The nature and origin of orientation specificity in neurons of the visual pathways

The effects of reversible inactivation of postero-temporal visual cortex on neuronal activities in cat's area 17

'Spontaneous' and visually evoked action potentials were recorded from single neurons in cytoarchitectonic area 17 (striate cortex, area V1) of anaesthetized and immobilized cats, prior to, during and after brief reversible inactivation of the ipsilateral postero-temporal visual (PTV) cortex (presumed homologue of primate inferotemporal cortex). Inactivation of PTV cortex resulted: 1) in significant changes in the response magnitude (mostly a reduction) to optimal and/or sub-optimal visual stimuli in over 55% of area 17 cells and 2) significant changes (usually a reduction) in the 'spontaneous' (background) activity of about two-thirds of the cells in which inactivation of PTV cortex significantly affected the magnitude of responses to optimal stimuli. In over 85% of the significantly affected area 17 cells, rewarming PTV cortex to normal temperature (36 degrees C) resulted in the recovery of both the magnitude of responses and the background activity to levels not significantly different from pre-inactivation levels. Irrespective of the significance of changes in the magnitude of responses, in a substantial proportion of area 17 cells, inactivation of PTV cortex resulted in changes in some receptive field characteristics. Thus, there were substantial (20% or more) changes in orientation tuning widths (in over a quarter of the sample) and/or direction selectivity indices (in about a third of the sample). Thus, the feedback signals originating from PTV cortex, like signals originating from some other 'higher-order' visual cortical areas exert a clear modulatory influence on the responsiveness, background activity and some receptive field properties of neurons in the ipsilateral area 17.

Spatial coding and response redundancy in parallel visual pathways of the marmoset Callithrix jacchus

Many neurons in the primary visual cortex (area V1) show pronounced selectivity for the orientation and spatial frequency of visual stimuli, whereas most neurons in subcortical afferent streams show little selectivity for these stimulus attributes. It has been suggested that this transformation is a functional sign of increased coding efficiency, whereby the redundancy (or overlap in response properties) is reduced at consecutive levels of visual processing. Here we compared experimentally the response redundancy in area V1 with that in the three main dorsal thalamic afferent streams, the parvocellular (PC), koniocellular (KC), and magnocellular (MC) divisions of the dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN) in marmosets. The spatial frequency and orientation tuning of single cells in the LGN and area V1 were measured, using luminance contrast sine-wave gratings. A joint spatial frequency-orientation response selectivity profile was calculated for each cell. Response redundancy for each population was estimated by cross-multiplication of the joint selectivity profiles for pairs of cells. We show that when estimated in this way, redundancy in LGN neurons is approximately double that of neurons in cortical area V1. However, there are differences between LGN subdivisions, such that the KC pathway has a spatial representation that lies between the redundant code of the PC and MC pathways and the more efficient sparse spatial code of area V1.

Emergence of orientation-selective inhibition in the primary visual cortex: a Bayes-Markov computational model

The recent consensus is that virtually all aspects of response selectivity exhibited by the primary visual cortex are either created or sharpened by cortical inhibitory interneurons. Experimental studies have shown that there are cortical inhibitory cells that are driven by geniculate cells and that, like their cortical excitatory counterparts, are orientation selective, though less sharply tuned. The main goal of this article is to demonstrate how orientation-selective inhibition might be created by the circuitry of the primary visual cortex (striate cortex, V1) from its nonoriented geniculate inputs. To fulfill this goal, first, a Bayes-Markov computational model is developed for the V1 area dedicated to foveal vision. The developed model consists of three parts: (i) a two-layered hierarchical Markov random field that is assumed to generate the activity patterns of the geniculate and cortical inhibitory cells, (ii) a Bayesian computational goal that is formulated based on the maximum a posteriori (MAP) estimation principle, and (iii) an iterative, deterministic, parallel algorithm that leads the cortical circuitry to achieve its assigned computational goal. The developed model is not fully LGN driven and it is not implementable by the neural machinery of V1. The model, then, is transformed into a fully LGN-driven and physiologically plausible form. Computer simulation is used to demonstrate the performance of the developed models.

Global motion detection is impaired in cats deprived early of pattern vision

We investigated global motion detection in binocularly deprived cats (BD cats) and control cats (C cats). The cats were trained in the two-choice free running apparatus for a food reward. The positive stimulus was a moving random-dot pattern with all dots moving in one direction, the negative stimulus was the same random-dot pattern but stationary. The BD cats were severely impaired in detection of global motion stimulus as compared with the C cats. In contrast, their level of performance in a simple relative motion detection task (one square) did not differ from that in the C cats. However, in more complex relative motion detection task (two squares) the performance of the BD cats was impaired. The deficit in the detection of global motion in BD cats may be due to impairments of their Y-pathway.

A novel mechanism of response selectivity of neurons in cat visual cortex

The spiking of cortical neurons critically depends on properties of the afferent stimuli. In the visual cortex, neurons respond selectively to the orientation and direction of movement of an object. The orientation and direction selectivity is improved upon transformation of the membrane potential changes into trains of action potentials. To address the question of whether the transformation of the membrane potential changes into spiking of a cell depends on the stimulus orientation and the direction of movement, we made intracellular recordings from the cat visual cortex in vivo during presentation of moving gratings of different orientations. We found that the relationship between the membrane polarization and the firing rate (input-output transfer function) depended on the stimulus orientation. The input-output transfer function was steepest during responses to the optimal stimulus; membrane depolarization of a given amplitude led to generation of more action potentials when evoked by an optimal stimulus than during non-optimal stimulation. The threshold for the action potential generation did not depend on stimulus orientation, and thus could not account for the observed difference in the transfer function. Oscillations of the membrane potential in the gamma-frequency range (25-70 Hz) were most pronounced during optimal stimulation and their strength changed in parallel with the changes in the transfer function, suggesting a possible relationship between the two parameters. We suggest that the improved input-output relationship of neurons during optimal stimulation represents a novel mechanism that may contribute to the final sharp orientation selectivity of spike responses in the cortical cells.

Neural field model of receptive field restructuring in primary visual cortex

Receptive fields (RF) in the visual cortex can change their size depending on the state of the individual. This reflects a changing visual resolution according to different demands on information processing during drowsiness. So far, however, the possible mechanisms that underlie these size changes have not been tested rigorously. Only qualitatively has it been suggested that state-dependent lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN) firing patterns (burst versus tonic firing) are mainly responsible for the observed cortical receptive field restructuring. Here, we employ a neural field approach to describe the changes of cortical RF properties analytically. Expressions to describe the spatiotemporal receptive fields are given for pure feedforward networks. The model predicts that visual latencies increase nonlinearly with the distance of the stimulus location from the RF center. RF restructuring effects are faithfully reproduced. Despite the changing RF sizes, the model demonstrates that the width of the spatial membrane potential profile (as measured by the variance sigma of a gaussian) remains constant in cortex. In contrast, it is shown for recurrent networks that both the RF width and the width of the membrane potential profile generically depend on time and can even increase if lateral cortical excitatory connections extend further than fibers from LGN to cortex. In order to differentiate between a feedforward and a recurrent mechanism causing the experimental RF changes, we fitted the data to the analytically derived point-spread functions. Results of the fits provide estimates for model parameters consistent with the literature data and support the hypothesis that the observed RF sharpening is indeed mainly driven by input from LGN, not by recurrent intracortical connections.

Temporal characteristics of line orientation identification

The hypothesis that identification of line orientation is based on different mechanisms--a detector mechanism at large orientation differences and a computational one at small orientation differences--was tested in three experiments. The first two experiments compared reaction time and time of complete temporal summation (tc) in two tasks, line detection and line orientation identification. Identification at orientation differences 15 degrees or more was similar to detection in several respects, suggesting that it was accomplished according to the principle of "labeled lines." In agreement with the initial hypothesis, identification at differences smaller than 15 degrees had a slower time course and could not be explained by the "labeled lines" principle. Experiment 3 explored the orientation acuity as a function of exposure duration and stimulus energy. Energy could not completely substitute for time in providing high orientation acuity, a result suggesting the involvement of neurophysiological mechanisms of large time constants.

Comparison of the selectivity of postsynaptic potentials and spike responses in cat visual cortex

Intracellular recordings were made from neurons in the cat visual cortex (area 17) to compare the orientation and direction selectivities of the output of a cell with those of the input the cell receives. The input to a cell was estimated from the PSPs (postsynaptic potentials) evoked by visual stimulation, and the output estimated from the number of spikes generated during the same responses. For the whole sample, selectivity of the output of cells was significantly higher than selectivity of their input. Upon PSP to spike transformation, the selectivity index was, on average, doubled. However, the degree of the selectivity improvement in individual cells was very different, varying from cases in which highly selective output was created from a poorly selective input and thus selectivity was greatly improved, to little or no improvement in other neurons. The improvement of selectivity was not correlated with resting membrane potential, threshold for action potential generation, background discharge rate or amplitude of optimal PSP response. Further, no systematic difference was found between simple and complex cells in the input-output relations, indicating that the 'tip of the iceberg' effect on shaping the response selectivity was cell specific, but not cell type specific. This supports the notion that multiple mechanisms are responsible for generation of the response selectivity, and that the contribution of any particular mechanism may vary from one cell to the other. The heterogeneity of the input-output relations in visual cortical cells could indicate different functions of cells in the cortical network; some cells are creating selectivity de novo, the function of other neurons probably being repetition and amplification of the selected signal and arrangement of the output of a whole column.

Feedback connections to the lateral geniculate nucleus and cortical response properties

The cerebral cortex receives sensory input from the periphery by means of thalamic relay nuclei, but the flow of information goes both ways. Each cortical area sends a reciprocal projection back to the thalamus. In the visual system, the synaptic relations that govern the influence of thalamic afferents on orientation selectivity in the cortex have been studied extensively. It now appears that the connectivity of the corticofugal feedback pathway is also fundamentally linked to the orientation preference of the cortical cells involved.

Matching the modules: cortical maps and long-range intrinsic connections in visual cortex during development

Visual cortical neurons exhibit a high degree of response selectivity and are grouped into small columns according to their response preferences. The columns are located at regularly spaced intervals covering the whole cortical representation of the visual field with a modular system of feature-selective neurons. The selectivity of these cells and their modular arrangement is thought to emerge from interactions in the network of specific intracortical and thalamocortical connections. Understanding the ontogenesis of this complex structure and contributions of intrinsic and extrinsic, experience-dependent mechanisms during cortical development can provide new insights into the way the visual cortex processes information about the environment. Available data about the development of connections and response properties in the visual cortex suggest that maturation proceeds in two distinct steps. In the first phase, mechanisms inherent to the cortex establish a crude framework of interconnected neural modules which exhibit the basic but still immature traits of the adult state. Relevant mechanisms in this phase are assumed to consist of molecular cues and patterns of spontaneous neural activity in cortical and corticothalamic interconnections. In a second phase, the primordial layout becomes refined under the control of visual experience establishing a fine-tuned network of connections and mature response properties.

Multiple groups of orientation-selective visual mechanisms underlying rapid orientated-line detection

Visual search for an edge or line element differing in orientation from a background of other edge or line elements can be performed rapidly and effortlessly. In this study, based on psychophysical measurements with ten human observers, threshold values of the angle between a target and background line elements were obtained as functions of background-element orientation, in brief masked displays. A repeated-loess analysis of the threshold functions suggested the existence of several groups of orientation-selective mechanisms contributing to rapid orientated-line detection; specifically, coarse, intermediate and fine mechanisms with preferred orientations spaced at angles of approximately 90 degrees, 35 degrees, and 10 degrees-25 degrees, respectively. The preferred orientations of coarse and some intermediate mechanisms coincided with the vertical or horizontal of the frontoparallel plane, but the preferred orientations of fine mechanisms varied randomly from observer to observer, possibly reflecting individual variations in neuronal sampling characteristics.

The layout of orientation and ocular dominance domains in area 17 of strabismic cats

In the primary visual cortex of strabismic cats, the elimination of correlated activity between the two eyes enhances the segregation of the geniculocortical afferents into alternating ocular dominance domains. In addition, both tangential intracortical fibres and neuronal synchronization are severely reduced between neurons activated by different eyes. Consequently, ocular dominance columns belonging to different eyes are functionally rather independent. We wondered whether this would also affect the organization of orientation preference maps. To this end, we visualized the functional architecture of area 17 of strabismic cats with both optical imaging based on intrinsic signals and double labelling of orientation and ocular dominance columns with [14C]2-deoxyglucose and [3H]proline. As expected, monocular iso-orientation domains had a patchy appearance and differed for the two eyes, leading to a clear segregation of the ocular dominance domains. Comparison of 'angle maps' revealed that orientation domains exhibit a pinwheel organization as in normally reared cats. Interestingly, the map of orientation preferences did not show any breaks at the borders between ocular dominance columns: iso-orientation domains were continuous across these borders. In addition, iso-orientation contours tended to cross the borders of adjacent ocular dominance columns at right angles. These data suggest that the basic relations between the layout of orientation maps and ocular dominance columns are not disturbed by artificial decorrelation of binocular input. Therefore in cat area 17, the orientation map does not seem to be modified by experience-dependent changes of thalamic input connections. This suggests the possibility that use-dependent rearrangement of geniculocortical afferents into ocular dominance columns is due to Hebbian modifications whereby postsynaptic responsivity is constrained by the scaffold of the orientation map.

A metabolic mapping study of orientation discrimination and detection tasks in the cat

Increasing evidence suggests that a large number of distinct cortical areas and associated subcortical structures participate in the processing of visual information and that different aspects of visual scenes are evaluated in different areas. This necessitates identification of cortical and subcortical regions cooperating in particular visual tasks. Using the 2-deoxyglucose technique, we monitored the differential activation of areas in the cat visual cortex participating in an orientation discrimination and a detection task. Concordant with previous lesion studies, we found increased activity levels in area 17 in the discrimination condition relative to the detection condition. In addition, the 2-deoxyglucose technique revealed discrimination-related increased activations in the claustrum, the putamen and in parts of the anteromedial, anterolateral and posterolateral lateral suprasylvian visual areas. Regions activated differentially with the detection task comprised subdivisions of areas 17, 18, 19 and 21, posterior area 7 (7p), several areas of the posterior part of the middle and posterior suprasylvian sulcus, the pulvinar complex and the superior colliculus. These results show that the 2-deoxyglucose technique is useful to investigate cognitive brain functions, and that different sets of cortical and subcortical regions are activated during two visual tasks with similar visual stimulation.

Excitatory convergence of Y and non-Y information channels on single neurons in the PMLS area, a motion area of the cat visual cortex

We analysed the receptive field properties of neurons in the posteromedial lateral suprasylvian (PMLS) visual cortical area of anaesthetized cats in which there was selective conduction block of the largest (Y-type) fibres in one optic nerve. As in normal cats, in cats with selective block of one optic nerve the great majority of PMLS cells could be activated by photic stimulation through either eye. However, the responses evoked by stimulation via the eye with the selectively pressure-blocked optic nerve ('Y-blocked eye') were significantly weaker than those of the same cells evoked by the stimulation via the normal eye. Accordingly, eye dominance histograms were shifted markedly in favour of the normal eye. Furthermore, there was a significant shift towards lower preferred velocities when PMLS cells were photically stimulated via the Y-blocked eye. Finally, when stimulated via the Y-blocked eye, PMLS cells responded poorly or not at all to high stimulus velocities (> or = 100 degrees/s). On the other hand, a number of receptive field properties, such as the spatial organization of receptive fields, the size of the discharge fields, orientation tuning and direction selectivity indices, were not significantly affected by the removal of the Y input. We conclude that virtually all neurons in the PMLS area of the cat receive excitatory input from both Y and non-Y information channels, although the Y channel provides the dominant input and makes the principal contribution to the detection of high-velocity motion.

A linear model fails to predict orientation selectivity of cells in the cat visual cortex

1. Postsynaptic potentials (PSPs) evoked by visual stimulation in simple cells in the cat visual cortex were recorded using in vivo whole-cell technique. Responses to small spots of light presented at different positions over the receptive field and responses to elongated bars of different orientations centred on the receptive field were recorded. 2. To test whether a linear model can account for orientation selectivity of cortical neurones, responses to elongated bars were compared with responses predicted by a linear model from the receptive field map obtained from flashing spots. 3. The linear model faithfully predicted the preferred orientation, but not the degree of orientation selectivity or the sharpness of orientation tuning. The ratio of optimal to non-optimal responses was always underestimated by the model. 4. Thus non-linear mechanisms, which can include suppression of non-optimal responses and/or amplification of optimal responses, are involved in the generation of orientation selectivity in the primary visual cortex.

Basic information processing and higher cognition: does the mammalian cerebral cortex deal with them at different hierarchical levels?

1. The primary visual cortex has been generally considered as a feature processing area where the neurons code for basic stimulus attributes, such as orientation, colour and direction of movement. Higher cognitive functions, such as attention and memory, were believed to be mediated by extrastriate regions at higher levels in a hierarchy of visual areas. However, the experiments reported here suggest that the function of the primary visual cortex is more than basic information processing in at least two respects. 2. First, significant modulation of visual responses occur in the primary visual cortex (V1) of the monkey depending upon attentional factors. There appears to be a feedback to V1 from extrastriate regions that facilitates neuronal responses in areas of attention and suppresses responses in other regions of the visual field. 3. Second, one would expect a region that is concerned with coding basic stimulus features to be rather resistant to plastic changes, as cells need to be reliable feature detectors for meaningful behaviour by the organism. However, the experiments on anaesthetized cats reported here show that a subset of neurons in visual area 17 of the cat have a potential for synaptic plasticity. Their response properties can undergo long-term changes under certain circumstances. To induce these changes, specific visual stimuli were combined with iontophoretic administration of NMDA and the GABA antagonist, bicuculline, which are believed to provide the molecular milieu for long-term potential and long-term depression.

Multiple mechanisms underlying the orientation selectivity of visual cortical neurones

For over three decades, the mechanism of orientation selectivity of visual cortical neurones has been hotly debated. While intracortical inhibition has been implicated as playing a vital role, it has been difficult to observe it clearly. On the basis of recent findings, we propose a model in which the visual cortex brings together a number of different mechanisms for generating orientation-selective responses. Orientation biases in the thalamo-cortical input fibres provide an initial weak selectivity either directly in the excitatory input or by acting via cortical interneurones. This weak selectivity of postsynaptic potentials is then amplified by voltage-sensitive conductances of the cell membrane and excitatory and inhibitory intracortical circuitry, resulting in the sharp tuning seen in the spike discharges of visual cortical cells.

Recurrent inhibition and clustered connectivity as a basis for Gabor-like receptive fields in the visual cortex

A continuous-space model of visual cortex interactions which, starting from elongate Gaussian functions, leads to high-selective Gabor-like receptive fields, is proposed. The model is based on intracortical inhibition mechanisms occurring through medium-range clustered connections. The analysis, carried out under the assumption of a linear superposition of geniculate and intracortical contributions, shows how inhibition enhances both spatial and spatial-frequency selectivity. The effects of inhibition strength and of its spatial organization on the properties of the resulting receptive field are investigated. Specifically, the relationships between receptive fields and inhibition schemes are investigated by deriving analytical expressions for their dependence and through a systematic numerical parametric study. The emergence of periodic receptive fields, like the ones observed in neurophysiological measurements, is also pointed out in relation to the clustered nature of the inhibitory scheme.

Vernier acuity during image rotation and translation: visual performance limits

Our capacity to detect spatial misalignments a fraction of the distance between retinal receptors in the presence of image motion challenges our understanding of spatial vision. We find that vernier acuity, while robust to image translation, rapidly degrades during image rotation. This indicates that orientation is a critical cue utilized by the visual system in vernier acuity tasks. Moreover, vernier acuity is robust to translational motion only at high target strengths. Vernier acuity for translating 3-dot targets over midrange velocities can be predicted from vernier acuity data derived from static targets of different presentation durations. However, the degradation observed at higher velocities is greater than predicted. The high velocity degradation reveals that performance is limited by a 1 msec asynchrony sensitivity. The moving vernier stimulus appears to constitute an optimal configuration for the visual system to achieve a 1 msec asynchrony sensitivity by making use of an orientation cue.