DNA methyltransferase genes of Bacillus subtilis phages: structural relatedness and gene expression

DISARM is a widespread bacterial defence system with broad anti-phage activities

The evolutionary pressure imposed by phage predation on bacteria and archaea has resulted in the development of effective anti-phage defence mechanisms, including restriction-modification and CRISPR-Cas systems. Here, we report on a new defence system, DISARM (defence island system associated with restriction-modification), which is widespread in bacteria and archaea. DISARM is composed of five genes, including a DNA methylase and four other genes annotated as a helicase domain, a phospholipase D (PLD) domain, a DUF1998 domain and a gene of unknown function. Engineering the Bacillus paralicheniformis 9945a DISARM system into Bacillus subtilis has rendered the engineered bacteria protected against phages from all three major families of tailed double-stranded DNA phages. Using a series of gene deletions, we show that four of the five genes are essential for DISARM-mediated defence, with the fifth (PLD) being redundant for defence against some of the phages. We further show that DISARM restricts incoming phage DNA and that the B. paralicheniformis DISARM methylase modifies host CCWGG motifs as a marker of self DNA akin to restriction-modification systems. Our results suggest that DISARM is a new type of multi-gene restriction-modification module, expanding the arsenal of defence systems known to be at the disposal of prokaryotes against their viruses.

Bacteriophage orphan DNA methyltransferases: insights from their bacterial origin, function, and occurrence

Type II DNA methyltransferases (MTases) are enzymes found ubiquitously in the prokaryotic world, where they play important roles in several cellular processes, such as host protection and epigenetic regulation. Three classes of type II MTases have been identified thus far in bacteria which function in transferring a methyl group from S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) to a target nucleotide base, forming N-6-methyladenine (class I), N-4-methylcytosine (class II), or C-5-methylcytosine (class III). Often, these MTases are associated with a cognate restriction endonuclease (REase) to form a restriction-modification (R-M) system protecting bacterial cells from invasion by foreign DNA. When MTases exist alone, which are then termed orphan MTases, they are believed to be mainly involved in regulatory activities in the bacterial cell. Genomes of various lytic and lysogenic phages have been shown to encode multi- and mono-specific orphan MTases that have the ability to confer protection from restriction endonucleases of their bacterial host(s). The ability of a phage to overcome R-M and other phage-targeting resistance systems can be detrimental to particular biotechnological processes such as dairy fermentations. Conversely, as phages may also be beneficial in certain areas such as phage therapy, phages with additional resistance to host defenses may prolong the effectiveness of the therapy. This minireview will focus on bacteriophage-encoded MTases, their prevalence and diversity, as well as their potential origin and function.

M.phi 3TII: a new monospecific DNA (cytosine-C5) methyltransferase with pronounced amino acid sequence similarity to a family of adenine-N6-DNA-methyltransferases

The temperate B.subtilis phages phi 3T and rho 11s code, in addition to the multispecific DNA (cytosine-C5) methyltransferases (C5-MTases) M. phi 3TI and M. rho 11sI, which were previously characterized, for the identical monospecific C5-MTases M. phi 3TII and M. rho 11sII. These enzymes modify the C of TCGA sites, a novel target specificity among C5-MTases. The primary sequence of M. phi 3TII (326 amino acids) shows all conserved motifs typical of the building plan of C5-MTases. The degree of relatedness between M. phi 3TII and all other mono- or multispecific C5-MTases ranges from 30-40% amino acid identity. Particularly M. phi 3TII does not show pronounced similarity to M. phi 3TI indicating that both MTase genes were not generated from one another but were acquired independently by the phage. The amino terminal part of the M. phi 3TII (preceding the variable region 'V'), which predominantly constitutes the catalytic domain of the enzyme, exhibits pronounced sequence similarity to the amino termini of a family of A-N6-MTases, which--like M.TaqI--recognize the general sequence TNNA. This suggests that recently described similarities in the general three dimensional organization of C5- and A-N6-MTases imply divergent evolution of these enzymes originating from a common molecular ancestor.

M.phi 3TII: a new monospecific DNA (cytosine-C5) methyltransferase with pronounced amino acid sequence similarity to a family of adenine-N6-DNA-methyltransferases

The temperate B.subtilis phages phi 3T and rho 11s code, in addition to the multispecific DNA (cytosine-C5) methyltransferases (C5-MTases) M.phi 3TI and M.rho 11sI, which were previously characterized, for the identical monospecific C5-MTases M.phi 3TII and M.rho 11sII. These enzymes modify the C to TCGA sites, a novel target specificity among C5-MTases. The primary sequence of M.phi 3TII (326 amino acids) shows all conserved motifs typical of the building plan of C5-MTases. The degree of relatedness between M.phi 3TII and all other mono- or multispecific C5-MTases ranges from 30-40% amino acid identity. Particularly M.phi 3TII does not show pronounced similarity to M.phi 3TI indicating that both MTase genes were not generated from one another but were acquired independently by the phage. The amino terminal part of the M.phi 3TII (preceding the variable region 'V'), which predominantly constitutes the catalytic domain of the enzyme, exhibits pronounced sequence similarity to the amino termini of a family of A-N6-MTases, which--like M.Taql--recognize the general sequence TNNA. This suggests that recently described similarities in the general three dimensional organization of C5- and A-N6-MTases imply divergent evolution of these enzymes originating from a common molecular ancestor.

Effect of site-specific modification on restriction endonucleases and DNA modification methyltransferases

Restriction endonucleases have site-specific interactions with DNA that can often be inhibited by site-specific DNA methylation and other site-specific DNA modifications. However, such inhibition cannot generally be predicted. The empirically acquired data on these effects are tabulated for over 320 restriction endonucleases. In addition, a table of known site-specific DNA modification methyltransferases and their specificities is presented along with EMBL database accession numbers for cloned genes.

In vivo methylation in Escherichia coli by the Bacillus subtilis phage phi 3T I methyltransferase to protect plasmids from restriction upon transformation of Clostridium acetobutylicum ATCC 824

The restriction endonuclease Cac824I has been shown to be a major barrier to electrotransformation of Clostridium acetobutylicum ATCC 824 (L. D. Mermelstein, N. E. Welker, G. N. Bennett, and E. T. Papoutsakis, Bio/Technology 10:190-195, 1992). Methylation by the phi 3T I methyltransferase encoded by Bacillus subtilis phage phi 3T was shown to protect plasmid DNA from restriction by Cac824I. Expression in Escherichia coli of the phi 3tI gene (which encodes the phi 3T I methyltransferase) from pAN1, which replicates via the p15A origin of replication, was sufficient to completely methylate coresident E. coli-C. acetobutylicum shuttle vectors with ColE1 origins of replication. Three shuttle vectors (pIMP1, pSYL2, and pSYL7) methylated in this manner were used to efficiently electrotransform strain ATCC 824. These vectors could not be introduced into strain ATCC 824 when unmethylated because the E. coli portions of the plasmids contain a large number of Cac824I sites. This method obviates the need to use B. subtilis-C. acetobutylicum shuttle vectors with few Cac824I sites to introduce DNA into C. acetobutylicum ATCC 824.

Characterization of the mcrBC region of Escherichia coli K-12 wild-type and mutant strains

We have carried out an analysis of the Escherichia coli K-12 mcrBC locus in order to (1) elucidate its genetic organization, (2) to identify the proteins encoded by this region, and (3) to characterize their involvement in the restriction of DNA containing methylated cytosine residues. In vitro expression of recombinant plasmids carrying all or portions of the mcrBC region revealed that the mcrB and mcrC genes are organized as an operon. The mcrBC operon specifies five proteins, as evident from parallel in vitro and in in vivo expression studies. Three proteins of 53, 35 and 34 kDa originate from mcrB expression, while two proteins of 37 and 16 kDa arise from mcrC expression. Products of both the mcrB and mcrC genes are required to restrict the methylated substrate DNA used in this study. We also determined the nature of mutant mcrBC loci in comparison to the E. coli K-12 wild-type mcrBC locus. A major goal of these studies was to clarify the nature of the mcrB-1 mutation, which is carried by some strains employed in previous analyses of the E. coli K-12 McrBC system. Based on our analyses the mutant strains investigated could be divided into different complementation groups. The mcrB-1 mutation is a nonsense or frameshift mutation located within mcrB. It causes premature termination of mcrB gene product synthesis and reduces the level of mcrC gene expression. This finding helps to understand an existing conflict in the literature. We also describe temperature-sensitive McrA activity in some of the strains analysed and its relationship to the previously defined differences in the tolerance levels of E. coli K-12 mcrBC mutants to cytosine methylation.

Organization of restriction-modification systems

The genes for over 100 restriction-modification systems have now been cloned, and approximately one-half have been sequenced. Despite their similar function, they are exceedingly heterogeneous. The heterogeneity is evident at three levels: in the gene arrangements; in the enzyme compositions; and in the protein sequences. This paper summarizes the main features of the R-M systems that have been cloned.

Specificity of restriction endonucleases and DNA modification methyltransferases a review (Edition 3)

The properties and sources of all known class-I, class-II and class-III restriction endonucleases (ENases) and DNA modification methyltransferases (MTases) are listed and newly subclassified according to their sequence specificity. In addition, the enzymes are distinguished in a novel manner according to sequence specificity, cleavage position and methylation sensitivity. Furthermore, new nomenclature rules are proposed for unambiguously defined enzyme names. In the various Tables, the enzymes are cross-indexed alphabetically according to their names (Table I), classified according to their recognition sequence homologies (Table II), and characterized within Table II by the cleavage and methylation positions, the number of recognition sites on the DNA of the bacteriophages lambda, phi X174, and M13mp7, the viruses Ad2 and SV40, the plasmids pBR322 and pBR328, and the microorganisms from which they originate. Other tabulated properties of the ENases include relaxed specificities (integrated within Table II), the structure of the generated fragment ends (Table III), interconversion of restriction sites (Table IV) and the sensitivity to different kinds of DNA methylation (Table V). Table VI shows the influence of class-II MTases on the activity of class-II ENases with at least partially overlapping recognition sequences. Table VII lists all class-II restriction endonucleases and MTases which are commercially available. The information given in Table V focuses on the influence of methylation of the recognition sequences on the activity of ENases. This information might be useful for the design of cloning experiments especially in Escherichia coli containing M.EcodamI and M.EcodcmI [H16, M21, U3] or for studying the level and distribution of site-specific methylation in cellular DNA, e.g., 5'- (M)CpG-3' in mammals, 5'-(M)CpNpG-3' in plants or 5'-GpA(M)pTpC-3' in enterobacteria [B29, E4, M30, V4, V13, W24]. In Table IV a cross index for the interconversion of two- and four-nt 5'-protruding ends into new recognition sequences is complied. This was obtained by the fill-in reaction with the Klenow (large) fragment of the E. coli DNA polymerase I (PolIk), or additional nuclease S1 treatment followed by ligation of the modified fragment termini [P3]. Interconversion of restriction sites generates novel cloning sites without the need of linkers. This should improve the flexibility of genetic engineering experiments [K56, P3].(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Characterization and cloning of MwoI (GCN7GC), a new type-II restriction-modification system from Methanobacterium wolfei

R.MwoI, a type-II restriction enzyme with the new specificity 5'-GCN7GC-3', was found in extracts of the thermophilic archaebacterium, Methanobacterium wolfei. R.MwoI cleaves duplex DNA producing fragments with 3-nt, 3'-terminal extensions, thus: GCN5/N2GC. The genes coding for the MwoI restriction and modification enzymes were cloned into Escherichia coli on the plasmid vector pBR322. The clones synthesize a low level of R.MwoI endonuclease. The plasmids display incomplete MwoI-specific modification, suggesting that the clones synthesize a low level of the M.MwoI methyltransferase, too.

Sequence motifs specific for cytosine methyltransferases

Using a new alignment method, the sequences of 13 m5C methyltransferases (MTases) have been examined. Five extremely well-conserved blocks of sequence have been detected and have been used as fixed points for the alignment of the 13 sequences. Following this initial alignment, five further blocks of similarity have been identified to give a total of ten recognizable blocks of sequence homology that are all arranged in a common order. The structures of these MTases consist of a variable-length N-terminal arm followed by eight well-conserved blocks each separated by small variable-length regions. A large variable-length segment of 90 to 270 amino acids (aa) then follows. After this are two blocks, and a variable-length C-terminal segment completes the sequence. Within the final alignment, 20 aa in the protein sequences, and 86 nucleotides in the nucleotide sequences are invariant. The strongest conservation is found in proximity to a suspected functional site that contains the dipeptide proline-cysteine. Consensus patterns can be defined for the five best conserved blocks and, when used as search motifs, are able to clearly distinguish between the m5C MTases and all other identified proteins in the PIR database. This suggests they may be of use in identifying putative MTases among protein sequences of unknown function.

Cloned restriction-modification systems--a review

The genes for numerous restriction endonucleases and modification methylases have been cloned into Escherichia coli. A summary is given for the clones isolated so far (115 entries) and of the procedures used to obtain them.

Cloning and analysis of the HaeIII and HaeII methyltransferase genes

The HaeIII methyltransferase (MTase) gene from Haemophilus aegyptius (recognition sequence: 5'-GGCC-3') was cloned into Escherichia coli in the plasmid vector pBR322. The gene was isolated on a single EcoRI fragment and on a single HindIII fragment. Clones carrying additional adjacent fragments were found to code also for the HaeII restriction endonuclease and HaeII modification MTase (recognition sequence: 5'-PuGCGCPy-3'). The sequence of the HaeIII modification gene was determined. The inferred amino acid sequence of the protein was found to share extensive similarity with other sequenced m5C-MTases. The central 'non-conserved' region of the M.HaeIII MTase, thought to form the nucleotide sequence-specificity domain, is almost identical to that of the M.BsuRI, M.BspRI and M.NgoPII MTases, which also recognize the sequence 5'-GGCC-3'.

Chimeric multispecific DNA methyltransferases with novel combinations of target recognition

DNA target recognizing domains of different multispecific DNA-cytosine-methyltransferases can be rearranged through engineering of the corresponding genes to generate enzymes with novel combinations of target recognition.

RglB facilitated cloning of highly methylated eukaryotic DNA: the human L1 transposon, plant DNA, and DNA methylated in vitro with human DNA methyltransferase

In vitro methylation of Bluescribe plasmid DNA (pBS) with human placental DNA methyltransferase to 6% 5-methylcytosine (mC) reduced transformation efficiencies in rglB+ host strains C600 and DS410 by almost 2 orders of magnitude. By contrast, the rglB- derivative of DS410 showed no reduction in transformation efficiency with methylation while the rglB- derivative of C600 was partially tolerant to methylation. Further, we show that the 1.8 kilobase (kb) and 1.2 kb KpnI fragments derived from the human L1 repeat have respectively 18.3% and 2.3% mC in vivo. Using these hyper- and hypo-methylated genomic segments ligated into the pBS plasmid, transformants with the highly methylated 1.8 kb L1 insert were recovered at 17 to 40 fold higher frequency with the rglB- host strains than with the rglB+ hosts. In addition, recombinant phage (lambda 2001) containing inserts of plant genomic DNA with 26.7% mC (from Petunia hybrida) when plated on rglB- hosts gave titres up to 222 times higher than on the rglB+ strains.

Cloning and expression of the MspI restriction and modification genes

The genes for the MspI restriction (R) and modification enzymes (recognition sequence CCGG) have been cloned into Escherichia coli using the vector pBR322. Clones carrying both genes have been isolated from libraries prepared with EcoRI, HindIII and BamHI. The smallest fragment that encodes both activities is a 3.6-kb HindIII fragment. Plasmids purified from the clones are fully resistant to digestion by MspI, indicating that the modification gene is functional in E. coli. The clones remain sensitive to phage infection, however, indicating that the endonuclease is dysfunctional. When the R gene is brought under the control of the inducible leftward promoter from phage lambda, the level of endonuclease increases and the level of methylase decreases, suggesting that the genes are transcribed in opposite directions.

Cloning, sequencing and expression of the Taq I restriction-modification system

The Taq I modification and restriction genes (recognition sequence TCGA) have been cloned in E. coli and their DNA sequences have been determined. Both proteins were characterized and the N-terminal sequence of the endonuclease was determined. The genes have the same transcriptional orientation with the methylase gene 5' to the endonuclease gene. The methylase gene is 1089 bp in length (363 amino acids, 40,576 daltons); the endonuclease gene is 702 bp in length (234 amino acids, 27,523 daltons); they are separated by 132 bp. Both methylase and endonuclease activity can be detected in cell extracts. The clones fully modify the vector and chromosomal DNA but they fail to restrict infecting phage. Clones carrying only the restriction gene are viable even in the absence of modification. The restriction gene contains 7 Taq I sites; the modification gene contains none. This asymmetric distribution of sites could be important in the regulation of the expression of the endonuclease gene.

Cytosine-specific DNA modification interferes with plasmid establishment in Escherichia coli K12: involvement of rglB

Several chimeric pBR322/328 derivatives containing genes for cytosine-specific DNA methyltransferases (Mtases) can be transformed into the Escherichia coli K12/E. coli B hybrid strains HB101 and RR1 but not into other commonly used E. coli K12 strains. In vitro methylation of cytosine residues in pBR328 and other unrelated plasmids also reduces their potential to transform such methylation sensitive strains, albeit to a lesser degree than observed with plasmids containing Mtase genes. The extent of reduced transformability depends on the target specificity of the enzyme used for in vitro modification. The role of a host function in the discrimination against methylated plasmids was verified by the isolation of K12 mutants which tolerate cytosine methylated DNA. The mutations map in the vicinity of the serB locus. This and other data indicate that the host rglB function is involved in the discrimination against modified DNA.

Multispecific DNA methyltransferases from Bacillus subtilis phages. Properties of wild-type and various mutant enzymes with altered DNA affinity

Temperate Bacillus subtilis phages SPR, phi 3T, rho 11 and SP beta code for DNA methyltransferases, each having multiple sequence specificities. The SPR wild-type and various mutant methyltransferases were overproduced 1000-fold in Escherichia coli and were purified by three consecutive chromatographic steps. The stable form of these multispecific enzymes in solution are monomers with a relative molecular mass (Mr) of about 50,000. The methyl-transfer kinetics of the SPR wild-type and mutant enzymes were determined with DNA substrates carrying either none or one of the three recognition sequences (GGCC, CCGG, CCATGG). Evaluation of the catalytic properties for DNA and S-adenosylmethionine binding suggested that the NH2-terminal part of the protein is important for both non-sequence-specific DNA binding and S-adenosylmethionine binding as well as transfer of methyl groups. On the other hand, mutations in the COOH-terminal part lead to weaker site-specific interactions of the enzyme. Antibodies raised against the purified SPR enzyme specifically immunoprecipitated the phi 3T, rho 11 and SP beta methyltransferases, bu failed to precipitate the chromosomally coded enzymes from B. subtilis (BsuRI) and B. sphaericus (BspRI). Immunoaffinity chromatography is an efficient purification step for the related phage methyltransferases.

Cloning and expression of Bacillus subtilis phage DNA methyltransferase genes in Escherichia coli and B. subtilis

The DNA methyltransferase (Mtase) genes of the temperate Bacillus subtilis phages SPR (wild type and various mutants), phi 3T, rho 11 and SP beta have been cloned and expressed in Escherichia coli and B. subtilis host-plasmid vector systems. Mtase activity has been quantitated in these clones by performing in vitro methylation assays of cell-free extracts. The four-phage Mtase genes differ in the amount of Mtase synthesized when transcribed from their genuine promoters. In B. subtilis as well as in E. coli the SPR Mtase is always produced in smaller amounts than the other phage Mtases. Expression levels of the SPR Mtase are dependent on the strength of the upstream vector promoter sequences. Overproduction of the SPR wild-type and mutant enzymes was achieved in E. coli (inducible expression) by fusions to the lambda pL or the tac promoter and in B. subtilis (constitutive expression) by means of the phage SP02 promoter.

DNA methyltransferase genes of Bacillus subtilis phages: comparison of their nucleotide sequences

The phi 3T DNA methyltransferase (Mtase) and most of the SP beta Mtase genes have been sequenced. With the exception of their promoters, no difference was found between the phi 3T and SP beta Mtase genes which code for an enzyme with a Mr of 50 507, consisting of 443 amino acids (aa). Comparison of the deduced aa sequence of the phi 3T/SP beta type Mtase (target specificity: GGCC and GCNGC) with that of the previously established sequence of the SPR Mtase (Buhk et al., 1984) which has the target specificity GGCC and CCGG, reveals strong similarities between these two types of enzymes. There is, however, one striking difference: both the phi 3T/SP beta and the SPR enzymes contain at different positions inserts of 33 aa, which have no homology to each other. We suggest that the methylation specificity unique to each of the two types of Mtases (GCNGC in phi 3T/SP beta; CCGG in SPR) depends on these inserts, while the GGCC-specific modification potential common to all Mtases is determined by structures conserved in both types of enzymes. A DNA fragment of non-modifying phage Z, which shows homology to both flanks of the SPR Mtase gene, was also sequenced. This segment can be described as a derivative of SPR DNA, in which the Mtase gene and sequences at its 5' end have been deleted, with the deletion extending between two direct repeats of 25 bp.