Ageing of hamster embryo fibroblasts as the result of both differentiation and stochastic mechanisms

MUTATION LOAD AND THE SURVIVAL OF SMALL POPULATIONS

Previous attempts to model the joint action of selection and mutation in finite populations have treated population size as being independent of the mutation load. However, the accumulation of deleterious mutations is expected to cause a gradual reduction in population size. Consequently, in small populations random genetic drift will progressively overpower selection making it easier to fix future mutations. This synergistic interaction, which we refer to as a mutational melt-down, ultimately leads to population extinction. For many conditions, the coefficient of variation of extinction time is less than 0.1, and for species that reproduce by binary fission, the expected extinction time is quite insensitive to population carrying capacity. These results are consistent with observations that many cultures of ciliated protozoans and vertebrate fibroblasts have characteristic extinction times. The model also predicts that clonal lineages are unlikely to survive more than 10⁴ to 10⁵ generations, which is consistent with existing data on parthenogenetic animals. Contrary to the usual view that Muller's ratchet does more damage when selection is weak, we show that the mean extinction time declines as mutations become more deleterious. Although very small sexual populations, such as self-fertilized lines, are subject to mutational meltdowns, recombination effectively eliminates the process when the effective population size exceeds a dozen or so. The concept of the effective mutation load is developed, and several procedures for estimating it are described. It is shown that this load can be reduced substantially when mutational effects are highly variable.

Cellular aging and the importance of energetic factors

The in vitro aging of human fibroblasts has become a classical model for studying cellular aging. This model was lately redefined by showing that these cells represent a stem cell system in which they progressively pass through seven morphotypes. Experimental data showed that external conditions that can be considered as stresses for the cells, can modulate the genome expression by speeding up the passage of the cells from one morphotype to the other. In this article, we will interpret these observations from the point of view of the thermodynamics of far from equilibrium open systems, which shows the importance of the production and the use of energy, both responsible for the generation of a given amount of entropy production. In stable systems like these cell morphotypes, such a production is constant but external stresses can prematurely destabilize the steady state of entropy production and, in doing so, accelerate the process of aging. It is also predicted that cells submitted to a stress will use part of their energy in response to the stress. Some experimental data in favor of such an interpretation have been obtained and more will be presented here that show that both cell death and accelerated cell aging under stress are modulated by the level of energy metabolism. All theoretical and experimental arguments presented in this article will show that cellular aging is related to stress and also to energy production through a very elaborate system of regulatory processes necessary for the cell to survive and to perform specific functions according to its differentiated state. This regulatory system also permits the cell to adapt its response according to the intensity of external as well as internal challenges and one of these responses will influence the cellular aging rate.

Gestation stage-specific frequency of adipogenic cells in Syrian hamster cell cultures

High frequencies (up to 50%) of spontaneous adipocyte differentiation are observed in cultures of 9 day gestation Syrian hamster embryos (E9 cells) within six to eight population doublings after primary culture. This is in contrast to the absence of adipogenic cells in primary cultures derived from later gestation age Syrian hamster tissue. In addition, E9 primary cultures contain a transient subpopulation of presumptive mesenchymal stem or progenitor cells that lack density dependent inhibition of growth [contact-insensitive (CS-) cells]. Analysis of the temporal pattern of expression of the CS- and adipocyte phenotypes during the proliferative life span of E9 cells demonstrates that maximal expression of the CS- phenotype precedes maximal expression of adipocyte differentiation. In addition, lipid accumulation appears to occur primarily, if not exclusively, in the contact-sensitive (CS+) cells that are derived from CS- cells. These observations suggest that primary E9 cultures contain either adipoblasts or primordial mesenchymal cells that become determined to the adipocyte lineage early during the in vitro life span of the cultures, and that the CS- phenotype may be a marker for these earlier developmental cell stages.

Atypical stromal giant cells of cervix uteri--evidence of Schwann cell origin

The report describes atypical multinucleated giant cells adjacent to proliferated nerve fascicles in a circumscribed subepithelial area of the cervix uteri of a 44-year-old multipara. Ultrastructural examination revealed cytoplasmatic processes, basal lamina, intracytoplasmic microfibrils, bizarre nuclear shapes with pseudoinclusions and nuclear fragments connected by small chromatin bridges (nucleotesimals). Immunohistochemical examination showed positive staining for vimentin and S-100 protein. Quantitative topography exhibited an isotropic distribution of the giant cells in an anisotropic architecture of mononuclear cells. A Schwann cell origin of the atypical giant cells is postulated. Aetiopathogenetically the lesion is regarded to be due to a trauma during delivery followed by regenerative proliferation of nerve fascicles and degenerative alterations of proliferating Schwann cells. The knowledge of this lesion is considered important, because the atypical cells could be confounded with malignant neoplastic cells.

Involvement of microtubules in modifications associated with cellular aging

Microtubules are ubiquitous cellular components involved in the control of cell structure and functions, such as cell division, regulation of shape and polarity, intracellular transport, etc. Consequently, any alteration affecting them in structure or function has a good chance of affecting the cell and generally leads to cell dysfunctions. This has been shown for instance, after treatment with microtubule-interacting drugs. Cellular aging is also characterized by the appearance of various cell dysfunctions, but the possible involvement of the microtubules in the aging process, although a rather tempting hypothesis, has not yet been extensively investigated. In this paper, I will first rapidly review the different components that build, organize and control the microtubules in normal cells, independently of the aging process. I will then consider the possible involvement of the microtubules in the aging process, more particularly in models of cells aging in vitro and in aging neuronal cells, which have been the most extensively investigated. There is some evidence for alterations in the microtubule organization both in cells aging in vitro and in the aging brain. But the interpretation of these data awaits further experiments, taking into account the latest progress in tubulin genetics and in microtubule biochemistry. Microtubules could also represent one of the cellular targets affected after signal transduction and could thus be involved in the resulting cellular responses. This hypothesis will be discussed, as it offers new insights into the regulation of microtubule organization, dynamics and functions in normal cells, which will be worthwhile to investigate during the aging process.

Two classes of continuous cell lines established from Syrian hamster 9 day gestation embryos: preneoplastic cells and progenitor cells

Primary cultures of 9-d-gestation Syrian hamster embryo (E9) cells are distinct from primary cultures of later gestational age in terms of their growth and differentiation. First, primary E9 cell cultures express multiple mesenchymal differentiation lineages (e.g., adipocyte, myoblast) only rarely seen in cultures of 13-d-gestation fetal (F13) cells. Second, although most primary E9 cultures have a limited in vitro proliferative life span and exhibit cellular senescence similar to primary cultures of F13 cells, E9 cultures seem to have higher frequency of escape from senescence and conversion to continuous cell lines compared to F13 cells. Moreover, this frequency can be further increased 4- to 5-fold by continuous exposure of the E9 cells to tumor promoters or epidermal growth factor. Eleven continuous cell lines have been isolated from untreated, promoter-treated, or epidermal growth factor-treated primary E9 cultures. Seven of these are neoplastic or preneoplastic. However, the remaining four do not show any evidence of being in neoplastic progression and three of these continue to express the same differentiated phenotype observed in ther parental primary cell cultures.

Age, anatomic site, and the replication and differentiation of adipocyte precursors

The effects of donor age and anatomic site on cellular replication and differentiation were studied in adipocyte precursors cloned from epididymal and perirenal depots of young, middle-aged, and senescent rats. As animals aged from 3 to 29 mo, there was a progressive reduction in the proportion of cells capable of extensive replication in both depots. An inverse relation between clonal capacity for replication and differentiation was found. This relation was affected by donor site but not age. Aging was, however, associated with a reduction in the frequency of clones capable of full differentiation into cells with single, large, central lipid inclusions. Hence, age and donor site may affect adipocyte precursor replication and differentiation by different mechanisms.

Independent evidence for a commitment model of clonal attenuation

We previously reported a model of clonal attenuation which assumes three classes of cells: small highly replicative cells; intermediate size cells of limited replicative potential and large non-diving cells. Computer simulations carried out with the model lead to predictions of how the relative proportion of each cell type varies throughout the in vitro replicative life span of a mass population. These predictions appear to be broadly confirmed by independent data recently reported by another laboratory.

Human skin fibroblasts in vitro differentiate along a terminal cell lineage

Secondary mitotic human skin fibroblast populations in vitro underwent 53 +/- 6 cumulative population doublings (CPD) in 302 +/- 27 days. When the growth capacity of the mitotic fibroblasts is exhausted, and if appropriate methods are applied, the fibroblasts differentiate spontaneously into postmitotic fibroblast populations, which were kept in stationary culture for up to 305 +/- 41 additional days. Mitotic and postmitotic fibroblast populations are heterogeneous populations with reproducible changes in the proportions of mitotic fibroblasts F I, F II, and F III, and postmitotic fibroblasts F IV, F V, F VI, and F VII. This process makes it evident that the fibroblasts differentiate spontaneously along a seven-stage terminal cell lineage F I-F II-F III-F IV-F V-F VI-F VII. Shifts in the frequencies of the mitotic and postmitotic fibroblasts in mass populations are accompanied by alterations in the [35S]methionine polypeptide pattern of the developing mass populations. The [35S]methionine polypeptide patterns of homogeneous subpopulations of F I, F II, F III, F IV, F V, and F VI isolated from heterogeneous mass populations reveal that the six fibroblast morphotypes studied express their cell-type-specific [35S]methionine polypeptide pattern in the heterogeneous mass populations.

Reversible inhibition of DNA and protein synthesis by cumene hydroperoxide and 4-hydroxy-nonenal

To test the possible role of lipid peroxidation in the process of in vitro ageing, human diploid skin fibroblasts were cultured with the lipophilic hydroperoxide cumene hydroperoxide (Chp) or the breakdown product of lipid peroxidation 4-hydroxy-2,3-trans-nonenal (HNE). Both compounds inhibited cellular DNA and protein synthesis in a dose-dependent way. Cells exposed to Chp or to HNE during growth inhibition recovered DNA and protein synthesis within 24 h upon removal of Chp or HNE from the culture medium. Continuously proliferating cells showed only a partial recovery of DNA and protein synthesis. Pre-culturing cells with the lipophilic free radical scavenger vitamin E did not abolish the effect of Chp upon DNA synthesis. Cellular levels of reduced glutathione (GSH) rose slightly during 1 week of culture with HNE, but remained unaltered with Chp. Neither ATP levels nor cellular energy charges were affected during culture with Chp or HNE. So, DNA synthesis is not impaired due to a shortage of nucleotides nor does GSH protect DNA synthesis against the effects of Chp or HNE. These results suggest that oxygen free-radical induced lipid peroxidation is not the cause of the irreversible loss of proliferation occurring during in vitro ageing.

Potential and limitations of cultivated fibroblasts in the study of senescence in animals. A review on the murine skin fibroblasts system

Senescence is the last period of the life span, leading to death. It happens in all animals, with the exception of a few didermic species (Hydras) having a stock of embryonic cells and being immortal. The causes of animal senescence are badly known. They depend both on genetic characters (maximum life span of a species) and on medium factors (mean expectation of life of the animals of a species). Animal senescence could depend on cell aging: (1) by senescence and death of the differentiated cells, (2) by modified proliferation of the stem cells of differentiated tissues, (3) by alterations in the extracellular matrices, (4) by interactions between factors (1) (2) and (3) in each tissue, and (5) by interactions between the several tissues of an organism. This complexity badly impedes the experimental study of animal senescence. Normal mammal cells are aging when they are cultivated (in vitro aging). Present literature upon in vitro aging of cultivated human fibroblasts consists essentially of papers devoted to proliferation and differentiation characteristics and not to cell senescence. Murine skin fibroblasts have been studied in our laboratory, using different systems: (1) primary cultures isolated from peeled skins of mouse embryos, (2) mouse derms analysed in the animals, (3) cultivated explants of skins, (4) serial sub-cultures of fibroblasts isolated from these explants, (5) cells cultivated comparably on plane substrates (glass, plastic, collagen films) and on three-dimensional matrices (collagen fibres). In primary cultures (system 1) all the cell generations have been analysed, including the last one until death of the culture. We have shown that many characters are varying with cell generation. All the observed variations were: progressive, non-linear and correlated (intracellular feedbacks). We come to the conclusion that the main effects of cell mitotic age are (1) to depress the plasticity of the chromatin, (2) to change the organization of the cytoplasmic filaments, (3) to change the organization of the extracellular matrix. The collagen fibres are also acting upon nucleus and filaments either in the animals or in the cultures. The phenotype of a fibroblastic cell is thus both age- and environment-dependent. Overall data on in vitro cell aging point to the hypothesis that senescent cells are phenotypic variants and not mutant cells. Aging cell cultures are remarkably useful to the studies on cell proliferation decrease and cell cycle lengthening shown by the stem cells in animal tissues. We propose the hypothesis that the fibroblasts of the vertebrates would be homologous to the pluripotent mesenchyme cells of their embryos.

Proliferative potential of human fibroblasts: an inverse dependence on cell size

Human foreskin fibroblast-like cells were separated on the basis of DNA content and cell size by fluorescence-activated cell sorting. Subpopulations of "large" or "small" cells with the same (G1) DNA content were clonally expanded and found to contain predominantly nondividing or highly proliferative cells, respectively. From the rate of clonal growth, we deduce that small cells divide faster than large cells. Intermediate-sized cells were found to yield primarily smaller ("attenuated") clones. The clonal data can be incorporated into a previously reported kinetic model of clonal attenuation. This version of the model postulates that small "stem" cells yield larger daughters which have only a limited proliferative potential. We also postulate that a progressive increase in cell size can account for the decreasing concentration of DNA polymerase alpha, which has been reported in older cultures.

Evidence for a universal process underlying clonal attenuation

It is shown by computer simulation that an established commitment model of clonal attenuation can account for clone size distribution data obtained from three vertebrate species--chick, hamster and human--from two evolutionarily divergent classes. The different in vitro replicative lifespans of each cell strain can be explained by differences in cell kinetics. These results suggest that the process of clonal attenuation is qualitatively similar in fibroblasts from all vertebrate species.

Cellular senescence revisited: a review

The field of cellular senescence (cytogerontology) is reviewed. The historical precedence for investigation in this field is summarized, and placed in the context of more recent studies of the regulation of cellular proliferation and differentiation. The now-classical embryonic lung fibroblast model is compared to models utilizing other cell types as well as cells from donors of different ages and phenotypes. Modulation of cellular senescence by growth factors, hormones, and genetic manipulation is contrasted, but newer studies in oncogene involvement are omitted. A current consensus would include the view that the life span of normal diploid cells in culture is limited, is under genetic control, and is capable of being modified. Finally, embryonic cells aging in vitro share certain characteristics with early passage cells derived from donors of increasing age.

Influence of cumene hydroperoxide and 4-hydroxynonenal on the glutathione metabolism during in vitro ageing of human skin fibroblasts

Cumene hydroperoxide (Chp) and 4-hydroxynonenal (HNE) were used to investigate the effect of peroxidative challenge upon the glutathione (GSH) metabolism of human skin fibroblasts. Cellular GSH contents decreased during short-term incubations with Chp and oxidised glutathione (GSSG) was formed concomitantly. During longer incubations the GSH level was restored and the substrate flux through the pentose phosphate shunt increased. So in the presence of hydroperoxides the GSH level is maintained by reduction of GSSG. HNE caused a strong decrease in cellular GSH contents. Prolonged incubation with HNE lead to a rise in GSH contents above the basal level. The flux through the pentose phosphate shunt did not change during exposure to HNE. Hence, during incubation with HNE the cell maintains its GSH content by de novo synthesis of GSH. This conclusion is further substantiated by the findings with a cell strain deficient in GSH synthetase. These cells survived if incubated with Chp but not if exposed to HNE. GSH contents of normal cells from phase II (young) cultures and from phase III (aged) cultures responded similarly to Chp during short-term incubations and during a week of culture with the test compound. The flux through the pentose phosphate shunt rose much more in phase III than in phase II cells when incubated with the same concentration series of Chp. We conclude that during in vitro ageing the amount of NADPH needed to maintain cellular GSH levels in the presence of hydroperoxides increases, while the capacity to respond to such a challenge is not affected.

Alteration of the microtubule organization in aging WI-38 fibroblasts. A comparative study with embryonic hamster lung fibroblasts

The microtubule organization in human WI-38 fibroblasts subcultivated in vitro has been investigated using nocodazole, a reversible inhibitor of the microtubules. Two phenotypes were observed. The typical fibroblast cells, called Type 1 cells, showed, after nocodazole treatment, a centripetal depolymerization wave of the microtubules and the giant Type 2 cells which have a more heterogeneous behaviour. Some of the cells clearly showed a centrifugal depolymerization of the microtubules, others a mixed behavior and less than 1% displayed the same behavior as the Type 1 cells. Confirming previous data obtained with Hamster fibroblasts (Raes et al., 1983, 1984), these results suggest a modification in the microtubule organization which could account for the aberrant division of some WI-38 cells in aged cultures. The relevance of this observation for the emergence of the morphologically different Type 2 cells and for cell division impairment in serially in vitro cultivated cells is discussed.

In vitro senescence of Syrian hamster mesenchymal cells of fetal to aged adult origin. Inverse relationship between in vivo donor age and in vitro proliferative capacity

Normal diploid Syrian hamster dermal mesenchymal cell strains, regardless of the age of the tissue of origin, exhibit in vitro cellular senescence. The frequency of spontaneous escape from senescence and conversion to a permanent cell line is less than 5% among replicate flasks. The overall pattern of senescence of cells of fetal, neonatal, young adult (6 months) and aged adult (24 months) origin is similar in terms of the morphological changes and proliferative changes indicated by the reduction of saturation density, cloning efficiency and [3H]thymidine labeling index and by the increase in population doubling time and cell volume. However, the average maximum cumulative population doubling level is characteristic for each cell type: 13-day gestation fetal cells, 28.6; neonatal cells, 18.7; young adult cells, 13.8; aged adult cells, 11.1. Thus, the in vitro proliferative capacity of Syrian hamster mesenchymal cells is inversely related to the in vivo age of the donor.

Behavior and ultrastructure of in vitro ageing mouse embryo fibroblasts grown in collagen gels

We have compared the behaviour and the ultrastructure of embryonic mouse fibroblasts embedded into collagen gels at early, middle and late population doubling levels (PDL). Late mouse fibroblasts were able to induce gel contraction with a greater efficiency than young cells. We did not find any differences in the organization of these gels. Electron microscope observations on gels containing fibroblasts of different PDL showed that the collagen lattice induced new specific and distinct phenotypes. The well-known ultrastructural differences between young and late fibroblasts grown on plastic substrates were less prominent when these cells were embedded into collagen gels. The late fibroblasts grown into gels kept their large size and their lobulated nuclei and resembled fibroblasts grown on plastic surfaces. However, dramatic changes were observed in their pattern of microfilaments, in the dispersion of their chromatin and in their ergastoplasmic structure; these characteristics observed in late fibroblasts grown into gels were close to those of young cells. The new phenotypes of young, middle-aged and late fibroblasts in the collagen gels seemed to be stable and did not display the characteristics of an older phenotype on continued incubation. When the fibroblasts left the gel, they returned to their initial phenotype.