The induction and acceleration of labour: some benefits and complications

Induction of labor: an integrated review

Women's response to induction and augmentation of labor has received little attention in North America. A review of the literature revealed that these procedures epitomize the use of technology in childbirth. From a psycho-emotional perspective, women respond less positively to induction and augmentation than to spontaneous labor and report less satisfaction with the birth experience. In this review of the research and anecdotal literature, reasons for inattention to induction and augmentation are explored, and the nature of the procedures and women's response to them are examined.

Outcomes of care in birth centers. The National Birth Center Study

We studied 11,814 women admitted for labor and delivery to 84 free-standing birth centers in the United States and followed their course and that of their infants through delivery or transfer to a hospital and for at least four weeks thereafter. The women were at lower-than-average risk of a poor outcome of pregnancy, according to many but not all of the recognized demographic and behavioral risk factors. Among the women, 70.7 percent had only minor complications or none; 7.9 percent had serious emergency complications during labor and delivery or soon thereafter, such as thick meconium or severe shoulder dystocia. One woman in six (15.8 percent) was transferred to a hospital; 2.4 percent had emergency transfers. Twenty-nine percent of nulliparous women and only 7 percent of parous women were transferred, but the frequency of emergency transfers was the same. The rate of cesarean section was 4.4 percent. There were no maternal deaths. The overall intrapartum and neonatal mortality rate was 1.3 per 1000 births. The rates of infant mortality and low Apgar scores were similar to those reported in large studies of low-risk hospital births. We conclude that birth centers offer a safe and acceptable alternative to hospital confinement for selected pregnant women, particularly those who have previously had children, and that such care leads to relatively few cesarean sections.

The use of epidural bupivacaine for the relief of childbirth pain

Epidural anaesthesia is now a widely used method for pain relief in childbirth, particularly using the drug Bupivacaine. There are nevertheless differing opinions in the research literature about the advisability of its routine use. While it is clearly very effective in relieving labour pain, there are some consistent, troublesome patterns; for example, a strong association between epidural use and other interventions, such as instrumental delivery. Further, there are no clear answers from the research to date concerning the risks and benefits of epidural anaesthesia for infant and mother. Answers could be provided by randomized clinical trials, but meanwhile a conservative approach to its use is recommended for uncomplicated labours.

Characteristics and motives of women choosing elective induction of labour

Personal characteristics of healthy term pregnant women who chose elective induction or spontaneous onset of labour and the motives for their choice were assessed. Almost 50% of 237 women with uncomplicated pregnancies opted for elective induction when offered the opportunity. These women appeared to have had more complaints during their pregnancy and menstrual periods, more complications in their obstetrical history and to be more anxious about their labour than women who chose a spontaneous onset of labour. Predominant motives were a feeling of safety and the desire to shorten the duration of pregnancy. These characteristics and motives seem to reflect a lack of trust in physical reproductive functions. It is concluded that in evaluating effects of elective induction of labour, pre-existing differences between women who choose elective induction and women who opt for a spontaneous onset must be taken into account.

Ambulation versus oxytocin in protracted labour: a pilot study

We compared ambulation with oxytocin in the treatment of protracted labour with a randomized, controlled trial of 57 patients. Sixty percent of the women in the ambulant group delivered their babies without oxytocin. In the ambulant group, the mean length of the second stage of labour was shorter and the women themselves held relatively positive views on their experiences. In the oxytocin group, on the other hand, the women experienced stronger contractions before pushing and also suffered from more excessively strong contractions. Our trial included too few women to judge which treatment is better for the infant's health. Nevertheless, the women's opinions and the quality of their contractions demonstrate that more attention should be paid to ambulation as a treatment for protracted labour.

Elective induction of labor: a prospective clinical study, II: Psychological effects

Several authors have stated that induction of labor may have deleterious psychological effects on women's experiences of labor and early mother-infant interaction. Research on this subject is scarce and in most cases no distinction is made between elective induction and induction for medical reasons. For that reason the observed effects may also have been caused by the medical complications that led to the induction. Differences in experience of labor may also be in part explained by differences in personal characteristics between women choosing or rejecting induction of labor. Influences of induction of labor can only be reliably assessed in prospective studies. In the present study of 271 women with an uncomplicated pregnancy, data regarding their experiences of pregnancy and their expectations of labor and motherhood were collected before labor. In 72 women labor was electively induced, and 199 women had a spontaneous onset of labor. Of 33 women, 19 with spontaneous labor and 14 with elective induction, the first contact with their newborn was observed. All women who could be contacted were interviewed about their experience of labor and the first contact with their infant. Six months after delivery the mothers were questioned about the state of health of mother and infant and about nursing the infant. Mothers with induced labor were rated as being generally less emotionally involved in the first contact with their newborn than mothers with spontaneous labor, but the differences were not significant (Fig. 1). The duration of spontaneous labor was longer, but the subjective time experience did not differ between groups. Women with spontaneous labor were more tired during labor.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Weight of all births and infant mortality

Birth weight is the most important determinant of perinatal and infant mortality. The lowest mortality rates in the first week of life are recorded among newborn infants weighing 3500 g or more and the proportion of such infants may be regarded as a measure of optimality of the birth population. There is an inverse relationship between the proportion of heavy newborn infants in a country and its infant mortality rate. In both these respects Iceland, Norway, and Sweden have better experience than England and Wales, Denmark, and the United States of America. The effects of parity, maternal age, social class, and smoking are considered, but it appears that there are still factors that inhibit the intrauterine growth potential of American, British, and Danish fetuses. Elective delivery, use of diuretics, and restriction of diet in pregnancy have shifted the birth distribution to the left and this may have more than counterbalanced the possible beneficial effects. These other factors may adversely affect birthweight distribution in North America and Europe to such an extent as to limit or even damage the favourable position already achieved in health and social development as measured by fetal survival.

Children born after elective induction of labour

A comparison was made between the performance at eight years of age of 63 children who were born after elective induction of labour, and 29 spontaneously born children. The children had been tested previously at five years of age. Tests of reading and arithmetic achievement, visuomotor coordination, aural-visual coordination, auditory discrimination, and behavioural rating scales were administered. On two of the 12 measures (reading comprehension and euroticism) the induced children performed better than the spontaneously born. On all other measures there were no significant differences. There appeared to be no evidence of specific learning disabilities or behavioural problems among the induced children.

Induction of labour by different methods in primiparous women. II. Neuro-behavioural status of the infants

The infants of primiparous women in whom labour had been induced by three different methods were studied, together with a fourth group (D) who had laboured spontaneously. The methods of induction were: amniotomy followed by intravenous oxytocin (A), amniotomy followed by intravenous prostaglandin E2 (B), and prostaglandin E2 by the extra-amniotic route (C). Neurological assessments were made on the first day after birth, 4 days later, and at the age of 2 mth. No significant associations were found between method of delivery and neurological scores at any age. On day 1 infants with a lower Apgar score at 1 min had a lower neurological score than those with a high Apgar score (P < 0.05). On day 5 infants with a high serum bilirubin level (> 207 mumol/l) had a lower mean neurological score than those with a lower recorded serum bilirubin level (P < 0.05). By the age of 2 mth this difference had increased still further (P > 0.001). No differences were found in the mean neurological scores of infants in the four groups during the neonatal period, but at the age of 2 mth the mean score for infants in group A was significantly lower than that for infants in group C (P > 0.05) and D (P > 0.01). Among those children seen again at the age of 18 mth fine-motor adaptive performance was poorer for infants in group A than in groups B (P > 0.05), C (P > 0.005) and D (P > 0.01).