Genetic susceptibility to radiation and chemotherapy injury: diagnosis and management

A Bayesian adaptive biomarker stratified phase II randomized clinical trial design for radiotherapies with competing risk survival outcomes

In recent decades, many phase II clinical trials have used survival outcomes as the primary endpoints. If radiotherapy is involved, the competing risk issue often arises because the time to disease progression can be censored by the time to normal tissue complications, and vice versa. Besides, many existing research has examined that patients receiving the same radiotherapy dose may yield distinct responses due to their heterogeneous radiation susceptibility statuses. Therefore, the "one-size-fits-all" strategy often fails, and it is more relevant to evaluate the subgroup-specific treatment effect with the subgroup defined by the radiation susceptibility status. In this paper, we propose a Bayesian adaptive biomarker stratified phase II trial design evaluating the subgroup-specific treatment effects of radiotherapy. We use the cause-specific hazard approach to model the competing risk survival outcomes. We propose restricting the candidate radiation doses based on each patient's radiation susceptibility status. Only the clinically feasible personalized dose will be considered, which enhances the benefit for the patients in the trial. In addition, we propose a stratified Bayesian adaptive randomization scheme such that more patients will be randomized to the dose reporting more favorable survival outcomes. Numerical studies and an illustrative trial example have shown that the proposed design performed well and outperformed the conventional design ignoring the competing risk issue.

Mobile phone radiation causes changes in gene and protein expression in human endothelial cell lines and the response seems to be genome- and proteome-dependent

We have examined in vitro cell response to mobile phone radiation (900 MHz GSM signal) using two variants of human endothelial cell line: EA.hy926 and EA.hy926v1. Gene expression changes were examined in three experiments using cDNA Expression Arrays and protein expression changes were examined in ten experiments using 2-DE and PDQuest software. Obtained results show that gene and protein expression were altered, in both examined cell lines, in response to one hour mobile phone radiation exposure at an average specific absorption rate of 2.8 W/kg. However, the same genes and proteins were differently affected by the exposure in each of the cell lines. This suggests that the cell response to mobile phone radiation might be genome- and proteome-dependent. Therefore, it is likely that different types of cells and from different species might respond differently to mobile phone radiation or might have different sensitivity to this weak stimulus. Our findings might also explain, at least in part, the origin of discrepancies in replication studies between different laboratories.

Epidemiology of intracranial meningioma

Meningiomas are the most frequently reported primary intracranial neoplasms, accounting for approximately 25% of all such lesions diagnosed in the United States. Few studies have examined the risk factors associated with a diagnosis of meningioma with two categories of exposure, hormones (both endogenous and exogenous) and radiation, most strongly associated with meningioma risk. Limited data are also available on long-term outcomes for meningioma patients, although it is clear that the disease is associated with significant morbidity and mortality. Recent legislation passed in the United States (The Benign Brain Tumor Cancer Registries Amendment Act [H.R. 5204]) mandates registration of benign brain tumors such as meningioma. This will increase the focus on this disease over the coming years as well as likely increase the reported prevalence of the disease. The increased emphasis on research dedicated to the study of brain tumors coupled with the advent of new tools in genetic and molecular epidemiology make the current era an ideal time to advance knowledge for intracranial meningioma. This review highlights current knowledge of meningioma epidemiology and new directions for research efforts in this field.

A pilot case-control study of gamma-radiation sensitivity and risk of papillary thyroid cancer

In vitro gamma-radiation-induced chromatid breaks per cell (b/c) in lymphocytes may be associated with risk of papillary thyroid cancer (PTC). This pilot case-control study involved 106 patients with thyroid disease (57 with PTC and 49 with benign thyroid disease) and 105 cancer-free matched controls. Multivariate logistic regression analyses identified that an elevated gamma-radiation-induced b/c value was a risk factor for PTC (adjusted odds ratio = 4.54; 95% CI, 2.07-9.95), and a dose-response relationship was evident when the b/c values were categorized into tertiles. High levels of chromatid breaks induced by gamma-radiation may constitute an independent risk factor for PTC, but further study is needed.

Heavy ion radiobiology for hadrontherapy and space radiation protection

Research in the field of biological effects of heavy charged particles is needed for both heavy-ion therapy (hadrontherapy) and protection from the exposure to galactic cosmic radiation in long-term manned space missions. Although the exposure conditions (e.g. high- vs. low-dose rate) and relevant endpoints (e.g. cell killing vs. neoplastic transformation) are different in the two fields, it is clear that a substantial overlap exists in several research topics. Three such topics are discussed in this short review: individual radiosensitivity, mixed radiation fields, and late stochastic effects of heavy ions. In addition, researchers involved either in experimental studies on space radiation protection or heavy-ion therapy will basically use the same accelerator facilities. It seems to be important that novel accelerator facilities planned (or under construction) for heavy-ion therapy reserve a substantial amount of beamtime to basic studies of heavy-ion radiobiology and its applications in space radiation research.

Partial breast irradiation with interstitial 60CO brachytherapy results in frequent grade 3 or 4 toxicity. evidence based on a 12-year follow-up of 70 patients

PURPOSE

To investigate the radiation-induced toxicity and cosmesis of brachytherapy (BT) alone in early stage breast cancer.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

A total of 70 women diagnosed with Stage I or II breast carcinoma participated in a BT study at the Municipal Oncoradiological Center, Uzsoki Hospital, Budapest, Hungary, between November 1987 and June 1992. They had undergone breast-conserving surgery with an unknown surgical margin. The postoperative tumor bed irradiation was performed with interstitial (60)Co sources with an active length of 4 cm, with 10-mm center-to-center spacing arranged in a single plane. The median number of inserted sources was 5 (range, 2-8), with a linear activity of 133-137 MBq/cm at the beginning of the study. The 50 Gy delivered dose at 5 mm from the surface of the (60)Co sources was administered during 10-22 h to the virtual postoperative lumpectomy cavity (i.e., plane). For radiobiologic considerations, the clinical target volume (CTV) was calculated retrospectively with a 10-mm safety margin, resulting in a 72-cm(3) median CTV (range, 36-108 cm(3)) irradiated with a reference dose of 28 Gy. In the assessment of the skin and subcutaneous toxicity, the RTOG late radiation morbidity scoring system was applied. The radiosensitivity of the cultured fibroblasts was determined by clonogenic assay to check whether individual radiosensitivity played a role in the development and course of radiation-induced side-effects.

RESULTS

The median follow-up was 12 years (range, 10-15 years). The population of the final study (34 cases) comprised all survivors with tumor-free breasts (27 cases) and patients with breasts erroneously ablated/excised for misinterpreted radiation-induced sequelae (7 patients). A total of 97% of the cohort (33/34) had grade > or =2, and 59% (20/34) had grade > or =3 radiation-induced toxicity. By the end of the follow-up, 85% of the patients experienced Grade > or =2 telangiectasis and 41% had Grade 3 telangiectasis. Eighty-eight percent had fibrosis of some form, and 35% had grade > or =3 fibrosis. Forty-one percent of the cohort displayed fat necrosis, which was always accompanied by Grade > or =3 fibrosis or telangiectasis. The cosmetic results were poor in 50% (17/34) of the patients. The radiosensitivity of the fibroblasts was increased in only 2/24 patients (8% of the investigated cases, in agreement with data published for the general population). Comparisons of our fibrosis prevalence data with those of others allowed an estimate of 0.47 h(-1) for the rate of recovery of DNA damage in the fibroblasts.

CONCLUSIONS

Interstitial (60)Co BT of the breast tumor bed alone with a limited CTV (median, 72 cm(3)) and a total dose of 28 Gy is associated with a high rate (59%) of grade > or =3 radiation-induced toxicity and a high rate (50%) of poor cosmetic outcome at the end of a median follow-up of 12 years. A relatively high BT dose rate (1.3-2.8 Gy/h) applied during a short overall treatment time (10-22 h) and a possible geographic miss (close to skin implantation) might have contributed to the development of these sequelae.

Gamma radiation sensitivity and risk of malignant and benign salivary gland tumors: a pilot case-control analysis

BACKGROUND

The salivary gland is a highly radiosensitive organ. Exposure to gamma radiation is a risk factor for both malignant (MSTs) and benign salivary gland tumors (BSTs), but the exact mechanisms remain unknown. The objectives of the current study were to determine whether gamma radiation-induced chromatid breaks increase the risk of MSTs and BSTs and whether there is any difference in risk between these two diseases.

METHODS

The authors performed a pilot case-control study of 57 patients with salivary gland diseases (45 patients with MSTs and 12 patients with BSTs) and 105 cancer-free controls. Peripheral blood lymphocytes from these participants were cultured and exposed to gamma radiation (1.5 grays). Five hours later, metaphase spread slides were evaluated. The chromatid breaks in 50 well-spread metaphase slides were counted to determine the average number of chromatid breaks per cell (b/c).

RESULTS

Multivariate logistic regression analyses revealed that gamma radiation-induced b/c values greater than the median of the controls were a significant risk factor for salivary gland tumors (adjusted odds ratio [OR], 17.25; 95% confidence interval [CI], 4.92-60.49). The risk remained significant for MSTs (adjusted OR, 40.45; 95% CI, 5.27-310.17) but was of borderline significance for BSTs (adjusted OR, 4.73; 95% CI, 0.94-23.87) when these tumors were analyzed separately.

CONCLUSIONS

In the current study, high levels of chromatid breaks in lymphocytes induced by gamma irradiation were associated with an independent risk for MSTs and were likely to increase the risk of BSTs. However, larger studies are needed to verify these findings.

A review on radiogenic Lhermitte's sign

Radiation myelopathy is a rare, but extremely serious side-effect of radiotherapy. Recovery from radiation-induced motor sequelae is rare, whereas, the regeneration of sensory losses is relatively frequent. Among the sensory radiogenic injuries of the spinal cord, Lhermitte's sign (LS) is most frequent. This review describes the clinical picture and diagnostic imaging signs of radiogenic LS. There have been only a few studies on large patient groups with radiogenic LS, demonstrating a rate of occurrence of 3.6-13%, relating mainly to mantle irradiation or the radiotherapy of head and neck tumors. These cases typically manifest themselves 3 months following radiotherapy and gradually disappear within 6 months. Only 3 LS cases have been described in the English literature with extraordinarily severe symptoms lasting for more than 1 year. MRI, a sensitive tool in the detection of demyelination, failed to reveal any pathological sign accompanying radiogenic LS. However, positron emission tomography demonstrated increased [18F]fluorodeoxyglucose accumulation and [15O]butanol perfusion, but a negligible [11C]methionine uptake in the irradiated spinal cord segments in patients with long-standing LS. These imaging data are suggestive of a close direct relationship between the regional perfusion and metabolism of the spinal cord, very much like the situation in the brain. We postulate that an altered, energy-demanding conduction along the demyelinated axons of patients with chronic radiogenic LS may explain the increased metabolism and perfusion.

The safety and tolerability of low-dose irradiation for the management of gynaecomastia caused by antiandrogen monotherapy

Gynaecomastia--a benign and often painful enlargement of the male breast--is a common side-effect of some therapies for prostate cancer, including non-steroidal antiandrogen monotherapy. Although gynaecomastia and breast pain are not harmful to the overall health of the patient, they can be serious enough to influence treatment decisions in the management of prostate cancer. Prophylactic low-dose irradiation can be effective in reducing the incidence and severity of both gynaecomastia and breast pain. In addition, irradiation may be effective in treating breast pain due to the development of gynaecomastia. Low-dose electron irradiation confers advantageous tissue dosing, is well tolerated, and has manageable side-effects, the most common of which is reversible skin erythema. Information on long-term safety after irradiation for gynaecomastia is limited at present, but trials are underway. Irradiation is likely to be an effective management option with an acceptable low risk of long-term complications for gynaecomastia associated with hormone therapy for prostate cancer.

Gamma-radiation sensitivity and risk of glioma

BACKGROUND

About 9% of human cancers are brain tumors, of which 90% are gliomas. gamma-Radiation has been identified as a risk factor for brain tumors. In a previous pilot study, we found that lymphocytes from patients with glioma were more sensitive to gamma-radiation than were lymphocytes from matched control subjects. In this larger case-control study, we compared the gamma-radiation sensitivity of lymphocytes from glioma patients with those from control subjects and investigated the association between mutagen sensitivity and the risk for developing glioma.

METHODS

We used a mutagen sensitivity assay (an indirect measure of DNA repair activity) to assess chromosomal damage. We gamma-irradiated (1.5 Gy) short-term lymphocyte cultures from 219 case patients with glioma and from 238 healthy control subjects frequency matched by age and sex. After irradiation, cells were cultured for 4 hours, and then Colcemid was added for 1 hour to arrest cells in mitosis. Fifty metaphases were randomly selected for each sample and scored for chromatid breaks. All statistical tests were two-sided.

RESULTS

We observed a statistically significantly higher frequency of chromatid breaks per cell from case patients with glioma (mean = 0.55; 95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.50 to 0.59) than from control subjects (mean = 0.44; 95% CI = 0.41 to 0.48) (P<.001). Using 0.40 (the median number of chromatid breaks per cell in control subjects) as the cut point for defining mutagen sensitivity and adjusting for age, sex, and smoking status, we found that mutagen sensitivity was statistically significantly associated with an increased risk for glioma (odds ratio = 2.09; 95% CI = 1.43 to 3.06). When the data were divided into tertiles, the relative risk for glioma increased from the lowest tertile to the highest tertile (trend test, P<.001).

CONCLUSION

gamma-Radiation-induced mutagen sensitivity of lymphocytes may be associated with an increased risk for glioma, a result that supports our earlier preliminary findings.

Risk assessment for developing gliomas: a comparison of two cytogenetic approaches

Chromosome instability (CIN) measured as chromosome aberrations has long been suggested as a cancer susceptibility biomarker. Conventional cytogenetic end-points are now being improved by combining molecular methods, which increases the sensitivity, specificity, and precision of the assay. In this study we examined both spontaneous and gamma-ray induced CIN in lymphocyte cultures from 51 previously untreated glioma patients and 51 age-, sex- and ethnicity-matched controls. CIN was assessed using two parallel methods: (1) the mutagen sensitivity (MS) assay and (2) the multicolor fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) assay. The frequency of spontaneous breaks was significantly higher in glioma patients (mean+/-S.D., 2.12+/-1.07) than in controls (1.24+/-0.86, P<0.001) when using the FISH assay but not the MS assay (0.019+/-0.02 and 0.019+/-0.01, respectively; P=0.915). Similarly, the frequency of induced chromatid breaks was significantly higher using the FISH assay (3.39+/-1.72) but not the MS assay (0.42+/-0.16) in the patients versus controls (2.08+/-1.18 and 0.37+/-0.15, respectively; P<0.001 and P=0.10, respectively). By using the median number of breaks in the controls as the cutoff value, we observed an odds ratio (ORs) of 5.13 (95% CI=2.23-12.1) for spontaneous and 4.86 (95% CI=2.08-11.4) for induced CIN using the FISH assay, whereas the ORs were 1.32 (95% CI=0.49-3.58) and 1.28 (95% CI=0.59-2.80) for spontaneous and induced CIN using the MS assay. There was also a significant increase in the frequency of hyperdiploid cells in the glioma cases which could only be detected using the FISH assay (OR=4.0, 95% CL=0.9-17.0). By combining both methods an estimated risk of 7.0 (95% CI=1.7-25.6) was observed. There was no correlation between the breaks detected by the two methods suggesting that each method is a measure of a different event. The results indicate that using the multicolor FISH assay for detection of CIN in peripheral blood lymphocytes in glioma patients is a more useful marker for risk assessment.

Mutagen sensitivity as an indicator of soft tissue sarcoma risk

The etiology of soft tissue sarcoma is poorly understood. Exposure to environmental chemicals may play a role, but the data are not clear. We compared a group of soft tissue sarcoma patients with healthy controls to determine whether the mutagen sensitivity assay, a simple chromosome aberration assay using the radiomimetic bleomycin, might be useful to identify patients at risk for soft tissue sarcoma. Patients with a diagnosis of soft tissue sarcoma at Memorial Sloan-Kettering's outpatient clinic signed informed consent and donated 30 ml of blood. Controls were selected from the general population of Connecticut by random digit dialing. Unrepaired DNA damage was assessed for 100 metaphase spreads for each individual, with the number of breaks in chromatids being counted as breaks per cell (b/c). The 20 cases with soft tissue sarcoma had 1.03 mean b/c and the controls had 0.88 b/c (P = 0.16). Patients with soft tissue sarcoma were 5.7 times more likely to be mutagen sensitive than controls (P = 0.01), as determined after dividing subjects into sensitive or not sensitive groups based on the median b/c among controls. As mutagen sensitivity has been shown to be associated with a number of cancers and appears to reflect genetic susceptibility, this assay may be an appropriate biomarker for radiation sensitivity or it may be a marker of susceptibility to soft tissue sarcoma. Larger studies should be undertaken to assess these possibilities.

Radiation-recall skin disorders associated with the use of antineoplastic drugs. Pathogenesis, prevalence, and management

Radiation-recall dermatitis is the occurrence, with subsequent administration of cytotoxic chemotherapy, of an acute inflammatory toxicity in a previously quiescent radiation field. It may occur from days to weeks, and sometimes years, after the radiation therapy. The precise mechanism is unknown. One hypothesis suggests that the initial radiation therapy leads to a depletion of tissue stem cells within the irradiated field and that subsequent cytotoxic chemotherapy exposure causes a 'remembered' reaction among the remaining surviving cells. An alternative proposition suggests that radiation induces heritable mutations within surviving cells, which then produce a subgroup of defective stem cells that are unable to tolerate the second insult of chemotherapy. Recently, ataxia telangiectasia gene mutation and protein kinase deficiency have been associated with patients who have increased susceptibility to severe radiation-induced skin toxicity. Most of the lesions will heal with supportive treatment. Although some reports have noted that radiation-recall dermatitis recurred with subsequent continued administration of the same chemotherapeutic agent, such experience is not universal. At present, a decision as to whether the same chemotherapeutic agent can be continued will usually be determined by the severity of the initial reaction, the chemoresponsiveness of the tumor to this particular agent, the individual patient's wishes, and a clinical judgment that takes into account the availability of alternative therapy.

Enhanced radiation late effects and cellular radiation sensitivity in an ATM heterozygous breast cancer patient

We observed severe late effects in a patient treated with radiation therapy for breast cancer. Radiation survival studies of patient fibroblasts show an enhanced cellular radiation sensitivity (Do = 0.95 Gy). Genetic analysis reveals that the patient is heterozygous for a mutated ATM gene. Protein truncation test (PTT) and sequence analysis identified a truncation within the leucine zipper domain, corresponding to a fragment previously reported to exhibit dominant negative function. These findings demonstrate that ATM heterozygosity may be associated with enhanced clinical radiation sensitivity and suggest a clinical relevance to this truncation that results in a dominant negative-acting protein.

Sequence analysis of the ATM gene in 20 patients with RTOG grade 3 or 4 acute and/or late tissue radiation side effects

PURPOSE

Patients with ataxia-telangiectasia (A-T) show greatly increased radiation sensitivity and cancer predisposition. Family studies imply that the otherwise clinically silent heterozygotes of this autosomal recessive disease run a 3.5 to 3.8 higher risk of developing cancer. In vitro studies suggest moderately increased cellular radiation sensitivity of A-T carriers. They may also show elevated clinical radiosensitivity. We retrospectively examined patients who presented with severe adverse reactions during or after standard radiation treatment for mutations in the gene responsible for A-T, ATM, considering a potential means of future identification of radiosensitive individuals prospectively to adjust dosage schedules.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We selected 20 cancer patients (breast, 11; rectum, 2; ENT, 2; bladder, 1; prostate, 1; anus, 1; astrocytoma, 1; Hodgkins lymphoma, 1) with Grade 3 to 4 (RTOG) acute and/or late tissue radiation side effects by reaction severity. DNA from the peripheral blood of patients was isolated. All 66 exons and adjacent intron regions of the ATM gene were PCR-amplified and examined for mutations by a combination of agarose gel electrophoresis, single-stranded conformational polymorphism (SSCP) analysis, and exon-scanning direct sequencing.

RESULTS

Only 2 of the patients revealed altogether four heteroallelic sequence variants. The latter included two single-base deletions in different introns, a single-base change causing an amino acid substitution in an exon, and a large insertion in another intron. Both the single-base deletions and the single-base change represent known polymorphisms. The large insertion was an Alu repeat, shown not to give rise to altered gene product.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite high technical efforts, no unequivocal ATM mutation was detected. Nevertheless, extension of similar studies to larger and differently composed cohorts of patients suffering severe adverse effects of radiotherapy, and application of new technologies for mutation detection may be worthwhile to assess the definite prevalence of significant ATM mutations within the group of radiotherapy patients with adverse reactions. To date, it must be recognized that our present results do not suggest that heterozygous ATM mutations are involved in clinically observed radiosensitivity but, rather, invoke different genetic predisposition or so far unknown exogenous factors.

Molecular genetic alterations in radiation-induced astrocytomas

Astrocytic tumors occasionally arise in the central nervous system following radiotherapy. It is not clear if these gliomas represent a unique molecular genetic subset. We identified nine cases in which an astrocytoma arose within ports of previous radiation therapy, with total doses ranging from 2400 to 5500 cGy. Irradiated primary lesions included craniopharyngioma, pituitary adenoma, Hodgkin's lymphoma, ependymoma, pineal neoplasm, rhabdomyosarcoma, and three cases of lymphoblastic malignancies. Patients ranged from 9 to 60 years of age and developed secondary tumors 5 to 23 years after radiotherapy. The 9 postradiation neoplasms presented as either anaplastic astrocytoma (3 cases) or glioblastoma multiforme (6 cases). Two of the latter contained malignant mesenchymal components. We performed DNA sequence analysis, differential polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and quantitative PCR on DNA from formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tumors to evaluate possible alterations of p53, PTEN, K-ras, EGFR, MTAP, and p16 (MTS1/CDKN2) genes. By quantitative PCR, we found EGFR gene amplification in 2 of 8 tumors. One of these demonstrated strong immunoreactivity for EGFR. Quantitative PCR showed chromosome 9p deletions including p16 tumor suppressor gene (2 of 7 tumors) and MTAP gene (3 of 7). Five of 9 tumors demonstrated diffuse nuclear immunoreactivity for p53 protein. Sequencing of the p53 gene in these 9 cases revealed a mutation in only one of these cases, a G-to-A substitution in codon 285 (exon 8). Somewhat unexpectedly, no mutations were identified in PTEN, a commonly altered tumor suppressor gene in de novo glioblastoma multiformes. Unlike some radiation-induced tumors, no activating point mutations of the K-ras proto-oncogene or base pair deletions of tumor suppressor genes were noted. These radiation-induced tumors are distinctive in their high histological grade at clinical presentation. The spectrum of molecular genetic alterations appears to be similar to that described in spontaneous high grade astrocytomas, especially those of the de novo type.

Radiosensitivity of normal tissues in ataxia-telangiectasia heterozygotes

PURPOSE

Approximately 5% of cancer patients given radiation therapy exhibit severe injuries to the noncancerous tissue in the radiation field. Striking clinical sensitivity to ionizing radiation has been observed frequently in ataxia-telangiectasia (A-T) homozygotes. This study was undertaken to test the hypothesis that heterozygous carriers of a mutated gene for A-T may represent a substantial proportion of all patients who suffer severe radiation toxicity.

METHODS

The medical records of all A-T heterozygotes treated with radiation therapy for breast or prostate cancer were compiled from an ongoing study of mortality and cancer incidence in A-T families. Diagnostic, treatment, and follow-up records were reviewed. Acute and long-term radiation complications were scored according to Radiation Therapy and Oncology Group criteria.

RESULTS

There were no instances of soft tissue necrosis or other apparent serious injuries to normal tissues of two A-T heterozygotes with prostate carcinoma and 11 with breast carcinoma who received moderate-to-high doses of conventionally fractionated radiation therapy by megavoltage techniques.

CONCLUSION

There is no evidence that abnormal clinical radiosensitivity occurs in A-T heterozygotes receiving conventionally fractionated radiation therapy for breast or prostate cancer.

Complications of fast neutron therapy

The purpose of the study was to identify the tissues and organs at risk following high-energy neutron-beam therapy for selected radioresistant tumors, estimating the separate probabilities of both normal tissue injury and of tumor recurrence, each in relation to the absorbed dose. Published statistical and anecdotal reports on the incidence of serious complications observed following fast neutron treatment directed to the cranium, head and neck, chest, upper abdomen, pelvis, and extremities are reviewed and dose-response parameters derived using bivariate probit or logistic analyses. We then calculate the conditional probability of uncomplicated control (PUC) at various doses, assuming that tumor cure and late injury are stochastically independent events. The median effective doses and coefficients of variation, derived for neutron irradiation of human brain and spinal cord, oropharynx, lung, stomach and bowel, rectum and bladder, and extremities, are tabulated and tentative "tolerance limits" estimated. Tolerance doses are shown to depend on several factors including beam quality, chemical composition, cell cycling rate, fraction-size, and follow-up time. In patients followed over 5 years, safe tolerance doses appear to range from < 14 GY for the central nervous system up to 22 GY in the oropharynx and mandible. Given well-determined dose-response data for specific normal tissues and the associated tumors, the separate probabilities of tumor control and of normal tissue injury at a given dose can be estimated. The particular treatment scheme yielding the highest PUC can usually be identified. The maximum PUC for neutron therapy, compared with other modalities, is a measure of both efficacy and safety for the procedure under study and thus provides a useful guide for comparing various modalities and treatment plans and for designing more effective treatment strategies.

Acute radiation reaction and local control in breast cancer patients treated with postmastectomy radiotherapy

BACKGROUND

We have investigated the variation of acute radiation reactions in medium-risk patients with postmastectomy radiotherapy with regard to a possible correlation between radiation reaction of normal tissues and local tumor control.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

From 1985 through 1991, a total number of 194 patients received postmastectomy radiotherapy for breast cancer pT1-2pN0-2M0 at the University of Halle-Wittenberg. The lymphatics were irradiated by an anterior 9-MV photon field and the chest wall by an individually shaped anterior field with 9-MV electrons. Both fields received single doses of 2 Gy 5 times weekly up to a total dose of 44 Gy to the chest wall and 50 Gy to the lymphatics. All patients were routinely evaluated once weekly during radiotherapy for acute side effects by one examiner. Skin erythema was classified as mild, moderate or severe, esophagitis as being present in form of dysphagia or not and pneumonitis, if present, as asymptomatic (visible only on repeated chest X-rays) or clinically symptomatic. A differential blood count was also carried out once weekly. For this analysis, the records of all patients were retrospectively reviewed. The median follow-up at the time of analysis was 4.2 years.

RESULTS

Of the patients, 98 (51%) had a mild, 53 (27%) moderate and 43 (22%) a severe erythema. Furthermore, 38 patients (20%) had signs of esophagitis, 13 (7%) had asymptomatic and 26 (13%) symptomatic pneumonitis. Patients with severe erythema or erythema plus esophagitis and pneumonitis had a more pronounced decrease in lymphocyte count during treatment than patients with mild erythema: the lymphocyte nadir was 0.14 vs 0.73 Gpt/l in patients with severe vs mild erythema, and 0.36 vs 0.69 Gpt/l in patients with erythema plus esophagitis plus pneumonitis vs patients with erythema only, p < 0.05. Of the patients, 44 (22%) developed chronic side effects, mostly arm edema. There was no correlation between acute and late effects. An overall number of seven local recurrences (3.6%) occurred. The risk of developing a local recurrence within 5 years after treatment was 0% in patients with severe erythema or erythema plus esophagitis/pneumonitis vs 7% in patients with mild erythema only; this difference was marginally significant, p = 0.055.

CONCLUSIONS

This analysis showed a trend towards better local control in patients with severe acute radiation reaction of normal tissue. The data support a recent publication by Dahl and coworkers showing a linkage between acute radiation reaction of normal tissue and tumor response in patients with preoperative radiotherapy for rectal cancer. The correlation between acute normal tissue reaction and local control might be explained by interindividual variations in the intrinsic, genetically determined radiosensitivity. However, local factors might also be involved, e.g. induction of a cytokin cascade in cases of acute reactions in normal tissues.

Radiation therapy tolerance limits. For one or for all?--Janeway Lecture

BACKGROUND

The optimal use of radiation therapy for cancer treatment is hampered by the application of tolerance limits of normal tissues derived empirically from population averages. Such limits do not reflect the considerable differences from patient to patient in susceptibility to late radiation sequelae. Assays that accurately predict normal tissue tolerance in individual patients would permit real application of the concept of treatment to tolerance thereby increasing the probability of an uncomplicated cure for the population as a whole.

METHODS

A summary of laboratory research is presented to test the hypothesis that the cellular radiosensitivity of normal skin fibroblasts can predict the severity of late connective tissue damage that develops following radiotherapy. The pathogenesis of radiation reactions and the possible role of radiation induced cellular senescence in the development of clinical late effects are briefly reviewed.

RESULTS

Although the pathogenesis of radiation injury is highly complex, several clinical studies have demonstrated a significant correlation between fibroblast radiosensitivity and the severity of late sequelae from treatment. However, the precision and reproducibility of fibroblast cell survival assays are inadequate for routine clinical use. Newer assays incorporating insights into the effects of radiation on cellular senescence and cytokine production are being developed. Such assays may, in the future, be complemented or replaced by molecular and/or cytogenetic probes to derive robust estimates of individual tolerance.

CONCLUSIONS

The principle of prediction of tolerance to radiotherapy has been established. Although current assays lack the precision required for clinical use, the goal of individualized treatment to tolerance ultimately should be achieved.