Radical radiotherapy as salvage treatment for relapse of Hodgkin's disease initially treated by chemotherapy alone: prognostic significance of the disease-free interval

Accelerated Total Lymphoid Irradiation-containing Salvage Regimen for Patients With Refractory and Relapsed Hodgkin Lymphoma: 20 Years of Experience

PURPOSE

We report the long-term results of integrated accelerated involved field radiation therapy (IFRT) followed by total lymphoid irradiation (TLI) as part of the high-dose salvage regimen followed by autologous bone marrow transplantation or autologous stem cell transplantation in patients with relapsed or refractory Hodgkin lymphoma (HL).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From November 1985 to July 2008, 186 previously unirradiated patients with relapsed or refractory HL underwent salvage therapy on 4 consecutive institutional review board-approved protocols. All patients had biopsy-proven primary refractory or relapsed HL. After standard-dose salvage chemotherapy (SC), accelerated IFRT (18-20 Gy) was given to relapsed or refractory sites, followed by TLI (15-18 Gy) and high-dose chemotherapy. Overall survival (OS) and event-free survival (EFS) were analyzed by Cox analysis and disease-specific survival (DSS) by competing-risk regression.

RESULTS

With a median follow-up period of 57 months among survivors, 5- and 10-year OS rates were 68% and 56%, respectively; 5- and 10-year EFS rates were 62% and 56%, respectively; and 5- and 10-year cumulative incidences of HL-related deaths were 21% and 29%, respectively. On multivariate analysis, complete response to SC was independently associated with improved OS and EFS. Primary refractory disease and extranodal disease were independently associated with poor DSS. Eight patients had grade 3 or higher cardiac toxicity, with 3 deaths. Second malignancies developed in 10 patients, 5 of whom died.

CONCLUSIONS

Accelerated IFRT followed by TLI and high-dose chemotherapy is an effective, feasible, and safe salvage strategy for patients with relapsed or refractory HL with excellent long-term OS, EFS, and DSS. Complete response to SC is the most important prognostic factor.

How I treat relapsed and refractory Hodgkin lymphoma

Relapsed or refractory Hodgkin lymphoma is a challenging problem for clinicians who treat hematologic malignancies. The standard management of these patients should include the use of salvage chemotherapy followed by autologous stem cell transplant (ASCT) in patients who are chemotherapy sensitive. Open issues in this area include the role of functional imaging, the specific chemotherapy regimen to be used before ASCT, and the role of consolidative radiotherapy. Some patients will not be eligible for ASCT, and alternative approaches with conventional chemotherapy alone or with salvage radiotherapy should be considered. Prognostic factors for relapsed/refractory disease have been identified but generally are not used as a part of risk-adapted therapy. Allogeneic transplantation may offer the potential of a graft-versus-lymphoma effect, but this therapy has significant toxicity and results in few long-term disease-free survivors; hence, it should only be offered in the context of disease-specific clinical trials. An expanding list of novel drugs has exhibited promising single-agent activity. Patients have effective options beyond primary therapy, and continued progress through controlled trials remains a tangible goal in the treatment of relapsed and refractory disease.

Salvage therapy for Hodgkin's lymphoma

Hodgkin's lymphoma (HL) is a clonal lymphoid malignancy that affects over 7000 patients in the United States annually. The disease remains one of the great success stories in the recent history of cancer treatment. More than 80% of HL patients will be expected to be long-term survivors because of recent advances in radiation therapy and combined chemotherapy. However, for the subset of patients who relapse after initial therapy, HL remains a challenging disease. Indeed, for patients who relapse after salvage high-dose chemotherapy and autologous stem cell transplant, effective therapeutic options remain limited, and further new therapies are warranted. This article provides a review of the current literature regarding salvage therapy for HL.

Standard therapy of advanced Hodgkin lymphoma

ABVD (doxorubicin, bleomycin, vinblastine and dacarbazine) continues to be the standard of care for patients with advanced-stage Hodgkin lymphoma (HL). Consolidation of primary chemotherapy with radiation or autologous stem cell transplantation (ASCT) has not demonstrated an improvement in overall survival in randomized controlled trials. Regimens such as escalated BEACOPP have more acute and late toxicities and survival benefits have yet to be confirmed.

Despite effective therapy, ultimately 30% to 40% of patients with advanced HL will relapse. ASCT has become the standard of care for patients with relapsed or refractory HL based on two randomized trials. The optimal salvage chemotherapy and high dose therapy regimen are not known. Similarly, non-ASCT strategies including salvage radiotherapy or non-ASCT chemotherapy strategies have been reported and have a potential role in selected clinical scenarios.

This review summarizes recent clinical trial results in the initial treatment of advanced HL and will focus on second-line treatment strategies for patients with relapsed or refractory disease.

New Strategies for the Treatment of Advanced-Stage Hodgkin's Lymphoma

In 2007, patients who have Hodgkin's lymphoma, even in advanced stages, have a better than 85% chance of being cured of their disease if adequate therapy is given at the outset. Most ongoing or planned international studies tailor therapy according to the needs of the individual patient, also accounting for anatomic stage, tumor burden, age, gender, and biologic host factors that affect prognosis. With this approach it might be possible to use less aggressive treatment regimens for the lower-risk groups and limit the use of the more aggressive dose- and time-intensified/dense regimens for the higher-risk groups. With this individualized approach it might be possible to yield higher cure rates and simultaneously reduce the risk for late complications and mortality.

Radioimmunotherapy of refractory or relapsed Hodgkin's lymphoma with 90Y-labelled antiferritin antibody

The aim of this study was to evaluate the safety and efficacy of radiolabelled rabbit polyclonal antiferritin antibody in relapsed or refractory Hodgkin's lymphoma. The protocol included a first intravenous injection of In-labelled antiferritin antibody, followed by immunoscintigraphy at 4, 48 and 72 h, and an intravenous injection of Y-labelled antiferritin antibody in the case of tumour targeting. Ten patients were included in the study: median number of chemotherapy regimens: 3; number of autografted patients: 8; number of previously irradiated patients: 9; response to last chemotherapy: six partial response and four progressions. All immunoscintigraphies showed tumour targeting. Nine patients were treated, as the last patient died from progressive Hodgkin's lymphoma before therapeutic injection. Median injected activity was 12 MBq/kg (0.32 mCi/kg). Among the 10 patients who were included in the study, one complete response and six partial responses were observed (overall response rate 70%) with a median duration of response of 8 months (range: 7-12 months). Toxicity was mainly haematological, with grade 1 or 2 neutropenia and anaemia, and grade 2 and 3 thrombocytopenia. The pharmacokinetic study showed that the half-lives of In and Y were almost identical. These results confirm those previously reported and show the therapeutic potential of rabbit polyclonal antiferritin antibody in relapsed or refractory Hodgkin's lymphoma. They therefore justify further multicentre prospective trials.

Treatment for Relapse in Stage I/II Hodgkin's Lymphoma After Initial Single-Modality Treatment

BACKGROUND

Doxorubicin/bleomycin/vinblastine/dacarbazine (ABVD) chemotherapy alone is a viable option for the treatment of stage I/II Hodgkin's lymphoma. Among the main drawbacks for widespread acceptance of this therapy is the absence of available data on the post-salvage therapy course in patients with limited-stage disease who relapse after ABVD. This article focuses on the outcome of 11 limited-stage patients who relapsed after ABVD alone.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

After a clinical restaging, the patients received mantle-type radiation therapy (only if patients met these criteria: supradiaphragmatic disease in a single-node area, erythrocyte sedimentation rate < 30 mm per hour, and absence of B symptoms) or conventional salvage chemotherapy followed by high-dose chemotherapy and autologous hematopoietic stem cell transplantation.

RESULTS

After a median follow-up of 64 months, 10 patients showed complete response and are still alive without disease progression. One patient showed refractory disease and died 9 months after relapse. This experiment entails the series with the longest follow-up in patients with limited-stage Hodgkin's lymphoma who relapsed after ABVD alone.

CONCLUSION

The data seem to indicate that salvage therapy is capable of providing cure in most cases and lend further support for the use of ABVD alone as first-line therapy.

Long-term follow-up of salvage radiotherapy in Hodgkin’s lymphoma after chemotherapy failure

PURPOSE

To evaluate the long-term results of salvage radiotherapy (SRT) for Hodgkin's lymphoma after chemotherapy failure.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We reviewed 81 patients undergoing SRT for persistent or recurrent Hodgkin's lymphoma after chemotherapy; 19 also received conventional-dose salvage chemotherapy.

RESULTS

At SRT, the median patient age was 31 years. Of the 81 patients, 81% had Stage I-II, 25.9% had B symptoms, 14.8% had bulky disease, and 7.4% had extranodal disease. A less than a complete response (CR) to the last chemotherapy regimen occurred in 47%. SRT was generally limited to one side of the diaphragm, and the median dose was 36 Gy. After SRT, 75% of patients achieved a CR, with 82% retaining durable in-field control. In-field failure was associated with less than a CR to the last chemotherapy regimen (p = 0.0287). Most failures were at distant sites, with 60% in previously involved sites. The 10-year freedom from treatment failure and overall survival rates were 32.8% and 45.7%, respectively. The adverse prognostic factors for freedom from treatment failure were age >50 years (p < 0.001), B symptoms (p < 0.001), extranodal disease (p = 0.012), and less than a CR to the last chemotherapy regimen (p = 0.001). The adverse prognostic factors for overall survival were male gender (p = 0.034), age >50 years (p < 0.001), B symptoms (p = 0.002), and less than a CR to the last chemotherapy regimen (p = 0.002). Favorable cohorts had a 10-year freedom from treatment failure rate of 51% and overall survival rate of 92%.

CONCLUSIONS

Salvage radiotherapy is effective for selected patients with Hodgkin's lymphoma after chemotherapy failure and should be considered for incorporation into salvage programs.

Salvage Radiotherapy in Patients With Relapsed and Refractory Hodgkin’s Lymphoma: A Retrospective Analysis From the German Hodgkin Lymphoma Study Group

Purpose

To evaluate treatment outcome and prognostic factors in patients with refractory or first relapsed Hodgkin’s disease (HD) treated with salvage radiotherapy (SRT) alone.

Patients and Methods

From 4,754 patients registered in the database of the German Hodgkin Study Group from 1988 to 1999, 624 patients were identified with progressive disease (n = 202), or with early (n = 170) or late (n = 252) relapsed HD. At first treatment failure, SRT alone was given to 100 patients. Patient characteristics were: median age, 36 years; progressive disease, 47%; early relapse, 23%; late relapse, 30%; and “B” symptoms, 14%. Eighty-five percent of the patients relapsed after cyclophosphamide, vincristine, procarbazine, and prednisone/doxorubicin, bleomycin, vinblastine, and dacarbazine (COPP/ABVD) –like regimens; 8% after bleomycin, etoposide, doxorubicin, cyclophosphamide, vincristine, procarbazine, and prednisone (BEACOPP) regimens, 7% after first-line radiotherapy alone.

Results

The volume irradiated was mantle field in 43% of patients, inverted-Y in 8%, total nodal irradiation in 12%, and involved-field in 37%. The median SRT dose was 40 Gy (range, 15 to 50 Gy). Seventy-seven patients achieved a complete remission and four patients achieved a partial remission. The 5-year freedom from treatment failure and overall survival (OS) rates were 28% and 51%, respectively. In multivariate analysis, significant prognostic factors for OS were B symptoms (P = .018) and stage at relapse (P = .014). For freedom from second failure (FF2F) Karnofsky performance status (P = .0001) was significant. In patients with limited stage at progression/relapse, duration of first remission was significant (P = .04) for FF2F.

Conclusion

SRT offers an effective treatment for selected subsets of patients with relapsed or refractory HD.

Optimal scheduling to reduce morbidity of involved field radiotherapy with transplantation for lymphomas: A Prospective Australasian Leukaemia and Lymphoma Group Study

This study evaluated delivery of involved field radiotherapy (IFRT) with transplantation for lymphomas timed to minimise toxicity. Patients transplanted for lymphoma had infradiaphragmatic disease irradiated pre-transplant and supradiaphragmatic disease post transplant. A total of 31 patients were studied, with a median follow-up duration of 4 years. Transplant conditioning was according to clinician preference. In all, 14 patients had pre-transplant abdominopelvic IFRT and 19 had post transplant IFRT (including three who had pre-transplant IFRT). Grade III-IV haematological toxicity from pre-transplant IFRT occurred in three patients and from post transplant IFRT in 10 patients. Pre-transplant IFRT had no effect on haematological recovery post transplant, but was associated with a trend towards increased gastrointestinal toxicity (P = 0.094). Pneumonitis due to post transplant thoracic IFRT occurred in one patient. Two patients failed in involved sites after completion of protocol radiotherapy. One case of myelodysplasia has been reported. As sequenced in this study, IFRT was feasible and produced a low incidence of severe pulmonary and haematological toxicities. Patient selection, field size and radiotherapy dose warrant further study.

Hodgkin's lymphoma: biology and treatment strategies for primary, refractory, and relapsed disease

Hodgkin's lymphomas belong to the most curable tumor diseases in adults. About 80% of patients in all anatomical stages and of all histological subtypes can be cured with modern treatment strategies. In spite of the great clinical progress, the pathogenesis of this peculiar lymphoproliferative entity has not been elucidated completely up until now. In Section I Drs. Stein, Hummel, and Zollinger describe the different pro-proliferative and antiapoptotic pathways and molecules involved in the transformation of the germinal center B-lymphocyte to the malignant Hodgkin-Reed-Sternberg cell. They use a comprehensive gene expression profiling (Affymetrix gene chip U133A) on B- and T-Hodgkin cell lines and state that the cell of origin is not the dominant determinant of the Hodgkin cell phenotype, but the transforming event. H-RS cells lack specific functional markers (B-T-cell receptors) and physiologically should undergo apoptosis. Why they do not is unclear and a matter of intensive ongoing research. In Section II Dr. Diehl summarizes the commonly used primary treatment strategies adapted to prognostic strata in early, intermediate and advanced anatomical stages using increasing intensities of chemotherapy (two, four, eight courses of chemotherapy such as ABVD) and additive radiation with decreased doses and field size. ABVD is without doubt the gold standard for early and intermediate stages, but its role as the standard regimen for advanced stages is challenged by recent data with time- and dose-intensified regimens such as the escalated BEACOPP, demonstrating superiority over COPP/ABVD (equivalent to ABVD) for FFTF and OS in all risk strata according to the International Prognostic Score. In Section III, Dr. Connors states that fortunately there is a considerably decreased need for salvage strategies in Hodgkin's lymphomas since primary treatment results in a more than 80% tumor control. Nevertheless, a significant number of patients experience either a tumor refractory to therapy or an early or late relapse. Therefore, one of the continuing challenges in the care for Hodgkin's lymphomas today is to find effective modes for a second tumor control. High-dose chemotherapy followed by autologous stem cell support has proved to be the treatment of choice when disseminated tumors recur after primary chemo- and or radiotherapy. Nodal relapses respond well to local radiation when they recur outfield of primary radiation without B-symptoms and in stages I-II at relapse. Allogeneic stem cell support needs further intensive evaluation in controlled studies to become an established alternative.

Early response to chemotherapy: a surrogate for final outcome of Hodgkin's disease patients that should influence initial treatment length and intensity?

BACKGROUND

Early adjustment of treatment may benefit the patient. In order to guide treatment adjustment, use of early response (ER) or early complete response (ECR), judged after the few initial cycles of chemotherapy, is common in pediatric and also adult Hodgkin's and non-Hodgkin's studies. Paradoxically, almost no data support this strategy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The influence of ECR on outcome was evaluated in three series of advanced Hodgkin's disease (HD), leading to a series of questions.

RESULTS

The 1982 EORTC study assessed prospectively the time frame needed to reach an apparent complete response (CR) through repeated tumor measurements. In patients assessed at mid-treatment before the fifth cycle, both 15 year freedom from progression (FFP) and overall survival (OS) were superior in ECR patients compared with other patients continued on the same treatment (61% versus 37%; P < 0.001). A series of questions arise from these observations. Question 1: is the shortening of treatment detrimental? In a randomized Swedish trial, in one arm treatment was shortened in patients evaluated from the fifth cycle as ECR as compared with the standard eight cycles arm, 10 year cause-specific-survival (CSS) was 53 versus 69% [not significant (ns)]; 10 year OS 49% versus 58% (ns). Conversely, in the EORTC 20884 study, ECR patients given only six cycles did as well as patients entering CR later and, for this reason, given eight cycles (identical 6 year event-free survival 75%). Question 2: is early treatment adaptation in patients who failed to reach ER beneficial? In the French MDH 90 trial, 15% of children failed to reach ECR after four cycles; in these children only, anthracyclines plus alkylating agents were given and the dose of radiotherapy increased, improving the results observed in the previous trial. In the EORTC 20884 study, patients who failed to reach an ECR were switched earlier to involved field RT: their results matched those of ECR patients, at the difference of the previous trial. Question 3: is ER a predicting factor that can be used with any type of treatment? Probably not, based on the German Hodgkin's Lymphoma Study Group trial HD 9: ECR is highly dependent on specific interval from treatment start and on treatment intensity.

DISCUSSION

More general questions stem from these results. Question 4: is the definition of ER secured? With conventional imaging, the different methods for response assessment at end treatment also lead to different response rates; the assessment in the middle of treatment itself and the use of newer imaging techniques may further increase the variation. Indeed, question 5 is: is ER a concept based on any biology? Correlation to markers, 99mTc uptake, PET and hematological tolerance might help to pinpoint how and why ER represents a surrogate for final outcome.

CONCLUSION

ER is a surrogate for final outcome, reflecting both tumor burden and activity. This predictability may, and possibly should, impact on treatment.

Changing role and decreasing size: current trends in radiotherapy for Hodgkin's disease

Radiotherapy, the first cancer treatment modality that offered cure, is still considered to be the most effective "single agent" in treating Hodgkin's disease (HD). Yet, the role of radiotherapy in HD has changed dramatically with the advent of effective combination chemotherapy and the rising concern of long-term complications associated with successful treatment of HD. The new principles of integrating radiotherapy into a combined-modality regimen for HD at different prognostic stages are reviewed here, along with the effect of this new role on radiation field size and design.

A 2-step comprehensive high-dose chemoradiotherapy second-line program for relapsed and refractory Hodgkin disease: analysis by intent to treat and development of a prognostic model

Salvage of patients with relapsed and refractory Hodgkin disease (HD) with high-dose chemoradiotherapy (HDT) and autologous stem cell transplantation (ASCT) results in event-free survival (EFS) rates from 30% to 50%. Unfortunately, the reduction in toxicity associated with modern supportive care has improved EFS by only 5% to 10% and has not reduced the relapse rate. Results of a comprehensive 2-step protocol encompassing dose-dense and dose-intense second-line chemotherapy, followed by HDT and ASCT, are reported. Sixty-five consecutive patients, 22 with primary refractory HD and 43 with relapsed HD, were treated with 2 biweekly cycles of ifosfamide, carboplatin, and etoposide (ICE). Peripheral blood progenitor cells from responding patients were collected, and the patients were given accelerated fractionation involved field radiotherapy (IFRT) followed by cyclophosphamide-etoposide and either intensive accelerated fractionation total lymphoid irradiation or carmustine and ASCT. The EFS rate at a median follow-up of 43 months, as analyzed by intent to treat, was 58%. The response rate to ICE was 88%, and the EFS rate for patients who underwent transplantation was 68%. Cox regression analysis identified 3 factors before the initiation of ICE that predicted for outcome: B symptoms, extranodal disease, and complete remission duration of less than 1 year. EFS rates were 83% for patients with 0 to 1 adverse factors, 27% for patients with 2 factors, and 10% for patients with 3 factors (P <.001). These results compare favorably with other series and document the feasibility and efficacy of giving uniform dose-dense and dose-intense cytoreductive chemotherapy and integrating accelerated fractionation radiotherapy into an ASCT treatment program. This prognostic model provides a basis for risk-adapted HDT.

[The role of radiotherapy in the management of advanced Hodgkin's disease]

The use of radiotherapy in advanced stages of Hodgkin's disease remains controversial. The rationale for its use is based on efficacy at all stages of the disease as well as in patients with recurrent disease, but also on the topography of the recurrences after exclusive chemotherapy (which occur at non irradiated sites in 75% of cases), and on its ability to improve relapse rates as shown in many randomized trials. Unfortunately, this improvement does not translate into higher survival rates because of the increased late morbidity and an inadequate selection of patients who might benefit from irradiation. The benefits of radiotherapy are probably the highest in stage III rather than IV, in patients with scleronodular disease, and in those with mediastinal involvement experiencing a complete response to radiotherapy. A better survival should be observed with the shift towards a decrease of the doses delivered, an improvement of the quality of the irradiation, and a better definition of the volumes to be treated in association with the use of optimal chemotherapies.

Salvage radiotherapy for Hodgkin's disease following chemotherapy failure

PURPOSE

This study aims to: 1) assess failure-free survival (FFS), overall survival (OS), and failure pattern after salvage radiotherapy (SRT) for patients with Hodgkin's disease (HD) who fail chemotherapy (CT); 2) identify patients suitable for SRT as an alternative to more aggressive salvage regimens.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between 1978 and 1992, 52 patients with relapsed/refractory HD following 26 CT received SRT at the Peter MacCallum Cancer Institute. Patient characteristics at diagnosis were: median age (range 12-63); male-31, female-21; Stage I-4, II-16, III-25, or IV-7. Prior to SRT 27 patients had received the equivalent of both MOPP and ABV(D). The duration of initial complete response (CR) from CT was greater than 12 months in 22 patients. SRT (dose 34-42 Gy) was given to active disease sites.

RESULTS

Five-year FFS and OS rates following SRT were 26 and 57%, respectively. Five-year FFS and OS rates of 36 and 75%, respectively, were achieved in patients who relapsed in supradiaphragmatic nodal sites without B symptoms; in a subset of patients with initial Stage I-II disease the FFS and OS rates were 50 and 86%, respectively. On multivariate analysis significant factors for FFS were B symptoms at the time of SRT (p = 0.003), extranodal involvement (p = 0.011) and histology (p = 0.018). For OS significant factors were B symptoms (p = 0.0007), age (p = 0.014) and number of prior CT regimens (p = 0.03).

CONCLUSION

The relatively poor results of SRT in terms of FFS justify the use of alternative salvage strategies for most patients with Hodgkin's disease who fail CT. However, SRT offers a low morbidity, potentially curative option for a subset of patients. Our data suggest that patients most suitable for SRT are those with relapse in supradiaphragmatic nodal sites and no B symptoms.

High-dose therapy and autologous bone marrow transplantation for Hodgkin's disease patients with relapses potentially treatable by radical radiation therapy

PURPOSE

A retrospective review evaluated the results of autologous bone marrow transplantation (A-BMT) for patients with relapsed Hodgkin's disease (HD) who were potentially treatable by radical radiation therapy (RRT).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Evaluated patient cases met the following criteria: initial treatment with chemotherapy (with or without involved field radiation therapy < 25 Gy); no history of bone marrow or extensive lung involvement; no current or previous evidence of systemic metastases except liver; radiation therapy used with salvage chemotherapy for prior relapse would not preclude use of RRT (e.g., > 20 Gy to spinal cord); HD at time of salvage therapy limited to lymph nodes, Waldeyer's ring, liver, spleen, direct extension sites, and/or one lung.

RESULTS

There were 23 A-BMT patients treated between 1986 and 1991 who fulfilled the criteria. Three (13%) patients died from treatment-related complications and eight (35%) developed nonfatal Grade 3-4 complications. The 3-year actuarial disease-free survival rate was 61%. The 3-year disease-free survival rate was 55% for the nine patients with at least one prior disease-free interval (DFI) > 12 months, 67% for nine patients with DFI < 12 months, and 60% for five induction failure patients (p > 0.10). These results are comparable to retrospective studies of RRT results in selected relapsed HD patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term disease-free survival is frequently possible with either A-BMT or RRT in appropriately selected relapsed HD patients. In considering treatment options, important prognostic factors include initial stage of disease, number of prior relapses, DFI, and extent of relapsed disease.