The value of exercise electrocardiography testing in the identification of coronary restenosis: a probability analysis

A comparative study of restenosis rates in bare metal and drug-eluting stents

BACKGROUND

Various studies have been performed throughout the world on the rate of restenosis using bare metal stents (BMS) and drug-eluting stents (DES). The prohibitive costs associated with DES generally dictate the type of stent used, especially in developing countries. Therefore, there was a need for a study to assess the effect of various risk factors on restenosis in BMS and DES in the Indian context. A study was performed in the premier institution of the Indian Armed Forces, the Army Hospital (Research and Referral), New Delhi, India, under the aegis of the Indian Council of Medical Research (New Delhi). The profile of patients in the armed forces is inherently diverse in terms of demography, ethnicity, genetics, etc, which reflects the diverse and varied nature of the population in India.

METHODS AND RESULTS

A total of 130 patients were included in the present study. Follow-up after stent implantation was scheduled for six to nine months following the procedure to assess symptoms, drug compliance, and treadmill test and coronary angiography results, and to ascertain the incidence of restenosis. However, only 80 patients returned for follow-up and, therefore, the final analysis was based on these patients. They were segregated into BMS (n=41) and DES (n=39) groups. Restenosis occurred in 29 patients (36.3%). Nine of 39 patients with DES (23.1%) and 20 of 41 patients with BMS (48.8%) developed restenosis. There was a statistically significant relationship between restenosis and female sex, clinical presentation before intervention and at the time of follow-up evaluation (unstable angina), hypertension, positive stress test and compliance with medical therapy (P<0.05). No statistically significant relationship was observed between restenosis and age, diabetes, smoking, obesity and diet (P>0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

DES appear to reduce the restenosis rate and clinical end points, and appear to be more cost effective than BMS. Patient-related factors (eg, sex, hypertension and unstable angina) are important variables that affect the restenosis rate. Noninvasive stress testing had high positive and negative predictive values. Therefore, based on the present study, noninvasive stress testing is suggested before routine angiography at follow-up, which will reduce the need for repeat coronary angiography.

Prognostic evaluation by clinical exercise test scores in patients treated with primary percutaneous coronary intervention or fibrinolysis for acute myocardial infarction (a Danish Trial in Acute Myocardial Infarction-2 Sub-Study)

The prognostic accuracy of exercise testing after myocardial infarction is low, and different models have been proposed to enhance the predictive value for subsequent mortality. This study tested a simple score against 3 established scores. Patients with ST-elevation myocardial infarctions were randomized in the Danish Trial in Acute Myocardial Infarction-2 (DANAMI-2) to either primary percutaneous coronary intervention or fibrinolysis with predischarge exercise testing. Clinical and exercise test data were collected prospectively and were available for 1,115 patients. A simple score was derived, awarding 1 point for history or new signs of heart failure, 1 point for a left ventricular ejection fraction <40%, 1 point for age >65 years in men and age >70 years in women, and 1 point for exercise capacity <5 METs in men and exercise capacity <4 METs in women. This DANAMI score was compared with the Veterans Affairs Medical Center score, the Duke treadmill score, and the Gruppo Italiano per lo Studio Della Sopravvivenza nell'Infarto Miocardico-2 (GISSI-2) score in multivariate Cox models and receiver-operating characteristic plots. All scoring systems were predictive of adverse outcomes. The DANAMI score performed better, with greater chi-square values (142 vs 53 to 88 for the prediction of death). Areas under the receiver-operating characteristic curves were compared and were larger for the DANAMI score (C-statistic 0.79 vs 0.71 to 0.74 for the other tests regarding mortality). The DANAMI score stratified patients into a small high-risk group (8% of the population with 43% mortality in 6 years), an intermediate-risk group (13% with 16% mortality in 6 years), and a low-risk group (79% with 4% mortality in 6 years). In conclusion, a simple exercise test score composed of age, METs, heart failure, and a left ventricular ejection fraction <40% seems to outperform the Duke treadmill score, Veterans Affairs Medical Center score, and GISSI-2 score in risk stratifying patients after myocardial infarction and deserves further evaluation.

Diagnostic value of stress echocardiography for the detection of restenosis after PTCA

Stress echocardiography (SE) has become a widely accepted clinical tool for the non-invasive diagnosis of coronary artery disease (CAD). Previous studies have confirmed that SE has superior diagnostic value compared to exercise ECG testing. SE has also emerged as a cost-effective alternative to nuclear imaging techniques in patients where symptoms and/or conventional ECG stress testing have provided ambiguous results. Several studies have investigated the value of SE to detect significant restenosis after PTCA. However, in these studies, different methods have been used to induce cardiovascular stress such as physical exercise by bicycle or treadmill, pharmacologic stress testing (with dipyridamole or dobutamine) or transoesphageal atrial pacing. This review evaluates the published database of SE to detect restenosis in patients after successful PTCA. It includes 13 studies with a total of 989 patients performed at 3-6 months after the primary intervention. The diagnostic value, utility and limitations of SE is presented and discussed. The data show that SE has a high diagnostic value for detecting significant restenosis after PTCA. Mean sensitivity of SE was 74% (CI 69-79%), mean specificity was 87% (CI 84-89%). The positive predictive value (PPV) of SE was 83%, the overall negative predictive value (NPV) 97%. We conclude that, in the follow-up of patients after PTCA, SE has distinct advantages over other non-invasive methods and is a recommended method for the detection of those to be considered for repeat angiography.

A QRS score versus ST-segment changes during exercise testing: which is the most reliable ischaemic marker after myocardial revascularisation?

BACKGROUND

The diagnostic ability of exercise testing based on ST-segment changes is low for the detection of restenosis after percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) or ischaemia after bypass surgery (CABG). The aim of this study was to improve the diagnostic accuracy of exercise testing in patients with a history of PTCA or CABG, with the implementation of a QRS score.

METHODS

We studied 128 post-PTCA patients (aged 49 +/- 8 years) and 104 post-CABG patients (aged 54 +/- 8 years), who had either positive exercise tests with or without angina, or negative exercise tests with continuing angina-like symptoms, and underwent cardiac catheterisation.

RESULTS

The univariate risk ratio of exercise-induced ST-segment deviation to detect restenosis was 3.05 (p = 0.005) and 0.83 (p = 0.690) in group A and group B patients, respectively. The univariate risk ratios of abnormal QRS score values to detect restenosis were 32.1 (p < 0.001) and 18.8 (p < 0.001) for group A and group B patients, respectively. The univariate risk ratios of the combination of exercise-induced ST-segment changes and of abnormal QRS score values to detect restenosis was 9.43 (p < 0.001) and 3.77 (p < 0.044) for group A and group B patients, respectively. The value of the area under the ROC curves is higher for the QRS score in group A patients, group B patients and for the whole study population.

CONCLUSIONS

QRS score values significantly improve the diagnostic ability of ST-segment change-based exercise testing, for the assessment of restenosis after PTCA or ischaemia after CABG.

Physiologic response to gain and loss in coronary minimal luminal diameter in patients treated with coronary angioplasty: prediction of restenosis on the basis of exercise capacity

BACKGROUND

The effect of percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) on physiologic measurements has previously been shown, but the relation between physiologic response and degree of change in coronary luminal diameter is not known. We studied the relation between exercise capacity and minimal luminal diameter before and after PTCA. We also explored the usefulness of measurement of attenuation in exercise capacity after PTCA to predict the likelihood of restenosis.

METHODS

Bicycle exercise testing was performed 2 weeks before and 2 and 20 weeks after PTCA in 395 consecutively enrolled patients. Angiograms obtained before and after PTCA and 20 weeks afterward were analyzed by quantitative coronary angiography. Restenosis was defined as both angiographic (>/=50% diameter stenosis at follow-up angiography) and clinical (target-vessel revascularization), after successful PTCA. Exercise capacity was defined as the cumulative work performed divided by body weight (watt x minutes x kilograms(-1)).

RESULTS

Exercise capacity increased 43% (P <.0001) from before PTCA to 2 weeks after PTCA (early increase) and decreased 4% (P =.01) from 2 to 20 weeks after PTCA (late decrease). The gain in minimal luminal diameter (Minimal luminal diameter after - Minimal luminal diameter before) was 0.92 +/- 0.46 mm. The loss in minimal luminal diameter (Minimal luminal diameter after PTCA - Minimal luminal diameter at follow-up examination) was 0.27 +/- 0.42 mm. Exercise capacity and minimal luminal diameter measured before PTCA were positively correlated (coefficient 3.3; R = 0.12; P =.01). Gain in minimal luminal diameter correlated with the early increase in exercise capacity (coefficient -3.8; R = 0.23; P <.0001). Loss in minimal luminal diameter correlated with the late decrease in exercise capacity (coefficient 3.3; R = 0.20; P <.0001). Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed that the late decrease in exercise capacity was independently predictive of both angiographically (odds ratio 1.13; P <.0001) and clinically (odds ratio 1.12; P <.0001) defined restenosis.

CONCLUSIONS

The results demonstrated a linear relation between the severity of coronary stenosis and exercise capacity measured before PTCA. The degree of coronary luminal enlargement achieved with angioplasty and the luminal reduction that occurred between PTCA and follow-up evaluation correlated with increases and decreases in exercise capacity. Attenuation in exercise capacity was found to be a strong predictor of restenosis.

[Is the exercise test performed after myocardial infarct really useful in improving prognosis? Arguments in favor]

The evaluation of risk after myocardial infarction accomplishes two objectives: a) selecting patients with high-risk for coronary angiography and revascularization, and b) identifying low-risk patients to avoid unnecessary laboratory investigation and revascularization procedures. Currently, patients eligible for exercise test are those with no evidence of heart failure or angina, and with a preserved left ventricular function. Overall prognosis for such patients, especially if they were thrombolyzed, is very good. In this setting, in contrast to that pointed out in previous reports, the positive predictive value of exercise electrocardiography is very low (i.e., a patient with S-T depression has a probability of cardiac death in the ensuing year of only 4% vs 2% if the test is negative). This suggests that a routine postinfarction exercise test is inefficient from a prognostic point of view. However, a recent study has shown that thrombolyzed patients with a positive response to the exercise test, have a significantly lower rate of reinfarction and unstable angina when they undergo myocardial revascularization. Mortality rate, as it was low in the study population, was unchanged by the use of revascularization procedures. We conclude that, in spite of the limitations pointed out, there are at least two reasons to continue performing exercise tests in all uncomplicated infarctions: a) a negative test, due to its high negative predictive value for adverse events, reassures the patient and his family and prompts an early discharge, and b) some patients, despite an uncomplicated in-hospital evolution, have a "strong" positive response that suggests multivessel disease and a possible benefit from myocardial revascularization.

Reliability of the exercise-induced ST-segment changes to detect restenosis three months after coronary angioplasty: significance of the appearance in other leads

BACKGROUND

Exercise-induced ST-segment changes 3 months after angioplasty may sometimes show a false-positive result.

METHODS

We therefore analyzed the ST changes observed during the exercise tests performed before and 3 months after angioplasty in 118 patients with single-vessel coronary artery disease.

RESULTS

Ninety-two (78%) of the 118 patients had ST changes in the same lead before and after angioplasty, whereas the remaining 26 (22%) patients had ST changes in other leads in the postangioplasty test when compared with the preangioplasty exercise test. Restenosis was found in 44 (48%) of the 92 patients with ST changes in the some lead but in only four (15%) of the 26 patients with ST changes in other leads.

CONCLUSIONS

Exercise-induced ST-segment changes are not reliable markers of restenosis 3 months after angioplasty. ST-segment changes observed in other leads after angioplasty compared with the preangioplasty exercise test may show a false-positive result.

Reliability of exercise-induced ST segment changes to detect restenosis 3 months after coronary angioplasty: significance of the appearance in other leads

Exercise-induced ST-segment changes 3 months after angioplasty sometimes may show a false-positive result. We therefore analyzed the ST changes observed during the exercise tests performed before and 3 months after angioplasty in 118 patients with single-vessel coronary artery disease. Ninety-two (78%) of the 118 patients had ST changes in the same lead before and after angioplasty, whereas the remaining 26 (22%) patients had ST changes in other leads in the postangioplasty exercise test when compared with the preangioplasty test. Restenosis was found in 44 (48%) of the 92 patients with ST changes in the same lead but in only 4 (15%) of the 26 patients with ST changes in other leads. We conclude that exercise-induced ST segment changes are not reliable markers of restenosis 3 months after angioplasty. ST segment changes observed in other leads after angioplasty may show a false-positive result when compared with the preangioplasty exercise test.

[Role of noninvasive examinations in the management of ischemic cardiopathy. V. Noninvasive examinations in the management of patients with chronic ischemic cardiopathy]

In the last few years the has been an enormous development in noninvasive testing in the field of clinical cardiology. In fact, excellent monographs on each one of these techniques have been published elsewhere, but fewer publications exist that treat the topic of their indications and use in an integrated way, except for in the most common clinical situations. In this paper, the treatment of patients who present chest pain, stable and unstable angina is discussed, including the study of postinfarction patients. Furthermore, the role of noninvasive tests in the detection of coronary heart disease in women and in patients with left bundle branch block is thoroughly analyzed; as well as their usefulness after surgical or percutaneous coronary revascularization and in patients with peripheral vascular disease.