Heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression: is the glass half empty or half full?

Application of exercise ECG stress test in the current high cost modern-era healthcare system

Exercise electrocardiogram (ECG) tests boasts of being more widely available, less resource intensive, lower cost and absence of radiation. In the presence of a normal baseline ECG, an exercise ECG test is able to generate a reliable and reproducible result almost comparable to Technitium–99 m sestamibi perfusion imaging. Exercise ECG changes when combined with other clinical parameters obtained during the test has the potential to allow effective redistribution of scarce resources by excluding low risk patients with significant accuracy. As we look towards a future of rising healthcare costs, increased prevalence of cardiovascular disease and the need for proper allocation of limited resources; exercise ECG test offers low cost, vital and reliable disease interpretation.

This article highlights the physiology of the exercise ECG test, patient selection, effective interpretation, describe previously reported scores and their clinical application in today’s clinical practice.

Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves and the definition of threshold levels to diagnose coronary artery disease on electrocardiographic stress testing. Part II: the use of ROC curves in the choice of electrocardiographic stress test markers of ischaemia

A common problem in diagnostic medicine, when performing a diagnostic test, is to obtain an accurate discrimination between 'normal' cases and cases with disease, owing to the overlapping distributions of these populations. In clinical practice, it is exceedingly rare that a chosen cut point will achieve perfect discrimination between normal cases and those with disease, and one has to select the best compromise between sensitivity and specificity by comparing the diagnostic performance of different tests or diagnostic criteria available. Receiver operating characteristic (or receiver operator characteristic, ROC) curves allow systematic and intuitively appealing descriptions of the diagnostic performance of a test and a comparison of the performance of different tests or diagnostic criteria. This review will analyse the basic principles underlying ROC curves and their specific application to the choice of optimal parameters on exercise electrocardiographic stress testing. Part II will be devoted to the comparative analysis of various parameters derived from exercise stress testing for the diagnosis of underlying coronary artery disease.

Left ventricular mechanics and geometry in patients with congenital complete atrioventricular block

BACKGROUND

Radiographic evidence of cardiomegaly is common in patients with congenital complete atrioventricular block (CCAVB). It has been speculated that left ventricular (LV) remodeling and increased stroke volume counteract the bradycardia, but the effects of slow heart rate and atrioventricular asynchrony on LV dimensions, geometry, wall stress, and function have not been examined in detail.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Thirty patients with CCAVB without associated congenital heart disease (mean age, 8.5+/-5.3 years; range, 0.2 to 20 years) were included in a cross-sectional two-institution study. Thirty-five echocardiograms were performed using standard techniques. ECG and 24-hour ECG recordings were reviewed. Seven patients did not receive a pacemaker, whereas 23 patients underwent pacemaker implantation after the echocardiogram. Compared with normal control subjects, LV volume (Z score=1.5+/-1.3) and LV mass (Z=1.2+/-1.5) were significantly increased, whereas LV mass-to-volume ratio (1.1+/-0.3) and geometry (short-axis diameter/length ratio=0.65+/-0.09) were normal. LV end-systolic stress (ESS) (a measure of afterload) was normal (Z score=0.2+/-2.3), whereas shortening fraction (Z=3+/-2.9) and velocity of circumferential fiber shortening (VCF) (Z=3+/-3.1) were increased. The relationship between VCF and ESS (a preload-insensitive and afterload-adjusted index of contractility) was increased (Z=2.2+/-2) with only small increase in preload (Z=1.02+/-1.1). Regression analyses showed no significant change over age in LV mass, volume, geometry, loading conditions, or systolic function. Patients who ultimately met criteria for pacemaker implantation did not differ from those who did not in terms of heart rate or LV function but did have increased LV volume (Z score=1.8+/-1.4 versus 0.4+/-0.9, P=.03) and LV mass (Z score=1.7+/-1.2 versus 0.2+/-1.7, P=.001) compared to the unpaced group.

CONCLUSIONS

In most patients with CCAVB, the LV was enlarged with normal geometry and enhanced systolic function during the first two decades of life. The degree of LV dilation and enhanced function did not significantly change with age. In patients who ultimately underwent pacemaker implantation LV function did not differ from those who remained unpaced, but evidence of a slightly increased load manifested as increased end-diastolic volume and mass.

Accuracy of heart rate-adjusted ST segments in populations with and without posttest referral bias

We compared the accuracy of the ST segment/heart rate (STHR) index and slope to standard criteria (> or =1 mm horizontal/downsloping ST-segment depression at J + 60 msec) in 1358 patients (152 underwent angiography). All exercise tests used the Cornell protocol and computer measurements of maximum ST-segment depression at J + 60 msec. Test accuracy was determined for the entire group with a probability-based method. Thresholds with equal specificity to standard criteria were determined. By using only patients who underwent angiography, neither STHR index nor slope was more accurate than standard criteria (maximum sensitivity: standard criteria, 42%; STHR index, 51%; STHR slope, 40%). However, by using the entire group, both STHR index and slope were more accurate than standard criteria, but only STHR index achieved statistical significance (maximum sensitivity: standard criteria, 31%; STHR index, 60%; STHR slope, 47%). We conclude that heart rate-adjusted ST-segment criteria are more accurate than standard ST-segment criteria. A lack of demonstration of improved accuracy of STHR index and slope only occurs in patients affected by posttest referral bias.

Heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression and performance of the exercise electrocardiogram: a critical evaluation

Analysis of the rate-related change in exercise-induced ST segment depression using the exercise ST segment/heart rate slope and ST segment/heart rate index can improve the accuracy of the exercise electrocardiogram (ECG) for the identification of patients with coronary artery disease, recognition of patients with anatomically or functionally severe coronary obstruction and detection of patients at increased risk for future coronary events. These methods provide a more physiologic approach to analysis of the ST segment response to exercise by adjusting the apparent severity of ischemia for the corresponding increase in myocardial oxygen demand, which in turn can be linearly related to increasing heart rate. Solid-angle theory provides a model for the linear relation of ST segment depression to heart rate during exercise and a framework for understanding the relation of the ST segment/heart rate slope to the presence and extent of coronary artery disease. False positive and false negative test results of the heart rate-adjusted methods are well known in selected populations and require further clarification. Application of these methods is also highly dependent on the type of exercise protocol, number of ECG leads examined, timing of ST segment measurement relative to the J point and accuracy and precision of ST segment measurement. These methodologic details have been an important limitation to test application when traditional protocols and measurement procedures are required. When applied with attention to required details, the heart rate-adjusted methods can improve the usefulness of the exercise ECG in a range of clinically relevant populations.

Diagnostic accuracy of heart rate-adjusted ST segments compared with standard ST-segment criteria

We compared the accuracy of ST segment/heart rate (ST/HR) index with that of standard criteria (> or = 0.1 mV horizontal/downsloping ST depression 80 ms after the J point) in 121 patients who had undergone angiography (49 with > or = 1 lesion with > or = 50% stenosis) and 50 clinically normal subjects. All exercise tests used the Cornell protocol and computer measurements of maximal ST depression 80 ms after the J point. Thresholds with equal specificity to standard criteria were determined for ST/HR index using each of the 2 normal groups (those who were normal by angiography and those who were clinically normal). In using only patients who underwent angiography, we found that the ST/HR index had a sensitivity that was not significantly greater than that of standard criteria (standard criteria 51%, ST/HR index 59%; p = 0.21). However, the receiver-operating characteristic curve area increased from 64 +/- 4 to 68 +/- 4 (p < 0.02). When clinically normal subjects were used instead of patients without angiographic disease, there was a clearly discernible improvement in sensitivity of ST/HR index over standard criteria (standard criteria 51%, ST/HR index 69%; p < 0.05). The associated curve areas were 69 +/- 4 and 79 +/- 3 (p < 0.001). Therefore, accuracy of the ST/HR index was marginally better than standard criteria only in patients who underwent angiography. When clinically normal subjects were used, the accuracy of the ST/HR index was definitely better than standard criteria. We conclude that the demonstration of improved accuracy of the ST/HR index depends on the population being tested.

Solid-angle theory and heart rate adjustment of ST-segment depression for the identification and quantification of coronary artery disease

Determinants of the ST-segment response to exercise can be mathematically modeled by solid-angle theory, and heart rate adjustment of the magnitude of exercise-induced ST-segment depression can remodel the solid-angle relationship to provide a theoretic and practical basis for application of heart rate-adjusted indexes of ST depression in exercise electrocardiography. Solid-angle theory indicates that the magnitude of ST depression recorded at a surface electrode (epsilon) can be described as the product of spatial and nonspatial determinants: epsilon = (omega/4 pi).(delta Vm).K (equation 1), where omega is the solid angle subtending the boundary of the ischemic territory, delta Vm is the difference in transmembrane voltage between the ischemic and adjacent nonischemic regions, and K is a term correcting for differences in intracellular and extracellular conductivity and changes in end-plate conductance. As a consequence, the magnitude of ST depression recorded by a surface electrode will be proportional both to the area of ischemic territory subtended by the recording electrode, which reflects the solid angle, and to the local transmembrane potential difference, which in turn reflects the electric consequences of the metabolic severity of ischemia at the level of the myocardial cell. It follows from equation 1 that the amplitude of ST depression can accurately reflect the area of ischemic boundary only when the severity of ischemia is constant or otherwise controlled, and differences in ST depression will only reflect varying areas of underlying ischemia when similar severity of ischemia is present. During exercise the severity of ischemia is directly proportional to changes in myocardial oxygen demand and coronary blood flow, which in turn are directly related to increasing heart rate (delta HR). Because the change in transmembrane voltage across the ischemic boundary is linearly proportional to delta HR, delta Vm/delta HR remains constant as ischemia develops. Dividing the solid-angle relationship in equation 1 by delta HR and making the appropriate substitution for a constant delta Vm/delta HR then indicates that epsilon/delta HR = (omega/4 pi).(c . K) [equation 2], where c is the new constant. Under conditions where changes in conductance are proportional or small, this simplified relationship reduces to delta ST/delta HR = c'.omega [equation 3], where delta ST reflects the magnitude of ST depression recorded by the surface electrode, delta HR the change in heart rate during developing ischemia, and c' the resulting empiric constant.

Effect of measurement interval on performance of the ST integral for the identification of three-vessel coronary disease

Measurement of the ST integral has usually incorporated ST-segment depression integrated between the J point and 80 ms after the J point (J + 80). To assess the effect of varied onset and offset of ST measurement on performance of the ST integral for the identification of three-vessel coronary disease, the exercise electrocardiograms (ECGs) of 60 patients with angiographically proven coronary disease were analyzed using J point or J + 20 onsets and J + 60 or J + 80 offsets of ST integral calculation. Simple ST-segment depression of greater than 200 microV, measured at 60 ms after the J point, identified three-vessel disease with a specificity of 68% (17 out of 25 patients) and sensitivity of 69% (22 out of 35 patients). At a matched specificity of 68% (17 out of 25 patients), there was identical sensitivity (54%, 19 out of 35 patients) of ST integrals measured either from the J point to J + 80, from the J point to J + 60, or from J + 20 to J + 60. A trend toward increased sensitivity (60%, 21 out of 35 patients) when the ST integral was measured from J + 20 to J + 80 did not reach statistical significance, and comparison of receive operating characteristics (ROC) curves demonstrated that varying the onset and offset of ST-segment measurement had no significant effect on the overall performance of ST integral criteria for the detection of three-vessel disease.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)