On the side chain conformation of 1α,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 responsible for binding to the receptor

Synthesis and Biological Activity of 2,22-Dimethylene Analogues of 19-Norcalcitriol and Related Compounds

Continuing our search for vitamin D analogues, we explored the modification of the steroidal side chain and inserted a methylene moiety in position C-22 together with either lengthening the side chain or introducing a ring at the terminal end. Our conformational studies confirmed that the presence of a methylene group attached to C-22 restricts the conformational flexibility of the side chain, which can result in changes in biological characteristics of a molecule. All synthesized 1α,25-dihydroxy-2,22-dimethylene-19-norvitamin D₃ analogues proved equal to calcitriol in their ability to bind to the vitamin D receptor, and most of them exert significantly higher differentiation and transcriptional activity than calcitriol. The most active compounds were characterized by the presence of an elongated side chain or 26,27-dimethylene bridge. The synthetic strategy was based on the Wittig-Horner coupling of the known A-ring phosphine oxide with the corresponding Grundmann ketones prepared from a 20-epi-Inhoffen-Lythgoe diol derived from vitamin D₂.

A 20S combined with a 22R configuration markedly increases both in vivo and in vitro biological activity of 1α,25-dihydroxy-22-methyl-2-methylene-19-norvitamin D3

Six new analogues of 1α,25-dihydroxy-19-norvitamin D(3) (3a-4b, 5, and 6) were prepared by a convergent synthesis applying the Wittig-Horner reaction as a key step. The influence of methyl groups at C-22 on their biological activity was examined. It was established that both in vitro and in vivo activity is strongly dependent on the configuration of the stereogenic centers at C-20 and C-22. Introduction of the second methyl group at C-22 (analogues 5 and 6) generates the compounds that are slightly more potent than 1α,25-(OH)(2)D(3) in the in vitro tests but much less potent in vivo. The greatest in vitro and in vivo biological activity was achieved when the C-20 is in the S configuration and the C-22 is in the R configuration. The building blocks for the synthesis, the respective (20R,22R)-, (20R,22S)-, (20S,22R)-, and (20S,22S)-diols, were obtained by fractional crystallization of mixtures of the corresponding diastereomers. Structures and absolute configurations of the diols 21a, 21b, and 22a as well as analogues 3a, 5, and 6 were confirmed by the X-ray crystallography.

22-Alkyl-20-epi-1α,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 Compounds of Superagonistic Activity: Syntheses, Biological Activities and Interaction with the Receptor

We previously reported that 22R-methyl-20-epi-1,25-(OH)2D3 (3) possesses strong binding affinity for the vitamin D receptor (VDR) and shows superagonistic biological activities. To examine the effect of the length of an alkyl substituent at C(22) and to extend our compound library, we successfully synthesized 22R-ethyl-20-epi-1,25-(OH)2D3 (4) and 22R-butyl-20-epi-1,25-(OH)2D3 (5). Surprisingly, 22-ethyl analogue 4 showed stronger VDR binding affinity and transactivation potency than the superagonist of methyl analogue 3, but its calcemic activity in vivo was weaker than that of both the methyl analogue 3 and the natural hormone (1), while 22-butyl analogue 5 showed activities comparable to those of the hormone (1). A study of the docking of these new analogues to the VDR-LBD and alanine scanning mutational analysis demonstrated that 22-methyl and 22-ethyl substituents enhance the favorable hydrophobic interactions with residues lining the ligand binding pocket of the VDR, and that 22-butyl analogue 5 binds to the VDR by an induced fit mechanism.

Two-dimensional alanine scanning mutational analysis of the interaction between the vitamin D receptor and its ligands: studies of A-ring modified 19-norvitamin D analogs

To clarify the structure-function relationship (SFR) of vitamin D analogs in terms of their interaction with the vitamin D receptor (VDR), we have proposed a new approach, two-dimensional alanine scanning mutational analysis (2D-ASMA). In this paper, attention was focused on the interactions around the A-ring of vitamin D. For this purpose, we synthesized four new 2-substituted 19-norvitamin D derivatives (3-6). The VDR affinity (3-6: 1, 5, 2 and 1/140, respectively) and transcriptional activity (3-6: 10, 30, 2 and 0.3, respectively) of the four compounds were evaluated relative to 1,25-(OH)(2)D(3) (5) (normalized to 1). Then, the transcriptional activities of wild-type and 18 mutant VDRs induced by the four compounds (3-6) were investigated. The results of this 18 x 4 2D-ASMA were presented as a patch table, and the effects of the mutations were analyzed in comparison with the natural hormone (1) and 2-methylene-19-nor-20-epi-1,25-(OH)(2)D(3) (2MD, 2). Of the four A-ring analogs, the 2alpha-hydroxyethoxy derivative (3) showed striking differences in the pattern on the patch table. From the results, we suggest a docking mode of this compound (3) in which the A-ring adopts the alpha conformation.

Interaction between vitamin D receptor and vitamin D ligands: two-dimensional alanine scanning mutational analysis

We present a new method to investigate the details of interaction between vitamin D nuclear receptor (VDR) and various ligands, namely a two-dimensional alanine scanning mutational analysis. In this method, the transactivation of various ligands is studied in conjunction with a series of alanine scanning mutations of the residues lining the ligand binding pocket (LBP) of VDR, and the complete set of results is profiled in a patch table. We investigated examples from four structurally diverse groups of known VDR ligands: the native vitamin D hormone and two compounds with the same side chain configuration; four 20-epi compounds; three 19-nor compounds; and two nonsecosteroids. The patch table of the results indicates characteristics of each group in terms of its interaction with 18 LBP residues. We demonstrate the validity of this approach by application to docking studies of the two nonsecosteroids.

Structure-function relationships of vitamin D including ligand recognition by the vitamin D receptor

First, the general structure and function of nuclear receptors (NRs) are described briefly to help our understanding of the mechanism of action of vitamin D mediated by the vitamin D receptor (VDR), a member of the NRs. Then we discuss the structure-function relationship (SFR) of vitamin D on the basis of ligand structures and the interaction of the ligand with the VDR. The SFR of vitamin D side chain analogs is discussed extensively in terms of our active space group concept, which was derived from conformational analyses of the side chains of vitamin D analogs and from studies with conformationally restricted 22-methyl-1,25-(OH)(2)D(3) isomers. The mobile area of the side chain of vitamin D can be grouped into five regions (E, G, EA, EG, and F), and the SFR has been analyzed in terms of these spatial regions. The SFR of ligand/VDR interaction is discussed on the basis of the crystal structure of VDR-LBD(delta 165-215), docking of various vitamin D ligands into the ligand binding pocket (LBP) of the VDR, and functional analysis of amino acids lining the LBP. Finally, we discuss total SFR, combining the results of the two approaches, and future aspects of structure-based design of vitamin D analogs.

Ligand recognition by the vitamin D receptor

Three-dimensional structure of the ligand binding domain (LBD) of the vitamin D receptor (VDR) docked with the natural ligand 1 alpha,25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) [1,25-(OH)(2)D(3)] has been mostly solved by the X-ray crystallographic analysis of the deletion mutant (VDR-LBD Delta 165-215). The important focus, from now on, is how the VDR recognizes and interacts with potent synthetic ligands. We now report the docking models of the VDR with three functionally and structurally interesting ligands, 22-oxa-1,25-(OH)(2)D(3) (OCT), 20-epi-1,25-(OH)(2)D(3) and 20-epi-22-oxa-24,26,27-trihomo-1,25-(OH)(2)D(3). In parallel with the computational docking studies, we prepared twelve one-point mutants of amino acid residues lining the ligand binding pocket of the VDR and examined their transactivation potency induced by 1,25-(OH)(2)D(3) and these synthetic ligands. The results indicate that L233, R274, W286, H397 and Y401 are essential for holding the all ligands tested, S278 and Q400 are not important at all, and the importance of S237, V234, S275, C288 and H305 is variable depending on the side-chain structure of the ligands. Based on these studies, we suggested key structural factors to bestow the selective action on OCT and the augmented activities on 20-epi-ligands. Furthermore, the docking models coincided well with our proposed active space-region theory of vitamin D based on the conformational analyses of ligands.

Three-dimensional structure-function relationship of vitamin D and vitamin D receptor model

On the basis of conformational analysis of the vitamin D side chain and studies using conformationally restricted synthetic vitamin D analogs, we have suggested the active space region concept of vitamin D: The vitamin D side-chain region was grouped into four regions (A, G, EA and EG) and the A and EA regions were suggested to be important for vitamin D actions. We extended our theory to known highly potent vitamin D analogs and found a new region F. The analogs which occupy the F region have such modifications as 22-oxa, 22-ene, 16-ene and 18-nor. Altogether, the following relationship between the space region and activity was found: Affinity for vitamin D receptor (VDR), EA > A> F > G > EG; Affinity for vitamin D binding protein (DBP), A >> G,EA,EG; Target gene transactivation, EA > F > A > EG > or = G; Cell differentiation, EA > F > A > EG > or = G; Bone calcium mobilization, EA > GA > F > or = EG; Intestinal calcium absorption, EA = A > or = G >> EG. We modeled the 3D structure of VDR-LBD (ligand binding domain) using hRARgamma as a template, to develop our structure-function theory into a theory involving VDR. 1alpha,25(OH)(2)D(3) was docked into the ligand binding pocket of the VDR with the side chain heading the wide cavity at the H-11 site, the A-ring toward the narrow beta-turn site, and the beta-face of the CD ring facing H3. Amino acid residues forming hydrogen bonds with the 1alpha- and 25-OH groups were specified: S237 and R274 forming a pincer type hydrogen-bond for the 1alpha-OH and H397 for the 25-OH. Mutants of several amino acid residues that are hydrogen-bond candidates were prepared and their biologic properties were evaluated. All of our mutation results together with known mutation data support our VDR model docked with the natural ligand.

Synthesis, biological evaluation, and conformational analysis of A-ring diastereomers of 2-methyl-1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) and their 20-epimers: unique activity profiles depending on the stereochemistry of the A-ring and at C-20

All eight possible A-ring diastereomers of 2-methyl-1, 25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) (2) and 2-methyl-20-epi-1, 25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) (3) were convergently synthesized. The A-ring enyne synthons 19 were synthesized starting with methyl (S)-(+)- or (R)-(-)-3-hydroxy-2-methylpropionate (8). This was converted to the alcohol 14 as a 1:1 epimeric mixture in several steps. After having been separated by column chromatography, each isomer led to the requisite A-ring enyne synthons 19 again as 1:1 mixtures at C-1. Coupling of the resulting A-ring enynes 20a-h with the CD-ring portions 5a,b in the presence of a Pd catalyst afforded the 2-methyl analogues 2a-h and 3a-h in good yield. In this way, all possible A-ring diastereomers were synthesized. The synthesized analogues were biologically evaluated both in vitro and in vivo. The potency was highly dependent on the stereochemistry of each isomer. In particular, the alpha alpha beta-isomer 2g exhibited 4-fold higher potency than 1 alpha,25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) (1) both in bovine thymus VDR binding and in elevation of rat serum calcium concentration and was twice as potent as the parent compound in HL-60 cell differentiation. Furthermore, its 20-epimer, that is, 20-epi-alpha alpha beta 3g, exhibited exceptionally high activities: 12-fold higher in VDR binding affinity, 7-fold higher in calcium mobilization, and 590-fold higher in HL-60 cell differentiation, as compared to 1 alpha,25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) (1). Accordingly, the double modification of 2-methyl substitution and 20-epimerization resulted in unique activity profiles. Conformational analysis of the A-ring by (1)H NMR and an X-ray crystallographic analysis of the alpha alpha beta-isomer 2g are also described.

Three-dimensional modeling of and ligand docking to vitamin D receptor ligand binding domain

The ligand binding domain of the human vitamin D receptor (VDR) was modeled based on the crystal structure of the retinoic acid receptor. The ligand binding pocket of our VDR model is spacious at the helix 11 site and confined at the beta-turn site. The ligand 1alpha, 25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) was assumed to be anchored in the ligand binding pocket with its side chain heading to helix 11 (site 2) and the A-ring toward the beta-turn (site 1). Three residues forming hydrogen bonds with the functionally important 1alpha- and 25-hydroxyl groups of 1alpha,25-dihydroxyvitamin D(3) were identified and confirmed by mutational analysis: the 1alpha-hydroxyl group is forming pincer-type hydrogen bonds with S237 and R274 and the 25-hydroxyl group is interacting with H397. Docking potential for various ligands to the VDR model was examined, and the results are in good agreement with our previous three-dimensional structure-function theory.

Three-dimensional structure-function relationship of vitamin D: side chain location and various activities

The various biological activities of side-chain mobility restricted analogs, four diastereomers at C(20) and C(22) of 22-methyl-1alpha,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3, were evaluated. The relationship between structure and the various activities of the analogs was discussed in terms of the active space region concept that we previously suggested.

Conformation-function relationship of vitamin D: conformational analysis predicts potential side-chain structure

In previous studies, we have grouped regions in space occupied by the vitamin D side chain into four: A, G, EA, and EG. We showed that the receptor (VDR) affinity of 1alpha,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 derivatives increases, in terms of side-chain region, in the order EG, G, A, and EA. We called this the active space group concept. In the present study, we used this active space group concept to analyze the conformation-activity relationship of about 40 representative potent 1alpha,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 analogues. We initially listed structural modifications in the side chain of potent vitamin D analogues and estimated their potency factor. Possible side-chain conformations of representative analogues were calculated by the molecular mechanics method and plotted on a dot map compared with the regions A, G, EA, and EG. The cell-differentiating potency of the analogues was correlated with our active space group concept with few exceptions. Among potent analogues with a natural configuration at C(20), the side chains of those with a 22-oxa, 22-ene, 16-ene, or a 18-nor modification were located in front of region EA (termed F). The side chains of the most potent 20-epi-22-oxa-24-homovitamin D analogues were concentrated at the left side of the EA region (L-EA). Thus, the side chains of almost all potent analogues were distributed around the EA region, and potency increased in the order A, F, EA, and L-EA.

Conformationally restricted analogs of 1 alpha, 25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 and its 20-epimer: compounds for study of the three-dimensional structure of vitamin D responsible for binding to the receptor

Two proteins play important roles in the expression of vitamin D function: the specific nuclear receptor protein (vitamin D receptor, VDR) and the transport protein (vitamin D binding protein, DBP). This study was conducted to clarify the conformation of vitamin D responsible for binding to those proteins. For the purpose, the side chain mobility of 1,25(OH)2D3 (1) and its 20-epimer, 20-epi-1,25(OH)2D3 (2), was analyzed by a systematic conformational search. The results were depicted as a three-dimensional dot map, which indicates that the side chains of the two vitamins (1 and 2) occupy different spatial regions that are separated in two areas. We denoted these areas as A and G for 1 and EA and EG for 2. Four analogs, the diastereomers at C(20) and C(22) (3-6) of 22-methylated 1,25(OH)2D3 whose side chains were confined to occupy G, A, EA, and EG, respectively, were designed. These analogs (3-6) were synthesized efficiently by a stereoselective conjugate addition of organocuprate to steroidal E- and Z-22-en-24-ones as the key step. In binding to the VDR the affinities of the analogs (3-6) relative to 1,25-(OH)2D3 (1) were 1/60, 1/3, 20, and 1/100, respectively. These results indicate that the A region is responsible for binding of 1 to VDR and the EA region for binding of 2. Only isomer 4 showed significant affinity for DBP, indicating only the A region is responsible for binding to DBP. Thus, 5 showed clear separation of binding affinities for two proteins, VDR and DBP. Having the highest known VDR affinity, (22R)-22-methyl-20-epi-1,25(OH)2D3 (5) has potential both as a therapeutic agent and as a tool to study the molecular mechanism of vitamin D-mediated gene transcription.