The effects of high dietary concentrations of sodium saccharin on in vivo metabolism of xenobiotics in rats

An analysis of the need for an additional uncertainty factor for infants and children

Uncertainty factors have been used for over 40 years to establish safe intakes of threshold toxicants. Tenfold factors are used to allow for species differences and for human variability, with extra factors for database inadequacies. The proposal to introduce an additional 10-fold factor for pesticides when exposure of infants and children is anticipated implies either age-related differences between species or differences within humans which exceed those present in adults. Alternatively, the extra factor could be related to deficiencies of current testing methods or concerns over irreversibility in developing organ systems. Available data do not provide a scientific rationale for the extra factor due to inadequacy of inter- and intraspecies uncertainty factors. Justification for the factor therefore must relate to the adequacy and sensitivity of current methods or concern about irreversible effects in the developing organism.

Toxicokinetics in infants and children in relation to the ADI and TDI

Age-dependent developmental changes in toxicokinetics occur in both rats and humans, particularly in relation to renal function and hepatic xenobiotic metabolism. These processes are immature in humans at birth, especially in the pre-term neonate, but mature rapidly over the first months of life. In consequence the duration of immaturity primarily corresponds to the period of suckling. Similar developmental changes occur in the neonatal rat over the first weeks of life. Rat pups start to consume some of the adult diet in the third week of life, prior to weaning, so that there is a potential for consumption of the adult diet during the period of immaturity. There is an extensive database on the pharmacokinetics of therapeutic drugs in infants and children. The elimination/clearance of many drugs is higher in children than in adults and this difference would apply to other xenobiotics. In consequence, children frequently will have lower body burdens than adults for the same daily intake of a chemical when this is expressed on a body weight basis, as used to describe the ADI (Acceptable Daily Intake) or TDI (Tolerable Daily Intake) (e.g. mg/kg body weight/day). Therefore, an increased safety or uncertainty factor for post-suckling infants and children is not required in relation to age-related differences in toxicokinetics. Indeed, the higher clearance of many xenobiotics (toxicokinetics) by children compared with adults may compensate, at least in part, for increased organ sensitivity (toxicodynamics) during development.