Preliminary report of a cooperative randomized study for the treatment of localized small cell lung carcinoma

Mouse hemithoracic irradiation and its interaction with cytotoxic drugs

Irradiation of the mouse right or left hemithorax at 14 or 18 Gy produced a dose-dependent rise in breathing rate 16 weeks after irradiation without significant mortality. The measurement of breathing rate changes following right hemithoracic irradiation combined with the maximally tolerated dose of cytotoxic drugs was assessed as a method for qualitatively detecting drug-irradiation interactions which either exacerbate pneumonitis or alter its time course. Cyclophosphamide at 100 mg/kg accentuated and accelerated the rise in breathing rate, culminating in early mortality. BCNU 30 mg/kg delayed the appearance of the radiation response. Busulphan 30 mg/kg appeared to be radioprotective, but this was shown to be due to the DMSO-containing vehicle. Doxorubicin 6 mg/kg had no effect when combined with right or left hemithoracic irradiation. Carboplatin 100 mg/kg, vindesine 4 mg/kg and vinblastine 4 mg/kg had no substantial effect upon the changes in breathing rate.

A randomized study of radiation treatment in small cell bronchial carcinoma treated with two types of four-drug chemotherapy regimens

Of an unselected series of 133 patients with small cell bronchial carcinoma, 110 patients (54 with extensive disease and 56 with limited disease) were randomly allocated to receive either chemotherapy with cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, vincristine, and methotrexate, alternating after four cycles with cyclophosphamide, lomustine, vincristine, and methotrexate, or the same chemotherapy combinations together with irradiation at 40 Gy to the primary tumor area and the adjacent mediastinum. In patients with extensive disease the total response rates were 70% and 86% and the median survival 7.6 and 9.2 months, respectively. There were no long-term survivors, and no advantage was gained from radiation combination treatment. The results confirm previously reported findings. In limited disease the complete remission rates were 68% and 64%, the partial remission rates 26% and 28%, and the median survival was 14.8 and 15.4 months, respectively. There were no statistically significant differences favoring either treatment regimen. The disease-free survival exceeding 2 years in the two respective groups was 6.5% and 25%; this difference was not statistically significant. A slight advantage of combined radiation and chemotherapy in the direction of better long-term survival was confirmed by the 4-year disease-free survival rate of 12% as compared with 0% in the nonirradiation group. This difference was statistically significant. There was considerable toxicity with both treatment regimens. The addition of radiation treatment to the chemotherapy most likely benefits patients with limited disease. The overall median survival of all the unselected 133 patients (nonrandomized included) was 10.3 months, and the cure rate was 3%.

Simultaneous chemotherapy-radiotherapy with prophylactic cranial irradiation for inoperable adeno and large cell lung carcinoma: a Southwest Oncology Group Study

From September 1980 to March 1983, 30 cases were registered in a Southwest Oncology Group Study. Twenty-four cases were evaluable and constitute the basis for this report. Patients were diagnosed with adenocarcinoma or large cell lung carcinoma. Tumors were considered inoperable but able to be encompassed in a single radiotherapy (RT) port. Seventy-two percent of measured tumors were 4 cm in diameter or bigger (range 2 cm to 10 cm). RT was given initially to the primary lung tumor and ipsilateral hilar, mediastinal, and supraclavicular nodes, at 2 Gy per day; total dose was 44 Gy. The areas involved by tumor were boosted with 10 Gy more. Prophylactic cranial irradiation (PCI) was started at the same time with 15 treatments of 2.75 Gy. A 2-week rest period was instituted after the first 11 treatments. Chemotherapy (CT) was given from day 1 which consisted of 5-Flourouracil, 500 mg./M2, (bolus day 1 and 8) Vincristine, 1 mg./M2, and Mitomycin C, 5 mg./M2 both given on day 1. Cycles were repeated at 28 day intervals for 3 cycles and at 6 week intervals for 5 more cycles, or until progression, with persistent disease. Eight cases (33%) achieved complete response (CR), and 5 (21%) partial response (PR). Overall median survival was 37 weeks and 2 years survival was 8%. CR patients had the best chance for long-term survival. Relapses were evenly distributed between extra and intrathoracic sites, with the latter even between the inside and outside the RT field. No patient died with clinical evidence of metastasis to the brain (MB), although one was found to have MB at autopsy. Toxicity was severe in 7 cases (29%) and 2 deaths are considered toxicity related. When comparing these results to those from the literature, we found this protocol has achieved a slightly higher CR rate than what is expected with RT alone, without survival improvement. As CR patients have the best prognosis, simultaneous CT-RT might offer some promise, but at the expense of increased toxicity. PCI was effective in preventing or delaying MB, and thus deserves further investigation. We should caution that the study of possible long-term effects of PCI could not be assessed because of the short median survival of the patients. It is possible that a less aggressive time-dose fractionation to the brain might be as effective as the one used in this protocol.

Outcome of prophylactic and therapeutic cranial irradiation in disseminated small cell lung carcinoma: a Southwest Oncology Group Study

The issue whether cranial radiotherapy (RT) should be used prophylactically (PCI) or therapeutically (TCI) in small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) is considered controversial by some oncologists. Trying to clarify this issue we have performed a retrospective analysis of a Southwest Oncology Group (SWOG) protocol for disseminated SCLC. Three Hundred and seventy-seven cases had no evidence of metastases to the brain (MB). One hundred and forty four of those had PCI. Seventy one cases were diagnosed of MB, and 64 received TCI. We confirmed previous reports showing a low percentage of brain relapse with PCI (around 5%), with minimal immediate morbidity. We also confirmed a high percentage of objective response (90%) with TCI, (although we had no response information in 40% of them) with long duration of response of 33 weeks. Brain relapse after TCI was only 18%. Only long-term survivors had brain relapse as survival of relapsing patients was longer than those without brain relapse (45 weeks versus 33 weeks, p = 0.06). However, 20 (31%) of the 65 with initial MB died within 6 weeks of registration, some without completing RT to brain. In the majority, cause of death was considered related directly to brain damage, or indirectly as sepsis developed in patients whose poor performance status was considered to be caused by their brain symptoms. When comparing patients with and without MB, the former had (a) worse survival (24 versus 32 weeks, p = 0.02) and (b) higher proportion of patients with poor initial performance status (50% versus 34%, p = 0.04). Although the possibility of long-term morbidity with PCI is deterring some oncologists from recommending it, our data show that MB creates a real chance for immediate morbidity and this should not be ignored. The pros and cons of both approaches and some new recommendations for PCI are discussed.

The role of radiation therapy in the treatment of small cell lung cancer

Patients with small cell lung cancer (SCLC) are candidates for aggressive therapy because of their potential for long-term survival, especially patients with limited-stage disease. Although no treatment protocol can be considered "standard", the best results in limited-stage SCLC appear to be produced by a combination of chemotherapy and thoracic irradiation. Ongoing protocols testing the efficacy of thoracic irradiation should be able to settle question of the optimal treatment approach in limited-stage SCLC over the next 1 to 2 years. Careful attention to volume treated and the use of shrinking fields produce the best results with the minimum of toxicity. Treatment of extensive-stage SCLC has not been substantially improved to date with the addition of local or systemic irradiation. Prophylactic cranial irradiation reduces the incidence of CNS failure in SCLC and should be given, at a minimum, to patients achieving complete response status. Whether patients with partial response should also receive prophylactic cranial irradiation remains controversial. Finally, half-body radiation in SCLC is an experimental research technique that has shown some promise but remains quite toxic when combined with systemic chemotherapy.

Esophageal complications from combined chemoradiotherapy (cyclophosphamide + Adriamycin + cisplatin + XRT) in the treatment of non-small cell lung cancer

Esophageal complications from combined chemoradiotherapy (CCRT) were analyzed in 55 patients with limited non-small cell lung cancer. CCRT consisted of chemotherapy (cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin (Adriamycin), and cisplatin: CAP) and chest irradiation (5000 rad in 25 fractions/5 weeks). Forty-five patients received two courses of CAP, followed by five weekly courses of low dose CAP and irradiation followed by maintenance courses of CAP (Group 1). Ten patients received concomitant CCRT from the onset of treatment (Group 2). Esophagitis occurred in 80% of all patients. Severe esophagitis occurred in 27% of patients of Group 1 and 40% of patients of Group 2. Esophageal stricture or fistula developed in 1 of 45 (2%) patients in Group 1, and 3 of 10 (30%) patients in Group 2 (p less than 0.025). Weekly low-dose chemotherapy administered concomitantly with chest irradiation (R) at the onset of treatment significantly increases esophageal complications. A review of the literature suggests that CCRT may be used safely with split courses of R. The duration between onset of chemotherapy either before or after R should be greater than one week.

New frontiers in the treatment of lung cancer

Surgical resection still is the only significant curative approach in nonsmall cell lung cancer. Recent surgical experience indicates that a modest decrease in the death rate from bronchogenic carcinoma may occur in three general areas: (1) the detection and treatment of radiographically occult squamous cell carcinoma; (2) the combination of adjuvant chemotherapy and surgical excision in selected patients with small cell carcinoma; and (3) surgical resection and postop irradiation of patients with hilar and mediastinal lymph node metastases. At the time of diagnosis, 80 to 85% of the patients present with unresectable lung cancer. These patients may benefit from other modalities of therapy, i.e., radiotherapy, chemotherapy, or immunotherapy. Failures following radiotherapy in unresectable nonsmall cell lung cancer are due to (1) distant metastasis, (2) local region failure, and (3) local and distant failure. To increase the local control, new methods of treatment have been tried, such as hyperfractionation of radiotherapy and the use of 131I antiferritin immunoglobulin. The development of effective systemic chemotherapy is necessary to treat metastatic bronchogenic carcinoma. The response rate to chemotherapeutic agents is substantially lower in nonsmall cell carcinoma than in small cell carcinoma. Investigation is ongoing to assess the effectiveness of new antitumor drugs used alone, in combination with other drugs, or combined with other modalities for the treatment of bronchogenic carcinoma.

Combined modality treatment of regional small cell undifferentiated carcinoma of the lung: a cooperative study of the RTOG and ECOG

Between 1975 and 1979, 271 patients with regional small cell undifferentiated (including oat cell) carcinoma of the lung were entered into a study involving treatment by radiation therapy (4500 cGy (rad) in five weeks) to the primary tumor, mediastinum and supraclavicular lymph nodes, and a randomization to receive or not receive prophylactic treatment of the brain (3000 cGy in two weeks) and a randomization to prophylactic or delayed chemotherapy (cyclophosphamide and CCNU). Analysis of the data indicates that the median survival for responders (53 weeks) was significantly longer than that of the non-responders and partial responders (37 and 34 weeks). Median survival by treatment arm was 48 weeks for thoracic irradiation (TI), brain irradiation (BI), and early chemotherapy (CT), 44 weeks for TI alone, 41 weeks for TI and CT, 38 weeks for TI and BI. Regional complete and partial tumor responses were 52 and 25% for prophylactic chemotherapy and 44 and 35% for delayed chemotherapy. The site of first failure was regional in 12%, regional and distant simultaneously in 21%, and distant only in 46%. Elective brain irradiation significantly reduced the incidence of brain metastases from 21 and 5%, but did not improve survival.

Patterns of failure in small cell carcinoma of the lung

The initial sites and frequencies of disease progression in 97 patients with small cell carcinoma of the lung treated in a Northern California Oncology protocol were analyzed. Among the extensive disease complete responders (25 patients), the chest was the most frequent initial relapse site (18 patients), followed by the liver (nine patients) and bone (six patients). For those patients who had a partial or no response to treatment, the chest was the most frequent site of persistent disease and the majority progressed in the chest initially. The addition of chest irradiation (5000 rad/5 weeks) to patients with limited disease significantly reduced the incidence of relapse (25%) and prolonged the disease-free interval in the chest in the complete responders, but did not affect the failure pattern in partial and nonresponders. All patients received prophylactic cranial irradiation and three limited disease patients (10%) and three extensive disease patients (4%) progressed in the brain.

Influence of chest radiotherapy in frequency and patterns of chest relapse in disseminated small cell lung carcinoma. A Southwest Oncology Group Study

The value of radiotherapy to the chest (RC) in disseminated small cell lung carcinoma (SCLC) has been questioned. Two protocols for disseminated SCLC from the Southwest Oncology Group (SWOG) have been compared. They were developed four years apart. The first one included radiotherapy (RT), 3000 rad in two weeks, to the primary tumor, mediastinum and supraclavicular areas, while the second one deleted any RC. Multidrug chemotherapy (CT) and brain RT were used in both protocols. Nonresponders to CT were removed from the study. Our main findings are as follows: (1) Initial chest relapses (patients with no initial extrathoracic relapse) have increased from 24-55% when RC is not given (P = 0.0001). Overall chest relapse (adding those patients that relapsed simultaneously in the chest plus other sites) in the second protocol was 73%. (2) Amount of response to CT does not influence the chances for relapse. Even complete responders to CT have a high chance for chest relapse. (3) Sites of relapse without RC are mainly in the primary tumor, ipsilateral hilus and mediastinum. (4) With RC, relapses shift to the chest periphery, mostly to the lung outside the radiotherapy field and to the pleura. (5) The two very different CT regimens have produced similar percentages and duration of response. (6) CT schema with periodic reinductions prolongs duration of response and survival over schema with continuous maintenance. Hence, interruption of CT to allow RC does not seem to adversely influence CT efficacy. From our results and the review of the literature we conclude that: (1) patients with disseminated SCLC that respond to CT should be given RC to decrease chest relapses. (2) A dose of 3000 rad in two weeks seems to be enough to produce a low percentage of chest relapse in disseminated SCLC, as survival of these patients is short and many will die prior to developing chest relapse. However, according to the literature, 4000-4800 rad is probably a more effective dose. (3) More studies and guidelines are needed to outline proper boundaries of radiotherapy fields, to decrease chances of peripheral chest relapses. (4) Median survival might not be a good parameter to evaluate the impact of RC in disseminated SCLC. The study of long-term survivors seems to be more important.

The influence of radiation therapy quality control on survival, response and sites of relapse in oat cell carcinoma of the lung: preliminary report of a Southwest Oncology Group study

Two hundred and ninety-eight patients with limited (confined to chest and supraclavicular area, encompassable by a single radiation portal) small cell carcinoma of the lung were entered on Southwest Oncology Group Protocol 7628. Patients were treated with multi-agent chemotherapy and radiation therapy with or without BCG. Radiation therapy quality control analysis, including dosimetric reconstruction and port film review was introduced after the protocol was activated and was retrospectively applied. Patients who were considered major protocol variations had statistically worse survival (40 weeks versus 60 weeks; P = .002), a lesser improvement in response rate after induction chemotherapy (27 versus 48%; P = .05) and a higher chest failure rate (77 versus 55%; P = .047) than evaluable patients. Five patients relapsed in the brain, all associated with chest failure. Quality control is essential in cooperative group studies.

The role of thoracic and cranial irradiation for small cell carcinoma of the lung

Since 1974, 120 previously untreated patients with small cell carcinoma of the lung seen in Therapeutic Radiology at The Medical College of Wisconsin have been entered into one of 4 successive studies. Study I used thoracic irradiation (TI) alone (4500-6000 rad in 3-6 weeks) with chemotherapy at progression. Study II randomized patients with limited disease to TI (3000 rad in 2 weeks) plus either cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, vincristine (CAV) or total body irradiation (TBI); patients with extensive disease received TI + CAV. Study III employed prophylactic cranial irradiation (PCI) plus CAV and withheld TI unless there was incomplete response or recurrence. Of 93 evaluable patients from the first three studies, 55 had limited and 38 extensive disease. Study I (37 patients) showed a 62% complete response (CR) rate; 43% failed in the chest, 14% had brain metastases, and the median survival was only 22 weeks in spite of a preponderance of limited disease patients. Study II (27 patients) showed a CR of 59%; 30% had brain metastases and the median survival was 48 weeks. Study II patients (29) had a 69% rate; 72% failed in the chest, 4% with PCI developed brain metastases, and the median survival was 50 weeks. In March, 1979, Study IV was initiated; patients receive PCI (2500 rad in 2 weeks) plus high dose CAV, methotrexate and leucovorin. After 6 cycles, consolidation TI (3750 rad in 3 weeks) is given to patients with complete response. Preliminary results with 27 patients treated on this study show a 67% CR rate, a 41% chest failure rate (but only 11% for the patients who received thoracic irradiation) and no intracranial failures, but a 13% extracranial CNS failure rate. PCI, TI and spinal irradiation may be necessary to maximize the probability of long term disease free survival.

Thoracic and elective brain irradiation with concomitant or delayed multiagent chemotherapy in the treatment of localized small cell carcinoma of the lung: a randomized prospective study by the Southeastern Cancer Study Group

A prospective randomized study was carried out to compare the effectiveness of concomitant or delayed multiagent chemotherapy combined with irradiation to the primary tumor and regional lymph nodes and to the brain in a group of 70 patients with histologically proven small cell undifferentiated carcinoma of the lung. Complete and partial response in both groups was comparable, and the overall survival was comparable. However, relapse-free survival was significantly higher in patients receiving concomitant chemotherapy and irradiation in comparison with the radiotherapy alone group. Disease-free survival was higher in the concomitant chemotherapy-radiotherapy patients, although survival was not significantly modified, probably because of suboptimal chemotherapy. The initial intrathoracic failure rate was 40.7% inthe concomitant chemotherapy-irradiation group, compared with 53.8% in the radiotherapy-alone patients. None of the patients receiving delayed chemotherapy following the radiotherapy recurrence showed significant tumor response to the drugs. The incidence of distant metastasis was slightly lower in the chemotherapy groups. Brain metastases were noted in 7% of the patients in both groups. Increased intrathoracic recurrences were noted in patients with lower doses of irradiation. Nine of 13 patients treated with inadequate portals developed intrathoracic recurrences in comparison to 13 of 40 treated with adequate irradiation fields. The study emphasizes the need for intensive chemotherapy and adequate radiation therapy to improve survival of patients with small cell undifferentiated carcinoma of the lung. Additional trials are necessary to assess the role of each modality in the management of these patients.