Contributions to the S'-subsite specificity of papain

Molecular dynamics simulations of the catalytic pathway of a cysteine protease: a combined QM/MM study of human cathepsin K

Molecular dynamics simulations using a combined QM/MM potential have been performed to study the catalytic mechanism of human cathepsin K, a member of the papain family of cysteine proteases. We have determined the two-dimensional free energy surfaces of both acylation and deacylation steps to characterize the reaction mechanism. These free energy profiles show that the acylation step is rate limiting with a barrier height of 19.8 kcal/mol in human cathepsin K and of 29.3 kcal/mol in aqueous solution. The free energy of activation for the deacylation step is 16.7 kcal/mol in cathepsin K and 17.8 kcal/mol in aqueous solution. The reduction of free energy barrier is achieved by stabilization of the oxyanion in the transition state. Interestingly, although the "oxyanion hole" has been formed in the Michaelis complex, the amide units do not donate hydrogen bonds directly to the carbonyl oxygen of the substrate, but they stabilize the thiolate anion nucleophile. Hydrogen-bonding interactions are induced as the substrate amide group approaches the nucleophile, moving more than 2 A and placing the oxyanion in contact with Gln19 and the backbone amide of Cys25. The hydrolysis of peptide substrate shares a common mechanism both for the catalyzed reaction in human cathepsin K and for the uncatalyzed reaction in water. Overall, the nucleophilic attack by Cys25 thiolate and the proton-transfer reaction from His162 to the amide nitrogen are highly coupled, whereas a tetrahedral intermediate is formed along the nucleophilic reaction pathway.

Simple modifications of the serpin reactive site loop convert SCCA2 into a cysteine proteinase inhibitor: a critical role for the P3' proline in facilitating RSL cleavage

The human squamous cell carcinoma antigens (SCCA) 1 and 2 are members of the serpin family that are 92% identical in their amino acid sequence. Despite this similarity, they inhibit distinct classes of proteinases. SCCA1 neutralizes the papain-like cysteine proteinases, cathepsins (cat) S, L, and K; and SCCA2 inhibits the chymotrypsin-like serine proteinases, catG and human mast cell chymase. SCCA2 also can inhibit catS, as well as other papain-like cysteine proteinases, albeit at a rate 50-fold less than that of SCCA1. Analysis of the mechanism of inhibition by SCCA1 revealed that the reactive site loop (RSL) is important for cysteine proteinase inhibition. The inhibition of catS by a mutant SCCA2 containing the RSL of SCCA1 is comparable to that of wild-type SCCA1. This finding suggested that there were no motifs outside and only eight residues within the RSL that were directing catS-specific inhibition. The purpose of this study was to determine which of these residues might account for the marked difference in the ability of SCCA1 and SCCA2 to inhibit papain-like cysteine proteinases. SCCA2 molecules containing different RSL mutations showed that no single amino acid substitution could convert SCCA2 into a more potent cysteine proteinase inhibitor. Rather, different combinations of mutations led to incremental increases in catS inhibitory activity with residues in four positions (P1, P3', P4', and P11') accounting for 80% of the difference in activity between SCCA1 and SCCA2. Interestingly, the RSL cleavage site differed between wild-type SCCA2 and this mutant. Moreover, these data established the importance of a Pro residue in the P3' position for efficient inhibition of catS by both wild-type SCCA1 and mutated SCCA2. Molecular modeling studies suggested that this residue might facilitate positioning of the RSL within the active site of the cysteine proteinase.

Evaluation of resins for on-bead screening: a study of papain and chymotrypsin specificity using PEGA-bound combinatorial peptide libraries

TentaGel, ArgoGel and PEGA resins were evaluated for on-bead biological screening, using a fluorescently-labelled peptide attached to each and assayed for papain activity. Peptide attached to PEGA was cleaved in near quantitative yield at the expected sites, whilst an identical sequence on TentaGel and ArgoGel beads was hydrolysed in very low yields and nonspecifically on ArgoGel. The compatibility of PEGA with enzymes was further demonstrated by the determination of subsite specificities of papain and chymotrypsin using PEGA-bound peptide libraries, which proved to be similar to those observed in free solution.

The specificity of prolyl endopeptidase from Flavobacterium meningoseptum: mapping the S' subsites by positional scanning via acyl transfer

The S1'-S3' subsite specificity of prolyl endopeptidase from Flavobacterium meningoseptum was studied by acyl transfer to libraries of amino acid amides and peptides. Whereas the S1' and S3' subsites influence the specificity for the amino component by approximately one order of magnitude, the S2' subsite possesses a markedly higher specificity. Besides the high specificity for hydrophobic residues at P1'-P3', proline was efficiently bound by the S2' and S3' subsites of the enzyme. In contrast, no binding of P1' proline-containing peptides was observed. It could be demonstrated that the specificity of the S' subsite is not restricted to L-amino acids. Effective P'-S' interactions were also found for beta- and gamma-amino acids indicating that the enzyme does not form close contacts to the backbone of P1' and P2' amino acid residues.

Revised definition of substrate binding sites of papain-like cysteine proteases

A review of kinetic and structural data has enabled us to reconsider the definition of substrate binding sites in papain-like cysteine proteases. Only three substrate binding sites, S2, S1 and S1', involve main as well as side chain contacts between substrate and enzyme residues. Interactions between the enzymes and the substrate P3 and P2' residues are based on side chains (an exception is cathepsin B which is a carboxydipeptidase), so their interaction surface spreads over a relatively wide area. The location and definition of substrate binding sites beyond S3 and S2' is even more questionable.

Nucleophile labeling of cysteine and serine protease substrates

Dipeptides containing fluorescein or biotin have been incorporated into proteolytic substrate cleavage products of bovine serum albumin generated by human cathepsin S or neutrophil elastase and into a fragment of the 31-kDa interleukin 1beta precursor by human interleukin 1beta-converting enzyme. Incorporation of the nucleophile is blocked by prior inhibition of the enzymes, and is not seen when proteolysis occurs in the absence of label, and the protease is then inhibited before the addition of label. Labeling is dependent on the pH, the time of reaction, and the concentrations of the nucleophile and substrate. Labeling of proteins can be readily detected by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The pattern of elastase-labeled bovine serum albumin bands differs among P1' Phe, Ala, and Gly, suggesting that nucleophilic attack on acyl enzyme intermediates derived from a large protein may differ from attack on small intermediates. The only observed labeled fragment catalyzed by interleukin 1beta-converting enzyme is fragment 28-116 from the interleukin 1beta precursor, suggesting that the cleavage between residues 27 and 28 is at least as efficient as between residues 116 and 117. This labeling method does not require organic solvent or nonphysiological pH values and thus may be useful for the discovery of novel protease substrates in cells or other in vivo systems or for diagnostic applications.

Contribution to activity of histidine-aromatic, amide-aromatic, and aromatic-aromatic interactions in the extended catalytic site of cysteine proteinases

Within the papain family of cysteine proteinases few other residues in addition to the catalytic triad, Cys25-His159-Asn175 (papain numbering) are completely conserved [Berti & Storer (1995) J. Mol. Biol. 246, 273-283]. One such residue is tryptophan 177 which participates in a Trp-His-type interaction with the catalytic His159. In all enzymes of this class for which a three-dimensional structure has been reported, an additional highly conserved tryptophan, Trp181, also interacts with Trp177 via an aromatic-aromatic interaction in which the planes of the indole rings are essentially perpendicular. Also, both indole rings participate as pseudo-hydrogen bond acceptors in interactions with the two side chain amide protons of Asn175. Clearly, the proximity of Trp177 and Trp181 to the catalytic triad residues His159 and Asn175 and their network of interactions points to potential contributions of these aromatic residues to catalysis. In this paper, using cathepsin S, a naturally occurring variant that has a phenylalanine residue at position 181, we report the kinetic characterization of mutants of residues 175, 177, and 181. The results are interpreted in terms of the side chain contributions to catalytic activity and thiolate-imidazolium ion-pair stability. For example, the side chain of Asn175 has a major influence on the ion-pair stability presumably through its hydrogen bond to His159. The magnitude of this effect is modulated by Trp177, which shields the His159-Asn175 hydrogen bond from solvent. The His159-Trp177 interaction also contributes significantly to ion-pair stability; however, Trp181 and its interactions with Asn175 and Trp177 do not influence ion-pair stability to a significant degree. The observation that certain mutations at positions 177 and 181 result in a reduction of kcat/Km but do not appear to influence ion-pair stability probably reflects the contributions of these residues to substrate binding.

The application of papain, ficin and clostripain in kinetically controlled peptide synthesis in frozen aqueous solutions

The capability of the cysteine proteases ficin, papain and clostripain to form peptide bonds in frozen aqueous solutions was investigated. Freezing the reaction mixture resulted in increased peptide yields in kinetically controlled coupling of Bz-Arg-OEt with various amino acid amides and dipeptides. Under these conditions, peptide yields increased up to 70% depending on the enzyme and the amino component used. Enzyme-catalysed peptide syntheses were carried out under optimized reaction conditions (temperature, amino component concentration and pH before freezing) using the condensation of Bz-Arg-OEt and H-Leu-NH2 as a model reaction.

Enzymatic approach to the synthesis of taurine-containing peptides

Subtilisins (subtilopeptidase A, nagarse) and proteinase K were able to catalyze the synthesis of taurine-containing peptides from various N-acylated amino acid or peptide esters and nonprotected taurine. The synthesis was optimized using a model reaction between Boc-Tyr-OMe and taurine. The best results were obtained under strongly alkaline conditions in acetonitrile with low water content as the reaction medium. The choice of the base added to the reaction medium had a substantial effect on the product yield. A preparative synthesis of Tyr-Tau and Ala-Phe-Tau is described.

The specificity of clostripain from Clostridium histolyticum. Mapping the S' subsites via acyl transfer to amino acid amides and peptides

The S' subsite specificity of clostripain from Clostridium histolyticum was investigated by acyl transfer to libraries of amino acid amides, Ala-Xaa dipeptides, proline derivatives and pentapeptides using N alpha-benzoyl-L-arginine ethyl ester as acyl donor. A pentapeptide library consisting of 29 pentapeptides with general structure Xaa-Ala-Ala-Ala-Gly, Ala-Xaa-Ala-Ala-Gly and Ala-Ala-Xaa-Ala-Gly, where Xaa represents Gly, Ala, Pro, Leu, Phe, Asp, Glu, Arg and Lys, was prepared by solid-phase synthesis. The data analysis was performed by HPLC and evaluated by statistical algorithms. The nucleophile efficiency covers a range of more than three orders of magnitude. In the P'1 position, low specificity for amino acid amides and Xaa-(Ala)3-Gly peptides was found, however, in the P'2 position, positively charged amino acid residues are strongly preferred. The negatively charged side chains of aspartic acid and glutamic acid in the P'1 and P'2 positions, respectively, show only poor nucleophilic behaviour. In the case of these amino acids, the S'-P' interactions depend significantly on their position of these residues in the peptide chain of the nucleophile. The transfer of aspartic acid and glutamic acid from P'1-P'3 increases the nucleophile efficiency by approximately two orders of magnitude. The aromatic side chains are not well accepted, especially in the case of P'3Phe. Surprisingly, P'1Gly leads to effective P'-S' interactions. However, the opposite result was obtained for P'2Gly. The high efficiency for Gly-NH2 does not fit with the hydrophobicity structure/activity relationships. In most cases, peptide chain elongation does not improve the nucleophile efficiency. The effective interaction of D-Leu-NH2 with the S' subsite of clostripain emphasizes the fact that the nucleophile stereospecificity is not restricted to L-amino acids. The results with proline derivatives indicate remarkably different specificities of the S' binding site which can only be explained by conformational restraints. A positive cooperativity between P'1Pro and P'2Gly and a negative cooperativity between P'1Pro and P'2Phe was observed. The arrangement of three proline residues next to each other represents a favourable conformation for effective enzyme-nucleophile interactions.

Recent applications of enzymatic peptide synthesis

Recent applications of enzyme catalysis in peptide synthesis are reviewed. A brief history of the development of these techniques is presented, and existing strategies and tactics of regio- and stereospecific peptide bond syntheses catalyzed by proteolytic enzymes are summarized. The recent literature (ca. 1987-1992) is surveyed for selected applications of enzyme catalysis to the synthesis of bioactive peptides and analogues, semisynthetic proteins and protein conjugates, and bioactive peptides from recombinant precursors. Newly isolated natural enzymes as well as chemically modified forms and recombinant mutants of the natural enzymes of potential utility in peptide synthesis are also reviewed.

N-peptidyl-O-carbamoyl amino acid hydroxamates: irreversible inhibitors for the study of the S2' specificity of cysteine proteinases

A series of new inhibitors for cysteine proteinases with the general structure Z-Phe-Gly-NHO-CO-Aa (Aa = amino acids) was synthesized and tested as inhibitors of papain-like enzymes (cathepsins S, L, B and papain). Like N-peptidyl-O-acyl hydroxamates the inhibitors inactivate cysteine proteinases by a sulfenamidation of the active site cysteine residue. The most effective inhibitors display second order-rate constants of inactivation in the range of 10(3)-10(4) M-1.s-1. Since the structure of the N-peptidyl-O-carbamoyl amino acid hydroxamates allows the variation of the leaving group this class of inhibitors was used as a new tool for evaluation of the S2' specificity of cysteine proteinases.