Comparative analysis of vaccinia virus promoter activity in fowlpox and vaccinia virus recombinants

Characterization of Fowlpox Virus

The complex cytoplasmic DNA virus known as the fowlpox virus (FWPV) is a member of the avipoxvirus genus, Subfamily Chordopoxvirinae, and Family Poxviridae. The large genome size of FWPV makes it a potential vector for the creation of vaccines against a range of serious veterinary and human ailments. It also allows for multiple gene insertion and the generation of abortive infection in mammalian cells. The virus, which causes fowlpox in chickens and turkeys, is mainly transmitted to poultry through aerosols or biting insects. Fowlpox is a highly contagious disease that affects both domestic and wild birds, causing cutaneous and/or diphtheritic illnesses. To control the illness, strict hygiene practices and immunization with FWPV attenuated strains or antigenically similar pigeon pox virus vaccines are employed. Recent years have seen an increase in fowlpox outbreaks in chicken flocks, primarily due to the introduction of novel forms of FWPV. It is believed that the pathogenic characteristics of these strains are enhanced by the integration of reticuloendotheliosis virus sequences of variable lengths into the FWPV genome. The standard laboratory diagnosis of FPV involves histopathological analysis, electron microscopy, virus isolation on chorioallantoic membrane (CAM) of embryonated chicken eggs or cell cultures, and serologic techniques. For quick and consistent diagnosis, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) has proven to be the most sensitive method. PCR is used in concert with restriction endonuclease enzyme analysis (REA) to identify, differentiate, and characterize the molecular makeup of isolates of the fowlpox virus. Sequencing of the amplified fragments is then done.

mTOR Dysregulation by Vaccinia Virus F17 Controls Multiple Processes with Varying Roles in Infection

Despite producing enormous amounts of cytoplasmic DNA, poxviruses continue to replicate efficiently by deploying an armory of proteins that counter host antiviral responses at multiple levels. Among these, poxvirus protein F17 dysregulates the host kinase mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) to prevent the activation of stimulator of interferon genes (STING) expression and impair the production of interferon-stimulated genes (ISGs). However, the host DNA sensor(s) involved and their impact on infection in the absence of F17 remain unknown. Here, we show that cyclic-di-GMP-AMP (cGAMP) synthase (cGAS) is the primary sensor that mediates interferon response factor (IRF) activation and ISG responses to vaccinia virus lacking F17 in both macrophages and lung fibroblasts, although additional sensors also operate in the latter cell type. Despite this, ablation of ISG responses through cGAS or STING knockout did not rescue defects in late-viral-protein production, and the experimental data pointed to other functions of mTOR in this regard. mTOR adjusts both autophagic and protein-synthetic processes to cellular demands. No significant differences in autophagic responses to wild-type or F17 mutant viruses could be detected, with autophagic activity differing across cell types or states and exhibiting no correlations with defects in viral-protein accumulation. In contrast, results using transformed cells or altered growth conditions suggested that late-stage defects in protein accumulation reflect failure of the F17 mutant to deregulate mTOR and stimulate protein production. Finally, rescue approaches suggest that phosphorylation may partition F17's functions as a structural protein and mTOR regulator. Our findings reveal the complex multifunctionality of F17 during infection.IMPORTANCE Poxviruses are large, double-stranded DNA viruses that replicate entirely in the cytoplasm, an unusual act that activates pathogen sensors and innate antiviral responses. In order to replicate, poxviruses therefore encode a wide range of innate immune antagonists that include F17, a protein that dysregulates the kinase mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) to suppress interferon-stimulated gene (ISG) responses. However, the host sensor(s) that detects infection in the absence of F17 and its precise contribution to infection remains unknown. Here, we show that the cytosolic DNA sensor cGAS is primarily responsible for activating ISG responses in biologically relevant cell types infected with a poxvirus that does not express F17. However, in line with their expression of ∼100 proteins that act as immune response and ISG antagonists, while F17 helps suppress cGAS-mediated responses, we find that a critical function of its mTOR dysregulation activity is to enhance poxvirus protein production.

Poxviral promoters for improving the immunogenicity of MVA delivered vaccines

Modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) is a replication-deficient poxvirus, attenuated in chick embryo fibroblast primary cells. It has been utilised as a viral vector to develop many vaccines against cancer and infectious diseases such as malaria, HIV/AIDS, influenza, and tuberculosis, MERS-CoV, and Ebola virus infection. There is accumulating data from many preclinical and clinical studies that highlights the excellent safety and immunogenicity of MVA. However, due to the complex nature of many pathogens and their pathogenicity, MVA vectored vaccine candidates need to be optimised to improve their immunogenicity. One of the main approaches to improve MVA immunogenicity focuses on optimising poxviral promoters that drive recombinant vaccine antigens, encoded within recombinant MVA vector genome. A number of promoters were described or optimised to improve the development of MVA based vaccines such as p7.5, pF11, and mH5 promoters. This review focuses on poxviral promoters, their optimisation, genetic stability, and clinical use.

Genus Avipoxvirus

Poxviruses identified in skin lesions of domestic, pet or wild birds are assigned largely by default to the Avipoxvirus genus within the subfamily Chordopoxvirinae of the family Poxviridae. Avipoxviruses have been identified as the causative agent of disease in at least 232 species in 23 orders of birds. Vaccines based upon attenuated avipoxvirus strains provide good disease control in production poultry, although with the large and intensive production systems there are suggestions and real risks of emergence of strains against which current vaccines might be ineffective. Sequence analysis of the whole genome has revealed overall genome structure and function resemblance to the Chordopoxvirinae; however, avipoxvirus genomes exhibit large-scale genomic rearrangements with more extensive gene families and novel host range gene in comparison with the other Chordopoxvirinae. Phylogenetic analysis places the avipoxviruses externally to the Chorodopoxvirinae to such an extent that in the future it might be appropriate to consider the Avipoxviruses as a separate subfamily within the Poxviridae. A unique relationship exists between Fowlpox virus (FWPV) and reticuloendothelosis viruses. All FWPV strains carry a remnant long terminal repeat, while field strains carry a near full-length provirus integrated at the same location in the FWPV genome. With the development of techniques to construct poxviruses expressing foreign vaccine antigens, the avipoxviruses have gone from neglected obscurity to important vaccine vectors in the past 20 years. The seminal observation of their utility for delivery of vaccine antigens to non-avian species has driven much of the interest in this group of viruses. In the veterinary area, several recombinant avipoxviruses are commercially licensed vaccines. The most successful have been those expressing glycoprotein antigens of enveloped viruses, e.g. avian influenza, Newcastle diseases and West Nile viruses. Several recombinants have undergone extensive human clinical trials as experimental vaccines against HIV/AIDS and malaria or as treatment regimens in cancer patients. The safety profile of avipoxvirus recombinants for use as veterinary and human vaccines or therapeutics is now well established.

Genetic manipulation of two fowlpox virus late transcriptional regulatory elements influences their ability to direct expression of foreign genes

Fowlpox virus (FWPV) is currently used as a vector to express foreign genes of various poultry and mammalian pathogens. However, due to limited information available about the primary structure of FWPV promoters required for an optimal transcriptional efficiency, the full potential of FWPV as an expression vector has not been completely realized. To dissect such transcriptional regulatory elements at the molecular level, we selected two FWPV promoters dictating contrasting levels of expression of acidic-type inclusion body protein gene (P190) and A15L vaccinia virus homolog of FWPV (P180) for site-directed mutagenesis studies. The transcriptional activity of mutated promoters was analyzed based on their ability to transcribe a reporter gene, lacZ, and translation of the resultant mRNA into functional protein. Replacement of the spacer sequences of P180 with those of P190 resulted in a five-fold increase in mRNA and a 17.6-fold increase in protein over those with its parental promoter, P180. Similarly, replacement of a thymidine after the start codon with guanosine resulted in a 2.3-fold increase in lacZ mRNA and a seven-fold increase in protein. Combining these substitutions in P180SG produced a maximum increase in mRNA and protein of 6.7- and 29.9-fold, respectively, over concentrations with its parental P180 promoter. The promoter activity of P180SG was comparable to that of the strongest natural promoter, P190. The amount of protein per transcript generated by the mutated promoters of P180 increased to at least three times that with the parental P180. In contrast, similar replacements in P190 resulted in a 40-50% reduction in mRNA and protein in all the mutated promoters. We discuss the significance of spacer sequence and the purine after the start codon in the context of a high level of expression.

Poxviruses: past, present and future

The analysis of poxvirus genomes is complex, in part, because of their size (130-360 kb) and the fact that gene content is variable; a common set of 49 genes has been found in all sequenced poxviruses and an additional 41 genes are also present in all sequenced orthopoxviruses. As a group, poxviruses have a very broad range of eukaryotic hosts (including mammals, birds, reptiles and insects) and many poxvirus genes are associated with blocking host anti-viral responses. One consequence of this is that many poxvirus genes are not essential for growth in tissue culture and that extensive passaging in vitro results in the accumulation of mutations, including deletions that result in loss of gene function. Here, we review various comparative analyses of the poxviruses including gene prediction, gene conservation and function, genome organization, and poxvirus taxonomy and evolution.

A consideration of previously uncharacterized fowl poxvirus unidirectional and bidirectional late promoters for inclusion in homologous recombinant vaccines

Because of the limited analysis of fowl poxvirus (FPV) promoters, expression of foreign proteins by recombinant FPV has usually been directed by heterologous vaccinia virus or synthetic poxvirus promoters. Thus, the impact of completely homologous recombinant virus vaccines has yet to be realized by the poultry industry. In an effort to increase the availability of such transcriptional regulatory elements, the modulation of gene expression by six previously uncharacterized FPV late promoters was examined. To simplify this comparison, each promoter region was separately coupled to the same reporter gene (lacZ) in individual plasmid constructs, and their activities in transfected, virus-infected cells were monitored. In each of the four selected unidirectional transcriptional regulatory elements as well as a 30-base pair representative of the bidirectional promoter region, the predicted temporal specificity of expressing at late stages of virus replicative cycle was verified. Stable lacZ gene transcripts arising from each plasmid varied less than threefold in quantity, whereas the amounts of beta-galactosidase product ranged within a 130-fold interval. Only the promoter that naturally regulates expression of the A type inclusion body protein gene directed production of beta-galactosidase at a level comparable with that associated with the strong vaccinia virus P11 promoter. Because one of the remaining unidirectional transcriptional regulatory elements, P174, was only 2.4-fold less efficient, both of these promoters, P174 and P190, should be satisfactory for directing the expression of poultry pathogen genes inserted into the genomes of FPV recombinant vaccines.

Identification of novel transmembrane gene sequence and its use for cell-surface targeting of beta subunit of human chorionic gonadotropin

We identified a 685-nucleotide gene fragment that codes for the transmembrane and cytoplasmic domains of glycoprotein of the LEP strain rabies virus and carried out experiments designed to express a novel fusion protein on the cell surface. The cDNA encoding the membrane anchor sequence was fused in the correct reading frame to the 3' end of the cDNA encoding the beta subunit of human chorionic gonadotropin (beta(h)CG), a secretory glycoprotein that is used as an antigen for a contraceptive vaccine being developed in our laboratory. The fusion gene cassette was placed under the control of a vaccinia virus early promoter and cloned in a host-restricted fowlpox viral vector. The recombinants, when used to infect mammalian cells that do not allow the replication of fowlpox virus, expressed the N-terminal 135 amino acid residues of beta(h)CG anchored in the cell membrane by the 75-amino acid C-terminal sequence derived from rabies virus glycoprotein. This hybrid protein is correctly processed post-translationally and transported efficiently to the plasma membrane of non-permissive cells such that the anchored beta(h)CG molecule retains the correctly folded native antigenic epitope(s).

Recombinant swinepox virus expressing beta-galactosidase: investigation of viral host range and gene expression levels in cell culture

Swinepox virus (SPV) has been proposed as a potential vector for generating recombinant vaccines for swine. However, little is known about important aspects of SPV biology, such as the functionality of SPV promoters or the host range of SPV. Using a transient expression assay, well-characterized vaccinia virus promoters were shown to be active in cells infected with SPV. A recombinant SPV expressing beta-galactosidase (beta-gal) was constructed and characterized. The E. coli LacZ gene was placed under the control of a strong vaccinia synthetic early/late promoter and was inserted by homologous recombination in a noncoding region of the SPV genome. The recombinant SPV expressing beta-gal was used to characterize the host range of the virus by measuring protein expression and virus production in different cell lines. In general, SPV expressed more protein and grew more efficiently than vaccinia virus in porcine cell lines. Surprisingly, the recombinant SPV was able to infect and replicate in several cell lines of nonswine origin. The virus directed regulated early and late gene expression of beta-gal in those cells and formed blue plaques in cell monolayers in the presence of X-gal. Upon infection with the recombinant SPV, there was a significant level of viral replication, and the virus can be serially passaged in some nonswine cell lines. The data presented suggest that despite the strict host tropism of SPV, the virus exhibits a relatively broad host range in cell culture.

Studies of fowlpox virus recombination in the generation of recombinant vaccines

A p7.5/beta-galactosidase (7.5 lacZ) gene construct, cloned adjacent to the fowlpox virus (FPV) thymidine kinase (tk) gene was used as a marker to identify the products of recombination as 'blue' FPV plaques. The rFPVs were detected as early as 4 h after the introduction of plasmid DNAs and by 72 h post-infection (p.i.) for one transfer vector comprised 0.48% of the viral population. The proportion of rFPV increased linearly from 0.073% to 0.62% as the cumulative length of homologous sequences in the transfer vector increased from 0.73 to 4.5 kb. Two approaches using a second reporter gene, the Newcastle disease virus haemagglutinin-neuraminidase (NDV HN) gene were tested to differentiate between single and double cross-over events. In one, the HN gene was cloned into the FPV tk gene and the 7.5 lacZ cloned outside of the homologous region. Progeny of a single cross-over with FPV DNA generated an unstable plaque containing the HN gene and subsequent intramolecular recombination resulted in excision of the 7.5 lacZ and the generation of a stable 'white' plaque. For virus grown in CEF cells (tk+) in the presence of 5-bromo-deoxyuridine, only those viruses which contained a tk gene disrupted by the HN gene formed plaques. This approach allowed us to easily identify rFPV containing the HN gene but lacking 7.5 lacZ or other bacterial sequences. In a second approach, a double cross-over between rFPV DNA containing a stably expressed beta-galactosidase gene cloned into the tk gene (blue plaque) and plasmid DNA containing the HN gene flanked by tk sequences would allow transplacement of the 7.5 lacZ gene with the HN gene, and generating a white plaque. We were unable to generate recombinant viruses with the HN gene and which generated a white plaque, indicating that double cross-over events do not occur at a sufficiently high frequency in FPV.

Identification and functional analysis of the fowlpox virus homolog of the vaccinia virus p37K major envelope antigen gene

A fowlpox virus (FPV) gene with homology to the vaccinia virus p37K major envelope antigen gene was identified and sequenced. The predicted product has a molecular weight of 43,018 Da (p43K). The FPV p43K gene has 37.5% identity with its vaccinia counterpart and higher homology with a molluscum contagiosum virus gene (42.6% identity). Based on upstream sequences, p43K appears to be regulated as a late gene. Recombinant FPV were generated in which a large portion of p43K was replaced by the Escherichia coli lacZ gene. These recombinants failed to produce visible plaques under standard conditions. After prolonged incubation the microplaques developed into small macroscopic plaques. Plaques were purified on the basis of lacZ expression. Single-cycle growth curves comparing the p43K-deleted recombinant (designated fJd43Z) with parental FPV showed that the two viruses produce identical amounts of intracellular virions, but that fJd43Z released 20-fold fewer infectious particles into the medium. CsCl gradient centrifugation of [3H]thymidine-labeled virus was employed to examine differences in the production of physical particles. The two viruses produced equivalent levels of intracellular virions, but fJd43Z failed to produce detectable levels of released particles. FPV p43K is therefore involved in the release of virions from infected cells.

Quantitative assessment of poxvirus promoters in fowlpox and vaccinia virus recombinants

A comparison was undertaken of poxvirus promoters in vaccinia and fowlpox virus (FPV) recombinants using the level of beta-galactosidase expressed from the LacZ gene as a measure of promoter function. In this study a comparison was made of the vaccinia virus promoters, P 7.5 and P L11, the major late promoter of cowpox virus, P CPX (expressing the abundant inclusion body protein), and the FPV promoters, P E/L and P L. In vaccinia virus recombinants the FPV P E/L promoter expressed one-third to one-half the level of beta-galactosidase expressed by the P L11 promoter. In comparison with the P 7.5 promoter, the FPV P E/L promoter expressed four to five times the level of beta-galactosidase. In FPV recombinants beta-galactosidase activity expressed was equal for the P E/L and P CPX promoters. Levels expressed by P L11 and P L were one-half and one-fifth that level, respectively. The temporal regulation of the promoters was maintained in both vaccinia virus and FPV recombinants. The P E/L promoter of FPV has the TAAATG sequence characteristic of late poxvirus promoters at the transcription initiation site. In an attempt to enhance the utility of this promoter for the expression of foreign genes in FPV and vaccinia virus recombinants, the effect upon promoter function of changing the G of the ATG to A, T, or C was determined using transient expression assays with vaccinia virus. Substitution of A, T, or C for the G abolished promoter function. Because of its early/late function, the level of expression and the presence of the oppositely oriented late P L promoter, the FPV P E/L promoter will be valuable for the expression of foreign genes in poxvirus recombinants.

Recombinant fowlpox viruses expressing the glycoprotein B homolog and the pp38 gene of Marek's disease virus

Two Marek's disease virus (MDV) genes, one homologous to the glycoprotein B gene of herpes simplex virus and encoding the B antigen complex and the other encoding a 38-kDa phosphorylated protein (pp38), were inserted into the fowlpox virus (FPV) genome under the control of poxvirus promoters. Randomly selected nonessential regions of FPV were used for insertion, and the vaccinia virus 7.5 kDa polypeptide gene promoter or a poxvirus synthetic promoter was used for expression of MDV genes. Gene expression in cells infected with these recombinants was highly influenced by the promoter (the synthetic promoter being more effective) but was only slightly influenced by the insertion site and by the transcription direction of the insert relative to the direction of the flanking FPV sequences. Cells infected with an FPV recombinant expressing the MDV gB gene reacted positively with a monoclonal antibody specific to this glycoprotein in an immunofluorescence assay. Immunoprecipitation of infected cell lysates showed three glycoproteins identical to those associated with the B antigen complex of MDV (100, 60, and 49 kDa). Cells infected with a recombinant expressing the pp38 gene reacted positively with an anti-pp38 monoclonal antibody in an immunofluorescence assay. The generated protein was phosphorylated and had a molecular weight similar to that of the native pp38 protein. Sera from chickens immunized with an FPV recombinant expressing the MDV glycoprotein B gene reacted with MDV-infected cells.

The 5' noncoding region sequence of the Choristoneura biennis entomopoxvirus spheroidin gene functions as an efficient late promoter in the mammalian vaccinia expression system

About 100 nucleotides of DNA sequence at the 5' noncoding region of the Choristoneura biennis entomopoxvirus spheroidin gene was chemically synthesized and inserted into a vaccinia expression vector, interrupting the vaccinia thymidine kinase gene. When the bacterial beta-galactosidase gene was introduced downstream of this sequence and a recombinant vaccinia virus containing these inserts was obtained by homologous recombination, beta-galactosidase was shown to be expressed at a high level late in the vaccinia infection cycle. The level of beta-galactosidase expression was four- to fivefold higher with this spheroidin-vaccinia recombinant virus than with a similar recombinant in which the beta-galactosidase gene was under the control of the vaccinia 7.5-kDa promoter. Primer extension and S1 mapping of the 5' terminus of the beta-galactosidase transcript located the transcription initiation site within the spheroidin DNA sequence, confirming the promoter nature of this DNA sequence in the vaccinia system. Dot blot analysis indicated that the difference in beta-galactosidase expression with these two recombinant viruses can be attributed to the difference in their transcript levels. We also demonstrated that full promoter activity encoded in the spheroidin 5' noncoding sequence was contained within a 38-nucleotide DNA fragment.

Activity of a fowlpox virus late gene promoter in vaccinia and fowlpox virus recombinants

Characterization of a late promoter of fowlpox virus (FPV) and a study of its activity in FPV and vaccinia virus (VV) was carried out. The 5'-mRNA start site of the FPV late gene mapped to a TAAAT sequence near the translation start site (ATG). A cloned DNA fragment of FPV genome (PFL1) comprising of the 5'-end of the late gene was used to express the LacZ gene of E. coli in FPV and VV recombinants. A comparative analysis of beta-galactosidase (BG) expression from the LacZ gene under the control of the FPV promoter and a VV late promoter (PL11) was performed. Like FPV-PL11-LacZ and VV-PL11-LacZ constructs, FPV-PFL1-LacZ and VV-PFL1-LacZ virus recombinants expressed BG indicating that essential features of transcription were conserved in the two viruses. Furthermore, the LacZ transcripts originating from PFL1 in FPV and VV recombinants mapped to the expected TAAAT sequence. Time course analysis of BG expressed by VV and FPV recombinants suggested that although the transcription machinery in the two viruses was essentially conserved, subtle differences in the efficiency of transcription or translation may exist.