The lactose permease of Escherichia coli

A revised model for the structure and function of the lactose permease. Evidence that a face on transmembrane segment 2 is important for conformational changes

The lactose permease is an integral membrane protein that cotransports H(+) and lactose into the bacterial cytoplasm. Previous work has shown that bulky substitutions at glycine 64, which is found on the cytoplasmic edge of transmembrane segment 2 (TMS-2), cause a substantial decrease in the maximal velocity of lactose uptake without significantly affecting the K(m) values (Jessen-Marshall, A. E., Parker, N. J., and Brooker, R. J. (1997) J. Bacteriol. 179, 2616-2622). In the current study, mutagenesis was conducted along the face of TMS-2 that contains glycine-64. Single amino acid substitutions that substantially changed side-chain volume at codons 52, 57, 59, 63, and 66 had little or no effect on transport activity, whereas substitutions at codons 49, 53, 56, and 60 were markedly defective and/or had lower levels of expression. According to helical wheel plots, Phe-49, Ser-53, Ser-56, Gln-60, and Gly-64 form a continuous stripe along one face of TMS-2. Several of the TMS-2 mutants (S56Y, S56L, S56Q, Q60A, and Q60V) were used as parental strains to isolate mutants that restore transport activity. These mutations were either first-site mutations or second-site suppressors in TMS-1, TMS-2, TMS-7 or TMS-11. A kinetic analysis showed that the suppressors had a higher rate of lactose transport compared with the corresponding parental strains. Overall, the results of this study are consistent with the notion that a face on TMS-2, containing Phe-49, Ser-53, Ser-56, Gln-60, and Gly-64, plays a critical role in conformational changes associated with lactose transport. We hypothesize that TMS-2 slides across TMS-7 and TMS-11 when the lactose permease interconverts between the C1 and C2 conformations. This idea is discussed within the context of a revised model for the structure of the lactose permease.

Suppressor analysis of mutations in the loop 2-3 motif of lactose permease: evidence that glycine-64 is an important residue for conformational changes

A superfamily of transport proteins, which includes the lactose permease of Escherichia coli, contains a highly conserved motif, G-X-X-X-D/E-R/K-X-G-R/K-R/K, in the loops that connect transmembrane segments 2 and 3 and transmembrane segments 8 and 9. Previous analysis of this motif in the lactose permease (A. E. Jessen-Marshall, N. J. Paul, and R. J. Brooker, J. Biol. Chem. 270:16251-16257, 1995) has shown that the conserved glycine residue found at the first position in the motif (i.e., Gly-64) is important for transport function. Every substitution at this site, with the exception of alanine, greatly diminished lactose transport activity. In this study, three mutants in which glycine-64 was changed to cysteine, serine, and valine were used as parental strains to isolate 64 independent suppressor mutations that restored transport function. Of these 64 isolates, 39 were first-site revertants to glycine or alanine, while 25 were second-site mutations that restored transport activity yet retained a cysteine, serine, or valine at position 64. The second-site mutations were found to be located at several sites within the lactose permease (Pro-28 --> Ser, Leu, or Thr; Phe-29 --> Ser; Ala-50 --> Thr, Cys-154 --> Gly; Cys-234 --> Phe; Gln-241 --> Leu; Phe-261 --> Val; Thr-266 --> Iso; Val-367 --> Glu; and Ala-369 --> Pro). A kinetic analysis was conducted which compared lactose uptake in the three parental strains and several suppressor strains. The apparent Km values of the Cys-64, Ser-64, and Val-64 parental strains were 0.8 mM, 0.7 mM, and 4.6 mM, respectively, which was similar to the apparent Km of the wild-type permease (1.4 mM). In contrast, the Vmax values of the Cys-64, Ser-64, and Val-64 strains were sharply reduced (3.9, 10.1, and 13.2 nmol of lactose/min x mg of protein, respectively) compared with the wild-type strain (676 nmol of lactose/min x mg of protein). The primary effect of the second-site suppressor mutations was to restore the maximal rate of lactose transport to levels that were similar to the wild-type strains. Taken together, these results support the notion that Gly-64 in the wild-type permease is at a site in the protein which is important in facilitating conformational changes that are necessary for lactose translocation across the membrane. According to our tertiary model, this site is at an interface between the two halves of the protein.

Role of conserved residues in hydrophilic loop 8-9 of the lactose permease

A peptide motif, GXXX(D/E)(R/K)XG(R/K)(R/K), has been conserved in a large group of evolutionarily related membrane proteins that transport small molecules across the membrane. Within the superfamily, this motif is located in two cytoplasmic loops that connect transmembrane segments 2 and 3 and transmembrane segments 8 and 9. In a previous study concerning the loop 2-3 motif of the lactose permease (A. E. Jessen-Marshall, N. J. Paul, and R. J. Brooker, J. Biol. Chem. 270:16251-16257, 1995), it was shown that the first-position glycine and the fifth-position aspartate are critical for transport activity since a variety of site-directed mutations greatly diminished the rate of transport. In the current study, a similar approach was used to investigate the functional significance of the conserved residues in the loop 8-9 motif. In the wild-type lactose permease, however, this motif has been evolutionarily modified so that the first-position glycine (an alpha-helix breaker) has been changed to proline (also a helix breaker); the fifth position has been changed to an asparagine; and one of the basic residues has been altered. In this investigation, we made a total of 28 single and 7 double mutants within the loop 8-9 motif to explore the functional importance of this loop. With regard to transport activity, amino acid substitutions within the loop 8-9 motif tend to be fairly well tolerated. Most substitutions produced permeases with normal or mildly defective transport activities. However, three substitutions at the first position (i.e., position 280) resulted in defective lactose transport. Kinetic analysis of position 280 mutants indicated that the defect decreased the Vmax for lactose uptake. Besides substitutions at position 280, a Gly-288-to-Thr mutant had the interesting property that the kinetic parameters for lactose uptake were normal yet the rates of lactose efflux and exchange were approximately 10-fold faster than wild-type rates. The results of this study suggest that loop 8-9 may facilitate conformational changes that translocate lactose.

Structural topology of transmembrane helix 10 in the lactose permease of Escherichia coli

In the lactose permease of Escherichia coli, transmembrane helix 10 has been shown to be functionally important. The structure of this helix has been examined in greater detail in this study. A total of 46 substitution and 8 insertional mutants were constructed and analyzed along the entire length of transmembrane helix 10. The results identified amino acids that are tolerant of substitutions by a variety of amino acids. Since a number of these amino acids (Thr-320, Val-331, Phe-325, and Ile-317) are clustered in one region in a helical wheel projection of transmembrane helix 10, it seems likely that this face of helix 10 is interacting with the membrane. The channel lining domain is thought to consist of the helical face containing Glu-325, Leu-318, Leu-329, His-322, Val-315, Cys-333, Val-326, and Lys-319 based on the results here and from earlier findings. Deleterious mutations along this face tended to greatly increase the Km value for lactose transport with only minor effects on the Vmax. Analysis of insertional mutants revealed that perturbation of the spatial relationship between amino acids at the periplasmic edge is less deleterious than perturbation in the center of the helix or the cytoplasmic edge. Using all of the above information, a detailed structural topology of transmembrane helix 10 is proposed.

Evidence that transmembrane segment 2 of the lactose permease is part of a conformationally sensitive interface between the two halves of the protein

A conserved motif, GXXX(D/E)(R/K)XG(R/K)(R/K), is found in a large group of evolutionarily related membrane proteins involved in the transport of small molecules across the membrane. This motif is located within the cytoplasmic side of transmembrane domain 2 (TM-2) and extends through the hydrophilic loop that connects transmembrane domains 2 and 3. The motif is repeated again in the second half of the protein. In a previous study concerning the loop 2/3 motif (Jessen-Marshall, A. E., Paul, N. J., and Brooker, R. J. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 16251-16257), it was shown that the conserved aspartate at the fifth position in the motif is critical for transport activity since a variety of site-directed mutations were found to greatly diminish the rate of transport. In the current study, two of these mutations, in which the conserved aspartate was changed to threonine or serine, were used as parental strains to isolate second site suppressor mutations that restore transport function. A total of 10 different second site mutations were identified among a screen of 19 independent mutants. One of the suppressors was found within loop 1/2 in which Thr-45 was changed to arginine. Since the conserved aspartate and position 45 are at opposite ends of TM-2, these results suggest that the role of the conserved aspartate residue in loop 2/3 is to influence the topology of TM-2. Surprisingly, the majority of suppressor mutations were found in the second half of the permease. All of these are expected to alter helix topology in either of two ways. Some of the mutations involved residues within transmembrane segments 7 and 11 that produced substantial changes in side chain volume: TM-7 (Cys-234-->Trp or Phe, Gln-241-->Leu, and Phe-247-->Val) and TM-11 (Ser-366-->Phe). Alternatively, other mutations were highly disruptive substitutions at the ends of transmembrane segments or within hydrophilic loops (Gly-257-->Asp, Val-367-->Glu, Ala-369-->Pro, and a 5-codon insertion into loop 11/12). It is hypothesized that the effects of these suppressor mutations are to alter the helical topologies in the second half of the protein to facilitate a better interaction with the first half. Overall, these results are consistent with a transport model in which TM-2 acts as an important interface between the two halves of the lactose permease. According to our tertiary model, this interaction occurs between TM-2 and TM-11.

The conserved motif, GXXX(D/E)(R/K)XG[X](R/K)(R/K), in hydrophilic loop 2/3 of the lactose permease

A conserved motif, GXXX(D/E)(R/K)XG(R/K)(R/K), has been identified among a large group of evolutionarily related membrane proteins involved in the transport of small molecules across the membrane. To determine the importance of this motif within the lactose permease of Escherichia coli, a total of 28 site-directed mutations at the conserved first, fifth, sixth, eighth, ninth, and tenth positions were analyzed. A dramatic inhibition of activity was observed with all bulky mutations at the first-position glycine. Based on these results, together with sequence comparisons within the superfamily, it seems likely that small side chain volume (and possibly high beta-turn propensity) may be structurally important at this position. The acidic residue at the fifth position was also found to be very important for transport activity and even a conservative glutamate at this location exhibited marginal transport activity. In contrast, many substitutions at the eighth-position glycine, even those with a high side chain volume and/or low beta-turn propensity, still retained high levels of transport activity. Similarly, none of the basic residues within the motif were essential for transport activity when replaced individually by nonbasic residues. However, certain substitutions at the basic residue sites as well as the eighth-position glycine were observed to have moderately reduced levels of active transport of lactose. Taken together, the results of this study confirm the importance of the conserved loop 2/3 motif in transport function. It is suggested that this motif may be important in promoting global conformational changes within the permease.

A functional superfamily of sodium/solute symporters

Eleven families of sodium/solute symporters are defined based on their degrees of sequence similarities, and the protein members of these families are characterized in terms of their solute and cation specificities, their sizes, their topological features, their evolutionary relationships, and their relative degrees and regions of sequence conservation. In some cases, particularly where site-specific mutagenesis analyses have provided functional information about specific proteins, multiple alignments of members of the relevant families are presented, and the degrees of conservation of the mutated residues are evaluated. Signature sequences for several of the eleven families are presented to facilitate identification of new members of these families as they become sequenced. Phylogenetic tree construction reveals the evolutionary relationships between members of each family. One of these families is shown to belong to the previously defined major facilitator superfamily. The other ten families do not show sufficient sequence similarity with each other or with other identified transport protein families to establish homology between them. This study serves to clarify structural, functional and evolutionary relationships among eleven distinct families of functionally related transport proteins.

Computer-aided analyses of transport protein sequences: gleaning evidence concerning function, structure, biogenesis, and evolution

Three-dimensional structures have been elucidated for very few integral membrane proteins. Computer methods can be used as guides for estimation of solute transport protein structure, function, biogenesis, and evolution. In this paper the application of currently available computer programs to over a dozen distinct families of transport proteins is reviewed. The reliability of sequence-based topological and localization analyses and the importance of sequence and residue conservation to structure and function are evaluated. Evidence concerning the nature and frequency of occurrence of domain shuffling, splicing, fusion, deletion, and duplication during evolution of specific transport protein families is also evaluated. Channel proteins are proposed to be functionally related to carriers. It is argued that energy coupling to transport was a late occurrence, superimposed on preexisting mechanisms of solute facilitation. It is shown that several transport protein families have evolved independently of each other, employing different routes, at different times in evolutionary history, to give topologically similar transmembrane protein complexes. The possible significance of this apparent topological convergence is discussed.

Lactose permease mutants which transport (malto)-oligosaccharides

Lactose permease mutants, which were previously isolated in sugar specificity studies, were screened for their abilities to transport the trisaccharide maltotriose. Six multiple mutants (e.g., five double mutants and one triple mutant) were identified as forming fermentation-positive colonies on maltotriose MacConkey plates and were also shown to grow on maltotriose minimal plates. All of these multiple mutants contained a combination of two or three amino acid substitutions at position 177, 236, 306, or 322 within the permease. In contrast, none of the corresponding single mutants at these locations were observed to exhibit an enhanced rate of maltotriose transport. In whole-cell assays, the multiple mutants were shown to transport relatively long alpha-nitrophenylglucoside (alpha NPG) molecules. In certain cases, alpha NPG molecules containing up to four glucose residues in addition to the nitrophenyl group were shown to be transported to a significant degree. Overall, the abilities of lactose permease mutants to transport maltotriose and long alpha NPGs are discussed with regard to the dimensions of the sugar and the mechanism of sugar transport.

The mitochondrial carrier family of transport proteins: structural, functional, and evolutionary relationships

Energy transduction in mitochondria requires the transport of many specific metabolites across the inner membrane of this eukaryotic organelle. We have screened the protein sequence database for proteins homologous to the mitochondrial ATP/ADP exchange carrier, and the homologous proteins found were similarly screened to ensure that all currently sequenced members of the mitochondrial carrier family (MCF) had been identified. Thirty-seven proteins were identified, 28 of which were less than 90% identical to any other sequenced member of the MCF, and the latter proteins fell into 10 clusters or subfamilies as follows: (1) ATP/ADP exchangers of mammals, plants, algae, yeast, and fungi (11 members); (2) a bovine oxoglutarate/malate exchanger (one member); (3) mammalian uncoupling carriers (five members); (4) yeast and mammalian phosphate carriers (three members); (5) MRS proteins that suppress mitochondrial splicing defects in Saccharomyces cerevisiae (two members); (6) a putative peroxysomal carrier of Candida boidinii; (7) a putative solute carrier from the protozoan, Oxytricha fallax; (8) a putative solute carrier from S. cerevisiae; (9) a putative solute carrier from Zea mays, and (10) two putative solute carriers from the mammalian thyroid gland. The specificities of proteins in clusters 5 to 10 are not known. A multiple alignment and an evolutionary tree of the 28 selected members of the MCF were constructed, thus defining the conserved residues and the phylogenetic relationships of the proteins. Hydropathy plots of the homologous regions were determined and averaged, and the average hydropathy plots were evaluated for sequence similarity. These analyses revealed that the six transmembrane spanners exhibited varying degrees of sequence conservation and hydrophilicity. These spanners, and immediately adjacent hydrophilic loop regions, were more highly conserved than other regions of these proteins. All members of the MCF appear to consist of a tripartite structure with each of the three repeated segments being about 100 residues in length. Each repeat contains two transmembrane spanners, the first being more hydrophobic with conserved glycyl and prolyl residues, the second, preceded by a highly conserved glycyl residue, being more hydrophilic with largely conserved hydrophilic residues in certain positions. Five of the six spanners are followed by the largely conserved sequence (D/E)-Hy (K/R)[- = any residue; Hy = a hydrophobic residue]. Based on both intracluster and intercluster statistical comparisons, repeats 1, 2, and 3 are homologous, but repeats 1 are more similar to each other than they are to repeats 2 or 3 or repeats 2 or 3 are to each other.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Isolation of lactose permease mutants which recognize arabinose

In the present study lactose permease mutants were isolated which recognize the monosaccharide, L-arabinose. Although the wild-type permease exhibits a poor recognition for L-arabinose, seven independent mutants were identified by their ability to grow on L-arabinose minimal plates. When subjected to DNA sequencing, it was found that all seven of these mutants were single-site mutations in which alanine 177 was changed to valine. The wild type and valine 177 mutant were then analyzed with regard to their abilities to recognize and transport monosaccharides and disaccharides. Free L-arabinose was shown to competitively inhibit [14C]-lactose transport yielding a Ki value of 121 mM for the Val177 mutant and a much higher value of 320 mM for the wild-type. Among several monosaccharides, D-glucose as well as L-arabinose inhibited lactose transport in the Val177 mutant to a significantly greater extent, while D-arabinose and D-xylose only caused a slight inhibition. On the other hand, kinetic studies with sugars which are normally recognized by the wild-type permease such as [14C]-galactose and [14C]-lactose revealed that the Val177 mutant and wild-type strains had similar transport characteristics for these two sugars. Overall, these results are consistent with the notion that the Val177 substitution causes an enhanced recognition for particular sugars (i.e. L-arabinose) but does not universally affect the recognition and unidirectional transport for all sugars. This idea is further supported by the observation that site-directed mutants containing isoleucine, leucine, phenylalanine, or proline at position 177 also were found to possess an enhanced recognition for L-arabinose.

A major superfamily of transmembrane facilitators that catalyse uniport, symport and antiport

Many transport proteins of bacteria and eukaryotes are thought to possess a common structural motif of 12 transmembrane-spanning alpha-helical segments. In this report we use statistical methods to establish that five families or clusters of these facilitators comprise a single superfamily. The five clusters include: (1) drug-resistance proteins, (2) sugar facilitators, (3) facilitators for Krebs cycle intermediates, (4) phosphate ester-phosphate antiporters and (5) a distinct group of oligosaccharide-H+ symporters. Over 50 transporters of bacteria, lower eukaryotes, plants and animals, and one putative bacterial transcriptional regulatory protein are members of this superfamily, which we term the 'major facilitator superfamily' (MFS).

Transport proteins in bacteria: common themes in their design

Bacterial transport proteins mediate passive and active transport of small solutes across membranes. Comparison of amino acid sequences shows strong conservation not only among bacterial transporters, but also between them and many transporters of animal cells; thus the study of bacterial transporters is expected to contribute to our understanding of transporters in more complex cells. During the last few years, structures of three bacterial outer membrane transporters were solved by x-ray crystallography. Much progress has also occurred in the biochemical and molecular genetic studies of transporters in the cytoplasmic membranes of bacteria, and a unifying design among membrane transporters is gradually emerging. Common structural motives and evolutionary origins among transporters with diverse energy-coupling mechanisms suggest that many transporters contain a central module forming a transmembrane channel through which the solute may pass. Energy-coupling mechanisms can be viewed as secondary features added on to these fundamental translocation units.

Amino acid substitution in the lactose carrier protein with the use of amber suppressors

Five lacY mutants with amber stop codons at known positions were each placed into 12 different suppressor strains. The 60 amino acid substitutions obtained in this manner were tested for growth on lactose-minimal medium plates and for transport of lactose, melibiose, and thiomethylgalactoside. Most of the amino acid substitutions in the regions of the putative loops (between transmembrane alpha helices) resulted in a reasonable growth rate on lactose with moderate-to-good transport activity. In one strain (glycine substituted for Trp-10), abnormal sugar recognition was found. The substitution of proline for Trp-33 (in the region of the first alpha helix) showed no activity, while four additional substitutions (lysine, leucine, cysteine, and glutamic acid) showed low activity. Altered sugar specificity was observed when Trp-33 was replaced by serine, glutamine, tyrosine, alanine, histidine, or phenylalanine. It is concluded that Trp-33 may be involved directly or indirectly in sugar recognition.

Studies of translocation catalysis

There is a symbiotic relationship between the evolution of fundamental theory and the winning of experimentally-based knowledge. The impact of the General Chemiosmotic Theory on our understanding of the nature of membrane transport processes is described and discussed. The history of experimental studies on transport catalysed by ionophore antibiotics and the membrane proteins of mitochondria and bacteria are used to illustrate the evolution of knowledge and theory. Recent experimental approaches to understanding the lactose-H+ symport protein of Escherichia coli and other sugar porters are described to show that the lack of experimental knowledge of the three-dimensional structures of the proteins currently limits the development of theories about their molecular mechanism of translocation catalysis.

Proton-linked sugar transport systems in bacteria

The cell membranes of various bacteria contain proton-linked transport systems for D-xylose, L-arabinose, D-galactose, D-glucose, L-rhamnose, L-fucose, lactose, and melibiose. The melibiose transporter of E. coli is linked to both Na+ and H+ translocation. The substrate and inhibitor specificities of the monosaccharide transporters are described. By locating, cloning, and sequencing the genes encoding the sugar/H+ transporters in E. coli, the primary sequences of the transport proteins have been deduced. Those for xylose/H+, arabinose/H+, and galactose/H+ transport are homologous to each other. Furthermore, they are just as similar to the primary sequences of the following: glucose transport proteins found in a Cyanobacterium, yeast, alga, rat, mouse, and man; proteins for transport of galactose, lactose, or maltose in species of yeast; and to a developmentally regulated protein of Leishmania for which a function is not yet established. Some of these proteins catalyze facilitated diffusion of the sugar without cation transport. From the alignments of the homologous amino acid sequences, predictions of common structural features can be made: there are likely to be twelve membrane-spanning alpha-helices, possibly in two groups of six; there is a central hydrophilic region, probably comprised largely of alpha-helix; the highly conserved amino acid residues (40-50 out of 472-522 total) form discrete patterns or motifs throughout the proteins that are presumably critical for substrate recognition and the molecular mechanism of transport. Some of these features are found also in other transport proteins for citrate, tetracycline, lactose, or melibiose, the primary sequences of which are not similar to each other or to the homologous series of transporters. The glucose/Na+ transporter of rabbit and man is different in primary sequence to all the other sugar transporters characterized, but it is homologous to the proline/Na+ transporter of E. coli, and there is evidence for its structural similarity to glucose/H+ transporters in Plants. In vivo and in vitro mutagenesis of the lactose/H+ and melibiose/Na+ (H+) transporters of E. coli has identified individual amino acid residues alterations of which affect sugar and/or cation recognition and parameters of transport. Most of the bacterial transport proteins have been identified and the lactose/H+ transporter has been purified. The directions of future investigations are discussed.

Evolution of permease diversity and energy-coupling mechanisms with special reference to the bacterial phosphotransferase system

Different classes of apparently unrelated permeases couple different forms of energy to solute transport. While the energy coupling mechanisms utilized by the different permease classes are clearly distinct, it is proposed, based on structural comparisons, that many of these permeases possess transmembrane, hydrophobic domains which are evolutionarily related. Carriers may have arisen from transmembrane pore-forming proteins, and the protein constituents or domains which are specifically responsible for energy coupling may have had distinct origins. Thus, complex permeases may possess mosaic structures. This suggestion is substantiated by recent findings regarding the evolutionary origins of the bacterial phosphoenolpyruvate-dependent phosphotransferase system (PTS). Mechanistic implications of this proposal are presented.