Psychosocial outcome following temporal lobe surgery

The consequences of uncontrolled epilepsy

The consequences of epilepsy can be quite severe and include shortened lifespan, excessive bodily injury, neuropsychological and psychiatric impairment, and social disability. There is evidence that seizures cause brain injury, including neuronal death and physiological dysfunction. Mortality rates are 4-7 times higher in people with medically refractory seizures, and injury rates are substantial, ranging from one per 20 person-years to as much as one per 3 person-years. Quality of life is impaired in epilepsy, and relates to seizure control. Psychosocial disabilities, including lower social interaction with reduced marriage rates and reduced employment levels, are more common in people with refractory seizures. Complete seizure control is desirable, since seizures potentially constitute a serious threat to health and well-being. Therefore, satisfactory seizure control should be defined as having no seizures. Treatment should be directed to preventing seizures whenever possible and achieving control early in the course of illness. The risks of uncontrolled seizures outweigh the risks of aggressive medical or surgical therapy.

Psychosocial and Neurobehavioral Factors Related to Surgical Treatment for Partial Epilepsy: A Multivariate Analysis

Studies of temporal lobe surgery rarely include anatomical and neurobehavioral data in the analysis of outcome. We carried out a retrospective study on 50 patients, using clinical data from case notes, resection volumes, and preoperative imaging data. Three main conclusions emerge from this study: (1) Psychosocial outcome is related to postoperative seizure control. (2) Late postoperative aggression and clinical depression are associated with bad psychosocial outcome. (3) Right-sided hippocampal sclerosis, as suggested by measurements with T2 relaxometry, correlates with interictal psychopathology, as measured with the Beck Depression Inventory, the Leyton Obsessional Inventory, and the Bear-Fedio personality inventory.

Cost of epilepsy in Hong Kong: experience from a regional hospital

To study the economic implications of epilepsy in Hong Kong, a cost-of-illness study was performed on a retrospective cohort of medically treated patients from a regional hospital. A societal perspective was examined. Utilization data from 1992 to 1996 were reviewed to obtain the direct costs. Lost productivity was used as a proxy for estimating the indirect costs. Future cost projected over 10 years was derived by incorporating model parameters. Of 745 records reviewed, total direct costs added up to USD 0.98 million and indirect costs to USD 1.32 million. Regarding the overall direct costs, hospitalization was the most consumptive item among patients with a shorter history of epilepsy and those with suboptimal seizure control. The mean total cost per patient increased steadily from 1992 to 1996 except for those with long-standing remission, and was highest in patients with medically refractory epilepsy in terms of both the actual value and rate of increment. Parameters with the most leverage on future cost would be unemployment rate and annual discount rate. The overall economy of the society would exert a major effect on the future cost of epilepsy, in particular, for patients with poorly controlled disease.

Outcome of temporal lobectomy: expectations and the prediction of perceived success

PURPOSE

This study examined the independent contributions of medical and psychosocial factors to perceived surgical success. We aimed to develop a multidimensional model predictive of perceived surgical outcome.

METHODS

Fifty anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) patients were prospectively assessed, using a formally coded, semistructured clinical interview. This has been routinely administered pre- and post-operatively as part of a larger, nationwide study of Australian ATL patients. The interview covers a broad range of epileptological, psychiatric, neuropsychological and psychosocial issues. Variables from these domains were examined in relation to the patient's perception of surgical success at the 6-month post-operative review.

RESULTS

Variables that correlated with success were analysed using principal components analysis and multiple regression. A predictive model of perceived surgical success emerged, which highlighted the multidimensionality of outcome. Independent effects were observed for both medical and psychosocial factors. These included the patients' pre-operative expectations of surgery, their post-operative seizure outcome, and affective state. The findings also highlighted the importance of discarding sick role behaviours associated with chronic epilepsy, after surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Traditional outcome measures (seizure frequency, post-operative affect) are significant in the patient's evaluation of surgical success. These traditional measures, however, do not account for the process of psychosocial adjustment surrounding seizure surgery. This process involves two major components: (1) positive anticipation of change prior to surgery, and (2) learning to discard roles associated with chronic epilepsy after surgery.

Presurgery expectations, postsurgery satisfaction, and psychosocial adjustment after epilepsy surgery

PURPOSE

The medical benefits of epilepsy surgery are well documented, but the psychosocial consequences of surgery have received less attention. This is especially true of the roles of expectations and satisfaction in postsurgery functioning. The present study was designed to examine the relationships between expectation, satisfaction with surgery, and psychosocial functioning in patients and their significant others before and after epilepsy surgery.

METHODS

The neuropsychology findings of 79 patients undergoing epilepsy surgery were examined from assessments made before, 2 months after, and 1 year after anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL) was performed. The Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) and the Washington Psychosocial Seizure Inventory (WPSI) were used to assess psychosocial functioning. A subset of 32 patients and their significant others were followed prospectively with an additional semistructured interview to assess expectations for and satisfaction with surgery outcome.

RESULTS

Before surgery, patients showed considerable problems with psychosocial adjustment. After surgery, patients in the seizure-free group showed improvements on the psychosocial measures at both follow-ups, whereas patients with continued seizures showed improvement at the 2-month follow-up and then a decline to baseline or worse at the time of the 1-year follow-up. Subjects who were studied prospectively had high presurgery expectations for seizure elimination. After surgery, subjects whose expectations were met reported high satisfaction whereas subjects whose expectations were not met reported low satisfaction. Satisfaction with surgery was associated with better psychosocial functioning.

CONCLUSIONS

Such data help elucidate the ways in which successful epilepsy surgery results in improved psychosocial functioning. The results identify ways to increase the likelihood that both patients who are seizure-free and those with reduced seizure frequency may benefit from surgery.

Pre- and postoperative socioeconomic development of 151 patients with focal epilepsies

PURPOSE

We evaluated retrospectively the socioeconomic development of epilepsy patients after temporal or extratemporal epilepsy surgery and analyzed the relationship to clinical and neuropsychological data.

METHODS

151 patients (from ages 11-65 years; mean postoperative followup: 3 years) replied to a structured questionnaire, which referred to objective data of the patient's educational and vocational development. Neuropsychological data were obtained from pre- and postoperative (1-year follow-up) examinations.

RESULTS

The preoperative development data indicated that patients exposed to epilepsy at any developmental stage had a higher prevalence of educational/vocational difficulties as compared with patients with a later onset of epilepsy. Postoperatively, the integration of the formerly unemployed improved and the unemployment rate decreased from 33 to 16%. Out of those patients who had been schooled or who were employed, 79%-91% made progress in development, or were at least able to keep their status. Only 2 of 14 patients, who had been retired early because of their epilepsy, returned to employment. In general, a deterioration of the socioeconomic status was significantly related to insufficient seizure control. A reemployment of patients who were formerly unemployed depended mainly on age and neuropsychological outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that early and successful surgical intervention improves or at least maintains the socioeconomic situation, especially the employment status.

A cost-effectiveness analysis of anterior temporal lobectomy for intractable temporal lobe epilepsy

Patients with medically intractable temporal lobe epilepsy are potential candidates for anterior temporal lobectomy (ATL), in which epileptogenic temporal lobe tissue is localized and surgically removed. This surgical approach can eliminate or drastically reduce seizures in the majority of patients. The authors used a decision-analysis model to examine the cost-effectiveness of a surgical evaluation and treatment protocol for medically intractable temporal lobe epilepsy. This model compared a cohort treated with the new protocol with a continuation of their immediate preoperative medical management and projected these differences over the patient's lifetime. The Markov model incorporated postoperative seizure status, patient quality of life, death from surgical and natural causes, discounting, and the direct medical costs associated with outpatient evaluation, hospitalization, surgery, antiepileptic drugs, and lifetime outpatient treatment. The intent-to-treat analysis included patients who underwent evaluation but were not eligible for ATL. Sensitivity analyses were also performed on the variables in the model. Data from the baseline model indicated that evaluation for ATL provided an average of 1.1 additional quality-adjusted life years (QALYs) compared with continued medical management, at an additional cost of $29,800. Combining the clinical and economic outcomes yielded a cost-effectiveness ratio of $27,200 per QALY. This value is comparable to other accepted medical or surgical interventions, such as total knee arthroplasty ($16,700/QALY) or coronary artery balloon angioplasty ($40,800/QALY). Sensitivity analyses demonstrate that the results are critically dependent on postoperative seizure status and improvement in quality of life. Although further work is necessary to quantify the improvement in quality of life after epilepsy surgery better, the present data indicate that ATL for treatment of intractable temporal lobe epilepsy is a cost-effective use of medical resources.

Factors associated with work outcome after anterior temporal lobectomy for intractable epilepsy

PURPOSE

Whereas the effect of anterior temporal lobectomy on seizure frequency is well recognized, less is known about its impact on work status.

METHODS

One hundred thirty-four of 190 consecutive patients with temporal lobectomy participated in this study. Eligibility criteria were developed to ensure that only patients with the potential of achieving specific outcomes were included in the corresponding analyses.

RESULTS

After surgery, significantly more patients were independent in activities of daily living (p < 0.001) or able to drive (p < 0.001). Income from work also increased (p < 0.01). Nearly one fifth of the patients who were eligible for analysis had either a gain (8%) or a loss (11%) of full- or of part-time work. Univariate analyses revealed the following factors to be associated with full-time work after surgery: student or full-time work within a year before surgery, full-time work experience before surgery, full- or part-time employment experience before surgery, no disability benefits before surgery, low postsurgical seizure frequency, improved postsurgical seizure control, excellent postsurgical seizure control, driving after surgery, and further education after surgery (p < 0.05). Significant factors on multivariate analysis were being a student or having full-time work within a year before surgery [odds ratio, 16.2 (95% CI, 4.3-60.5)], driving after surgery [15.2 (3.2-72.0)], and obtaining further education after surgery [9.2 (2.2-53.0)].

CONCLUSIONS

Anterior temporal lobectomy for intractable epilepsy improves activities of daily living and the ability to drive. Work outcome of this surgery is influenced by presurgical work experience, successful postsurgical seizure control especially to allow driving, and obtaining further education after surgery.