Percutaneous radiologic gastrostomy

A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis on Outcomes and Complications of Percutaneous Endoscopic Versus Radiologic Gastrostomy for Enteral Feeding

BACKGROUND

The optimal technique for long-term enteral feeding has not yet been established. Both percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG) and percutaneous radiologic gastrostomy (PRG) are widely used. Aim was to extensively review outcomes of PEG and PRG.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A systematic review using Medline, Embase, and Cochrane was performed, using standardized tools for assessing bias. Main outcomes were infectious and tube-related complications, procedure related and 30-day mortality. Pooled risk differences (RDs) with corresponding 95% confidence intervals (95% CIs) were calculated using random effects. Arcsine transformations were applied.

RESULTS

In total, 344 studies were identified, of which 16 were included, reporting on 934 PEGs and 1093 PRGs. No differences were found for infectious complications [RD, 0.03 (-0.05 to 0.11)], procedure-related mortality [RD, 0.01 (-0.04 to 0.06)], or 30-day mortality [RD, 0.06 (-0.01 to 0.13)]. Tube-related complications were higher in PRG [RD, 0.16 (0.06-0.26)]. Subgroup analysis was performed for head and neck cancer (HNC) and motor neuron disease. In HNC, this revealed significantly lower tube-related complications and procedure-related mortality after PEG. In motor neuron disease, no differences were seen. The level of evidence appears sufficient considering the low degree of heterogeneity.

CONCLUSIONS

No differences were found with regard to mortality or infectious complications. PEG showed lower risk of tube-related complications. Subgroup analysis revealed PEG to be favorable in HNC based on lower rates of procedure-related mortality and tube-related complications. Local experience and availability should be taken into account in the decision process.

Percutaneous Gastrostomy Guided by Ultrasound and Fluoroscopy

Percutaneous gastrostomy, utilizing a dedicated catheterization kit, with a combination of ultrasonographic (US) and fluoroscopic guidance, was carried out in 27 patients. The main indication for gastrostomy was the need for nutritional support in malignant esophageal stricture. After distending the stomach with water via a nasogastric tube, the gastric antrum was punctured under US guidance and a guide wire was inserted, followed by fluoroscopically guided tract dilatation and insertion of a 2.5-mm Cope-loop catheter. In all patients but one (96%) the procedure was successfully completed in one or 2 attempts. Two complications occurred: one case of a small subcutaneous abscess near the puncture site, and one late incident of dislodgement of a catheter without string-loop fixation, which had been inserted at a catheter exchange after 6 weeks. Percutaneous gastrostomy guided by US and fluoroscopy is a safe and efficacious alternative to endoscopic and surgical gastrostomy.

[The value of percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy in ENT tumor patients]

Many patients with advanced head and neck cancer are already in a poor nutritional status and need supportive nutritional therapy at the time of initial diagnosis. Malnutrition is associated with delayed recovery, prolonged hospital stay and unfavorable prognosis. By using percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy (PEG), the social stigmatization for the patient resulting from the conspicuous nasal feeding tube is avoided. The PEG can be easily implemented at the time of diagnosis by head and neck surgeons in patients suffering from massive tumor-associated weight loss, when definitive or adjuvant radiochemotherapy is anticipated, or prior to tumor surgery likely to be followed by prolonged significant dysphagia and protracted swallowing rehabilitation. Analgesics can be administered via the PEG tube, thus simplifying adequate pain management, which plays a central role in the care of head and neck cancer patients.

Simplified percutaneous gastrostomy

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to develop a simple radiological method for the creation of percutaneous gastrostomy.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Percutaneous gastrostomy was created in 15 patients. After a blunt dissection of the abdominal wall under local anesthesia, puncture of the stomach was performed. A 6-mm peel-off introducer sheath was used to place the permanent catheter. Immediate use of the catheter was allowed.

RESULTS

The procedure was successful in all cases and no procedural complications were seen.

CONCLUSION

The method is simple, cost-saving, and may be recommended as an alternative to other methods.

Surgical palliation of head and neck cancer

Palliative care in head and neck cancer has not been studied systematically. Patients with incurable head and neck tumors may live months and even years. Ideal palliation should enable them to engage in a normal life before death ensues. It is likely that our improving ability to treat these tumors without achieving cures will cause people to live longer with their cancer. Hence, the need for palliation will probably increase. Also, treatments that cure patients produce conditions that require palliation. Achievement of the best possible function is the major consideration in dealing with head and neck tumors. Difficulty with speech, swallowing, oral hygiene, and laodorous tumors are all common. Depression too should be addressed in a comprehensive fashion by the "head and neck team". The surgeon, radiotherapist, and medical oncologist will need help from dentists, prosthodontists, dental hygienists, psychiatrists, physiatrists, occupational and physical therapists, visiting nurses, nutritionists, and social workers. Palliative care in the hospital is the least desirable, although often unavoidable. Proper hospice support will benefit patients and their families.

Technical aspects of enteral nutrition

Advances in technical aspects of enteral feeding such as the manufacture of tubes from polyurethane or silicone have helped promote the science of enteral nutrition. Nasoenteral tubes have few complications, apart from a high unwanted extubation rate and some reluctance from patients because of cosmetic unacceptability. Needle jejunostomy has low morbidity but can only be placed at laparotomy. Percutaneous gastrotomy (in all its different guises) has been established as a low risk procedure and is the access route of choice for longterm enteral feeding, in particular for cancer, geriatric, and neurological patients.