Antigenic diversity of respiratory syncytial viruses and its implication for immunoprophylaxis in ruminants

Infection of differentiated airway epithelial cells from caprine lungs by viruses of the bovine respiratory disease complex

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV), bovine parainfluenza virus type 3 (BPIV3) and bovine herpesvirus type 1 (BHV-1) are important pathogens associated with the bovine respiratory disease complex (BRDC). Non-bovine ruminants such as goats may also be infected and serve as a virus reservoir to be considered in the development of control strategies. To evaluate the susceptibility of caprine airway epithelial cells to infection by viruses of BRDC, we established a culture system for differentiated caprine epithelial cells. For this purpose, we generated precision-cut lung slices (PCLS), in which cells are retained in their original structural configuration and remain viable for more than a week. The three bovine viruses were found to preferentially infect different cell types. Ciliated epithelial cells were the major target cells of BPIV3, whereas BHV-1 preferred basal cells. Cells infected by BRSV were detected in submucosal cell layers. This spectrum of susceptible cells is the same as that reported recently for infected bovine PCLS. While infection of caprine cells by BRSV and BPIV3 was as efficient as that reported for bovine cells, infection of caprine cells by BHV-1 required a tenfold higher dose of infectious virus as compared to infection of bovine airway cells. These results support the notion that non-bovine ruminants may serve as a reservoir for viruses of BRDC and introduce a culture system to analyze virus infection of differentiated airway epithelial cells from the caprine lung.

Phylogenetic relationships of Brazilian bovine respiratory syncytial virus isolates and molecular homology modeling of attachment glycoprotein

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) causes lower respiratory tract disease in young cattle. Recently, it was possible to determine the sequence of the G protein gene, which plays a role in the attachment of BRSV particles to the cells, from three distinct Brazilian isolates. The phylogenetic analysis conducted here using those sequences compared to other worldwide distributed isolates of BRSV allow us to allocate Brazilian strains within the subgroup B, which was no longer found in the world since the 1970s. One of the Brazilian strains has a major mutation between amino acid residues 173 and 178, within the central hydrophobic conserved region, exactly on the site of two of the four cysteine-noose forming cysteine residues. Homology modeling with the previously determined NMR structure of this protein domain was made to check whether these mutations altered the three-dimensional conformation of this immunodominant region. Possible consequences on the biological effects induced by such mutation on the G protein are discussed.

Protection against bovine respiratory syncytial virus challenge following a single dose of vaccine in young calves with maternal antibody

Twenty-one young calves with maternally derived antibody to bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) were divided into three groups of seven, each group balanced for BRSV antibody titre. The calves had no evidence of previous exposure to BRSV. The calves in one group were given a single dose of a monovalent modified live BRSV vaccine; the calves in the second group were given a single dose of an inactivated combined BRSV, parainfluenza virus type 3, Mannheimia haemolytica vaccine and the calves in the third group were left as unvaccinated controls. Three weeks after the single doses of vaccine, all the calves were challenged with BRSV. The clinical signs of disease were mild, and virus excretion was limited to two calves in the group given the inactivated vaccine, compared with six in the negative controls (P = 0.05) and five in the group given the live vaccine. The mean virus excretion titres after the challenge were not significantly different between the groups. There was little seroconversion before the challenge, but six of the seven calves in the group given the inactivated vaccine showed significant seroconversion within two weeks after the challenge, compared with only one calf in each of the other two groups (P = 0.015).

Evaluation of efficacy of an inactivated vaccine against bovine respiratory syncytial virus in calves with maternal antibodies

OBJECTIVE

To assess short- and long-term efficacy of an inactivated bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) vaccine administered i.m. to calves with maternally derived antibodies.

ANIMALS

28 two-week-old calves with neutralizing, maternally derived antibodies against BRSV.

PROCEDURE

For evaluation of short-term efficacy, 6 calves were vaccinated i.m. at 2 and 6 weeks of age and challenged intranasally and intratracheally along with a matched group of 4 unvaccinated control calves at 10 weeks of age. For evaluation of long-term efficacy, 2 groups of 6 calves each were vaccinated i.m. at 2, 6, and 18 weeks of age or 14 and 18 weeks of age; these calves were challenged intranasally and intratracheally along with 6 matched unvaccinated control calves at 43 weeks of age. Serum virus neutralizing antibody titer, clinical reactions, and virus shedding in nasal mucus and lung washings were assessed.

RESULTS

None of the vaccination regimens resulted in a significant increase in serum virus neutralizing antibody titer. As judged by virus shedding in nasal mucus and lung washings, vaccinated calves were protected against challenge, compared with unvaccinated control groups. Clinical signs attributable to challenge were coughing (short-term efficacy study) and tachypnea and dyspnea (long-term efficacy study). The severity and incidence of disease were significantly lower in the vaccinated groups, compared with that in the unvaccinated groups.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Through vaccination, it is possible to protect vulnerable calves with maternal antibodies against BRSV infection and reduce respiratory tract disease.

Animal pneumoviruses: molecular genetics and pathogenesis

Pneumoviruses are single-stranded, negative-sense, nonsegmented RNA viruses of the family Paramyxoviridae, subfamily Pneumovirinae, and include pathogens that infect humans (respiratory syncytial virus and human metapneumovirus), domestic mammals (bovine, ovine, and caprine respiratory syncytial viruses), rodents (pneumonia virus of mice), and birds (avian metapneumovirus). Among the topics considered in this review are recent studies focused on the roles of the individual virus-encoded components in promoting virus replication as well as in altering and evading innate antiviral host defenses. Advances in the molecular technology of pneumoviruses and the emergence of recombinant pneumoviruses that are leading to improved virus-based vaccine formulations are also discussed. Since pneumovirus infection in natural hosts is associated with a profound inflammatory response that persists despite adequate antiviral therapy, we also review the recent experimental treatment strategies that have focused on combined antiviral, anti-inflammatory, and immunomodulatory approaches.

Priming of multiple T cell subsets by modified-live and inactivated bovine respiratory syncytial virus vaccines

T cell activity is a critical component of immunity to bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV). We tested the effects of immunization by modified-live and inactivated BRSV vaccines on cell-mediated and humoral immunity in young calves. The two forms of vaccine stimulated similar serum neutralizing antibody production, although the early kinetics of those responses differed. CD4+, CD8+, and gammadelta T cells were analyzed before and after immunization for BRSV-specific in vitro recall responses, as evaluated by CD25 upregulation measured by flow cytometry. Modified-live virus (MLV) primed each of the three subsets for statistically significant in vitro responses to antigen. Inactivated vaccine also primed each T cell population for significant antigen-driven CD25 upregulation, including responses by CD4+ and gammadelta T cells that were stronger and longer-lasting than those primed by MLV. Monoclonal antibody was used in additional assays to block MHC class I during incubation of BRSV antigen with peripheral blood mononuclear cells from an animal in the inactivated vaccine group. The recall response by CD8+ T cells was more inhibited by this treatment than the other subsets, further suggesting that the inactivated vaccine had primed antigen-specific CD8+ T cells. In summary, the data indicate that balanced BRSV-specific T cell responses can be induced by inactivated, as well as modified-live, conventional vaccines, which may implicate an alternative pathway of MHC class I antigen presentation.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus can induce apoptosis in MDBK cultured cells

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) is a major cause of respiratory disease in calves. BRSV infection is associated with epithelial cell death and inflammation. Over the past few years, a growing number of viruses have been found to induce apoptosis. In order to determine the ability of BRSV to induce apoptosis, we studied the effect of BRSV infection in cultured MDBK cells. We used ligation-mediated PCR assay to detect specific blunt-end cellular DNA fragments produced by cellular endonucleases cleaving the genomic DNA between the nucleosomes during apoptosis. We found that BRSV infection resulted in apoptosis in MDBK cells. This data demonstrates for the first time that BRSV can induce apoptosis. This data also may contribute to delineate the mechanisms that regulate tissue injury and potential lung repair following BRSV infection.

Validation of synthetic peptide enzyme immunoassays in differentiating two subgroups of ruminant respiratory syncytial virus

Subgroup-specific peptide-based enzyme immunoassays from each respective G-glycoprotein of the ovine and the bovine respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) were developed to detect RSV-specific IgG responses in cattle. Antigenic peptides from the respective G-glycoprotein were identified from the extracellular central hydrophobic region (amino acids 158-189) located between 2 mucin-rich regions. These antigenic peptides identified by epitope mapping from each G-glycoprotein were synthesized and used to develop the subgroup-specific enzyme immunoassays. The negative cutoff for each enzyme immunoassay was established as the mean optical density of indirect immunofluorescent antibody-negative bovine sera plus 3 SDs. The sensitivity (82.9%) and specificity (100%) of the bovine enzyme immunoassay and the specificity (95.8%) of the ovine enzyme immunoassay were determined by comparison with indirect immunofluorescence (used as the "gold standard"). The negative and positive predictive values were calculated for each assay. The presence of serum antibody to ovine RSV in cattle implies that this virus infects cattle and may contribute to the pathogenesis of bovine respiratory disease.

Prevalence of ovine and bovine respiratory syncytial virus infections in cattle determined with a synthetic peptide-based immunoassay

Subgroup-specific peptide-based enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays from the G-protein of the ovine and bovine respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), respectively, were used to determine the prevalence of the ovine and bovine subgroup strains of RSV infections in cattle. A total of 1,102 bovine serum samples were obtained from 6 diagnostic laboratories located in the northwestern and the southeastern USA and were tested for antibody to either the bovine or ovine subgroups of RSV. Antibody to viruses from each subgroup was present in samples from each region and all states tested. The Southeast had a higher prevalence of the bovine subgroup strains (69.5%). Then did the Northwest (40.9%). The prevalence of the ovine strain was similar for the two regions (16.7% in the southeast, 14.9% in the northwest). The overall prevalence was 56.6% for the bovine strain and 15.9% for the ovine strain. These results suggest members of the ovine subgroup of RSV circulate in the cattle population but with less frequency than those viruses of the bovine subgroup.

A bovine respiratory syncytial virus strain with mutations in subgroup-specific antigenic domains of the G protein induces partial heterologous protection in cattle

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV) strains are tentatively divided in subgroups A, AB and B, based on antigenic differences of the G protein. A Dutch BRSV strain (Waiboerhoeve: WBH), could not be assigned to one of the subgroups, because the strain did not react with any monoclonal antibody against the G protein. We describe here that the WBH strain has accumulated critical mutations in subgroup-specific domains of the G protein gene, which also occur but then independently in G protein genes of BRSV subgroup A or B strains. Although the comparison of nucleotide residues 256-792 of the G gene of the WBH strain with those of subgroup A and B strains showed that the G gene of the WBH strain is different from that of BRSV subgroup A and B strains, the sequence divergence was not more than observed within the G genes of human respiratory syncytial virus subgroup A or B strains. The WBH strain did not induce severe disease after experimental infection of calves, and induced partial protection against a heterologous challenge. Despite the dissimilarity of the conserved central regions of the G protein of the WBH strain and that of the challenge strain, a secondary antibody response against this region was induced in WBH-infected calves after challenge. We conclude that complete BRSV virus can partially protect against a BRSV infection with a strain that contains an antigenic dissimilar G protein.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus

Since the first report of BRSV in the 1970s, the understanding of this agent and its respective disease has increased dramatically. Current evidence supports a major role for this virus in bovine respiratory disease. Advances in diagnostics have increased the ability to demonstrate this virus in field outbreaks of respiratory disease. The clinical signs and pathologic features have been well described, and vaccines are available to aid in prevention and control. Still, many questions remain to be answered with respect to BRSV. It appears there may be antigenic subgroups of BRSV, but the epidemiologic significance and relevance to immunization of this remains unknown. The question of differences in virulence among isolates of this virus has yet to be addressed. From an epidemiologic standpoint, the means by which BRSV perpetuates in the cattle population has yet to be elucidated. Although progress has been made in understanding the pathogenesis and immune response to BRSV, the mechanism of disease production and immune protection is incomplete. Lastly, efficacy testing of existing vaccines need to continue, as well as the development of new vaccines and new approaches to vaccination.

Sequence conservation in the attachment glycoprotein and antigenic diversity among bovine respiratory syncytial virus isolates

Partial nucleotide sequences were determined from the coding regions of the attachment glycoprotein (G) mRNAS of eight isolates of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (BRSV). The antigenic characteristics of 18 field and reference isolates were analyzed using the reactivity patterns of monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) directed against the human respiratory syncytial virus (HRSV) and BRSV G. fusion protein (F), nucleoprotein (N), and phosphoprotein (P), by radioimmunoprecipitation and immunofluorescence assays. The MAb reaction patterns demonstrated some random antigenic differences among the isolates, but for the most part were cross-reactive to the viral protein epitopes, especially on the F protein. Structural differences in the F and P proteins were observed among BRSV isolates; the P protein migrated at three different apparent molecular weights on PAGE gels. Antigenic and structural variation occurs among isolates, however, the structural differences in the P protein did not correlate with the antigenic differences among the F, N and P proteins. The G mRNA nucleotide sequence identities were high, ranging from 94.1 to 99.9%, and the predicted amino acid sequence identities ranged from 89.9 to 99.6%. Variance was due to substitution point mutations. The G protein ectodomains contained areas of sequence divergence flanking a highly conserved region, with four cysteine residues, which is analogous to the putative HRSV receptor binding domain. The high sequence and amino acid identities and random antigenic diversity among the isolates indicates that the BRSV isolates analyzed belong in a monophyletic group.

Subgrouping of bovine respiratory syncytial virus strains detected in lung tissue

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus is an important respiratory pathogen in cattle. Recently, subgroups of BRSV have been identified, based on antigenic differences. However, little is known about subgroups of BRSV that circulate in the cattle population. Therefore, we determined the reactivity of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs), directed against the G, F, or P protein of BRSV, with lung tissue from 47 calves, that suffered from severe respiratory disease. Fourteen animals (30%) proved to be infected with BRSV, because they all reacted with mAbs against the P or F protein, as detected by fluorescent antibody tests. Monoclonal antibodies against the G protein were able to discriminate between the BRSV-positive specimens: 7 strains were identified as subgroup A strains, and 5 strains as subgroup AB, which is introduced as BRSV subgroup in this paper. Two strains could not be identified unambiguously. It is concluded that BRSV subgroup A and AB were associated with severe respiratory disease, and that strains belonging to either subgroup circulated concurrently in the cattle population in the Netherlands.

Bovine respiratory syncytial virus antibodies in non-bovine species

To study the role of non-bovine species in the epidemiology of bovine respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) infections, sera obtained from 9 non-bovine animal species and from humans were examined for bovine RSV specific antibodies. Sera were mainly from animals and humans which had been in contact with cattle. Forty sera of each species were tested in an RSV specific whole virus ELISA as well as in a peptide based ELISA, that was developed to measure antibodies specific for bovine RSV. Antibodies directed against RSV were detected in over 50% of sera obtained from sheep, goat, cattle and human beings, and anti-RSV activity was also found in some roe and dogs and one horse. Antibodies to bovine RSV were found in sera of all tested cattle, 11 (27.5%) goats and in some other individual animals: 3 horses, 2 roe, 1 cat and 1 dog. These results indicate that of the investigated species, besides cattle only goats might play a role in the epidemiology of bovine RSV.