Computed tomography in planning radiation therapy

Applications of simulator computed tomography number for photon dose calculations during radiotherapy treatment planning

PURPOSE

To study the variation of computed tomography (CT) number from a simulator-based scanner and the effect of this variation on photon-dose calculations.

METHOD AND MATERIALS

CT images of a cylindrical phantom with multiple inserts were obtained using a commercially-available simulator-CT (Ximatron: Varian, Palo Alto, CA). The linear correlation coefficient and Chi-square methods were used to determine the X-ray effective energy in a phantom. CT numbers in Hounsfield units (HU) were measured as a function of phantom size, orientation, field of view (FOV), distance from the center, and time for various inserts. The change of dose calculations due to the CT number variations was then determined using the equivalent path-length (EPL) and collapsed cone convolution methods.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

A significant beam-hardening effect was observed for the simulator-CT. Consequently, the CT number from the sim-CT was more sensitive to the size of the phantom than those from a conventional CT. The sim-CT number is not sensitive to the locations within the phantom and is stable over a 6-week period. It is important to use the proper FOV for sim-CT studies; scanning a small polystyrene phantom using a large FOV may result in an increase of l20 HU in CT number at the center of the field. However, the dose-calculation variations, due to the CT number uncertainty, do not exceed 2-3% for 6-18 MV photon beams.

CONCLUSION

The simulator CT images were acquired with patients in the treatment position, and these CT numbers are useful for CT-based dose calculations.

Volumetric visualization of head and neck CT data for treatment planning

PURPOSE

To demonstrate the utility of volume rendering, an alternative visualization technique to surface rendering, in the practice of CT based radiotherapy planning for the head and neck.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Rendo-avs, a volume visualization tool developed at the University of Chicago, was used to volume render head and neck CT scans from two cases. Rendo-avs is a volume rendering tool operating within the graphical user interface environment of AVS (Application Visualization System). Users adjust the opacity of various tissues by defining the opacity transfer function (OTF), a function which preclassifies voxels by opacity prior to rendering. By defining the opacity map (OTF), the user selectively enhances and suppresses structures of various intensity. Additional graphics tools are available within the AVS network, allowing for the manipulation of perspective, field of view, data orientation. Users may draw directly on volume rendered images, create a partial surface, and thereby correlate objects in the 3D scene to points on original axial slices. Information in volume rendered images is mapped into the original CT slices via a Z buffer, which contains the depth information (Z coordinate) for each pixel in the rendered view. Locally developed software was used to project conventionally designed GTV contours onto volume rendered images.

RESULTS

The lymph nodes, salivary glands, vessels, and airway are visualized in detail without prior manual segmentation. Volume rendering can be used to explore the finer anatomic structures that appear on consecutive axial slices as "points." Rendo-avs allowed for acceptable interactivity, with a processing time of approximately 5 seconds per 256 x 256 pixel output image.

CONCLUSIONS

Volume rendering is a useful alternative to surface rendering, offering high-quality visualization, 3D anatomic delineation, and time savings to the user, due to the elimination of manual segmentation as a preprocessing step. Volume rendered images can be merged with conventional treatment planning images to add anatomic information to the treatment planning process.

The delta-TCP concept: a clinically useful measure of tumor control probability

PURPOSE

The aim of this article is to provide a quantitative tool to evaluate the influence of the different dose regions in a non-uniformly irradiated tumour upon the probability of controlling that tumor.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

First, a method to generate a distribution of the probability of controlling the cells in a voxel (VCP) is explored and found not to be useful. Second, we introduce the concept of delta-TCP, which represents the gain or loss in the overall TCP as a result of each particular bin in a DVH not receiving the prescribed dose (the same concept is applicable to dose cubes or to a fraction of the bin). The delta-TCP method presented here is based on the Poisson TCP model, but any other model could also be used. Third, using this tool, with parameters appropriate to Stage C prostate tumors, the consequences of "cold" and "hot" dose regions have been explored.

RESULTS

We show that TCP is affected by the minimum dose, even if it is delivered to a very small volume (20% dose deficit to 5% of the volume makes the TCP decrease by 18%), and that a hot region may be "wasted" unless the boost is to the bulk of the volume. An example of the application of the delta-TCP concept to a prostate radiotherapy plan is also given.

CONCLUSION

The delta-TCP distribution adds more objective information to the original DVH by enabling the clinician or planner to directly evaluate the effects of a non-uniform dose distribution on local control.

Beams eye view-based photon radiotherapy I

Geographic miss, dosimetric miss (underdosing), and proximity of the tumor to sensitive normal tissues are some of the causes of inadequate radiation dose delivery; this is one of many causes of failure after radiotherapy. In the past decade, computerized tomography (CT)-based treatment planning has helped to overcome some of these problems. Beam's eye view (BEV)-based radiotherapy planning is an improvement over CT-based treatment planning that may further increase the therapeutic ratio. Since January 1988, we have treated 198 patients with BEV-based photon radiotherapy. About 40% of our patients treated with radical radiotherapy undergo BEV-based treatment, and about 70% of patients who undergo planning CT in the treatment position receive BEV-based radiotherapy. Our findings are as follows: (a) routine use of BEV-based RT (BEVRT) is possible in a busy radiation oncology department; (b) BEVRT improves geometric coverage of tumors; (c) BEVRT is extremely useful in the design of oblique portals; (d) time commitments for various members of the RT treatment-planning team are reasonable; (e) BEVRT helps individualize RT technique; (f) preliminary data suggest decreased acute toxicity with the use of BEVRT for prostate cancer patients. Whether these advantages will help to improve the outcome (i.e., improve local control and survival) and/or decrease the long-term toxicity is not yet known.

Dose to the cardiac vascular and conduction systems in primary breast irradiation

Using computerized tomography (CT) in which cardiac anatomy was defined, doses delivered to the cardiac compartments, vascular and conduction systems were assessed for various standard techniques of primary breast irradiation. Included in the analysis were 6 MV photon tangents (T) alone, or in conjunction with a separate internal mammary field (IMF). Beams evaluated in the IMF were 6 MV photons, 12 MeV electron beam, and mixed photon/electron beam; Cobalt 60 was also analyzed as an alternate photon beam. Treatment of the IMF with photons, either alone or in combination with electron beam, delivered doses ranging between 30 Gy to 50 Gy to all chambers of the heart, coronary arteries and branches of the conduction system. Complete sparing of the posterior cardiac structures and volume is accomplished with treatment plans using tangents alone or in combination with 12 MeV electron beam irradiation to the IMF. Sparing of the anterior wall of the left ventricle, Bundle of His and left anterior descending coronary artery is also achieved in treatment with tangents and 12 MeV electron beam IMF. Doses to this region with tangents alone ranged from 20 Gy to 45 Gy compared to 0 to 30 Gy with tangents and 12 MeV electron beam IMF. Clinical significance of these findings will be discussed.

Improved radiotherapy treatment planning for spinal cord tumors using gadolinium enhanced MR imaging

Primary intramedullary spinal cord tumors are frequently difficult to localize for radiation treatment planning. Conventional imaging techniques, including unenhanced magnetic resonance (MR) scans, cannot clearly distinguish residual tumor from surrounding normal spinal cord. Recently, contrast agents have been developed for MR that have considerable promise for improving tumor volume definition. This report describes the impact of contrast-enhanced MR on the treatment planning process for four patients with primary spinal cord tumors and discusses the significance of this technique for patients with these neoplasms.

Prism representation: a 3D ray-tracing algorithm for radiotherapy applications

Computing the intersection of a line with a volume, or 'ray tracing' as it is commonly known, is an integral component of three-dimensional radiotherapy dose calculation algorithms. Examples of ray tracing include the intersection of a ray from the radiation source with the patient, with heterogeneous volumes within the patient and with beam-modifying devices, such as a wedge or compensator. Ray tracing is also of primary importance in the field of three-dimensional computer graphics. Through the process of ray tracing, various display features, such as hidden surfaces, shadows, reflection and refraction, can be rendered simply and with startling realism. Advances have recently been made in three-dimensional ray-tracing methods in computer graphics. Due to the similarity of ray tracing in three-dimensional computer graphics and radiotherapy, these new techniques have an immediate application to the ray-tracing problems in three-dimensional radiotherapy dose calculations. The purpose of this paper is to present these advances and illustrate their use in radiation therapy.

Locate: An application of computed tomography in radiation therapy treatment planning with emphasis on tumor localization

Computed tomography can provide precise information for radiation therapy treatment planning. However, inaccuracies in radiation field design may occur when the radiation oncologist attempts to transfer information about tumor location from the transverse plane of the CT scan to the longitudinal plane of the simulation film. This report describes a new computer program, LOCATE, which addresses this problem. The program uses operator generated information from the cross sectional CT images to draw an outline of tumor on AP and lateral longitudinal scanned projection radiographs. The resultant images are useful because they are in the same plane as radiographs obtained on a therapy simulator. The impact of LOCATE on radiation treatment planning for 26 patients is discussed along with several cases in which LOCATE was particularly helpful.

Multi-dimensional treatment planning: I. Delineation of anatomy

We discuss the scope of a multi-dimensional treatment program designed to assist in planning radiation therapy. It includes: synthesis of diagnostic information; techniques for the assessment and delineation of anatomy; fully three-dimensional simulation of therapy; calculation and assessment of dose distributions; verification of treatment delivery; and assessment of the patient during and after treatment. In this paper we present details of techniques for the assessment and delineation of anatomy, including the display of CT information in three dimensions and the ability to draw on and edit the image displays.

Role of computed tomography in the evaluation and management of carcinoma of the prostate

Between January 1978 to March 1980, 25 patients with biopsy-proven prostate carcinoma were evaluated by computerized tomography (CT). CT differed from clinical stage in 7 of 25 patients (28%). In 6 of the 7 patients, change in stage resulted because of demonstration of extracapsular extension and/or pelvic lymph node involvement. Twelve of the 25 patients (48%) underwent surgery with histological confirmation of CT findings. Ct identified nodal involvement accurately in 10 of 12 patients (83%). We recommend use of CT for initial staging, treatment planning and assessment of response in the management of prostate cancer.