Origin and evolution of the class I gene family: why are some of the mammalian class I genes encoded outside the major histocompatibility complex?

A Highly Complex, MHC-Linked, 350 Million-Year-Old Shark Nonclassical Class I Lineage

Cartilaginous fish, or Chondrichthyes, are the oldest extant vertebrates to possess the MHC and the Ig superfamily-based Ag receptors, the defining genes of the gnathostome adaptive immune system. In this work, we have identified a novel MHC lineage, UEA, a complex multigene nonclassical class I family found in sharks (division Selachii) but not detected in chimaeras (subclass Holocephali) or rays (division Batoidea). This new lineage is distantly related to the previously reported nonclassical class I lineage UCA, which appears to be present only in dogfish sharks (order Squaliformes). UEA lacks conservation of the nine invariant residues in the peptide (ligand)-binding regions (PBR) that bind to the N and C termini of bound peptide in most vertebrate classical class I proteins, which are replaced by relatively hydrophobic residues compared with the classical UAA. In fact, UEA and UCA proteins have the most hydrophobic-predicted PBR of all identified chondrichthyan class I molecules. UEA genes detected in the whale shark and bamboo shark genome projects are MHC linked. Consistent with UEA comprising a very large gene family, we detected weak expression in different tissues of the nurse shark via Northern blotting and RNA sequencing. UEA genes fall into three sublineages with unique characteristics in the PBR. UEA shares structural and genetic features with certain nonclassical class I genes in other vertebrates, such as the highly complex XNC nonclassical class I genes in Xenopus, and we anticipate that each shark gene, or at least each sublineage, will have a unique function, perhaps in bacterial defense.

Comparative genomics of the NKG2D ligand gene family

NKG2D ligands (NKG2DLs) are a group of stress-inducible major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I-like molecules that act as a danger signal alerting the immune system to the presence of abnormal cells. In mammals, two families of NKG2DL genes have been identified: the MIC gene family encoded in the MHC region and the ULBP gene family encoded outside the MHC region in most species. Some mammals have a third family of NKG2DL-like class I genes which we named MILL (MHC class I-like located near the leukocyte receptor complex). Despite the fact that MILL genes are more closely related to MIC genes than ULBP genes are to MIC genes, MILL molecules do not function as NKG2DLs, and their function remains unknown. With the progress of mammalian genome projects, information on the MIC, ULBP, and MILL gene families became available in many mammalian species. Here, we summarize such information and discuss the origin and evolution of the NKG2DL gene family from the viewpoint of host-pathogen coevolution.

Genetics, genomics, and evolutionary biology of NKG2D ligands

Human and mouse NKG2D ligands (NKG2DLs) are absent or only poorly expressed by most normal cells but are upregulated by cell stress, hence, alerting the immune system in case of malignancy or infection. Although these ligands are numerous and highly variable (at genetic, genomic, structural, and biochemical levels), they all belong to the major histocompatibility complex class I gene superfamily and bind to a single, invariant, receptor: NKG2D. NKG2D (CD314) is an activating receptor expressed on NK cells and subsets of T cells that have a key role in the recognition and lysis of infected and tumor cells. Here, we review the molecular diversity of NKG2DLs, discuss the increasing appreciation of their roles in a variety of medical conditions, and propose several explanations for the evolutionary force(s) that seem to drive the multiplicity and diversity of NKG2DLs while maintaining their interaction with a single invariant receptor.

Immunogenetics of the NKG2D ligand gene family

NKG2D ligands (NKG2DLs) are a group of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I-like molecules, the expression of which is induced by cellular stresses such as infection, tumorigenesis, heat shock, tissue damage, and DNA damage. They act as a molecular danger signal alerting the immune system for infected or neoplastic cells. Mammals have two families of NKG2DL genes: the MHC-encoded MIC gene family and the ULBP gene family encoded outside the MHC region in most mammals. Rodents such as mice and rats lack the MIC family of ligands. Interestingly, some mammals have NKG2DL-like molecules named MILL that are phylogenetically related to MIC, but do not function as NKG2DLs. In this paper, we review our current knowledge of the MIC, ULBP, and MILL gene families in representative mammalian species and discuss the origin and evolution of the NKG2DL gene family.

Evolutionary biology of CD1

The recognition more than a decade ago that lipids presented by CD1 could function as T cell antigens revealed a startling and previously unappreciated complexity to the adaptive immune system. The initial novelty of lipid antigen presentation by CD1 has since given way to a broader perspective of the immune system's capacity to sense and respond to a diverse array of macromolecules. Some immune recognition systems such as Toll-like receptors can trace their origins back into the deep history of sea urchins and arthropods. Others such as the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) appear relatively recently and interestingly, only in animals that also possess a jaw. The natural history of CD1 is thus part of the wider story of immune system evolution and should be considered in this context. Most evidence indicates that CD1 probably evolved from a classical MHC class I (MHC I) gene at some point during vertebrate evolution. This chapter reviews the evidence for this phylogenetic relationship and attempts to connect CD1 to existing models of MHC evolution. This endeavor is facilitated today by the recent availability of whole genome sequence data from a variety of species. Investigators have used these data to trace the ultimate origin of the MHC to a series of whole genome duplications that occurred roughly 500 million years ago. Sequence data have also revealed homologs of the mammalian MHC I and MHC II gene families in virtually all jawed vertebrates including sharks, bony fishes, reptiles, and birds. In contrast, CD1 genes have thus far been found only in a subset of these animal groups. This pattern of CD1 occurrence in the genomes of living species suggests the emergence of CD 1 in an early terrestrial vertebrate.

Characterization of two avian MHC-like genes reveals an ancient origin of the CD1 family

Many of the genes that comprise the vertebrate adaptive immune system are conserved across wide evolutionary time scales. Most notably, homologs of the mammalian MHC gene family have been found in virtually all jawed vertebrates, including sharks, bony fishes, reptiles, and birds. The CD1 family of antigen-presenting molecules are related to the MHC class I family but have evolved to bind and present lipid antigens to T cells. Here, we describe two highly divergent nonclassical MHC class I genes found in the chicken (Gallus gallus) that have sequence homology to the mammalian CD1 family of proteins. One of the chicken CD1 genes expresses a full-length transcript, whereas the other has multiple splice variants. Both Southern blot and single nucleotide polymorphism analysis indicates that chicken CD1 is relatively nonpolymorphic. Moreover, cross-hybridizing bands are present in other bird species, suggesting broad conservation in the avian class. Northern analysis of chicken tissue shows a high level of CD1 expression in the bursa and spleen. In addition, molecular modeling predicts that the potential antigen-binding pocket is probably hydrophobic, a universal characteristic of CD1 molecules. Genomic analysis indicates that the CD1 genes are located on chicken chromosome 16 and maps to within 200 kb of the chicken MHC B locus, suggesting that CD1 genes diverged from classical MHC genes while still linked to the major histocompatibility complex locus. The existence of CD1 genes in an avian species suggests that the origin of CD1 extends deep into the evolutionary history of terrestrial vertebrates.

Conservation and diversification of MHC class I and its related molecules in vertebrates

The elucidation of the complete peptide-binding domains of the highly polymorphic shark MHC class I genes offered us an opportunity to examine the characteristics of their predicted protein products in the light of the latest advance in the structural studies of the MHC class I molecules. The results suggest that the fundamental characteristics in the T-cell recognition of the MHC class I molecule/peptide complex are expected to have been established at the early stage of the vertebrate evolution. The elucidation of the typical classical class I molecules from fishes and also of some MHC class I-related molecules may help us-to explore the common denominator of the ancient class I molecules.

The chromosomal duplication model of the major histocompatibility complex

The major histocompatibility complex (MHC) is a genetic region that has been extensively studied by immunologists, molecular biologists, and evolutionary biologists. Nevertheless, our knowledge of how the MHC acquired its present-day organization is quite limited. The recent discovery that the mammalian genome contains regions paralogous to the MHC has led us to the proposal that the MHC region of jawed vertebrates arose as a result of ancient chromosomal duplications. Here, I review the current status of this proposal.

The mouse major histocompatibility complex: some assembly required

We have assembled a contig of 81 yeast artificial chromosome clones that spans 8 Mb and contains the entire major histocompatibility complex (Mhc) from mouse strain C57BL/6 (H2b), and we are in the process of assembling an Mhc contig of bacterial artificial chromosome (BAC) clones from strain 129 (H2bc), which differs from C57BL/6 in the H2-Q and H2-T regions. The current BAC contig extends from Tapasin to D17Leh89 with gaps in the class II, H2-Q, and distal H2-M regions. Only four BAC clones were required to link the class I genes of the H2-Q and H2-T regions, and no new class I gene was found in the previous gap. The proximal 1 Mb of the H2-M region has been analyzed in detail and is ready for sequencing; it includes 21 class I genes or fragments, at least 14 olfactory receptor-like genes, and a number of non-class I genes that clearly establish a conserved synteny with the class I regions of the human and rat Mhc.

What sharks can tell us about the evolution of MHC genes

Similarity in structural features would argue that sharks possess class I, class IIA and class IIB genes, coding for classical peptide-presenting molecules, as well as non-classical class I genes. Some aspects of shark major histocompatibility complex genes are similar to teleost genes and others are similar to tetrapod genes. Shark class I genes form a monophyletic group, as also seen for tetrapods, but the classical and nonclassical genes form two orthologous clades, as seen for teleosts. Teleost class I genes arose independently at least four different times with the nonclassical genes of ray-finned fishes and all the shark and lobe-finned fish class I genes forming 1 clade. The ray-finned fish classical class I genes arose separately. In phylogenetic trees of class II alpha 2 and beta 2 domains, the shark and tetrapod genes cluster more closely than the teleost genes and, unlike the teleost sequences, the class II alpha 1 domains of sharks and tetrapods lack cysteines. On the other hand, both shark and teleost genes display sequence motifs in the antigen-binding cleft that have persisted over very long time periods. The similarities may reflect common selective pressures on species in aqueous environments while differences may be due to different evolutionary rates.

New insights into the genomic organization and origin of the major histocompatibility complex: role of chromosomal (genome) duplication in the emergence of the adaptive immune system

Recently, it became clear that the human and mouse genomes contain at least three regions paralogous to the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) region. This observation led us to the proposal that the MHC region emerged as a result of chromosomal duplication that took place at an early stage of vertebrate evolution. Here I briefly review this proposal. Accumulating evidence indicates that (a) genome-wide duplication(s) took place close to the origins of vertebrates. Taking this and others into account, I suggest that the duplication(s) involving the MHC region probably took place as a part of the genome-wide duplication(s). The human T cell receptor (TCR) and immunoglobulin (Ig) genes also appear to be located on paralogous chromosomal segments. These findings raise the possibility that the genome-wide duplication provided a major impetus not only to the emergence of the full-fledged MHC system, but also to the appearance of other key molecules of the adaptive immune system such as TCR and Ig.

Major histocompatibility complex gene mapping in the amphibian Xenopus implies a primordial organization

One of the most provocative recent discoveries in immunology was the description of a genetic linkage in the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) between structurally unrelated genes whose products are involved in processing and presentation of antigens for recognition by T lymphocytes. Genes encoding MHC class I molecules, which bind and present at the cell surface proteolytic fragments of cytosolic proteins, are linked to nonhomologous genes whose products are involved in the production and subsequent transfer of such fragments into the endoplasmic reticulum. In mammals, the class I presentation and processing genes are found in different regions of the MHC. To examine the evolutionary origins of this genetic association, linkage studies were carried out with Xenopus, an amphibian last sharing an ancestor with mammals over 350 million years ago. In contrast to mammals, the single copy Xenopus class I gene is located between the class II and III regions, speculated to be in close linkage with the processing and transport genes. In addition to suggesting a primordial organization of genes involved in class I antigen presentation, these linkage studies further provide insight into the origins of the MHC class III region and the phenomenon of class I gene instability in the mammalian MHC.