic error on the shape of the Scatchard plots has been analysed in a model experiment where the binding proceeds at two independent sites. The Scatchard plot for this binding model has a concave-upwards shape. When the concentration of the ribosomes is kept constant, a small systematic error in tRNA concentration changes this Scatchard plot markedly to a concave-downwards plot as though a co-operative interaction occurred. In contrast, when the tRNA concentration exceeds the ribosomal concentration and their concentration ratio is constant, the Scatchard plot is stable with respect to the systematic error. We suggest the latter type of experiment to be more appropriate. The results also imply a non-co-operative interaction of tRNAPhe with the 80 S ribosome.

Protein environment of mRNA at the decoding site of 80S ribosomes from human placenta as revealed from affinity labeling with mRNA analogs--derivatives of oligoribonucleotides

Affinity labeling of 80S ribosomes from human placenta has been studied using various mRNA analogs, namely, 2',3'-O-[4-(N-2-chloroethyl)-N-methylamino]benzylidene derivatives of oligoribonucleotides (Up)(n-1)U[32P]pC (n = 3, 6 or 12) and AUGU3[32P]pC as well as ([4-(N-2-chloroethyl)-N-methylamino]benzylmethyl-[5'-32P]-phospham ide derivatives of pAUGUn (n = 3 or 6). Labeling of 80S ribosomes with the derivatives of oligouridylates was carried out in complexes obtained nonenzymatically in the presence of saturating amounts of Phe-tRNA(Phe). Complexes with derivatives bearing AUG codon were obtained using a fractionated lysate from rabbit reticulocytes which contained protein translation factors and was deprived from endogeneous ribosomes and mRNAs. In all cases, 40S subunits were labeled preferentially. Within the subunits, both 18S rRNA and proteins were found to be modified. Sites of cross-linking in 18S rRNA have been identified earlier. Here, it is shown that the main targets of cross-linking among the ribosomal proteins were S3 and S3a (with minor modification of S26) for the 3'-derivatives of (Up)5UpC and (Up)11UpC. For the same derivative of (Up)2UpC, the reverse modification pattern was observed. 5'-derivatives of pAUGUn were cross-linked to proteins S3 and S3a in comparable extent; 3'-derivative of AUGU3pC modified protein S3a preferentially.

Studying functional significance of the sequence 980-1061 in the central domain of human 18S rRNA using complementary DNA probes

Region 980-1061 in human 18S rRNA has been chosen on the basis of our previous results, indicating that cross-linking sites of the alkylating mRNA analogs are located within this region. In the present study, we have used 10 DNA 15-mers complementary to various overlapping sequences within the 18S rRNA positions 980-1061. Their abilities to bind selectively to the target rRNA sequences were proved by hydrolysis of 18S rRNA within heteroduplexes with the corresponding probes by RNase H. Four sequences (980-994, 987-1001, 1025-1039 and 1032-1046) were found to be well accessible for binding of the respective cDNA probes within 40S subunits. None of the oligomers inhibited tRNA(Phe)-dependent binding of oligo(U) messenger to 40S subunits and binding of Met-tRNA(imet) to 40S subunits in the presence of eIF-2 and nonhydrolysable GTP analog. Nevertheless, two probes (complementary to the 18S rRNA sequences 987-1001 and 1025-1039) being covalently attached to 40S subunits, inhibited translation of poly(U) by human 80S ribosomes in a cell-free system. The same oligomers revealed the most pronounced inhibitory action on the binding of messenger trinucleotide in the complex pAUG.40S.Met-tRNA(imet).eIF-2.GTP. Results of these functional assays demonstrate the importance of the 18S rRNA sequences 987-1001 and 1025-1039 for translation process on human ribosomes, most probably at the initiation step.

Arrangement of mRNA at the decoding site of human ribosomes. 18S rRNA nucleotides and ribosomal proteins cross-linked to oligouridylate derivatives with alkylating groups at either the 3' or the 5' termini

Affinity labeling of human placental 80S ribosomes with mRNA analogs of up to 12 uridyl residues, i.e. alkylating derivatives of oligouridylates bearing either 4-(N-2-chloroethyl-N-methylamino)benzylmethylphosphamide group at the 5'-termini or 2',3'-O-[4-(N-2-chloroethyl-N-methylamino)]benzylidene residue attached to the 3'-termini, in the presence of cognate Phe-tRNA(Phe) has been investigated. All the mRNA analogs modified only the 40S subunit. The fraction of 18S rRNA modified by the mRNA analogs with the alkylating group at the 5'-end decreased dramatically with extension of the reagent oligouridylate moiety. Nucleotides of 18S rRNA alkylated with the mRNA analogs were determined using a reverse transcription technique. For the mRNA analogs with the alkylating groups at the 3'-termini, G1702 and G1763/G1764 were identified as the cross-linking sites. The intensities of the bands corresponding to reverse transcriptase stops depended on the length of the reagent oligouridylate moieties. Cross-linking sites of the mRNA analogs with the alkylating group at the 5'-termini on 18S rRNA were A1023, C1026, C1057 and A1058 for the (pU)3 and (pU)4 derivatives and a single nucleotide C1057 for the (pU)6 one. Ribosomal protein S26 was found as the main target of modification with the same derivatives of (pU)6 and (pU)12.

Solution of the ribosome riddle: how the ribosome selects the correct aminoacyl-tRNA out of 41 similar contestants

Three tRNA binding sites, the A, P and E sites, have been demonstrated on ribosomes of bacterial, archaebacterial and eukaryotic origin. In all these cases the first and the third site, the A and the E site, are allosterically coupled in the sense of a negative co-operativity. Therefore, the allosteric three-site model seems to be a generally valid description of the ribosomal elongation phase, where in a cycle of reactions the nascent peptide chain is prolonged by one amino acid. The molecular concept of the allosteric three-site model explains the astonishing ability of the ribosome to select the correct substrate out of a large number of very similar substrates, and it provides a framework within which the mechanisms of the elongation factors could be understood.