Construction and evaluation of an expression vector allowing the stable expression of foreign antigens in a Salmonella typhimurium vaccine strain

Salmonella enterica as a vaccine carrier

Salmonella enterica is an invasive, facultative intracellular gastrointestinal pathogen causing human diseases such as gastroenteritis and typhoid fever. Virulence-attenuated strains of this pathogen have interesting capacities for the generation of live vaccines. Attenuated live typhoidal and nontyphoidal Salmonella strains can be used for vaccination against Salmonella infections and to target tumor tissue. Such strains may also serve as live carriers for the development of vaccination strategies against other bacterial, viral or parasitic pathogens. Various strategies have been developed to deploy regulatory circuits and protein secretion systems for efficient expression and delivery of foreign antigens by Salmonella carrier strains. One prominent example is the use of type III secretion systems to translocate recombinant antigens into antigen presenting cells. In this review, we will describe the recent developments in strategies that utilize live attenuated Salmonella as vaccine carriers for prophylactic vaccination against infectious diseases and therapeutic vaccination against tumors. Considerations for generating safe, attenuated carrier strains, designing stable expression systems and the use of adjuvants for live carrier strategies are discussed.

Removal of antibiotic resistance of live vaccine strain Escherichia coli MM-3 and evaluation of the immunogenicity of the new strain

MM-3 was a live vaccine strain candidate for protecting neonatal piglets from diarrhea. Designed in the 1980s, a high degree of protection from colibacillosis was afforded to piglets in a challenge study and field trials. However MM-3 had a drawback of carrying the antibiotic resistance gene (chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene, cat). The introduction of a host-plasmid balanced lethal system into the vaccine was a good idea to solve the problem. The lambda-Red recombination system was adopted in this study to realize the replacement of cat by aspartate-semialdehyde dehydrogenase gene (asd) in the plasmid pMM085. The new plasmid named pMMASD was introduced into an Escherichia coli strain chi6097 and Salmonella typhimurium chi4072 where the asd gene had been knocked out in their chromosomes. Cultured in an Erlenmeyer flask, expression levels of two antigens K88ac fimbriae and heat-labile enterotoxin B subunit (LTB) in cell lysate were similar among MM-3, chi4072(pMMASD) and chi6097(pMMASD). However, chi4072(pMMASD) possessed the more effective secretion mechanism to transport LTB enterotoxin into culture liquid. The relatively higher stability of pMMASD in Salmonella typhimurium chi4072 than that of pMM085 in MM-3 was determined both in vitro in the absence of selective pressure, and in vivo following oral inoculation. Oral immunization of BALB/c mice with chi4072(pMMASD) or chi6097(pMMASD) was sufficient to elicit IgA responses in mucosal tissues as well as systemic IgG antibody responses to the K88 fimbriae, while MM-3 failed to elicit specific antibody responses to K88 fimbriae in mucosal tissues. Among three live strains, only chi4072(pMMASD) could develop strong humoral responses against LTB enterotoxin. The results suggest that chi4072(pMMASD) is expected to be a promising live vaccine strain.

Use of the α-hemolysin secretion system of Escherichia coli for antigen delivery in the Salmonella typhi Ty21a vaccine strain

This study examined the suitability of the hemolysin secretion system of Escherichia coli for expression and delivery of alpha-hemolysin (HlyA) by the S. typhi Ty21a strain, the only live oral Salmonella vaccine strain licensed for human use, under in vitro and in vivo conditions. For this purpose, two plasmid vectors encoding either the whole alpha-hemolysin of E. coli (pANN202-812/pMOhly2) or the hemolysin secretion signal (pMOhly1) were transferred into S. typhi Ty21a. S. typhi Ty21a carrying pANN202-812/pMOhly2 revealed efficient secretion of hemolysin in vitro. After formulation according to a process suitable for commercial production of Salmonella-based live bacterial vaccines, plasmids were shown to be stable in Ty21a and hemolysin secretion was demonstrated even after storage of the strains under real-time and stress conditions. After intranasal immunization of mice with S. typhi Ty21a/pANN202-812 plasmids are stable in vivo, and immunization induced a profound immune response against the heterologous HlyA antigen. Therefore, the combination of the hemolysin secretion system and S. typhi Ty21a could form the basis for a new generation of live bacterial vaccines.

Animal models paving the way for clinical trials of attenuated Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi live oral vaccines and live vectors

Attenuated Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi (S. Typhi) strains can serve as safe and effective oral vaccines to prevent typhoid fever and as live vectors to deliver foreign antigens to the immune system, either by the bacteria expressing antigens through prokaryotic expression plasmids or by delivering foreign genes carried on eukaryotic expression systems (DNA vaccines). The practical utility of such live vector vaccines relies on achieving a proper balance between minimizing the vaccine's reactogenicity and maximizing its immunogenicity. To advance to clinical trials, vaccine candidates need to be pre-clinically evaluated in relevant animal models that attempt to predict what their safety and immunogenicity profile will be when administered to humans. Since S. Typhi is a human-restricted pathogen, a major obstacle that has impeded the progress of vaccine development has been the shortcomings of the animal models available to assess vaccine candidates. In this review, we summarize the usefulness of animal models in the assessment of the degree of attenuation and immunogenicity of novel attenuated S. Typhi strains as vaccine candidates for the prevention of typhoid fever and as live vectors in humans.

Salmonella vaccines for use in humans: present and future perspectives

In recent years there has been significant progress in the development of attenuated Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi strains as candidate typhoid fever vaccines. In clinical trials these vaccines have been shown to be well tolerated and immunogenic. For example, the attenuated S. enterica var. Typhi strains CVD 908-htrA (aroC aroD htrA), Ty800 (phoP phoQ) and chi4073 (cya crp cdt) are all promising candidate typhoid vaccines. In addition, clinical trials have demonstrated that S. enterica var. Typhi vaccines expressing heterologous antigens, such as the tetanus toxin fragment C, can induce immunity to the expressed antigens in human volunteers. In many cases, the problems associated with expression of antigens in Salmonella have been successfully addressed and the future of Salmonella vaccine development is very promising.

Delivery of protein antigens and DNA by attenuated intracellular bacteria

On the basis of attenuated intracellular bacteria, we have developed two delivery systems for either heterologous proteins or DNA vaccine vectors. The first system utilizes attenuated strains of Gram-negative bacteria which are engineered to secrete heterologous antigens via the alpha-hemolysin secretion system (type I) of Escherichia coli. The second system is based on attenuated suicide strains of Listeria monocytogenes, which are used for the direct delivery of eukaryotic antigen expression vectors into professional antigen-presenting cells (APC) like macrophages and dendritic cells in vitro and can be also used in animal models.

Salmonella: immune responses and vaccines

Salmonella infections are a serious medical and veterinary problem world-wide and cause concern in the food industry. Vaccination is an effective tool for the prevention of Salmonella infections. Host resistance to Salmonella relies initially on the production of inflammatory cytokines leading to the infiltration of activated inflammatory cells in the tissues. Thereafter T- and B-cell dependent specific immunity develops allowing the clearance of Salmonella microorganisms from the tissues and the establishment of long-lasting acquired immunity to re-infection. The increased resistance that develops after primary infection/ vaccination requires T-cells cytokines such as IFNgamma TNFalpha and IL12 in addition to opsonising antibody. However for reasons that are not fully understood seroconversion and/or the presence of detectable T-cell memory do not always correlate with the development of acquired resistance to infection.Whole-cell killed vaccines and subunit vaccines are used in the prevention of Salmonella infection in animals and in humans with variable results. A number of early live Salmonella vaccines derived empirically by chemical or u.v. mutagenesis proved to be immunogenic and protective and are still in use despite the need for repeated parenteral administration. Recent progress in the knowledge of the genetics of Salmonella virulence and modern recombinant DNA technology offers the possibility to introduce multiple defined attenuating and irreversible mutations into the bacterial genome. This has recently allowed the development of Salmonella strains devoid of significant side effects but still capable of inducing solid immunity after single oral administration. Live attenuated Salmonella vaccines have been used for the expression of heterologous antigens/proteins that can be successfully delivered to the immune system. Furthermore Salmonella can transfer plasmids encoding foreign antigens under the control of eukaryotic promoters (DNA vaccines) to antigen-presenting cells resulting in targeted delivery of DNA vaccines to these cells. Despite the great recent advances in the development of Salmonella vaccines a large proportion of the work has been conducted in laboratory rodents and more research in other animal species is required.

Recombinant live Salmonella spp. for human vaccination against heterologous pathogens

Live attenuated Salmonella spp. are promising candidates as oral vaccine delivery systems for heterologous antigens. Clinical trials have demonstrated that this approach is feasible for human vaccinations but further optimisation is necessary to obtain a better efficacy. Here, we discuss how existing clinical and pre-clinical data can be used to guide such optimisation efforts.

Immunisation with live attenuated Salmonella dublin expressing a sporozoite protein confers partial protection against Theileria parva

Cattle immunised with a recombinant form of p67, the major surface antigen of Theileria parva sporozoites, have been shown to be protected against parasite challenge. In an attempt to simplify the immunisation procedure live attenuated Salmonella strains expressing p67 have been constructed and used to induce anti-p67 immune responses in cattle. All animals immunised with these strains developed strong antibody responses to p67. Specific T cell responses could be detected in the majority of immunised cattle. Challenge with T. parva sporozoites revealed a significant level of protection in immunised calves compared to naive control animals or animals inoculated with non-recombinant attenuated Salmonella.

Tightly controlled two-stage expression vectors employing the Flp/FRT-mediated inversion of cloned genes

We have developed a tightly controlled, two-stage expression system. It is based on a single plasmid that carries the TetR repressor/Ptet promoter/Otet operator for the first-stage control, and the Flp recombinase/ FRT sites for the second-stage control. The gene to be expressed (GENE) is cloned in an inverted orientation (with respect to the stationary promoter) into a multiple-cloning site (MCS) located between two convergent FRT1 and FRT2 sites. In the OFF stage, no inadvertent transcription can enter the 5' end of cloned GENE because of four rrnBT1 terminators, located just outside the FRT1-MCS-FRT2 cassette and because the FRT2 construct was deprived of any promoter function. When using the lacZ reporter, it was shown that in their OFF stage our two-stage expression plasmids exhibit a significantly lower basal expression than the repressed single-stage tetR/PtetOtet-lacZ vectors. To enter the ON stage, the tetR/PtetOtet module is induced by adding autoclaved chlortetracycline (cTc), leading to synthesis of the Flp recombinase, which in turn, inverts the FRT1-MCS-FRT2 module together with the cloned GENE. This results in the massive GENE expression from one (pInvMS) or two (pImpMS) stationary promoters.

Expression and immunogenicity of an Echinococcus granulosus fatty acid-binding protein in live attenuated Salmonella vaccine strains

Fatty acid-binding proteins (FABPs) are candidate molecules for vaccines against several parasitic platyhelminths. A FABP from the cestode Echinococcus granulosus (EgDf1) was expressed in Salmonella vaccine strains as a C-terminal fusion to fragment C of tetanus toxin (TetC) by using expression vector pTECH. The fusion protein was equally expressed in several attenuated vaccine strains derived from bacteria with different genetic backgrounds and different attenuating mutations. Single-dose immunization experiments with the aroA Salmonella typhimurium strain SL3261 carrying the pTECH-EgDf1 construct were conducted with mice, using both the intravenous and the oral routes. Surprisingly, the antibody response to EgDf1 and the antigen-specific cytokine production in spleen cells were stronger in mice immunized orally. Furthermore, immune mouse sera strongly reacted with fixed sections of the worm's larval stage. Analysis of the isotype distribution of the specific anti-EgDf1 antibodies showed similar production of immunoglobulin G1 (IgG1) and IgG2a together with specific IgA antibodies. In addition, stimulation of spleen cells from mice immunized with the different constructs with either Salmonella lysate, TetC, or EgDf1 showed that, together with Th1-related cytokines (gamma interferon and interleukin 2 [IL-2]), significant levels of a Th2 cytokine (IL-5) were produced specifically, indicating a Th2 component to the response to the Salmonella carrier and to the recombinant antigens. Salmonellae expressing the TetC-rEgDfl fusion are currently under evaluation as potential vaccines against E. granulosus.

Induction of feline immunodeficiency virus specific antibodies in cats with an attenuated Salmonella strain expressing the Gag protein

Salmonella typhimurium aroA strains (SL3261), expressing high levels of the Gag protein of feline immunodeficiency virus (FIV) fused with maltose binding protein (SL3261-MFG), were constructed using an invertible promoter system that allows the stable expression of heterologous antigens at levels toxic for bacteria. A SL3261 strain expressing the B subunit of cholera toxin by a similar system (SL3261-CtxB) served as a control in FIV-immunization experiments. Cats immunized once orally or intraperitoneally with SL3261-MFG or SL3261-CtxB all developed serum antibodies to SL3261 lipopolysaccharide and against maltose binding protein or the B subunit of cholera toxin, respectively. Two intraperitoneal immunizations with SL3261-MFG also resulted in the development of Gag specific serum antibodies. Two oral immunizations with SL3261-MFG primed for a Gag specific response, which was demonstrated upon FIV challenge. All challenged cats became infected and no significant differences in viral loads were found between SL3261-MFG and SL3261-CtxB immunized cats.

Vaccine efficacy of Salmonella strains expressing glycoprotein 63 with different promoters

The development of Salmonella vaccine vectors has been hindered by both the requirement for multiple doses to induce immune responses and a lack of plasmid stability. Direct comparisons of different promoter systems with the same antigen are necessary to address these important issues. We have previously described an AroA- AroD- deletion mutant of Salmonella typhimurium (GID101) which expresses the gene encoding the Leishmania major promastigote surface glycoprotein gp63 (GID101). While this construct provided significant protection against L. major challenge to highly susceptible BALB/c mice, this required at least two oral doses. We report here the use of two different inducible promoters, the nirB and osmC promoters, to improve vaccine efficacy. These constructs (termed GID105 and GID106, respectively) expressed gp63 in vitro under inducible conditions and colonized BALB/c mice after oral administration. GID105 demonstrated greater plasmid stability in vitro and in vivo than did either GID106 or GID101, which expresses gp63 constitutively. Spleen and lymph node cells from mice immunized with a single oral dose of GID105 proliferated in vitro in response to L. major and secreted gamma interferon, whereas cells from mice given the other constructs did not. Mice immunized with a single oral dose of GID1O5 or GID106 developed significantly smaller lesions upon challenge with L. major, whereas mice administered GID101 did not. Mice administered GID105 also showed considerable resistance to Leishmania donovani infection. These data provide a direct comparison of promoter systems and demonstrate that the use of inducible promoters such as the nirB promoter allows a considerable improvement over the previous vaccine construct in terms of protection against infection.

Expression of genes encoding two major Theileria annulata merozoite surface antigens in Escherichia coli and a Salmonella typhimurium aroA vaccine strain

The genes, Tams1-1 and Tams1-2, encoding the 30-and 32-kDa major merozoite surface antigens of Theileria annulata (Ta), have recently been cloned and characterized. Both genes encode a protein of 281 amino acids (aa) containing a putative hydrophobic N-terminal signal peptide. Another hydrophobic stretch is predicted at the C terminus which probably functions to anchor the protein in the membrane of the merozoite and piroplasm. Here, we report the successful expression of both Tams1-1 and Tams1-2 in Escherichia coli (Ec) using gene fragments lacking both hydrophobic domains. Attempts to produce high amounts of the entire recombinant (re-) protein, or a fragment containing the N terminus only, were unsuccessful. This is presumably due to the toxicity of these re-proteins. The internal part of both genes was also expressed in Salmonella typhimurium (St) aroA vaccine strain SL3261. We employed a dual-plasmid expression system based on an invertible promoter and selected the most stable St construct in vitro using liquid cultures and a macrophage-like cell line. The re-Tams1-1 protein produced in Ec, as well as in St, was recognized by monoclonal antibody (mAb) 5E1 specific to the 30-kDa protein. Both re-Tams1-1 and re-Tams1-2 were recognized by Ta immune calf serum.

Mixed population approach for vaccination with live recombinant Salmonella strains

Attenuated strains of enteropathogenic species, such as Salmonella, represent useful carries for the delivery of heterologous recombinant antigens to the immune system. A frequently encountered obstacle, however, is the negative influence of high-level antigen production on the stability of carrier strains and the maintenance of their specific properties concerning tissue colonization and viability during infection. To solve this problem we have established an expression system based on genetic variation. This generates two sub-populations of a recombinant vaccine strain, i.e., one consisting of viable cells which maintain all characteristics of the native carrier strain and generate a second population of cells producing antigen(s) of interest at a very high level. This novel expression system offers unique applications and advantages over common live recombinant vaccine approaches.

Induction of the phoE promoter upon invasion of Salmonella typhimurium into eukaryotic cells

Live attenuated Salmonella typhimurium strains expressing foreign antigens can be used for vaccination purposes. Due to deleterious effects of constitutive, high-level expression of the heterologous antigens, there is often strong selection pressure against plasmids encoding these antigens, resulting in rapid segregation in vivo. In vivo-inducible promoters may be a good alternative for constitutive promoters. The outer membrane protein PhoE of Escherichia coli is being used as a carrier for foreign antigenic determinants. Here we studied whether its expression from a plasmid is induced in S. typhimurium upon invasion of eukaryotic cells. This appeared to be the case. Furthermore, a S. typhimurium phoE mutant was constructed and the effects of the mutation on invasion, intracellular survival and virulence were studied. Survival in HEp-2 cells or in the macrophage-like cell line J744 was not, or only slightly, affected. Furthermore, the mutant appeared to be as virulent for mice as the wild-type strain.