Excision repair in permeable arrested human skin fibroblasts damaged by UV (254 nm) radiation: evidence that alpha- and beta-polymerases act sequentially at the repolymerisation step

The mechanism of switching among multiple BER pathways

To preserve genomic beta DNA from common endogenous and exogenous base and sugar damage, cells are provided with multiple base excision repair (BER) pathways: the DNA polymerase (Pol) beta-dependent single nucleotide BER and the long-patch (2-10 nt) BER that requires PCNA. It is a challenge to identify the factors that govern the mechanism of switching among these pathways. One of these factors is the type of DNA damage induced in DNA. By using different model lesions we have shown that base damages (like hypoxanthine and 1, N6-ethenoadenine) excised by monofunctional DNA glycosylases are repaired via both single-nucleotide and long-patch BER, while lesions repaired by a bifunctional DNA glycosylase (like 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine) are repaired mainly by single-nucleotide BER. The presence of a genuine 5' nucleotide, as in the case of cleavage by a bifunctional DNA glycosylase-beta lyase, would then minimize the strand displacement events. Another key factor in the selection of the BER branch is the relative level of cellular polymerases. While wild-type embryonic mouse fibroblast cell lines repair abasic sites predominantly via single-nucleotide replacement reactions (80% of the repair events), cells homozygous for a deletion in the Pol beta gene repair these lesions exclusively via long-patch BER. Following treatment with methylmethane sulfonate, these mutant cells accumulate DNA single-strand breaks in their genome in keeping with the fact that repair induced by monofunctional alkylating agents goes predominantly via single-nucleotide BER. Since the long-patch BER is strongly stimulated by PCNA, the cellular content of this cell-cycle regulated factor is also extremely effective in driving the repair reaction to either BER branch. These findings raise the interesting possibility that different BER pathways might be acting as a function of the cell cycle stage.

Strategic down-regulation of DNA polymerase beta by antisense RNA sensitizes mammalian cells to specific DNA damaging agents

Previously, mouse NIH 3T3 cells were stably transfected with human DNA polymerase beta (beta-pol) cDNA in the antisense orientation and under the control of a metallothionein promoter [Zmudzka, B.Z. and Wilson, S.H. (1990) Som. Cell Mol. Gen., 16, 311-320]. To assess the feasibility of enhancing the efficacy of chemotherapy by an antisense approach and to confirm a role for beta-pol in cellular DNA repair, we looked for increased sensitivity to DNA damaging agents under conditions where beta-pol is down-regulated in the antisense cell line. Such a sensitization is anticipated only where beta-pol is rate-limiting in a DNA repair pathway. A number of agents were tested: cis-diamminedichloroplatinum II (cisplatin); 1,3-bis(2-chloroethyl)-1- nitrosourea (BCNU); ionizing radiation and the radio-mimetic drug bleomycin; the bifunctional alkylating agents nitrogen mustard and L-phenylalanine mustard (melphalan); the monofunctional alkylating agent methyl methane sulfonate (MMS) and ultraviolet (UV) radiation. In the cases of cisplatin and UV radiation, a significant enhancement of cytotoxicity was observed. Damage as a result of both of these agents is thought to be repaired by the nucleotide excision repair (NER) pathway. The results suggest that, in this cell line, beta-pol is involved in and is rate-limiting in NER. We propose that down-regulation of beta-pol by antisense approaches might be used to enhance the cytotoxic effects of cisplatin and other DNA damaging chemotherapeutic agents.

Specific inhibition of DNA polymerase beta by its 14 kDa domain: role of single- and double-stranded DNA binding and 5'-phosphate recognition

DNA polymerase beta (beta-polymerase) has been implicated in short-patch DNA synthesis in the DNA repair pathway known as base excision repair. The native 39 kDa enzyme is organized into four structurally and functionally distinct domains. In an effort to examine this enzyme as a potential therapeutic target, we analyzed the effect of various beta-polymerase domains on the activity of the enzyme in vitro. We show that the 14 kDa N-terminal segment of beta-polymerase, which binds to both single- and double-stranded DNA, but lacks DNA polymerase activity, inhibits beta-polymerase activity in vitro. Most importantly, the 8, 27 and 31 kDa domains of beta-polymerase do not inhibit beta-polymerase activity, demonstrating that the inhibition by the 14 kDa domain is specific. The inhibition of beta-polymerase activity in vitro is abolished by increasing the concentrations of both of the substrates (template-primer and deoxynucleoside triphosphate). In contrast, an in vitro base excision repair assay is inhibited in a domain specific manner by the 14 kDa domain even in the presence of saturating substrates. The inhibition of beta-polymerase activity by the 14 kDa domain appears specific to beta-polymerase as this domain does not inhibit either mammalian DNA polymerase alpha or Escherichia coli polymerase I (Klenow fragment). These data suggest that the 14 kDa domain could be used as a potential inhibitor of intracellular beta-polymerase and that it may provide a means for sensitizing cells to therapeutically relevant DNA damaging agents.

Aphidicolin inhibits excision repair of UV-induced pyrimidine photodimers in low serum cultures of mitotic and mitomycin C-induced postmitotic human skin fibroblasts

The rates of formation and excision of UVC light-induced cyclobutane-type pyrimidine photodimers were determined in cultures of foreskin-derived normal human fibroblasts in mitotic (MF) and mitomycin-C (MMC)-induced postmitotic fibroblasts (PMF). Characteristic morphological changes support the notion that MMC accelerates the differentiation pathway from MF to PMF. In cultures treated with aphidicolin, I am able to show that this inhibitor of alpha and/or delta polymerases significantly inhibits the repair of pyrimidine photodimers in foreskin-derived mitotic and MMC-induced postmitotic fibroblasts in low serum cultures (0.5%) following UVC irradiation. Over the concentration range of 0-2 micrograms/ml of aphidicolin, there is a strong concentration-dependent inhibition of repair in cells treated with 10 J/m2 of UVC and incubated with aphidicolin during the post-incubation time (0-24 h). The results demonstrate that pyrimidine photodimers are repaired in low serum cultures by an alpha- and/or delta-polymerase-dependent pathway. These data also imply that the fibroblast differentiation system is a very useful tool to unravel the complex mechanisms of UV-induced DNA damage and repair.

A role for the human single-stranded DNA binding protein HSSB/RPA in an early stage of nucleotide excision repair

The human single-stranded DNA binding protein (HSSB/RPA) is involved in several processes that maintain the integrity of the genome including DNA replication, homologous recombination, and nucleotide excision repair of damaged DNA. We report studies that analyze the role of HSSB in DNA repair. Specific protein-protein interactions appear to be involved in the repair function of HSSB, since it cannot be replaced by heterologous single-stranded DNA binding proteins. Anti-HSSB antibodies that inhibit the ability of HSSB to stimulate DNA polymerase alpha also inhibit repair synthesis mediated by human cell-free extracts. However, antibodies that neutralize DNA polymerase alpha do not inhibit repair synthesis. Repair is sensitive to aphidicolin, suggesting that DNA polymerase epsilon or delta participates in nucleotide excision repair by cell extracts. HSSB has a role other than generally stimulating synthesis by DNA polymerases, as it does not enhance the residual damage-dependent background synthesis displayed by repair-deficient extracts from xeroderma pigmentosum cells. Significantly, when damaged DNA is incised by the Escherichia coli UvrABC repair enzyme, human cell extracts can carry out repair synthesis even when HSSB has been neutralized with antibodies. This suggests that HSSB functions in an early stage of repair, rather than exclusively in repair synthesis. A model for the role of HSSB in repair is presented.

The mode of action of 1-beta-D-arabinofuranosylcytosine in inhibiting DNA repair; new evidence using a sensitive assay for repair DNA synthesis and ligation in permeable cells

Mammalian cells permeabilised by treatment with saponin are capable of UV excision repair. We have developed an assay system which permits measurement of the later stages of repair, i.e. repair synthesis and ligation. Incomplete repair sites are accumulated in UV-irradiated cells by incubating them with DNA synthesis inhibitors hydroxyurea and aphidicolin. On removal of the inhibitors at the time of permeabilisation, these incomplete sites, detected as DNA breaks, are rapidly ligated in a reaction that requires deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates and is blocked by aphidicolin. Thus ligation is possible only after a significant amount of DNA synthesis. We have used the assay to clarify the mode of inhibition of DNA repair by 1-beta-D-arabinofuranosylcytosine (ara C), another DNA polymerase inhibitor. It is well known that incomplete repair sites accumulated in whole cells with ara C are ligated at a slow rate, if at all. The hypothesis that ara C blocks or reduces further polymerisation after its incorporation into repair patches is disproved by our demonstration that, in permeable cells, the accumulated DNA breaks are ligated very rapidly. The likely explanation of the action of ara C is that, once phosphorylated, it remains in the cell as ara CTP and continues to inhibit polymerisation through competition with dCTP; in permeable cells, it readily leaks out.

DNA single stranded gaps formed during DNA repair synthesis induced by methyl methanesulfonate are filled by sequential action of aphidicolin- and dideoxythymidine sensitive DNA polymerases in HeLa cells

DNA repair synthesis induced by methyl methanesulfonate in preconditioned HeLa cells in which DNA replicative synthesis had been highly suppressed was inhibited by aphidicolin (an inhibitor of DNA polymerases alpha and delta) and dideoxythymidine (ddThR, an inhibitor of DNA polymerase beta). Incomplete repair patches sensitive to exonuclease III were accumulated in the presence of aphidicolin while not in the presence of ddThR. These patches were comopleted by the combined action of Klenow fragment and T4 DNA ligase, indicating that the single-stranded gaps were formed during the repair synthesis. Moreover, ddThR had little effect on the repair synthesis in the presence of aphidicolin. Thus, the results suggest that the single-stranded gaps may be sealed first by aphidicolin-sensitive polymerase followed by ddThR-sensitive DNA polymerase on the same site of the repair patch.

A critical review of permeabilized cell systems for studying mammalian DNA repair

Permeabilized cell systems have proven valuable for studies of the enzymology of mammalian DNA repair and this review will summarize and contrast the different systems used to this end. Results from permeable cell studies will be reviewed which pertain to 3 questions of DNA repair: the role(s) of ATP, DNA polymerase enzymology, and the isolation of repair factors by in vitro correction of repair-defective cells.

Interaction of hyperthermia and radiation in tolerant and nontolerant HeLa S3 cells: role of DNA polymerase inactivation

The activities of DNA polymerase alpha and beta were measured in tolerant and nontolerant HeLa S3 suspension cells. The heat-inactivation of the enzymes and their recovery when cells were incubated at 37 degrees C after the heat challenge was compared to the synergistic action of heat and radiation and its disappearance at the level of cell survival. Thermotolerant cells were radiosensitized by heat similarly to nontolerant cells, but the sensitization decreased more rapidly in the tolerant cells when time at 37 degrees C was allowed between the two treatments. For polymerase activities the extent of inactivation, as well as the kinetics of recovery, were similar in tolerant and nontolerant cells. The results show that the activities of DNA polymerase alpha and beta do not always correlate with the extent of heat radiosensitization. It is concluded that heat inactivation of these enzymes may not be taken as a general cause for the synergistic effect of hyperthermia and radiation. As an alternative mechanism, changes in nuclear protein binding due to cellular heating are suggested, since these correlate well with effects observed for radiosensitization under different experimental conditions, including the use of thermotolerant cells.

Common fragile sites in couples with recurrent spontaneous abortions

Recently, increased spontaneous chromosome instability was reported in couples with recurrent spontaneous abortions but without constitutional chromosome aberrations. Therefore, we investigated the frequency and distribution of aphidicolin-induced common fragile sites in couples with recurrent spontaneous abortions and no children and in age-related control couples. The breakage rate was significantly elevated in the abortion-prone couples; the women in the abortion couples had an especially higher breakage rate than the control women. Breakpoints cluster to those chromosome regions where common fragile sites have been localized. No preference of a particular common fragile site was demonstrated in the abortion couples. Our findings appear to support the hypothesis of increased chromosome instability in at least some couples with recurrent spontaneous abortions. As long as the nature of aphidicolin-induced common fragile sites is not completely understood, the significance of these findings remains unclear.

Formation of DNA strand breaks in UV-irradiated human fibroblast preparations

The formation of DNA strand breaks was characterized in human fibroblasts prepared by several methods. In quiescent monolayer cultures of normal human fibroblasts (NHF), exposure to 254 nm radiation (UV) caused the rapid appearance of DNA strand breaks as monitored by alkaline elution analysis. Maximal levels of DNA breaks were seen 30 min after 10 J/m2; thereafter, strand breaks disappeared. Breakage soon after irradiation appeared to saturate at fluences above 10 J/m2. Xeroderma pigmentosum fibroblasts belonging to complementation group A (XPA) did not display this response which reflects operations of the nucleotidyl DNA excision repair pathway. When fibroblast strains were released from culture dishes by enzymatic digestion with trypsin or by scraping with a rubber policeman, UV-dependent DNA breakage displayed altered dose and time responses. Few breaks were detected in detached preparations of NHF after 10 J/m2 indicating inactivation of nucleotidyl DNA excision repair. The fluence response in detached fibroblasts was linear up to an incident fluence of 100 J/m2. Moreover, after 25 or 50 J/m2, strand breaks accumulated as a linear function of time for up to 2 h after irradiation. This UV-dependent and time-dependent incision activity was also observed in XPA monolayers and released-cell preparations. In permeable fibroblast preparations, DNA breaks accumulated in unirradiated cells that had been released with trypsin or by scraping. Permeabilization in situ saponin to open the plasma membrane produced a cell preparation that accumulated fewer UV-independent breaks. In saponin-permeabilized NHF that were irradiated with 10 J/m2, UV-dependent strand incision activity occurred at about 30% of the rate of incision seen in intact monolayer NHF. These results reveal at least 3 DNA strand incision activities in human fibroblast preparations of which only one reflects operation of the nucleotidyl DNA excision repair pathway.

Common fragile sites: their prevalence in subjects with constitutional and acquired chromosomal instability

Chromosomal fragile sites that are inducible by methotrexate and aphidicolin are frequent in the human population. To assess the frequency and distribution of these common fragile sites, we performed a cytogenetic survey on lymphocytes from subjects known to be particularly prone to breakage because of constitutional chromosomal instability, the possession of a rare fragile site, or Fanconi anemia. Furthermore, a group of cancer patients was included in this study in view of possible acquired chromosomal instability. Lymphocyte chromosomes from several healthy donors were analyzed under identical conditions. We found that methotrexate- and aphidicolin-induced fragile sites are widespread in the general population, showing a similar breakpoint distribution. Ten fragile sites (3p14, 16q23, 2q32, 6q25, 4p16, 4q31, 14q24, 1p31, 20p12, 7q21) were observed in at least 40% of the individuals among the different groups. Our data point out a significantly increased breakage induced by aphidicolin in lymphocytes from cancer patients and, to a lesser extent, from rare fragile sites carriers. These results suggest that common fragile sites are enhanced in some constitutional and acquired conditions.

Inhibition of polymerases-alpha and -beta completely blocks DNA repair induced by UV irradiation in cultured mouse neuronal cells

The effects of hydroxyurea, aphidicolin and dideoxythymidine on UV-induced DNA repair of mouse neuronal granular cells were studied. Aphidicolin, which is considered a specific inhibitor of polymerase-alpha, decreased spontaneous DNA synthesis by 93% and totally suppressed DNA repair. Dideoxythymidine, an inhibitor of polymerase-beta, was more potent in decreasing scheduled DNA synthesis than aphidicolin, and also completely blocked the UV-induced DNA repair. Hydroxyurea, a specific inhibitor of ribonucleotide reductase, inhibited scheduled DNA synthesis, but unscheduled DNA synthesis after UV irradiation was always well detectable. Our data suggest that in neuronal cells from 5 to 10 days old mice both polymerases-alpha and -beta are required for both DNA synthesis and repair. These two enzymes may act jointly in filling up the gaps along the DNA molecule and elongating the DNA chain.

Excision repair in u.v. (254 nm) damaged non-dividing human skin fibroblasts: a major biological role for DNA polymerase alpha

We have used the eukaryotic DNA polymerase alpha inhibitor, aphidicolin, and the polymerase beta inhibitor, dideoxythymidine, to examine the role of these enzymes in excision repair of ultraviolet (u.v., 254 nm) damage induced in non-dividing (arrested) human skin fibroblasts. The effects of these drugs on u.v.-treated cells have been monitored using a simple and reproducible repair synthesis assay in parallel with viability measurements to determine the degree of inhibition of repair of potentially lethal damage. In agreement with previous studies using density gradients, repair synthesis induced by low fluences of u.v. (less than 3 J m-2) is relatively insensitive to inhibition by aphidicolin compared to high fluences where approximately 85 per cent inhibition is observed at the highest (20 micrograms/ml) aphidicolin concentration employed. However, repair of potentially lethal damage is inhibited by at least 90 per cent over the entire fluence range. Although dideoxythymidine led to considerable inhibition of repair synthesis, the result is probably an artifact under these in vivo conditions. The polymerase beta inhibitor was not toxic to u.v.-treated cells nor did it add to the toxicity of aphidicolin when the drugs were used in combination. We conclude that if the beta polymerase is involved in excision repair then its temporary (4 h) inhibition by dideoxythymidine is entirely reversible. In contrast, polymerase alpha appears to be an enzyme essential to the majority of biologically effective excision repair over the entire u.v. fluence range tested.