A phylogenetic study of U4 snRNA reveals the existence of an evolutionarily conserved secondary structure corresponding to 'free' U4 snRNA

The SMN complex drives structural changes in human snRNAs to enable snRNP assembly

Spliceosomal snRNPs are multicomponent particles that undergo a complex maturation pathway. Human Sm-class snRNAs are generated as 3'-end extended precursors, which are exported to the cytoplasm and assembled together with Sm proteins into core RNPs by the SMN complex. Here, we provide evidence that these pre-snRNA substrates contain compact, evolutionarily conserved secondary structures that overlap with the Sm binding site. These structural motifs in pre-snRNAs are predicted to interfere with Sm core assembly. We model structural rearrangements that lead to an open pre-snRNA conformation compatible with Sm protein interaction. The predicted rearrangement pathway is conserved in Metazoa and requires an external factor that initiates snRNA remodeling. We show that the essential helicase Gemin3, which is a component of the SMN complex, is crucial for snRNA structural rearrangements during snRNP maturation. The SMN complex thus facilitates ATP-driven structural changes in snRNAs that expose the Sm site and enable Sm protein binding.

Characterization of Pre-mRNA Splicing and Spliceosomal Machinery in Porphyridium purpureum and Evolutionary Implications for Red Algae

Pre-mRNA splicing is a highly conserved eukaryotic process, but our understanding of it is limited by a historical focus on well-studied organisms such as humans and yeast. There is considerable diversity in mechanisms and components of pre-mRNA splicing, especially in lineages that have evolved under the pressures of genome reduction. The ancestor of red algae is thought to have undergone genome reduction prior to the lineage's radiation, resulting in overall gene and intron loss in extant groups. Previous studies on the extremophilic red alga Cyanidioschyzon merolae revealed an intron-sparse genome with a highly reduced spliceosome. To determine whether these features applied to other red algae, we investigated multiple aspects of pre-mRNA splicing in the mesophilic red alga Porphyridium purpureum. Through strand-specific RNA-Seq, we observed high levels of intron retention across a large number of its introns, and nearly half of the transcripts for these genes are not spliced at all. We also discovered a relationship between variability of 5' splice site sequences and levels of splicing. To further investigate the connections between intron retention and splicing machinery, we bioinformatically assembled the P. purpureum spliceosome, and biochemically verified the presence of snRNAs. While most other core spliceosomal components are present, our results suggest highly divergent or missing U1 snRNP proteins, despite the presence of an uncharacteristically long U1 snRNA. These unusual aspects highlight the diverse nature of pre-mRNA splicing that can be seen in lesser-studied eukaryotes, raising the importance of investigating fundamental eukaryotic processes outside of model organisms.

Dramatically reduced spliceosome in Cyanidioschyzon merolae

The human spliceosome is a large ribonucleoprotein complex that catalyzes pre-mRNA splicing. It consists of five snRNAs and more than 200 proteins. Because of this complexity, much work has focused on the Saccharomyces cerevisiae spliceosome, viewed as a highly simplified system with fewer than half as many splicing factors as humans. Nevertheless, it has been difficult to ascribe a mechanistic function to individual splicing factors or even to discern which are critical for catalyzing the splicing reaction. We have identified and characterized the splicing machinery from the red alga Cyanidioschyzon merolae, which has been reported to harbor only 26 intron-containing genes. The U2, U4, U5, and U6 snRNAs contain expected conserved sequences and have the ability to adopt secondary structures and form intermolecular base-pairing interactions, as in other organisms. C. merolae has a highly reduced set of 43 identifiable core splicing proteins, compared with ∼90 in budding yeast and ∼140 in humans. Strikingly, we have been unable to find a U1 snRNA candidate or any predicted U1-associated proteins, suggesting that splicing in C. merolae may occur without the U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein particle. In addition, based on mapping the identified proteins onto the known splicing cycle, we propose that there is far less compositional variability during splicing in C. merolae than in other organisms. The observed reduction in splicing factors is consistent with the elimination of spliceosomal components that play a peripheral or modulatory role in splicing, presumably retaining those with a more central role in organization and catalysis.

A phylogenetic study of Drosophila splicing assembly chaperone RNP-4F associated U4-/U6-snRNA secondary structure

The rnp-4f gene in Drosophila melanogaster encodes nuclear protein RNP-4F. This encoded protein is represented by homologs in other eukaryotic species, where it has been shown to function as an intron splicing assembly factor. Here, RNP-4F is believed to initially bind to a recognition sequence on U6-snRNA, serving as a chaperone to facilitate its association with U4-snRNA by intermolecular hydrogen bonding. RNA conformations are a key factor in spliceosome function, so that elucidation of changing secondary structures for interacting snRNAs is a subject of considerable interest and importance. Among the five snRNAs which participate in removal of spliceosomal introns, there is a growing consensus that U6-snRNA is the most structurally dynamic and may constitute the catalytic core. Previous studies by others have generated potential secondary structures for free U4- and U6-snRNAs, including the Y-shaped U4-/U6-snRNA model. These models were based on study of RNAs from relatively few species, and the popular Y-shaped model remains to be systematically re-examined with reference to the many new sequences generated by recent genomic sequencing projects. We have utilized a comparative phylogenetic approach on 60 diverse eukaryotic species, which resulted in a revised and improved U4-/U6-snRNA secondary structure. This general model is supported by observation of abundant compensatory base mutations in every stem, and incorporates more of the nucleotides into base-paired associations than in previous models, thus being more energetically stable. We have extensively sampled the eukaryotic phylogenetic tree to its deepest roots, but did not find genes potentially encoding either U4- or U6-snRNA in the Giardia and Trichomonas data-bases. Our results support the hypothesis that nuclear introns in these most deeply rooted eukaryotes may represent evolutionary intermediates, sharing characteristics of both group II and spliceosomal introns. An unexpected result of this study was discovery of a potential competitive binding site for Drosophila splicing assembly factor RNP-4F to a 5’-UTR regulatory region within its own premRNA, which may play a role in negative feedback control.

In vitro reconstitution of yeast splicing with U4 snRNA reveals multiple roles for the 3' stem-loop

U4 small nuclear RNA (snRNA) plays a fundamental role in the process of premessenger RNA splicing, yet many questions remain regarding the location, interactions, and roles of its functional domains. To address some of these questions, we developed the first in vitro reconstitution system for yeast U4 small nuclear ribonucleoproteins (snRNPs). We used this system to examine the functional domains of U4 by measuring reconstitution of splicing, U4/U6 base-pairing, and triple-snRNP formation. In contrast to previous work in human extracts and Xenopus oocytes, we found that the 3' stem-loop of U4 is necessary for efficient base-pairing with U6. In particular, the loop is sensitive to changes in both length and sequence. Intriguingly, a number of mutations that we tested resulted in more stable interactions with U6 than wild-type U4. Nevertheless, each of these mutants was impaired in its ability to support splicing, indicating that these regions of U4 have functions subsequent to base pair formation with U6. Our data suggest that one such function is likely to be in tri-snRNP formation, when U5 joins the U4/U6 di-snRNP. We have identified two regions, the upper stem of the 3' stem-loop and the central domain, that promote tri-snRNP formation. In addition, the loop of the 3' stem-loop promotes di-snRNP formation, while the central domain and the 3'-terminal domain appear to antagonize di-snRNP formation.

Functional characterization of spliceosomal introns and identification of U2, U4, and U5 snRNAs in the deep-branching eukaryote Entamoeba histolytica

Pre-mRNA splicing is essential to ensure accurate expression of many genes in eukaryotic organisms. In Entamoeba histolytica, a deep-branching eukaryote, approximately 30% of the annotated genes are predicted to contain introns; however, the accuracy of these predictions has not been tested. In this study, we mined an expressed sequence tag (EST) library representing 7% of amoebic genes and found evidence supporting splicing of 60% of the testable intron predictions, the majority of which contain a GUUUGU 5' splice site and a UAG 3' splice site. Additionally, we identified several splice site misannotations, evidence for the existence of 30 novel introns in previously annotated genes, and identified novel genes through uncovering their spliced ESTs. Finally, we provided molecular evidence for the E. histolytica U2, U4, and U5 snRNAs. These data lay the foundation for further dissection of the role of RNA processing in E. histolytica gene expression.

Identification of the major spliceosomal RNAs in Dictyostelium discoideum reveals developmentally regulated U2 variants and polyadenylated snRNAs

Most eukaryotic mRNAs depend upon precise removal of introns by the spliceosome, a complex of RNAs and proteins. Splicing of pre-mRNA is known to take place in Dictyostelium discoideum, and we previously isolated the U2 spliceosomal RNA experimentally. In this study, we identified the remaining major spliceosomal RNAs in Dictyostelium by a bioinformatical approach. Expression was verified from 17 small nuclear RNA (snRNA) genes. All these genes are preceded by a putative noncoding RNA gene promoter. Immunoprecipitation showed that snRNAs U1, U2, U4, and U5, but not U6, carry the conserved trimethylated 5' cap structure. A number of divergent U2 species are expressed in Dictyostelium. These RNAs carry the U2 RNA hallmark sequence and structure motifs but have an additional predicted stem-loop structure at the 5' end. Surprisingly, and in contrast to the other spliceosomal RNAs in this study, the new U2 variants were enriched in the cytoplasm and were developmentally regulated. Furthermore, all of the snRNAs could also be detected as polyadenylated species, and polyadenylated U1 RNA was demonstrated to be located in the cytoplasm.

RNA structural requirements for the association of the spliceosomal hPrp31 protein with the U4 and U4atac small nuclear ribonucleoproteins

The kink-turn, a stem I-internal loop-stem II structure of the 5 ' stem-loop of U4 and U4atac small nuclear (sn) RNAs bound by 15.5K protein is required for binding of human Prp31 protein (hPrp31) during U4 and U4atac snRNP assembly. In box C/D snoRNPs a similar kink-turn with bound 15.5K protein is required for selective binding of proteins NOP56 and NOP58. Here we analyzed RNA structural requirements for association of hPrp31 with U4 snRNP in vitro by hydroxyl radical footprinting. hPrp31 induced protection of the terminal penta-loop, as well as of stems I and II flanking the kink-turn. Similar protection was found with U4/U6 snRNA duplex prebound with 15.5K protein. A detailed mutational analysis of the U4 snRNA elements by electrophoretic mobility shift analysis revealed that stem I could not be shortened, although it tolerated sequence alterations. However, introduction of a third Watson-Crick base pair into stem II significantly reduced hPrp31 binding. While stem I of U4atac snRNA showed relaxed binding requirements, its stem II requirements were likewise restricted to two base pairs. In contrast, as shown previously, stem II of the kink-turn motif in box C/D snoRNAs is comprised of three base pairs, and NOP56 and NOP58 require a G-C pair at the central position. This indicates that hPrp31 binding specificity is achieved by the recognition of the two base pair long stem II of the U4 and U4atac snRNAs and suggests how discrimination is achieved by RNA structural elements during assembly of U4/U6 and U4atac/U6atac snRNPs and box C/D snoRNPs.

Multiple functions for the invariant AGC triad of U6 snRNA

The invariant AGC triad of U6 snRNA plays an essential, unknown role in splicing. The triad has been implicated in base-pairing with residues in U2, U4, and U6. Through a genetic analysis in S. cerevisiae, we found that most AGC mutants are suppressed both by restoring pairing with U2, supporting the significance of U2/U6 helix Ib, and by destabilizing U2 stem I, indicating that this stem regulates helix Ib formation. Intriguingly, one of the helix Ib base pairs is required specifically for exon ligation, raising the possibility that the entirety of helix Ib is required only for exon ligation. We also found that U4 mutations that reduce complementarity in U4 stem I enhance U2-mediated suppression of an AGC mutant, suggesting that U4 stem I competes with the AGC-containing U4/U6 stem I. Implicating an additional, essential function for the triad, three triad mutants are refractory to suppression--even by simultaneous restoration of pairing with U2, U4, and U6. An absolute requirement for a purine at the central position of the triad parallels an equivalent requirement in a catalytically important AGC triad in group II introns, consistent with a role for the AGC triad of U6 in catalysis.

U4 small nuclear RNA genes of trypanosomes: cloning of the Leptomonas seymouri gene and mutational analysis of core snRNP assembly

Trans mRNA splicing in trypanosomatids requires as cofactors small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs) U2, U4, U5, and U6, in addition to the spliced leader (SL) RNA. To allow a phylogenetic comparison and functional analysis of trypanosomatid U4 snRNAs, we have cloned the single-copy gene for the Leptomonas seymouri U4 snRNA. In addition, a putative U4 snRNA gene from Leishmania tarentolae was identified by database searching. Using an episomal expression system, we introduced mutations into the conserved Sm region of the L. seymouri U4, which is the putative binding site for the common proteins that are present in each of the trans-spliceosomal snRNPs. As demonstrated by CsCl density gradient centrifugation, Sm mutant U4 snRNAs are non-functional in core RNP assembly. Furthermore, we present evidence by cell fractionation that U4 snRNAs with Sm mutations are partially defective in nuclear-cytoplasmic translocation. Taken together this indicates that the Sm site of U4 snRNA is responsible for stable core RNP assembly and nuclear localization.

The trans-spliceosomal U4 RNA from the monogenetic trypanosomatid Leptomonas collosoma. Cloning and identification of a transcribed trna-like element that controls its expression

U4 small nuclear RNA is essential for trans-splicing. Here we report the cloning of U4 snRNA gene from Leptomonas collosoma and analysis of elements controlling its expression. The trypanosome U4 RNA is the smallest known, it carries an Sm-like site, and has the potential for extensive intermolecular base pairing with the U6 RNA. Sequence analysis of the U4 locus indicates the presence of a tRNA-like element 86 base pairs upstream of the gene that is divergently transcribed to yield a stable small tRNA-like RNA. Two additional tRNA genes, tRNA(Pro) and tRNA(Gly), were found upstream of this element. By stable expression of a tagged U4 RNA, we demonstrate that the tRNA-like gene, but not the upstream tRNA genes, is essential for U4 expression and that the B box but not the A Box of the tRNA-like gene is crucial for expression in vivo. Mapping the 2'-O-methyl groups on U4 and U6 small nuclear RNAs suggests the presence of modifications in canonical positions. However, the number of modified nucleotides is fewer than in mammalian homologues. The U4 genomic organization including both tRNA-like and tRNA genes may represent a relic whereby trypanosomatids "hired" tRNA genes to provide extragenic promoter elements. The close proximity of tRNA genes to the tRNA-like molecule in the U4 locus further suggests that the tRNA-like gene may have evolved from a tRNA member of this cluster.

Chlamydomonas U2, U4 and U6 snRNAs. An evolutionary conserved putative third interaction between U4 and U6 snRNAs which has a counterpart in the U4atac-U6atac snRNA duplex

The spliceosomal UsnRNAs U2, U4 and U6 from the green alga Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (Cre) were sequenced using a combination of RNA and cDNA sequencing methods and were compared to other sequenced UsnRNAs. The lengths of Cre U6 and Cre U2 RNAs are similar to those of their higher plant equivalents. Cre U4 RNA is shorter (139 nt) than its counterpart from higher plants (150-154 nt), and contains stem IV and loop D which are absent, with the exception of the Tetrahymena U4 RNA, from the U4 RNAs of other unicellular organisms studied to date. Base-pairing interactions between U6 and U4 RNAs and between U6 and U2 RNAs, identical to those described for mammalian and yeast systems, are structurally feasible in the Cre system. In addition, based on comparative analyses of the predicted U4/U6 RNA duplex from various species, an evolutionary conserved third putative U6-U4 interaction was found. Interestingly, it can also be formed with the recently discovered U6atac and U4atac RNAs. This is a strong support in favor of the possible biological significance of this third putative interaction. Based on comparative analysis, an extension of the earlier described U6-U2 interaction patterns is also proposed.

Mutational analysis of Saccharomyces cerevisiae U4 small nuclear RNA identifies functionally important domains

U4 small nuclear RNA (snRNA) is essential for pre-mRNA splicing, although its role is not yet clear. On the basis of a model structure (C. Guthrie and B. Patterson, Annu. Rev. Genet. 22:387-419, 1988), the molecule can be thought of as having six domains: stem II, 5' stem-loop, stem I, central region, 3' stem-loop, and 3'-terminal region. We have carried out extensive mutagenesis of the yeast U4 snRNA gene (SNR14) and have obtained information on the effect of mutations at 105 of its 160 nucleotides. Fifteen critical residues in the U4 snRNA have been identified in four domains: stem II, the 5' stem-loop, stem I, and the 3'-terminal region. These domains have been shown previously to be insensitive to oligonucleotide-directed RNase H cleavage (Y. Xu, S. Petersen-Bjørn, and J. D. Friesen, Mol. Cell. Biol. 10:1217-1225, 1990), suggesting that they are involved in intra- or intermolecular interactions. Stem II, a region that base pairs with U6 snRNA, is the most sensitive to mutation of all U4 snRNA domains. In contrast, stem I is surprisingly insensitive to mutational change, which brings into question its role in base pairing with U6 snRNA. All mutations in the putative Sm site of U4 snRNA yield a lethal or conditional-lethal phenotype, indicating that this region is important functionally. Only two nucleotides in the 5' stem-loop are sensitive to mutation; most of this domain can tolerate point mutations or small deletions. The 3' stem-loop, while essential, is very tolerant of change. A large portion of the central domain can be removed or expanded with only minor effects on phenotype, suggesting that it has little function of its own. Analysis of conditional mutations in stem II and stem I indicates that although these single-base changes do not have a dramatic effect on U4 snRNA stability, they are defective in RNA splicing in vivo and in vitro, as well as in spliceosome assembly. These results are discussed in the context of current knowledge of the interactions involving U4 snRNA.

Phylogenetic conservation of modified nucleotides in the terminal loop 1 of the spliceosomal U5 snRNA

In order to study the phylogenetic conservation of modified nucleotides in the spliceosomal U5 snRNA, we determined the nucleotide sequences of the U5 snRNAs from the slime mold Physarum polycephalum (EMBL data bank accession numbers: X74440 and X74441) and we identified the pseudouridine and 2'-O-methylated residues. From a comparison of all the U5 snRNAs studied at the level of nucleotide modifications, we concluded that the modified nucleotides in U5 snRNA can be divided into three classes according to their degree of conservation: i) the modified nucleotides of the 5' terminal cap structure that display some variations from one species to the other; ii) the modified nucleotides located in the helical part of the stem/loop structure I that vary greatly in number, position and identity from one species to the other; and iii) the modified nucleotides of the terminal loop 1, that are almost identical in all the species studied. Taking into account the recent discovery of a crucial role played by this terminal loop of U5 snRNA in 5' and 3' splice site definition, we postulate that the numerous modified nucleotides it contains, five out of a total of 11, play an important role in spliceosome assembly and function. Their possible role is discussed.

Reconstitution of functional mammalian U4 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein: Sm protein binding is not essential for splicing in vitro

We have developed an in vitro splicing complementation assay to investigate the domain structure of the mammalian U4 small nuclear RNA (snRNA) through mutational analysis. The addition of affinity-purified U4 snRNP or U4 RNA to U4-depleted nuclear extract efficiently restores splicing activity. In the U4-U6 interaction domain of U4 RNA, only stem II was found to be essential for splicing activity; the 5' loop is important for spliceosome stability. In the central domain, we have identified a U4 RNA sequence element that is important for splicing and spliceosome assembly. Surprisingly, an intact Sm domain is not essential for splicing in vitro. Our data provide evidence that several distinct regions of U4 RNA contribute to snRNP assembly, spliceosome assembly and stability, and splicing activity.

Reconstitution of functional mammalian U4 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein: Sm protein binding is not essential for splicing in vitro

We have developed an in vitro splicing complementation assay to investigate the domain structure of the mammalian U4 small nuclear RNA (snRNA) through mutational analysis. The addition of affinity-purified U4 snRNP or U4 RNA to U4-depleted nuclear extract efficiently restores splicing activity. In the U4-U6 interaction domain of U4 RNA, only stem II was found to be essential for splicing activity; the 5' loop is important for spliceosome stability. In the central domain, we have identified a U4 RNA sequence element that is important for splicing and spliceosome assembly. Surprisingly, an intact Sm domain is not essential for splicing in vitro. Our data provide evidence that several distinct regions of U4 RNA contribute to snRNP assembly, spliceosome assembly and stability, and splicing activity.