An alternative to the magic bullet paradigm for specific cancer therapy

Gene therapy in clinical medicine

Although the field of gene therapy has experienced significant setbacks and limited success, it is one of the most promising and active research fields in medicine. Interest in this therapeutic modality is based on the potential for treatment and cure of some of the most malignant and devastating diseases affecting humans. Over the next decade, the relevance of gene therapy to medical practices will increase and it will become important for physicians to understand the basic principles and strategies that underlie the therapeutic intervention. This report reviews the history, basic strategies, tools, and several current clinical paradigms for application.

Regional versus systemic delivery of recombinant vaccinia virus as suicide gene therapy for murine liver metastases

OBJECTIVE

Specific and efficient tumor-targeted gene delivery is the major goal for successful cancer gene therapy.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

A recombinant thymidine kinase-deleted vaccinia virus (vv) encoding the firefly luciferase (luc) reporter gene or the prodrug converter gene cytosine deaminase (CD) was constructed. The authors compared the extent, duration, and pattern of transgene (luc) expression in vivo after portal venous, intraperitoneal, or intravenous virus administration and survival after treatment with the vv containing CD followed by the prodrug 5-fluorocytosine (5-FC) in a murine model of disseminated liver metastases from colon cancer.

METHODS

Recombinant vv containing the luc transgene within the thymidine kinase locus was administered to mice with isolated liver metastases from an MC38 adenocarcinoma. Transgene expression was determined in tumor and organs at various time points. Tumor-bearing mice were treated with recombinant vv containing CD and 5-FC or with appropriate controls and followed for survival.

RESULTS

Tumor-specific gene delivery was achieved irrespective of administration route, with gene expression in tumors increased by up to 100,000-fold compared with normal tissues. There was significantly increased transgene expression in tumor after portal venous or intraperitoneal virus administration (p = 0.001 vs. systemic). Treatment using a CD-expressing vv and systemic 5-FC resulted in a significant survival benefit in all treatment groups compared with controls (p < 0.007); there was no additional benefit for portal venous or intraperitoneal virus administration.

CONCLUSIONS

Suicide gene therapy using vv with the CD/5-FC system leads to tumor-specific gene expression and improved survival and can result in cure of established liver metastases.

Virus-directed enzyme/prodrug therapy (VDEPT). Selectively engineering drug sensitivity into tumors

A gene therapy approach has been described that generates a tumor-selective qualitative difference in the metabolic capability in tumor cells. This is the result of the selective expression of a nonmammalian enzyme in tumor cells. Selective expression is achieved by utilization of a chimeric gene composed of the TRS from a tumor-associated marker gene linked to the coding domain of a gene encoding a nonmammalian enzyme. We have described the application of this approach for the treatment of metastatic CRC. This approach involves creation of a chimeric gene composed of the CEA TRS linked to the coding domain of the CD gene. Selective expression of CD in the tumor cells will allow the selective conversion of the prodrug 5-FCyt to 5-FCyt in the tumor while sparing normal cells. Most importantly, delivery and expression of CD into a small fraction of tumor cells may be sufficient to achieve a significant antitumor effect.