Shear bond strength of four dentinal adhesives applied in vivo and in vitro

Does extended air-drying time improve bond strength of universal adhesives to enamel?

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the effect of extended air-drying time on the microshear bond strength (MSBS) of universal adhesives to enamel.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The distal and mesial specimens from third molars were wet-ground and randomly assigned to three groups according to adhesives tested (n = 60): Clearfil Bond Universal, Gluma Bond Universal, and G-Premio Bond. The adhesives were applied in etch-and-rinse or self-etch modes, followed by air-drying for 5, 15, or 25 s. Composite buildups were constructed and subjected to the MSBS test after 24-h or thermocycling. MSBS results were evaluated using a four-way ANOVA. The thickness of the adhesive layer and the degree of solvent evaporation were further evaluated.

RESULTS

At 24-h, MSBS of G-Premio Bond significantly improved with the 25 s air-drying in both of the etching modes when compared to the 5 s air-drying. After thermocycling, the extended air-drying did not produce a significant difference on the MSBS, regardless of the application strategy. Extended air-drying (25 s) evaporated almost all of the volatile part of Gluma Bond Universal and G-Premio Bond.

CONCLUSIONS

Extended air-drying times increased solvent evaporation but did not contribute to the bonding effectiveness of the adhesives, regardless of the etching mode.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

Air-drying applications for more than 5 s had no significant effect on enamel bonding performance of universal adhesives.

Effect of matrix metalloproteinase inhibitors on bonding durability of universal adhesives

This study aimed to evaluate the effect of different matrix metalloproteinase inhibitors (MMPIs) on the microtensile bond strength (μTBS) and nanoleakage of universal adhesives. One hundred twenty non-carious human molars were prepared and randomly assigned to two groups: Scotchbond Bond Universal (SBU) and Gluma Bond Universal (GBU). The samples in each group were assigned to five subgroups (n=12) based on one control (water) and four MMPIs (Benzalkonium-chloride (BAC), Batimastat (BB94), Chlorhexidine (CHX), and Epigallocatechin-gallate (EGCG)). Each adhesive was applied in self-etch (SE) mode or etch-and-rinse (ER) mode. Dentin/composite sticks were fabricated and subjected to the μTBS test after 24 h or 6 months. At 6 months, MMPIs did not affect the μTBS of the adhesives, regardless of etching mode. Nanoleakage was more pronounced in ER mode than in SE mode for all subgroups. All MMPIs, with the exception of CHX, decreased the nanoleakage of GBU in ER mode.

Enhancement performance of application mussel-biomimetic adhesive primer for dentin adhesives

In this study, a bioinspired adhesive primer monomer was prepared and evaluated for durable adhesion between dentin and composite resins.

Comparison of the Shear Bond Strength of Silorane-Based Composite Resin and Methacrylate Based Composite Resin to MTA

Background. Mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) is a material that has recently gained popularity in the application of the vital pulp therapy. Along with the increasing use of MTA to this end, the permanent restoration material to be placed on MTA has become a significant issue. The aim of this in vitro study was to investigate the bond strength of the novel low-shrinkage silorane-based composite resin (SBC) to MTA.

Methods. Twenty acrylic blocks filled with MTA were prepared for this study. SBC was the test group and methacrylate-based composite resin (MBC) was used as the control group. Shear bond strength test was performed to determine the bond strength. The surfaces of broken samples were evaluated under a stereomicroscope and grouped as adhesive, cohesive and mixed. Data were examined by statistical analysis.

Results. Statistical analysis revealed that SBC exhibited higher shear bond strength than the control group. It was observed that most of the failures in the test group were of cohesive type within MTA.

Conclusion. Based on the results, SBC showed higher shear bond strength than the control group; however, clinical follow-up is needed to evaluate the clinical success.

The role of dentin moisture in the degradation of resin-dentin interfaces under clinical and laboratory conditions

BACKGROUND

The authors conducted a study to evaluate the influence of dentin moisture on the degradation of the resin-dentin interface in primary teeth under clinical and laboratory conditions.

METHODS

The authors prepared 40 Class I restorations (five teeth per group) by using a cylindrical diamond bur, leaving a flat dentin surface on the pulpal floor. They vigorously rubbed two coats of a simplified etch-and-rinse adhesive on either dry or wet demineralized dentin under clinical or laboratory conditions. After performing restorative procedures, the authors extracted teeth prepared under clinical conditions after 20 minutes (immediately) or the teeth exfoliated after six months. The authors also tested the teeth prepared under laboratory conditions immediately or after six months of being stored in water. They sectioned the teeth to obtain resin-dentin bonded specimens for microtensile testing and for silver nitrate uptake (SNU) under scanning electron microscopy. They performed a three-way analysis of variance and Tukey test (α = .05) on the SNU bond strength data.

RESULTS

Statistically higher bond strength values (megapascals [standard deviation]) were observed when bonding was performed under laboratory conditions (clinical = 25.2 [3.6] MPa versus laboratory = 28.5 [4.4] MPa; P < .05). Degradation occurred only in the wet dentin groups under both experimental conditions (immediately = 31.3 [4.5] MPa versus after six months = 21.3 [2.1] MPa; P < .05). SNU occurred in all groups and was statistically higher after six months of clinical function or water storage (immediately = 13.9 [4.9 SD] percent versus after six months = 34.1 [4.5 SD] percent; P < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

The bonding of adhesives to dry demineralized dentin produces adhesive interfaces that are more resistant to degradation regardless of the bonding condition.

CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS

Resin-dentin bond strengths produced under laboratory conditions in primary teeth may be higher than those obtained under clinical circumstances, although both conditions (clinical and laboratory) seemed to yield similar results. Bonding to dry demineralized primary tooth dentin produced resin-dentin interfaces that were more resistant to degradation.

Effect of placement agitation and drying time on dentin shear bond strength: an in vivo study

The current study measured the bond strength of a self-etch system to dentin with and without agitation and with varying drying times of primer in vital dentin. The null hypotheses tested were that primer agitation and primer drying time did not affect the dentin shear bond strength. Sixty human maxillary and mandibular premolars scheduled to be extracted for orthodontic reasons were selected. The adhesive/resin combination used was Clearfil SE (Kuraray, Osaka, Japan)/TPH Spectrum (Dentsply DeTrey, Konstanz, Germany). The occlusal surfaces of the teeth were flattened using straight fissure diamond abrasive points ISO-012. Samples were divided into six groups of 10 teeth each. Primer was applied following the manufacturer's instructions with and without agitation followed by air-drying time of 0 (without air drying), five and 10 seconds. Clearfil SE Bond was applied and cured for 10 seconds. TPH Spectrum composite, shade A2 (Dentsply DeTrey), was placed over cured adhesive and was cured for 40 seconds. The teeth were restored to their original anatomy. The teeth were extracted after one week and the samples were kept in distilled water until testing at room temperature. The samples were tested in shear at a 1 mm/minute crosshead speed using an LR100 Universal Testing Machine. The data was analyzed using ANOVA and Tukey post-hoc tests (p < 0.05). Varying the drying time of the primer from zero (0) to 10 seconds did not significantly affect the bond strength values in vivo. At five seconds drying time, agitation significantly improved the shear bond strength to dentin. Agitation showed no effect when primer was not dried or it was dried for 10 seconds.

Bonding agents in pit and fissure sealants: a review

Dental adhesive systems used for bonding dental resins to enamel and dentin have evolved through several "generations," with changes in chemistry, mechanism, number of bottles, application technique, and clinical effectiveness. The trend in the latest generation of dental bonding systems is to reduce the number of components and clinical placement steps. The introduction of i bond, a single-bottle dental adhesive system, is the latest of the new generation materials, and combines etchant, adhesive, and desensitizer in one component. This paper describes different dentin bonding agents, its evolution, mechanism of action and different commercially available dentin bonding agents and their role in the retention of pit and fissure sealant.

Adhesive performance of dentin bonding agents appliedin vivo andin vitro. Effect of intrapulpal pressure and dentin depth

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the influence of intrapulpal pressure and dentin depth on bond strengths of an etch-and-rinse and a self-etching bonding agent to dentin in vitro and in vivo. Twenty-four pairs of premolars were randomly divided into four groups (n = 6) according to the dentin bonding agent, Single Bond and Clearfil SE Bond, and intrapulpal pressure, null or positive. Each tooth of the pair was further designated to be treated in vivo or in vitro. The intrapulpal pressure was controlled in vivo by the delivery of local anesthetics containing or not a vasoconstrictor, while in vitro, it was achieved by keeping the teeth under hydrostatic pressure. Class I cavities were prepared and the dentin bonding agents were applied followed by incremental resin restoration. For the teeth treated in vitro, the same restorative procedures were performed after a 6 month-storage period. Beams with 1 mm(2) cross-sectional area were prepared and microtensile tested. Clearfil SE Bond was not influenced by any of the variables of the study, while bond strengths produced in vitro were significantly higher for Single Bond. Overall, lower bond strengths were produced in deep dentin, which reached statistical significance when Single Bond was applied under physiological or simulated intrapulpal pressure. In conclusion, in vitro bonding may overestimate the immediate adhesive performance of more technique-sensitive dentin bonding systems. The impact of intrapulpal pressure on bond strength seems to be more adhesive dependent than dentin morphological characteristics related to depth.

In vitro evaluation of microleakage of indirect composite inlays cemented with four luting agents

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Microleakage around dental restorations is implicated in the occurrence of secondary carious lesions, adverse pulpal response, and reduced restoration longevity.

PURPOSE

The aim of this in vitro study was to evaluate the microleakage of indirect resin composite inlays cemented with 4 luting agents.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Standardized Class V inlay preparations overlapping the cemento-enamel junction were prepared on the buccal and lingual surfaces of 40 extracted human mandibular third molars. Eighty postpolymerized, heat-treated resin composite inlays (Targis, 72 specimens, 8 controls) were processed in stone replicas and cemented into the preparations using 4 luting agents (n = 18 + 2 controls for each cement group): a resin composite used with a bonding agent (Variolink II/Excite), a resin composite used with a self-etching primer, but without bonding agent (Panavia F/ED Primer), a modified resin composite used with a bonding agent (Resinomer/One Step), and a resin-modified glass-ionomer cement (Fuji Plus). Thirty-six inlays (n = 9 + 1 control) were subjected to thermal cycling (2000 cycles, 5 degrees C/55 degrees C), whereas the other 36 were not. All the teeth were then immersed in 1% methylene blue dye solution for 48 hours. Microleakage score, margin location (enamel/cementum), thermal cycling history, and preparation location (buccal/lingual) were analyzed using a multivariate model (alpha = .05). Multivariate analysis was performed using a polychotomous logistic regression.

RESULTS

The preparation location had no significant effect on dye penetration. The margin location (enamel or cementum) and the thermal cycling had a significant effect on microleakage (odds ratios [ORs] = 17.6 and 8.04, respectively). In comparing the 3 resin-based luting agents (Variolink II, Panavia F, and Resinomer) to Fuji Plus, Panavia F exhibited the lowest significant overall microleakage (OR = 0.09), followed by Variolink II (significant OR equal to 0.43), whereas Resinomer demonstrated the greatest significant overall microleakage (OR = 1.35).

CONCLUSION

Within the experimental conditions of this in vitro study, thermal cycling significantly increased microleakage (OR = 8.04). The overall microleakage at the enamel margins was significantly lower than the overall microleakage at the cementum margins for the 4 luting agents tested (OR = 17.6).

In vitro evaluation of dental bonding agents using shear and vibrational methods

OBJECTIVE

To determine the suitability of two mechanical test methods for the in vitro evaluation of dental bonding agents.

METHODS

The first method was the Iosipescu shear test in which a pure shear stress is induced in a notched beam sample, and the second was a multilayer vibrating reed test in which the effectiveness of bonding could be assessed by the magnitude of relative elastic modulus and mechanical damping factors. The tests were applied to bonded samples of high-copper amalgam, gallium alloy and composite resin with two different types of adhesive. Representative data is presented to show the capabilities of the test methods.

RESULTS

Both methods were shown to generate more consistent data with lower scatter than that usually reported in this field. Each may be used to provide information of clinical relevance.

CONCLUSION

With further development, these test methods could make a useful contribution to the assessment of dental bonding agents.

Meta-analytical review of factors involved in dentin adherence

Literature data on adherence tests of dentin-bonding systems (DBS) may differ widely, even for the same DBS. The problem of bond testing is that materials are seldom compared with a standard, and experimental conditions often vary. We sought to identify the parameters that influence this variability. Using inclusion and exclusion criteria, we conducted a meta-analytical review of 75 articles, published between 1992 and 1996 in SCI reviews, that give bond strength data for 15 dentin-bonding agents of the so-called third and fourth generations. Seventeen selected parameters were classified into four groups: Group A includes factors related to the dentin substrate (i.e., nature of teeth); group B, composite and bonding area (i.e., composite stiffness); group C, storage conditions of the bonded samples (i.e., thermocycling); and group D, test design (i.e., crosshead speed). For each report, the experimental features, the bond strength means and standard deviations, and the failure mode were extracted and tabulated. Statistical Analysis System software was used to perform Pearson correlation analysis and analysis of variance, with bond strength as the dependent variable and experimental conditions as the independent variables. The meta-analytical review highlighted the significant influence of various parameters in the different groups: origin of dentin, types of teeth, pulpal pressure, tooth storage temperature, maximum storage time of teeth, and dentin depth in group A; type and stiffness of composite and bonding area in group B; storage of bonded samples (medium, temperature, and time) in group C, and testing mode and crosshead speed in group D. A significant positive correlation was observed between the mean bond strength and the rate of cohesive failure. It can be concluded from this study that some of these parameters should be controlled by the use of a standardized protocol. Unfortunately, the substrate-related variables are more difficult to control, even though their influence is consistent.

Pilot study of the effects of three bonding systems on the torsional resistance of a titanium-reinforced composite core

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

There are no studies analyzing the effects of a bonding agent on torsional resistance for a titanium-reinforced core material bonded with a multistep bonding system.

PURPOSE

This pilot study investigated the effects of multistep bonding agents on torsional resistance of a titanium-reinforced composite core material (Ti-Core core material).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 40 recently extracted human molars with their crowns removed were placed into acrylic resin blocks and divided into 4 groups of 10 specimens. Only multistep bonding systems were used (AllBond-2, ScotchBond Multi-

PURPOSE

Tenure A&B, and the control without bonding agent). Specimens were prepared according to manufacturer's instructions. The control group was etched with a 37.5% phosphate acid. All cores were fabricated with Ti-Core titanium core material with No. 1 hard copper bands as the matrix. Ti-Core core material was applied and allowed to cure for 1 hour, then the cores were placed in 100% humidity (water) for 1 week. Test specimens were placed in a special jig and a clockwise torsional force applied. Torsional force was measured on a Lebow 1102-200 torque transducer and recorded on a Hewlett Packard 7015B X-Y recorder in inch x ounce then converted into Newton-meter. One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to test for statistical significance (P <.05).

RESULTS

Torsional values (Newton-meter) were AllBond-2, 0.1980, ScotchBond Multi-

PURPOSE

0.1890, Tenure A&B, 0.2142; the control group recorded a value of zero. Statistical analysis revealed that bonding systems did not differ from one another.

CONCLUSION

Use of a bonding agent increased the core's resistance to torsional forces. Lack of a bonding agent dramatically reduced the resistance to torque.

Effects of three bonding systems on the torsional resistance of titanium-reinforced composite cores supported by two post designs

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

There are no studies that have investigated the effects of bonding agents on the resistance to torque of a composite core supported by a prefabricated post.

PURPOSE

This study investigated the ability of bonding agents to resist rational forces applied to titanium-reinforced composite cores supported by 2 post designs.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Two post designs (AccessPost and ParaPost dowels) with titanium-reinforced core material and 4 bonding conditions (AllBond-2, ScotchBond Multi-Purpose, Tenure A&B, and without a bonding agent) were studied. A total of 80 specimens in 8 experimental groups were prepared and subjected to clockwise torsional forces until failure.

RESULTS

Torsional values ranged from 53.31 in. x oz (ParaPost/ScotchBond Multi-Purpose) to 72.31 in. x oz (AccessPost/ScotchBond Multi-Purpose). Two-way of analysis of variance failed to demonstrate a significant difference among posts or type of bonding system.

CONCLUSION

The use of a multistep bonding agent had no significant effect on the torsional resistance of a core supported by a passive endodontic post.

Marginal integrity and postoperative sensitivity in Class 2 resin composite restorations in vivo

INTRODUCTION

Problems that may arise in resin composite Class 2 restorations include microleakage and postoperative sensitivity. However, limited in-vivo research is conducted to evaluate these processes.

AIM

The aim of this study was to assess postoperative sensitivity, microleakage and the pooling of adhesives in relation to Class 2 box-type composite restorations placed in vivo using various adhesive systems and application techniques.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred and forty-four Class 2 box restorations were placed in the mesial and distal surfaces of 72 premolar teeth in-vivo using one of three combinations of adhesive systems and three filling techniques. After 6 weeks of clinical service postoperative sensitivity was recorded. The teeth were then extracted, immersed in a dye solution and sectioned. Microleakage and pooling of the adhesive was recorded. Statistical analysis involved logistic regression and chi2 tests to identify differences between groups at p < 0.05.

RESULTS

Of the 144 restorations, 65 showed minimal cervical leakage in enamel, 5 suffered leakage into dentin and 74 were free of microleakage. No statistically significant differences were found in cervical microleakage between the adhesive systems or between filling procedures. Occlusal microleakage in the enamel was present in 16 of the 160 restorations. Liner Bond 2 restorations leaked significantly more at the occlusal surface (p < 0.05). Pooling of the adhesive was significantly less when PhotoBond was used. No spontaneous postoperative sensitivity was reported. Twenty-eight restorations were sensitive to loading. Postoperative sensitivity was significantly less in patients with Liner Bond 2 restorations.

CONCLUSIONS

The adhesive systems used in this study showed minimal leakage into dentin in vivo. Using Liner Bond 2, restorations exhibited more occlusal leakage but were significantly less sensitive to loading.

Shear bond strength of a titanium reinforced core material after using multistep and single-step bonding agents

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Recently introduced single-step bonding agents reduce the number of steps involved in the bonding process. Nevertheless, there are few studies on the bond strengths obtained with these new systems.

PURPOSE

This in vitro study evaluated the shear bond strength of a titanium-reinforced cores bonded with 5 multistep bonding systems (ScotchBond Multi-Purpose, OptiBond, All Bond-2, Tenure, and ProBond) and 5 single-step bonding systems (Single-Bond, OptiBond Solo, One-Step, Tenure Quik, and Prime & Bond 2.1).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The experiment was divided into 10 groups with 10 specimens per group. The shear bond strengths were evaluated after 24 hours on an MTS universal testing machine with a crosshead speed of 6.35 mm/minute.

RESULTS

A 2-way ANOVA showed that All Bond-2 and One-Step recorded the highest means and differed significantly from the Den-Mat systems (Tenure A&B and Tenure Quik), the Kerr systems (OptiBond and Opti-Solo), and the Caulk systems (ProBond and Prime & Bond 2.1). ProBond and Prime & Bond 2.1 bonding systems had the lowest mean and differed from the 3 other brands. Tenure A&B and Tenure Quik bonding systems and OptiBond and Opti-Solo bonding systems did not differ from one another.

CONCLUSION

The single-step bonding agents did not produce an improvement in shear bond strengths. The wide range of shear bond strength reported for the single-step systems appeared to indicate that these bonding systems are technique sensitive.

In vitro interfacial relationship between human dentin and one-bottle dental adhesives

OBJECTIVES

One-bottle dentin adhesives combine primer and adhesive resin into a single solution. This study was conducted to determine the bond strengths to dentin of four one-bottle bonding systems and to evaluate their SEM interfacial morphology. The hypothesis to be tested was that the water-based bonding system would produce lower bond strengths and less complete penetration into dentin than other bonding systems that are dissolved in organic solvents.

METHODS

Forty extracted molars were ground to expose middle dentin and were randomly assigned to four groups (n = 10): Group 1--Experimental Single Bond (3M Dental Products Division); Group 2--Prime&Bond 2.1, pre-launch version (Dentsply DeTrey); Group 3--Syntac Single-Component (Vivadent); Group 4--Tenure Quik with Fluoride (Den-Mat Co.) The surfaces were treated according to manufacturers' instructions. After 24 h in water, the specimens were thermocycled, and the bond strengths were measured in shear. The data were analyzed with ANOVA and Duncan's test at a confidence level of 95%. Further, the adhesives were also applied to 600 microns thick dentin disks. After preparing polished cross sections, the bonded interfaces were demineralized, deproteinized, and observed under a FE-SEM. The morphological appearance of the resin-dentin interface surfaces was compared by screening the entire resin-dentin interface for each specimen.

RESULTS

Two morphological characteristics were evaluated: 1) the depth of resin penetration into the tubules and 2) the thickness and density of the resin-dentin interdiffusion zone. Single Bond showed statistically higher mean shear bond strengths (p < 0.001) compared to the other three materials. Specimens prepared with Syntac Single-Component and Prime&Bond 2.1 were ranked in the intermediary Duncan's grouping. Specimens bonded with Tenure Quik with Fluoride exhibited the lowest mean shear bond strength. All materials penetrated and hybridized dentin. Single Bond formed a thick layer of adhesive resin on the top of the interdiffusion area without debonding, whereas some areas of debonding were observed on the top of the hybrid layers for Prime&Bond 2.1 and Syntac Single-Component. For the water-based adhesive Syntac Single-Component, the interdiffusion zone displayed a thick filigree pattern, containing scattered open spaces between the resin-enveloped collagen fibers. Tenure Quik with Fluoride did not thoroughly infiltrate the demineralized dentin zone, resulting in wide gaps in all specimens. Prime&Bond 2.1 formed the shortest resin tags, whereas Syntac Single-Component formed the longest resin tags.

SIGNIFICANCE

Bonding to dentin remains unpredictable using one-bottle bonding systems. The chemistry of each individual material may be more important than the type of solvent.