Genesis of eukaryotic transcriptional activator and repressor proteins by splitting a multidomain anabolic enzyme

Proteins with class alpha/beta fold have high-level participation in fusion events

Now that complete genome sequences are available for a variety of organisms, the elucidation of potential gene products function is a central goal in the post-genome era. Domain fusion analysis has been proposed recently to infer the functional association of the component proteins. Here, we took a new approach to the analysis of the structural features of the proteins involved in fusion events. An exhaustive survey of fusion events within 30 completely sequenced genomes and subsequent structure annotations to the component proteins at a SCOP superfamily level with hidden Markov models was carried out. A domain fusion map was then constructed. The results revealed that proteins with the class alpha/beta fold are frequently involved in fusion events, around 86% of the total 676 assigned single-domain fusion pairs including at least one component protein belonging to the alpha/beta fold class. Moreover, the domain fusion map in our work may offer an attractive framework for designing chimeric enzymes following Nature's lead, and may give useful hints for exploring the evolutionary history of proteins. (c) 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd.

Evaluating low level sequence identities. Are Aspergillus QUTA and AROM homologous?

A review published several years ago [Hawkins, A.R. & Lamb, H.K. (1995) Eur. J. Biochem. 232, 7-18] proposed that genetic, biochemical and physiological data can override sequence comparison in the determination of homology in instances where structural information is unavailable. Their lead example was the hypothesis that the transcriptional activator protein for quinate catabolism in Aspergillus nidulans, QUTA, is derived from the pentafunctional AROM protein by a gene duplication followed by cleavage [Hawkins, A.R., Lamb, H.K., Moore, J.D. & Roberts, C.F. (1993) Gene 136, 49-54]. We tested this hypothesis by a sensitive combination of position-specific log-odds scoring matrix methods. The position-specific log-odds scoring matrices were derived from a large number of 3-dehydroquinate synthase and 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase domains that were proposed to be the domains from the AROM protein that gave rise to the transcriptional activator protein for quinate metabolism. We show that the degree and pattern of similarity between these position-specific log-odds scoring matrices and the transcriptional activator protein for quinate catabolism in A. nidulans is that expected for random sequences of the same composition. This level of similarity provides no support for the suggested gene duplication and cleavage. The lack of any trace of evidence for homology following a comprehensive sequence analysis indicates that the homology hypothesis is without foundation, underlining the necessity to accept only similarity of sequence and/or structure as evidence of evolutionary relatedness. Further, QUTA is homologous throughout its entire length to an extended family of fungal transcriptional regulatory proteins, rendering the hypothesized QUTA-AROM homology even more problematic.

Cobalt-dependent transcriptional switching by a dual-effector MerR-like protein regulates a cobalt-exporting variant CPx-type ATPase

CoaR associates with and confers cobalt-dependent activation of the coaT operator-promoter. A CoaR mutant (Ser-Asn-Ser) in a carboxyl-terminal Cys-His-Cys motif bound the coaT operator-promoter but did not activate expression in response to cobalt, implicating thiolate and/or imidazole ligands at these residues in an allosteric cobalt binding site. Deletion of 1 or 2 nucleotides from between near consensus, but with aberrant (20 base pairs) spacing, -10 and -35 elements enhanced expression from the coaT operator-promoter but abolished activation by cobalt-CoaR. It is inferred that cobalt effects a transition in CoaR that underwinds the coaT operator-promoter to realign promoter elements. In the absence of cobalt, CoaR represses expression (approximately 50%). CoaR is a fusion of ancestral MerR (mercury-responsive transcriptional activator)- and precorrin isomerase (enzyme of vitamin B(12) biosynthesis)-related sequences. Expression from the coaT operator-promoter was enhanced in a partial mutant of cbiE (encoding an enzyme preceding precorrin isomerase in B(12) biosynthesis), revealing that this pathway "inhibits" coaT expression. Disruption of coaT reduced cobalt tolerance and increased cytoplasmic (57)Co accumulation. coaT-mediated restoration of cobalt tolerance has been used as a selectable marker.

THE SHIKIMATE PATHWAY

The shikimate pathway links metabolism of carbohydrates to biosynthesis of aromatic compounds. In a sequence of seven metabolic steps, phosphoenolpyruvate and erythrose 4-phosphate are converted to chorismate, the precursor of the aromatic amino acids and many aromatic secondary metabolites. All pathway intermediates can also be considered branch point compounds that may serve as substrates for other metabolic pathways. The shikimate pathway is found only in microorganisms and plants, never in animals. All enzymes of this pathway have been obtained in pure form from prokaryotic and eukaryotic sources and their respective DNAs have been characterized from several organisms. The cDNAs of higher plants encode proteins with amino terminal signal sequences for plastid import, suggesting that plastids are the exclusive locale for chorismate biosynthesis. In microorganisms, the shikimate pathway is regulated by feedback inhibition and by repression of the first enzyme. In higher plants, no physiological feedback inhibitor has been identified, suggesting that pathway regulation may occur exclusively at the genetic level. This difference between microorganisms and plants is reflected in the unusually large variation in the primary structures of the respective first enzymes. Several of the pathway enzymes occur in isoenzymic forms whose expression varies with changing environmental conditions and, within the plant, from organ to organ. The penultimate enzyme of the pathway is the sole target for the herbicide glyphosate. Glyphosate-tolerant transgenic plants are at the core of novel weed control systems for several crop plants.

The AngR protein and the siderophore anguibactin positively regulate the expression of iron-transport genes in Vibrio anguillarum

Vibrio anguillarum virulence is associated with the presence of a plasmid-mediated iron-uptake system expressed under iron-limiting conditions, which consists of the siderophore anguibactin and specific iron-transport proteins. This system is maximally expressed under iron-limiting conditions and requires the AngR protein that acts as a positive regulator of anguibactin biosynthesis and also possess an EntE-like enzymatic function that may play a role in anguibactin biosynthesis. In this work, we demonstrate that in addition to possessing these functions related to anguibactin production, AngR also positively regulated transcription of the iron-transport genes fatA and fatB. We also show that transcription of angR is repressed by Fur under iron-rich conditions. In addition, we present evidence that anguibactin itself enhanced transcription of the iron-transport genes fatA and fatB, independently of AngR and the trans-acting factor (TAF) product(s). The presence of either AngR (together with the TAF product(s)) or anguibactin alone led to a partial level of expression of the iron-transport genes fatA and fatB, while full expression is achieved when AngR, the TAF products and anguibactin are all present.

The QUTA activator and QUTR repressor proteins of Aspergillus nidulans interact to regulate transcription of the quinate utilization pathway genese

Genetic evidence suggests that the activity of the native QUTA transcription activator protein is negated by the action of the QUTR transcription repressor protein. When Aspergillus nidulans was transformed with plasmids containing the wild-type qutA gene, transformants that constitutively expressed the quinate pathway enzymes were isolated. The constitutive phenotype of these transformants was associated with an increased copy number of the transforming qutA gene and elevated qutA mRNA levels. Conversely, when A. nidulans was transformed with plasmids containing the qutR gene under the control of the constitutive pgk promoter, transformants with a super-repressed phenotype (unable to utilize quinate as a carbon source) were isolated. The super-repressed phenotype of these transformants was associated with an increased copy number of the transforming qutR gene and elevated qutR mRNA levels. These copy-number-dependent phenotypes argue that the levels of the QUTA and QUTR proteins were elevated in the high-copy-number transformants. When diploid strains were formed by combining haploid strains that contained high copy numbers of either the qutA gene (constitutive phenotype) or the qutR gene (super-repressing; non-inducible phenotype), the resulting diploid phenotype was one of quinate-inducible production of the quinate pathway enzymes, in a manner similar to wild-type. The simplest interpretation of these observations is that the QUTR repressor protein mediates its repressing activity through a direct interaction with the QUTA activator protein. Other possible interpretations are discussed in the text. Experiments in which truncated versions of the QUTA protein were produced in the presence of a wild-type QUTA protein indicate that the QUTR repressor protein recognizes and binds to the C-terminal half of the QUTA activator protein.

Control of metabolic flux through the quinate pathway in Aspergillus nidulans

The quinic acid ulitization (qut) pathway in Aspergillus nidulans is a dispensable carbon utilization pathway that catabolizes quinate to protocatechuate via dehydroquinate and dehydroshikimate(DHS). At the usual in vitro growth pH of 6.5, quinate enters the mycelium by means of a specific permease and is converted into PCA by the sequential action of the enzymes quinate dehydrogenase, 3-dehydroquinase and DHS dehydratase. The extent of control on metabolic flux exerted by the permease and the three pathway enzymes was investigated by applying the techniques of Metabolic Control Analysis. The flux control coefficients for each of the three quinate pathway enzymes were determined empirically, and the flux control coefficient of the quinate permease was inferred by use of the summation theorem. There measurements implied that, under the standard growth conditions used, the values for the flux control coefficients of the components of the quinate pathway were: quinate permease, 0.43; quinate dehydrogenase, 0.36; dehydroquinase, 0.18; DHS dehydratase, <0,03. Attempts to partially decouple quinate permease from the control over flux by measuring flux at pH 3.5 (when a significant percentage of the soluble quinate is protonated and able to enter the mycelium without the aid of a permease) led to an increase of approx. 50% in the flux control coefficient for dehydroquinase. Taken together with the fact that A. nidulans has a very efficient pH homeostasis mechanism, these experiments are consistent with the view that quinate permease exerts a high degree of control over pathway flux under the standard laboratory growth conditions at pH 6.5. The enzymes quinate dehydrogenase and 3-dehydroquinase have previously been overproduced in Escherichia coli, and protocols for their purification published. The remaining qut pathway enzyme DHS dehydratase was overproduced in E. coli and a purification protocol established. The purified DHS dehydratase was shown to have a K(m) of 530 microM for its substrate DHS and a requirement for bivalent metal cations that could be fulfilled by Mg(2+), Mn(2+) or Zn(2+). All three qut pathway enzymes were purified in bulk and their elasticity coefficients with respect to the three quinate pathway intermediates were derived over a range of concentrations in a core tricine/NaOH buffer, augmented with necessary cofactors and bivalent cations as appropriate. Using these empirically determined relative values, in conjunction with the connectivity theorem, the relative ratios of the flux control coefficients for the various quinate pathway enzymes, and how this control shifts between them, was determined over a range of possible metabolic concentrations. These calculations, although clearly subject to caveates about the relationswhip between kinetic measurements in vitro and the situation in vivo, were able to successfully predict the hiearchy of control observed under the standard laboratory growth conditions. The calculations imply that the hierarchy of control exerted by the quinate pathway enzymes is stable and relatively insensitive to changing metabolite concentrations in the ranges most likely to correspond to those found in vivo. The effects of substituting the type I 3-dehydroquinases from Salmonella typhi and the A. nidulans AROM protein (a pentadomain protein catalysing the conversion of 3-deoxy-D-arabinoheptulosonic acid 7-phosphate into 5-enolpyruvylshikimate 3 phosphate), and the Mycobacterium tuberculosis type II 3-dehydroquinase, in the quinate pathway were investigated and found to have an effect. In the case of S. typhi and A. nidulans, overproduction of heterologous dehydroquinase led to a diminuation of pathway flux caused by a lowering of in vivo quinate dehydrogenase levels increased above those of the wild type. We speculate that these changes in qu

Comparative analysis of the QUTR transcription repressor protein and the three C-terminal domains of the pentafunctional AROM enzyme

The AROM protein is a pentadomain protein catalysing steps two to six in the prechorismate section of the shikimate pathway in microbial eukaryotes. On the basis of amino acid sequence alignments and the properties of mutants unable to utilize quinic acid as a carbon source, the AROM protein has been proposed to be homologous throughout its length with the proteins regulating transcription of the genes necessary for quinate catabolism. The QUTR transcription repressor protein has been proposed to be homologous with the three C-terminal domains of the AROM protein and one-fifth of the penultimate N-terminal domain. We report here the results of experiments designed to overproduce the QUTR and AROM proteins and their constituent domains in Escherichia coli, the purpose being to facilitate domain purification and (in the case of AROM), complementation of E. coli aro- mutations in order to probe the degree to which individual domains are stable and functional. The 3-dehydroquinate dehydratase domain of the AROM protein and the 3-dehydroquinate dehydratase-like domain of the QUTR spectroscopy and fluorescence emission spectroscopy. The CD spectra were found to be virtually superimposable. The fluorescence emission spectra of both domains had the signal from the tryptophan residues almost completely quenched, giving a tyrosine-dominated spectrum for both the AROM- and QUTR-derived domains. This unexpected observation was demonstrated to be due to a highly unusual environment provided by the tertiary structure, as addition of the denaturant guanidine hydrochloride gave a typical tryptophan-dominated spectrum for both domains. The spectroscopy experiments had the potential to refute the biologically-based proposal for a common origin for the AROM and QUTR proteins; however, the combined biophysical data are consistent with the hypothesis. We have previously reported that the AROM dehydroquinate synthase and 3-dehydroquinate dehydratase are stable and functional as individual domains, but that the 5-enol-pyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase is only active as part of the complete AROM protein or as a bi-domain fragment with dehydroquinate synthase. Here we report that the aromA gene (encoding the AROM protein) of Aspergillus nidulans contains a 53 nt intron in the extreme C-terminus of the shikimate dehydrogenase domain. This finding accounts for the previously reported observation that the AROM protein was unable to complement aroE- (lacking shikimate dehydrogenase) mutations in E. coli. When the intron is removed the correctly translated AROM protein is able to complement the E. coli aroE- mutation. An AROM-derived shikimate dehydrogenase domain is, however, non-functional, but function is restored in a bi-domain protein with e-dehydroquinate dehydratase. This interaction is not entirely specific, as substitution of the 3-dehydroquinate dehydratase domain with the glutathione S-transferase protein partially restores enzyme activity. Similarly an AROM-derived shikimate kinase domain is non-functional, but is functional as part of the complete AROM protein, or as a bi-domain protein with 3-dehydroquinate dehydratase.

Domain structure and function within the QUTA protein of Aspergillus nidulans: implications for the control of transcription

QUTA is a positively acting regulatory protein that regulates the expression of the eight genes comprising the quinic acid utilization gene (qut) gene cluster in Aspergillus nidulans. It has been proposed that the QUTA protein is composed of two domains that are related to the N-terminal two domains-dehydroquinate (DHQ) synthase and 5-enolpyruvyl shikimate-3-phosphate (EPSP) synthase-of the pentadomain AROM protein. The AROM protein is an enzyme catalysing five consecutive steps in the shikimate pathway, two of which are common to the qut pathway. A genetic and molecular analysis of non-inducible qutA mutants showed that all 23 mutations analysed map within the N-terminal half of the encoded QUTA protein. One dominant mutation (qutA382) introduces a stop codon at the boundary between the two domains that were identified on the basis of amino acid sequence alignments between the QUTA protein and the N-terminal two domains of the pentafunctional AROM protein. The truncated protein encoded by mutant qutA382 has DNA-binding ability but no transcription activation function. A second dominant mutation (in strain qutA214) is missense, changing 457E-->K in a region of localized high negative charge and potentially identifies a transcription activation domain in the N-terminus of the EPSP-synthase-like domain of the QUTA protein. A series of qualitative and quantitative Northern blot experiments with mRNA derived from wild-type and mutant qutA strains supported the view that the QUTA protein regulates the expression of the qut gene cluster, including the qutA gene which encodes it. A series of Western blot and zinc-binding experiments demonstrated that a putative zinc binuclear cluster motif located within the N-terminus of the QUTA protein is able to bind zinc in vitro.

The molecular biology of multidomain proteins. Selected examples

The aim of this review is to give an overview of the contribution molecular biology can make to an understanding of the functions and interactions within multidomain proteins. The contemporary advantages ascribed to multidomain proteins include (a) the potential for metabolite channelling and the protection of unstable intermediates; (b) the potential for interactions between domains catalysing sequential steps in a metabolic pathway, thereby giving the potential for allosteric interactions; and (c) the facility to produce enzymic activities in a fixed stoichiometric ratio. The alleged advantages in (a) and (b) however apply equally well to multi-enzyme complexes; therefore, specific examples of these phenomena are examined in multidomain proteins to determine whether the proposed advantages are apparent. Some transcription-regulating proteins active in the control of metabolic pathways are composed of multiple domains and their control is exerted and modulated at the molecular level by protein-DNA, protein-protein and protein-metabolite interactions. These complex recognition events place strong constraints upon the proteins involved, requiring the recognition of and interaction with different classes of cellular metabolites and macromolecules. Specific examples of transcription-regulating proteins are examined to probe how their multidomain nature facilitates a general solution to the problem of multiple recognition events. A general unifying theme that emerges from these case studies is that a basic unitary design of modules provided by enzymes is exploited to produce multidomain proteins by a complex series of gene duplication and fusion events. Successful modules provided by enzymes are co-opted to new function by selection apparently acting upon duplicated copies of the genes encoding the enzymes. In multidomain transcription-regulating proteins, former enzyme modules can be recruited as molecular sensors that facilitate presumed allosteric interactions necessary for the molecular control of transcription.

Evolution of transcription-regulating proteins by enzyme recruitment: molecular models for nitrogen metabolite repression and ethanol utilisation in eukaryotes

Studies on the quinic acid utilisation gene (qut) cluster in Aspergillus nidulans showed that the genes encoding transcriptional activator and repressor proteins evolved by co-opting duplicated copies of genes encoding metabolic enzymes. In order to test the hypothesis that this was a general route for the genesis of regulatory proteins, the origins of the major control protein mediating nitrogen metabolite repression (an example of inter-pathway regulation) and ethanol utilisation (an example of intra-pathway regulation) in filamentous fungi were sought. The regulatory proteins mediating nitrogen metabolite repression were deduced to have originated in a duplication of genes encoding the anthranilate synthase complex which is active in the shikimate pathway. The major protein regulating ethanol utilisation was deduced to have its origin in the fusion of duplicated genes encoding the aldehyde and alcohol dehydrogenases (ALDA and ALCA). These data strongly support the view that transcriptional regulatory proteins evolve by the recruitment of functional domains provided by metabolic enzymes.

Efficient independent activity of a monomeric, monofunctional dehydroquinate synthase derived from the N-terminus of the pentafunctional AROM protein of Aspergillus nidulans

The dehydroquinate synthase (DHQ synthase) functional domain from the pentafunctional AROM protein of Aspergillus nidulans has previously been overproduced in Escherichia coli [van den Hombergh, Moore, Charles and Hawkins (1992) Biochem J. 284, 861-867]. We now report the purification of this domain to homogeneity and subsequent characterization. The monofunctional DHQ synthase was found to retain efficient catalytic activity when compared with the intact pentafunctional AROM protein of Neurospora crassa [Lambert, Boocock and Coggins (1985) Biochem J. 226, 817-829]. The apparent kcat. was estimated to be 8 s-1, and the apparent Km values for NAD+ and 3-deoxy-D-arabino-heptulosonate phosphate (DAHP) were 3 microM and 2.2 microM respectively. These values are similar to those reported for the intact N. crassa enzyme, except that the apparent Km for NAD+ reported here is 15-fold higher. The monofunctional DHQ synthase domain is inactivated by treatment with chelating agents in the absence of substrates and is re-activated by the addition of metal ions; among those tested, Zn2+ gave the highest kcat./Km value. The enzyme is inactivated by diethyl pyrocarbonate; both the substrate, DAHP, and the product phosphate protected against inactivation. Size-exclusion chromatography suggested an M(r) of 43,000 for the monofunctional domain, indicating that it is monomeric and compactly folded. The c.d. spectrum confirmed that the domain has a compact globular conformation; the near-u.v. c.d. of zinc- and cobalt-reactivated domains were superimposable.