Topical antiseptics

Clinical correlation of a skin antisepsis model

The use of pigskin as a test substrate for evaluating topical antimicrobial activity has been developed. Simulated handwashing protocols with this in vitro model in parallel with in vivo studies have been evaluated, based on an ASTM method for the clinical evaluation of a healthcare personnel handwash. Using Serratia marcescens as the test organism, similar log reductions were observed using the in vitro model when compared to in vivo efficacy. Results suggest that this model can be used as a reliable indicator of antiseptic efficacy on the skin. The use of sterilized skin simplifies the use of this model for both efficacy and skin-pathogen interaction studies.

Effects of a protective foam on scrubbing and gloving

OBJECTIVE

To test the effects of a skin protectant on surgical scrub and glove integrity.

DESIGN

Forty-nine healthy adult volunteers were assigned (12 subjects per group) to apply a protective foam (DermaMed; Benchmark Enterprises, Salt Lake City, Utah) in conjunction with surgical scrub in one of the following formulations: 70% isopropyl alcohol, a liquid detergent base containing 4% chlorhexidine gluconate, a liquid detergent base containing 7.5% povidone-iodine, or a nonantimicrobial liquid soap (control). According to a standard protocol, subjects performed a surgical scrub on 3 days (every other day). Foam was applied after surgical scrub on day 1 and before surgical scrub on day 3. No foam was applied on day 2. Subjects were gloved for 2 hours after surgical scrub.

SETTING

Laboratory setting.

RESULTS

On all test days, there were significant differences in bacterial reduction by products (chlorhexidine gluconate or alcohol > povidone-iodine > control). When controlling for baseline counts and products used, there were no significant differences in colony-forming unit counts on hands with or without foam immediately after scrubbing or at 2 hours after scrub on gloved or ungloved hands, nor were there differences in glove leakage rates when foam was on hands.

CONCLUSIONS

Such protectants can be used without detrimental effects to scrub effectiveness or glove integrity.